The International Date Line, Explained
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 май 2020
- The date line, it's somewhat of a border, but who is in charge of it?
Go to expressvpn.com/johnnyharris and find out how you can get 3 months free.
- ways to support -
My Patreon: / johnnyharris
Our custom Presets & LUTs: store.dftba.com/products/john...
- where to find me -
Instagram: / johnny.harris
Tiktok: / johnny.harris
Facebook: / johnnyharrisvox
Iz's (my wife’s) channel: / iz-harris
- how i make my videos -
Tom Fox makes my music, work with him here: tfbeats.com/
I make maps using this AE Plugin: aescripts.com/geolayers/?aff=77
All the gear I use: www.izharris.com/gear-guide
- my courses -
Learn a language: brighttrip.com/course/language/
Visual storytelling: www.brighttrip.com/courses/vi...
- about -
Johnny Harris is a filmmaker and journalist. He currently is based in Washington, DC, reporting on interesting trends and stories domestically and around the globe. Johnny's visual style blends motion graphics with cinematic videography to create content that explains complex issues in relatable ways. He holds a BA in international relations from Brigham Young University and an MA in international peace and conflict resolution from American University.
- press -
NYTimes: www.nytimes.com/2021/11/09/op...
NYTimes: www.nytimes.com/video/opinion...
Vox Borders: • Inside Hong Kong’s cag...
Finding Founders: findingfounders.co/episodes/j...
NPR Planet Money: www.npr.org/transcripts/10721...
13:40 “at the end of the day, it doesn’t really matter”, but whose end of the day, Johnny? 😂
I see what you did there! 😂👌
nice
Underappreciated comment. This needs more likes!
I thought he was gonna explain what happens at the end of the day at first lol
amazing
I never realized that in some places Amazon could offer "previous day" shipping.
That is cute.
Now that is intresting!
GG
lol except that unless the person physically moves from where they ordered the item, to a region in the previous day, that person can never receive the product on the previous day.
If youre going from Samoa to American Samoa or back then yes (technically)
I was in the Navy and in 2003, we crossed the IDL going West, losing a day, meaning I only experienced 364 calendar days that year. However, we came back in 2004 and crossed the IDL going East, so I experienced an extra day. It was also a leap year in 2004 which means I got to experience 367 days that year.
And to top it off, my ship played the movie Groundhog's Day for 48 hrs straight on the TVs as we crossed back over going East. It wasn't awesome but at least my ship had a sense of humor.
You probably have superpowers now
I'm a geographer, and i can tell you how hard, and what a pain in the ass is to describe how International Date Line works to common people.
2:25 That animation you do by looking the earth upside down from pole is great. It would help a lot of people to understand the concept of how it works.
I bet it took forever to get it through your head the first time too.
except flat earthers?
didnt take a braincell to figure out how the date line worked. Some people just are a little slower on the uptake lolol
I always was dumbfounded by it, too much so to bother looking it up. I wondered why the IDL wasn’t GMT since that’s where time was kept.
If you understand timezones, why Alaska's and East russia's timezones are 1-2 hours not matching the South's opposite ?
Flat earthers must be freaking out
😂😂😂
They are used to denial and cognitive dissonance, so they'll be fine
They probably see these videos like fun fiction.
😂😂😂
@@HelgaCavoli It must be like watching fiction fans fighting over some plot holes in the lore.
I’m from the Cook Islands 🇨🇰 and I just want to confirm that your info in this video is 100% spot on in terms of what day the Cook Islands fall in.. Your research and content here is just incredible..thank you 🙌🏾
Ok so we got a confirmation that Google is wrong😂😂
Cheers Johnny 🥂
sorry if im being stupid here but aren't the Cook Island people islanders? Or do they have just as good technology as us (those pictures were really misleading)
(sorry if im being stupid)
@@TheGameChallenger 😆 great question... yea so we have technology just like everyone else.. not going to lie our internet is expensive but it works fine👍🏾 great holiday destination 🤷🏾♂️
@@m.daniels1496 that's great, sorry for asking such a stupid question, have a nice day and thank you for answering!
