Why Closed Community Games ALWAYS FAIL…

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 янв 2025

Комментарии • 169

  • @flarethefox9836
    @flarethefox9836 3 дня назад +163

    CC players trying not to act like they are royal, pristine, above-the-law, and single as fuck challenge (IMPOSSIBLE)

    • @blkyonko
      @blkyonko  3 дня назад +18

      😭 dude got it out for cc players, but true some are chill and then u have the others bro

    • @todimuamole4196
      @todimuamole4196 3 дня назад +5

      lol thats exactly what i think of CC people

    • @hmeee9588
      @hmeee9588 3 дня назад +7

      @@blkyonko hes not wrong though theres a few chill ones but the majority gotta fall off that high horse 😭

    • @Timmy-mi2ef
      @Timmy-mi2ef 3 дня назад +4

      Even roblox discords got the same mentality think they're better than you for having more texts

    • @KadenFinity
      @KadenFinity 3 дня назад +1

      fr

  • @flarethefox9836
    @flarethefox9836 3 дня назад +123

    also there’s no way that Ninja, an unfinished Roblox game, prices itself almost 3x more than Eldin Ring (which got game of the year btw)

    • @blkyonko
      @blkyonko  3 дня назад +21

      😭 ninja being more than elden ring is crazy bro i never even thought of that

    • @Smol.Gillian
      @Smol.Gillian 3 дня назад +3

      $100 for Monster Hunter Wilds PREMIUM Deluxe Edition

    • @severusreee9234
      @severusreee9234 3 дня назад

      @@blkyonko im being so deadass i used invites to get into the game but i havent touched it in a while

    • @myatphonehan9240
      @myatphonehan9240 3 дня назад +2

      it legit looks like a knockoff of sekiro which costs like 60$ and constantly goes on sale

    • @alaskafr58
      @alaskafr58 18 часов назад

      per month too, not even a permanent

  • @davidgreen1236
    @davidgreen1236 3 дня назад +54

    200 dollars to play a roblox game is literally insane. You can buy so many better games with that money.

    • @Skeletonbones_10
      @Skeletonbones_10 2 дня назад +11

      Elden ring for example like how a Roblox game more expensive then probably the greatest game of all time

    • @bbggtyrone7578
      @bbggtyrone7578 2 дня назад +2

      ​@@Skeletonbones_10 STRETCH lol

    • @destroyheaI
      @destroyheaI День назад +1

      that's two black ops 6s

    • @Hivatel
      @Hivatel День назад +2

      ​@@Skeletonbones_10Deepwoken's better. Costs 12 times less.

    • @Skeletonbones_10
      @Skeletonbones_10 День назад

      @@Hivatel also that

  • @5aiv.
    @5aiv. 2 дня назад +14

    i swear, the CC games themselves are normally unmatched in terms of gameplay, like it's deadass fun; the ownership, the developers, the community, and everything about them are just what make it horrible. elitism, gatekeeping, paywalls, scandals & drama, sm make it horrible

    • @viola4202
      @viola4202 2 дня назад +4

      The progression is always ass, the combat always try to copy deepwoken (and fail miserably), then the maps are empty as hell. These games are just ment for role-playing and nothing else. The only people that say it's fun are people that have a deepwoken addiction but instead of playing deepwoken they play "deepwoken but no"

  • @frhelium
    @frhelium 3 дня назад +143

    I never get why ppl make closed community 🤦‍♂️

    • @blkyonko
      @blkyonko  3 дня назад +36

      the idea is always good but the execution is usually terrifying bro

    • @Peabody_9
      @Peabody_9 3 дня назад +65

      1: Roleplaying (Like in One Piece New Dream devil fruits are 1 per person)
      2: Power Tripping (Usually gives the devs a reason to power trip by making themselves lore character)
      3: Make their own story (Basically playable fan fiction)
      4: All of the above

    • @todimuamole4196
      @todimuamole4196 3 дня назад +8

      ego?

