LOTR The Fellowship Of The Ring - The Breaking Of The Fellowship pt1

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 дек 2024

Комментарии • 219

  • @IronDragon-2143
    @IronDragon-2143 2 года назад +313

    I love how even when Gandalf is gone, Frodo still looks to him for guidance. It really says about how much he loved him.

    • @SilhouetteSE
      @SilhouetteSE 2 года назад +27

      And Sam keeps the promise that he gave him, too

    • @galenirby3553
      @galenirby3553 2 года назад +20

      And shows you how Gandalf is basically what kept the fellowship to never stray from the path not just frollo and the hobbits but everyone who was with him and you clearly tell when they think he’s dead he was that big of an influence on them

    • @samuelbaldwin1407
      @samuelbaldwin1407 Год назад +13

      Gandalf became even more wise than Saruman, for he chose love instead of power.

    • @Cloofinder
      @Cloofinder Год назад +7

      It really shows how Frodo didn't want Gandalf's death to be in vane.

    • @Cloofinder
      @Cloofinder Год назад +3

      @@samuelbaldwin1407 and fellowship over being a loner lol

  • @eizneckam4936
    @eizneckam4936 Год назад +126

    "I'm going alone!"
    "Course you are, and I'm going with you!"
    I love that line. It could have been so cheesy, but the delivery makes it so sincere and heartwarming.

    • @12classics39
      @12classics39 Год назад +6

      And it indicates what becomes more and more true as the story unfolds: Frodo and Sam are really two halves of one whole, they’re no longer separate beings.

    • @alpharius2omegaboogaloo384
      @alpharius2omegaboogaloo384 Год назад +4

      @@12classics39In such peril, the love of brothers can surpass any fear or doom. (Brothers in more than biological terms)

    • @coolgamingchanallal7612
      @coolgamingchanallal7612 10 месяцев назад

      Love this scene true friend Sam is love it

    • @raterus
      @raterus 10 месяцев назад +1

      I tell my wife, whom I love, that if she ever leaves me, I'm coming with her.

  • @FiendMatadorSlayerOfNoobs
    @FiendMatadorSlayerOfNoobs 2 года назад +309

    The fact that Sam can't swim and is actually wary and fidgety around water yet went into it without hesitation or fear KNOWING that far greater perils than drowning would await him on this journey is testament to his unshakable loyalty to his friend.
    Samwise the Brave truly earned his name ten times over.

    • @willrobinson9767
      @willrobinson9767 2 года назад +8

      He had faith in Frodo that wouldn't let his friend drown.....

    • @InvertedWIng
      @InvertedWIng 2 года назад +5

      As well as to the lengths he would go to uphold his oath. Eru rewards those who keep to their word.

    • @tomlinkxxx
      @tomlinkxxx 11 месяцев назад

      As far as I remember, in the book, Sam's biggest fear in the world was to swim. That means that in this particular moment in the story that Sam's had surpassed it and was willing to die following the path Gandalf (Ilubatar's angel) had set for him.
      It is because of this act that he's immediately saved in the story and Frodo's hand appears coming from the sun, which kind of makes you wonder for a second, since Sam was not struggling anymore, if the hand represents Ilubatar's hand coming to get him into heaven.
      Sam had proven himself and at this point, of all the fellowship members, he's the only one who had evolved beyond, matured his strenghts overcoming his former self entirely.

  • @rheeelijah
    @rheeelijah 2 года назад +125

    "All you have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to you." Dang man that line hits hard :')

  • @IfUBuildItHeWillCome
    @IfUBuildItHeWillCome 11 лет назад +110

    "So do all who live to see such times, but that is not for them to decide, all you have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to you"

  • @Sbock86
    @Sbock86 2 года назад +236

    No music between 0:14 - 0:54 really makes this scene special. The silence except for the little bit of wind. It's so contemplative. And Frodo really doesn't have to say anything for us to capture everything we need in the moment.

    • @Beverly_Dingus
      @Beverly_Dingus 2 года назад +26

      I think this is the moment when he felt the true weight of the task ahead of him. The silence, to me, reflects the emptiness he feels having realized that it's too dangerous to keep the ring with the fellowship, and that he is now alone. It also highlights Sam calling out to him, since Sam is the only one who cuts through that emptiness and keeps Frodo going.

