I think IPS is more importance than IAS because IPS have both mentally and physically fit but In case of IAS only mentally fit not physically nessesary.
IAS ... IPS ... IFS ... IRS Ye Sab Desh Ki Prestigious Jobs He ... Sab Apne Apne Hisab Se Mehnat Karte Hi He .... All Are Required For Better Governance .
IAS के पास वर्दी नही होती ओर IPS के पास वर्दी होती है ओर वर्दीका Power क्या है सब जानते है. किसी जिल्ले मे जाके IAS का नाम पुछो किसी को पत्ता नही होता लेकिन IPS का पुछो बचा बचा जनता है IPS को.
Ips is fire🔥🔥🔥. Aur jb IAS ki salary utni hi rahegi air baat sirf ips aur irs ke salary ko ias se same karne ki hui toh IAS ki jal uthi😂😂😂. Actually reporyer ne sahi kaha ki agar salary air promotion sabki same ho toh logo ka first preference ips hogi na ki ias . And ips sbki baat nhi hai , usske liye guts courage and everything chaiye . Mai toh yahi kahunga ki jinki ips first preference rahti hai usse ulajna nhi chaiye kiuki usse power se khelne aata hai .
All civil servants are equal in rank it's like cabinet ministers are equal in rank but prime minister known the head otherwise they are equal. similarly IAS and IPS are equal both services gives Secretary rank in government and this rank is bigger not the service .Both are bigger in their field. Law and order is the subject of IPS and administration is the subject of IAS. So they should be awarded by equal salery and benefits.
tum bhai abhi bacchey ho ias bdaa isiliye hotah h kyuki uskey paas ek ips ko suspend krney ki taaqat hotih h aur ias ko upar isiliye rakkha gaya h kyonki beta agar police vaalo ko ssaara authority di jaaaye toh pakistan bnjayega india
Pata hai ye neta kaise itna achha rules banate hai kyunki ias unki rules banane me help karte hai ips bas police station me baith ke order dete hai par ias ke karan hi pura rules Nana hai aur ips kisi se khud ni ladta hai wo police ke madad se ladte hai ias ke karan pura desh chal raha hai and people like u who are happy with any post are called midiokers aur jo ips Bhai bante hai unhe bhi ias banna hota hai par kam marks ane ke Karan unhe ips banna padta hai my father is ias and many ips officers are under him like servant
Even if I get one meal a day for serving with their posts, I would work without complaint......these people are disgrace to officer's society of india...
That's not right i am preparing for IAS but it doesn't mean i should hate IPS or IRS Both are very useful services,If there will be no IPS who will give protection to IAS? IAS officers are physically not strong as IPS so i believe All services are same and best in their niche.
Crystal Gazer Clairvoyant from where do you taking preparation for ias?? and who told you ips officers are responsible to give protection to ias..very bad mentality..you should repair your brain..gourav agarwal saloni rai both were top rank holder even gourav sir stood first hence chooses ips. might be you are looking for ias..its appreciating but some people's wants ips because they are mindsets..
IAS and IRS do not have the same job profile as IPS. IPS officers head paramilitary forces in the country, which is no less than Military work. I think IPS should be given more preference among all
Ias or ips dono ka kaam apni apni feild m important hota h lekin ek ips officer ias officer se jyda mehnet krta h...... Dono ko barabr salary milni chahiye
There are many examples who join IPS IRS by their choice. Rank 3 in 2010 - R Varun is an IPS Rank 13 ,Rank 25 , Rank 55 in UPSC CSE 2017 are in IPS Rank 78 in UPSC CSE is in IRS. But in same UPSC CSE 2017 an OBC Candidate AIR 424 is in IAS.
upsc doesn't discriminate any service,its the local people who have thought IAS is great. Service is based on demand ,who gets good rank will get his preferred service. As many nerds and most of the girls feel they're unfit for IPS chose IAS .Thus ias got more demand. Ias needs only mental power but IPS needs Both mental &physical strength.
IAS, IPS, IFS, IRS all should not be given directly with only marks. Experience also matters they should be promoted based on performance not but by marks.....
I think IAS and IPS both are very challenging so salary should be equal because there are many people who are eligible for IAS but they didn't take IAS as an profession what about them.....
Bhai city mein police ki chalti hai isiliye ias ko jalan hota hai aur district mein ias bada hai bolke dhindora pittei hai agar kal se sp district nahi samhalega toh district nahi handle kar payega ias
It is just a silly exam.. monetary compensation should be according to the performance of civil servants. Although I would like to add in times to come IRS will become backbone of the nation as every superpower relies on revenue to project its powers. One just has to see how internal revenue service operate in US to see how much revenue service is important. IAS instead should focus more on demanding that they could specialise in some field of policy making like agriculture or education or health so that more well read and thoughtful policy can be made and IPS training should be prolonged to 4 years as Armed forces officers train 3 years in NDA and 1 year in IMA.