    • @Geijin1
      @Geijin1 3 дня назад +22

      Because they want people to call their game the most unique game of that anime because it has parry based pvp

    • @noiihr
      @noiihr 3 дня назад +2

      naa the problem is WHY poeples KEEP ads these shit

  • @TheZionLab
    @TheZionLab 3 дня назад +12

    the old dev for sorcery didn't only stay around, the "new" dev is literally just the old dev on an alt account

  • @Blahamus
    @Blahamus 2 дня назад +24

    There is two types of CC games:
    1. Actual CC games (Semi-RP/RP games with events and a lot of community interactions between devs and players, dont have to pay to access but has to apply/know people there, essentially a roblox D&D game)
    2. "Closed-Community" game where you have to pay, devs have close to no player interactions, staff team in a power trip with overpowered specs, no roleplay aspects whatso-ever removing the entirety of the original CC game's goal, need to pay for access or needs to be a ytber promoting said game for access.
    1st type of CC games are rare nowadays, but they get mistreated because of the fake CC games that are just cashgrabs.

    • @doubledog5187
      @doubledog5187 2 дня назад

      Youre forgetting that we tend to say "cc game" but the reality is we just mean a game you pay to get in. Its indistinguishable.

  • @boizap2175
    @boizap2175 3 дня назад +29

    closed community games are just pieces of shit that keep popping up on the platform and im tired of it. they ALWAYS end up terrible and its usually never the games fault but the community and devs and its honestly very sad 😭

    • @RealGalxy
      @RealGalxy 3 дня назад +3

      Recently it’s definitely been all 3

    • @Hivatel
      @Hivatel День назад +1

      Closed community games are supposed to stay closed community. They're made to build stories through community events and interactions.

  • @glubtas
    @glubtas 3 дня назад +14

    These games ride off the hype and popularity of the series they're parodying and rugpull the development when they've gotten their share. There's a reason people who are serious about game development move on to other platforms like steam or itch, its because the developer climate on Roblox is extremely exploitive and most of the games that ever make it to the homepage are uninspired garbage made to vacuum kids dry of all their allowance.
    The reason its so popular is because its an easy cash grab, literally anyone can spend a few weeks learning how to code and write scripts to pump out one of these. If they're serious they could spend a little more time creating a and for a lack of a better term "time sink bandit beater with pretty colors that has a gameplay loop with zero to no substance." Which is what most of these "games" boil down to, looking at you Jujutsu Infinite.

    • @jayfogo
      @jayfogo 3 дня назад +1

      So from 35$ to 25$

  • @Bugermanchi
    @Bugermanchi 3 дня назад +10

    There’s a story of my friend playing jji in CC. He played only a couple of weeks on it and got banned just for saying “Ugly” or something.
    Imagine paying 30$ for something and you get banned from it over something so small.

  • @mrneonred3693
    @mrneonred3693 3 дня назад +6

    I think of it like this:
    CC sounds like somekind of exclusivity that alot of teens yearn for and overlook alot of things without looking into it.
    There's also the problem with the whole activity checks and shit. Think of it like that teenagers and kids have ALOT of time on their hand so they can play the game all the time but when it comes to people who like have an actual life outside of roblox and don't feel like "Playtesting" a game 24/7 for completely for free mind you. like bro i dont have time to playtest a fucking roblox game each time i come back from work. If i got access i want to play the game at my own pacing and whenever i feel like it like why the fuck there's some CC games that has like member limit.

    • @minismallists
      @minismallists 2 дня назад +1

      The reason some CC games have a member limit (like for example Crawfish) is so there aren’t just a metric shit ton of people running around during PD’s doing whatever they want and messing up lore, the more exclusive it is the more desperate people will be to not lose their spot, if ANYONE could just get in then you have people that don’t play to actually participate in lore and the story and only pay to play the game early or just to hog a spot cause they think they are gonna do something with it when they actually do nothing to progress the story

  • @gametime8387
    @gametime8387 3 дня назад +15

    about 90% of these problems would be fixed if people would just stop paying for CC games. Devs on power trips and stuff because they know that people are gonna not only let them but pay them as well. Legit just bullying your suffering but the solution is simple stand up for yourself stop paying for this trash and the devs will get their act together.

