I told a guy that in the next 10 years red dead redemption 2 will still be competing. It's a next gen game. Sometimes it's not all about console power/potentials. Talented developers matters a lot. They're the ones that can fully utilize it.
@@josefelfinito6925 It isn't a next gen game half of the buildings aren't even enterable in towns, the gunplay is the exact same as previous rockstar games etc
the sad part is that this is not exactly passion, rdr 2 and other Rockstar titles suffered of a lot of crunch, yup, the game is excellent, but at what cost?
Both look insanely good. But considering how harder it is to create those levels of visuals in a huge, seamless open world, compared to linear games with different sections of maps, RDR2 is clearly the superior one.
R* has always been on the cutting edge graphics wise, and the game was made by 2,000 people over 7 years. While a lot of the stuff it uses has become mainstream like subsurface scattering which it uses for light shining through ears, nose and hands of PEDs it also has an insane amount of tessellation which is still somewhat experimental and is usually very taxing on machines as well as lowering performance, but not only did they make it work but it’s everywhere in the game. Those snow physics? Tessellation. Your footsteps dragging through Valentine? Tessellation. Falling in mud and leaving behind an imprint? Tessellation. Usually those things are handled by textures, 3D objects or aren’t even addressed but it’s everywhere in RDR2, and it’s well optimized. Not to mention everything else and the size of its world it’s insane. It’s truly what Next-Gen games should be or strive to be, but they still haven’t.
Clearly two amazing games and two of my all-time favorites. Just goes to show you how much work and detail was put into RDR2 that it has the overall edge even against a remade Naughty Dog game.
It's interesting how the mechanics in each one serves purpose to the story. Arthur not being able to smash windows in the same way as Joel makes sense bc he doesnt have to. Joel's horse not having a reaction or being able to be hurt by him, makes sense considering that's the only horse hes got around, while with Arthur, the cowboy/outlaw life requires them to have a good relationship tothe horse and its part of the game mechanics to take care of yours. Both incredibly stunning games with mechanics that fit their purpose as an open world and linear story game!
They chose the only window in the game that can't be smashed, because the mirrors in hotel room are what allows you to change clothing, he could break any other windows.
The mechanics of Red Dead Redemption 2 was amazing and the Last Of Us Part 1 was too, but the way the world looked in The Last Of Us Part 1 was astounding!
@@diogod2347 that's stupid, it's a disadvantage, they will have less detail because the world itself is bigger, it gives you less time to work on small things, not only that but the space of the game itself increases 10x, an open world game cannot have as much detail as a linear game like tlau when it comes to anything, if tlau had the same team, the same amount of time, technology and effort that rdr2 had, while only having a small map and a shorter amount of activities it would be way better than rdr2 in graphics and details, naturally as work will be more focused, It'd probably be finished earlier, and no extra hours, but this isn't the case, that isn't the type of games Rockstar makes or the ones they find worth selling.
It's amazing because we're comparing 2 games that are 4 years apart and Rdr2 takes the lead in a lot of aspects! They just have to make it 60fps on ps5
@@theghostofsparta4528 he showed a weak take down tho, the take down with the gun is supposed to be faster, if you do it empty handed it will actually choke them out, with a knife it will stab them or slit their throat, an axe will be hacked across their neck, etc. Though I gotta say it was a nice expression it did in tlou, I think it would be better for well, expressing.
@@Aishu092 no still locked on 30, I tried on ps5 and felt the frame rate lag for RDR2 comparing to last of us part 1 and last of us part 2(already 60 fps patched for ps5) on ps5.
Great video, the only thing missing was a cityscape walkthrough for RDR2 like you did for TLOU. A shot of a walk through Saint Denis would’ve been the perfect matchup shot.
Rdr 2 is huge open world and we can do everything and visit every spot in the map even its mountain. With those amount of details in a huge open world is not easy guys.
@@Searaa06 rdr2 is literally the most detailed game ever made and the fact that it's open world and rockstar took the time and effort to put in all those details that can rival linear games is just insane
I think for the glass details one thing that is really cool in rdr2 is if your taking cover next to a window and you aim, arthur will automatically smash the glass, you can also throw people throw windows
I think TLOU does rain better. The rain drops and how they interact with the environment are similarly matched in Red Dead, but TLOU adds the slight foggy effect in the distance.
I don't know, in terms of gameplay I go more for the last of us since I feel it more fluid and when it comes to fighting melee the impacts are felt more in the last of us than in red dead
@@theghostofsparta4528 comparing tlou's melee to rdr is like comparing rdr2's horses to tlou's. You will almost never use melee in rdr and it is still very good.
RAGE (ROCKSTAR ADVANCED GRAPHICS ENGINE) IS AWESOME 😎 GTA V 2013 RDR2 2018 GTA VI ???? IMAGINE WHAT GTA VI WILL LOOK LIKE MAN I CAN'T WAIT TO SEE THAT GAME 😍
being a big fan of both games I can say that both are the current quality standards in terms of open world or linear stories, The Last Of Us Part I integrates the best of Part II to put it a bit on a par although Part II is still much more ambitious and better in technical terms while Red Dead Redemption 2 is still a next generation game, the fact that you can interact with almost everything in its world is abysmal, from NPC's, animals, objects and environments, which The Last Of Us Part I also does but in smaller settings, although The Last Of Us has better facial expressions than Red Dead Redemption 2.
@@soupaa It is one thing for someone to use words that are difficult to understand and another for you to be an idiot who does not understand the words.
@@soupaa I was going to argue with you but then I read the actual context he wrote it in, yeah that's silly. thought you're shitting on him for using the word not for using it wrong lmao
I think TLOU 1 Remake is the toughest comparison for RDR 2. But i think RDR 2 has done the best considering its an openworld game came out on 2018. Things i found TLOU 1 Remake did better: -Glass physics - Combat (debateable) - Graphics ( the graphics literally making me crazy) -Vegetation - Better facial texture and facial expression (it is perfect, the best i have ever seen) Did i miss something? Things i found RDR 2 did better: -The horse behavior -Water physique and fire logic - The amazing detail in rdr 2 (there is a lot of them that making me go insane, im going to show you an example, hair and facial hair will grow overtime, and many that i cannot show it all.) - Combat (debateable) - and many other features rdr 2 offers like fishing, hunting, robbing(but i dont think this would count in this comparison, I am sorry people 👍🏼) And yeah, did i miss something? Both of these game have their respective advantages and disadvantages. I play red dead 2 and i also play last of us, and i love both games.
