THE BIG COMPARISON 2 | GTA IV vs. GTA V vs. Red Dead Redemption 2 | PC | ULTRA
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 ноя 2019
- I made this second part for the BIG GTA IV vs. GTA V vs. Red Dead Redemption 2 PC comparison to show more differences! Which game is the best?
Buy Red Dead Redemption 2 with the link below to support PlayGround! :)
www.greenmangaming.com/games/...
Thank you!
If you like my video, please SHARE it with your friends!
I hope you enjoy the content I made!
Welcome to the PlayGround!
Go to chrono.gg/PlayGround - for TODAY's deal!
Many thanks for everyone who support PlayGround through this!
Thank you so much for watching!
► Subscribe for more high quality videos! :) ruclips.net/user/PlayGroundFH...
/////////////////////////////////////////////
My PC:
CPU: i7 8700K 4.7 GHz
RAM: 32 GB DDR4 3200 MHz
VGA: RTX 2070 8 GB
/////////////////////////////////////////////
Music:
Production Music courtesy of Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsound.com
New York 2006 - Aldous Young
Beast Coast - Amber Spill
Boooom - Aldous Young
Facebook - / finalhopegameplays
Twitter - / fh_gameplays
Support PlayGround on Patreon!
/ playground
Donation:
www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr...
#PlayGroundComparisons 
Игры
If you fall from such height, water becomes hard like concrete.
Hard*
Water becomes had, oh ok
Kristi Teneqexhi I hate people like you
@@flameslaw7127 i hate myself as well but i just had to do it
@@flameslaw7127 dudes got
gotta
gotta rick sanchez profile
Meanwhile, in cyberpunk if you shoot a man in a wheelchair, he will run away on his legs.
@@brijeshkumarshukla7962 yea
😂😂😂lol
Lmao this really cracked me up🤣🤣🤣
You help the wheelchair dude
Napoli Edition POPPOROOOPOPPOROOO ITALYYY
Title should be " Legend vs Legend vs Legend "
3:00 Niko is waterproof
Amine Moha that’s not realistic at all, a fall from that high would kill you even if you fall in the water,force of gravity will break your bones
@@bigboi9711 rockstar forgot to add that one
@@bigboi9711 if you make a t pose you'll survive
The Doom Slayer true this applies to real life T Pose if ur gonna get shot
@@bigboi9711 dude I know , it's just a game and we're just joking
2:58 haha that song never get old
3:43 best physics...
It is cool, but it is actually not realistic... If you had a gun you would know that if you shoot a round in the water it just blows a lot of water up, just like in gta IV, in rdr2 the amount of water was minimum
Um Crysis 3 did this better back in 2013.
Wouldn’t depend on the gun ? I mean if u think about it a silent gun wouldn’t make a splash
@@xxphhhxx6921 that doesn't make sense, at first any gun is silent, it would be suppressed, and what you reduce with a suppressor is the sound but the energy if the bullet still being the same.
@@xxphhhxx6921 and in the game you are shooting a shotgun, so I can tell you for sure that a shotgun splash a lot more water, and a .45 too.
7:19 The reason the ship sank went off the map, and in gta5, it's like this, it's sinking in the water.
Hi Nugget
co ty tu
only in bad faith in this comparison
bro there is a thing called map boundaries and if you tried to go across it with a boat the boat will simply sink
You can actually break that wheels in RDR2 if you shoot between the center and the exterior of the wheel
I like how RDR2 has the same things as gta 4 and gta 5, this is why I play and love RDR2
DeadSkull 1643 agreed man
@Roman Bellic keep dreaming kid...there will never be a gta 4 sequel
RD2 are bether of the Cyberpunk 2077
These 3 games are a masterpiece, Thanks rockstar for making our lifes great.
Nope, they're all trash
@@wallacesousuke1433 well tell me a game better than them
@@minidice3274 almost every minimally decent game out there ;) I'd rather play Tetris or patience than those boring walking sims
@@wallacesousuke1433 i asked u to tell me an open world game not ( tetris)
@@minidice3274 ah, I usually don't like open world games but HZD and Dragon's Dogma shit all over Rockstard games :)
I don't understand why they didn't recycled the details from GTA 4 to GTA 5 and then added new ones
Cars of paper in gta 4
@Roosevelt Panzer that's a stupid reason which I doubt is true
@@Xighor a reason that is largely accepted to be true is that they got rid of the car physics because many people were complaining that the cars handled like boats or like if they were on ice in GTA 4. and apparently that's why GTA 5 driving seems a lot more easy.