@@TheGameChallenger most people live with simialr standards nowadays
Dates can have a pretty major impact on trade. Less confusing date hopping between important Pacific nations like Japan and Australia means less delays and easier logistics. I suspect this is why countries like Samoa chose to change sides. So in that way, this does affect what countries get how many resources and when, and is very important. Just one more way we've carved up the planet in the interest of business rather than being easily understandable to the average geographer
:0
And how is that a bad thing? Islands getting this business can have a direct impact on the quality of life for their people. Confusing some hobby geographers at home shouldn't be a consideration for them.
The math is of the same difficulty though
Yes but, in an era when much of the logistics will be ironed out by algorithms on computers, is it really so consequential anymore? I would want to hear from someone in the business.
Personally, i think a world without timezones would be fairly interesting. But that's just s thought experiment
@@deathmetal11111 nowhere in that comment did he claim it was "a bad thing" - or a "good thing" for that matter.
The fun part is that some of these islands are GMT+13 and GMT+14 hours! In fairness, the time zone borders over land are just as messed up. Coming down from us here in the UK, a good half of France is immediately below us, and Spain is all below or to the west of us, yet they prefer to be in a more easterly time zone to be with their neighbours on the same land mass. Interestingly, Portugal is the same as the UK, so the line follows the Spain/Portugal border. I dare say there are similar quirks through Asia and the Americas.
In the US, we have a state called Arizona in the southwest that changes time zones so they don't have to deal with Daylight Saving Time like the rest of us.
So part of the time they match the states to the North & the other part of the year they match with California to the West.
Honestly, we should just eliminate time zones and instead consider that other countries have different schedules. No disadvantages, plus you have the advantage of communicating when things are happening far easier
@@Anonymous-df8it We could just use UTC without offset everywhere. That is data is already processed. Timestamps are in UTC and the local system adjusts the offset, but saves changes in UTC again.
The reason France is in a different time zone actually dates back to the German occupation in World War II, and the same goes for the Netherlands, Belgium, and Luxembourg. Spain also switched time zones at this time (if I were to guess, it'd be because Spain wanted to have positive relations with Germany).
12:41
That moment When you use Google search engine to prove that Google maps are wrong
It’s a savage move hahaha
Dats Wikipedia
I used Google to destroy Google
@@burstingsanta2710 no he used google
if google was correct this video couldn't exist ... so now is fix point in time and space!
I can't wait for the future series of Borders when Johnny takes a boat and travels along the whole international date line to expand on this video.
YES!
Of course, he promised :D
PLEASE
omG that would be great
yes please
Just a quick notice: the picture with the ship wreck that you show at 6:33 claiming to be from Pacific Ocean islands is actually from the beach Navagio in Zakynthos, an island of Greece. I state this so that you can make better references next time, giving every place the correct credits.
12:43PM
6:26 "Just remember that the international date line runs through some of the most beautiful ocean in the world, and it's worth just looking at it for a second."
Greeks at 6:33:
*mr worldwide*
Dear lord your editing skills are next level
Lord, your*
He works for vox , vox has team of editors and those editors edit his videos
आshu not true! This is his personal channel and he edits the videos.
@@hurd4978 exactly and even on vox he edits his own videos to my knowledge
His understanding of geomatics engineering could use some work
This is a man of culture, he puts the sponsorship ad at the end of the video
That dosent really say anything about culture..
@@Poseidon-oz9pg I see that you. are. NOT. a man/woman/attack helicopter of culture.
i will watch his ad only bc he thought of us
a real man of culture doesn't include sponsorships
Ah... I hadn't noticed. I have Sponsor Block.
I remember reading somewhere - which I can't locate in three minutes of extensive Wikipedia research - that a big argument of Greenwich as Prime Meridian was the relative lack of population that put near the 180 degree anti-meridian.
If, for example, the Prime Meridian was somewhat logically located in the mid-Atlantic then the Monday / Tuesday Date Line would run somewhere through New South Wales. If alternatively Jerusalem was chosen then the Date Line would run through Anchorage instead of Kiribati. Picking New York would put the Date Line mess in the middle of East Asia. Choosing mid-Europe makes a lot of sense.
