You're wrong about reparations. Firstly, germany payed reparations to everyone else. Secondly, germany benefited from stolen goods, money, art and children that went missing and never came back home. Thirdly, a country doesn't pay reparations in one shot, obviously.
Recently, the original "Gaude Mater Polonia" of the first Polish anthem with the stamp of the cathedral library from Płock, robbed during World War II, was found in a German museum. The Germans stated that if the Polish origin of the monument is proven, they will start possible negotiations regarding the return of the monument to Poland. The thief wants to negotiate with the robbed person, but it is up to the victim to prove that something belonged to him. Such German honesty.
I’m a Pole, that has lived outside of Poland for a long time. In fact, I grew up all over the world (Libya, Japan, UK) because my parents were diplomats. I have been living in United States for the past 30 years. I hold both American and Polish passport as does my family. I truly love Poland and what it has done especially with its tumultuous history, certainly in the 20th century. The problem with nonpayment of reparations by Germany, and Russia is absolutely pivotal. For starters it’s the amount of damage and the loss of human life which in the case of Poland amounted too close to 6 million souls. This was true barbaric and murderous behavior that the perpetrators have to number one acknowledge and secondly compensate for. In order for there to be peace and moral justice, in the case of Germany there has to be an acknowledgment number one and secondly, a pathway to compensation. If Germany is truly to shake off the horrors of its past, it needs to step up and work with Poland and I might add Greece, whom they also ignored as far as reparations, in order to work out a path forward. I don’t think there is an expectation of payment of the whole asked amount at once or even in hard cash. I think there’s other ways of acknowledging and caring this out. The amount that was estimated by the IPN (the Institute of national remembrance) in Poland did not include the actual human potential loss, it didn’t include barbaric and permeative destruction of city of Warsaw in 1944, it did not include the return of all the cultural goods that were robbed from the country and thus not returned. With all of this said, how would you feel in this situation if you were Polish? Unfortunately, on top of this, there is still prejudice directed against Poland by German businesses. I’ve experienced this as a business person in the United States purchasing significant equipment from Germany. There is a lot of pent up prejudice and nationalism still embedded in the German psyche. This has to be dealt with by Germany from within as quickly as possible. As a sidenote, both Poland and United States also have a lot of issues to work through. I’m staying positive through current reshuffling that’s going on worldwide end caused entropy that I trust will eventually result in a much more just and evolved the world post 2030.
Say it as you see it. Big boys are LAZY and feel entitled to EXPLOIT and manipulate the honorable Empathic nation, Poland. How many wars do these psychopaths started world wide? How many loans they took from the world and DEFAULTED? Yet, they sit im EU imposing their covert narcissistic ideologues in order to BRING DOWN HARD WORKING PROSPEROUS emerging COUNTRIES. In schools we call them bullies. They never outgrow what works for them gaslighting, lies, projections, etc. Visit Auschwitz were truth does not lie on PSYCHOPATHIC PANDEMICS.
You are correct. I also hold American and Polish citizenship and I worked with Germans for 15 years - in the USA. I did some spectacular things for them (I am the guy who wrote PT Pilot for gearmotors configuration, the first online gearmotor configuration software / web app ever) and Germans absolutely hated me for it, committing significant resources over many years to erase the American / Polish contribution to the industry and to substitute it with (much inferior) German solution. They outspent our development by a factor 5:1 just to get rid of us (the same company, mind you). Germans hate Polish people irrationally and fanatically and would rather lose billions $$$ than allow a Polish person to be in charge of anything.
To get a full picture of what happened. Poland lost over 5 million citizens as a result of World War II. War damage is estimated at PLN 6 trillion, 220 billion and 609 million. Poland, as the victim and the most injured party of this war, lost 20% of its territory, just as the perpetrators of this war, the losers, Germany. The Germans stole 518,000 works of art worth USD 11.14 billion (estimates for 2001). Poland has only recovered several thousand works of art to date. The most interesting thing is how much compensation the Germans paid: PLN 4.7 billion, it's not a mistake. This is the same as four new tram lines in 2024 (the new line in Warsaw to Wilanów cost PLN 1.2 billion) For better thinking, the exchange rate of USD 1 is PLN 4.09. Do you have any thoughts of your own... of course the question is rhetorical.
Dear Sirs, nobody is talking about paying compensation in full at once, you probably know that Germany pays France, England and other countries, including people of Jewish origin, war reparations for World War I and World War II every year and this is not a small amount of money. So why can't Poland pay it back over a longer period of time in the annual amount set by both countries. Poland is the only country where helping Jews was punished with death for the entire family, in other countries there were no such punishments and yet Poles helped Jews. And now the world media no longer write that the concentration camps were German but often write that Polish death camps were possibly Nazi and those Nazis came from the moon? We have to say openly that they were Germans and not Nazis
@@danielmenefrego u see amount of cash and impact in deaths and how they re also treated kids with strange operations? U should be ashamed that ur mind emote fun. Karma soon
“Those who choose to forget the past are doomed to repeat it” written in Auschwitz. Same use of media as then by Hitler to fool the world. Visit to examine their old films. I did. It’s only being repackaged and re marketed as honest news. Lies by omission is still a lie.
