God the tone is insanely different. High honour (which is the only way I can ever play) this moment feels like the last bit of calm and hope before the final battle, but here it feels like the world is closing in on Arthur and that there's no choice but to ride down that trail. Either way he's going to his death, but the fact the player gets to choose how this deeply intimate moment feels, is so cool!!! God this game is amazing!!!!
Both versions are beautiful (and sad) especially when you consider the lyrics in the context of the story. The whole story is pretty sad after they get back from Guarma. I’m totally with you on playing as a good guy. I always finish with high honor. It makes the game generally easier to play when you save money on stuff and aren’t constantly paying off bounties.
DecayGamer outlaw’s basically escape from the law and are fugitives, whereas criminals break the law without a sense of right from wrong. You can be an outlaw trying to steal from the rich and give to the poor, and try to commit good acts just like Arthur does when you play the game with high honour, so technically it’s slightly different from being a criminal.
This final ride makes the player feel bad about what they’ve done, and that their path will never change. Their ending will be brutal and unforgiving, as they have been for their playthrough. It’s like the game is saying... “You’ve had your fun. You’ve killed so many innocent people. You made others suffer, now you will suffer.”
@Angad Menon well congratulations dude that's the point of the game REDEMPTION... I kind of was always honorable though I never really got to bad honor well excluding online lol
Rainzzx but that doesn’t make sense because when you have low honor all Arthur cares about is money but with high honor all he talks about is helping marston
Senpai kun wait, if your honor is just low enough to get that bad horse ride cutscene, could the going with John option that gives honor possibly give younthe sun ending?
The best part of the Low Honot last ride is the sense of fear and the dread it transmits. In the High Honor version, Arthur accepts his fate and is like "Ok, things are the way they are, there is nothing I can do to change them, at least I'm gonna go out with a good act". The Low Honor, instead, is just full of dread; he knows he was a bad man and he is terrified at the thought he is gonna die in a bad way.
No, man. I played with High honor and the only feeling I had was “I did my best to be a good man, why should I face such fate”. It’s really terrible to understand that there is no escape and everything you did had no meaning as the result
The worst part is either path you pick it’s sad. Either way Arthur is terrified and cannot accept that he’ll die. He’s scared. That’s why high honor makes the most sense in the end. It’s his Redemption.
At this point, in the end all he wanted to redeem himself by saving John Marston, that’s all that matters to him now. Unless he is low honor in which this case is apparent.
@@16yearsago825 for me it’s “There ain’t nothing’ left, Mister!” At the end of the low honor, after all that money I stole and the pleasure of torturing and killing, there was nothing left but emptiness. Arthur was going to die alone and with nothing to show for his life. Nothin left. It was over. Truly haunting for a first time low honor play through.
There is a difference on which Dutch viewed his gang. He thought of himself as protesting against the old American corruption and tried through illegal actions make him appear as the "savior" of sorts while in reality Dutch and his gang only cared about themselves, about their selfish desires and greed. That's ehy he says: "We are not criminals". He doesn't view himself as a criminal but as someone who wants to start a change: "We are outlaws".
Dutch : were not criminals The 230 dead o driscos , colm , cronwall ,milton catherine braithwait ,angelo bronte .will dis agree. And this is with HIGH HONOR! If i write my play through With low honor ...oh shit! Im gonna be here all day😂
"My Pa used to say when you stare in the fire long enough,you can see the whole world pass by."-Hosea Mathews "We are not criminals.We are outlaws."-Dutch Van Der Linde
This (low honor) version you feel the weight of the world closing in on you as the guilt over your horrible actions begins to suffocate you.. The High Honor version you feel the weight of the world lifting from your shoulders in a moment of levity as you head to the inevitable confrontation to finally do what's right.
Yeah, the high honor has a beautiful and majestic tone to it. While low honor might not make us all cry but it definitely will leave us all emotionless and thinking to ourselves that whatever comes to us now, we deserve it.
@@mr.hangman9708 I don't blame you bc i feel its the canon choice Arthur made. If i was Arthur and someone threaten that he saw me in Blackwater i wouldn't want to take risks letting him live.
