H. G. Wells - Letter to James Joyce on Finnegans Wake (1928)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 янв 2025

Комментарии • 24

  • @mrdProf42
    @mrdProf42 12 дней назад +3

    Wow.

  • @victoriator8863
    @victoriator8863 10 дней назад

    Very true!

  • @dorianwalker1408
    @dorianwalker1408 9 дней назад +1

    Politics of suppression and politics of responsibility-they remain mighty delusions today!

  • @Digibeatle09
    @Digibeatle09 10 дней назад

    Here - in Ireland - at least in Dublin - we’ve no end of Joyceans - not improbable that some of them - on this cold, grey day in early January - have already begun counting down the days to June the 16th …… 🥸

  • @stuartlodge1959
    @stuartlodge1959 10 дней назад +1

    Is our friend Mr AI at play here?

    • @oskar5724
      @oskar5724  10 дней назад +2

      Two people think this is AI. Which is very worrying for the state of AI

    • @OsirusHandle
      @OsirusHandle 8 дней назад

      ​​@@oskar5724 Some are prophecising the internet will soon be so full of AI produce, creative, nonsensical, regurgitations and fabrications, that it will basically be useless and unnavigatable: Oskur and Oshar reading James Boyces view, on Timbuktu...
      Perhaps there is hope in an Internet 2.0?

  • @dustykashifeathers858
    @dustykashifeathers858 10 дней назад +1

    Joyce is concerned with elegance and history, lotsa history in that book of subliminal Dubliner dialect, though so funny to hear HG's take.

  • @PhileaSmog
    @PhileaSmog 12 дней назад +2

    That's strong tobacco.

  • @Hoots_Maguire
    @Hoots_Maguire 12 дней назад +3

    Harsh. Not wrong though.

    • @garyspence2128
      @garyspence2128 10 дней назад

      Succinct, candid, and yet respectful in that old-school British way. Would love to see if Joyce responded, and what he said. In the internet age, things would probably turn totally toxic and vicious. Although Wells would have been the one to actually imagine and predict such a future device. I still write letters to friends and family, which makes me a relic of the past. I enjoy that status!

    • @oskar5724
      @oskar5724  6 дней назад

      I don’t think he did, although I could be wrong. But he did send a copy of WIP to Wells as in the thumbnail in hope of a promo for FW (as he did unsuccessfully with Einstein), because I suppose Wells was the big (but also somewhat out there content-wise?) English writer of the day. I did think while reading this that it’s sad that very few contemporary writers will give rise to a ‘collected letters’ after their death. Perhaps not even a collected emails. Writers used to produce short but often intriguing texts that they might have imagined would circulate post-mortem in a way that most contemporary writers don’t.

  • @tufsoft1
    @tufsoft1 10 дней назад +1

    A pithy retort to modernism in general.

  • @selwynr
    @selwynr 10 дней назад

    Well, well, well, Wells is a brilliant but ultimately minor writer, artistically speaking. Joyce is the definition of a major writer, artistically speaking. Most days I would rather read Wells because of my restricted time. But oh gee, "the delusion of political suppression" is British arrogance at its most repulsive, despite the qualifying self-exposure and critique of British imperialism. But Wells could be quite repulsive at times, at others, a prophet. Good stuff. I imagine this was an AI voice.

    • @oskar5724
      @oskar5724  10 дней назад +2

      Yeah I’m definitely not on Wells side here. Although it’s an interesting forking path. I know I put on a hammy posh English accent but why do people think this is AI 😂

    • @goydivision
      @goydivision 9 дней назад +2

      @@oskar5724 They don't know the field from the cold steel rail maybe. Great reading !

    • @kensilverstone1656
      @kensilverstone1656 3 дня назад

      @@oskar5724 I find Wells to be elegant, clear and highly intelligent. I've never heard Joyce speak, but I doubt he could match Wells. Are Joyce's works among the best, i don't know. But Iwould guess that 99 percent of people don't know as well and never will.

    • @ccahill2322
      @ccahill2322 2 дня назад

      @@oskar5724 , And ,as always, when you come to a"forking path"-- take it! Or so said the infamous "Yogi."

    • @ccahill2322
      @ccahill2322 2 дня назад

      @@kensilverstone1656 , Yet you seem to "know" a lot about what you don't know so, in your own words, you seem to be with the 99 percent of don't knows. You are not, by chance, a "writer" are you?

  • @chullupa
    @chullupa 9 дней назад

    I I don't think think it's a a good good idea to