The problem with Germany is that Germany, through its policy, is one of the main countries responsible for the war in Ukraine. Please remember that NS-2 (and more) is a German plan that was intended to make all EU countries energy-dependent on Russia through the hub in Germany but to give Germany the exclusive position of energy distribution in the all EU. This meant total German hegemony in Europe who will cooperate with Russia. This "hegemon" plan and cooperation with Russia was the reason for the liquidation of nuclear power plants in Germany. Today, Germany is paying a heavy price for this insidious plan caused today's energy crisis. For Poland, this would mean the liquidation of the state.
To prawda i jest to jedna z największych zbrodni współczesnych Niemców. Sfinansowali Putinowi wojnę w Ukrainie i ignorowali wszystkie ostrzeżenia ze strony Polaków i Bałtów. A gdy Putin napadł Ukrainę to zaoferowali napadniętemu państwu śpiwory i hełmy, gdy Polacy już słali napadniętemu sąsiadowi czołgi. Jest różnica nie tylko w mentalności, ale też w moralności.
Firstly Germany was against any military help to Ukraine. Poland and the Baltics wrung it out of Germany. Secondly I will explain: Germany gave 1 (one) patriot batery and the cost was around 1000.000.000$ . Poland gave 360 tanks + 250 armored fighting vechicles, that cost less. So the media truthfully reported that Germany gave more military aide (in $).... But if you are invaded by and ork army, what would you chuse to receive? The one Patriot batery?
Germany is blocking Polands growth for years. Is in their interest to have poor neighbour with cheap labour and food. Guess why you guys having such a cheap groceries compared to west of the UE.
Unfortunately it's not so easy, just to say "we don't want war". Because we may not want it, but goals of the authoritarian regimes are different than ours. It's like in the 1939 - we had nothing to say, cause these were totalitarian regimes, so Hitler and Germans as well as Stalin and Russians who wanted a global war.
1 Germany pay reparation to many other contrys but Poland. 2 Germany give less many with Poland compare to GDP. 3 Poland dont want war but we know if russia win it not be the last war. They want get more and more. Eweryone else will suffer...
The Germans claim that the issue of reparations was settled many years ago. Poland claims that this was done while Poland was de facto under soviet occupation and prior agreements did not reflect the will of the Polish people.
Wszystko ci się pomieszało. Polska nie twierdzi, że reparacje zostały skutecznie przeprowadzone w jakiejkolwiek formie. Nigdy nie powstał żaden dokument w tej sprawie. Nigdy nie nastąpiło zrzeczenie się polski z jej praw w sposób formalny. Niemcy mogą sobie gadać co chcą.
@@seboho6938 Chyba tobie…. Według wielu źródeł: In 1953, Poland's then-communist rulers relinquished all claims to war reparations under pressure from the Soviet Union, which wanted to free East Germany, also a Soviet satellite, from any liabilities.
@@ProblemSolverUS Nonsense, even communist government, didn't ratified that step, and it was directed towards DDR not West germany. Hence germany has no stance to its claims.
Ponad 100 mld euro Polska przekazała Ukrainie Jakie 4 mld niby od Niemiec gdzie na początku przekazali jakieś stare hełmy, a on mówi o największej pożyczce 🙂Daliśmy pomoc, socjal, militaria cały czas idą transze pomocy (chyba 45) A teraz chcą naszych żołnierzy w niby misjach pokojowych co spowoduje zaostrzenie konfliktu. Chcą nas wepchnąć w tą ''nie naszą'' wojne
Poland and Germany friends after WW2? Not really, at least not with West Germany. East was ally only because of being a puppet. West Germany wanted to take back Polish territory and didn’t recognized Polish west borders until 1971 or mostly 1991
Like Russians, Prussians, Islamists and even Napoleon wants to extinguish Their light. In 16th century, King Sobieski saved Europe from islamic Ottoman Invasion. Then came 1920 when they kicked out the Russians out of Warsaw. In late 1970’s their Son now a Saint marched back home preaching to “not be afraid”. They once again toppled USSR with help of Reagan who knew that US did not reciprocate for Kosciuszko’s & Pulaski’s service into obtaining their liberation from British. It was in Crimea after war where Roosevelt with Churchill and Stalin sliced Poland into fours. To Ukraine who massacred what ever intelligence was left, they received Lviv which was once Poland. Please no sugar coating, its not Trump’s style of honesty?
The Polish report about the damages caused by Germans in Poland during the WW II, giving the monetary value of these economic damages and the amount of reparations that Germany are due to Poland (Germany, so the state whose economy, including many of the companies that exist up to now, profited much from the whole WW II, in so many ways, who were exploiting the slavery workers, prisoners of the concentration camps, the goods stolen from the occupied lands etc.) - had a much important symbolic meaning. By the way, in the recent years (after 2020) Germany signed an agreement with Namibia, concerning payment of 1,1 billion euro for their even earlier crimes of genocide, committed in the years 1904-1908 on Herero and Nama people in Namibia (where they killed about 100 000 of people - while in Poland they killed more, and later).
On one hand germany closed its borders for migrants, on the other hand they sponsor ships bringing loads of migrants to Europe. One has to ask himself what is the goal for flooding Europe with people that germans reject.