  • @5aiv.
    @5aiv. 2 дня назад +3

    icl type soul for me was so fire when it was more simple, yes the old 2023 type soul died fast because we had no updates, in 2024 type soul we had so much updates that it was too much updates, every single week it was something new but also something broken or buggy. i would've preferred if type soul stayed more simple rather than pushing out so much updates

  • @girnogiovana6577
    @girnogiovana6577 3 дня назад +40

    The people in the closed communities are weird

  • @todimuamole4196
    @todimuamole4196 3 дня назад +2

    The humor, structure and quality of your videos are top tier(no glaze)

  • @Josh-jn4co
    @Josh-jn4co 3 дня назад +18

    OML i pray the roblox community can see these games are ass and no game thats unfinished should cost more then elden ring a GOTY award winner. And Y am i paying money to test your game should devs be paying YOU to test THEIR game like how slow is the roblox community its beyond me fr😒

    • @flarethefox9836
      @flarethefox9836 3 дня назад +2

      @@Josh-jn4co literally. Make it make sense.

  • @rico653caines3
    @rico653caines3 3 дня назад +4

    When I first saw ghoul:Re, i was happy that another Tokyo Ghoul inspired game was here on Roblox. I managed to play when it was also public for a short while.
    Problem is, anyone with a brain could see that making it closed community, Let alone asking you to spend 1500 robux to access the game is borderline crazy or just willingly evil, so to say.
    The game itself from what i saw had a pretty small roster of Quinques and Kagunes. Other than the map being pretty decently made, there was nothing that really made it stand out on its own especially since it felt like a cookie cutter Deepwoken. (Parry based combat and all). Not to mention the drama that started popping up surrounding the game and its devs, the games future looked dead on arrival to me.
    Which begs the question, who on god’s green earth would pay 1500 robux, or any exorbitant price, to gain ACCESS to a ROBLOX GAME, that is either unfinished, mediocre at best, or un-innovative (you could put it side by sit with other games and see 0 Difference).
    Kids with 0 concept of money and others with money but can’t spot a shady practice if it dropped a bomb on them are one of the things that keeps these “games” alive. There are evil Devs that know they can rip off individuals by doing the bare minimum and time and time again they get proven right.
    So glad i said hell no to cc games. Especially Ghoul Re.
    Anyhoo rant aside. Amazing video.

  • @AzelVendet
    @AzelVendet День назад

    the good CC games lies in games that are roleplay heavy. the devs and the community interactt daily and it's so fun. it is a bit rare to find one and they're not really popular because roleplay(or rather high roleplay) is just not the genre most people are looking for.

  • @severusreee9234
    @severusreee9234 3 дня назад +7

    the exit scam era of anime roblox may be more problematic then the battleground era

  • @JadenExists
    @JadenExists 3 дня назад

    stumbled on this channel outta nowhere and low-key a little glaze, mic good quality, hella well spoken, ima fan, had to sub

  • @sonofthesearolin
    @sonofthesearolin 3 дня назад +2

    Nah see cuz these devs are actually tripping. Cuz aint no way your boutta have me pay £30 for a cc game. Like its not even complete or a finished product. If you want me to actually test your shit then you should be paying me?
    Like even holy war x. Theyre charging like £250 for access. Like bro? At that point you may as well buy permanent fruits in blox fruit 😭

  • @5aiv.
    @5aiv. 2 дня назад +1

    i thinik what sums up CC games as whole is how elitist it is, yes every communtiy has a level of elitism but i swear to god CC games are just on a whole other level of egoing their own playerbase. all the owners, devs, staff, they all think they're mysterious and it's just sad behavior

  • @njoguszn
    @njoguszn 14 минут назад

    i could never understand people spending more than 10 bucks on a roblox game and even then that game must be top tier (which they arent).

  • @ChanceyLittleman
    @ChanceyLittleman 21 час назад

    Idk if you can technically count GPO as a closed community game but if we do since it fits some categories I think that truly was the ONLY closed community game that was successful when it was still closed, but once it opened to the public it just died. The reason why it died too is just crazy cause players that bought access didn't get anything besides a "special hat" and that's it, max level players were literally spawn killing freshies once they reached the pvp lvl req and was legit just giving them false info and horrible fruits. The fact that some of the staff team in the discord was trolling new players too and the game itself just eventually died off due to Pho still having long asl updates which you think would've changed since the game is now public. Like in my opinion if the game stayed closed community it prob would still be racking in players now

  • @TolitJ-n4x
    @TolitJ-n4x 3 дня назад

    The man back with more information Ty man

    • @TolitJ-n4x
      @TolitJ-n4x 3 дня назад

      Btw the game good but when it was in play testing the game not even worth that much

  • @kingsolokillasuper1730
    @kingsolokillasuper1730 3 дня назад +2

    Beyond nens testers is 88$ all these testing prices are crazy

  • @jaystar4968
    @jaystar4968 3 дня назад +2

    Who ever spend the 200 they are proof there isn't common sense anymore. Bro legit spend 200 on an online lego game....

