We Smuggled Ourselves Into New York's Abandoned City Hall Station

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 янв 2025

Комментарии • 5 тыс.

  • @thedexterbros
    @thedexterbros 5 лет назад +4403

    You didn't smuggle anything. You're allowed to stay on that train when it goes through the old station to turn around. I've done it a few times. Gonna sneak in to Central Park next?

    • @Angelof236
      @Angelof236 5 лет назад +51

      lmao xD

    • @blank2819
      @blank2819 5 лет назад +24

      Lmao

    • @DragonSlayerofficial
      @DragonSlayerofficial 5 лет назад +7

      @Stahlhelm Model. 1940 Fd. Gr. lol

    • @BigMan-pv3ee
      @BigMan-pv3ee 5 лет назад +23

      These lads ACTUALLY did it: ruclips.net/video/vWF3IDk9Gek/видео.html

    • @kahina3878
      @kahina3878 5 лет назад +22

      In"My haunted diary" video, the guy is actually in the station with a bunch of people getting off the train in the city hall station. Does not look like the impossible mission to me either...

  • @kobyschechter8163
    @kobyschechter8163 2 года назад +352

    You guys didn’t sneak in at all Lmao. I’ve ridden the 6 train around the loop a few times and the subway conductors are very nice about letting me do it. I got the chance to actually stand on the platform in August 2019 with the NY Transit Museum LEGALLY. It was ten minutes in my life that I’ll remember FOREVER.

    • @CamPalinSmith
      @CamPalinSmith 2 года назад +25

      I mean, this is a video by BuzzFeed. You can't be expecting actual quality from them.

    • @scubadiva666
      @scubadiva666 Год назад +7

      I came here to say this, since I've taken the Transit Museum tour twice-which included an informative above-ground walking tour immediately before the tour; I also regularly ride the 6 train around the bend from downtown to uptown, although visibility of the station is ridiculously poor.
      I'm more interested to see the now-closed lower-level City Hall station on the N line going out to Brooklyn Heights, since you can actually see the station by looking down through the locked gate.
      I'd love to visit the 18th street station on the 6 train, since that station was closed in the 40s; that's one I've only experienced by pressing my nose to the window when the 4 or 5 train slows just before it reaches the Union Square station.

  • @danielskinks8862
    @danielskinks8862 7 лет назад +4059

    that's how people In horror movies die

    • @danielskinks8862
      @danielskinks8862 7 лет назад +9

      Molly Bennett 😤😩👏🏼🍌

    • @m0llybn
      @m0llybn 7 лет назад +4

      danielskinks plz

    • @ThePasu88
      @ThePasu88 7 лет назад +11

      everything aboutt this video screams the movie wid bradley cooper "the midnight meat train" esp wid the whole last stop bit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @AlexisLaFury
      @AlexisLaFury 7 лет назад +8

      ThePasu88 OMG, yes! I totally thought Midnight Meat Train!

    • @bigmike9128
      @bigmike9128 7 лет назад +2

      Alexis LaFury me too.

  • @TheNakedNYC
    @TheNakedNYC 6 лет назад +489

    New York Transit Museum has Old City Hall tour. Old City Hall station tours begin above ground with a historical walk in the area, followed by a visit to the station itself. Tours last 90 minutes and tickets cost $50 per person.

    • @andrewyu5569
      @andrewyu5569 4 года назад +17

      thanks for ruining my dream cuz im not paying 200 bucks

    • @VieleGuteFahrer
      @VieleGuteFahrer 3 года назад +3

      @@andrewyu5569 Then go alone.

    • @whaur1394
      @whaur1394 3 года назад +3

      50$ for a visit ??

    • @Serkin76
      @Serkin76 3 года назад +3

      @@whaur1394 Not exactly. You must become a member of the NY Transit Museum (it costs 60 $ per year) and after that you can book a guided tour for 50 $. Total = 110 $ for the 90' visit. Sadly, it's too much for my pocket.

    • @whaur1394
      @whaur1394 3 года назад +2

      @@Serkin76 It's too much for you because it's simply just too much, in Europe visits cost between 5-15€ most of the time and for more things that just a station

  • @sarahdube3820
    @sarahdube3820 7 лет назад +1871

    I love how they have to make sure they tell everyone that trespassing is illegal and we shouldn't do it... most of us will do it anyways 😂

    • @gabriellakaranopoulos
      @gabriellakaranopoulos 7 лет назад

      Sarah Dubé I

    • @capableloop82
      @capableloop82 7 лет назад +37

      Sarah Dubé They don't want flocks if people trying to do the same thing and crowd an old subway station

    • @palomalopez8008
      @palomalopez8008 7 лет назад

      Sarah Dubé for real lol like idgaf

    • @abbyward8017
      @abbyward8017 7 лет назад +6

      I trespassed once... i was 3 and didn't know what i was doing was illegal lol

    • @meowcammi
      @meowcammi Год назад +2

      i know this was 6 yrs ago but this technically isn't trespassing, as people here in nyc are allowed to sit on trains after the last stop

  • @johnjacobjingleheimer-schm8283
    @johnjacobjingleheimer-schm8283 6 лет назад +3515

    Why not clean it up, and use it as a freaking tourist attraction? People travel all over the world to see old architecture, we’re obsessed with it as a species.

    • @MerleTrains
      @MerleTrains 6 лет назад +357

      the thing is: there actually are tours to this station by the mta transit museum

    • @jcfilmz509
      @jcfilmz509 6 лет назад +104

      Well if you think about people in 2018 we tend to love blowing up big meaningful structures and this station is right underneath the city hall.

    • @beachbum4691
      @beachbum4691 6 лет назад +5

      Julian Cameraboi Ha' ha, Now that would involve being just a bit too naughty ?? ;) Don't do it :)

    • @daveidmarx8296
      @daveidmarx8296 6 лет назад +19

      Yes, because there aren't ENOUGH tourist attractions (and tourists) all over New York. :-P

    • @matthewleeds9242
      @matthewleeds9242 6 лет назад +74

      They were planning and working on it, but after 9/11 they cancelled the project because of its proximity to city hall.

  • @allym6551
    @allym6551 7 лет назад +505

    Them: What abandoned, forgotten place should we go to next?
    Me: My hopes and dreams

    • @P1NKBLUSH
      @P1NKBLUSH 7 лет назад +5

      Bobthemonkeygut LOLOLOLOL you just made my day

    • @DarkusAltair
      @DarkusAltair 7 лет назад +1

      Jon Snow's knowledge

    • @rottiesdad
      @rottiesdad 7 лет назад +1

      Just...hilarious. thank you.

