📺 New Episodes of Everything’s Been Done 🗓 Every Thursday at 1pm PST / 4pm EST / 9PM GMT 📡 EBD LIVE: 30 min before each weeks premiere: 12:30pm PST / 3:30pm EST / 8:30PM GMT 🤘Subscribe to GET RAD: bit.ly/Subscribe_to_EBD
I'm in Alaska. I have the 45 Nrth Japanther. They are very much like a cross between the Giro and Shimanos you reviewed. They have bomber lugs, a nice combo velco cuff and dry zip and they are good to 20 degrees. They have pull on heel loop and no other exterior do-dads to muck up so they hose off in a flash. I've had mine for 6 years and they are still in great shape. I give them an 11 out of 13 rating. Great video Dustin.
@@IowaNinersFan Not to mention having to start all over, endurance and muscle wise. Unless you have a cycling trainer at home, which I don't. As a dog person, I always found there to be not really bad weather, only wrong clothes. Now I cycle year round (to get to work and back) and for fun, MTB. Year round. I especially like freshly fallen snow in the forest. Makes a very nice sound.
@@IowaNinersFanI see your name is Iowa niners fan I grew up 30 years in council bluffs Iowa which is 10 minutes from Omaha Nebraska and I'm also a huge 49er fan since the Montana Jerry Rice days safe ride and dude 🤙🏻🤙🏻🤙🏻
I haven't seen anybody mention this: The zipper on the Giro isn't broken, it's a feature. Flap the little tab down and it locks up and pull it away from the zipper or up it unlock it. I really love those zippers.
I'm glad that I'm not the only one that struggles with shoe covers. Also, I finally discovered that if you put the shoe cover on FIRST, before the shoe, it's easier to pull them over the shoe after.
@@pierrex3226 No, you put the shoe cover on your ANKLE without the shoe. Then you put on the shoe, then you pull the cover down over the shoe. I dunno if this is common knowledge or what, but I always put on the shoe and then struggled to pull the cover over the shoe and it would take me ages and I'd rip the more delicate ones. I've been riding bikes for so long and I couldn't believe it'd taken me so many years and so many struggles to put them on like this. It's so much easier.
Yep I also came to this method through trials and tribulations. I use neoprene overshoes made by a company called Spatz - recommended by many seasoned UK cyclists. They do the job, keeps your feet dry and warm. But to get them on? Man alive if you manage it, you feel as if you need to knock out at least 150km to make the effort worthwhile. One things for sure you'll be properly warmed up before you leave for your ride.
I found the 45NRTH Japanther & Wolfhammer are bother waterproof, but not warm enough for more than an hour and a half. However, battery powered socks have made all the difference in length of my rides in New England
@@Smithandrossiter On the lowest setting I can easily ride 4 hours and me feet stay quite comfortable. I haven't gone beyond that because other parts get cold. For about $30 you can't go wrong.
Yip ! Total gamechanger. Winter shoe/boots work. Easy on/ off. Road and off road, 3 bolt and 2 bolt. No faffing with multiple socks, overshoes, baking foil😂. Can't believe I didn't do it sooner.
When zippers on shrouds are pointed up they’re not “locked” and can and will migrate but when you flip the zipper down it locks the zipper and it won’t migrate.
1:10 put the shoe cover up your ankle and stick your foot though the large shoe hole, put your shoe and tighten it, and then bring the cover down on your shoe. That's how you put shoe covers on without the hassle.
Great video! I committed year round for more then 10 years in and around Seattle and a good pair of winter shoes was a must have. It was many years ago and not a lot of options but the Lake i had a pair of shoes covers, if it was really Shitty worked well. I had a commute the 1990s the snow was so deep on the I90 floating bridge, I had to run the entire flat section and up the hill on Mercer Island! Cyclocross bike and a smile on my face!
those giros are literally just cross country ski boots. My carbonlite classic boots used the same lace style, shoe/cover design, and central zipper. Actually makes a lot of sense since xc ski boots also connect to the binding at the front and need to be relatively stiff, even the classic ones.
Also, if anyone out there needs a COLD weather boot, the Blivet Quilo is rated down to -18C (-4F). I have a pair because I used to live in Montreal and they really do work for the cold and snow.
45N Japanthers, Specialized Defrosters are both major league winter boots. Both warm, water-proof and comfy. Buy 1 full size larger than normal shoes for merino wool winter socks (riding in western mass, outside, all winter, commuted at 6:30am for 7 years). My older Shimanos were warm but not very waterproof. Also own a pair of Sidi "rain boots" which are great for keeping the wet out but not very warm. I've got mine, but if I was buying new now I'd buy the 45N Ragnorok or Japanther.
I have the previous version of the Shimano boot- MW701, they have a Michelin tread and look a lot grippier than the version reviewed here. These winter boots have been a complete game changer for my winter riding, and having some riding trousers that go over the ankle cuff makes a big difference.