Sprawdźcie proszę kiedy Niemcy przestali płacić reparacje za I wojnę światową. Nikt nie oczekuje, że reparacje zostaną zapłacone w jednej racie. Sprawdźcie proszę, kiedy Niemcy uznały granicę z Polską na Odrze i co o tym sądzi AdF i „wypędzeni”. Co do rezygnacji z reparacji to ZSRR wymusił na nas rezygnację z reparacji od NRD a nie NRF
Myślę, że 100% Polaków wyrzekła się marzeń i pragnień o odzyskaniu kresów, Lwowa i Wilna. To już wyłącznie część naszego dziedzictwa i tylko sentymentalna historia. Nie mam na to badań, ale tak z 10% Niemców chce zwrotu naszych "Ziem Odzyskanych" do rzeszy i są środowiska, które to mniej lub bardziej otwarcie głoszą.
Officially Germany was forced by USA, UK and USSR to pay contributions. Poland was not part of this deal but some money was decided to be paid to Poland. Contributions for every country one east of Germany was to be redistributed by USSR but they took all of it for themselves and after robbing every nation they claim they saved from Germany. What is more there are many personal accounts stating that German soldiers managed to keep everything they looted and it helped Germany a lot with the recovery. We ware looted by Germans and Russians, our familly members were murdered, imprisoned, assaulted, terrorized and humiliated by both of them only in the end to be forced to be a puppet state of the USSR and be not only robbed by forced unfair trade relationship (where we sold them stuff below our costs) for decades but also having totalitarian rule forced upon us. This angers people. They started the war, lost we were on the side that won the war but we ended up robbed, indentured servants. Both Germans and Soviets kept stuff looted from us, many (if not most) avoided any personal punishment. Because we were sold to Stalin all of our efforts and contributions were downplayed and ignored by all major powers. I would argue that the only respect we got was from people of Breda and some recognition for 303 flight squadron. This all is just unfair especially while Germans kept looking down on us (many of them still do).
my family had a farm in poland from grandmothers side and a company with 12 workers from grandfathers side. both was looted by the polish gov and later sold to the polish people. ia this included in the polish reparations? anyway. in revange I looted a polish girl from poland. because I am older then her she will in the end work to pay of the from poland wanted reparations.
Wars, except those in self-defense, are crimes against humanity and as such are the subject of reparations, if ever possible. Case in point, if Ukraine-Russia war ends, who else should pay for rebuilding Ukraine than Russia, while nobody think they will ever do that, at least not when under Putin. Not to mention, where the reparation for economic damages the Soviet Russia done to Poland shall come from? One moral standard has to apply---which, I guess, may apply to all truly ethical standards ever developed---no children shall ever pay for the crimes of their parents. As such, any reparation strategy must accommodate those "children" and, most likely, shall apply to German business entities that benefited from the WWII, which might include Volkswagen, BMW, Siemens, IG Farben (BASF, Bayer, Hoechst), Deutsche Bank, Krupp, Daimler-Benz (Mercedes-Benz), Allianz, Dr. Oetker, and Porsche.
For some time now I have been watching several channels of foreign creators talking or looking for information about Poland. Your channel took the lead after the break. Therefore, I thought that maybe you would like to have films about Poland from a Polish perspective. Any topic. I'm open to suggestions. I only warn you that the films will be subjective, based on the image of Poland from the perspective of a right-winger living in the provinces, in eastern Poland.
Christmas song by CZERWONE GITARY's original song ruclips.net/video/XWRRK-ws2Sk/видео.htmlsi=Nxn_Nzg-F0TNgjWc&t=56 released in 1967 - 1970's performance - Poland
jak sie nie ma nic rozsadnego do powiedzenia to lepiej nic nie mówić. Pisowska retoryka jest absurdalna. Podaj solidne fakty a nie glupkowate opinie to moze nikt cie nie bedzie z niczego usuwać.
Solidne fakty. 1. Pawel Piskorski,współzałożyciel z donkiem KLD, opisał jak twój idol nosil reklamówki kasy od niemców. 2. Wszystkie inwestycje zamykane w Polsce dziwnym trafem były konkurencją dla reichu. Kiedyś😢 Port Szczeciński, żegluga po Odrze, teraz CPK, LOT(miał być sprzedany za grosze Luftwaffe), PKP Cargo, ustawienie wymagań na szybkie koleje tak by tylko niemcy mogli wygrać kontrakt, itp. 3. Zapomniałeś o jego hołdzie lennym-Fur Deutschland? 4. Otrzymywał nagrody od frau Anieli, łącznie z wysoko wynagradzanym stanowiskiem w Brukseli. 5. Jak myślisz na czyje polecenie ślinił się do Wowy?.
What do you mean Poland and germany have fallen out? Germany is treating Poles as subhumans that MUST be taught how to be cicvilized. As for current primeminister, despite appearances, he walks on german leash. He follows instructions sent from Berlin sometines via Brussels.