As a Geographer I’ve watched many of your videos and love how your mapping examples show! I suggest later on integrating into Geographic Information Systems! Maybe if you upload the Pacific site layer and Google Maps layer it can be the same depending the coordinate system your looking them. Hope it helps! Greetings from Puerto Rico 🇵🇷 saludos
Bro I wanna get really smart at Geography; where should I start from?
Google Maps shouldn't be considered a definitive source. Nicaragua accidentally invaded Costa Rica in 2010 due to a Google Maps error.
really?
I happened to have caught on to that while looking for routes through the Bosawas. Sorry on behalf of my country, I guess (^_^)
This is a good subject for a next Johnny Harris's video!
governments should not rely on international companies and that is a fact
Can you provide a source?
13:08 "Google Maps has something wrong?"
**Every country with contested borders that just discovered Google uses dotted lines in other countries' versions of the map**
"Damn RIGHT they do!"
Are they showing people in different countries different things?
@@scaredyfish Yes if both countries A and B claim the same land X
Google maps show:
Land X is within A's border, a solid line with A IP address
within B's border with B IP address
A dotted line if you are using not A nor B IP address
Example: Kashmir in India/Pakistan, Crimea, Taiwan
@@seangt but in the country(with contested borders)'s google maps, it often shows solid lines over their claims e.g. Kashmir.
obviously, each country wants to assert their claim and would be upset at anyone who disagrees or even shows a dotted border
@@seangt Yeah, but no country wants to see that there is even a question of the region not being a part itself and thus the op comment
@@AntonWongVideo Like Arunachal Pradesh between India and China.
I wouldn't put setting a dateline to arbitrariness ("it doesn't matter"), but instead, it is about geopolitical and economical influence of one state to another; considering Australia's and NZ's economical influence on the Pacific Islands-- it reduces commercial and logistical confusion.
This was an amazing video!!! Loved every bit of it from the animation to music selection to audio etc. learned a lot too! You are amazing !!
6:34 I always find it funny that Zakynthos, Greece makes it to the list of stunning pacific beach pictures.
Haha I saw that photo as well and thought, wtf that looks just like Zakynthos. :D
Same, people should check their sources 😂😂
@Joel Scrimshaw same
That is indeed a stupid mistake :P
Literally thought the same lol
6:34 that’s Zacynthos, an island in Greece.
whoops! i blew that one lol
Johnny Harris still a great video
@@johnnyharris google reverse image search
👍 I thought that.
This proves Greece Islands are as beautiful as Pacific island Nations
I'm glad this video popped up in my feed, I remember when I was in elementary school and we heard / learned about the map lines and this video would have been a fantastic find back then as the explanation at that time was basically "that's just the way it is and how you need to answer on the test" with little real parts of the why. It wasn't until years later and hours in the library that I really knew the why, so thank you for this video and even now I wish someone would have made just a short film like this to watch back then
Had a 30 minute long conversation about what happens with time zones when they meet back at the origin. Never heard of the international date line. Did one googling and found this video. Fantastic stuff! Thanks for sharing.
As a geography nerd, I always felt so embarrassed telling people this was something I enjoyed. But now, I just show them your videos, cuz you make Geography look so goddamn cool. Thank you!
Um, yeah, me too.
Geography is the real and practical learning..helps understand our nature.
You could say that any topic is interesting, people are just stupid to say that something is boring. They look at everything at surface level.
The whole timezone changing thing just to fit it with their own geographic boundaries is soo stupid & complicated, it’s just, it’s stupid
Yeah. Geology may rock, but geography is where it's at.
My favourite part of living ahead of GMT is that when you travel over the IDL, you often arrive at your destination before you left. When I went to the US, I took off from New Zealand at 10:00 AM GMT+12 on Tuesday, and arrived in New York at 4AM on Tuesday.
Yay a -6 hour flight
That's silly, take a flight from -10 to +10 to skip mondays
Helps only when you don't have to travel back, or the loss of one day hurts more than gaining extra hours of traveling to west.