I run the Shimano MW701. I add a Castelli toe cover and a toe warmers and I'm good for 4 hour rides at temperatures of -5 C to -10 C. The toe covers add wind and water resistance and the toe warmer makes good heat. I wear two pair of medium weight wool socks.
Waterproof socks over a pair of quality wool socks got me through 4 winters as an NYC bike courier. Only had to bust out the winter cycling shoes when it gets below freezing. ❄️
Love your sense of humor and how you present it! Plenty of appreciated giggling throughout the video! Keep It up dude. Oh, great reviews too! Yeah, and why 12?
The Giro would win for me just because it doesn't contain the pox that is BOA. There is also the Endura MT500 that is much like Giro. Another option is the Leatt 7.0 HydraDri that, construction wise, is the same as their normal shoes, but bathed in a waterproof cover. Also... There are other options, especially for those that have less PNW winters and more real winters. As someone that bikes through the winter in MN, I have some suggestions. The Blivet Sports Quilo boots (there are different types, all with the same name) are better than there 45NRTH counterparts. Just as warm, but slimmer in construction/feel. Also, recent 45NRTH offerings have been less durable than older offerings. The big thing to remember is that for cold weather, good wool socks are a must. Closer 100% wool the better.
Very good video. I like the openness and candor. With respect to the selling aspect of what you're doing. I tend to consider your opinions more as a result! Keep going. Also, yeah. I tend to buy one set of shoe covers every year so maybe I should be going for a dedicated winter shoe.
If you are riding consistently through the winter each year(sound like you are). You deserve some winter shoes(if budget allows). they really do make the difference.
Granted UK winters aren't THAT cold, but I've had my Grip Grab overshoes for four years. No zips to break and warm dry (ish) feet. Remember to put the tights over the shoe cover! So the water doesn't run into the shoes (as much).
Completely unrelated to the topic of this video, I saw your tire storage @2:25 and realized that I could just re-roll my folding bead tires instead of just jamming them in a tote or hooking them on nails around the garage.
Mad respect to the PNW winter riders. Cold rain is really difficult to dress appropriately for compared to riding in freezing temps and snow. I swear by my Bontrager OMW boots but I care more about insulation and having a removable liner over being 100% waterproof.
No it isnt. You wear actual rain gear. Rubber boots with flats. Its legs, lungs and heart that matters not pedals and shoes. Its never off season for me but it is for you so aero doesnt matter and neither does weight. If you work harder you're that much better off in the spring. So stop shoping like a pro racer and start shopping like a humble commuter. You will be far more comfortable and the money you save can probably pay for a week riding some where warm in the sun.
Pretty great video overall! Try increasing the final edit playback speed just slightly. It seems that for people who aren’t very experienced with narration - it helps smooth out the listening flow.
+1 for the Shimano’s. I run the older version in eastern Canada winter for commuting maximum 1h at a time and they’ve been great! After three years the top Velcro has died however and I had to improvise something to keep the top flap closed.
Dustin’s original winter shoe/boot shown is Lake’s MX145. Amazing product; these converted me to Lake. The new MX146 is even better, and Lake also makes two models to step up/down to cover sub-zero conditions. I use the MX146 down to around -5C.
Winter riding shoes have a big problem - they have a big hole in the top, which lets in water. Water runs down your legs into your boots. Once your feet are wet they are toast. Not warm toast, I mean cold and frigid, which ruins your ride. What you need are neoprene cuffs which clamp the leg and overlaps the top of the boot. Viola, no water runs down your legs into the boot. Winter boots need cuff supplementation when water is around.
My best recent purchase, BlueTooth Li battery heated socks! I still use antiperspirant (Mnt climbing trick) & usually shoe covers as Winter cycling shoes can be hard to fit layers of socks.
after 40 years of cycling and many years commuting to work in winter the toe covers do not provide enough protection from the wind. The toe covers also do not keep your feet from getting wet in wet snow and rain. situation is the decider of what you need. I used full covers that zipped on the side and were gortex with leather bottoms i still have them after 20 years
Great video, I have the Giro blaze and wanted to love them but i find them so tight round the ankle that bottom of my shin above the ankle became very painful. Also the slide fastener works well but has to fit under the cover which is very tight making the zip hard to close. I also have the 45north Ragnarock and the only issue has been the boa system which is not great and i have had to replace twice so far. Keep going back to my old Shimano MW80’s. So try on carefully before you buy.
Here I am in South Texas and I have not worn shoe covers yet this season. I did wear wool socks one day because I had them. So why am I watching this? Because it DK and DK you are entertaining. Thanks for the video.
I like the design of the Giro shoes. Agree on the Gore rain pants, work great for me. For my flat pedal brethren, I like the Five Ten Freerider EPS mid flat shoes. Nice fit, insulated, and a bit more substantial than regular Freeriders. Have been on rides recently with those in temps low 20’s F. Still use shoe covers for wetness and added warmth, and neoprene toe caps are ideal to keep my toe beans warm.