Good analysis. I think TLOU wins, because it has a better and more original storyline and also better missions design. RDR 2 was a enjoyable experience, but I felt that the storyline was kind of dull. Also, TLOU factions (multiplayer) is one my favourite multiplayer experiences ever.
Its just like GTA 5 which is giving competition to todays games as well... rockstar has made a few open world and unique games which are making history even til now..🙂😘
This comparison is very surface level. For example, in the bow comparison, you didn't show that different arrow types in RDR2 act differently, the small game arrow (Which has a blunt shotgun casing as its tip), bounces off every surface, including wood. Another example, the takedown animations in RDR2 are amazing, you just don't know how to use them, every weapon type has multiple animations, with revolver, you can simply hit a guy, you can grab him and shoot him in the head or hit him after, you can tackle him to the ground and hit him or shoot him (Also, animations are varied depending if you grab a guy from the front or back). In different environments, you can drown a guy, throw him off a ledge, throw him through the window, knock him out, choke him out, and different melee weapons such as knifes and axes have different takedown animations as well. Overall, shitty comparison video made for views since TLOU1 just came out.
I see them RUclips videos hyping the last of us remaster 2.0, the criminal naughty dog advertise as a "remake". There's actually nothing new aside graphics and facial expressions. It's no competition for red dead redemption 2 at all in every aspect.
You do realize that wouldn’t be fair to TLOU remake because it doesn’t have or need details like arrow size so comparing that is frivolous and only serves to make RDR2 look better creating a bias comparison video.
@@stillvillian Maybe because it is not a real REMAKE, it's a REMASTER of a REMASTERED version of TLoU. RESIDENT EVIL 2 (2019) is a REAL REMAKE of RESIDENT EVIL 2 (1998).
2 legendary games. It’s interesting to see 2 peak games side by side. Nonetheless these guys will be timeless! And of course they’re both different to their own extension and right I love TLOU2 for its dynamic gameplay, best game I’ve played with such. They’re both satisfying games once you “master” it
Personally i think Tlou just looks better overall, but im not gonna deny RDR2 IS CRAZY DETAILED AND IMPRESSIVE. So they definitely compete with each other. Then again i think we should also take in the consideration that they are two completely differently games going for completely didn’t feels and themes. I digress though, they are still two AMAZING GAMES
@@Shutupsitdownrelax well I’m not gonna say that it’s obvious, but the graphics are much better than RDR2. Character models, textures, lighting, etc are all noticeably better. I also think that the animations are a little bit more realistic in TLOUp1 with things like swimming, so in that regard i think TLOU part 1 wins.
@@Gryphondork.the textures are very high resolution in both games lighting is much better on rdr2 the character models are a bit better on tlou and about the animations rdr2 is a game focused more on realism that's why some of the animations like running,swimming etc might look a bit off when you compare it to non realistic ones like tlou not to mention rdr2 is a MUCH bigger game than tlou since it is open world whereas tlou is linear hence it also has much more going on and they still managed to keep it on par with games released in 2022 4 years after it was released
@@Shutupsitdownrelax I’m not saying that TLOUp1 is better then RDR2. Im just implying that TLOUp1 has better graphics. There are a lot of things that RDR2 does better than TLOUp1 when it comes to the amount of detail that RDR2 has, but you can’t honestly say that RDR2 is focused more on realism and say it just looks off when the swimming and running animations are clearly and obviously not as realistic then TLOUp1. I know its just your opinion, but it’s pretty obvious you’re just sugarcoating things that the last of us does better and not actually looking at it critically or unbiased. How can you say that RDR2 focuses more on realism if the animations aren’t as good as a game that ALSO FOCUES on realism just as much if not more than RDR2. All things considered though, thats just my opinion.
Rockstar and Naughty Dog are both incredible developers but Rockstar is just insane when it comes to their open world in Red Dead 2. Rockstar will always be one of my favorite developers.
TLOU2P1 might win on basic object and character lighting (I mean it IS PS5 graphics), but clearly RDR2 environmental physics win HANDS DOWN in every way shown here. In fact I never would have guessed that had you not shown a side by side comparison. I can only imaging RDR2 revamped for PS5!!
@@tronicol235 Totally disagree. For starters, look at the first comparison...the snow physics. TLOU footprints looks like a bad Nintendo bitmap while RDR2 looks like realistic snow. Not even a comparison. Granted these are two different games going for two different experiences and have focused their energy in different areas. But if we are going to focus purely on physics. RDR2 for the win.
In terms of graphics and details then yeah you're correct. But a lot of other aspects on rdr2 like the story is beaten by tons of games. The story is good and emotional in the ending but it really can't compare to a lot of other games.
@@KimJongUn278 you're watching it right now. Tlou has way better story and a more interesting setting than rdr2. And don't even get me started on those absolutely emotional and amazing indie games like Ori And The Blind Forest.
@@KimJongUn278 hot take but rdr2's ending is pretty generic ngl. "Someone betrays you, main character dies" is basically what the ending of rdr2 is.(i bet you're gonna say some bullshit like "HaVe YOu EvEn PLaYed RDR2")
Um, why at 6:15 did you make Arthur knock the guy out with a gun?? Arthur also has a chokehold and a neck breaking takedown that you could have shown off instead... lol
From this we can know that character physics and animation plays a major role in video game.. we can feel their body weight through the controller and their movement style.. this is how a game looks realistic
It's March 2023 and I just picked up RDR2 like 6 months ago. For whatever reason, it just wasn't on my radar when it came out and even now, I waited until I could get it for like 10 bucks on my Series X. It is hands down the greatest game I have ever played. I thoroughly enjoyed both TLOU games, but it's no contest imo. RDR2 is a living, breathing world. It's a masterpiece.
There are so many cool details in RDR2 that I can forgive the bedroom mirror for not getting damaged if one shoots it; that was a small oversight on Rockstar though
It's silly to compare the two because The Last of Us was built for storytelling and Red Dead Redemtion 2 has an open world to explore. It is obvious that in an open world with good elaboration, even small details are important.