  • @danmcdonald726
    @danmcdonald726 5 лет назад +1570

    Congrats you did what sleeping homeless people do every day

    • @JMH702
      @JMH702 4 года назад +22

      Lol

    • @SG-xy6hf
      @SG-xy6hf 4 года назад +119

      Sleeping people don’t do anything, because they are asleep

    • @pvt.jamesramirez1219
      @pvt.jamesramirez1219 4 года назад +10

      S G You’re Right

    • @bm.3759
      @bm.3759 4 года назад +19

      S G sleeping is doing. its an activity.

    • @pvt.jamesramirez1219
      @pvt.jamesramirez1219 4 года назад +2

      Panda 730S No Shot Sherlock

  • @RockyLikes
    @RockyLikes 6 лет назад +371

    These guys would be bad criminals...
    "Hey Officer, what is the best time to rob that convenient store?"

    • @mcpinball1
      @mcpinball1 4 года назад +2

      Thats A Great Point Made !+)

    • @bonusyt6413
      @bonusyt6413 2 года назад +1

      “Turn around put your hand behind your ba-“

  • @rndmvds930
    @rndmvds930 7 лет назад +1817

    New series: *FORGOTTEN*

  • @50shadesofhina90
    @50shadesofhina90 7 лет назад +1392

    Buzzfeed blue is pretty much the only thing keeping buzzfeed alive ( unsolved mysteries, worth it and this).

    • @ameliachristmas712
      @ameliachristmas712 7 лет назад +25

      50shadesofHina
      The try guys

    • @50shadesofhina90
      @50shadesofhina90 7 лет назад +3

      Angie K its somehow kinda on buzzfeedvideo and buzzfeedblue lol

    • @meganlandry8567
      @meganlandry8567 7 лет назад

      true

    • @imanithepinkmonster
      @imanithepinkmonster 7 лет назад +10

      There is a food channel they run called Tasty the only thing cancerous is the comments. :)

    • @derpdawg3492
      @derpdawg3492 7 лет назад +1

      50shadesofHina buzzfeed is also a news outlet

  • @agentpiggles6685
    @agentpiggles6685 5 лет назад +1397

    You guys could have just gotten a ticket for the city hall tour 😂

    • @iwx2672
      @iwx2672 5 лет назад +28

      Thanks for that, I will!

    • @jonahweaver2182
      @jonahweaver2182 5 лет назад +161

      but that ticket is like $30. a subway ride is $2.75

    • @iwx2672
      @iwx2672 5 лет назад +9

      @@jonahweaver2182 Which subway is it? Coming over there soon

    • @JMH702
      @JMH702 4 года назад +10

      IW X 6 line

    • @kimberlysommers9245
      @kimberlysommers9245 4 года назад +5

      This is my favorite comment

  • @HereBeBarr
    @HereBeBarr 7 лет назад +4070

    Great video . I wouldn't say smuggled is the right word though.. This little trick is well known by many New Yorkers, I even made a vlog about this at the end of the winter. The conductor generally doesnt' care if you stay on the train.. Now if you had hopped off the train and walked around the abandoned station yourself, THAT would have been interesting.

    • @seungylim606
      @seungylim606 7 лет назад +77

      Here Be Barr the subway doors don't open at the stop in city hall

    • @HereBeBarr
      @HereBeBarr 7 лет назад +139

      Nope, but it does run right through.

    • @Oscar-ej8pe
      @Oscar-ej8pe 7 лет назад +6

      Here Be Barr i

    • @chriszhang2797
      @chriszhang2797 7 лет назад +70

      You could get into serious trouble if you got caught by MTA authority.

    • @HereBeBarr
      @HereBeBarr 7 лет назад +181

      I don't think the MTA cares if you sit on the train when it runs past City Hall Station.. but if you hang outside like that, I could see them getting pissed.

  • @SunnyBear
    @SunnyBear 6 лет назад +1647

    This video is SO Buzzfeed. A seven minute build-up to some shaky shots in low light, and we already saw how it looked at the start of the video. :P

    • @martinfamilybklyn803
      @martinfamilybklyn803 6 лет назад +1

      yeah

    • @johnargus9081
      @johnargus9081 6 лет назад +40

      Especially since they never actually got off. There are several videos on youtube with people actually walking around there - with permission.

    • @southwestxnorthwest
      @southwestxnorthwest 5 лет назад +8

      @Disney is the Devil Yet here you are, having stuck around to watch the video. That must make you super gay.

    • @Hessijames79
      @Hessijames79 4 года назад +3

      They probably googled it, read just stay in the 6, did it. And then they created the lengthy mediocre detective way to find it out again...

    • @darrentylor5473
      @darrentylor5473 4 года назад +1

      It's the awe and wonder that it still exists in all its beautiful glory...despite not being used or seen by the majority of the population for decades...

  • @Sarah-yh8nw
    @Sarah-yh8nw 7 лет назад +2464

    I love when big companies document their employees doing illegal things

    • @PSong-rg5yu
      @PSong-rg5yu 7 лет назад +29

      Sarah Adams please watch the entire video

    • @Sarah-yh8nw
      @Sarah-yh8nw 7 лет назад +43

      P. Song I did and I made a joke

    • @NoahDitlefsen
      @NoahDitlefsen 7 лет назад

      Sarah Adams same

    • @liz2880
      @liz2880 7 лет назад +59

      It's not even that big of a deal, a lot of people ride the train through that loop, only every now and then people are told to get off, which almost never happens since when the trains are taken out of service it's in the Bronx. The riding in between cars is dangerous and more of a problem, but not uncommon

    • @ada3360
      @ada3360 7 лет назад +2

      true.

  • @theripoffchicago
    @theripoffchicago 6 лет назад +835

    If you’re from NYC you know the 6 train loop already.
    Amateurs.