It’s crazy when people question my choice of getting winter riding shoes, both for gravel and road versions. When I was noob, id burn thru a set of full and toe covers every season at least…I have a pair of Shimano Goretex SPD winter boots and a pair of Lake roadie boots for almost 6 years now and they have held up great, and go on super easy, and have never failed to keep my feet dry and warm.
Couldnt agree more with winter shoes being a game changer in my cycling. Always hated those over booties. Sometimes I'd give up a ride just to the thought of putting those on. I have the shimano one. Very nice shoe. Can't comment on the others. For some reason, it is very hard to find (don't even know if you can) the regular version of the shoe. I could only find the wide version. I just do what the video says, I use a ticker sock. It works, but not necessarily ideal.
1:36 I even think that while winter cycling the shoes and gloves are more important because unlike anything else they don’t really get hot as they don’t really move enough. I got my first boots a few years ago and I never looked back
Riding in Scotland I guess qualifies as 'west coast weather' - hovering around freezing and very wet. I have really poor circulation to my hands and feet and hated winter riding until I got a pair of Giro Blaze a couple of years ago (I wear a Giro shoe in the summer too). I went up a size so I can wear thicker socks without cutting off the circulation and I almost always wear neoprene over-shoes as well. I still get cold feet but not painfully so. They have let the water in on occasion so the overshoe comes in very handy (and keeps the shoe cleaner). I've never had a problem with the zip slipping because it folds down and locks.
Since this video I bought and tested the Giro Blaze shoes, and I am very satisfied. Just be mindful that you need at the very least one size bigger than what you usually use, that it fits easily on narrow feet, and the closing of the zips is really tight above the ankle. The waterproofing is very good, went through ponds of mud and water, generously dipping the shoes under the water, feet remained perfectly dry (do not immerge the feet higher than the top of the shoes though 😅). I've not had temperatures below 4°C (but with humid/rainy weather) and did not felt cold. Not sure how they handle colder weather but where I live, it also means dryer weather so... I am confident it will be enough for my place.
ONLY if I wear too bulky of a sock... but, I find that a thin, summer weight sock in this shoe-down to high 30s degrees-works great and the shoe provides enough warmth.@@evanm.2300
Aces! Good shoulder season gear. Now… could you do one that’s for real winter for those of us with real winter - aka the North, aka maybe fat biking shoes? You said -4C ‘no thanks’ but that’s where the fun begins up here in Canada in the winter. Great review! And my god… comedy! Love it!
I have been using a pair of neoprene shoe covers from Performance for well over 10 years. Get them oversized. I have winter shoes but they are too heavy. I found slightly larger shoes with shoe covers warmer than winter shoes. Winter shoes have thicker soles which is their big plus. The soles are where you lose all your heat.
8:20 That Lake outsole and the layout of the upper makes me think that they let Lake or their contracting factory produce the shoe. Also one plus for overshoes it that there is no change in cleat location or height. My winter boots are from a different company than my normal mtb shoes and the slight difference in foot position drives my OCD nuts
ah good for you. I'm having big problem finding a shoe that would fit me. Sadly big foot here. Shimano doesn't do the same size range for winter shoes as they do for summer ones
Tell me about it I'm a size 50 and you have to get whatever there is going lake do their winter range in a 49-50 i managed to snag some sidi gore frost 2's on sale in a 50 good luck 🤞
@@zedddddful ok went forward and got northwave Celsius XC Arctic GTX thanks for the inspiration (just did the math calculation looking at my shimano shoes and how long was the insert)
here just for curiosity. where i live, winters have been coming much dryer and hotter in the last 15/20 years, from having ocasional snow and not uncommon heavy rains, to 2 days under 0° last winter. i've just discarded some old waterproof shoe covers that were rotting in the garage. so 0 snow, almost 0 mud, a few drops of rain. the dust on the other side.... i feel i'm living in the set of Interstellar.
I took this to heart and picked up a pair of Sidi boots on sale from PDX-based biketiresdirect. I'm super stoked to avoid the shoe cover shuffle (Which one? How cold will it be?). The best part of the full GTX boots is that there is no splash-up through the sole. This is definitely a solid piece of advice and a long-term purchase.
please review the Giro's after the season! i passed them up for Northwave's Kingrock GTX because the Giro Blaze top layer appears to be too similar to DMT's WKM1 which only lasted a season because the outer layer cracked along the zipper. Also, they're not the warmest and if you care about personal records & KOMS, forget it. The Kingrock's are the warmest boots i've had so far, the coldest i've ridden them in was -5 C, & the waterproofing works well too
6:11 I have the Northwaves with the same closure system and it works but the plastic thingy wears out after a while. Also not that great when you have to close and open it a lot as I takes more time (important if you use them as your commuter shoes)
having extre wide feets are great for swimming and hiking, but awful when trying to find good fitting winter shoes :( (wide shoes are usually not enough, crocs are too narrow for one). iv opted for winter overshoes when not below freezing(autumn/spring) and just riding mtb with flat pedals when freezing and using hiking boots.