    • @joshdawson5850
      @joshdawson5850 2 года назад +4

      ‘Show, don’t tell’

  • @rayandnoah8769
    @rayandnoah8769 2 года назад +130

    Probably the most inspiring heartfelt moment of any movie I have ever seen

  • @imranesmail23
    @imranesmail23 12 лет назад +141

    how music can capture emotions so perfectly is a mystery to me. without the music here the acting isn't enough to convince me of the greatness in this scene. what an amazing movie! what an amazing soundtrack !

  • @bensonbrett30
    @bensonbrett30 2 года назад +270

    Elijah Wood was great in this film. Sean Astin was phenomenal. How did he not win an Oscar for best supporting actor?
    Together, one of the best scenes ever in movie history.

    • @edoardo7311
      @edoardo7311 2 года назад +8

      I guess fantasy and sci-fi had never been very popular in Hollywood...

    • @THEDOORIZCLOSED
      @THEDOORIZCLOSED 2 года назад +11

      Elijah Wood was the perfect Frodo. Big, round, innocent eyes and a sweet face. You just wanted him to STOP suffering. The whole cast was perfect. Love Sean Bean as Boromir. I dont how they knew everything would turn out perfectly

    • @shizzl0rable
      @shizzl0rable Год назад +8

      @@THEDOORIZCLOSED I think the beauty here is they didn’t 😁 how did it out so perfectly ? I mean who the fuck knows but one thing is certain: there is Love in this, love from the people who wrote the script, love from the director trying to get the best picture, love from the actors portraying these characters, love from the musicians expressing these pieces with such …. Humility… idk it’s just special

    • @THEDOORIZCLOSED
      @THEDOORIZCLOSED Год назад

      @@shizzl0rable awwwww. Made me tear up. So true🥹

    • @davidhansman7190
      @davidhansman7190 Год назад

      Yeah that's really cool, thanks for pointing that out

  • @12classics39
    @12classics39 Год назад +23

    Elijah Wood tells Frodo’s whole story with just his face. He doesn’t need to speak a word for the audience to know exactly what he’s feeling. Not many actors can pull that off so flawlessly. And his scream of “SAM!” at 2:08 is heartbreakingly genuine; nothing hammy or forced about it at all. He was robbed of every award in the business for his acting here. It’s because he makes us love Frodo that the trilogy works at all; the whole thing would’ve failed if we didn’t believe in and care for the protagonist.

  • @NordicSoldier
    @NordicSoldier 2 года назад +62

    This scene right here...
    It helped me through a really tough time in my life when I was feeling the hard effects of ptsd. Gandalfs words of wisdom and Frodo's determination really made me think deeply about what I want to achieve in life and what to do with each day. To live fully and never regret any of it.

    • @morcjul
      @morcjul Год назад +4

      All the best to you man, glad you shared your ptsd. I'm currently in the process of diagnosis as I'm suffering from cptsd symptoms

  • @Draxyn1
    @Draxyn1 11 лет назад +91

    Sam, the best friend every person hopes for.

    • @chasebennion
      @chasebennion 2 года назад +8

      I have my sam, and he's the best. 🙂

    • @THEDOORIZCLOSED
      @THEDOORIZCLOSED 2 года назад +1

      @@chasebennion lucky! Hang on to him!

    • @chasebennion
      @chasebennion 2 года назад +4

      @@THEDOORIZCLOSED I will. When we used to get in fights, it was miserable. Not being with my "Sam" was... it wasn't fun.

    • @bagrCZ
      @bagrCZ Год назад

      I hope to be Sam to my friends

    • @12classics39
      @12classics39 Год назад

      Total boyfriend material too. I envy Rosie.

  • @darthblob10
    @darthblob10 2 года назад +26

    This scene makes me cry. Sam is such a good friend. And the music is so beautiful.