Because gta 5 is arcade
I heard that since it would originally release on 360, the physics needed to be toned down so the game wouldn't lag or crash, as gta 4 was already pushing the system limits as a 2008 game on 360.
GTA IV needs to be remastered it just lacked in terms of graphics but everything else was just damn great . I loved how the Euphoria Physics engine worked and the overall attention to detail that had been put into the NPC's were just damn good.
IV physics may be fun, but they are not very realistic
@@ramp7857 yeah man idk how throwing a cup at someone making them back away 2 meters while turning into a ballon with weightless sentient legs is very realistic
@@ramp7857 they are at least for a 14 year old game
Who gives a shit about graphics? You resolution nerds really need to go outside.
Gta 4 is best in grapics physics and all above gta games
_0:40__ For those wondering how Niko was able to survive such a fall it's because Rockstar made it that way so we could more easily escape from the police. Although in GTA V he can also be survived by throwing himself like this; If you look closely, when Michael falls, the water is very shallow and hits the bottom very hard, so he dies immediately. But I was once with Franklin fleeing from the police in a helicopter, I jumped into the sea and survived, I guess for two reasons: the bottom was very deep and also had a bit high statistics._
But we can't swim in gta 4
@@cdog7358 you can swim in gta iv but you cant dive
@@Sryloth oh must be one of the older ones
Yah
In real life you crashed into the water
finally someone understood we can't see all the games when the videos play at the same time
4:46 the mam just reading a paper in a rain
Saints Denise's really don't care go check out valatine and small town there will be more details
I am %100 sure this guy used weather changer mods in game. These mods breaks game and the people stays at what they are doing with sunny weather.
@@ujoufzn5795 when that boat glitched out in the Beginning you could tell he spawned it with mods, and yea I've never seen npcs in rdr2 acting as wierd as in that clip.
It's a mod, smart man!!
3:48 i love that part
Me too :D
Me too :)))))
RDR2 Win
@@agpromc8176 *Gta4 wins
@@noose04 hey i saw you before in another comments
You are a hardcore toxic gta 4 fankid
Niko its roman lets go bowling
Assil Cheniti why?
Assil Cheniti On like. Every video related to GTA IV
@@kamgrant i love gta iv
@@assilcheniti7979 Same. Its my favourite
You look like niko in real life
4:45 Lol man reading news paper outside while raining🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂 so detailed
3:09
Cops:🗿🗿🗿
6:25 i expected riding a seahorse
4:28
To be fair i dont have an umbrella with me all day either.
4:49 and it’s clear that most people go below the little house when it’s raining
this comparison makes no sense
That does not excuse that Gta4 has more features and is better detailed.
@@noose04 you never play red dead 2 or...?
@@mocha6583 Shut up, i wasn't talking to you.
@@noose04 but I'm talking to you, your comment is useless just like your life with your free "shut up" you do not argue, and I can assure you that red dead redemption 2 has 1000x more details than gta4
4:41 and the horse just vibing lol
GTA IV was ahead of its time
GTA V was ahead of its time
RDR2 was ahead of its time
@Randominator no not in all aspects. GTA 5 is way more fun and feels more "alive" in a certain way. way vaster car customization ability, 3 protagonists, better map (at least for me. i always preferred LS over LC), numerous and diverse vehicles, honorable mention: better MODS and modding community, and last but not least better online (i know it sucks for the most part because of "pro blowing you up" but the amount of fun you can have with friends is great, not to mention you can make private/solo lobbies) that's how i see it. each gta got its piece of cake
@Randominator GTA IV is too overrated
@@beneictus1419 Yeah, it is not as good as people make it seem
Rdr2 is still ahead😹
3:21 It doesn't hurt to try
What, did he think the non existent tire would pop?
@@TheSunIsMyDestroyer That the wood would break?
@@SillyGoose778 Understandable, have a nice day.
@@TheSunIsMyDestroyer lol
@@SillyGoose778 it breaks if you use a shotgun, I believe
Part 3 is here:
ruclips.net/video/URcrsEAXjs4/видео.html
:D
hey I would like you to give me a little heart and say hello to me in a video and I want to say something that everyone likes
Jesus Christ died for our sins
BRUH LOL
Where is it located
@Tomas de Lange no
gta 4 is made by einstein...coz this game have more physics or logics 😂
*Lol I think you spelled Trevor wrong*
@@deem0n__ checkout my lifeinveder page
hy mike u want some drink together?