Let's be honest, the reparations subject is created just for political purposes. I agree Poland deserves reparations both from Germany and from Russia. But no one talks about reparations from Russia because it's so impossible to receive, that it's even funny to think about it. However, we have a party that decides to build its own political base on antagonism (PiS). So, from the beginning, they create anti-German rhetoric, and the reparations subject was brought up as something to fill news time and cover other subjects that the media wouldn't be able to focus on anything different - because the reparations subject is catchy and it's something like a political clickbait for the media.
The problem is that not only were the reparations not paid, but also priceless Polish works of art are still in German museums and warehouses. This is not about interpersonal relations but about international politics, the Germans interfere too much in Poland's internal affairs. When the left in Poland lost the elections (8 years ago), the Germans blocked EU subsidies that we were entitled to because we pay contributions. They stated then that constitutional law is being broken in Poland, and when we proved to them that they were doing exactly the same, they told us that we have a worse legal culture, so they can break the law and we can't :) It's funny because Poland created the second constitution in the world right after the USA, and now the Germans want to teach us democracy where they were taught by force after World War II, and we have had democratic governments since the Middle Ages :)
@@DarthSkye-Gaming But you know that sounds so childish? We were wrong (by insulting Germany at every step under the PiS government), they were wrong (because they cut subsidies), and we prefer to pinch each other than to talk constructively. In the 8 years of the PiS government, there wasn't anything resembling a foreign policy, perhaps besides cooperation with Hungary. But hey, look at it from a distance. If you want to take back your things from your friend, do you first give them an insulting speech? Because that's how the demand for reparations seems: 7 years of insults followed by a bill for 6.2 trillion PLN. This is not how you speak when you expect something from someone, especially in diplomacy.
Both countries ENVIED POLISH HARDWORK & DISCOVERIES to date. France hijacked Polish Maria Sklodowska who discovered uranium; gave the world X-ray machine besides chemotherapy. She travel to US much like Pulaski and Kosciszko with sole daughter to finish their first reactor. Yet history has this TWO PEACE PRIZE WINNER WOMAN as if she was French due to marrying into Curies. Pillaging of Poland never stops and their creativity continues to inspire the world.
It is absolutely opposite! Germany attacked Polish government (you may not like the political flavor of our authorities but it is Germany attacking Poland for a God sake!) so we created this reparation report and fight back. So I agree - reparation request is made mostly for political reason and nobody expected Germans to pay. Not that we do not deserve money from Berlin, rather we just knows Germans . :) Anti German resentment in Polish society is true and was not created by PiS. PiS simply used it as a political leverage which is 100% legit action. Germany is benefitting a lot in keeping us in the Middle Income Trap and are doing a lot of actions to support the target. These actions are simply hidden and muted cause a lot of Polish media market share belongs to Germany. Just mind the CPK, Baltic ports, Odra river transport, atomic power plant build up, Izera project and many more being more or less secretly saboted by Berlin. Germany is not our Enemy but is a biggest rival of our state (excluding pure enemy - Russia). Just recognize facts and mind with it. ;) Peace...
I don't like politics, it's a pity that you started dealing with it (especially with that populist idiot Tarczyński). Fortunately, we have a democratic government in Poland again and, hopefully, a democratic president soon. Back to the topic, Suné's reaction to "swing" was so cute hahahaha. Love you guys.
Demokratyczny prezydent z ugrupowania polityczbego przestępców,w państwie rządzonym przez bandytów którzy za nic mają prawo? Jesteś narkomanem - prawda?
To get a full picture of what happened. Poland lost over 5 million citizens as a result of World War II. War damage is estimated at PLN 6 trillion, 220 billion and 609 million. Poland, as the victim and the most injured party of this war, lost 20% of its territory, just as the perpetrators of this war, the losers, Germany. The Germans stole 518,000 works of art worth USD 11.14 billion (estimates for 2001). Poland has only recovered several thousand works of art to date. The most interesting thing is how much compensation the Germans paid: PLN 4.7 billion, it's not a mistake. This is the same as four new tram lines in 2024 (the new line in Warsaw to Wilanów cost PLN 1.2 billion) For better thinking, the exchange rate of USD 1 is PLN 4.09. Do you have any thoughts of your own... of course the question is rhetorical.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Welcome back to another video! 💕👋 Thank you all for watching! We will see you in the next video👀 Are you Ready for our Poznan Vlogs?
You're wrong about reparations. Firstly, germany payed reparations to everyone else. Secondly, germany benefited from stolen goods, money, art and children that went missing and never came back home. Thirdly, a country doesn't pay reparations in one shot, obviously.
Yes, I am. Poznan is my hometown. Greetings from a former RSA resident (in the 80's) , currently residing in California.
Recently, the original "Gaude Mater Polonia" of the first Polish anthem with the stamp of the cathedral library from Płock, robbed during World War II, was found in a German museum. The Germans stated that if the Polish origin of the monument is proven, they will start possible negotiations regarding the return of the monument to Poland. The thief wants to negotiate with the robbed person, but it is up to the victim to prove that something belonged to him. Such German honesty.
Nie chodzi tylko o reparacje wojenne za zniszczenie kraju. Ukradli wiele dzieł sztuki i innych dóbr majątkowych, które nie chcą oddać.
A najgorsze, że oni się wcale nie zmienili. To są wciąż takie syny
A najgorsze, że oni się wcale nue zmienili. To są wciąż scoorvy yny
Niemcy kradli wszystko - absolutnie wszystko. Nie tylko złote zęby,ale nawet kible i umywalki.