@@rukitlas7130 so? Literally means they had more time and space to add more details and textures, not the opposite, rdr2s map is WAY bigger, it's WAY WAY harder to fill something like that with details like the glass breaking tlau has.
@@SpecterNeverSpectator bro I’m talking about hitting your horse in the game in open world you can do whatever you like tlou you can’t cause it’s levels rather then open world Im not saying there’s not details in tlou I’m just saying your more free in rdr2
@@man_77 En ese aspecto comparativo de mundo abierto tienes razón, pero hay muchos otros aspectos de detalles que no mostraron en este video, te invito a que veas un "detalles impresionantes de TLOU" para que notes por ti mismo que Naughty Dog también realiza con mucho cariño los detalles en sus videojuegos aún siendo lineal.
Fanboys comparing and arguing on which one is better, yall should just appreciate both amazing games, there aren't many games out there with this much passion and detail put into them.
Well I'll add few to the list if you don't mind Kratos from God of war John marston from rdr1 and 2 And micah bell is the best written villain I have ever seen
Rdr2 is going to be the most detailed and graphically impressive game on the market until it is dethroned by Rockstar themselves when they release GTA 6
No. Not at all. The complete opposite. Linear games cannot give the player experimental freedom because that would ruin the experience. Open Worlds are mich larger and like the name suggests are open the player and give more room for details. I mean you can for Example punch your horse in RDR2 but not in Tlou and that’s perfectly fine for both games
@@DeutscherPatrick open worlds are much harder to add details and good graphics because of the size of the world already and how long it takes too Linear games have it easy
@@namedclaiming821 there are different types of details. Details tuned on the player are more common in Linear games but details resulting from experiments and deep exploration aren’t in Linear games
Playing rdr2 is so immersive! I don't even do quest/story most of the time just riding with my horse and shooting grumpy strangers and accidentally running over people.
é uma judiação não ter saido 60fps para PS5 e xsx. Estava esperando uma versão melhorada para curtir este game, no PS4 achei insuportável os 30fps, cansa de mais a vista.
there are people like me that prefer a story driven game that is rather liniear. I played my fair share of open world games and they are just too big and run out of steam at some point. Not everyone has to like open world you know.
Both are incredibly impressive and the peak standard every developer should strive for, but once you get to gameplay The Last of Us is leagues above rdr2. Rockstar needs to step their game up in this area for their next installment.
@@mickclusterduck2940 I disagree. If you don't agree with my opinion, just don't try to project your God damn opinions on me. I agree, they're both realistic, but I think rdr2 has better graphics. Don't bash people for their opinions.
@@abbaAbba. youre the one projecting your opinions man. i was never bashing you at all in anyway. rdr2 can have realism or immersion or whatever but tlou objectively looks more realistic in nearly every aspect so forgive me if I dont want you to downgrade one of my favorite games.
There is no comparison with RDR2 it's a vast open world game which is alive and keeps evolving changing around you as you keep playing exploring it there is no comparison here it is the best and how deep the devs went into making this magnificent highly detailed world with well written story, characters and even animals, NPCs have there own life in this beautiful world. I can write whole essay on this game....
In general I like more lighting, contrast, brightness and Bloom in tlou, they are much more comfortable to the eye, although keep in mind that it is not the same to compare a game from 2010 to 2015 than a game from 2018 to 2022, the graphic difference will be less and less noticeable.
Plus RDR2 is very moddable in terms of it's visual presentation so you could easily adjust all those aspects with various mods and reshade presets (on PC of course).
I really appreciate how gamers, who have commented on this video, like exploring a huge map of a beautiful game like RDR2, despite the game having zero gameplay and a shallow story. RDR2 looks amazing and I like hunting in it a lot.
Both are some of the best games I've ever played, but to me last of us wins in story just by a bit, it wins in graphics and it wins in gameplay. But considering rdr 2 is open world is very impressive
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Want a video detailing the Last of us remake???
Nah
نعم
Yesz
TLOU2 is better imo so maybe rdr2 vs tlou2
YES
I told a guy that in the next 10 years red dead redemption 2 will still be competing. It's a next gen game. Sometimes it's not all about console power/potentials. Talented developers matters a lot. They're the ones that can fully utilize it.
I agree with you
@@5hv4n کورد لە هەموو شوێنێکە 😂💚
"next gen game" *realizes it has gta 3 missions design*
@@DinaricUbermensch we're talking about quality not just design
@@josefelfinito6925 It isn't a next gen game half of the buildings aren't even enterable in towns, the gunplay is the exact same as previous rockstar games etc
Rdr 2 is too much, the passion that Rockstar put in this game’s making is simply insane, who played it, know that
Game Best tried to scam me
ruclips.net/video/HYHnniWuiJo/видео.html
Exactly.
the sad part is that this is not exactly passion, rdr 2 and other Rockstar titles suffered of a lot of crunch, yup, the game is excellent, but at what cost?
@@jamesvjcs doesn't remove the passion ppl work crunch times because they have a lot of passion for that game so yea
Yeah i know S A I M O N i game rdr 2 i ts much realisticfor the last of us
When you are playing RDR 2, you are not actually playing, you are living in the game
Fax
Damn facts!
Fact
It's hard to argue against that statement!
If we could play it with a vr or something like that for real it will be' like we living in it
Both look insanely good.
But considering how harder it is to create those levels of visuals in a huge, seamless open world, compared to linear games with different sections of maps, RDR2 is clearly the superior one.
Yeah the thing is that RDR2 has much less environment and object density. Not even trying to knock the game but it’s a point worth noting
@@Splenetic- Yeah and theres a lot of flat textures and flat rocks. but still its an open world game for ps4 vs a linear ps5 game
Not really considering that LoU was originally developed for the ps3 system...
@@nils7988 yeah but it is now made as a remastered for the ps5
@@strong7868 remade* huge difference
It's insane how good RDR2 looks, especially since it's an open world game.
