Is bigger always better? | Head Squeeze

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
  • Have you ever heard the claim, that if an ant was the size of a human it could lift an elephant? Aside from the fact it would suffocate under its own exoskeleton, Hannah Fry @FryRsquared explains how things change with size. Subscribe: bit.ly/Subscrib...
    Best Earth Science videos: bit.ly/EarthLab...
    The Doctors Are In The House: bit.ly/TheDocto...
    Number Hub (Ep 29)
    Stand up mathematicians reveal the mind boggling stats and figures that make up the modern world.
    Welcome to BBC Earth Science! Here we answer all your curious questions about science in the world around you. If there’s a question you have that we haven’t yet answered let us know in the comments on any of our videos and it could be answered by one of our Earth Science experts.

Комментарии • 269

  • @ayszhang
    @ayszhang 7 лет назад +57

    Is it just me or is her voice so soothing

    • @clermeil
      @clermeil 7 лет назад +29

      I find her voice obscenely sexy.

    • @mathman1923
      @mathman1923 7 лет назад +4

      i could listen to her all day

  • @Lucas-on2wg
    @Lucas-on2wg 9 лет назад +196

    Holy shit this woman's voice is so nice to listen to

    • @ウィンディアス
      @ウィンディアス 9 лет назад +2

      +Lucas right....I was just drawn in...that voice...

    • @rinsmiff
      @rinsmiff 9 лет назад +8

      +Lucas math ASMR.

    • @davidm.johnston8994
      @davidm.johnston8994 8 лет назад +1

      YES!

    • @LePedant
      @LePedant 6 лет назад +1

      Her voice makes me super uncomfortable, it makes me feel like there is someone standing behind me. She is an awesome mathematician, so I bear threw and watch.

    • @GregorShapiro
      @GregorShapiro 5 лет назад

      Hanna Fry! A real mathematician too!

  • @Muppajevel
    @Muppajevel 5 лет назад +2

    Hannah is sooo comforting to listen to. Wish i had me one.

  • @ELYESSS
    @ELYESSS 8 лет назад +75

    That is not what I was thinking about when I clicked on the video

    • @owenevans83
      @owenevans83 8 лет назад +6

      Me neither. I'd give her something big...

    • @hornyfuckinturtle
      @hornyfuckinturtle 7 лет назад +1

      Big isn't better. Small ones last longer.

  • @TheRainshine79
    @TheRainshine79 10 лет назад +1

    i love the way she explains things and does not hesitate to draw upon multiple sources and analogies when figuring things out. the 2d-3d explanation was so ultimately short an clear. just perfect. :-)
    and she is gorgeous. somehow she reminds me of that ginger girl in "that 70s show". ;-)
    p.s.: social network analysis rocks! ;-)

  • @EebstertheGreat
    @EebstertheGreat 7 лет назад +2

    Fleas can actually jump well over 50 times their body length. But yes, that is still easily understood by considering scale. In more extreme cases, consider the pressure bacterial spores can withstand. Although most bacteria would be killed or inactivated at such extreme pressures, a wide variety can withstand 6,000 standard atmospheres. So why don't we make our submarine hulls out of protein? The answer of course is that these material properties don't apply at large scales. I wonder how much pressure a steel particle of 1 μm diameter could withstand!

  • @DummyFace123
    @DummyFace123 9 лет назад +18

    You've ruined ant man!

    • @livedandletdie
      @livedandletdie 8 лет назад +1

      +Hokibukisa He's the worst superhero.

  • @Henchman_Holding_Wrench
    @Henchman_Holding_Wrench 11 лет назад

    Her voice! It's so soothing.

  • @sth128
    @sth128 9 лет назад +45

    Yes but should I fight 100 duck sized horses or 1 horse sized duck?

    • @najkraemer3117
      @najkraemer3117 9 лет назад

      sth128 hhahaha i think i get it. its that game where you fight weird animals right??

    • @vantahawk2834
      @vantahawk2834 8 лет назад +14

      +sth128 Definitely 1 horse sized duck. This vid gave you a clear answer if you listened closely ;)

    • @thethirdjegs
      @thethirdjegs 2 года назад

      6 years later: are you going to fight an orangutan once a year or a chicken everyday you go to work.