I got low honor but so close to good but it still the low honor but after i choose to help john it gave me a high honor ending because on low honor its raining but when you have high honor its not
@@danish1650 Thats honestly the best way to end the game, considering helping john serves as a redeeming moment for arthur after everything seemed hopeless
This one makes you a hell of a lot more regretful and makes you reflect on your actions, whereas the good one makes you much more emotional as you try to be the good guy but still suffer a horrible fate.
@@creepquest no it right high honor is depression because even though you did good you still gonna die and Not be with mary. Low honor : regreted because ypu did a lot of bad shit and NEVER REDEM YOURSELF Like me i NEVER help Thomas wife she still a prostitute on my playthrough , i Never did mary missions , i sold penelope gift from beu and wend penelope ask for a favor on the letter never went to rhodes, i said no to charles on helping rain falls
@@cameronwhitemusic6 Firstly, Arthur is his real name. Beatrice met Lyle and had a baby, (in 1863) and named him Arthur. She died while he was very little, but Arthur's father died in 1874, which means that Arthur's father died when he was 11. It seems a long time to be without a name, especially since his parents' last names are also morgan.
Ngl i heard “shine right into darkness” different every ending he could be saying to Arthur with high honor “shine right into darkness” with low honor it sounds more like “shine light into darkness” as if he is talking to someone else telling them that they are the hero and Arthur is the darkness
Bad Honor it feels like you have so much to do in this world... but you can't and now you must pay for your action. You deserve all of this. High Honor it feels like you make mistakes but you try to the end to redempt yourself and this is the last thing that you can do before the end and you are at peace with you. Amazing.
I just cant bring myself to get the Low Honor ending. I cant allow Micah to kill Arthur, I Can't ignore Ms .Dowes. I cant ignore the Widow north of Annesburg. I need to help Penelope and Bo escape. I just *CAN'T* let Arthur die a bad man
penelope is bad tho. if you bring her to her crazy cousin she would make excuses and lie about helping her which arthur responds with sarcasm "sure you will.. goddamn"
Man its so sad to hear that quote from hosea.... Makes me cry. He said "My pa used to say if you stare into the campfire long enough you can see the whole world pass by" and just seeing Hosea passed away is so sad because he was such an inspiring character
The low honour version ending is the only one I ever knew until I came to RUclips, I finished RDR2 the first time 4 years ago on low honour, this version and ending brought me to tears when I first experienced it. What a game, it should be turned into a Netflix or Stan series.
It blows my mind how the ending is virtually the same. You get chased out, up the hill with john, and die on the mountain from TB and Micah's fight. Yet the tone of this scene determines the feelings the player gets in that moment. With low honor, it's depressing, hopeless, and in a way, poetic in the way that you experience an ending that allows you to watch a man that has been brutal and evil die in a brutal and evil way. The world is better off with Arthur's death in a lpw honor playthrough. With high honor he dies in mostly the same way, beaten and bruised and sick after his fight with Micah, but he does so with a sense of pride, saddness, and a longing for things to be different due to the love you feel for the character. Absolutely a masterclass of storytelling.
I've recently completed with low honor, and on my ride you could also hear hosea say "You damn us all!" Which I think he said to Dutch or Arthur when Arthur agrees with Dutch to take revenge on either Angelo Bronthe, or do one of the heists in Saint Denis. I cant remember now
Arthur looks serious throughout the ride but we know the song is how he feels and the quotes are what he remembers most. The only quote in the low honor version to not really talk about Arthur and what he has done is what Hosea said, "My pa used to say if you stare into the fire long enough you can see the whole world pass by."
My first playthrough was low honor i never got one wave of emotional energy in this whatsoever as I love this emotional detachment I felt for low honor, it felt like Arthur is more of a man of action not emotion and it’s very cold and I love it as it genuinely feels like the old west outlaw rather than being a romanticised, petty and poetic villain on a sudden and desperate redemption mission despite killing hundreds or even thousands of people in the past and countless robberies. In my opinion it shows the level of disillusionment and how foolish people are and how willing people are to see the good in folk, even if they’re truly ruthless and demented monsters.
