Not having a lot of formal music training, I feel free to evaluate a work on its own merit. In this, I ask dto I like a work. I found to my listening ear, this work to be exceptional. It is now part of my listening repertoire.
Siefried Wagner est un grand compositeur, malheureusement éclipsé par son père Richard. Il faut écouter ses opéras, sa symphonie, pour s'en convaincre.
Very beatifull connection at the beginning to Richar's Wagner Renunciation of Love motiv, used in Ring of Nibelungs. What a loose that Richard used it only few times during whole 4 Nibelung dramas ...
This music is really GOOD ! Obviously cannot be better or even equal to that of his father, Richard Wagner . Maybe , If was a work of Gustav Mahler or Richard Straus (pos-romantic composers ) we would have many compliments here .
I find that it has a lot of similarity to Hans Rott Symphony no. 1 from 1880. The proto post-romantic. It's less progressive than even Rott though. But that ending is really nice!
A truly inspired and moving masterpiece that deserves far wider recognition. Too bad its fame has been obscured by repetition of second-raters like Mahler, Bernstein, Mendelssohn, et al!
bastianjohannse Siegfried was also part jewish through his mother! so much for 'racial superiority'---our lives are up to the individual, not the race.
Beats me why he thought it a good career choice to become a composer. Not that he was a bad one, but he had a legacy that was impossible to live up to. So why bother and not become a dentist instead?
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks lot for having the score simultaneously running in the background!!!!
wow at last Siegfried Wagner has a bit more of a youtube presence! Thank you- keep up the good work! :)
I love that he wrote this piece after his first homoerotic encounter. Gives such a nice context to the piece.
Franz, Richard and Siegfried, great family.
Very close family....sensitive.....touchy-feeling. BRAVO from Acapulco!
@@steveegallo3384 Absolutely. ^^
Not having a lot of formal music training, I feel free to evaluate a work on its own merit. In this, I ask dto I like a work. I found to my listening ear, this work to be exceptional. It is now part of my listening repertoire.
Siefried Wagner est un grand compositeur, malheureusement éclipsé par son père Richard. Il faut écouter ses opéras, sa symphonie, pour s'en convaincre.
Oui c'est vrai que cette pièce est très bonne à mon avis 🥰
Very beatifull connection at the beginning to Richar's Wagner Renunciation of Love motiv, used in Ring of Nibelungs. What a loose that Richard used it only few times during whole 4 Nibelung dramas ...
Musical beauty is truly in the ear of the listener. So many diametrically opposed opinions are in the comments about this video.
Amazing :)
So beautiful-especially 17:09! :)
Prelude to his Sternengebot, op. 5
This music is really GOOD ! Obviously cannot be better or even equal to that of his father, Richard Wagner . Maybe , If was a work of Gustav Mahler or Richard Straus (pos-romantic composers ) we would have many compliments here .
I find that it has a lot of similarity to Hans Rott Symphony no. 1 from 1880. The proto post-romantic. It's less progressive than even Rott though. But that ending is really nice!
According to IMSLP it was published at around 1908. So I would assume that it's the manuscript which resurfaced, not the work as a whole.
"Helferich" did well. He created his own oeuvre. A lot of respect for the underestimated son of a genius (sic).
Why "sic"? Greetings from Acapulco.
Reminiscent of passages from Wagner's Tristan und Isolde.
grandilocuente y vacia de sentimiento por mas que si lo intenta pero languidece
12:50 overture der fliegende holländer
17:08 Prelude to Sternengebot
*~17:07
A truly inspired and moving masterpiece that deserves far wider recognition. Too bad its fame has been obscured by repetition of second-raters like Mahler, Bernstein, Mendelssohn, et al!
I hope that it is a coincidence, that the supposed "second-raters" are all composers with jewish backround!
bastianjohannse Siegfried was also part jewish through his mother! so much for 'racial superiority'---our lives are up to the individual, not the race.
+marc roland Mendelssohn second rate????
+marc roland Mendelssohn died in 1847, 20 years before Siegfried was born....give it another try....
+bastianjohannse NOT a coincidence :(
Beats me why he thought it a good career choice to become a composer.
Not that he was a bad one, but he had a legacy that was impossible to live up to. So why bother and not become a dentist instead?
3rd rate stuff. No one would listen to this without knowing his father.