@@shahsb_27 for sure, when I travelled to Vietnam, we lost close to a day on the way over
@@ahuman7523 Air New Zealand taking it to the next level
Thank you Johnny! I just looked up the International Date Line for the first time, because I am planning a trip to the south pacific. When I looked for an image of the International Date Line, I was very surprised to see it was not a straight line. I said to myself, "What the Hey?" Your video has explained it perfectly for me. Where I am planning on going will be on the Tuesday side of the date line.👍😊💖
Thank you brother. You made this amazingly simple and your AE skills are great!
6:34 This is a beach on Zakintos Greece. Definitely not in the middle of pacific.
Never the less. One of the most beautifull islands there is
I was laughing my ass of when I saw it
It's funny that that's the one that caught my eye the most
nah its the island from surfs up thats big z shack
I’ve been there, very beautiful.
UK: to further distance ourselves from the rest of Europe, we've decided to move to the other side of the international date line
Honestly at this point I wouldn't be surprised
@muhammad wafri Yeah I know I think that what I said was a pretty obvious joke
Can they do that
muhammad wafri oh yeah
@muhammad wafri They already did some weird stuff. The town of Greenwich doesn't have GMT 0 time.
Great video Johnny. As always very practical and clear.Thanks.
Great vid thank you!!
Especially thank u for the island pics 👍
Boss: I need that done yesterday
Kiwi employee: ight Imma head out
*flies to Cook Islands
...: I did the job boss
Easy solution?
Did the boss go to the Cook Islands too?
Wouldn't you have to come from the cook islands to get it done yesterday? Not tomorrow..
@@sambeaumont395 no, he called him up on the phone.
@@brookedilworth761 no the cook islands are on west side which means they are aligned with US timeline and Since NZ time is ahead of US than it will be yesterday on Cook islands.
Johnny you owe us a Borders episode in Northern Ireland for that one 😂
Definitely, and explain why he threw in a random picture of a beach in Greece in with his beautiful Pacific islands.
@@neilohara6227 Well you see, Zakynthos is famed for its independent spirit, they unilaterally declared to be in GMT-21.2 million, somewhere during 404 BC, at the height of their power and influence
Legitimately came down here the instant Ireland was in the circle to see if there was a comment 😆
I haven't seen a big RUclips channel comment under another big RUclips channel's video until now
@@emirkuvvet you fr?😂😂
Love from Kenya 🇰🇪🇰🇪 your explanation is much simpler and easier to understand than my geography teacher 😂 thanks
Very nice description. Amazing effort Johny👍
Just wanted to add that the people in Greenwich said, "obviously let's make it easy for us and let the people on the other side of the world deal with the complicated part".
well I could imagine the brits are tired of getting in other people's business
what you on about
Go try doing a line that split the entire world in two for the international date line without splitting any country, oh and don't forget that some country also want to use the same date as their biggest economic partner.
@@Boby9333 don't overthink my comment, I just think we got lucky with the IDL placement, but then again the planet is 70% ocean.
@@Boby9333 i dont think the sun cares if someone is american LOL
6:34 thats actually a picture of zakynthos in greece
Haha exactly! I had to paus the video and scroll down to if nobody had spotted this...
@@bmsmusician same
Another same. I’m paused at 6:35 scrolling too. 😂😉
Σαμε
Definitely Zakynthos. Stock footage used with no research into where.
The style of this is so thought out and clean I like it
The quality of video-making here is just absolutely phenomenal. Good fucking job @JohnnyHarris!
This morning at Google’s headquarters, “Uh.. so I watched this RUclips video today and we’re going to redraw the international date line on Google Maps guys.”
My dad use to be captain of a boat and we had to go from Tahiti to Tonga, we were passing the international date line right before the sun was coming up, in some little dumb way that morning I got to be the first person to see the sunrise for that day, it's dumb and selfish but always enjoyed it.
That's awesome
Ancient Tonga Ha'amonga a Maui Stonehenge Calendar as where time begins today 🤔
That's not dumb and selfish, that's cool!
That's rather very interesting than selfish.
Absolutely the best IDL explanation anywhere . . . . just not sure if I just watched it in a Monday or a Tuesday 😅. Brilliant, thank you.