I remember the first time I played Red dead Redemption 2 I had low honour throughout the most of the game I was an arsehole I stole from innocent people and murdered even more but after I got diagnosed with TB i changed I stopped robbing and killing and helped anyone I could I think this game is a very good way to showcase someone’s personality and what they are really like.
It really is I killed and then I started feeling guilty so I got high honor. I know it’s just a game but rockstar did a good job showcasing psychological behavior. Some like myself can’t help but be good, while others have to turn good, and lastly you have those who will never be good. Like you said this game caters towards the players personality.
When I first played it through, when the person is begging "I have a family!" Arthur's voice came in with "You act like killing is something I care about".
This version is cold and haunted compared to high honor. Idk, I think both high and low endings are cool. Very different. High honor is soothing. Arthur rides to camp knowing he did all he could and is at peace with himself. But here I can hear villain at the death doorstep. He's doing the last good thing but he's still a villain. His final choice won't change things. It's cool.
High honor he's content for what he knows is about to happen to him, so he's going back to try to save whomever can still be saved as a final good deed. Low honor he feels the crashing world tearing him down, and the only goal left for him is to take Micah down with him. Also I'm sad Hosea only has a line in the low honor ride.
Man....I just... It's hard to believe this is a low honor version because it honestly doesn't feel like it. Like the music feels so damn peaceful and comforting despite the reminders of what Arthur's done
When i played this game had i low honor right to the end. Just before the final missions, brought the honor bar slighy over mid way. The high honor ending broke me.
This was the last ride/ending I got first time and I have no regrets. I was a cold killer and stayed true to going after the money, this theme was perfect to sum that up.
“You can’t exactly beat it out of him now can you?” This hits harder. It shows that Arthur was realizing just how awful of a man he had became just to help and protect the gang. It shows just how realistic and genuine this game is. Your actions have consequences. You don’t just do bad things and get rewarded. Just like on this last ride. Arthur was a bad man and couldn’t change. He shall now pay the price.
The many miles we walked The many things we learned The building of the shrine Only just to burn That's the way it is That's the way it is May the wind be at your back Good fortune touch your hand May the cards lay out a straight All from your commands That's the way it is That's the way it is Shine light into darkness Shine light into darkness
I actually prefer the low honor ending to high honor, and helping John as a last ditch effort to regain some redemption. It feels like a true reflection of who Arthur really is - a ruthless outlaw and killer who harmed more people than he had helped. The sombre music with melancholic undertones sounds foreboding, signifying his brutal impending death, as he broods on all of the innocent folk he had wronged during his life. Arthur died savagely at the hands of Micah by either getting shot in the head execution style, or having a knife stuck in his back. That seems like more of a fitting end for someone like Arthur - he died brutally by the guy who orchestrated the destruction of the gang. Like Agent Milton said, "You people venerate savagery and you will die savagely. All of you." Speaks true.
During the last ride I couldn’t help but realize that even if it weren’t for this mission Arthur would’ve died from his sickness anyways at some point it was fate Miss playing as him 🔥
Me on my way to school with 6 exams in one day knowing damn well I didn't revise for a single one
Let's go I got pinned comment
@@louiszinn5547 I felt the same way.
@Track Nation same lmao but I finished school now just waiting for my results
@Track Nation don't blame you 😂
@Louis Zinn ikr!! The hairs on my arm stand every time I hear it
A moment of silence for the rdr1 fans that died before rdr2 came out
Such... A tragic fate!
Pay respects
never thought about that.
I always try to forget it but,I can’t,you can be depressed so easily if you really think about those kind of things.
F
The low honor version really makes you feel the gravity of your actions throughout the game, god it’s been nearly 2 years and it still gets me.
Yeah 2 years but still it feels like now and gives me chills
Everytime I replay the game I try to get the low honor ending but I can't commit to it
Ive been a bad boah
It’s the true ending honestly
Well gravity is a hard thing to fight after all
Man the bad honor ride just gives you the shivers! It’s sounds like hells music!
