Vaganova method doesn't say cambré. Neither count 1 to 8 as you did, and the second port de bras is not like that. Wonder have you even read Vaganova's book ?
Vaganova's book is not a complete method for pedagogy and even she said that her method, as with any method based in science, can and will evolve with time.
@@AllieHutchins of course, but she clearly hasn't been taught by a St. Petersburg teacher, so at least read her book... It's impossible to perfectly understand the technique without correct demonstration and explanation live from dancers and teachers of Russia, but if you at least read her book, you don't make such big mistakes...
Hmmm, it doesn't matter which syllabus you teach necessarily, important is HOW. Students will always copy their teacher, good and bad. Notice the port de bras, even the assistant is copying the teacher's arms exactly, dropped elbows, and moving from the wrists etc..pause @5:11 for a 2nd position of the arms cringe-fest!
Спорт
Beautifully taught. How nice to have access to this. Thank you.
Thank you very much for posting this video. Very useful material and beautiful demo.
Amazing!
I'm going to order your book by mail
Thank you!
Me encanto esta clase!!❤
Graciasss
veraaaaaaaaaa1111!!!
4:44
Hm.... Vera is in my class 😂
Vaganova method doesn't say cambré. Neither count 1 to 8 as you did, and the second port de bras is not like that. Wonder have you even read Vaganova's book ?
The first version is Vaganova's book and is correct. I have the book in front of me right now.
FYI the first version is exactly Vaganova's book. I have right now in front of me the book!
Vaganova's book is not a complete method for pedagogy and even she said that her method, as with any method based in science, can and will evolve with time.
@@AllieHutchins of course, but she clearly hasn't been taught by a St. Petersburg teacher, so at least read her book... It's impossible to perfectly understand the technique without correct demonstration and explanation live from dancers and teachers of Russia, but if you at least read her book, you don't make such big mistakes...
Hmmm, it doesn't matter which syllabus you teach necessarily, important is HOW. Students will always copy their teacher, good and bad. Notice the port de bras, even the assistant is copying the teacher's arms exactly, dropped elbows, and moving from the wrists etc..pause @5:11 for a 2nd position of the arms cringe-fest!
Oh.mein Gott, die Lehrerin soll unbedingt alle port-de-bras noch mal nach dem Vaganova Buch erfrischen! Es gibt in jedem port-de-bras groben Fehler!