I’m a Pole, that has lived outside of Poland for a long time. In fact, I grew up all over the world (Libya, Japan, UK) because my parents were diplomats.
I have been living in United States for the past 30 years. I hold both American and Polish passport as does my family. I truly love Poland and what it has done especially with its tumultuous history, certainly in the 20th century.
The problem with nonpayment of reparations by Germany, and Russia is absolutely pivotal. For starters it’s the amount of damage and the loss of human life which in the case of Poland amounted too close to 6 million souls.
This was true barbaric and murderous behavior that the perpetrators have to number one acknowledge and secondly compensate for. In order for there to be peace and moral justice, in the case of Germany there has to be an acknowledgment number one and secondly, a pathway to compensation. If Germany is truly to shake off the horrors of its past, it needs to step up and work with Poland and I might add Greece, whom they also ignored as far as reparations, in order to work out a path forward. I don’t think there is an expectation of payment of the whole asked amount at once or even in hard cash. I think there’s other ways of acknowledging and caring this out. The amount that was estimated by the IPN (the Institute of national remembrance) in Poland did not include the actual human potential loss, it didn’t include barbaric and permeative destruction of city of Warsaw in 1944, it did not include the return of all the cultural goods that were robbed from the country and thus not returned.
With all of this said, how would you feel in this situation if you were Polish?
Unfortunately, on top of this, there is still prejudice directed against Poland by German businesses. I’ve experienced this as a business person in the United States purchasing significant equipment from Germany. There is a lot of pent up prejudice and nationalism still embedded in the German psyche. This has to be dealt with by Germany from within as quickly as possible.
As a sidenote, both Poland and United States also have a lot of issues to work through.
I’m staying positive through current reshuffling that’s going on worldwide end caused entropy that I trust will eventually result in a much more just and evolved the world post 2030.
Say it as you see it. Big boys are LAZY and feel entitled to EXPLOIT and manipulate the honorable Empathic nation, Poland. How many wars do these psychopaths started world wide? How many loans they took from the world and DEFAULTED? Yet, they sit im EU imposing their covert narcissistic ideologues in order to BRING DOWN HARD WORKING PROSPEROUS emerging COUNTRIES. In schools we call them bullies. They never outgrow what works for them gaslighting, lies, projections, etc. Visit Auschwitz were truth does not lie on PSYCHOPATHIC PANDEMICS.
You are correct. I also hold American and Polish citizenship and I worked with Germans for 15 years - in the USA. I did some spectacular things for them (I am the guy who wrote PT Pilot for gearmotors configuration, the first online gearmotor configuration software / web app ever) and Germans absolutely hated me for it, committing significant resources over many years to erase the American / Polish contribution to the industry and to substitute it with (much inferior) German solution. They outspent our development by a factor 5:1 just to get rid of us (the same company, mind you). Germans hate Polish people irrationally and fanatically and would rather lose billions $$$ than allow a Polish person to be in charge of anything.
To get a full picture of what happened. Poland lost over 5 million citizens as a result of World War II. War damage is estimated at PLN 6 trillion, 220 billion and 609 million. Poland, as the victim and the most injured party of this war, lost 20% of its territory, just as the perpetrators of this war, the losers, Germany. The Germans stole 518,000 works of art worth USD 11.14 billion (estimates for 2001). Poland has only recovered several thousand works of art to date. The most interesting thing is how much compensation the Germans paid: PLN 4.7 billion, it's not a mistake. This is the same as four new tram lines in 2024 (the new line in Warsaw to Wilanów cost PLN 1.2 billion) For better thinking, the exchange rate of USD 1 is PLN 4.09. Do you have any thoughts of your own... of course the question is rhetorical.
Dear Sirs, nobody is talking about paying compensation in full at once, you probably know that Germany pays France, England and other countries, including people of Jewish origin, war reparations for World War I and World War II every year and this is not a small amount of money. So why can't Poland pay it back over a longer period of time in the annual amount set by both countries. Poland is the only country where helping Jews was punished with death for the entire family, in other countries there were no such punishments and yet Poles helped Jews. And now the world media no longer write that the concentration camps were German but often write that Polish death camps were possibly Nazi and those Nazis came from the moon? We have to say openly that they were Germans and not Nazis
They have actually paid off WWI reparations a few years ago 😂
@@danielmenefrego u see amount of cash and impact in deaths and how they re also treated kids with strange operations? U should be ashamed that ur mind emote fun. Karma soon
“Those who choose to forget the past are doomed to repeat it” written in Auschwitz. Same use of media as then by Hitler to fool the world. Visit to examine their old films. I did. It’s only being repackaged and re marketed as honest news. Lies by omission is still a lie.
@danielmenefrego Also, they paid reparations to one of the African nations for crimes done 200 years ago.
The problem with Germany is that Germany, through its policy, is one of the main countries responsible for the war in Ukraine. Please remember that NS-2 (and more) is a German plan that was intended to make all EU countries energy-dependent on Russia through the hub in Germany but to give Germany the exclusive position of energy distribution in the all EU. This meant total German hegemony in Europe who will cooperate with Russia. This "hegemon" plan and cooperation with Russia was the reason for the liquidation of nuclear power plants in Germany. Today, Germany is paying a heavy price for this insidious plan caused today's energy crisis. For Poland, this would mean the liquidation of the state.