R* has always been on the cutting edge graphics wise, and the game was made by 2,000 people over 7 years. While a lot of the stuff it uses has become mainstream like subsurface scattering which it uses for light shining through ears, nose and hands of PEDs it also has an insane amount of tessellation which is still somewhat experimental and is usually very taxing on machines as well as lowering performance, but not only did they make it work but it’s everywhere in the game. Those snow physics? Tessellation. Your footsteps dragging through Valentine? Tessellation. Falling in mud and leaving behind an imprint? Tessellation. Usually those things are handled by textures, 3D objects or aren’t even addressed but it’s everywhere in RDR2, and it’s well optimized. Not to mention everything else and the size of its world it’s insane. It’s truly what Next-Gen games should be or strive to be, but they still haven’t.
@@ssgroup1475 still haven't seen a game with as much soul and life as rdr2. Not all AAA game companies make bad games now.
@@ssgroup1475 lmao😂
@@ssgroup1475 поплачь
10 times more optimized too
Considering RDR2 is an large open world game while TLOU part 1 is an linear story game, RDR2 holds up pretty well.
RDR2 literally won
Game Best tried to scam me
ruclips.net/video/HYHnniWuiJo/видео.html
@@namedclaiming821 tlou is better in terms of animation details though
@@Wabu_227 nah
@@Wabu_227 nah bro you clearly didn't play rdr2
Clearly two amazing games and two of my all-time favorites. Just goes to show you how much work and detail was put into RDR2 that it has the overall edge even against a remade Naughty Dog game.
Game Best tried to scam me
ruclips.net/video/HYHnniWuiJo/видео.html
Nah last of us outshines rdr2 in many ways
@@tronicol235 not here
Rdr2 eats the last of us
@@tronicol235 nah as a TLOU fan I’m pretty sure rdr2 wins most of these
It's interesting how the mechanics in each one serves purpose to the story. Arthur not being able to smash windows in the same way as Joel makes sense bc he doesnt have to. Joel's horse not having a reaction or being able to be hurt by him, makes sense considering that's the only horse hes got around, while with Arthur, the cowboy/outlaw life requires them to have a good relationship tothe horse and its part of the game mechanics to take care of yours. Both incredibly stunning games with mechanics that fit their purpose as an open world and linear story game!
Well said
They chose the only window in the game that can't be smashed, because the mirrors in hotel room are what allows you to change clothing, he could break any other windows.
@@Sjbx that's a mirror, and the comparison was between breaking mirrors, not windows.
I’ll never forget playing the snow level for the first time in RD2 on PS4. The graphics looked so damn good it made me feel cold
For me it was extra immersive cause the heat in my house didn't work at the time... it was unintentional immersion but it was immersive lol.
but comparing to tlou, it looks unrealistic.. Tlou's grphics is crazy
@@user-di373udke8snow in tlou looks like some high quality mobile game lmao. Rdr2 is definetly superior in graphics
What a shit take. This is coming from someone who owns both games 😂@@кчау-л6я
@@user-di373udke8rdr2 solos
The mechanics of Red Dead Redemption 2 was amazing and the Last Of Us Part 1 was too, but the way the world looked in The Last Of Us Part 1 was astounding!
The fact rdr2 actually does win despite being 4 years older and an open world is just crazy
and a ps4 game while tlou part 1 is a ps5 game
@Ching Vang he means the ps5 version
Exactly...it's open world,that's an advantage,open worlds are obviously gonna have more details and stuff lol
@@diogod2347 that's stupid, it's a disadvantage, they will have less detail because the world itself is bigger, it gives you less time to work on small things, not only that but the space of the game itself increases 10x, an open world game cannot have as much detail as a linear game like tlau when it comes to anything, if tlau had the same team, the same amount of time, technology and effort that rdr2 had, while only having a small map and a shorter amount of activities it would be way better than rdr2 in graphics and details, naturally as work will be more focused, It'd probably be finished earlier, and no extra hours, but this isn't the case, that isn't the type of games Rockstar makes or the ones they find worth selling.
rdr2 did not win at all lol
It's amazing because we're comparing 2 games that are 4 years apart and Rdr2 takes the lead in a lot of aspects! They just have to make it 60fps on ps5
Rain glass and takedowns are better in tlou
@@theghostofsparta4528 he showed a weak take down tho, the take down with the gun is supposed to be faster, if you do it empty handed it will actually choke them out, with a knife it will stab them or slit their throat, an axe will be hacked across their neck, etc.
Though I gotta say it was a nice expression it did in tlou, I think it would be better for well, expressing.
Isn't it already 60 fps on the PS5?
Only a 60-fps upgrade is not enough. It absolutely has to be adapted to the new controller as well!
@@Aishu092 no still locked on 30, I tried on ps5 and felt the frame rate lag for RDR2 comparing to last of us part 1 and last of us part 2(already 60 fps patched for ps5) on ps5.
Nobody can beat Rdr2!
Only Rockstar can beat Rockstar
Obviously
Ninguém mesmo kkkkkkkk só a rockstar pode vencer ela mesma
@@gamersykes no
Of course
For the last 4 years Red Dead Redemption 2 has been the gold standard when it comes to graphics and details in an open world setting.
Rdr2 is not a game it is an experience.what a masterpiece!!!
Agreed but I personally prefer tlou story
@@Gryphondork. Arthur is better than Joel and Ellie
@@namedclaiming821 you're a fanboy, RDR2 story and characters are far less captivating
@@blakbear6528 cope
@@namedclaiming821 Rdr 2 is a great game but the characters are much better in Tlou
Great video, the only thing missing was a cityscape walkthrough for RDR2 like you did for TLOU. A shot of a walk through Saint Denis would’ve been the perfect matchup shot.
Rdr 2 is huge open world and we can do everything and visit every spot in the map even its mountain. With those amount of details in a huge open world is not easy guys.
Thats why rdr2 wins by KO.
And if u enojoy more TLOU, thats subjetive and okey, but u cant ignore that fact u just said
@@Searaa06 rdr2 is literally the most detailed game ever made and the fact that it's open world and rockstar took the time and effort to put in all those details that can rival linear games is just insane
Agreed i do think tlou part 1 & 2 are right below it when it comes to most detailed
@@Gryphondork. hell no
The REAL difference is- One games requires 10GB vram to play ultra 1080p while the other one 5gb to play 4K ultra.