Exactly. It feels like it should be normal but everything is drained down from the music and the visuals. It's creepy in some ways and sad in others
Max Alaska I absolutely hate it in every way possible because it scares me SO much. Insanely chilling.
True horror is real horror
Cokeysmoke23 yeah
And little bit creepy
God the tone is insanely different. High honour (which is the only way I can ever play) this moment feels like the last bit of calm and hope before the final battle, but here it feels like the world is closing in on Arthur and that there's no choice but to ride down that trail. Either way he's going to his death, but the fact the player gets to choose how this deeply intimate moment feels, is so cool!!! God this game is amazing!!!!
I like Music i used to play high honor easily.
Until I met the incredible people of Van Horn and Butcher’s Creek
Both versions are beautiful (and sad) especially when you consider the lyrics in the context of the story. The whole story is pretty sad after they get back from Guarma. I’m totally with you on playing as a good guy. I always finish with high honor. It makes the game generally easier to play when you save money on stuff and aren’t constantly paying off bounties.
@@ima_psykopathpsn8411 lmao
High honer for me never got low
It's... Desperate.
" We are not criminals we are outlaws "
Nicholas Mattedi “there’s a difference?” 😭
Javier escuella
We are not outlaws we are criminals
DecayGamer outlaw’s basically escape from the law and are fugitives, whereas criminals break the law without a sense of right from wrong. You can be an outlaw trying to steal from the rich and give to the poor, and try to commit good acts just like Arthur does when you play the game with high honour, so technically it’s slightly different from being a criminal.
*There's a difference?*
This final ride makes the player feel bad about what they’ve done, and that their path will never change. Their ending will be brutal and unforgiving, as they have been for their playthrough. It’s like the game is saying... “You’ve had your fun. You’ve killed so many innocent people. You made others suffer, now you will suffer.”
@Angad Menon well congratulations dude that's the point of the game REDEMPTION... I kind of was always honorable though I never really got to bad honor well excluding online lol
@Angad Menon yeah I agree
The TRUE endings are this: Help John- Low Honor, Go back for the Money- High Honor, because y else would John go after Micah?
Rainzzx but that doesn’t make sense because when you have low honor all Arthur cares about is money but with high honor all he talks about is helping marston
Senpai kun wait, if your honor is just low enough to get that bad horse ride cutscene, could the going with John option that gives honor possibly give younthe sun ending?
The best part of the Low Honot last ride is the sense of fear and the dread it transmits.
In the High Honor version, Arthur accepts his fate and is like "Ok, things are the way they are, there is nothing I can do to change them, at least I'm gonna go out with a good act".
The Low Honor, instead, is just full of dread; he knows he was a bad man and he is terrified at the thought he is gonna die in a bad way.
No, man. I played with High honor and the only feeling I had was “I did my best to be a good man, why should I face such fate”. It’s really terrible to understand that there is no escape and everything you did had no meaning as the result
@Garland846 no, the player. I really felt interlinked with Arthur at this moment
The music at the end of the ride is different as well my fav part typically is the lil harmonica but instead we get a sinister noise lol
The worst part is either path you pick it’s sad. Either way Arthur is terrified and cannot accept that he’ll die. He’s scared. That’s why high honor makes the most sense in the end. It’s his Redemption.
Hoseas line is one of the best in the series
You stare into the fire long enough you can see the whole world pass by
I just don't want anymore folks to die Dutch.
"Sad thing is good people do bad things"
*Hello fellers*
@@TacitusKilgore347 hello Arthur
You can’t expect to live a bad life and have good things happen to you - Arthur Morgan
At this point, in the end all he wanted to redeem himself by saving John Marston, that’s all that matters to him now. Unless he is low honor in which this case is apparent.
Wow....The moment
-"We are not criminals.....we are outlaws" Gave me so much chills omg
For me was “you can’t beat the hell out of him now do you?”
@@16yearsago825 for me it’s “There ain’t nothing’ left, Mister!”