    • @beforeilay
      @beforeilay 5 лет назад +1

      theripoffchicago factsss

    • @thingything4004
      @thingything4004 5 лет назад

      theripoffchicago same

    • @agentpiggles6685
      @agentpiggles6685 5 лет назад +8

      theripoffchicago not to mention there is also a tour you can take of city hall for like 50 bucks

    • @basictransportenthusiast4386
      @basictransportenthusiast4386 5 лет назад +33

      The real forgotten stations are those like Worth Street, 18th Street, and 91st Street

    • @vintagenysubwaylover333
      @vintagenysubwaylover333 5 лет назад +1

      ruclips.net/video/e3H6E2wLT0I/видео.html

  • @jadajohnson4492
    @jadajohnson4492 7 лет назад +474

    More like "We briefly rode past New York's abandoned train station"

  • @mimiHTcat
    @mimiHTcat 7 лет назад +170

    I love that we're getting more video content from the new york office as opposed to just the LA one, NYC represent

  • @JacobCarlson
    @JacobCarlson 7 лет назад +1335

    I've done this a bunch of times. It's very cool. If anyone else decides to do this (perfectly allowed, btw), I'd recommend going during the day when there is sunlight streaming through the glass ceiling. Otherwise it will be very dark and hard to see.

    • @over00lordunknown12
      @over00lordunknown12 6 лет назад +58

      +Jacob Carlson Um... I guess in the sense of legality, yes, but they opened the door which says not to, and they have a rule that says you cannot be on the train past the last stop, so, no, this is not "perfectly allowed"... XD

    • @laney888
      @laney888 6 лет назад +5

      Oh well sounds fun

    • @Redbeard_1
      @Redbeard_1 6 лет назад +38

      So as the train is going around are they going slow enough to jump off to explore around I guess the only bad thing about it is you have no way of getting back out unless you wait for the train to leave and then follow the track or tunnel to the next open area... but I guess if you try that you might get arrested

    • @yeshuatjie1578
      @yeshuatjie1578 6 лет назад +27

      Jolly Goodbeard yeaa you can but like if you really wanna do it and you are willing to break some laws for it just do some research on Instagram and find an nyc urban explorer thats willing to take you there

    • @artmanrom
      @artmanrom 6 лет назад +5

      :) Only do not try to walk between train wagons whilst they are turning if you are appreciating your life. D

  • @stevehofmann9525
    @stevehofmann9525 5 лет назад +93

    Now that’s what I call a Nothing Sandwich. What’s next? Interview a tree in Central Park.

    • @no50svo
      @no50svo 5 лет назад +1

      Lmao!!!

    • @1953beetle
      @1953beetle 4 года назад +1

      The interview with the tree should be interesting.When's it being posted?Love to know.

  • @steph_lopez
    @steph_lopez 7 лет назад +363

    This City Hall Station was featured in 'Fantastic Beast's and Where to Find' Them. Its the last battle scene where they fight the Credence and arrest Grindleward. I pay attention to the backgrounds a lot.

    • @sarahfitzpatrick2461
      @sarahfitzpatrick2461 7 лет назад +9

      Stephanie Lopez I was just thinking that!!

    • @johannabern8006
      @johannabern8006 7 лет назад +1

      Stephanie Lopez THANK YOU, YOU KNEW IT TOO

    • @TheBabyturquoise
      @TheBabyturquoise 7 лет назад

      omg now i remember!!

    • @SL-kz5dk
      @SL-kz5dk 7 лет назад

      Stephanie Lopez I thought I was the only one thinking that

    • @SL-kz5dk
      @SL-kz5dk 7 лет назад +5

      Tamie Shakespeare they might’ve used the actual station cuz I know London Underground uses closed stations in films

  • @iriss9909
    @iriss9909 7 лет назад +1228

    Is it just me or does the city hall station look like the same place as the ending of Fantastic beasts and where to find them

  • @marlijn7783
    @marlijn7783 7 лет назад +2244

    it's quite sad that such a beautiful place in abandoned

    • @ChristinaWoodall
      @ChristinaWoodall 7 лет назад +94

      Terribly sad that it can't be used, I don't get the waste of places like this

    • @starhill6792
      @starhill6792 7 лет назад +112

      Marli x They should open it to the public as like a museum spot or something at least..

    • @TheCyberwoman
      @TheCyberwoman 7 лет назад +40

      Star Shine Put a heavy duty gate at the edge, (rod iron so it's not unsightly) so no one can get to the tracks, and you could even have events there, like weddings and charity galas. Can't you imagine a 20's themed party?

    • @lostcastro8857
      @lostcastro8857 7 лет назад +1

      Marli x is

    • @dean7144
      @dean7144 7 лет назад +1

      Marli x and what the new one turned Into

  • @EdGreenberg
    @EdGreenberg 6 лет назад +489

    Just join the Transit Museum and sign up for the tour. No brainer. Clickbait.

  • @Lynn925E
    @Lynn925E 7 лет назад +1910

    This needs to be a series
    Until they're arrested..

    • @AC-th4ci
      @AC-th4ci 7 лет назад

      Guinea Pig Adventure World all they have to say is "were from buzzfeed" and authorities will most likely let them go wherever they want

    • @malvavisco10
      @malvavisco10 7 лет назад +3

      They said "What abandoned or forgotten place should we go to next?" so it's obviously a series.

    • @chimera_chimera
      @chimera_chimera 7 лет назад +20

      Or dead

    • @kaylashaver249
      @kaylashaver249 7 лет назад

      Lynn Evans oooooh yess

    • @baetsimpson
      @baetsimpson 7 лет назад

      This is legal, though.

  • @FrazJ
    @FrazJ 7 лет назад +2147

    I was kinda hoping they'd hop off the train James Bond style and explore...Anyone else?

    • @kabhes9040
      @kabhes9040 7 лет назад +33

      are there no sort of side walks next to the tracks? you could walk there technicly.

    • @faithismine128
      @faithismine128 7 лет назад +110

      I actually expected it when he opened the door between cars and am slightly disappointed.

    • @Yung_Hefty
      @Yung_Hefty 7 лет назад +2

      FrazJ I wanna jump off

    • @AdaylnTheLifeOf
      @AdaylnTheLifeOf 7 лет назад +42

      That's illegal technically. But what they did is fine and people do it all the time.

    • @Bad_gyal_wadi
      @Bad_gyal_wadi 6 лет назад +4

      Well if you're in the tunnel No there's no side walks and it's illegal to do that.

  • @timetogotosleepzzz
    @timetogotosleepzzz 7 лет назад +1014

    I feel like more people are going to stay on the train to see the city hall stop.