    • @angelofwar9223
      @angelofwar9223 Год назад

      Agreed

    • @EricGraham94
      @EricGraham94 Год назад

      Sam is almost like a batman from WWI, where he sees to it that his soldier/pilot is doing okay, their health and equipment are in good order, etc

  • @kris11ocean
    @kris11ocean Год назад +8

    0:50 Can't watch this scene and not drop some tears. The combination of Frodo's expression, the words of Gandalf and the music of H. Shore. You can encourage anybody's heart in any situation of life. These movie adaptations from the books are masterpieces which will transcend time. Thank you Peter Jackson.

  • @Mel-xk9go
    @Mel-xk9go 2 года назад +49

    This Movie/Trilogy/ Saga is the best of all time and will always be.
    I’m exited to have children so that I could show them this Masterpiece.

    • @19azul89
      @19azul89 2 года назад +1

      Lets make the babies mami💓😘

    • @TheBfutgreg
      @TheBfutgreg 11 месяцев назад

      @@19azul89 wtf

  • @martymckay297
    @martymckay297 2 года назад +36

    This scene gives me strength to continue

    • @IANRogel09
      @IANRogel09 2 года назад +9

      Me too, It also helped me so that I can pass my anatomy exam in extraordinary in 6 days, because I did not pass the ordinary.

    • @IANRogel09
      @IANRogel09 2 года назад +10

      @@salvadorarjona3031 Yes, I passed with 8

    • @salvadorarjona3031
      @salvadorarjona3031 Год назад

      Congrats!!!​@@IANRogel09

  • @eliv8468
    @eliv8468 Год назад +22

    These movies and books need to be preserved with other timeless pieces like the Odyssey and such.
    They represent everything good about life.

  • @kolol2011
    @kolol2011 2 года назад +48

    In the beginning of the pair's journey, Frodo rescues Sam from the depth of Anduin River (water), and in the end of it, Sam lifts Frodo up at the Crack of Doom (magma). The parallelism is beautiful.

    • @zoomerjack5435
      @zoomerjack5435 Год назад

      That doesn’t happen in the book though

    • @productwholeslave2122
      @productwholeslave2122 Год назад +6

      Also ^in the movies^
      Frodo says to Samwise at the end of the scene right after this one, he says, "I'm glad you're here with me",
      And in the scene at mount doom in TROTK, he says to him, "I'm glad I'm here with you, Samwise Gamgee."

    • @EricGraham94
      @EricGraham94 Год назад +1

      Through fire and water…

  • @lex5519
    @lex5519 Год назад +9

    When the Lord of the Rings movies were released, I was 13 to 15 years old. I used to find Frodo and Sam's scenes boring, but as I grew older, I began to appreciate their emotions and friendship, and moved by Frodo's determination and enlightenment along the way.

  • @mjdrummerfreak
    @mjdrummerfreak 12 лет назад +29

    For me, not just the best scene of the movie but the best part of the score of the movie.

  • @BambooPenguin
    @BambooPenguin 11 лет назад +43

    Still the best movie scene of all time. Nothing will ever compare to this.

    • @bensonbrett30
      @bensonbrett30 2 года назад +7

      I think the Da Vinci Code Ending with the music is close. But I get what you mean 😊

    • @themadas
      @themadas 2 года назад +7

      There's plenty scenes in Two towers and ROTK as good as this though

    • @ogbee9690
      @ogbee9690 2 года назад +4

      i agree with you. the best ending to any movie ever along with rotk. lotr is AMAZING

    • @morcjul
      @morcjul Год назад +1

      @@bensonbrett30 great shout! Da Vinci code has probably the most powerful revelation, this Frodo scene is much more subtle so both inspire in different ways

  • @JesseJongbloets
    @JesseJongbloets 11 лет назад +15

    "Oh Sam" and the music kicks in. And then i'm like: "How am i ever gonna get these tears out of my keyboard.."

  • @camilachorro1663
    @camilachorro1663 12 лет назад +50

    This scene is incredibly amazing, the books abd the movies are what I would call a masterpiece! LOTR will always be my favourite movies

  • @bbslabaugh
    @bbslabaugh Год назад +2

    This is a Masterpiece. The combination of Emotion and Action is unlike anything Hollywood could make today -- sadly.

