Gratulations to the audience! They managed not to appplaud after the third movement. Knowing there will be a finale with lots of emotions. Wonderful rendition.
Every time I listen to the Pathetique I get a jolt right at the beginning of the 4th movt and that's because the 3rd movt is so festive. That last movement is just the epitomy of utter pain; everything leads to ultimate tragedy.
After having heard Mr Manze in concert with the forces of the WDR (Respighi, Schumann, Tchaikovsky), I am a fan. A wonderful conductor. He deserves greater recognition, IMO. And this, btw, was a very fine performance as well. Keep the standard high!
So much energy and passion. It truly brings resonance to the ongoing tragedies in Ukraine. May peace be upon the country and many survive such atrocities and families be reunited very soon. Bravo to the conductor, the orchestra and the recording team for this brilliant performance. 👏👏👏
I think, that Schostakovich's 11 "truly brings resonance to the ongoing tragedies in Ukraine". And 7! As Maxim Schostakovich said, his father's music rises above the descriptions of Stalin's character to a generalization of his attitude toward tyranny in all its forms.
"It truly brings resonance to the ongoing tragedies in Ukraine" - Indeed it does. 46 biolabs close by & finally Russian patience is lost. Will us peasants ever be free of the powerful families that have ruled us for centuries?
マンゼさんの理に適った自然な演奏の流れと、知性に支えられた抑制と解放のバランスが絶妙である。オーケストラから紡ぎだされるサウンドの一つ一つが全てみな美しい。最高の演奏を届けて頂き、心から深く感謝致します。 Its the best performance ive ever heard. All the sounds that come out are beautiful. I experienced a fresh impression. Thank you! 光明こと中井章弘
Thank you very much! If you are interested in Manze's farewell, you can find the live stream on saturday at 8pm here... -> www.ndr.de/orchester_chor/radiophilharmonie/konzerte/Abschiedskonzert-fuer-Chefdirigent-Andrew-Manze,manze434.html
At last, a pause after the pppp double bassoon. Silvestri showed the way 65 years ago. Bravo Andrew Manze! Then he puts the first mvmt closure through a blender :(
Wunderschöne und detaillierte Aufführung dieser romantischen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut vereinigten und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Der letzte Satz klingt besonders schön und echt wehkläglich. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das perfekt trainierte Orchester im gut analysierten Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Wahrlich hörenswert!
War dieses sinnentleerte Geschwurbele nicht der Text für Elgars "perfekt komponierte" Erste? Wieder eine Sinfonie mit "gut vereinigten(!)" und "perfekt entsprechenden"(!) Tönen. Erstaunlicherweise sogar ALLER Instrumente! Und wieder ein intelligenter Dirigent (der hat sogar Abitur!). Wer ist denn der nächste "intelligente und geniale" Dirigent mit "gut analysiertem" Tempo und "künstlerisch kontrollierter" Dynamik. - Das muss KI geschrieben haben, sowas lächerliches bringt wohl kein denkendes Wesen zustande. - Meldung von KI: Ist selbst ihr zu peinlich..
Russia has wonderful authors and wonderful composers and I believe, also wonderful people. We are neighbours! So sad that this aggression of Putin in starting an attack of an innocent country has in Russia been to defending Russia against nazists. It is like in Orwells book 1984.
Спасибо! Любви! Здоровья! Удачи! Мира и Добра!🌹🌹🌹🧧🍀 Тольятти Россия, Павлодар Казахстан. 14.03.2022 г.
I have been listening to this masterpiece of a symphony for over 70 years and I still goosebumps. Thank you for the stunning performance.
Our pleasure! Thank you for joining us!
Gratulations to the audience! They managed not to appplaud after the third movement. Knowing there will be a finale with lots of emotions. Wonderful rendition.
Just wanted to say thanks to the audience!
Every time I listen to the Pathetique I get a jolt right at the beginning of the 4th movt and that's because the 3rd movt is so festive. That last movement is just the epitomy of utter pain; everything leads to ultimate tragedy.
After having heard Mr Manze in concert with the forces of the WDR (Respighi, Schumann, Tchaikovsky), I am a fan. A wonderful conductor. He deserves greater recognition, IMO. And this, btw, was a very fine performance as well. Keep the standard high!
Thank you! :)
May peace and kindness prevail! Big thanks for sharing this wonderful music of my favorite composer.
🕊️ Thank you 🕊️
Bellísimo!! Muchas gracias por compartirlo!!
Gracias 🤩 ¡¡Y gracias por el comentario!!