I'm in the same boat as you, the only problem is I get very cold feet and overshoes do not do the trick for me. They shops in my area hate me, I try all the shoes and never buy anything... The cycling shoe industry really have to do something for us wide footed fellas
@@thispodI’ve got Bont double wides which are amazing - well the Vaypor+ are, they were so good that I bought the Vaypor G and they’re not nearly as wide even in the same size. Full custom is the only other option but that’s a lot more.
"Why 12?" says the man who measures his heigth in inches. Also Endura does a hardshell overshoe that's made of thick neoprene and is more durable than the sock-style ones. Still a pain to put on and does not close the venting holes beneath the sole but works great in dry and mildly rainy conditions.
Been watching you awhile now but just subscribed. If you have any winter cycling shoes that need some use and are just sitting around that’s my husband size 45 wide would be better . Nick could really use a p.air of winter cycling shoes… Merry Christmas .
Now if we could just get manufactures to produce even a few options for large riders. 6'5" 270# size 15(50) shoe. Don't even get me started on how frame designs don't fit me anymore!
I'm running the cheaper shimano shoe in the Pacific Northwest. They leak and one shoe flap ripped where the neoprene and the rubber met. They aren't particularly warm for below 0C riding which is why I bought them. I did get them cheap on clearance which makes me generally ok with this mediocre performance.
Love all your videos! Entertaining and informative. Dual purpose 😂. I currently use DMT WKM1. Curious your thoughts as they are close to the Giro you picked but zipper doesn’t come down.
I had some Northwave GTX artics. I thought they would be waterproof but they were not and took ages to dry after riding in the rain all day. The cuff also ripped after an accident. I don't trust any boot or shoe unless it has an integrated "rain jacket" gaitor
Hey Dustin - you need to convince CC to give discounts to buyers who have already purchased before. I still purchased a pair of 45s from them but still--
Good socks, plastic bags over feet, put inside shoe. Dry, 100% wind resistant and cheap. However, due to no more plastic bags ive resorted to paper, which doesn't work as well. Biking doesn't have to be expensive. Marketing says otherwise.
📺 New Episodes of Everything’s Been Done
🗓 Every Thursday at 1pm PST / 4pm EST / 9PM GMT
📡 EBD LIVE: 30 min before each weeks premiere:
12:30pm PST / 3:30pm EST / 8:30PM GMT
🤘Subscribe to GET RAD: bit.ly/Subscribe_to_EBD
I'm in Alaska. I have the 45 Nrth Japanther. They are very much like a cross between the Giro and Shimanos you reviewed. They have bomber lugs, a nice combo velco cuff and dry zip and they are good to 20 degrees. They have pull on heel loop and no other exterior do-dads to muck up so they hose off in a flash. I've had mine for 6 years and they are still in great shape. I give them an 11 out of 13 rating. Great video Dustin.
My secret to winter cycling comfort is to stay inside until April.
You are NOT WRONG...🤣
And miss having the trail all to yourself??? As if!!! 😂
@@IowaNinersFan Not to mention having to start all over, endurance and muscle wise. Unless you have a cycling trainer at home, which I don't. As a dog person, I always found there to be not really bad weather, only wrong clothes. Now I cycle year round (to get to work and back) and for fun, MTB. Year round. I especially like freshly fallen snow in the forest. Makes a very nice sound.
In a perfect year, I go straight from bikes to skis
@@IowaNinersFanI see your name is Iowa niners fan I grew up 30 years in council bluffs Iowa which is 10 minutes from Omaha Nebraska and I'm also a huge 49er fan since the Montana Jerry Rice days safe ride and dude 🤙🏻🤙🏻🤙🏻
I haven't seen anybody mention this: The zipper on the Giro isn't broken, it's a feature. Flap the little tab down and it locks up and pull it away from the zipper or up it unlock it. I really love those zippers.
Yep. Never had a problem with mine either.
the mirror killed me
I'm glad that I'm not the only one that struggles with shoe covers. Also, I finally discovered that if you put the shoe cover on FIRST, before the shoe, it's easier to pull them over the shoe after.
@@pierrex3226 No, you put the shoe cover on your ANKLE without the shoe. Then you put on the shoe, then you pull the cover down over the shoe. I dunno if this is common knowledge or what, but I always put on the shoe and then struggled to pull the cover over the shoe and it would take me ages and I'd rip the more delicate ones. I've been riding bikes for so long and I couldn't believe it'd taken me so many years and so many struggles to put them on like this. It's so much easier.
Yep I also came to this method through trials and tribulations.
I use neoprene overshoes made by a company called Spatz - recommended by many seasoned UK cyclists. They do the job, keeps your feet dry and warm. But to get them on? Man alive if you manage it, you feel as if you need to knock out at least 150km to make the effort worthwhile. One things for sure you'll be properly warmed up before you leave for your ride.