    • @Fucisko
      @Fucisko 2 года назад

      @@thethirdjegs Definetly orangutan once a year. From a strength standpoint you would obviously be able to fight one chicken per day basically forever, however it would get so fucking annoying I'd rather let the orangutan kill me.

    • @thethirdjegs
      @thethirdjegs 2 года назад

      @@Fuciskoare you a fellow from wild green memes for ecological fiends?

  • @DJICAR
    @DJICAR 11 лет назад +3

    Love her voice!

  • @jeremywhillans987
    @jeremywhillans987 9 лет назад +9

    Them facts, that voice and not to be rude but very attractive as well. Your like a Quintuple threat!

  • @thegreatone921
    @thegreatone921 11 лет назад +2

    I could listen to Hannah's voice all day:)

  • @Silver_-_SunS
    @Silver_-_SunS 11 лет назад

    Head Squeeze deserves many more views than they get now. I simply can't wrap my head around it

  • @stikibunn
    @stikibunn 11 лет назад

    Someone should tell this to the people in Attack on Titan. If the titans are 3-12 metres tall they should be impossibly easy to beat. (actually the story does mention that they're incredibly light and therefore a 12 meter tall titan only weighs as much as a man in armor)

  • @TheBeetrootman
    @TheBeetrootman 11 лет назад

    A horse-sized duck of course! Can you imagine how awesome it'd be to ride it to work?!

  • @fikr1234
    @fikr1234 11 лет назад

    Size to power graph is drawn wrong. Shows power increasing exponentially with size.

  • @sashrill
    @sashrill 10 лет назад +56

    does anyone else feel like she is exremely attractive?

    • @jasonlancestewart
      @jasonlancestewart 10 лет назад +1

      Duh!

    • @Kiadaw77
      @Kiadaw77 9 лет назад +15

      I do not usually replies to such comments, but I guess its a combination of physical beauty, intelligence, & classic English accent.

    • @endezeichengrimm
      @endezeichengrimm 9 лет назад

      Why do you say anyone else?

    • @Rith9789
      @Rith9789 9 лет назад

      Adam Miller Why do we feel the need to point it out is the better question. I'd argue that women make us react in different ways.

    • @phantom498
      @phantom498 6 лет назад

      No, but she has a nice voice

  • @ColdBlade97
    @ColdBlade97 11 лет назад

    What about rowing??? Everybody says rowers should be big and heavy but judging your explanation they should be short and light because rowing is endurance race (2-6 km depends on the race).

  • @asthmaticrhino
    @asthmaticrhino 11 лет назад

    Horse sized duck would break it's own legs

  • @harley291096
    @harley291096 11 лет назад +1

    She's make an awesome weather girl.

  • @EriAirlangga
    @EriAirlangga 7 лет назад

    Let's hope for the extra footage soon

  • @shreedhar333
    @shreedhar333 11 лет назад +2

    I'm in love with your voice; obviously, not as much as I'm in love with science! :)

  • @D4rkTooga
    @D4rkTooga 11 лет назад

    PFF!! Easy, horse sized duck would let me get on his back and fly away!

  • @Ghost572
    @Ghost572 11 лет назад

    Also structure makes a difference aswell

  • @DFredleinPortfolio
    @DFredleinPortfolio 11 лет назад

    this could be a stupid question, but would gravity and relative size have an effect on this topic?

  • @motanelustelistu
    @motanelustelistu 10 лет назад +14

    I love inteligent girls :D + the soft lovely voice and the perfectly red hair,it's just the perfect girl

  • @xpac101000
    @xpac101000 11 лет назад

    she's floating

  • @Darca1n
    @Darca1n 11 лет назад

    Indeed, an easy example of how weight has an effect is by looking at a cube of say..one kilo, make it 2x2 and you have a cube that is double in size, but is four times the weight, muscles are somewhat the same and they also have to support the body itself.

  • @MrSandman730
    @MrSandman730 11 лет назад

    This begs the age old question: a horse-sized duck or 100 duck-sized horses?

  • @IAMCY8ORG
    @IAMCY8ORG 11 лет назад

    I may have missed it but did you mention anything about Gravity?

  • @torosyan
    @torosyan 11 лет назад

    well explained, shame about the graphics person not drawing the axis in the correct order! (unless that was some kind of inside joke)

  • @mehmetcangokcimen2846
    @mehmetcangokcimen2846 11 лет назад

    The title made my day.