At the end of the low honor, after all that money I stole and the pleasure of torturing and killing, there was nothing left but emptiness. Arthur was going to die alone and with nothing to show for his life. Nothin left. It was over. Truly haunting for a first time low honor play through.
Dutch: We are not criminals, we are outlaws.
That just made me sad
There is a difference on which Dutch viewed his gang. He thought of himself as protesting against the old American corruption and tried through illegal actions make him appear as the "savior" of sorts while in reality Dutch and his gang only cared about themselves, about their selfish desires and greed. That's ehy he says: "We are not criminals". He doesn't view himself as a criminal but as someone who wants to start a change: "We are outlaws".
Don’t be an out law look at the massacre you can leave behind you
My take on this line is that Arthur realised they were criminals and murderers all along
Dutch : were not criminals
The 230 dead o driscos , colm , cronwall ,milton catherine braithwait ,angelo bronte .will dis agree. And this is with HIGH HONOR! If i write my play through With low honor ...oh shit! Im gonna be here all day😂
The low honor has synth while high honor is more acoustic.
High honor version is like Hurt cover by Johnny Cash, low honor song is the original one
The Gooseman that’s a good way of putting it
@@TheGooseman14 Hurt by Johnny Cash is a cover.
The original is by Nine Inch Nails.
I just wanted to feed my ego.
My ego feels good now.
I'm tired !
@@jaxthedisintegrator8096 hey bud I think you read that wrong, I said that cash version of hurt was a cover
The high honor ride makes his last words hit so much harder.
“I tried, in the end I did.”
"My Pa used to say when you stare in the fire long enough,you can see the whole world pass by."-Hosea Mathews "We are not criminals.We are outlaws."-Dutch Van Der Linde
I wish they had included Hosea and Dutch's dialogues in the High Honor ride 😕
Played with both honours but the low honour ending felt like world coming to an end. It was more tragic.
yeah bad honor hits super hard, jsut finished 2nd playthrough with high honro and it was good. but bad honor is best for first playthrough.
Yeah wend i reach chapter 6 gonna go to saint denist and push GREAT GREAT GREAT GREAT DING! GREAT GREAT GREAT DING!
This version really makes the player feel guilty.
@@Kvs-vf9nt Wow you're tough
I don't care you should get some therapy I don’t know if you mean this in terms of depression or sociopathy but either way it doesn’t sound good
@@Kvs-vf9nt bro please get help immediately, for the sake of others.
Never got this ending so im glad
@@tastycookiechip What did they comment
When you hear Micah’s voice in the final ride that’s how you know you’ve been a bad boy
There's a big picture here morgan
The high honour one was an absolute tear jerker
Yep
This one makes you fell guilty
This (low honor) version you feel the weight of the world closing in on you as the guilt over your horrible actions begins to suffocate you..
The High Honor version you feel the weight of the world lifting from your shoulders in a moment of levity as you head to the inevitable confrontation to finally do what's right.
Yeah, the high honor has a beautiful and majestic tone to it.
While low honor might not make us all cry but it definitely will leave us all emotionless and thinking to ourselves that whatever comes to us now, we deserve it.
@@WanderingLoner1 low honor one hit me right in the feels hard for some reason lol
I see you saved Jimmy Brooks
If you don't save him and kill him you will hear him say "I made a mistake I'm sorry!"
I thought its Lenny
lol i accidently pressed the drop button
@@mr.hangman9708 based
@@mr.hangman9708 I don't blame you bc i feel its the canon choice Arthur made. If i was Arthur and someone threaten that he saw me in Blackwater i wouldn't want to take risks letting him live.
I accidentally shot him.
It feels wrong playing with low honor, but the low honor version of this is just phenomenal.
My honor was just a little bit near good so I got a mixture of the dialogue which is really neat
I got low honor but so close to good but it still the low honor but after i choose to help john it gave me a high honor ending because on low honor its raining but when you have high honor its not
Oh what version of the song did you get
@@robertcampbell3019 he had more good honor than bad honor, like he said, so the high honor version likely played.