GCN hosts seem to do it this way too.
I found the 45NRTH Japanther & Wolfhammer are bother waterproof, but not warm enough for more than an hour and a half. However, battery powered socks have made all the difference in length of my rides in New England
Question! How cold and how long can you comfortably ride with the heated socks?
@@Smithandrossiter On the lowest setting I can easily ride 4 hours and me feet stay quite comfortable. I haven't gone beyond that because other parts get cold. For about $30 you can't go wrong.
@@JakeLuke308 That's pretty incredible! What temperature outside can you ride for 4 hours with the heated socks?
@@Smithandrossiter As near as I can remember as low as mid to low teens.
@@JakeLuke308 Man, I'm shocked. Just ordered a pair of heated socks. That'll be a game changer
Using Shimano winter shoes. Bought a size up, then I have heating soles. With good merino wool socks, no problem at -10/-15C for close to 2 hours.
Yip ! Total gamechanger. Winter shoe/boots work. Easy on/ off. Road and off road, 3 bolt and 2 bolt. No faffing with multiple socks, overshoes, baking foil😂. Can't believe I didn't do it sooner.
I switched to flat pedals on my gravel bike and got some of those stupid Van's hiking boots. So far I like them.
To be fair on the shimano although wouldn't have it the "silver" is reflective you cab see it reflecting on some camera angles
When zippers on shrouds are pointed up they’re not “locked” and can and will migrate but when you flip the zipper down it locks the zipper and it won’t migrate.
1:10 put the shoe cover up your ankle and stick your foot though the large shoe hole, put your shoe and tighten it, and then bring the cover down on your shoe. That's how you put shoe covers on without the hassle.
Great video! I committed year round for more then 10 years in and around Seattle and a good pair of winter shoes was a must have. It was many years ago and not a lot of options but the Lake i had a pair of shoes covers, if it was really Shitty worked well.
I had a commute the 1990s the snow was so deep on the I90 floating bridge, I had to run the entire flat section and up the hill on Mercer Island!
Cyclocross bike and a smile on my face!
those giros are literally just cross country ski boots. My carbonlite classic boots used the same lace style, shoe/cover design, and central zipper. Actually makes a lot of sense since xc ski boots also connect to the binding at the front and need to be relatively stiff, even the classic ones.
Also, if anyone out there needs a COLD weather boot, the Blivet Quilo is rated down to -18C (-4F). I have a pair because I used to live in Montreal and they really do work for the cold and snow.
Are they really warm?
I am South shore od Montreal
@@NinthwaveThe yeah, they were great for me. Climbed Mont-Royal a lot during the winter. I’ve also gone showshoeing with them.
Agree on the shoe covers - I invested in winter road boots and it has changed everything about winter riding - super fun
Just bought some Northwave wintershoes. Can't wait for winter! Never thought I'd say that... 😂😂
It helps ease the pain ;)
The Van Halen really did it for me haha. Thanks again for an awesome gear video!
You rule Cameron!
You got me into the Giro Privateer and it’s been bomb for everything. Like seriously everything!
Those shoes rule!
45N Japanthers, Specialized Defrosters are both major league winter boots. Both warm, water-proof and comfy. Buy 1 full size larger than normal shoes for merino wool winter socks (riding in western mass, outside, all winter, commuted at 6:30am for 7 years). My older Shimanos were warm but not very waterproof. Also own a pair of Sidi "rain boots" which are great for keeping the wet out but not very warm. I've got mine, but if I was buying new now I'd buy the 45N Ragnorok or Japanther.
I have the previous version of the Shimano boot- MW701, they have a Michelin tread and look a lot grippier than the version reviewed here. These winter boots have been a complete game changer for my winter riding, and having some riding trousers that go over the ankle cuff makes a big difference.
I run the Shimano MW701. I add a Castelli toe cover and a toe warmers and I'm good for 4 hour rides at temperatures of -5 C to -10 C. The toe covers add wind and water resistance and the toe warmer makes good heat. I wear two pair of medium weight wool socks.
Five Ten Trailcross gtx ! I couldn't imagine winter and/or rainy bike trips without them. Game changers for me 👌
I have those as well! Terrific shoe.
New boot goofin!
My current winter shoes need replacing after five years of service. This vid helps a bunch with choosing a good replacement. Thank you!
Love the 45N Ragnaroks! I don't have the tall version but standard height is perfect for a winter in New York!
Good choice!
Waterproof socks over a pair of quality wool socks got me through 4 winters as an NYC bike courier. Only had to bust out the winter cycling shoes when it gets below freezing. ❄️
Love your sense of humor and how you present it! Plenty of appreciated giggling throughout the video! Keep It up dude. Oh, great reviews too! Yeah, and why 12?