That is a great explainer. That topdown view was such a clear representation
13:38 "At the end of the day it doesn't really matter". At the end of what day? Monday or Tuesday?
Yes
Sunday
Both and neither
Stolen comment
Doesn't matter
Here's a scenario you missed. It's 10:00 on Monday in London (GMT +0). Kiribati is GMT +14, making it 00:00 Tuesday. However in Pago Pago (American Samoa -11GMT) it's still 23:00 on Sunday. Three days at the same time.
Corollary: There is never a well-defined date on Earth, as a whole.
@@loveforsberg530 UTC is a well-defined date applicable everywhere. Local times are just an offset forward or backward from that. UTC is also free of seasonal DST changes that are a far worst nightmare than the date line. Because DST results in a 1 hour range being repeated twice and another 1 hour range never existing. That's why all computers truly keep track of time in UTC and only do a conversion to local time for display.
Took me a while to fully understand how it works tbh but that's great 👏🏼
I was waiting this whole video that this kind of scenario about GMT +13 or +14 mentioned... And it not mentioned. But video was great anyways.
There should be just 24 hours in a day! Oh forget it...let's just use 25 hours clocks 🎧
Jonny: has existential crisis about Google maps
Also Jonny 2 seconds later: It’s doesn’t matter at all.
Johnny: Nature isn’t too good with straight lines
Globe: Gotcha!
Everyone else: what’s a straight line?
"it doesn't matter at all"
- 16 minutes video
But it's worth it to watch 😂
Bu it matters a lot to people living there! That's the reason they made their choices what time they are using. And all time zones are nice example. Extreme one is China, lying in 5 zones, decided to use one.
marcel balaz you right!
marcel balaz yeah I agree, “it doesn’t matter” is such a bad take and ignores the fact Google clearly thinks the Pacific Islanders in these areas aren’t worth their effort, plus the international date line has a massive economic impact and is telling of political and cultural allegiances in the area.
Wow this is perfect. I literally learning this in online school
Before the corona, I never expected people saying "online school" as a thing. Back then people just say "read it online" or "online classes"
The future is now old man.
Great video. Interesting and informative. Great sense of humor too! Well done!
Damn! The amount of time and research you put into this is incredible. Hats off!
I've caught minor errors on Google maps (directions) before. They really appreciate people sending in corrections, and I saw them fix a couple of mistakes pretty quickly. They will also add businesses you submit.
You can suggest street misinformation and they will aprove it
Let's not forget that they display different information in different regions. Basically every location with unclear or contested borders will be displayed differently depending on which side of the border you live on.
They don't mind the mistakes, it makes it easier to spot plagiarism
You can report mapping errors to Google. They get plenty of stuff wrong. I've corrected spelling on lake and river names (this seems to be a common error, since we don't usually use Google maps for bodies of water, so people don't notice it), and due to local highway construction they've been wrong about a local route for several years now.
It's interesting to think about how much less our lives are structured around bodies of water than they once were.
I find reporting map errors to Google a frustrating process. Often there's no option on the pop-up form to make the necessary correction.
@@DadgeCity agreed.
My home address is incorrect, and after reporting it twice, it still is not fixed.
@@JonathanSchrock I imagine that would be difficult for them to verify. With bodies of water and highways, it's fairly easy. It also makes an impact on many people, vs only a few.
I’ve seen videos like this where they give run around answers to a question that could be answered straight forward and thank you for answering the question! I saw this in my feed and I’m like “HMMM why is that line like that?” And now I know. Thank you for being an awesome creator!
Great video. I especially liked the "top-down" view of the globe to demonstrate the concept. I remember my dad doing something similar with pencil & paper when I asked about it as a kid (he was a draftsman, so he never had a sloppy circle).
One thing that could use a little expansion is why countries choose to be on one side or the other. You went into detail on why Kiribati consolidated, so that they didn't have offset weekends, but the exact same consideration is why countries like Samoa switch from one side to the other: So that they can have overlapping work weeks with their biggest trading partners. That's why it's a line that very much matters to the people living there. For such small nations, it's one of the most important foreign affairs decisions they can make.