Ultra? 10gb vram is probably for medium/high, you need more than 16gb of vram to play at ultra lmao
I think for the glass details one thing that is really cool in rdr2 is if your taking cover next to a window and you aim, arthur will automatically smash the glass, you can also throw people throw windows
It's insane that red dead redemption 2 is 2018 and it it's still the most realistic game that i ever seen
wait till gta 6
@@inigo-montoya im pretty sure is gonna be a flop..
@@giorgionecascus5658 WHAT! WHY
TLOU is from 2013 and almost had all the features of this remake, except the graphics upgrade.
@@giorgionecascus5658 what? It’s not going to be a flop
Red dead 2 will still look and feel good 30 years from now.
the textures are already quite bad. sorry to break it to you buddy
@@ys0Minecraft did anyone ask
@@CinematicUniverse26290 dId AnYoNe AsK?
@@ys0Minecraft bet
cod from 10 years back already look good :/
I think TLOU does rain better. The rain drops and how they interact with the environment are similarly matched in Red Dead, but TLOU adds the slight foggy effect in the distance.
So does rdr2 but light rain doesn't make a fog effect only heavy rain does
@@callmedawg001 but in real life fog can also be there with light or even no rain, why does fog only come with heavy rain?
@@shivamarya5225 fog can come without rain at all
Game Best tried to scam me
ruclips.net/video/HYHnniWuiJo/видео.html
so does rdr2
You guys will never get over with these versus videos - __ -
Both games are fantastic in their aspect, i love both
Last of Us definitely has the most emotive facial expressions.
You are right about that
it's cool to compare those two Legendary games but red dead redemption 2 is far better in every aspect
Not glass at least.
@@denisucuuu yes glass physics is crazy in tlou 2 and 1 remake i Iove to break every windows everytime i play
Story is another factor that tlou pt1 wins, rdr2 is less captivating and has worse pacing
@@Smallahz really u need help
I don't know, in terms of gameplay I go more for the last of us since I feel it more fluid and when it comes to fighting melee the impacts are felt more in the last of us than in red dead
The amount of different kinds of takedowns you have in rdr2 and all you did was but him with a gun lol
Theres many of takedowns in last of us
Tlou has the most satisfying melee in any game
@@theghostofsparta4528 comparing tlou's melee to rdr is like comparing rdr2's horses to tlou's. You will almost never use melee in rdr and it is still very good.
@@theghostofsparta4528 in any game?!? I think that’s a bit of a broad statement my guy
@@marv5780dude stop dickriding and accept tlou takedowns are better
RAGE (ROCKSTAR ADVANCED GRAPHICS ENGINE) IS AWESOME 😎
GTA V 2013
RDR2 2018
GTA VI ????
IMAGINE WHAT GTA VI WILL LOOK LIKE MAN I CAN'T WAIT TO SEE THAT GAME 😍
Yeah it won't come so your waiting is over
Real simulation 6: deluxe edition
@@9273Lamn yeah
The rage engine isn't actually that good, when compared to other engines it's kinda lacking in some areas
@@Smallahz such as?
being a big fan of both games I can say that both are the current quality standards in terms of open world or linear stories, The Last Of Us Part I integrates the best of Part II to put it a bit on a par although Part II is still much more ambitious and better in technical terms while Red Dead Redemption 2 is still a next generation game, the fact that you can interact with almost everything in its world is abysmal, from NPC's, animals, objects and environments, which The Last Of Us Part I also does but in smaller settings, although The Last Of Us has better facial expressions than Red Dead Redemption 2.
bro said "abysmal" 💀yall need to stop using words just to look a little smarter
Fr lol
@@soupaa It is one thing for someone to use words that are difficult to understand and another for you to be an idiot who does not understand the words.
@@soupaa how does lil bro not know what "abysmal" means 😭😭 it takes like 3 seconds to google that
@@soupaa I was going to argue with you but then I read the actual context he wrote it in, yeah that's silly. thought you're shitting on him for using the word not for using it wrong lmao
If only I can experience rdr2 for the first time again. Rdr2 is amazing. I play it more than any games I own.
I think TLOU 1 Remake is the toughest comparison for RDR 2. But i think RDR 2 has done the best considering its an openworld game came out on 2018.
Things i found TLOU 1 Remake did better:
-Glass physics
- Combat (debateable)
- Graphics ( the graphics literally making me crazy)
-Vegetation
- Better facial texture and facial expression (it is perfect, the best i have ever seen)
Did i miss something?
Things i found RDR 2 did better:
-The horse behavior
-Water physique and fire logic
- The amazing detail in rdr 2 (there is a lot of them that making me go insane, im going to show you an example, hair and facial hair will grow overtime, and many that i cannot show it all.)
- Combat (debateable)
- and many other features rdr 2 offers like fishing, hunting, robbing(but i dont think this would count in this comparison, I am sorry people 👍🏼)
And yeah, did i miss something?
Both of these game have their respective advantages and disadvantages. I play red dead 2 and i also play last of us, and i love both games.
I think a Ps5 enhanced version of Rdr2 might have better texture quality compared to ps4. Sad thing it hasn't been released yet.
Good analysis. I think TLOU wins, because it has a better and more original storyline and also better missions design. RDR 2 was a enjoyable experience, but I felt that the storyline was kind of dull. Also, TLOU factions (multiplayer) is one my favourite multiplayer experiences ever.
@@tacos4419tbh i enjoyed RDR2 storyline much deeper than TLOU1/2. So much unique well written characters in this huge open world map.
Man RDR2 best game in the world ❤️
Master peice❤️
It truely is. I’ve probably been playing for almost a year .. can’t get enough
Not in my opinion
"The details of the glass are also better developed in The Last of Us compared to Red Dead Redemption 2."
I love how detailed the ground/floor looks in TLOU at 6:55
😂lol a “floor”? Wtf Ig now we gunna talk about how detail the floors now
@@Souls_25 rdr2 fucking solos that too LMAO
@@Souls_25 probably meant the glasss on the floor I think idk
@@doggodiggin Ikr😂. This guy talking about how floors are so nice in Tlous. Really? Floors? Red dead has them better
@@clef9883 I hope so. I hope it's not floors hes talking
You can always count on rockstar to make a graphically beautiful game
Even 4 years later stands unbeatn
stands unshaken
@@oHaze. oh I love that song
@@shaantanukhaire fax
I like y’all’s vibe
@@oHaze. damn you,you beat me to it
Yeah RDR2 holds up incredibly well even 4 years later and it will for years to come. The passion from both studios is evident. Keep innovating!