@@danish1650 Thats honestly the best way to end the game, considering helping john serves as a redeeming moment for arthur after everything seemed hopeless
1:17 "I see clearly that you world, is not a world for which one can escape"
Those words have remained very present in my memory.
This one makes you a hell of a lot more regretful and makes you reflect on your actions, whereas the good one makes you much more emotional as you try to be the good guy but still suffer a horrible fate.
Low Honor: *Regret*
High Honor: *Depression*
I feel like it's the other way around
@@creepquest no it right high honor is depression because even though you did good you still gonna die and Not be with mary.
Low honor : regreted because ypu did a lot of bad shit and NEVER REDEM YOURSELF
Like me i NEVER help Thomas wife she still a prostitute on my playthrough , i Never did mary missions , i sold penelope gift from beu and wend penelope ask for a favor on the letter never went to rhodes, i said no to charles on helping rain falls
@@RaulitoTheAssassin yeah i think u r right. That's the reason Arthur thinks of the bad things he did when he rides back to camp
@@RaulitoTheAssassin taking Penelope's bracelet is considered a good choice in the game
You speak as if killing was something I cared about...
- Arthur Morgan 1863 To 1899
Arthur Morgan Rest In Peace Morgan
That's not the year he was born. He was orphaned and doesn't know his real name nor age.
@@cameronwhitemusic6 fr?
Dusty Productions yes him and John Marston although John Marston is his actual name except he doesn't know his real name
@@cameronwhitemusic6 Firstly,
Arthur is his real name. Beatrice met
Lyle and had a baby, (in 1863) and named him Arthur. She died while he was very little, but Arthur's father died in 1874, which means that Arthur's father died when he was 11. It seems a long time to be without a name, especially since his parents' last names are also morgan.
I had no idea there was a low honor version of this song
I mean i knew about the low honor May I stand unshaken
Ngl i heard “shine right into darkness” different every ending he could be saying to Arthur with high honor “shine right into darkness” with low honor it sounds more like “shine light into darkness” as if he is talking to someone else telling them that they are the hero and Arthur is the darkness
Arthur is not in the darkness he is the darkness
I thought it was shine bright into darkness
Bad Honor it feels like you have so much to do in this world... but you can't and now you must pay for your action. You deserve all of this.
High Honor it feels like you make mistakes but you try to the end to redempt yourself and this is the last thing that you can do before the end and you are at peace with you.
Amazing.
Yes this is it, good one
"My pa use to say you stare in to the fire long enough you see the world go by"
It’s true too
I just cant bring myself to get the Low Honor ending. I cant allow Micah to kill Arthur, I Can't ignore Ms .Dowes. I cant ignore the Widow north of Annesburg. I need to help Penelope and Bo escape. I just *CAN'T* let Arthur die a bad man
I can
@@humanbeing478I'm doing it as well.
penelope is bad tho. if you bring her to her crazy cousin she would make excuses and lie about helping her which arthur responds with sarcasm "sure you will.. goddamn"
I can ignored mary linton 😂 bitch is allways asking for a favor
I can and I did
Man its so sad to hear that quote from hosea.... Makes me cry. He said "My pa used to say if you stare into the campfire long enough you can see the whole world pass by" and just seeing Hosea passed away is so sad because he was such an inspiring character
Wow… this game teaches me that does not matter what you do in life,you can always find redemption.
Redemption? Sure
Forgiveness? Never
I feel like this version is arthur accepting he is a bad man, but he's going to do one final good act.
The low honour version ending is the only one I ever knew until I came to RUclips, I finished RDR2 the first time 4 years ago on low honour, this version and ending brought me to tears when I first experienced it. What a game, it should be turned into a Netflix or Stan series.