  • @svtha1988
    @svtha1988 6 лет назад +1

    Whatever sometime bigger is better 😂😂😂😂😂 I mean bigger the heart, good deeds etc

  • @laynenadon9278
    @laynenadon9278 11 лет назад

    I get it and the math adds up, but I don't understand how dinosaurs got as big as they did or as to why the we're so strong as they were. Please explain to me. I am confounded, and confused.

  • @dionemoolman
    @dionemoolman 4 года назад

    So this means that there are three ways to measure strength: Raw force, force proportional to mass and force proportional to mass adjusted for size.

  • @frederickthorne2496
    @frederickthorne2496 5 лет назад

    BBC Earth Lab - feel free to moderate your comment section

  • @zachary007
    @zachary007 3 года назад +1

    How in the world was I seduced by a maths video?

  • @HomicidalDavid
    @HomicidalDavid 11 лет назад

    I suppose it's not possible for a human to be both a very good Marathon Runner and a Sprinter??
    I prefer the sprinters body even if there endurance is not as good as a long distance runners.

  • @dekippiesip
    @dekippiesip 9 лет назад +1

    100 mice vs the cat can only win if they have human intelligence.

  • @OmegaCraftable
    @OmegaCraftable 11 лет назад

    She is awesome! :) Well explained!

  • @alundrasrt
    @alundrasrt 11 лет назад

    Clever video.

  • @scoutfromearth9726
    @scoutfromearth9726 11 лет назад

    Best voice ever, just listen

  • @predator412569
    @predator412569 11 лет назад

    does this mean that a man who is 4 ft tall would be stronger than a clone at 6 ft tall?

  • @DavidLiu
    @DavidLiu 11 лет назад

    Now that's an easily misinterpretable title...

  • @lmenascojr
    @lmenascojr 5 лет назад

    Does this translate to inanimate objects like tanker ships and rockets?

  • @DarrenBrynly
    @DarrenBrynly 11 лет назад

    She has a lovely voice :)

  • @kujmous
    @kujmous 11 лет назад +5

    I think a channel of her doing nothing more than counting numbers may be in order. No? Ok.

  • @rickardliljekvist5983
    @rickardliljekvist5983 7 лет назад

    The Swedish Handball Team.
    How did they come into the picture at the end?
    Waz it a joke about "the real size" in the shorts? =)

  • @julbak01
    @julbak01 9 лет назад +1

    I must say that I really liked the video...BUT! the voice, damn, is gorgeous

  • @ArcanePhoenix980
    @ArcanePhoenix980 11 лет назад

    That's what she said ?

  • @facundovarela6813
    @facundovarela6813 11 лет назад

    Exelente!!!!

  • @aaroo9554
    @aaroo9554 11 лет назад

    don't*

  • @cedricburkhart3738
    @cedricburkhart3738 4 года назад

    Yeah I was made because I wanted to really know what the strongest animal is for it's size. I don't want to hear that some really small animal is strong for it's size when it's only able to lift so many times it's one weight because it's little. 😒 Make them the same size and then do the math to find out which is the strongest for it's size! or it's a shame!

  • @arcadyt
    @arcadyt 11 лет назад

    video's title is misleading :)

  • @medzoPuh
    @medzoPuh 11 лет назад

    Nice voice, do more vids with her

  • @Ghost572
    @Ghost572 11 лет назад

    So really we're limited by oxygen? I have heard of the concept that if insects grew in size they wouldn't function. I guess I'll need to watch this video again because I have been wondering for a while about this. Or someone could simplify it for me : p

  • @DD3874
    @DD3874 8 лет назад +2

    my girlfriend can't help saying bigger is better! shall i woory?

    • @livedandletdie
      @livedandletdie 8 лет назад +4

      +Daniel Evrard Tell her that a smaller one is more efficient, and that the bigger it is, the more likely that the male will die if it gets erect. Seeing as after a certain size, the 6litres of blood isn't enough to keep you from falling unconscious.

  • @TheAdder36
    @TheAdder36 11 лет назад

    LOL, really you thought calling it that was a good idea...