Na fam red dead two
Realistic games turn out to be more boring, that's why they didn't implement it in GTA V
3:25 im beyond that😂😂
gta iv was ahead of its time. Especially the damage physics on cars and environments. Put on the simple ragdoll mod from a trainer and hours of fun will ensue.
RDR2 WAS AHEAD OF ITS TIME
@@JustaUser24876 no it isn't really,rdr2 is a modern game.
GTA 4 was made in 2008,it isn't really surprising for long time rockstar fans,but you seem to be new here.
@@WorlWyrm I'm not saying I like tlou2 but I truly believe technically and detail wise red dead and that are ahead of their time just because how detailed everything is
@@shaneypoo2022 nobody asked about tlou2 here?
Also, I said that rdr2 is a modern game, it never really was ahead of it's time, just look at the matrix demo for example.
@@WorlWyrm I know nobody brought up the last of us 2 dumb fuck thanks for saying the obvious I was just saying they're the most detailed games of all time and there are no other games that are nearly as detailed as those ones and I said that quite clearly
GTA IV physics with RDR2 Graphics = Perfect Game
The rdr2 physics are already better than gta 4
Karol Redfearn And RDR’s gun play and some rag doll features.
Next one is: GTA6 vs RDR3 vs another good rockstar game
Sadly we have to wait years for that comparison and i mean A LOT OF YEARS
vs GTA4 to see how cartooness they are compared to it
@@IAmEndlous yeah :(
I think your ship at 7:24 sank not because it was out of steam, but because you got to close to the world border (I crossed the entire ocean from Blackwater to Saint-Denis yesterday and didn't have the problem until I went too close to the other side of the river)
No i was riding the steam boat sadly it sank 😔
Rockstar don't want us to reach mexico ;)
Damage I guess
But other boat were even farer from that steam boat
In 3:25 if you shot the wheels 3 or 4 times it will break the wheel in a very realistic way
🤓
Seeing how detailed and awesome red dead redemption 2 is gets me hyped to see how detailed and great gta6 wiil be
Gotta wait another 29 years
4 years
I just realized you copy this comment from the top comment
1:49 Mikel hit a dab
I first 10 likes
Oh yeah i saw him dabbing lol XDXD
Michael*
It was mistace
@@Anvar-sv9fn Michael
3:24 Ik... just embarrassing for a rdr2 fan that Rockstar didn't implement deflating wagon wheels, smh
You seem to not get the point of it as well,he tried to break the wooden wheel,not deflate it.
@@WorlWyrm Are you... tryin' to test me, is that it?
@@couchmaster3773 no just pointing out what the purpose of that clip is,many people literally misunderstood it
@@WorlWyrm How do you figuratively misunderstand something?
@@couchmaster3773 idk,using sarcasm to indicate that you misunderstood?
Who love Gta 4🤩
Hit Like👍
NOOB ! GTA 4 remastered on PS4 would be nice👌
5 it’s way way way way way way way way way better
Is better Red Dead Redemption 2 you keep saying that??!!
Gta 4 is the best video game in pc
Yes
I love GTA IV
3:20 my face is actually like that because you don't get that there were no tires that were made out of rubber thingies filled with air back then.
My face is like that because you didn't get the point of it,he tried to break the wooden wheel,not deflate it.
@@WorlWyrm it's made out of steel of iron lol
@@bananaboy1013 steel of iron?
I lost brain cells
@@bananaboy1013 oh wait,now that I rewatched the clip,I can confirm that the wheel is wood,you can see wood crumbling down after he shoots it.
@@WorlWyrm oh ok
4:48 remembered me of donkey transformed into horse of shrek 2 xd
This really made me think of how impressive GTA IV is even for today's standards
True. If we compare gta iv to v, one of the only things v is better than iv is the graphics.
Yeah but GTA 4 physics don't make sense like hitting a wall while going 10km/h in a vehicle sends you flying which isn't very realistic but other than that it's a pretty awesome game even GTA v doesn't compare to GTA 4 in terms of many details
@@potatogod6540 it's good game
@@heresyterminator Ty
Very bad graphics
3:27 yeah im facepalming at how you think that a wooden wheel would be flat after shooting it
That is the entire point..
THANK YOU FOR MAKING THIS VIDEO!
And the winner is
ROCKSTAR GAMES!!!!!
EA stl
Man somehow I knew rockstar games was going to win
@@jimphaldiahanwashcanzarqui1039 yep
rockstar!!!11!!1!!!11
@Danny 2008 r/woosh
I can remember clearly that Gta5 npc's had umbrellas during rain. Not everyone, but some of them. At least on Ps3 in 2013 they had umbrellas.