6:34 that's a picture of the greek island zakinthos on a beach named "shipwreck" not in the pacific but in the ionian sea
I guess I can quit wondering what island in the mid-Pacific was formed on top of sedimentary limestone.
I thought the same. Like that's ship wreck beach in Greece man 🤣🤣
Yes, it's Zakynthos.
Came here to make the same comment. Saw you beat me to it. Zante is absolutely stunning!
I was scrolling through hoping to see this comment
Ummm isn't 6:34 Zakynthos, Greece? 😅
yes my observation exactly! that is Zakynthos
whoops!!
That's definitely the Navagio beach in Greece.
"Johnny Harris is.... wrong? Johnny Harris got it wrong??!"
Was going to say. Bit of an oppsie there Johnny! :D
I am learning so very much. Thank you 🙏🏻 this stuff is priceless
Thanks for good video quality and good research!
6:34 is Zakynthos Greece. Not anywhere near the Pacific Ocean.
I thought I was the only one to notice. I live near Zakynthos and that pissed me off.
HAHAHA thats awesome !
It’s hard to get stock video of specific things. The video got the point across
I'm surprised you ended that on "at the end of the day, it doesn't really matter" because depending on what side of the international date line these nations are on is a big show of who their closest friends and trading partners are. Changing sides can be quite controversial and massively ruffles feathers
How bro?
False, they don't really care
@@aucklandnewzealand2023 you’re wrong, ask me why did Samoa change the date line, or the thousands of other pacific nations on the date line….
@@zerioxiii so they could trade with Australia and New Zealand, before it was one of the last places. To see sunrise which made ot harder to trade.
I’m still confused but a whole lot less. For that fun and informative video you just got a new subscriber!!! Thanks Jonny.
This analysis was amazing, very impressive.
6:34 I'm from Greece and at some point where you showed the pictures, you also added a picture of Zakynthos, which I guess is not in the International Date Line.... but I'm proud you added it! I just love your content and your wife as well!!!
3:04
Dude explaining his stuff: So right now its noon in Florida
Me who lives in Florida and watching this at midnight: Wha-
It was recorded before it was uploaded and wasn't uploaded on the same day
@@DrWhoo-kz7sw rip, r/woooosh
@Dragonfury 15 he used it as example
Mathe ist mein Hobby I know, i just noticed how it kinda lined up in a way, i was only trying to make a joke, although it seems some people don’t understand comedy
@@dragonfury1565 exactly lmao like am i the only one who understands it
I'm in Australia, so new years day is a big one for us, being one of the 1st countries to see the sun come up on a new year, also as a child I remember watching live cricket matches played in Western Australia where it was still day light but for us on the east coast it was well & truly dark, well done for trying to get it all straight in my head.
I never ever watched this type of well composed video on date line
Thnks
6:34 that's Zakynthos in Greece that's in the Ioanian Sea nowhere close to the Pacific
Hé probably just searched for pacific coasts and got that as a result. It’s pretty hard knowing where every coast in the world is so if it’s in google searches for pacific coast and looks kinda like a pacific island you would assume it’s somewhere in the pacific. He doesn’t know it’s in Greece
@@simonuser ok you can do a reverse image search before making the video I guess and if you don't know something do you research better before posting
@@raphaelvrahimis964 chill my guy its one img that doesnt affect the video a lot
@@raphaelvrahimis964 Do you know how much more work it would be? Hours of someone's life wasted so 1 image that barely affects the video doesn't sneak in.
"doesn't really matter" ?? ... yeah, ask a software developer about that.
Headache incoming
Not if you use UTC! ..... despite William Willet coming along and deciding we in the UK would mess around with GMT and it all got difficult again.
Hello. I've been summoned
@@RJPick1 Not really. Some things (like birthdays, for example) must ONLY be stored in dates, not datetimes, meaning it can not be UTC. You basically have to store it in user's timezone. There are more examples of this; not always can you use 00:00/23:59 as starting/ending points, due to timezones like +13 and even +14 being a thing.
So UTC is a savior, but definitely not an easy solution. Plus, don't forget you have to convert every single datetime to user's zone coming from the server, then back to UTC coming to the server and sometimes to user's zone on the server. It's not easy task. Definitely a headache.