    • @Allegra_Marzulli
      @Allegra_Marzulli 7 лет назад +3

      timetogotosleepzzz i will do it

    • @SL-vw7ix
      @SL-vw7ix 7 лет назад +44

      I actually wanna step foot and check out the station

    • @SL-vw7ix
      @SL-vw7ix 7 лет назад +8

      Chris Sasaki Yeah I guess the only way is to walk on track

    • @versatilefaerie
      @versatilefaerie 7 лет назад +18

      @Skender: There are ways to get there and look around but none of them are legal so it isn't worth it.

    • @gayagowrikaran
      @gayagowrikaran 7 лет назад +1

      timetogotosleepzzz uû

  • @phoenixman8569
    @phoenixman8569 5 лет назад +78

    this station was rediscovered back in 1989, by the ghostbusters then they were looking for the origin of ghost slime seeping up from under the streets...….

  • @trisumphrey
    @trisumphrey 7 лет назад +854

    new series! called "forgotten" PLEASEE BUZZBEED. they should do the abandoned Disney park

    • @Taoxlrgion1982
      @Taoxlrgion1982 7 лет назад

      There are a lot of people in the Disneyparks....

    • @cecil3585
      @cecil3585 7 лет назад +7

      Taoxlrgion1982 there is one abandoned disney park

    • @cinderellacomplex7
      @cinderellacomplex7 7 лет назад +4

      Disney would have the law on their asses as soon as they found out. Plus, just because it's abandoned, doesn't mean security isn't on the prowl there.

    • @mariastevenson6734
      @mariastevenson6734 7 лет назад

      There's already a RUclips channel that explores and talks about forgotten places.

    • @jackeeyy14
      @jackeeyy14 7 лет назад

      Maria Stevenson what channel is it?

  • @richardwasserman
    @richardwasserman 6 лет назад +180

    I did this by accident last month. The Transit Museum also offers tours.

  • @meganwilson8601
    @meganwilson8601 7 лет назад +162

    I was nervous about how this was going to go, but this was so respectful and courteous! I loved it!

    • @thefuumanchuu
      @thefuumanchuu 7 лет назад +21

      It's not even smuggling, this is just a thing you can do if you have the knowledge. I was expecting them to try to get off the train to walk around the old city hall 👎

  • @gdkid
    @gdkid 5 лет назад +104

    Casually asks cop: “Yeah, so I’m just lookin’ for the entrance to a closed subway station, can you just point me to it please”? Cop replies: “Sure it’s down by those trees over there”

  • @KingLionTearingBlast
    @KingLionTearingBlast 7 лет назад +1152

    I like buzzfeed unsolved this is also seems really cool and I hope they post more

    • @Alex632
      @Alex632 7 лет назад +13

      It seemed fake af "omg no your not making go there"

    • @CHIOTIS1821
      @CHIOTIS1821 7 лет назад +16

      Connor M Wall maybe if it was Shane and Ryan in this series

    • @kgal1298
      @kgal1298 7 лет назад +3

      Yeah not to mention they didn't do anything illegal knowing MTA would fine them because there are other urban explorers who've gotten in.

    • @bxdanny
      @bxdanny 7 лет назад +4

      Correct. Staying on the 6 train while it loops around through the old station is completely legal. They even changed the announcements at Brooklyn Bridge (on the newer R-142(a) trains that have automated announcements) to say something like "This is the last downtown stop on this train. The next stop is Brooklyn Bridge-City Hall on the uptown side." It is the only line where the announcements at the last stop don't say "Everyone please leave the train." They used to say that, but the MTA responded to pressure and changed them.

    • @oneblumaccaw244
      @oneblumaccaw244 7 лет назад

      Connor M Wall i

  • @simrankang5435
    @simrankang5435 7 лет назад +2929

    This should be series with these two guys where they try to get to old forgotten places called forgotten
    Edit: wow I've never gotten so many likes and replys on a comment before thanks guys

    • @roselina7823
      @roselina7823 7 лет назад +11

      Sim Sim YES

    • @lesliedavila7511
      @lesliedavila7511 7 лет назад +4

      Sim Sim that's genius

    • @autumn7809
      @autumn7809 7 лет назад +14

      They're gonna get arrested

    • @koreanchick1231
      @koreanchick1231 7 лет назад +19

      I mean, there are already tons of videos of urban explorers finding these forgotten places on youtube. You just have to search for them.

    • @Seriousbeek
      @Seriousbeek 7 лет назад +22

      Sim Sim yes new series! old ghost towns and possibly abandoned mansions. good idea

  • @emilymarie1962
    @emilymarie1962 7 лет назад +2864

    Who else thought Shane and Ryan would be in this

  • @Ronwixziv
    @Ronwixziv 2 года назад +26

    My father worked for the MTA for over 20 years - There IS a way in. Every station has "escape tunnels" that lead to the street. You would need to find one of those. People pass them unknowingly every day. Find the "emergency escape exit", and you will have access to the station.

  • @m.leslie6281
    @m.leslie6281 7 лет назад +168

    I love how they played the dramatic music like they just discovered the lost city of Atlantis. lol.

  • @aeiressstancil6403
    @aeiressstancil6403 7 лет назад +89

    I think this should be a series and should be called " Lost and Found"

  • @fpsSwiftG31
    @fpsSwiftG31 7 лет назад +209

    This could actually be a very good series... like Buzzfeed Unsolved type good.

  • @RRansomSmith
    @RRansomSmith 6 лет назад +99

    SPOILER
    It's not illegal to ride the (6) around the loop to see City Hall Station. I've done it a million times with MTA personnel on board. It's fine.
    And for the record, the CONDUCTOR does not drive the train.
    That's the OPERATOR, or MOTORMAN.
    The CONDUCTOR controls the doors and makes station announcements from the center of the train.

    • @hollisb.flemingii8197
      @hollisb.flemingii8197 5 лет назад +2

      Rick Traveler Smith as a former conductor, we never recommend it, and you can get in trouble, because one superintendent and 5.0 can make it happen..., many people by accident wind up staying on the train, but at times they had us to clean out the trains...

  • @WinterRoseYT
    @WinterRoseYT 7 лет назад +1364

    Hey! A new Buzzfeed series we can all love! Buzzfeed Unzolved, Worth It, The Try Guys, and now this! :D It needs a name though.....
    How about, "Buzzfeed Unseen" or "Not Quite Illegal"?

    • @kohchenkit266
      @kohchenkit266 7 лет назад +81

      Or forgotten

    • @vrynnie
      @vrynnie 7 лет назад +38

      unseen is cool because it ties in with unsolved. haha.