I love your style man,informative and you crack me up 😂👍🚲🌨️
The Giro would win for me just because it doesn't contain the pox that is BOA. There is also the Endura MT500 that is much like Giro. Another option is the Leatt 7.0 HydraDri that, construction wise, is the same as their normal shoes, but bathed in a waterproof cover. Also... There are other options, especially for those that have less PNW winters and more real winters. As someone that bikes through the winter in MN, I have some suggestions. The Blivet Sports Quilo boots (there are different types, all with the same name) are better than there 45NRTH counterparts. Just as warm, but slimmer in construction/feel. Also, recent 45NRTH offerings have been less durable than older offerings.
The big thing to remember is that for cold weather, good wool socks are a must. Closer 100% wool the better.
Very good video. I like the openness and candor. With respect to the selling aspect of what you're doing. I tend to consider your opinions more as a result! Keep going. Also, yeah. I tend to buy one set of shoe covers every year so maybe I should be going for a dedicated winter shoe.
If you are riding consistently through the winter each year(sound like you are). You deserve some winter shoes(if budget allows). they really do make the difference.
Granted UK winters aren't THAT cold, but I've had my Grip Grab overshoes for four years. No zips to break and warm dry (ish) feet. Remember to put the tights over the shoe cover! So the water doesn't run into the shoes (as much).
Completely unrelated to the topic of this video, I saw your tire storage @2:25 and realized that I could just re-roll my folding bead tires instead of just jamming them in a tote or hooking them on nails around the garage.
I wear wide Shimano shoes in the winter. They give lots of extra room for thicker socks, or neoprene inner booties.
Mad respect to the PNW winter riders. Cold rain is really difficult to dress appropriately for compared to riding in freezing temps and snow. I swear by my Bontrager OMW boots but I care more about insulation and having a removable liner over being 100% waterproof.
No it isnt. You wear actual rain gear. Rubber boots with flats. Its legs, lungs and heart that matters not pedals and shoes.
Its never off season for me but it is for you so aero doesnt matter and neither does weight.
If you work harder you're that much better off in the spring. So stop shoping like a pro racer and start shopping like a humble commuter.
You will be far more comfortable and the money you save can probably pay for a week riding some where warm in the sun.
@@davideades4839 bruh
Lake MX 146's are very nice. They work well for Seattle winter riding.
It’s like watching an old friend ❤
Bike shoes with shoe covers is my go to. Thinner covers in warmer temps. Thick neoprene covers in really cold weather.
I have the Shimano SH-MW501 - basically the same as the ones in the video but without the Goretex lining - and they're awesome
Flat peddles for winter. You’ll thank me.😉
I need to get a pair now. I love your videos. Thank you
Hope it helps!
Pretty great video overall! Try increasing the final edit playback speed just slightly. It seems that for people who aren’t very experienced with narration - it helps smooth out the listening flow.
Thank you. Great info, totally fun, insanely creative. You da best bro!
I appreciate that!
Dude! You are the best entertainment thank you for your content!
Love my Lake mtb shoes
+1 for the Shimano’s. I run the older version in eastern Canada winter for commuting maximum 1h at a time and they’ve been great! After three years the top Velcro has died however and I had to improvise something to keep the top flap closed.
Dustin’s original winter shoe/boot shown is Lake’s MX145. Amazing product; these converted me to Lake. The new MX146 is even better, and Lake also makes two models to step up/down to cover sub-zero conditions. I use the MX146 down to around -5C.
What? No flat pedal love?!? Great video as always… even if there’s no flat pedal content here. ;-)
Winter riding shoes have a big problem - they have a big hole in the top, which lets in water. Water runs down your legs into your boots. Once your feet are wet they are toast. Not warm toast, I mean cold and frigid, which ruins your ride. What you need are neoprene cuffs which clamp the leg and overlaps the top of the boot. Viola, no water runs down your legs into the boot. Winter boots need cuff supplementation when water is around.
My best recent purchase, BlueTooth Li battery heated socks! I still use antiperspirant (Mnt climbing trick) & usually shoe covers as Winter cycling shoes can be hard to fit layers of socks.
after 40 years of cycling and many years commuting to work in winter the toe covers do not provide enough protection from the wind. The toe covers also do not keep your feet from getting wet in wet snow and rain. situation is the decider of what you need. I used full covers that zipped on the side and were gortex with leather bottoms i still have them after 20 years
Great video, I have the Giro blaze and wanted to love them but i find them so tight round the ankle that bottom of my shin above the ankle became very painful. Also the slide fastener works well but has to fit under the cover which is very tight making the zip hard to close. I also have the 45north Ragnarock and the only issue has been the boa system which is not great and i have had to replace twice so far. Keep going back to my old Shimano MW80’s. So try on carefully before you buy.
Here I am in South Texas and I have not worn shoe covers yet this season. I did wear wool socks one day because I had them. So why am I watching this? Because it DK and DK you are entertaining. Thanks for the video.
Thanks for a great and fun review of winter bike shoes!
RUclips was indeed correct. I am a winter commuter in a very cold climate and footwear is important.