To prawda i jest to jedna z największych zbrodni współczesnych Niemców. Sfinansowali Putinowi wojnę w Ukrainie i ignorowali wszystkie ostrzeżenia ze strony Polaków i Bałtów. A gdy Putin napadł Ukrainę to zaoferowali napadniętemu państwu śpiwory i hełmy, gdy Polacy już słali napadniętemu sąsiadowi czołgi. Jest różnica nie tylko w mentalności, ale też w moralności.
Some DNA’s habits never change.
@@Cp-o6c
The difference between germany and russia is working plumbing in german houses.
Firstly Germany was against any military help to Ukraine. Poland and the Baltics wrung it out of Germany. Secondly I will explain: Germany gave 1 (one) patriot batery and the cost was around 1000.000.000$ . Poland gave 360 tanks + 250 armored fighting vechicles, that cost less. So the media truthfully reported that Germany gave more military aide (in $).... But if you are invaded by and ork army, what would you chuse to receive? The one Patriot batery?
@PrzemysawNizioek Polska niczego nie dała , Polacy zostali po prostu okradzeni przez swojego prezydenta , który okazał się zdrajcą ,,,
Dodatkowo Niemcy cały czas starali się opóźniać pomoc dla Ukraińców. Cały czas retoryka Scholza oscylowała na pograniczu zdrady.
Germany is blocking Polands growth for years. Is in their interest to have poor neighbour with cheap labour and food. Guess why you guys having such a cheap groceries compared to west of the UE.
Some hide sloth behind envy.
@@Cp-o6c others working with own hands way up cos they born without family fortune. Stolen during wars.
You guys seem like very nice people. Unfortunately, Poland's neighbour's have not been and this is unlikely to change.
Unfortunately it's not so easy, just to say "we don't want war". Because we may not want it, but goals of the authoritarian regimes are different than ours. It's like in the 1939 - we had nothing to say, cause these were totalitarian regimes, so Hitler and Germans as well as Stalin and Russians who wanted a global war.
1 Germany pay reparation to many other contrys but Poland. 2 Germany give less many with Poland compare to GDP. 3 Poland dont want war but we know if russia win it not be the last war. They want get more and more. Eweryone else will suffer...
The Germans claim that the issue of reparations was settled many years ago. Poland claims that this was done while Poland was de facto under soviet occupation and prior agreements did not reflect the will of the Polish people.
Wszystko ci się pomieszało. Polska nie twierdzi, że reparacje zostały skutecznie przeprowadzone w jakiejkolwiek formie. Nigdy nie powstał żaden dokument w tej sprawie. Nigdy nie nastąpiło zrzeczenie się polski z jej praw w sposób formalny. Niemcy mogą sobie gadać co chcą.
@@seboho6938 Chyba tobie…. Według wielu źródeł: In 1953, Poland's then-communist rulers relinquished all claims to war reparations under pressure from the Soviet Union, which wanted to free East Germany, also a Soviet satellite, from any liabilities.
@@ProblemSolverUS
Nonsense, even communist government, didn't ratified that step, and it was directed towards DDR not West germany. Hence germany has no stance to its claims.
Germany did not give more than anyone. They just PROMISED it . And so far they did not keep single promise to Ukraine yet
Ponad 100 mld euro Polska przekazała Ukrainie Jakie 4 mld niby od Niemiec gdzie na początku przekazali jakieś stare hełmy, a on mówi o największej pożyczce 🙂Daliśmy pomoc, socjal, militaria cały czas idą transze pomocy (chyba 45) A teraz chcą naszych żołnierzy w niby misjach pokojowych co spowoduje zaostrzenie konfliktu. Chcą nas wepchnąć w tą ''nie naszą'' wojne
Poland and Germany friends after WW2? Not really, at least not with West Germany. East was ally only because of being a puppet. West Germany wanted to take back Polish territory and didn’t recognized Polish west borders until 1971 or mostly 1991
Like Russians, Prussians, Islamists and even Napoleon wants to extinguish Their light. In 16th century, King Sobieski saved Europe from islamic Ottoman Invasion. Then came 1920 when they kicked out the Russians out of Warsaw. In late 1970’s their Son now a Saint marched back home preaching to “not be afraid”. They once again toppled USSR with help of Reagan who knew that US did not reciprocate for Kosciuszko’s & Pulaski’s service into obtaining their liberation from British. It was in Crimea after war where Roosevelt with Churchill and Stalin sliced Poland into fours. To Ukraine who massacred what ever intelligence was left, they received Lviv which was once Poland. Please no sugar coating, its not Trump’s style of honesty?
The Polish report about the damages caused by Germans in Poland during the WW II, giving the monetary value of these economic damages and the amount of reparations that Germany are due to Poland (Germany, so the state whose economy, including many of the companies that exist up to now, profited much from the whole WW II, in so many ways, who were exploiting the slavery workers, prisoners of the concentration camps, the goods stolen from the occupied lands etc.) - had a much important symbolic meaning. By the way, in the recent years (after 2020) Germany signed an agreement with Namibia, concerning payment of 1,1 billion euro for their even earlier crimes of genocide, committed in the years 1904-1908 on Herero and Nama people in Namibia (where they killed about 100 000 of people - while in Poland they killed more, and later).