    • @GuiSmith
      @GuiSmith 7 лет назад +15

      Trogdor Tibbles Forgotten is better, Unseen implies that nobody alive has seen some of these things even though many have, and often there will be many photos online.

    • @oranplan1630
      @oranplan1630 7 лет назад +26

      I like Not Quite Illegal

    • @sydneyfreund5486
      @sydneyfreund5486 7 лет назад +15

      Trogdor Tibbles it should be called forgotten

  • @lunalex446
    @lunalex446 7 лет назад +155

    Who else thought they were going to jump off the train?

    • @jamiecrovello8367
      @jamiecrovello8367 7 лет назад +1

      Luna Lex me

    • @liz-6967
      @liz-6967 7 лет назад +5

      *thinks of divergent*

    • @cinderellacomplex7
      @cinderellacomplex7 7 лет назад +3

      As tempting as it would be, they know getting back would be difficult. They're not gonna wait for the next train and try to jump on. That's a death wish, plus they'd get found out and be in trouble.

  • @superaurae
    @superaurae 7 лет назад +104

    I love this!!! I find abandoned places suuuper interesting, please make more of this!!

  • @jcfra420
    @jcfra420 5 лет назад +56

    Just a heads up, they don't smuggle into anything. The whole ending is them riding a subway past it lol. Click bait.

  • @rustyshackleford4076
    @rustyshackleford4076 7 лет назад +539

    If you want to visit City Hall Station you can schedule a tour via the MTA Transit Museum membership.

    • @rustyshackleford4076
      @rustyshackleford4076 7 лет назад +42

      Oh Buy the MTA museum membership, its like $35 for students, then when you have the membership you buy a separate City Hall Station tour ticket which is $50 and only goes on sale 3 times per year, there might still be some tickets for a date between Sept-Dec on sale now. Expensive but if you really want to see it in person there you go

    • @Jessica_Creates
      @Jessica_Creates 7 лет назад

      Thank you

    • @slimyqualityvideos1233
      @slimyqualityvideos1233 7 лет назад

      Oh i

    • @Gr95dc
      @Gr95dc 7 лет назад +7

      Really 😍😍😍 awesome expensive but awesome

    • @bronxosei3719
      @bronxosei3719 7 лет назад

      Claire Knight I

  • @hobbesfield1082
    @hobbesfield1082 7 лет назад +878

    This could really become an awesome series!

    • @TaylorShantell
      @TaylorShantell 7 лет назад +3

      Hobbesfield same thing I was thinking!

    • @celinejahan5471
      @celinejahan5471 7 лет назад +1

      Hobbesfield yeah this was actually a very cool idea!

    • @backtomimsey
      @backtomimsey 7 лет назад +43

      Hobbesfield It's already a thing within the RUclips community. It's called urban exploration. A lot of these abandoned places are on private property. Some of my favorite channels are The Proper People. This is Dan Bell. and Exploring with Josh.

    • @hobbesfield1082
      @hobbesfield1082 7 лет назад +3

      +rooney and peter miss appa thanks dude, gonna check them out!

    • @TheZombifiedFairy
      @TheZombifiedFairy 7 лет назад +3

      Also, there are some YTbers that go into the really private places (Ie Disney abandoned places) and take videos for 30-45 minutes. Its uber good and kinda hard to find for newbies (like me).

  • @teagannutella9324
    @teagannutella9324 7 лет назад +242

    A new series called "forgotten" would be awesome!

  • @goldgamercommenting2990
    @goldgamercommenting2990 2 года назад +21

    There are events in the New York Transit Museum that allows people to visit the abandoned station

  • @timdella92
    @timdella92 7 лет назад +82

    I actually teared up when they finally saw the station. And the misic doesn't help either.

    • @username-wx3sc
      @username-wx3sc 7 лет назад +4

      RIGHT! I read a comment like yours before watching and thought wow, its not that deep. I was sobbing by the time the video was over

  • @beccaelmel
    @beccaelmel 7 лет назад +918

    Who else is going on a RUclips marathon while riding out a hurricane?
    P.S. - All of y'all in the same boat, stay safe!
    Edit: Omg thank you for all the love!!! Over 900 likes?!? And again, fellow Texans, stay safe!!!!

    • @adrianamireles4924
      @adrianamireles4924 7 лет назад +17

      Before i die I'm watching all buzzfeed videos

    • @katrinakatana8030
      @katrinakatana8030 7 лет назад +9

      Fandom Obsessed
      Wow, stay safe!

    • @REctershi
      @REctershi 7 лет назад +11

      Fandom Obsessed God bless stay safe!

    • @cgkeith9838
      @cgkeith9838 7 лет назад +41

      i’m in new york the only hurricane here is my family

    • @morganrae9172
      @morganrae9172 7 лет назад +3

      Fandom Obsessed stay safe frens!

  • @thenpguy5852
    @thenpguy5852 7 лет назад +22

    I respect buzz feed workers, this is one the best video I've ever watched on this channel. Please continue it, it's a top series worth being as high as buzzfeed unsolved and worth it

  • @dianecohen8876
    @dianecohen8876 Год назад +8

    back in the seventies and eighties if you rode the trains at like 1am the trains would usually be rerouted. you would travel through all these abandoned stations with the arches and beautiful tile work. amazing stuff.

  • @jbozon
    @jbozon 7 лет назад +866

    To everyone who's about to comment something related to buzzfeed unsolved, please remember that Shane and Ryan aren't the only people in Buzzfeed. Also, this is an entirely different concept from buzzfeed unsolved. People work hard to make these videos, let's take time to actually appreciate these videos for what they are, and not for what they're not.

    • @bottombagfrenchfry7127
      @bottombagfrenchfry7127 7 лет назад +15

      Agree 100%
      I like the historical hidden gem aspect of this video. I hope there's more to come.

    • @prakatitadas4232
      @prakatitadas4232 7 лет назад +4

      Agreed!
      I mean just give a chance to new comers. They too have ideas to show us.

    • @sylvibee1674
      @sylvibee1674 7 лет назад +2

      EXACTLY

    • @inezj3156
      @inezj3156 7 лет назад +19

      I agree but I live for "wheeze"

    • @jiminepark274
      @jiminepark274 7 лет назад +6

      Janssen Bozon did buzzfeed hire you ?