I like the design of the Giro shoes. Agree on the Gore rain pants, work great for me. For my flat pedal brethren, I like the Five Ten Freerider EPS mid flat shoes. Nice fit, insulated, and a bit more substantial than regular Freeriders. Have been on rides recently with those in temps low 20’s F. Still use shoe covers for wetness and added warmth, and neoprene toe caps are ideal to keep my toe beans warm.
It’s crazy when people question my choice of getting winter riding shoes, both for gravel and road versions. When I was noob, id burn thru a set of full and toe covers every season at least…I have a pair of Shimano Goretex SPD winter boots and a pair of Lake roadie boots for almost 6 years now and they have held up great, and go on super easy, and have never failed to keep my feet dry and warm.
Finnish perspective: why is he reviewing spring/fall shoes and not winter shoes?
Couldnt agree more with winter shoes being a game changer in my cycling. Always hated those over booties. Sometimes I'd give up a ride just to the thought of putting those on.
I have the shimano one. Very nice shoe. Can't comment on the others. For some reason, it is very hard to find (don't even know if you can) the regular version of the shoe. I could only find the wide version. I just do what the video says, I use a ticker sock. It works, but not necessarily ideal.
1:36 I even think that while winter cycling the shoes and gloves are more important because unlike anything else they don’t really get hot as they don’t really move enough. I got my first boots a few years ago and I never looked back
Riding in Scotland I guess qualifies as 'west coast weather' - hovering around freezing and very wet. I have really poor circulation to my hands and feet and hated winter riding until I got a pair of Giro Blaze a couple of years ago (I wear a Giro shoe in the summer too). I went up a size so I can wear thicker socks without cutting off the circulation and I almost always wear neoprene over-shoes as well. I still get cold feet but not painfully so. They have let the water in on occasion so the overshoe comes in very handy (and keeps the shoe cleaner). I've never had a problem with the zip slipping because it folds down and locks.
Since this video I bought and tested the Giro Blaze shoes, and I am very satisfied. Just be mindful that you need at the very least one size bigger than what you usually use, that it fits easily on narrow feet, and the closing of the zips is really tight above the ankle. The waterproofing is very good, went through ponds of mud and water, generously dipping the shoes under the water, feet remained perfectly dry (do not immerge the feet higher than the top of the shoes though 😅). I've not had temperatures below 4°C (but with humid/rainy weather) and did not felt cold. Not sure how they handle colder weather but where I live, it also means dryer weather so... I am confident it will be enough for my place.
Good taste picking the Giro. 👌
Thanks T!!
Love the Giro Blaze, best of what I've tried/tested/spent two winters in.
how is that zipper doing when it's getting beaten up with mud and dirt? Any issues so far?
No troubles yet! @@black.raven.adventures
Does the zipper fall on u?
ONLY if I wear too bulky of a sock... but, I find that a thin, summer weight sock in this shoe-down to high 30s degrees-works great and the shoe provides enough warmth.@@evanm.2300
Aces! Good shoulder season gear. Now… could you do one that’s for real winter for those of us with real winter - aka the North, aka maybe fat biking shoes? You said -4C ‘no thanks’ but that’s where the fun begins up here in Canada in the winter. Great review! And my god… comedy! Love it!
I have been using a pair of neoprene shoe covers from Performance for well over 10 years. Get them oversized. I have winter shoes but they are too heavy. I found slightly larger shoes with shoe covers warmer than winter shoes. Winter shoes have thicker soles which is their big plus. The soles are where you lose all your heat.
8:20 That Lake outsole and the layout of the upper makes me think that they let Lake or their contracting factory produce the shoe. Also one plus for overshoes it that there is no change in cleat location or height. My winter boots are from a different company than my normal mtb shoes and the slight difference in foot position drives my OCD nuts
ah good for you. I'm having big problem finding a shoe that would fit me. Sadly big foot here. Shimano doesn't do the same size range for winter shoes as they do for summer ones
Tell me about it I'm a size 50 and you have to get whatever there is going lake do their winter range in a 49-50 i managed to snag some sidi gore frost 2's on sale in a 50 good luck 🤞
@@zedddddful how is the width? sidi is known for italian width (quite narrow)
@@zedddddful ok went forward and got northwave Celsius XC Arctic GTX thanks for the inspiration (just did the math calculation looking at my shimano shoes and how long was the insert)
@@kamilk6807 they aren't too bad I expect they made them slightly wider for winter socks and that's great I've not seen Northwave above a 48 👍
@@zedddddful tbh this northwave 48 has shimano's 50 sizing ;) so fingers crossed
here just for curiosity. where i live, winters have been coming much dryer and hotter in the last 15/20 years, from having ocasional snow and not uncommon heavy rains, to 2 days under 0° last winter. i've just discarded some old waterproof shoe covers that were rotting in the garage.
so 0 snow, almost 0 mud, a few drops of rain. the dust on the other side.... i feel i'm living in the set of Interstellar.