Mostly rdr2 tho. Think about it tbh
I mean, everyone’s entitled to their opinion. I think their about equal. Though I prefer last of us’ story. @@Souls_25
tlou really kills rdr2.. Tlou's graphics, physics is insane
@@user-di373udke8the physics on TLOU aren't allat. No wonder a linear story game made 4 years later has better graphics
It's amazing how a 2018 game can be superior to a 2022 game, rockstar gave herself body and soul in this game, programmers deserve my respect
The last of us is a 2013 game
@@GForceIntel remake 2022
@@GForceIntel Correct and The Last of Us Remake is from 2022
@@yoshivv_it’s still a 2013 game. remake didn’t make any good cause they just changed graphics.
Its just like GTA 5 which is giving competition to todays games as well... rockstar has made a few open world and unique games which are making history even til now..🙂😘
Imagine an undead nightmare for rdr2, could potentially be the best open world zombie game ever made
This comparison is very surface level. For example, in the bow comparison, you didn't show that different arrow types in RDR2 act differently, the small game arrow (Which has a blunt shotgun casing as its tip), bounces off every surface, including wood. Another example, the takedown animations in RDR2 are amazing, you just don't know how to use them, every weapon type has multiple animations, with revolver, you can simply hit a guy, you can grab him and shoot him in the head or hit him after, you can tackle him to the ground and hit him or shoot him (Also, animations are varied depending if you grab a guy from the front or back). In different environments, you can drown a guy, throw him off a ledge, throw him through the window, knock him out, choke him out, and different melee weapons such as knifes and axes have different takedown animations as well.
Overall, shitty comparison video made for views since TLOU1 just came out.
I see them RUclips videos hyping the last of us remaster 2.0, the criminal naughty dog advertise as a "remake". There's actually nothing new aside graphics and facial expressions. It's no competition for red dead redemption 2 at all in every aspect.
At least these videos serve the purpose of showing that RDR2's graphics and character animation have set a standard for video games.
@@Herandro_just_Herandro True. Other developers should try to beat red dead redemption 2
You do realize that wouldn’t be fair to TLOU remake because it doesn’t have or need details like arrow size so comparing that is frivolous and only serves to make RDR2 look better creating a bias comparison video.
@@stillvillian Maybe because it is not a real REMAKE, it's a REMASTER of a REMASTERED version of TLoU. RESIDENT EVIL 2 (2019) is a REAL REMAKE of RESIDENT EVIL 2 (1998).
just play both of them. they are 2 of the best games ever made
Game Best tried to scam me
ruclips.net/video/HYHnniWuiJo/видео.html
Facts
no game comes closer to the weather effects in RDR2 absolute best
Game Best tried to scam me
ruclips.net/video/HYHnniWuiJo/видео.html
tlou1 is better imo
Crysis 3 water is better than rdr2
@@mickclusterduck2940 😂😂😂
@@mickclusterduck2940 objectively worse than RDR2 buddy no opinion to be had here it’s simply less impressive
2 legendary games. It’s interesting to see 2 peak games side by side. Nonetheless these guys will be timeless! And of course they’re both different to their own extension and right
I love TLOU2 for its dynamic gameplay, best game I’ve played with such. They’re both satisfying games once you “master” it
Personally i think Tlou just looks better overall, but im not gonna deny RDR2 IS CRAZY DETAILED AND IMPRESSIVE. So they definitely compete with each other. Then again i think we should also take in the consideration that they are two completely differently games going for completely didn’t feels and themes. I digress though, they are still two AMAZING GAMES
Okay tell me in which aspects tlou looks better?
@@Shutupsitdownrelax well I’m not gonna say that it’s obvious, but the graphics are much better than RDR2. Character models, textures, lighting, etc are all noticeably better. I also think that the animations are a little bit more realistic in TLOUp1 with things like swimming, so in that regard i think TLOU part 1 wins.
@@Gryphondork.the textures are very high resolution in both games lighting is much better on rdr2 the character models are a bit better on tlou and about the animations rdr2 is a game focused more on realism that's why some of the animations like running,swimming etc might look a bit off when you compare it to non realistic ones like tlou not to mention rdr2 is a MUCH bigger game than tlou since it is open world whereas tlou is linear hence it also has much more going on and they still managed to keep it on par with games released in 2022 4 years after it was released
@@Shutupsitdownrelax I’m not saying that TLOUp1 is better then RDR2. Im just implying that TLOUp1 has better graphics. There are a lot of things that RDR2 does better than TLOUp1 when it comes to the amount of detail that RDR2 has, but you can’t honestly say that RDR2 is focused more on realism and say it just looks off when the swimming and running animations are clearly and obviously not as realistic then TLOUp1. I know its just your opinion, but it’s pretty obvious you’re just sugarcoating things that the last of us does better and not actually looking at it critically or unbiased. How can you say that RDR2 focuses more on realism if the animations aren’t as good as a game that ALSO FOCUES on realism just as much if not more than RDR2. All things considered though, thats just my opinion.
@@Shutupsitdownrelax Stop getting so defensive and let people have opinions
Rockstar and Naughty Dog are both incredible developers but Rockstar is just insane when it comes to their open world in Red Dead 2. Rockstar will always be one of my favorite developers.
Rochstar game es una mierda
Uwu
TLOU2P1 might win on basic object and character lighting (I mean it IS PS5 graphics), but clearly RDR2 environmental physics win HANDS DOWN in every way shown here. In fact I never would have guessed that had you not shown a side by side comparison. I can only imaging RDR2 revamped for PS5!!
Wdym the physics are way better in tlou
@@tronicol235 Totally disagree. For starters, look at the first comparison...the snow physics. TLOU footprints looks like a bad Nintendo bitmap while RDR2 looks like realistic snow. Not even a comparison. Granted these are two different games going for two different experiences and have focused their energy in different areas. But if we are going to focus purely on physics. RDR2 for the win.
Lol volumetric lighting totally goes to RDR2
@@tronicol235 You're the definition of insanity to say that
@@munehboi are you a cg artist? I am
Their both amazing but rdr2 is still on another level that NO game has come to beat yet
Real the only game that will beat rdr2 is gta 6 in terms of graphics
In terms of graphics and details then yeah you're correct. But a lot of other aspects on rdr2 like the story is beaten by tons of games. The story is good and emotional in the ending but it really can't compare to a lot of other games.