  • @VanillaCupcakes13
    @VanillaCupcakes13 7 лет назад +169

    If you're willing to pay for a membership to the New York City Transit Museum + $50 each person, you can get a tour. They do them 16 times a year. These are the dates for the rest of the year!
    September 28 6pm-8pm
    October 8 at 6pm-8pm
    October 21 at 11am-1 pm and 2pm-4pm
    November 12 at 2pm-4pm
    November 18 at 11am-1 pm and 2pm-4pm
    December 2 at 11am-1 pm and 2pm-4pm
    December 17 at 2pm-4pm

    • @minchui
      @minchui 7 лет назад +4

      VanillaCupcakes13 You Are The Real MVP!!! Thanks for the info

  • @JamesGoldblood
    @JamesGoldblood 7 лет назад +378

    You guys realize the New York Transit Museum offers tours of the City Hall station right? All you had to do was pay $50 bucks to walk in it. You can't film though lol

    • @fi2867
      @fi2867 7 лет назад +10

      lmao

    • @extrident7950
      @extrident7950 7 лет назад +38

      James Gold I accidently saw the city hall subway station when I went through the loop. I looked it up and you have to be a member of the museum.

    • @Eternal56
      @Eternal56 7 лет назад +3

      true story.

    • @basillah7650
      @basillah7650 7 лет назад +38

      $50 and you cannot even film that means he could not put it on youtube which is why he is doing it

    • @CommanderSiriusStar
      @CommanderSiriusStar 7 лет назад +7

      That's what hidden/button cams were made for...

  • @amujan
    @amujan 3 года назад +1

    I don’t get, why they don’t offer guided tours down there? Here in Berlin we have „Berlin Underworld“, where an association has the rights from the city/transportation authority to visit old abandoned bunkers/subwaystations and with the money, they keep them from falling into disrepair.

  • @usahenry
    @usahenry 7 лет назад +1655

    Waiting for buzzfeed unsolved xdddd

  • @SweetandSpicyLuv
    @SweetandSpicyLuv 7 лет назад +271

    BuzzFeed NY is starting to surpass BuzzFeed LA

  • @mollycampbell
    @mollycampbell 7 лет назад +1113

    Isn't that the train station that fantastic beasts and where to find them was filmed

    • @notAshildr
      @notAshildr 7 лет назад +105

      It's not where it was filmed but I guess it's where the scene was set. Not sure about that either though...

    • @elliegracie
      @elliegracie 7 лет назад +65

      I WAS LOOKING FOR THIS COMMENT I SAW IT AND I WAS LIKE OMG

    • @maxeyn1832
      @maxeyn1832 7 лет назад +24

      i thought the exact same thing

    • @charl2139
      @charl2139 7 лет назад +42

      Molly Campbell fantastic beasts was filmed in Liverpool in the U.K. But it was set in New York

    • @Mae-fp5br
      @Mae-fp5br 7 лет назад +5

      1 min through and I thought the same lmao

  • @langstonreese7077
    @langstonreese7077 24 дня назад +1

    “This is a City Hall bound (6) Local train. The next and last stop is *City Hall* “

  • @maryrosebouton9121
    @maryrosebouton9121 7 лет назад +877

    Is it weird that I got a little emotional when they finally got to see City Hall? idk lol

    • @chs75
      @chs75 7 лет назад +13

      No, not weird at all.

    • @duaawail3757
      @duaawail3757 7 лет назад +11

      i got emotional tooooo

    • @Taoxlrgion1982
      @Taoxlrgion1982 7 лет назад +3

      Yes tou're a cry baby

    • @vexel5851
      @vexel5851 7 лет назад +7

      Mary Bouton nah it's normal 😂

    • @Mooncrest0
      @Mooncrest0 7 лет назад +4

      Taoxlrgion1982 crying is not a bad thing tho?

  • @lorloretta_
    @lorloretta_ 7 лет назад +839

    BUZZFEED FORGOTTEN

  • @IceCreamCookie
    @IceCreamCookie 7 лет назад +251

    When I saw the thumbnail I was like ‘Fantastic Beasts and Where To Find Them’

    • @pemo2676
      @pemo2676 7 лет назад +7

      I was thinking what if they actually filmed there
      It's possible

    • @supered227
      @supered227 6 лет назад

      This station was the inspiration for it

    • @jacobscanlan
      @jacobscanlan 6 лет назад

      Yesss

  • @irv999
    @irv999 6 лет назад +17

    Guys if you want to see the city hall station and not act like children, join the Transit museum. they do tours a few times a year free! and legal

  • @natalie8212
    @natalie8212 7 лет назад +97

    VERY cool ! I know it was brief, but it was really glorious to see all the beautiful tile work , arches and skylights. I just can't believe there wasn't ONE REFERENCE to Ninja Turtles!

  • @L013-r9y
    @L013-r9y 7 лет назад +2131

    More of these dudes PLEASE!

  • @Screamingtut
    @Screamingtut 7 лет назад +107

    go under the station that goes to the Waldorf Astoria from Grand Central. FDR used it during his Presidency. there is his Train that is still parked.

    • @labellavita992
      @labellavita992 7 лет назад +1

      Kristyanna Virgona they already did in another video (not these guys, but other buzzfeed employees)

    • @lauragm2513
      @lauragm2513 7 лет назад +2

      labellavita992 what video?

    • @labellavita992
      @labellavita992 7 лет назад

      Lora Moka ruclips.net/video/bOt0KkMv9tg/видео.html

  • @jaredcx
    @jaredcx 3 года назад +1

    "we smuggled ourselves" is a funny way of saying we trespassed lol

  • @ElleCullen17
    @ElleCullen17 7 лет назад +53

    PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE MAKE THIS A SERIES!!!!!

  • @ddaipata
    @ddaipata 7 лет назад +36

    This should be another series just like Buzzfeed Unsolved!!!

  • @bellawhitmore8609
    @bellawhitmore8609 7 лет назад +84

    PLEASE MAKE THIS A SERIES

  • @nellennatea
    @nellennatea 3 года назад +1

    AWESOME You did it. CITY HALL. & I loved the music as the train went through and passed City Hall. Beautiful empty station.

  • @SS-rw2pc
    @SS-rw2pc 7 лет назад +2871

    Omg this is great! Explore more places in new york

  • @dumbanddumber5023
    @dumbanddumber5023 6 лет назад +359

    8 minutes and 10 seconds has just been stolen from me.