  • @TumainiTiger1
    @TumainiTiger1 11 лет назад

    or we could just stick to what we do now, the much easier option of stepping on them xD

  • @warlord456able
    @warlord456able 11 лет назад

    What if u/something else where twice as big

  • @izamanaick
    @izamanaick 11 лет назад

    How exactly do you get 8 times bigger? You get 2x bigger in height, width and depth but what else?

  • @OlleLindestad
    @OlleLindestad 11 лет назад

    With a drawing tablet! :)

  • @aaronmcdaniel7768
    @aaronmcdaniel7768 7 лет назад

    I need more of your voice... *Subscribes*

  • @nikolanovakovic7095
    @nikolanovakovic7095 7 лет назад

    i love you hannah

  • @ericsteiner4094
    @ericsteiner4094 9 лет назад

    Aight, so she said ants breath through osmosis. I thought ants breathed through diffusion,
    Now osmosis is just the diffusion of water...so did she mean diffusion or do ants actually take in water through their skin and breath like that?

    • @BananaBLACK
      @BananaBLACK 9 лет назад

      Osmosis is diffusion though a cell membrane. Water is the most common solvent, but not the only one.

  • @Si-Al-Ti
    @Si-Al-Ti 7 лет назад +3

    swedish handball team? i dont think i get it?

    • @richardtickler8555
      @richardtickler8555 7 лет назад +1

      bolt had a hotel party with the swedish womens handball team at the 2012 olympics

    • @Si-Al-Ti
      @Si-Al-Ti 7 лет назад

      ty

  • @patmacalister
    @patmacalister 11 лет назад

    So, "Tarantula" was bullshit?

  • @chitarito100
    @chitarito100 9 лет назад +1

    You are iggy's red headed more intelligent, sexier twin.

  • @Meninx87
    @Meninx87 11 лет назад

    oh wait, dUck!

  • @jgbusquets
    @jgbusquets 9 лет назад +3

    What does she exactly say at the end of the speech? Something about a "sweedish handball team", do I hear right? Looks like a joke but I don't get it...

    • @LiamE69
      @LiamE69 9 лет назад +1

      +Jordi Garcia Yes you heard right. www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/usain-bolt-parties-with-three-of-the-swedish-1230004

    • @jgbusquets
      @jgbusquets 9 лет назад

      +LiamE69 Thanks LiamE69... but what does she exactly say after "bigger it's not always necesseraly better"?

    • @LiamE69
      @LiamE69 9 лет назад +2

      +Jordi Garcia "bigger is not always necessarily better but try telling that to Usain Bolt and the Swedish Handball team."

    • @jgbusquets
      @jgbusquets 9 лет назад

      +LiamE69 Thanks!

  • @nnahomm
    @nnahomm 11 лет назад

    The end was pretty corny

  • @mattacy
    @mattacy 11 лет назад

    i thought this video would be about something else....

  • @actiontom
    @actiontom 11 лет назад

    :) I love your voice

  • @Travis.Ryckman
    @Travis.Ryckman 11 лет назад

    vsause

  • @happymonkey39
    @happymonkey39 11 лет назад

    I may have subscribed if it weren't for that last comment...

  • @OwnageProductions03
    @OwnageProductions03 11 лет назад

    Why the hell was this posted into the James May topic in a ploy to get me to watch this? Pathetic.

  • @tylerbrown8098
    @tylerbrown8098 7 лет назад +1

    I'd be perfectly willing to perform experiments with her to determine the answer to the title of the video.

  • @webjunkienl
    @webjunkienl 11 лет назад +1

    1 cat vs 100 mice..
    well, my money is on the cat.
    and to the comments below..
    haven't you nerds seen a woman before?
    control those hormones ffs.. lol

  • @sfhie
    @sfhie 11 лет назад

    omg that whole time im like, wow she is so pretty and then she had to go do the Bolt stance and it was soo cringeworthy.

  • @zhemin
    @zhemin 11 лет назад

    Hehe LoL :'D

  • @rackhisho
    @rackhisho 11 лет назад

    missleading title for the dirty minded

  • @F_L_U_X
    @F_L_U_X 11 лет назад

    Are you sure that's even female?

  • @juanpaolofigueras9865
    @juanpaolofigueras9865 9 лет назад

    Iggy Azalea bish!