I mean... the real pain as a software developer is doing all this shit while KNOWING it doesn't really matter.
Hello Johnny. I've been enjoying your history/map videos. You know what would be a good follow up to the international date line video? A video that explains why a, "new day," technically begins at night. Wouldn't the first hour of the local SUNRISE make more sense? I would love this video, so please consider it. Keep up the good work.
Good research. A subject I've been curious about for years.
There is one explanation that I haven't seen mentioned yet: Google maps contains many intentional errors. This is a long practiced method to detect copied maps. In the olden days, this could be adding a non-existent island or mountain, nowadays its more likely to be a road or a town. Map Men (Jay Foreman) here on youtube did a video on some of these discrepancies that you can find in Google Maps and visited one to show it.
That said, it would seem odd to me to do that for the dateline. Adding fake towns and roads is unlikely to cause a map reader too much trouble, but being able to tell which day it is for an island seems like a much bigger deal.
John Green has a whole book called paper towns on this!
There are also stories about GM actually helping people define their borders when they didn't have the resources to do it them selves after a civil war or some such. My favourite is how depending on where you access it it from the China-India border changes to suite the will of the political powers that influence that region.
@@LadyLexyStarwatcher Yep. And China's is the oddest. The country is correctly mapped, but it's all with a slight distortion/shift.
Could you link me that video?
Here's the link for the Map Men video: ruclips.net/video/DeiATy-FfjI/видео.html
13:13 Even though I had never heard of Pacioos before watching this video, I would've still taken their word over Google's on which version of the Date Line is accurate.
yeah I wouldn't event think twice before trusting Pacioos over Google
True. These people study and keep up on this
I was up until 2am randomly trying to figure this out. So, I'm glad you have a video to explain it to me easier.
Amazing visual explanation 👏
When you realize you can time travel but only for one day
You aren't really time travelling. You are just going to another place, where people keep track of the time from a different starting point. It's not like you can travel 12 time zones to the east, and know the future in your original time zone.
@@carultchr/wooooooosh
@@6telephone r/thisisntreddit
That top look at the earth is one of the best explanations I’ve seen so far
Very informative piece of information.. I was teaching my 6th standard boy and your explanation made it really easy for us both to understand!!! keep up the good work buddy....
This is a very interesting video that explans a lot on how the time zones work. Minute 6:33, the image of the "beautiful" island in the middle of the pacific, is actualy a picture of Zakynthos and is a Greek island in... Mediterranean...about 12 time zones apart. But again very interesting video!
This is such a good video! I just have an issue about your last statement, though. I disagree that it "doesn't really matter".
Time zones matter very much do matter. They are powerful political statements that declare alliances and the values of a country.
There's a reason why, even though it spans 5 "actual" geological time zones, China only has one in its entire territory, As a statement of unity. Same with India.
There's a reason why, for a few years, North Korea turned its time zone back by 30 minutes as a rejection of historical Japanese imperialism.
There's a reason why Spain lived in the wrong time zone for decades. As an act of solidarity to Nazi Germany.
There's a reason why Singapore lives one hour ahead of its geographical time zone. It makes trading with China, one of its allies, easier.
Time zones are political statements.
In the case of the Cook Islands, their time zone is part of their sovereignty. THEY decided where they belonged on the side of the date line.
I feel like that decision should be respected. These lines on a map, however imaginary, have politics, driven by human connections, behind them
I live in Jakarta, Indonesia where the time zone is GMT+7, and I had a conversation with a Singaporean guy over an online game. He asked me what the time was in Jakarta, and he told me what time it was in Singapore. He answered precisely one hour ahead of my time which I thought was confusing since Singapore seems to be within the GMT+7 line. Now I know why Singapore is one hour ahead thanks to you.
Noah Dominic Silvio Wth is wrong with u
I agree with your point. However imaginary they may be, they are significant in decision making, and Google maps must represent them accurately, or not show it at all.
Megaclone347 what do you mean “wth is wrong with you”? He was trying to make a good analysis with substantial geographic statements. He clearly knows what he’s talking about
@@Sofiaode18 Because the globe is tilting a bit. That's why they can witness the sunrise first.