  • @davidallinson8248
    @davidallinson8248 Год назад +47

    This is and will always be the most poignant scene in cinematic history. Only time I have ever seen a standing ovation in a cinema.

  • @B501M
    @B501M 3 года назад +23

    this part always makes me cry

  • @DominickRuocco
    @DominickRuocco 2 года назад +10

    Everyone in life deserves a friend as good as Sam.

  • @TheBlueDragon86
    @TheBlueDragon86 10 месяцев назад +2

    This scene coupled with Boromir’s final interaction with Aragorn are some of the most beautiful moments in cinema history.

    • @throwoutable
      @throwoutable 2 месяца назад

      The whole last 15-20 minutes are just awesome

  • @imankyun
    @imankyun 12 лет назад +13

    Every time i see this it touches my heart and encourages me and gives me the confidence that i go through the hard times.

  • @stephensperr1379
    @stephensperr1379 2 года назад +10

    Nothing can ever top this movie series. The English-speaking world is divided into two groups: those who have seen LOTR and those who have yet to see it.

    • @CaseyLaarkamp
      @CaseyLaarkamp Год назад +1

      LOL, this would be true of every movie in existence.

  • @danielannett1019
    @danielannett1019 2 года назад +15

    2:49 this is what true freindship looks like

  • @AETHL
    @AETHL Год назад +6

    Undoubtedly the best scene in the whole trilogy for me.

  • @kassi420
    @kassi420 2 года назад +16

    Still one of the greatest endings of all times. When I first watched this scene I cried… I read the books I knew Gandalf survived but the scene genuinely made me feel like I lost some who was close to me

  • @Otulissa22
    @Otulissa22 12 лет назад +18

    I dunno man, but the whole ending of FOTR was really awesome.

  • @janeyrevanescence12
    @janeyrevanescence12 2 года назад +7

    “Of course you are, and I’m coming with you!” Who else would follow their friend into Hell?

  • @commenting_otter
    @commenting_otter 6 месяцев назад +1

    Sam obviously kept the promise for Frodo, but remember, he also gave this promise to Gandalf, whom the Fellowship had lost. I believe Sam was also keeping the promise for Gandalf to honor his memory.

  • @JonMichael1087
    @JonMichael1087 Год назад +3

    I don't think I knew this at the time when I saw it, but I think this scene did a lot to normalize male friends hugging each other when they really need support. That's not something I think we were really taught growing up. Amazing and beautiful how they modeled it here, wrote it in, and the actors delivered it such a powerful and meaningful way that we could all relate. I'm sure it influenced me and my friends growing up in more ways than I knew. God I love this movie.

  • @xcarnage3936
    @xcarnage3936 2 года назад +6

    Just finished the first book and searched this scene. I'm in tears 😭

  • @fyllingenoy131
    @fyllingenoy131 2 года назад +12

    Interestingly this was actually one of the last scenes of the entire trilogy to be filmed.

  • @Adralen8
    @Adralen8 12 лет назад +11

    Such a powerful scene

  • @jesusofsuburbia01
    @jesusofsuburbia01 12 лет назад +5

    "All you have to decide, is what to do with the time that is given to you"

  • @andystarkiller7492
    @andystarkiller7492 Год назад +3

    Am I the only one crying when I hear the music not to mention watching the scene ??

  • @lydiamcgowan2125
    @lydiamcgowan2125 Год назад +1

    Poor Frodo weeping at he stares beyond the lake with the ring in the palm of his hand.

  • @dark4krad
    @dark4krad 11 лет назад +4

    *Wiping tears for the zillionth time*

  • @Sauc333
    @Sauc333 2 года назад +28

    I just lost my friend yesterday and this scene is hitting me hard right now

  • @megan4519
    @megan4519 2 года назад +1

    Oh how much I love them both.

  • @karvind
    @karvind 2 года назад +10

    This movie was a journey. Everyone went aboard.. moments only fans can understand

  • @lucypeterson2231
    @lucypeterson2231 3 года назад +3

    I literally just started the video and I've already got chills

  • @deansmalley2582
    @deansmalley2582 2 года назад +3

    This part of the movie makes me cry 😭

  • @e-rock6328
    @e-rock6328 Год назад

    Since the 1st time I witnessed this scene...I have never ever been able to hold back tears. Everytime. All these years later and it still hits me.