It blows my mind how the ending is virtually the same. You get chased out, up the hill with john, and die on the mountain from TB and Micah's fight. Yet the tone of this scene determines the feelings the player gets in that moment. With low honor, it's depressing, hopeless, and in a way, poetic in the way that you experience an ending that allows you to watch a man that has been brutal and evil die in a brutal and evil way. The world is better off with Arthur's death in a lpw honor playthrough. With high honor he dies in mostly the same way, beaten and bruised and sick after his fight with Micah, but he does so with a sense of pride, saddness, and a longing for things to be different due to the love you feel for the character. Absolutely a masterclass of storytelling.
This music is just told u that ur a lil bit closer to hell it's just so frightening.
" We are not Criminals"
" We are Outlaws"
hoseas line.. i miss him so much.
POV your leaving school for the last time and your the quet kid
This song is that much better just hearing Arthur's horse in the background.
I still cried at this moment even though he had low honor
Эта концовка доводит до слез, всегда становится жаль Артура, даже с плохой честью
The intro to the low honour gets me everytime
Which part? It’s the outro that does it for me. The harmonica is my fav part in high honor and here we get a very dooming noise instead 😂 so well made
Me walking home from school getting ready to suffer the consequences for acting up knowing my mom is home
He looks like he regrets doing the bad stuff and being low honor.
Eerie, dark and grey. Signs of a man who never changed and chose the path of darkness.
Who else almost cried when you got to this part
I did cry
I did not cause I got the high honor one I cried then I got the low honor one and felt guilty for killing the man from black water on accident
Almost? I broke down
This version is literally Arthur riding to his execution.
Low honor ending: “The muneh miles we walked..”
My pa used to say you stare into the fire long enough you can see the whole world pass by. Damn
I've recently completed with low honor, and on my ride you could also hear hosea say "You damn us all!" Which I think he said to Dutch or Arthur when Arthur agrees with Dutch to take revenge on either Angelo Bronthe, or do one of the heists in Saint Denis. I cant remember now
He says to Dutch when he decides to get his revenge on Bronte.
İt will be my last words before die: My Pa used to say if you stare into the fire long enough, you can see the whole world pass by
How the hell Arthur has Otis Miller revolver???
Bug on Chapter 4 where you can go in New Austin as Arthur.
Replaying missions as John uses John's honor and weapons
@@seilepigon4913 but if you replay a mission it arthur will wear the gunslinger clothes
Arthur looks serious throughout the ride but we know the song is how he feels and the quotes are what he remembers most. The only quote in the low honor version to not really talk about Arthur and what he has done is what Hosea said, "My pa used to say if you stare into the fire long enough you can see the whole world pass by."
i just realized this played but i got high honor ending by helping john
My first playthrough was low honor i never got one wave of emotional energy in this whatsoever as I love this emotional detachment I felt for low honor, it felt like Arthur is more of a man of action not emotion and it’s very cold and I love it as it genuinely feels like the old west outlaw rather than being a romanticised, petty and poetic villain on a sudden and desperate redemption mission despite killing hundreds or even thousands of people in the past and countless robberies. In my opinion it shows the level of disillusionment and how foolish people are and how willing people are to see the good in folk, even if they’re truly ruthless and demented monsters.
a sick man that couldn't attain redemption
That's the way it is.
@@Kamal_AL-Hinai indeed
"DAWWWGAHHHGH" - Hosea Matthews, 1899
That sad overlay soundtrack just shatters my heart to tiny pieces. I'll never recover from this story.
This music is so cold-blooded
Though it never really seemed like it, Mr. Downes was a really important character In the game
I remember the first time I played Red dead Redemption 2 I had low honour throughout the most of the game I was an arsehole I stole from innocent people and murdered even more but after I got diagnosed with TB i changed I stopped robbing and killing and helped anyone I could I think this game is a very good way to showcase someone’s personality and what they are really like.
It really is I killed and then I started feeling guilty so I got high honor. I know it’s just a game but rockstar did a good job showcasing psychological behavior. Some like myself can’t help but be good, while others have to turn good, and lastly you have those who will never be good. Like you said this game caters towards the players personality.
I usually control my intrusive thoughts until I get to the epilogue then I just go absolutely crazy as John. 😭
who else got chills when Hosea said "My father said if you look into the fire long enough you can see the whole world go by"
When I first played it through, when the person is begging "I have a family!" Arthur's voice came in with "You act like killing is something I care about".