@@NDRKlassik Muchos saludos desde México! :)
Just could not be better, thank you!
You are very welcome! Thank you for commenting!
So much energy and passion. It truly brings resonance to the ongoing tragedies in Ukraine. May peace be upon the country and many survive such atrocities and families be reunited very soon. Bravo to the conductor, the orchestra and the recording team for this brilliant performance. 👏👏👏
I think, that Schostakovich's 11 "truly brings resonance to the ongoing tragedies in Ukraine". And 7!
As Maxim Schostakovich said, his father's music rises above the descriptions of Stalin's character to a generalization of his attitude toward tyranny in all its forms.
"It truly brings resonance to the ongoing tragedies in Ukraine" - Indeed it does. 46 biolabs close by & finally Russian patience is lost. Will us peasants ever be free of the powerful families that have ruled us for centuries?
The Ukrainians should play the third movement march when they defeat the russian invaders.
How nice to see a conductor actually using the stick from his wrist, instead of just an extension of his arm.
What….? It is about MUSIC, not about dance, sport. You have to rehearse well…it does not matter ONE bit what you do with a stick.
マンゼさんの理に適った自然な演奏の流れと、知性に支えられた抑制と解放のバランスが絶妙である。オーケストラから紡ぎだされるサウンドの一つ一つが全てみな美しい。最高の演奏を届けて頂き、心から深く感謝致します。 Its the best performance ive ever heard.
All the sounds that come out are beautiful. I experienced a fresh impression. Thank you!
光明こと中井章弘
Many thanks!! Much appreciated!
Bravo, Manze! Bravo his team! Bravo, NDR!
Thank you very much! If you are interested in Manze's farewell, you can find the live stream on saturday at 8pm here... -> www.ndr.de/orchester_chor/radiophilharmonie/konzerte/Abschiedskonzert-fuer-Chefdirigent-Andrew-Manze,manze434.html
Exactly war is bad,but Tchaikovsky, music,art culture of Russia is not bad !
I only pray for and want the peace , all person’s happiness.
Magnífico! 🎶👏👏
Gracias!!
Joya del inmortal maestro ruso.
Lo más conmovedor...el prolongado silencio que cierra la obra...
The director sure had an eye for the Korean lady in the first violin section.
I can’t say I blame him either. She is beautiful.
この曲は最高のオーケストレーションです。
At last, a pause after the pppp double bassoon. Silvestri showed the way 65 years ago. Bravo Andrew Manze!
Then he puts the first mvmt closure through a blender :(
The Pathetique is both the last and the most tragic piece Tchaikovsky wrote
0:54 21:49 Contrabass's bowing
15:42 clarinet solo
Wunderschöne und detaillierte Aufführung dieser romantischen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut vereinigten und perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Der letzte Satz klingt besonders schön und echt wehkläglich. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das perfekt trainierte Orchester im gut analysierten Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Wahrlich hörenswert!
Vielen Dank :)
Hahaha! Schon wieder wunderschöne und detaillierte…..intelligente und geniale dirigent!
War dieses sinnentleerte Geschwurbele nicht der Text für Elgars "perfekt komponierte" Erste? Wieder eine Sinfonie mit "gut vereinigten(!)" und "perfekt entsprechenden"(!) Tönen. Erstaunlicherweise sogar ALLER Instrumente! Und wieder ein intelligenter Dirigent (der hat sogar Abitur!). Wer ist denn der nächste "intelligente und geniale" Dirigent mit "gut analysiertem" Tempo und "künstlerisch kontrollierter" Dynamik. - Das muss KI geschrieben haben, sowas lächerliches bringt wohl kein denkendes Wesen zustande. - Meldung von KI: Ist selbst ihr zu peinlich..
@@leonardoiglesias2394 Er kanns nicht lassen. Fürchterlich...
@@michaelfischer5800 aber der NDR kann es auch nicht lassen sich bei so jemanden zu bedanken….die nehmen ihn ernst….
Good job, but Bernstein is an other planet
Bernstein is a person, not a planet.
😂😂😂😂😂.
StopRussianAggression
Stop NATO/US agression to the east.
StopViolenceToCitizen
@@peckz8327 Stop fascist Russian propaganda.
Замечательное произведение.Блестящее исполнение.Спесибо !
Russia has wonderful authors and wonderful composers and I believe, also wonderful people. We are neighbours! So sad that this aggression of Putin in starting an attack of an innocent country has in Russia been to defending Russia against nazists. It is like in Orwells book 1984.