Overall imo:
1. RDR2
2. GTA 4
3. GTA 5
2 and 3 are close overall
GTA 5 sucks in physics and logic things, It just got lots of votes because it is newer
PH Zanoni Gamer it has a ton of things to do tho, that's a great point
@@PHZanoni The guy was talking about the game as a whole not just physics. The fact that you were this quick to trash GTA V shows how nostalgia biased a lot of GTA IV fans are.
1 is best. it uses a modern engine for physics
@Johnny B to me both games have their pros and cons. While IV may have had a better story I wouldn't say it was a better game overall, just a better story.
Niko belic is indestructible
It's because he slav, therefore the Russia logic apply
He don't crush on water
Water crush on him
@@orctrihar 😂👍
Amazing Dude Great More Pls
In 1899 umbrellas did not exist.
Actually it did. It was invented around the 1850s
@@seanmccormack3735 I thought that didn't exist yet. Well, I was wrong.
Arthur Morgan ye 😂😂😂😂
Aren’t you dead?? 😂😂😂
@@seanmccormack3735 I'm in heaven and I asked God for a computer to see how people react when I post a comment. XD
@@seanmccormack3735 I'm with John Marston, too.
Play Ground:Lets go bowling
Red Dead Redemption 1 should've been in this comparison if we're comparing 2 gta games with 1 rdr game, feels like there's an empty hole there.
Just saying.
However RDR2 still stands.
"PC"
5:24 wait a minute, what she was doing? 😐😂
hi
Bro it's obvious
the fact that you can drive a hot air balloon in rdr2 just beats everything else lol
Seeing now how pretty damn good gta 4 was is unreal...
I mean look at those physics!
GTA 5 sucks in that point totally
That doesn't make GTA 5 a bad game. Don't forget GTA 5 does have features that 4 didn't have. The fact that 4 is "realistic" doesn't make 5 a bad game. Just a heads up.
WHAT ABOUT RDR2?? either yk rdr 2 is better than gta 4 or you just don’t wanna say anything about it
GTA V has better water physics tho,you will totaly die when you dropped into the sea from 1 kilometers high.
GTA 5 is way better i played both. the story for 4 is better than 5 ill give you that but everything else no way. Especially the cars and also online.
@@deflategate1297 i agree so much
I played both two and as you said the depth of story in 4 is just awesome and it's physics is more realistic but gta 5 is better in a lot of things like gameplay and customization
i wanna kiss the hands of every single person that worked on these games
A bit gay but ok
@@wayworld8527 😂😂😂
Mahmoodreza Maboodi lol
Mahmoodreza Maboodi should've said no homo
Henry pm lol 😂
Awesome video
I feel the video is biased.... For instance John Marston instead of Arthur Morgan is being shown for swimming and boating.
This guy don't know this
SPY!! He’s an idiot
SPY!! Or maybe he does know but he’s just a GTA fanboy
Or maybe he’s just that far in RDR2 that he didn’t want to restart a game for this video.
@@privateerbouncher9622 Dude, he was literally using mods to be there.
John has never been to Guarma.
holaaa excelente video desearía que prosigan haciendo este metarial... Voy a seguir mirando sus creaciones. Les envio un beso chau ❤️👍🏽
Also irl if you shoot something with a cannonball there’s not going to be some sort of explosion like a rocket. It’s just a giant projectile being thrown at a very high speed. It’s practically a giant steel ball just being thrown at a wagon. I’d imagine it shouldn’t even catch fire really. But Rockstar added that in just for it to be more fun. Also I’ve shot parts of wagon wheels off but to be fair I’m not sure if it was before or after I had already blown it up, but either way it’s not a tire so I’m not sure what else you’d expect
There are explosive cannon balls at that time
Nice
Man keep it up👍👍👍
Hey! What tags and search keyword did you use for this video? Coz I also wanna make dis kind of videos.
Red Dead Redemption 2
_Grand Theft Auto IV!_
@@user-fp5ff7wn6w nope
Rockstar Games is the best.
Yeah
Wait for GTA VI and RDR3
@Agustin Rossetti wait for GTA VI...
@@neo2030jars no I'll wait for gta online update since that's the only game rockstar likes to profit off.
The beta Games Group is the best
I aggree
Gta IV is such a masterpiece
No, its a such a trash, 2008 fanboy
@@user-lv5yu2bx1w The 9year old with GTA V profile pic in a Crusade against better games.