The biggest loss in the gang was losing hosea
My pa used to say when you stared at the fire long enough you can see the whole world pass by - hosea Matthews
The high honour music gives you relief and this music gives you regret
So glad that I made Arthur a good man with high honor.
Arthur is the best video game protagonist that even the hair on my body stand up for him.
This version is cold and haunted compared to high honor. Idk, I think both high and low endings are cool. Very different.
High honor is soothing. Arthur rides to camp knowing he did all he could and is at peace with himself.
But here I can hear villain at the death doorstep. He's doing the last good thing but he's still a villain. His final choice won't change things. It's cool.
High honor he's content for what he knows is about to happen to him, so he's going back to try to save whomever can still be saved as a final good deed.
Low honor he feels the crashing world tearing him down, and the only goal left for him is to take Micah down with him.
Also I'm sad Hosea only has a line in the low honor ride.
The ray of light coming from the sun is so gorgeus in this game. They really gave their best efforts in this game.
God what a masterpiece the way it makes you feel is such a feeling that I can never explain
Man....I just... It's hard to believe this is a low honor version because it honestly doesn't feel like it. Like the music feels so damn peaceful and comforting despite the reminders of what Arthur's done
My pa used to say. You stare into the fire long enough you can see the whole world in it . God I miss you Hosea
When i played this game had i low honor right to the end. Just before the final missions, brought the honor bar slighy over mid way. The high honor ending broke me.
This scene made me cry
This was the last ride/ending I got first time and I have no regrets.
I was a cold killer and stayed true to going after the money, this theme was perfect to sum that up.
Imo the low honor quotes are more impactful than the high honor quotes.
i only like the part where the one guy says "my pa use to say if you stare in the fire long enough, you can see the whole world pass by."
it was Hosea
the line that said shine light into darkness makes so much more sence in bad honor version
There's a biiig picture here Arthur.
T R U S T ME
damn i cried cause i had a feeling that he was gonna die
Arthur: My life for Marston
This was me. Even saving John at the end wasn't enough to avoid the bad ending
this game deserve an oscar
“You can’t exactly beat it out of him now can you?” This hits harder. It shows that Arthur was realizing just how awful of a man he had became just to help and protect the gang. It shows just how realistic and genuine this game is. Your actions have consequences. You don’t just do bad things and get rewarded. Just like on this last ride. Arthur was a bad man and couldn’t change. He shall now pay the price.
The many miles we walked
The many things we learned
The building of the shrine
Only just to burn
That's the way it is
That's the way it is
May the wind be at your back
Good fortune touch your hand
May the cards lay out a straight
All from your commands
That's the way it is
That's the way it is
Shine light into darkness
Shine light into darkness
This is so much more sadder than high honor
Low honor version of this song is awesome
Low honor thoughts:
Damn! Was I really that bad of a person
Shine darkness in the darkness.
I actually prefer the low honor ending to high honor, and helping John as a last ditch effort to regain some redemption. It feels like a true reflection of who Arthur really is - a ruthless outlaw and killer who harmed more people than he had helped. The sombre music with melancholic undertones sounds foreboding, signifying his brutal impending death, as he broods on all of the innocent folk he had wronged during his life. Arthur died savagely at the hands of Micah by either getting shot in the head execution style, or having a knife stuck in his back. That seems like more of a fitting end for someone like Arthur - he died brutally by the guy who orchestrated the destruction of the gang.
Like Agent Milton said, "You people venerate savagery and you will die savagely. All of you." Speaks true.
During the last ride I couldn’t help but realize that even if it weren’t for this mission Arthur would’ve died from his sickness anyways at some point it was fate
Miss playing as him 🔥
Why does arthur look like us when we go to school?
School is easy. Try getting yelled at for messing up or being responsible for people and equipment you have no interest in being in charge of.
And this is so much different, I would feel like shit if I had this
Imo this was sadder then his actual death
We are not criminals... We are outlaws.