Because of Germany, everyone will soon be afraid to go to fairs
On one hand germany closed its borders for migrants, on the other hand they sponsor ships bringing loads of migrants to Europe. One has to ask himself what is the goal for flooding Europe with people that germans reject.
Sprawdźcie proszę kiedy Niemcy przestali płacić reparacje za I wojnę światową. Nikt nie oczekuje, że reparacje zostaną zapłacone w jednej racie. Sprawdźcie proszę, kiedy Niemcy uznały granicę z Polską na Odrze i co o tym sądzi AdF i „wypędzeni”. Co do rezygnacji z reparacji to ZSRR wymusił na nas rezygnację z reparacji od NRD a nie NRF
Myślę, że 100% Polaków wyrzekła się marzeń i pragnień o odzyskaniu kresów, Lwowa i Wilna. To już wyłącznie część naszego dziedzictwa i tylko sentymentalna historia. Nie mam na to badań, ale tak z 10% Niemców chce zwrotu naszych "Ziem Odzyskanych" do rzeszy i są środowiska, które to mniej lub bardziej otwarcie głoszą.
"Gutta cavat lapidem, non vi, sed sæpe cadendo"
"Załuski Library" History
Officially Germany was forced by USA, UK and USSR to pay contributions. Poland was not part of this deal but some money was decided to be paid to Poland. Contributions for every country one east of Germany was to be redistributed by USSR but they took all of it for themselves and after robbing every nation they claim they saved from Germany.
What is more there are many personal accounts stating that German soldiers managed to keep everything they looted and it helped Germany a lot with the recovery.
We ware looted by Germans and Russians, our familly members were murdered, imprisoned, assaulted, terrorized and humiliated by both of them only in the end to be forced to be a puppet state of the USSR and be not only robbed by forced unfair trade relationship (where we sold them stuff below our costs) for decades but also having totalitarian rule forced upon us. This angers people. They started the war, lost we were on the side that won the war but we ended up robbed, indentured servants. Both Germans and Soviets kept stuff looted from us, many (if not most) avoided any personal punishment. Because we were sold to Stalin all of our efforts and contributions were downplayed and ignored by all major powers. I would argue that the only respect we got was from people of Breda and some recognition for 303 flight squadron. This all is just unfair especially while Germans kept looking down on us (many of them still do).
my family had a farm in poland from grandmothers side and a company with 12 workers from grandfathers side. both was looted by the polish gov and later sold to the polish people. ia this included in the polish reparations?
anyway. in revange I looted a polish girl from poland. because I am older then her she will in the end work to pay of the from poland wanted reparations.
Wars, except those in self-defense, are crimes against humanity and as such are the subject of reparations, if ever possible. Case in point, if Ukraine-Russia war ends, who else should pay for rebuilding Ukraine than Russia, while nobody think they will ever do that, at least not when under Putin. Not to mention, where the reparation for economic damages the Soviet Russia done to Poland shall come from? One moral standard has to apply---which, I guess, may apply to all truly ethical standards ever developed---no children shall ever pay for the crimes of their parents. As such, any reparation strategy must accommodate those "children" and, most likely, shall apply to German business entities that benefited from the WWII, which might include Volkswagen, BMW, Siemens, IG Farben (BASF, Bayer, Hoechst), Deutsche Bank, Krupp, Daimler-Benz (Mercedes-Benz), Allianz, Dr. Oetker, and Porsche.
For some time now I have been watching several channels of foreign creators talking or looking for information about Poland. Your channel took the lead after the break. Therefore, I thought that maybe you would like to have films about Poland from a Polish perspective. Any topic. I'm open to suggestions. I only warn you that the films will be subjective, based on the image of Poland from the perspective of a right-winger living in the provinces, in eastern Poland.
You are doing good job, I like to watch your videos 😘
Christmas song by CZERWONE GITARY's original song ruclips.net/video/XWRRK-ws2Sk/видео.htmlsi=Nxn_Nzg-F0TNgjWc&t=56 released in 1967 - 1970's performance - Poland
Komentarz usunięty a ja tylko powiedziałem że Tusk to niemiecka marionetka.
jak sie nie ma nic rozsadnego do powiedzenia to lepiej nic nie mówić. Pisowska retoryka jest absurdalna. Podaj solidne fakty a nie glupkowate opinie to moze nikt cie nie bedzie z niczego usuwać.
Solidne fakty.
1. Pawel Piskorski,współzałożyciel z donkiem KLD, opisał jak twój idol nosil reklamówki kasy od niemców.
2. Wszystkie inwestycje zamykane w Polsce dziwnym trafem były konkurencją dla reichu. Kiedyś😢 Port Szczeciński, żegluga po Odrze, teraz CPK, LOT(miał być sprzedany za grosze Luftwaffe), PKP Cargo, ustawienie wymagań na szybkie koleje tak by tylko niemcy mogli wygrać kontrakt, itp.