@@user-lv5yu2bx1w Says the child who only played GTA 5.
I’ve never played gta games
RDR: 2 is a Master Piece as well
Rocket launcher part :- Rickshaw b like m udega ni saala 😂
The rain part in gta 5 is pretty legit，in Cali we love the rain
Legends watching video after 2 years😂
3:04 Niko shoots the cops car and the cops are like 👁️👄👁️
Excellent
This si fucking Awesome.
Te quedó genial!
Si señor
Nice video
Grande nikopresioooo! 2:55
John Marston: HHHHHIIIIIIIIIIYYYYYYYYYYYAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRHHHHH!!!!!!!!!
And that wheel on rdr2 is made outta wood it doesn't need tires to drive it and wood doesn't have air in it it's the wild west not overwatch bro.
This guy sucks.He likes gta 4.It is game of noobs.Gta 4 sucks.Arthur is legend.The the hero the king.nico is shit.
@Eftinoiu Eduard yo bruh chill out you don't gotta insult everybody who just says something that you said. What if they didn't see it. =/
Most realistic game->rdr2
And newest game lol
And the Newbie !
I espected someone of your reputation to be ..younger..
And gta 4
gta iv was so ahead of its time, gta v was a little bit flop with realism
That scream around the 2:50 mark was funny
you have to use a shotgun to make tires damaged in rdr2
If you go to Rhodes in RDR2 when it starts raining they run inside. Some of them Grab newspapers or something to cover their heads but I’ve seen them take shelter
Just a Bigfoot With Internet Access you are on every single video i'm about to flip
Micheal: STOP FIRING AT MY HOUSE !!!
Nice 😎👍🏽
eu amo os seus videos de comparação... são otimos
Oh mel dels um BR! Prazer em te conhecer
Rockstar is really great at making games
Here you have two masterpieces and GTA V
Osm video bro
Bueno, la fuerza de un cañon antiguo y un lanzacohetes es diferente. En cuanto a comparación de RPGs GTA 4 sigue siendo más realista.
Niko its ROMAn LETS Go BOWLING!?
4:50 old town road 😂😂
thia guy expecting a wood to deflat
Niko, where are you men? Come back!? Please...
You need people, you need world!
"What every GTA Game is good at"
• 2D GTA Universe.
-1. GTA 1: Introduction
-2. GTA LDN: Different
-3. GTA 2: Upgrade
-4. GTA ADV: Stunts
-5. GTA CTW: Cooler
• 3D GTA Universe.
-1. GTA III: Memories
-2. GTA VC: Soundtrack
-3. GTA SA: Storyline
-4. GTA LCS: Darkest
-5. GTA VCS: Brightest
• HD GTA Universe.
-1. GTA IV: Physics
-2. GTA TLAD: Gangs
-3. GTA TBOGT: Party
-4. GTA V: Graphics
-5. GTA ONLINE: flying bikes (not really a good thing).
Gta V is good at Weapons customization, Car customization and graphics
Bruh give GTA v some respect it’s still top five games
@@tomasvolpe5152 May I ask for your own Opinion ?
@@Pkxvk Can I listen to your own Opinion ?
I like sound Wated vs Busted Gta 5.😍🥰
My favorite thing was watching the stuff like the helicopters and be like 🤨 whats he gonna use in Red Dead?
go subscribe + 5
GTA IV: Great physics
GTA V: Decent physics
Red Dead Redemption: It's great in *Everything*
stfu gta iv is the biggest dissapointment in gta series
@@exe9790 Your opinion
@@lGNITED not opinion but a fact look at its Graphics its worst than Mario 1990 game
@@exe9790 are you sure? those aren't graphics, back then it was pixel by pixel, there was no 3D in mario 1990
@@lGNITED but GTA Iv graphics is worse though its 2008 so its graphics should be as level as GTA V
Niko didnt die cuz 4 still had some of the arcade implaments. But the driving was very realistic in 4 over 5.
The only thing driving fails in 4 is steering. Cars felt like boat while steering left or right and that's pretty not realistic
@@HazerV2
You don't have play 5
In 5, he died because the water was not enough deep, in RD2, it's because you automatically die in water.
Nether of them apply that water because as hard as the ground if you fall encounter it with too much speed
I really want an open world Walking Dead game with RDR2 graphics and style of gameplay
Subbed faster than speed of light after seeing niko survived & others died
Love rockstar. Really wish they would do dlc for rdr2. Guess have to wait for gt6
Lets go bowling kkkk
watching only first seconds, we really need evolution
fantastic 💕😊