  • @SoshiXD
    @SoshiXD 3 дня назад +2

    yo whats the name of the game you were playing in the backround at 0:17 it looks rlly fun

    • @Qkitey
      @Qkitey 3 дня назад

      No,

    • @AidenWilliams-b4y
      @AidenWilliams-b4y 3 дня назад

      It’s really not fun but it’s ninja and it’s 2000 robux

    • @SoshiXD
      @SoshiXD 2 дня назад

      @@AidenWilliams-b4y oh its ninja I ain't playing that 💀

  • @cruzandoarena3201
    @cruzandoarena3201 2 дня назад

    The problem with all these games is that they saw that Type soul gave them shit to get more money from the games and it worked for them so they try the same, people see how the owners scam and do horrible things (PDF) and they keep supporting them as if they were the best people and the worst thing is that they promote their scams (Nano prodigy and more content creators). We have to stop supporting scams once and for all and support games that deserve it.

  • @beastz2043
    @beastz2043 3 дня назад

    Parkour reborn is a great closed community, aside from unreliable late update schedules

  • @Garryidk1229
    @Garryidk1229 3 дня назад +1

    They opened sorcery to playtesters

  • @Sterling913
    @Sterling913 День назад

    Gang, you can literally get Elden ring with the dlc and Dark souls 3 with both its dlcs for less than 200 😭

  • @ih4d3s
    @ih4d3s 3 дня назад

    damn near charging triple a games just to play a tester version and everyone keeps falling for it

  • @imgaming2393
    @imgaming2393 3 дня назад

    Gpo also went from closed to open, also your thumbnails and edits are looking better bro keep it up🔥🔥

  • @Patodon-q6o
    @Patodon-q6o 3 дня назад +1

    yo bro, can you make a vid about Revengers? it was a roblox game inspired by tokyo revengers, it was so good and i don't know why it just closed

  • @ricosinn36
    @ricosinn36 3 дня назад +3

    Type soul swore they were bigger than the player base 😂😂every game does till they get humbled by lack of income 😅

  • @Peneumodrip
    @Peneumodrip 23 часа назад

    What is the game your playing on the outro

  • @MilanBogajcevic
    @MilanBogajcevic День назад

    Whats the game ur playing in background,ones with samurais and shi

  • @kezzykool8618
    @kezzykool8618 2 дня назад

    ninja is in cc rn and its closer to 20$ (if you dont buy robux onna 3rd party) tester is wild tho

  • @szybkidzidzius7258
    @szybkidzidzius7258 День назад

    Bro what is the game in the backround it looks kinda fire ngl

  • @vikktooqp8514
    @vikktooqp8514 2 дня назад

    What is the name of the song on the background

  • @Modimodo
    @Modimodo 3 дня назад +1

    Honestly I'm just gonna say, Vance is just a horrible developer and made some really really bad decisions, He broke promises multiple times, blamed that he didn't have time because of school (understandable but you could've at least hired some devs on your game to work on it while you're at school dumbass) not to mention sorcery is def just a huge exit scam, why are they having me pay 2000 robux to play a game that isn't even finished 💀

  • @2kDanieru
    @2kDanieru 3 дня назад

    Crazy how its been damn near a full year since mashle closed

  • @Dr_death969
    @Dr_death969 День назад

    the hp bar looks like rouge liniage ong

  • @ermis1619
    @ermis1619 3 дня назад +2

    unc yonko when are you coming back to life 🙏

    • @blkyonko
      @blkyonko  3 дня назад +2

      one day man when roblox finally does

    • @ermis1619
      @ermis1619 3 дня назад

      @@blkyonko unc will you be alive on the cord

  • @ult6533
    @ult6533 2 дня назад

    aye gng whats the game in the bg

  • @VamprexGamez
    @VamprexGamez 3 дня назад +1

    Mashle Academy mentioned :)))