    • @muttfreeworld
      @muttfreeworld 5 лет назад +10

      I rather spent 8 min reading the comments than watching this b.s video

    • @andya5068
      @andya5068 5 лет назад +3

      Buzz feed wack bro

    • @aghia5709
      @aghia5709 3 месяца назад

      Imagine mine

  • @nkosiannisette3057
    @nkosiannisette3057 7 лет назад +357

    did anybody find it weird that there was a man recording another man recording?

    • @novaquartz5049
      @novaquartz5049 7 лет назад +38

      JustNormalStuff catfish does it all the time. It's weird there too...

    • @MetalDragon42
      @MetalDragon42 7 лет назад +1

      I hate these side on camera stuff that every one seems to be doing just hate it

    • @moonis5632
      @moonis5632 7 лет назад

      its not other man its a camera on a table

    • @MK-ex4pb
      @MK-ex4pb 7 лет назад

      JustNormalStuff yes

  • @kristiananoel
    @kristiananoel 5 лет назад +17

    You did break a law though, you can get tickets for going between trains.

  • @emily4323
    @emily4323 7 лет назад +767

    Where's buzzfeed unsolved tho

  • @visenya9
    @visenya9 7 лет назад +126

    I usually just watch unsolved and worth it but Buzzfeed could actually make a series out of this that I'd enjoy as well. Yes, there are other youtube channels that do these types of videos but it wouldn't hurt to have another and to have actual journalists research and discover these places for our entertainment. It's interesting, to say the least. I really enjoyed this video. Good job, guys.

    • @matthewrobar7360
      @matthewrobar7360 7 лет назад +2

      I agree that this is good but I wouldn't go as far as to call these people journalists.

    • @rileyanne9547
      @rileyanne9547 7 лет назад

      Wood Elf but they are journalists. That's their job. Buzzfeed may produce fluff pieces but journalists write them.

    • @matthewrobar7360
      @matthewrobar7360 7 лет назад

      That's wrong Buzzfeed hires Writers for their "News" on their website but they also employ content creators for their youtube channels who don't report the news. The people in this video are not journalists there are cameramen and a host, no journalists.

    • @SuperDrLisa
      @SuperDrLisa 7 лет назад

      Lol journalists

  • @soybeanwind223
    @soybeanwind223 7 лет назад +691

    Since you guys are NYC based, you guys should go to the abandoned Seaview Asylum in Staten Island :^). Staten Island is gross and it totally sucks but it's well worth the trip, this is the asylum that season 2 of AHS was based off of!

    • @MichaelNaness
      @MichaelNaness 7 лет назад +8

      Soybean Wind did you just say a whole burrow is gross....

    • @maddieshalaby3482
      @maddieshalaby3482 7 лет назад +3

      Soybean Wind yes they did and I completely agree being that I live there but seaview, amongst our other various abandoned places, are a gift

    • @ottilie8890
      @ottilie8890 7 лет назад +5

      I love that place!

    • @giobelinelli9751
      @giobelinelli9751 7 лет назад +2

      i just was in yesterday lol

    • @gamekobra
      @gamekobra 7 лет назад +1

      Staten Island isn't gross you dolt

  • @michaelderenne9838
    @michaelderenne9838 2 года назад +2

    What a waste. They could make money with that train station if they opened it to the public for tours. I'd pay

  • @stevenm.r9023
    @stevenm.r9023 6 лет назад +182

    To me it’s funny because not a lot of people get to step foot on that old abandon city hall train station stop. But since I work in the MTA I got to walk on that old abandon station and it’s really nice the colorful tile, and the way it was built.

    • @VincentIrkallaOfficial
      @VincentIrkallaOfficial 5 лет назад +13

      Would you be able to take some photos one day and post them online?

    • @RRansomSmith
      @RRansomSmith 5 лет назад +3

      @@VincentIrkallaOfficial they're already online.
      Try here
      Nycsubway.org

    • @vaskokosteski2094
      @vaskokosteski2094 Год назад

      Please do it Steven.

  • @caitlynjones2147
    @caitlynjones2147 7 лет назад +16

    YES YES YES FOR THE LOVE OF GOD BUZZFEED MORE OF THIS

  • @sarahmforever
    @sarahmforever 7 лет назад +74

    While this was very interesting and that platform is absolutely gorgeous; I would love to see them do something with the abandoned train platforms in London. They are pretty famous.

  • @freddieorange1673
    @freddieorange1673 2 года назад +11

    When I worked for Transit Authority summer program, they took on tour which included the City Hall train stop. We were able to stay on train as the 6 train was getting ready to go back uptown. Like you mentioned there is large gap between train and old platform. It looked really nice

  • @shop236
    @shop236 7 лет назад +262

    Umm the station isn't forgotten. You can request a tour from the New York Transit Museum.

    • @wgatevans3017
      @wgatevans3017 7 лет назад +22

      Your name is fucked up
      Y-ay
      A-n
      A-frican
      S-traving
      S-ex
      S-lave

    • @moonbeam112
      @moonbeam112 7 лет назад +4

      wassup scam squad

    • @bottombagfrenchfry7127
      @bottombagfrenchfry7127 7 лет назад +39

      Up until recently you can go on the tour but it was abandoned for many years. Also the tours are only like 3 times a year.

  • @diyasworld7047
    @diyasworld7047 7 лет назад +71

    Go to the Central Terminal in Buffalo, New York. I heard there's amazing history there and maybe even some ghosts!

  • @musicom67
    @musicom67 6 лет назад +715

    Dude - everyone knows (in the area) the 6 train loops around the old City Hall station to go uptown. And they have tours. Now, never mind that dopey station. The 18th Street abandoned station further uptown on the Lex is the real deal. More surprised the train doors weren't locked... BuzzFeed Blew.

    • @telisto
      @telisto 6 лет назад +6

      18th street station looks horrible. why would that be better?

    • @girlmastergeneral
      @girlmastergeneral 6 лет назад +13

      Those doors between cars are NEVER locked. They are emergency exits.

    • @Onetwothreepeanuts
      @Onetwothreepeanuts 6 лет назад +34

      Grew up in NYC writing graffiti in the mid 80s. They're ghost stations everywhere.