@@alduinfr what games
@@KimJongUn278 you're watching it right now. Tlou has way better story and a more interesting setting than rdr2. And don't even get me started on those absolutely emotional and amazing indie games like Ori And The Blind Forest.
@@KimJongUn278 hot take but rdr2's ending is pretty generic ngl. "Someone betrays you, main character dies" is basically what the ending of rdr2 is.(i bet you're gonna say some bullshit like "HaVe YOu EvEn PLaYed RDR2")
Um, why at 6:15 did you make Arthur knock the guy out with a gun?? Arthur also has a chokehold and a neck breaking takedown that you could have shown off instead... lol
From this we can know that character physics and animation plays a major role in video game.. we can feel their body weight through the controller and their movement style.. this is how a game looks realistic
I love part 1 but god damn I didn’t remember rdr2 being that detailed
Red Dead Redemption 2 is not a game. It is a transcendent reality.
I gotta give it to RDR2. It's a highly detailed world that the consumer can explore.
It's March 2023 and I just picked up RDR2 like 6 months ago. For whatever reason, it just wasn't on my radar when it came out and even now, I waited until I could get it for like 10 bucks on my Series X. It is hands down the greatest game I have ever played. I thoroughly enjoyed both TLOU games, but it's no contest imo. RDR2 is a living, breathing world. It's a masterpiece.
There are so many cool details in RDR2 that I can forgive the bedroom mirror for not getting damaged if one shoots it; that was a small oversight on Rockstar though
It's silly to compare the two because The Last of Us was built for storytelling and Red Dead Redemtion 2 has an open world to explore. It is obvious that in an open world with good elaboration, even small details are important.
They are both great games, but Last of Us feels more limited because it isn't open world
Anytime RDR2 is way ahead of all the games, it's so real no one can match the details and feel of Rdr2 ❤❤❤
2 different games, 2 different publishers, 2 different engines, wiiiierd comparison. Both games are beautiful
I just hope PlayStation and Rockstar keep up their track record of insane looking games that are actually well optimized.
1:26 Rdr2 goes further with the attention to detail, you can even hit your horse. Rdr2 is still unbeaten if we are talking about details.
It’s cause it’s open world
6:42attention to detail
@@leonardobruce929 2:15 Attention to detail.
@@rukitlas7130 so? Literally means they had more time and space to add more details and textures, not the opposite, rdr2s map is WAY bigger, it's WAY WAY harder to fill something like that with details like the glass breaking tlau has.
@@SpecterNeverSpectator bro I’m talking about hitting your horse in the game in open world you can do whatever you like tlou you can’t cause it’s levels rather then open world Im not saying there’s not details in tlou I’m just saying your more free in rdr2
RDR2 es impresionante en detalles a 4 años de su salida. 😱, TLOU es pasillero, RDR2 ES open world, tiene muchisimo mas merito eso.
Rdr2 está súper trabajado, pero no está doblado y el gunplay es bastante más pobre que en tlou , es más divertido tlou
@@MarcusDrake79se esta comprando el nivel tecnico en el video, no el idioma ni el gunplay, eso es ya gusto personal.
@@man_77 En ese aspecto comparativo de mundo abierto tienes razón, pero hay muchos otros aspectos de detalles que no mostraron en este video, te invito a que veas un "detalles impresionantes de TLOU" para que notes por ti mismo que Naughty Dog también realiza con mucho cariño los detalles en sus videojuegos aún siendo lineal.
@@MarcusDrake79 Bueno todo recae en como quieres jugar rdr2 solo te da las herramientas, en tlou debes de seguir casi al pie de la letra las gunfights
Como mérito en open world a nivel técnico Horizon fw ahí lo dejo
Esses dois jogos são incríveis. Mas no fim,eu acho que só quem pode superar a rockstar, é a própria rockstar.
RDR2 perdeu no Vidro, Natação e Flechas , empata em mais 3 , e ganha o resto
@@luizsena635 As flechas dependem do material e do tipo de flecha, podem até atravessar madeira ou não
@@luizsena635 nas flechas foi empate pq o Joel tem a animação de pegar elas de volta, e no RDR 2 a física quando acerta elas na árvore é mais realista
@@mateusgomes742 eu acho que perde por causa da animação em pegar as flechas .já RDR2 não tem essa animação.
Game Best tried to scam me
ruclips.net/video/HYHnniWuiJo/видео.html
the rdr2 fire spread especially inside a house is just crazy
Fanboys comparing and arguing on which one is better, yall should just appreciate both amazing games, there aren't many games out there with this much passion and detail put into them.
The game doesn't matter but we all agree that Arthur Morgan and Joel Miller are the best written characters in video games!??
only I think so!
Yes
Well I'll add few to the list if you don't mind
Kratos from God of war
John marston from rdr1 and 2
And micah bell is the best written villain I have ever seen
@@callmedawg001 Agree on everything except Micah
@@callmedawg001 not Micah, is actually dutch
Joel yes, Arthur no
both are good but rdr 2 prioritizes exploration while the last of us puts forward the story
Rdr2 is going to be the most detailed and graphically impressive game on the market until it is dethroned by Rockstar themselves when they release GTA 6
GTA VI is going to be insane
Probably, yeah...
I like the detail in rdr2 that Arthur can't dive into the water because back then people didn't know how to swim properly
Just think of it this way:
TLOU had a remake, RDR2 has always been like this :).
Remember that Red dead redemption is not a linear game it’s an open world, so that means they have to cut down on the details
No. Not at all. The complete opposite.
Linear games cannot give the player experimental freedom because that would ruin the experience.
Open Worlds are mich larger and like the name suggests are open the player and give more room for details.
I mean you can for Example punch your horse in RDR2 but not in Tlou and that’s perfectly fine for both games
@@DeutscherPatrick open worlds are much harder to add details and good graphics because of the size of the world already and how long it takes too
Linear games have it easy
@@namedclaiming821 there are different types of details.