  • @zoroimloss6674
    @zoroimloss6674 2 дня назад

    ninja was so fun man i wish they open it man

  • @yacouba6475
    @yacouba6475 День назад

    ngl Ninja is prop the only cc game that I see will flourish and actually be successful n shid. Cuz I be observing background play, and the fights really feels polished, not too flashy, I could see parry window, the punishments are good/bad enough n I feels like it could be a 2nd deepwoken

  • @greatemmanuel804
    @greatemmanuel804 День назад +1

    Bro i hate cc games there is a mha game called desperation and it looked really good i was like yes finally a good mha game and then i found out it was cc. Bro i can't can no one make a good mha game that isn't cc

  • @Serafin_was_here58
    @Serafin_was_here58 День назад

    The true irony is that games like Blox fruits still make more money than these mid ass games 😭

  • @istoleyourtoe.4933
    @istoleyourtoe.4933 3 дня назад

    Ninjas only problem is its price

  • @Greenpark-c2d
    @Greenpark-c2d 3 дня назад

    investing in memecoin would be a better investment of anything other than closed community games

  • @Bonetrafficker
    @Bonetrafficker 2 дня назад

    blackout revival moment

  • @KandyClub
    @KandyClub 3 дня назад

    managed to get ninja CC from winning shrimp game but always just get jumped playing it

  • @assorted.shorts1
    @assorted.shorts1 День назад

    game at 2:15

  • @torekdkdkdjs107
    @torekdkdkdjs107 2 дня назад

    Whats the background game

  • @Kami_Shura
    @Kami_Shura 3 дня назад

    I’m sorry for your soul if you have spent anything more than 1000 robux for a cc game

  • @whoisbro07
    @whoisbro07 2 дня назад

    what game is that hes playing in the background

  • @Rxallmm
    @Rxallmm 3 дня назад

    it doesnt cost 35$ for ninja its 2000k robux u dont need to buy any of the discord memberships anymore all people that pay for the CC gamepass gets access right now

    • @DiamondIngot.
      @DiamondIngot. 3 дня назад

      2000k is 2 million pal

    • @Rxallmm
      @Rxallmm День назад

      @DiamondIngot. spelling error

  • @toastedbreaf
    @toastedbreaf 3 дня назад

    What’s the game playing in the background bro 🙏

  • @lemuel420
    @lemuel420 3 дня назад

    ninja learnt from that nindo game

  • @Kage-fw8bw
    @Kage-fw8bw 3 дня назад

    ninja cost 2000 robux and you can play the game rn so its around 20 dollars

  • @acar_8979
    @acar_8979 3 дня назад

    song?

  • @alaskafr58
    @alaskafr58 18 часов назад

    two HUNDRED a MONTH to play is not worth any game, could litterally go buy 10 top tier games on steam with a seasonal sale and have well over a year of playing time with that instead of one ROBLOX game that barely ANYBODY plays paying that for a MONTH not even permanently 😂😂

  • @onlytxmmy
    @onlytxmmy 3 дня назад

    All of them are copies, devs are greedy, or the game is owned by a child 💔

  • @Instinct10_01
    @Instinct10_01 3 дня назад +1

    I HATE CC GAMES ON EVERYBODY SOUL IMMA SWISS CHEESE THE NEXT CC GAME I SEE

  • @erm329
    @erm329 3 дня назад

    What game is he playing in the vid?

  • @firerelease7
    @firerelease7 3 дня назад

    hella underrated watched till the end W video

  • @Illstay_unknown
    @Illstay_unknown 3 дня назад

    Cc players acting like they didn’t get scammed

  • @Ben-fs8yw
    @Ben-fs8yw 3 дня назад

    What game is he playing

  • @honokira_3744
    @honokira_3744 3 дня назад

    Music is nostalgia.mp3

  • @d4rk_44
    @d4rk_44 3 дня назад

    listen tho, hakuda wasnt even a problem yall were just bad

  • @YaniBro
    @YaniBro 3 дня назад

    The god complexes be insane

  • @SomeOldHeadOnGas
    @SomeOldHeadOnGas 3 дня назад

    none of these games you talking abt are closed community it’s basically js paid testing