  • @Fraytus
    @Fraytus 12 лет назад +20

    I think the thing that makes this scene better in the movie is the music and scenery which you can't have in a book, ofcourse

    • @southpole4776
      @southpole4776 2 года назад +5

      Yep, reading lord of the rings will be enriching, but will never be as good as these movies. I mean, you have to be both Peter Jackson and Howard shore at the same time to match up to this movie while reading

    • @brooksboy78
      @brooksboy78 Год назад

      @@southpole4776 Except the books are infinitely better, more detailed, and more thematically-powerful than the movies. You people are ridiculous.

    • @southpole4776
      @southpole4776 Год назад

      @@brooksboy78 books are a relic of the past. It has no place in the 21st century. Advances in technology have enabled a much more effective way to tell a story and it's called visual media. With AI on the horizon for enhancing content generation capabilities, books are all but dead, unless someone wants to cling on to the past

    • @willcapewell5700
      @willcapewell5700 Год назад

      ​@@southpole4776 Bait use to be believeable 🥱

    • @Goblonium
      @Goblonium 5 месяцев назад

      @@southpole4776 Absolute garbage take.

  • @Katzenkaiser4
    @Katzenkaiser4 2 года назад +4

    this is peak filmmaking

  • @danieldovhun5035
    @danieldovhun5035 2 года назад +6

    Imagine how it would all end if Sam didn’t have the wits to figure out that Frodo wants to leave alone

  • @gregorbegger9291
    @gregorbegger9291 10 месяцев назад +1

    Galadriel tells Frodo to do this task alone, but Sam kept a promise. "A promise!" Don't you lose him Samwise Gamgee

  • @galenirby3553
    @galenirby3553 2 года назад

    This movie does the act not say perfectly you can just feel what is being said just from each little emotion they show and the true power of friendship can do literally giving up all selfishness knowing that someone who isn’t you is in a dire situation and show them true compassion and the help they need it’s just smooth natural and damn phenomenal

  • @rossadams8934
    @rossadams8934 11 месяцев назад

    This movie demonstrates what bravery truly is.
    Fortitude in the face of fear.

  • @AverageArtz
    @AverageArtz Год назад +2

    Everything about this is perfect. This hits me so deeply, even after 20(!) years.

  • @fredterdk6788
    @fredterdk6788 12 лет назад +1

    I can watch this clip a million times, Thanks for uploading ;)

  • @alboKid001
    @alboKid001 12 лет назад +4

    no fucking other movie/movie series ever be as awesome as the lord of the rings nothing compares to it.

  • @fhf148
    @fhf148 Год назад +2

    0:39 Married people when they see their single friends out having fun

    • @Lr-tv3mh
      @Lr-tv3mh 11 месяцев назад

      That is the truth haha. Ring that rules all others 😅

  • @drewreid9112
    @drewreid9112 2 года назад +1

    All of them are better than any other movie series. But this, this film, is the greatest movie of all time

  • @ethan1142028
    @ethan1142028 12 лет назад

    Couldn't have said it better myself. Many tears will be shed.

  • @mrmetalfan365
    @mrmetalfan365 10 лет назад +6

    This scene kinda of makes me cry.

  • @Adralen8
    @Adralen8 12 лет назад +1

    Thank you so much for uploading this amazing bromance scene :)

  • @lucamerighi
    @lucamerighi 11 месяцев назад

    2:35 never noticed how Sam grasped his hand back in Frodo's arm. Similar how later Sam extended his hand to save Frodo from falling into the river of lava

  • @JC-tg1gf
    @JC-tg1gf 10 месяцев назад +1

    Does Frodo hear Gandalf's monologue in his head in the books too?

  • @Peak_Aussieman
    @Peak_Aussieman Год назад +1

    I just noticed the symbology between this and when they're in Mt Doom. Huh, weird, after all these years there's still a lot that can be gleamed from this trilogy. It can't be topped. Not now, not ever.