But it's not applied in northern region of Sumatra (Aceh, North Sumatra, etc).
“At the end of the day, it doesn’t really matter.” At the end of which day, Johnny??
Yesterday
Johnny, you should consider making a video on GMT and how time was used to determine Longitude in early European navigation. You should also consider a video on how the US Naval Observatory keeps time for the world (DoD Master Clock). GPS, Satellite, Computers, Phones are all set using this official clock at the Observatory in DC as their reference . The person with the responsibility to keep it set is known as the Master of Time. This would be a fascinating segment right up your alley. Cheers.
Master of time eh? Sounds like final boss on a finale of Dr WHO
Outstanding presentation!
YES! Been waiting for this video for *SIX MONTHS* since you did the video about Greenwich Britain being the center of the map!
Same here.. Patience is a virtue!
As someone who used to be in the same work area as PacIOOS, their mapping of the International Date Line is the correct one, so your pick is correct 🙂👍
This video is so trippy, I love it, and I feel so informed
I don't know why you think we're bored of your graphics, your presentations are excellent. I especially thought the top-down view of the globe made the situation very clear.
The “notch” looks like a bodybuilder flexing his bicep
I always thought it looks like a hammer
_Not at all what I was thinking._
That's a Tap... Which supplies water to Pacific ocean
I want to know what times zones are like in Antarctica.......
I know right?
6 months night 6 months day
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_in_Antarctica
there you go,its kind of complicated,just look at the image
@@dominiklehn2866 freaky
He means where all time zones overlap.
I think...
Fantastic video and analysis!
I am so glad I stumbled upon you today! It's an honor. You are brillant!
I don't know how many people worked on this, but this is A grade national TV quality! Great job!
Amazing editing Johnny! Could you make a video about your editing workflow and how to stay organized when tackling a project? Thanks!
I think he sells a course.
I had somany thoughts on the international date line, and you just cleared my thoughts.
What a great video! Honestly, I did not even know there's such a line where you can change a whole day! I don't know what I was thinking because I of course knew about time zones. That animation in the video is perfect. But I had to pause it because it was hard to face the reality :D
Now I'm thinking of an explanation my friends would understand the first part of (what is the date line) without having access to RUclips or any video in general, and I would put it this way.
Point at any location on the globe (preferably a land where people actually live). They would say, "We want the sun exactly above us at noon" - and they have every right to do that. Now you move around the globe at a speed so that the sun is always above, it's always noon for you - and ask people you meet every now and then, they will demand the same - and you grant them that. You do this until you arrive to the last island before your starting point. "Okay guys, you can also have it just like everyone else but you have to accept the fact that your neighbor is one day ahead because I've been travelling for a day since I was there".
But of course this point (line) isn't just anywhere but halfway around the world from Greenwich (for reasons not discussed here)
Amazing video.
When I traveled back to Chile from New Zealand I traveled early one day on a 12-hour flight and arrived the same day earlier than I had left in New Zealand.
Great video, as usual.
I think your final message, about the Google Maps error and what makes you think that error, is correct, borders are only a convention, lines that move throughout history and will continue to move. And unfortunately, they keep us in a constant cold war, in addition to generating separation between people who just want to be happy and live a full life.
I think what is happening with the Covid-19, is that we can see and share the daily routine of staying at home, and realize that on the other side of the "line" there is someone who is not different from me, and who enjoys the same as me in life.
Down the borders.
The date line is something that’s interested me too. Basically, there’s no internationally agreed upon definition so every mapmaker just draws it roughly corresponding to how countries have chosen their time zones. The reason Google has some places on the wrong side is probably just that they didn’t notice. Ships will often choose their own time for internal uses, but the “1917 Anglo-French Conference on Time-keeping at Sea” recommended that ships follow a country’s timezone when in territorial waters, and otherwise adopt an hourly timezone based on exact 15° wide slices. This is the ‘standard’ used when communicating externally to the ship.
I actually loved the globe from above with the different colors for Monday and Tuesday, it was my favorite part of the video hahaha
4:05 gotta love that e-girl ad