  • @astrid1870
    @astrid1870 10 лет назад +108

    That title though

    • @ibyzrulez
      @ibyzrulez 9 лет назад +5

      Omg you just made me burst out laughing haha xD

    • @omerbitton9689
      @omerbitton9689 5 лет назад

      I know what you're thinking about... capital, well communism rule you bourgeois pig

    • @VitaliyCD
      @VitaliyCD 2 года назад

      I am embarrassed for not even noticing that.

  • @avantgardeaclue
    @avantgardeaclue 9 лет назад +16

    just watched a couple of her videos. Really starting to like her

  • @jaredmowens
    @jaredmowens 7 лет назад +80

    I would disappoint her so hard.

  • @Abersanbn
    @Abersanbn 11 лет назад +8

    Hannah just destroyed my hate for math and numbers and replaced it with love, joy and happiness.

  • @SneakyFatKid7
    @SneakyFatKid7 9 лет назад +11

    Last I checked f(x)=x^(3/4) doesn't look like the graph at 2:09

    • @Currywurst4444
      @Currywurst4444 8 лет назад

      "Power is proportional to Mass^(3/4)" is right. The graph with mass on the x-Axis would correspond to the function f(x)=x^(4/3).

  • @santiagotopali1
    @santiagotopali1 9 лет назад +5

    ***** Please tell Mrs Hannah that her wisdom and beauty has reached Chile. Bloody Hell she's gorgeous.

  • @Tmathh
    @Tmathh 7 лет назад +9

    omg that voice

  • @ShadowsHeat
    @ShadowsHeat 11 лет назад +3

    Very informative, plus something about her voice really gets my attention.

  • @benedictifye
    @benedictifye 8 лет назад +7

    I've heard that insects were bigger in certain prior eras when there was more oxygen in the atmosphere, and bugs are as big as they can be while still being able to respirate in our current atmosphere

    • @benedictifye
      @benedictifye 8 лет назад

      Something to do with the size of blood vessels etc

    • @senselocke
      @senselocke 7 лет назад +3

      That's mentioned in the video: Ants breathe through osmosis. They don't have lungs to draw in fresh air and expel "used" air like we do, nor do they have oxygen travel through the circulatory system. Instead, they have spiracles (vents) that lead to tracheal tubes all throughout the body, so that oxygen from the air goes directly into oxygen-starved tissues, and built-up carbon dioxide goes directly from cell to relatively less densely carbonated air.
      So with a higher concentration of oxygen in the atmosphere, less air can provide the same amount of oxygen, leading to a higher potential number of cells able to be "fed" by this relatively simple system. Which means ants and other insects could be scaled up in size and still breathe safely.
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Respiratory_system_of_insects

  • @theghostmachine
    @theghostmachine 9 лет назад +4

    Dr. Hannah Fry is just brilliant. I learned a lot from her. I wish she was my math lecturer.

    • @najkraemer3117
      @najkraemer3117 9 лет назад +4

      theghostmachine dont you wish she was somthing more? XD *wink*

  • @reecelollylington3401
    @reecelollylington3401 7 лет назад +4

    Bing watching these videos

  • @babbisp1
    @babbisp1 4 года назад +1

    With a voice like that, who needs short-distance relationships?

  • @OlleLindestad
    @OlleLindestad 11 лет назад +1

    Insects do breathe by osmosis, but so do we (oxygen osmosing from air into blood vessels across the membranes of our lung cells).
    The difference, rather, is that insects breathe by diffusion to a much higher degree than we do. That is to say, they rely on the passive movement of oxygen into their thracheae, whereas we actively breathe.
    Then again, some larger insects (and spiders!) actively ventilate as well. Just look at the pumping abdomen of a wasp or dragonfly, for example. :)

  • @stopaskingmetousemyrealnam3810
    @stopaskingmetousemyrealnam3810 7 лет назад +1

    This title is a bit obnoxious. Surprised that it's coming from something affiliated with the BBC.

  • @singhanant
    @singhanant 11 лет назад +1

    Yes you are correct, they got it wrong in the graphic but I think the concept holds.

  • @ThePillow86
    @ThePillow86 11 лет назад +1

    How do you create those amazing animations that look like someone is drawing without seeing there hands?

  • @AaronMolligan
    @AaronMolligan 11 лет назад +1

    she has an amazing voice, i love it, i love it, sweet and beautiful, great explanation on size and great presenter.