Details tuned on the player are more common in Linear games but details resulting from experiments and deep exploration aren’t in Linear games
Can't even compare the 2. When red dead 2 came out that was a next generation game
U right, can’t even compare them, tlou smashes it
@@enxgma8085 😆
@@RAIDER-sf3wk not joking at all.
@@RAIDER-sf3wk not joking at all.
@@enxgma8085 😆
Red dead redemption 2 is the best open world games ever! 🐎🤠
Yes
Yeahhhh
Yesss 🏆👑
Yes
Playing rdr2 is so immersive! I don't even do quest/story most of the time just riding with my horse and shooting grumpy strangers and accidentally running over people.
Interesting that in RDR2 there aren't raindrops on the camera when it rains unlike RDR1.
RDR 2 é o game mais bem feito até hoje. Um trabalho primoroso em todos os aspectos.
é uma judiação não ter saido 60fps para PS5 e xsx.
Estava esperando uma versão melhorada para curtir este game, no PS4 achei insuportável os 30fps, cansa de mais a vista.
Você viu o vídeo mano ?
Estamos falando de um jogo gigante de mundo aberto e não de um jogo de 10h de gameplay e linear.@@demisto240
Graphics never really mattered to me. I play video games to escape reality not join it. But overall RDR2 is better for being an open world game alone
RDR2 is about the best game you can choose of you Want to escape reality, it offers both that and insane graphics
It matters to me
there are people like me that prefer a story driven game that is rather liniear. I played my fair share of open world games and they are just too big and run out of steam at some point. Not everyone has to like open world you know.
Being open world is just an style of designing a game. Doesnt mean is automatically better.
Both are great games, both put in effort for the sake of gaming. Rockstar and Naughty Dog go hand in hand.
Both are incredibly impressive and the peak standard every developer should strive for, but once you get to gameplay The Last of Us is leagues above rdr2. Rockstar needs to step their game up in this area for their next installment.
The fact they had to grab the 2022 remaster for Ps5 of the last of us to just stand a chance to RDR2 is amzing
It's not a remaster. It's a remake from scratch
@@JACKRIDERPLAYZ oh my bad I didn't know that I haven't played the ps5 version I've been planning on getting it though
is it just me or is it that last of us has better graphics and newer textures compared to rdr 2 but lacks the attention to detail rdr 2 has😅
Read Dead's horses have balls.
Read Dead wins.
Now, imagine Tlou 1 and 2 with Rdr2's graphics and skills of realism. Absolutely godly.
tlou looks better?
@@mickclusterduck2940 in my opinion, rdr2 is far more realistic.
@@abbaAbba. but tlou looks absolutely more realistic in every way. to give it red deads graphics would be a downgrade
@@mickclusterduck2940 I disagree. If you don't agree with my opinion, just don't try to project your God damn opinions on me. I agree, they're both realistic, but I think rdr2 has better graphics. Don't bash people for their opinions.
@@abbaAbba. youre the one projecting your opinions man. i was never bashing you at all in anyway. rdr2 can have realism or immersion or whatever but tlou objectively looks more realistic in nearly every aspect so forgive me if I dont want you to downgrade one of my favorite games.
To grow you must not compare, but simply, appreciate.
- Master Oogway, Probably
My second favorite game is RDR2 and i see its at least mechanics are better than any other game. A masterpiece.
The movement of the characters in RDR2 is just too natural.
It would be a god send to have these two studio do a colab for a game
There is no comparison with RDR2 it's a vast open world game which is alive and keeps evolving changing around you as you keep playing exploring it there is no comparison here it is the best and how deep the devs went into making this magnificent highly detailed world with well written story, characters and even animals, NPCs have there own life in this beautiful world. I can write whole essay on this game....
Man i have ps4 fat and rdr 2 its still crazy at graphics and ive never had fps drop how its this even real
In general I like more lighting, contrast, brightness and Bloom in tlou, they are much more comfortable to the eye, although keep in mind that it is not the same to compare a game from 2010 to 2015 than a game from 2018 to 2022, the graphic difference will be less and less noticeable.
Plus RDR2 is very moddable in terms of it's visual presentation so you could easily adjust all those aspects with various mods and reshade presets (on PC of course).
@@tars3249 I'm talking about it base game, if we take the mods up to minecraft it looks better than both games.
@@zLex.wYou can adjust all of these according to your preferences in the rdr2 settings easily.
2 obras maestras 2 protagonistas que son para mi los mejores e imagínate un the last of us 3 vs red dead redemption 3
Joel y Arthur gods
Para mi sinceramente gana rdr2
@@unnamed3697 para mi the last of us
Rdr 2 for sure wins this
@@gamersykes I was gonna respect that but then I saw ur profile name, now we're enemies
I dont think so
@Gamebest on telegram omg I'm the winner 😱😱😱, shut up bruh
@@gamersykes Yeah , The Last of us part 1 wins , the water physic are too good bro
@@Cailan.Fishing Yea the water physics are better but you're a fool if you think that makes the entire game better
I really appreciate how gamers, who have commented on this video, like exploring a huge map of a beautiful game like RDR2, despite the game having zero gameplay and a shallow story. RDR2 looks amazing and I like hunting in it a lot.
rdr has a shallow story?
Rockstar games: i am a clicker
Naughty dog: I'm waiting for RDR
Rdr2 is definetly better but textures are way better on TLOU
for sure but tlou is on the PS5
Both are some of the best games I've ever played, but to me last of us wins in story just by a bit, it wins in graphics and it wins in gameplay. But considering rdr 2 is open world is very impressive
Definitely don’t win in gameplay
Tlou definitely doesn't win the story nor the gameplay.
Both masterpieces in their own right, and two of my top five favorite games I've ever played.
Rdr2 was released in 2018 … imagine how gta 6 would be
The fire burning on top of the water in the last of us makes sense when you really think about because the water in the game would be very polluted
Maybe the last of us part 5 can be comparable with rdr2 no offense for naughty dog but rdr 2 is just from another world
Game Best tried to scam me
ruclips.net/video/HYHnniWuiJo/видео.html
fax
I think tlou has way better graphics
@@enxgma8085 graphic in rdr2 is more realistic
@@enxgma8085 nah
Both great. Can't wait for last of us part III
Can't wait for gta 6
@@Alex-bs5sd Oh yay, another generic crime simulator with a bland story. They should have spent their resources on a new Bully game.