  • @GofYu
    @GofYu 3 дня назад

    sorcery such a good game but the owner

  • @cursedcat9557
    @cursedcat9557 3 дня назад

    Pick your poison
    60 dollar pokemon game with open world
    Or
    Spend 100 dollar to play roblox with discord mods with finger marks on their mouse and keyboard

  • @snail20
    @snail20 3 дня назад

    cause they're closed community

  • @xerfirerexdsg4558
    @xerfirerexdsg4558 3 дня назад

    **cough** Ghoul re **cough**

  • @Catman-Playz
    @Catman-Playz 3 дня назад

    🔥🔥🔥

  • @skeleton_kingLinkin
    @skeleton_kingLinkin 3 дня назад +2

    Basically you're paying for a job

  • @timetellnolies9425
    @timetellnolies9425 2 дня назад

    ghoul//Re is trash it not even that good. it like demon hutner but on stareroid of running and being laggy. parry oh that a 1/5 change

  • @ChocolateKing123
    @ChocolateKing123 День назад +1

    Nah you mad funny ngl

  • @Epickfam
    @Epickfam 3 дня назад

    no demon hunter im refunding my like

  • @Iosi_Mech
    @Iosi_Mech 2 дня назад

    reacounter rip off

  • @jenki3211
    @jenki3211 3 дня назад

    cuz they suck

  • @mohammadmazhar3700
    @mohammadmazhar3700 3 дня назад +1

    Les go new vid please reply

  • @KadenFinity
    @KadenFinity 3 дня назад

    W ONGGGGGGGGG

  • @Rxnin_Kagemxri
    @Rxnin_Kagemxri 3 дня назад +1

    Ten dollars? Y'all can't be serious. Even before inflation, most REAL games made by big companies were anywhere between 20 to 50 dollars. It's a Roblox game, that's only asking for $10 at that. If you don't have the money, just say that. Having daddy's money to spend on Roblox isn't even a flex, stop being insecure because you're broke. 😭😭😭

    • @TheMostFreeGuy
      @TheMostFreeGuy 3 дня назад +5

      10 dollars? Ninja is 100 jji was 30 idk abt sorcery and the other but these games are costing prices of the normal games ur talking about some cost more than Elden ring (got btw) you cannot justify these prices 😭

    • @Kirbing0
      @Kirbing0 3 дня назад +4

      Yea but 10$ for a trashy game on roblox is crazy especially when you get scammed bruh

    • @glubtas
      @glubtas 3 дня назад +4

      Your paying 10 dollars for a game that wouldn't be worth shit even if it were free, its not about if you have the money its about what your paying for and how that product is worth your 10 dollars.

    • @rico653caines3
      @rico653caines3 3 дня назад +2

      The problem is, most of the CC games are asking you to spend money on a “game” that is either mediocre at best, dogshit at the least, or straight up UNFINISHED.
      A few of those said Devs WILLINGLY make their game paid access while overpricing it because THEY KNOW kids have no concept of money and that there’s people who like to flex the fact that they have money. And that its easier to rip them off that way.
      Think of it this way. 10 dollars spent to ACCESS a roblox game which is either unfinished or in no way, shape or form, different to the COUNTLESS other games like it. Not to mention if it’s even WORTH the 10 dollars. But congrats, you just spent 10 dollars on the game, filling the pockets of devs who see you as a stupid pay pig.
      Example, Ghoul:Re. Who on earth is paying 1500 robux to play a parry-style RPG, similar to many others on the platform like Deepwoken, no where near having enough content to justify the price (Kakujas aren’t even in the game much less a sizeable roster of kagunes/quinques). Which btw, as i checked earlier today, ONLY HAD 4 PEOPLE PLAYING.

    • @coin4898
      @coin4898 3 дня назад +2

      Yall gotta stop calling people broke because they are skeptical about paying for a game on roblox of all platforms😂
      Ur like those mfers in blockfruuts that call people poor because they dont eanna waste 50 dollars on a perm fruit in a bandit beater
      Like no, these guys arent broke they just dont wanna waste money on a game that falls off and dies in like 3 weeks
      Shut the hell uo😂

  • @tahmidekeolu4369
    @tahmidekeolu4369 18 часов назад

    Whats the background song?