  • @TJSaw
    @TJSaw 11 месяцев назад

    Greatest bromance in cinematic history.

  • @DrRichtofen94
    @DrRichtofen94 11 лет назад +1

    Every. Single. Time.
    At the end of each movie I do, too. lol

  • @sadeaton
    @sadeaton 3 года назад +2

    This feels like New Years Eve 2020.

  • @mugflub
    @mugflub Год назад

    Best trilogy ever

  • @Crest28
    @Crest28 Год назад +1

    Sean's foot got stabbed by a piece of glass when filming this scene. Amazing scene

  • @johnrockyryan
    @johnrockyryan Год назад

    "I made a promise mr Frodo a promise "dont you leave him Samwise Gamgee" and i dont mean to... i dont mean to"
    "Oh Sam"
    *They both embrace*
    Never fails to make me cry like a newborn baby 😂

  • @SparklyTwinklyShiny
    @SparklyTwinklyShiny 12 лет назад

    holy god, same here, i couldn't believe my ears - CAN THIS BE IT?!?!? AND IT WAS!!!!

  • @themadas
    @themadas Год назад

    Everyone was crying from the Boromir death, to the Frodo choice, and Sam's actions and then three hunters gave us some hope

  • @schawdaya
    @schawdaya Год назад

    Honest to god, i never knew my grandparents growing up, and they're all unfortunately passed away now, but Tolkien speaking through Gandalf is the closest thing ive had to that kind of relationship. I would sacrifice a limb just for a conversation with Tolkien

  • @DoTheHustle27
    @DoTheHustle27 12 лет назад

    Thank you so much for uploading this!

  • @thebatman7347
    @thebatman7347 Год назад

    Man my gf never seen me cry, damn you shire and samwise gamgee.
    Ive began to read lotr just finished fellowship so for the 1st time watched it, i watched the extended edition, the ending made me tear u0... ill be a mess by return of the king wont i?

  • @janeyrevanescence12
    @janeyrevanescence12 11 месяцев назад

    “I made a promise, Mr. Frodo. A promise. ‘Don’t you leave him, Samwise Gamgee.’ And I don’t mean to. I don’t mean to.”
    I thought of my late fiancé and his struggles with schizophrenia with that line. It got really bad at times and I sometimes wondered if I should leave him. But then I’d remember Sam’s words and know my fiancé would’ve stuck with me if the situation had been reversed.

  • @CaptainDarkFighter
    @CaptainDarkFighter 28 дней назад +1

    Sam is a true friend

  • @CoolJunk10001
    @CoolJunk10001 11 лет назад +1

    My favorite scene

  • @yallahhabbib
    @yallahhabbib 11 лет назад +2

    the music makes this

  • @davidallinson8248
    @davidallinson8248 Год назад

    Best scene ever mam

  • @gabemd1237
    @gabemd1237 12 лет назад

    I'd really like this classical music piece in my iTunes...

  • @joeman6738
    @joeman6738 11 лет назад +2

    Aaand Im drunk and crying

  • @jonathans.219
    @jonathans.219 2 года назад +2

    Everyone says the lotr is nerdy and all, but no. It’s inspiring means something.

    • @thechosenone93
      @thechosenone93 Год назад +1

      People who say things are “nerdy” usually have nothing going for them,ie they work,go home,watch TV,criticise others,repeat. But you’re a person who likes anime or goes to the gym regularly then you’re weird or a nerd. Tell them to shut up

    • @protoman1365
      @protoman1365 Год назад

      Lord of the Rings is definitely nerdy. Because as a nerd myself, I very much claim this franchise as our own.
      Things can still be high quality and nerdy. Provided you keep that quality up, there is nothing wrong with being a nerd/nerdy.