    • @bradleycooper5112
      @bradleycooper5112 6 лет назад +1

      @@Onetwothreepeanuts thug you should be punched in ur tiny peanuts

    • @Onetwothreepeanuts
      @Onetwothreepeanuts 6 лет назад +6

      @@bradleycooper5112hahahaha. Hold on Mr. ADAMS. O.G. Lol

  • @romeotango58
    @romeotango58 5 лет назад +6

    The person operating the train is called a Motorman or Train Operator, the conductor is the that opens and closes the doors.

  • @AttractionSpot
    @AttractionSpot 7 лет назад +459

    Lol this is funny why don't you guys just do one of the transit museum tours they do for this station and you can actually go walk this station legally? They supposedly do about 16 tours a year and tickets are $50 bucks but act quickly as tickets sell out fast. I have seen photos down there but no video is allowed I guess hut all you have to do is pretend your taking photos and record video.

    • @marinadela1361
      @marinadela1361 7 лет назад +5

      *you're

    • @AlbatrossXYZ
      @AlbatrossXYZ 6 лет назад +8

      This feels cooler lol

    • @amightysailingman
      @amightysailingman 6 лет назад +22

      It's $50 for the tour, but you have to be a Transit Museum member to sign up. That's another $60, for a total of $110 per person. I don't want it that badly.

    • @ethanrasiel3350
      @ethanrasiel3350 6 лет назад +9

      Video is very much allowed. No tripods though. www.nytransitmuseum.org/oldcityhall/

    • @aaronnadler8002
      @aaronnadler8002 6 лет назад +7

      Thank You!!!! I was watching this fake news saying all along "they give tours" the whole time...

  • @LogamusPrime
    @LogamusPrime 6 лет назад +1006

    This right here is what you call CLICKBAIT

    • @grigzie
      @grigzie 6 лет назад +7

      Just needed to Google the station and read the Wikipedia article.

    • @kbhasi
      @kbhasi 6 лет назад +17

      Yeah, this is like the highest high for clickbait.

    • @hamzaqureshi307
      @hamzaqureshi307 6 лет назад +10

      Clickbait 101

    • @thepurematrix
      @thepurematrix 6 лет назад +2

      Logamus Prime littrally the definition

    • @siyaciaraamandaperez
      @siyaciaraamandaperez 6 лет назад +2

      Pure Matrix black police was nice other white guy say u can’t go there something like that but they went thou 8-18-18

  • @mrernestoetaernestostransi8015
    @mrernestoetaernestostransi8015 2 года назад +2

    In The City Hall Station (R)(W) On the lower level there is an abandoned platform it’s kind of a yard

  • @wretch6719
    @wretch6719 7 лет назад +40

    Make a series called:ABANDONED

    • @AM-em5gc
      @AM-em5gc 7 лет назад +1

      There’s already a better series called abandoned. RUclips it, it’s very good.

    • @artistwithouttalent
      @artistwithouttalent 7 лет назад +1

      Alex McNeice I think it was a joke. Also, "WHAT'S UP GUYS?" :)

    • @AM-em5gc
      @AM-em5gc 7 лет назад +2

      Welcome to aBANdoned!

    • @mitchellcline5738
      @mitchellcline5738 7 лет назад

      "This is Jaaaaake"

  • @NYCHeckler
    @NYCHeckler 6 лет назад +285

    7 minutes of buildup just to watch these 2 stay on the 6 train loop?? Which is perfectly allowed btw. This was so lame. There are so many other videos of people actually sneaking in. 2 guys celebrating because they sat on the 6 train... awesome. Whats next? You gonna stay on the 6 train to see the abandoned Worth St subway stop and slow-mo it??

    • @slinq
      @slinq 6 лет назад +26

      yeah but they have beards and a over abundant self absorption

    • @karlepaul6632
      @karlepaul6632 6 лет назад +3

      NYCHeckler I just have you Thumbs Up #100! 😉👍🏻
      ALSO...I'm with ya 100% on your comment, I truly am. Don't hold back on ANYTHING ya find lame, because without quips from people like you, things wouldn't get changed up at all, and lousy crap after crap would continue to get churned out.

    • @vinnil1984
      @vinnil1984 6 лет назад

      right lol

    • @j9of10
      @j9of10 6 лет назад

      Clickbait bs

    • @outlawjesus
      @outlawjesus 6 лет назад

      but the super grainy / out of focus footage was soooo worth it.

  • @cecille5833
    @cecille5833 7 лет назад +10

    i somehow expected them to jump off and start exploring the place

  • @tornadochasing2883
    @tornadochasing2883 5 лет назад +4

    "We'd gone to the station without breaking any law"
    LITERALLY A SIGN SAYING:
    *Riding or moving between cars is prohibited*

  • @eboymnl
    @eboymnl 7 лет назад +24

    THIS MADE ME WANT TO CRY OMG SO HAPPY YOU GUYS DID THIS

  • @hardleecure
    @hardleecure 6 лет назад +327

    C'mon guys that was totally lame. The Proper People would've found a way in and not chickened out and rode a train through it. :/ smh

    • @lorenzo42p
      @lorenzo42p 6 лет назад +2

      the buzzfeed video about this station that I watched before this one.. really sucked. they had a guided tour into the station, but didn't show much more than what can already be seen in pictures. an elevator and a door to the train car.

    • @chrismhp
      @chrismhp 5 лет назад +8

      For one the Proper People did avoid going to this abandoned station. They explained this in one of their vlogs in NYC where they also rode the 6 train loop to see it. People need to wisen up. When it comes to subway stations, you are asking to get yourself killed unless you take an official tour or find an explorer who know the schedules and tracks in and out. Even then, there are always delays and hiccups in the schedule, express trains etc. so your safety is still not even guaranteed even if you know what you're doing. Steve Duncan is one of those experienced explorers, and his video they were not far from getting flattened.

    • @vexpho4512
      @vexpho4512 5 лет назад

      There is a video of people sneaking into the station and they recorded it on foot, not on a train if u wanna see it

    • @Rebecca-td5pt
      @Rebecca-td5pt 3 года назад

      @@vexpho4512 where is this?

  • @cheyennehogue6365
    @cheyennehogue6365 7 лет назад +5

    MY NEW BUZZFEED OBSESSION! I could see this being as is as the unsolved series!

  • @ladyjane9980
    @ladyjane9980 3 года назад +4

    Better to beg for forgiveness than to ask for permission. Make more of these. This was great.

  • @中村-r4m
    @中村-r4m 7 лет назад +14

    This is actually really interesting there should be more