3. Zapomniałeś o jego hołdzie lennym-Fur Deutschland?
4. Otrzymywał nagrody od frau Anieli, łącznie z wysoko wynagradzanym stanowiskiem w Brukseli.
5. Jak myślisz na czyje polecenie ślinił się do Wowy?.
Pod prysznicem słychać plusk, to Olafa kąpie Tusk!
Siemanko ;)
Being from SA, what is your take on Janusz Waluś?
Waluś jest naszym bohaterem , zlikwidował terrorystę i mordercę ...
What do you mean Poland and germany have fallen out?
Germany is treating Poles as subhumans that MUST be taught how to be cicvilized.
As for current primeminister, despite appearances, he walks on german leash. He follows instructions sent from Berlin sometines via Brussels.
You sounds South African. I wrote it before you revealed it. 😂
Let's be honest, the reparations subject is created just for political purposes. I agree Poland deserves reparations both from Germany and from Russia. But no one talks about reparations from Russia because it's so impossible to receive, that it's even funny to think about it. However, we have a party that decides to build its own political base on antagonism (PiS). So, from the beginning, they create anti-German rhetoric, and the reparations subject was brought up as something to fill news time and cover other subjects that the media wouldn't be able to focus on anything different - because the reparations subject is catchy and it's something like a political clickbait for the media.
The problem is that not only were the reparations not paid, but also priceless Polish works of art are still in German museums and warehouses. This is not about interpersonal relations but about international politics, the Germans interfere too much in Poland's internal affairs. When the left in Poland lost the elections (8 years ago), the Germans blocked EU subsidies that we were entitled to because we pay contributions. They stated then that constitutional law is being broken in Poland, and when we proved to them that they were doing exactly the same, they told us that we have a worse legal culture, so they can break the law and we can't :) It's funny because Poland created the second constitution in the world right after the USA, and now the Germans want to teach us democracy where they were taught by force after World War II, and we have had democratic governments since the Middle Ages :)
@@DarthSkye-Gaming But you know that sounds so childish? We were wrong (by insulting Germany at every step under the PiS government), they were wrong (because they cut subsidies), and we prefer to pinch each other than to talk constructively. In the 8 years of the PiS government, there wasn't anything resembling a foreign policy, perhaps besides cooperation with Hungary. But hey, look at it from a distance. If you want to take back your things from your friend, do you first give them an insulting speech? Because that's how the demand for reparations seems: 7 years of insults followed by a bill for 6.2 trillion PLN. This is not how you speak when you expect something from someone, especially in diplomacy.
Both countries ENVIED POLISH HARDWORK & DISCOVERIES to date. France hijacked Polish Maria Sklodowska who discovered uranium; gave the world X-ray machine besides chemotherapy. She travel to US much like Pulaski and Kosciszko with sole daughter to finish their first reactor. Yet history has this TWO PEACE PRIZE WINNER WOMAN as if she was French due to marrying into Curies. Pillaging of Poland never stops and their creativity continues to inspire the world.
If reparations with sanctions fail, has anyone given a thought to tariffs?
It is absolutely opposite! Germany attacked Polish government (you may not like the political flavor of our authorities but it is Germany attacking Poland for a God sake!) so we created this reparation report and fight back. So I agree - reparation request is made mostly for political reason and nobody expected Germans to pay. Not that we do not deserve money from Berlin, rather we just knows Germans . :)
Anti German resentment in Polish society is true and was not created by PiS. PiS simply used it as a political leverage which is 100% legit action.
Germany is benefitting a lot in keeping us in the Middle Income Trap and are doing a lot of actions to support the target. These actions are simply hidden and muted cause a lot of Polish media market share belongs to Germany. Just mind the CPK, Baltic ports, Odra river transport, atomic power plant build up, Izera project and many more being more or less secretly saboted by Berlin. Germany is not our Enemy but is a biggest rival of our state (excluding pure enemy - Russia). Just recognize facts and mind with it. ;)
Peace...
Pierwszy ;-)
I don't like politics, it's a pity that you started dealing with it (especially with that populist idiot Tarczyński). Fortunately, we have a democratic government in Poland again and, hopefully, a democratic president soon. Back to the topic, Suné's reaction to "swing" was so cute hahahaha. Love you guys.
Demokratyczny prezydent z ugrupowania polityczbego przestępców,w państwie rządzonym przez bandytów którzy za nic mają prawo? Jesteś narkomanem - prawda?
To get a full picture of what happened. Poland lost over 5 million citizens as a result of World War II. War damage is estimated at PLN 6 trillion, 220 billion and 609 million. Poland, as the victim and the most injured party of this war, lost 20% of its territory, just as the perpetrators of this war, the losers, Germany. The Germans stole 518,000 works of art worth USD 11.14 billion (estimates for 2001). Poland has only recovered several thousand works of art to date. The most interesting thing is how much compensation the Germans paid: PLN 4.7 billion, it's not a mistake. This is the same as four new tram lines in 2024 (the new line in Warsaw to Wilanów cost PLN 1.2 billion)
For better thinking, the exchange rate of USD 1 is PLN 4.09.
Do you have any thoughts of your own... of course the question is rhetorical.