    • @TheBfutgreg
      @TheBfutgreg Год назад

      ​@@thechosenone93 "But you’re a person who likes anime or goes to the gym regularly then you’re weird or a nerd."
      I doubt anyone would judge you for going to the gym regularly....seeing as you referenced anime (which I personally enjoy...sparsely I admit but anyway)
      Self-improvement even if superficially in the physical realm is great, but if people want to shit on that then fuck them
      Just have a "balanced" approach I guess? Just don't think by doing that you're going to become the next Shonen protag and get your dream girl and on and on and whatever

    • @thechosenone93
      @thechosenone93 Год назад

      @@TheBfutgreg In terms of the gym,if you start looking too good or people notice that you can eat twice what they do and stay in better shape than them,you may encounter shaming comments. I get shamed all the time because I’m quite confident but ugly but I know the shame comes from insecure people. Because I don’t shame anyone
      I’m never saying don’t engage in the activities you want to. I’m just giving a perspective that I have encountered.

  • @Arcexey
    @Arcexey Год назад +1

    it just hit me. they grab each other's arms. first sam then frodo.

  • @ironsentinel5847
    @ironsentinel5847 2 года назад +10

    George rr martin criticizes these type of fantasies as unrealistic (as in not enough sex,gore and deaths in lotr) however more emotion was dragged out of me kicking and screaming as you want in this scene than all of George's content combined.

    • @as52343
      @as52343 2 года назад +1

      Yeah you shouldnt really compare Game of Thrones and Lord of the rings in my opinion. They are very different types of fantasy where lord of the rings is more of a classic epic fantasy tale, while Game of Thrones tries to go for a more low fantasy with a more realistic approach. Cant compare them at all, so i dont really know why George RR Martin critize this. Jealousy and bitterness maybe?

  • @D2attemp
    @D2attemp 2 года назад +1

    Did Egalmouth of Gondolin get deleted?

  • @jaymutsuddi
    @jaymutsuddi 11 лет назад

    ''I made a pwomise Mr Frodo....A Pwomise.''

  • @JetBlack688
    @JetBlack688 12 лет назад

    Best movie ever

  • @ssiizzuurp1600
    @ssiizzuurp1600 2 года назад

    The more I read the books (just finished the 1st one) the more I fall in love with Sam's character. I'm not ready for that part when Frodo leaves him and sticks with Gollum 😭

    • @brandoncastro5025
      @brandoncastro5025 2 года назад +1

      Never happens in the book. I know it sounds like an absence of drama but once you take in the story that way it's always gonna seem a little forced and weird that Frodo ditches him in the movie

    • @ssiizzuurp1600
      @ssiizzuurp1600 2 года назад

      @@brandoncastro5025 Yes! I've read all the books already, glad it didn't happen :)

  • @ethan1142028
    @ethan1142028 12 лет назад +4

    have you read the book? I wouldn't think it possible but this scene is about 100x more powerful in the book.

    • @dussan2
      @dussan2 2 года назад +9

      I disagree, something about the music and scene transition. The look in Elijah Woods eyes as he decides to go it alone. I was a little choked up

    • @thekeyandthegate4093
      @thekeyandthegate4093 2 года назад +2

      The way the book describes Sam's desperation to stop Frodo here is awesome, with him falling and cutting his leg, but continuing to run and leaping out at the boat. It also is such a great moment for Sam because he knows it's Frodo in the boat even though the ring is still on him in the book, so he is invisible.
      The book made me cry in the scene where Sam reconciles to go with Frodo in spite of it just being the two of them. It's an excellent and bittersweet ending to the beginning of an epic tale.

  • @BigMackWitSauce
    @BigMackWitSauce Месяц назад

    The only thing that bothers me is that when it cuts Sams clothes are dry again lol, only his hair is still wet

  • @jk-vo3hn
    @jk-vo3hn 9 месяцев назад +1

    😭😭😭

  • @TheAlexMassaad
    @TheAlexMassaad 11 лет назад +2

    A masterpiece in film

  • @wistfulgraph
    @wistfulgraph Год назад

    2:42 Sam foot jumpscare

  • @alexm3855
    @alexm3855 11 лет назад +1

    0:41-1:05, I cry like a little kid

  • @SparklyTwinklyShiny
    @SparklyTwinklyShiny 12 лет назад +3

    finally found this scene in decent quality!!!

  • @sony1805
    @sony1805 12 лет назад

    nice
    epic music