Perfect. Thank you
45Nrth seems to know what they are doing, might buy a pair next year. This season I will suffer though it.
A must have for Winter riding. I have two pairs and love them.
I’ve got old Pearl Izumi Gore Tex 44’s & still snugg with thin socks & normal 43’s but warm & dry so there’s that. With a man sized width.
Good video. Thanks for the info from oak grove
Good video lol Thanks for the info.
Great Video!!!
Glad you enjoyed it
I took this to heart and picked up a pair of Sidi boots on sale from PDX-based biketiresdirect. I'm super stoked to avoid the shoe cover shuffle (Which one? How cold will it be?). The best part of the full GTX boots is that there is no splash-up through the sole. This is definitely a solid piece of advice and a long-term purchase.
Great to hear!
I feel like a stormtrooper when I put mine on. It feels good.
I wish everything did that for me.
I wear waterproof shoes with Seal skin socks, works well if you wear flats.
Thanks, I've been coveting winter shoes for decades. I don't have to watch the rain video. Never start in the rain
Which one is the warmest ? Loved the editing!
please review the Giro's after the season! i passed them up for Northwave's Kingrock GTX because the Giro Blaze top layer appears to be too similar to DMT's WKM1 which only lasted a season because the outer layer cracked along the zipper. Also, they're not the warmest and if you care about personal records & KOMS, forget it.
The Kingrock's are the warmest boots i've had so far, the coldest i've ridden them in was -5 C, & the waterproofing works well too
I really need to invest in some winter shoes, my Giro Privateers don't do much for warmth or staying dry in the PNW rainy season.
isn't the PNW "rainy season" from January to December?
Rainy season is like Oct/Nov-> April/May lol
@@hikesbikesbrews it’s probably like October to April/May honestly. Haha
6:11 I have the Northwaves with the same closure system and it works but the plastic thingy wears out after a while. Also not that great when you have to close and open it a lot as I takes more time (important if you use them as your commuter shoes)
having extre wide feets are great for swimming and hiking, but awful when trying to find good fitting winter shoes :( (wide shoes are usually not enough, crocs are too narrow for one). iv opted for winter overshoes when not below freezing(autumn/spring) and just riding mtb with flat pedals when freezing and using hiking boots.
I'm in the same boat as you, the only problem is I get very cold feet and overshoes do not do the trick for me.
They shops in my area hate me, I try all the shoes and never buy anything... The cycling shoe industry really have to do something for us wide footed fellas
@@thispodI’ve got Bont double wides which are amazing - well the Vaypor+ are, they were so good that I bought the Vaypor G and they’re not nearly as wide even in the same size. Full custom is the only other option but that’s a lot more.
Good review Dustin, but missing here any Northwave. Those are the absolute bestsellers in Europe.
"Why 12?" says the man who measures his heigth in inches.
Also Endura does a hardshell overshoe that's made of thick neoprene and is more durable than the sock-style ones. Still a pain to put on and does not close the venting holes beneath the sole but works great in dry and mildly rainy conditions.
These boot suggestions would be difficult for those of us who flat pedal
Where is your hood thingy from!? Didn’t see the link in the description
Been watching you awhile now but just subscribed. If you have any winter cycling shoes that need some use and are just sitting around that’s my husband size 45 wide would be better . Nick could really use a p.air of winter cycling shoes… Merry Christmas .
Nick would be stoked
Yeah he would!
Man you totally remind me on Nicks uncle Doug , you sound like him you even look like him kinda , well have similarities…
You make the best video’s
I miss Specialized Defrosters. Really wish they still made them.
Now if we could just get manufactures to produce even a few options for large riders. 6'5" 270# size 15(50) shoe. Don't even get me started on how frame designs don't fit me anymore!
"Mkay" had me dying 😂
I'm running the cheaper shimano shoe in the Pacific Northwest. They leak and one shoe flap ripped where the neoprene and the rubber met. They aren't particularly warm for below 0C riding which is why I bought them. I did get them cheap on clearance which makes me generally ok with this mediocre performance.
Love all your videos! Entertaining and informative. Dual purpose 😂. I currently use DMT WKM1. Curious your thoughts as they are close to the Giro you picked but zipper doesn’t come down.
Those look like a terrific winter shoe! I think I would love them as well.
I had some Northwave GTX artics. I thought they would be waterproof but they were not and took ages to dry after riding in the rain all day. The cuff also ripped after an accident. I don't trust any boot or shoe unless it has an integrated "rain jacket" gaitor
if anyone needs a moderate cold weather shoe id recommend the scarpa phantom 8000 thermic hd
Hey Dustin - you need to convince CC to give discounts to buyers who have already purchased before. I still purchased a pair of 45s from them but still--
Good socks, plastic bags over feet, put inside shoe. Dry, 100% wind resistant and cheap. However, due to no more plastic bags ive resorted to paper, which doesn't work as well. Biking doesn't have to be expensive. Marketing says otherwise.
With a foot of slush on my trails… I’ll just go skiing