@@adityay6484 I think you are here purely for trolling.. medical doctor doesn't make vaccine, PhD researchers do!! and yes being a doctor is any day better than free ki tankhah babu shahi service
Ips ko salary ias k barabar ya zyada deni chahiye kyuki ips pe bhi kafi pressure hota hai life ka risk hota hai and ias k marks jyada hai to kya hua ias wale ips ki training thodi pass kre hote hai. Agr apne bharat desh m police force ko salary jyada denge to to imandar log aayge nhi to imandar bhi rishwat lene lgte hai agr salary achi hogi to kyu krega koi aesa.
सेना में प्रोमोशन का system तो बिल्कुल सही है। सेनिओरीटी के मुताबिक होता है। परन्तु जो जवान पढे लिखे होते हैं, उन्हें corps signal ,eme व् asc में भर्ती किया जाता हैं। corps में एक तो trade बहुत ज़्यादा होते है। कम पढ़ा लिखा NAIK बन जाता है, पढ़ा लिखा उसके नीचे ड्यूटी करता हैं । दूसरा sepoy की service retirement age 20 साल होती है। कई sepoy को तो qualified & बिना दाग (कोई भी सज़ा नहीं ) होने के बावजूद भी sepoy से घर भेज दिया जाता हैं ।कई trade surplus होने में भेज दिये जाते हैं,कुछ तंग आकर primature retirement ले लेते हैं क्योंकि सेना सब से ज्यादा duty @ working sepoy से ही ली जाती है। promotion नहीं तो इन्हें pay @ pension में तो benefit मिलना चाहिए।जो sepoy examplary remarks लेकर 15 से 20 साल में घर आ जाते हैं, आने के बाद कोई नौकरी नहीं या तो ठेकेदारों के पास 6000 रुपये salary पर चौकीदार की duty कर रहे या मज़दूरी करके अपना बढ़ी मुश्किल से गुज़ारा कर रहे हैं। मोदी जी, जेतली जी व पर्रिकर जी से निवेदन हैं इसके बारे में भी कुछ सोचें।
I AM EXSERVICEMEN CFN ( SEPOY ) EME CORPS NAME MEGH PAL SHARMA DATE OF BIRTH 21 JAN 1964 DATE OF ENROLMENT 29 AUG 1984 DATE OF RETIRMENT 31 AUG 2000 HOME ADDRESS # 252 DALIMA VIHAR RAJPURA DISTT PATIALA (PUNJAB ) PIN -140401 09530577246 (MOBILE ) PLEASE अगर मेरी corps का jawan या जिसको मेरी ये रिपोर्ट अच्छी लगी हो फोन जरूर करना जी। धन्यवाद sir.
jis prakar class me 100 me 99 lane wala 1st or 98 lane wala 2nd hota h 1st ko gold medal or 2nd ko silver medal milta hai vaise hi IAS ko Gold(jyada sailery or IPS ko silver(ias se thoda kam sailery) milna chahiye
All are administrative services holders so wat if departments are different but they are supporting each other single department can't do anything alone
Besak IAS ka post IPS se bda Hota h. Yha baat kuch sallery ki nhi h. Yha baat post ki h, aur har insaan apne post k anurup hi Kaam krta h. Agar IAS ko IPS k equal sallery de jayegi to besak IAS apne ko kamjor mehsus krege
सबसे सही कमेन्ट डाली है आप ने बाकी लोग ips को ज्यादा मेहनत वाला बता रहे है। जबकि ias के पास ज्यादा ज्ञान होता है। इस लिए किसी जिले के sp की गोपनीय चरित्रावली उस जिले का कलेक्टर (ias ) लिखता है। धन्यवाद
Abei chutiye district ek ias chalata hai par kabhi suna hai city chalatei huye. City mein commissionerate system chalta hai jisme ias se jyada power ips ko diya gaya hai. City police commissioner chalata hai cos ias ki training city chalane ki liye lack karti hai. District mein agar sp ko nikal diya jai toh district pakistan banjayega aur dm kuch nahi kar payega. Khoon kharaba wala kaam dm nahi sabhal sakta. Isiliye badei sehero mein sp level dcp hota hai jo city samalta hai. Dm jitna bhi department samale lekin sabse important law and order hota hai. Agar kal se police dharne pe beth jaye toh dm ki khud ki beti ka rape hojayega aur dm kuch nahi kar payega.
IAS .....FATHER OF ALL....IN UPSC IF ALL TOTAL APPEARING CANDIDATES R ASKED TO CHOOSE ONE SERVICE U WILL LOVE TO JOIN ...WHAT WILL THEY SAY ANSWER "IAS"
Ofcourse their salaries should be same.bcz they write same test and its depend on the candidate's choice what they want to be an IPS or IAS or IRS. But power wise they all have power in their own departments, But somewhere IPS holds more power over people bcz of police department. Even after retirement an IAS will not that powerful as an IPS. I have seen few cases where IPS officers overide the IAS.
DM police ka head nhi hota district me. Police ka head SSP hota h district me or state me DGP hota h no IAS. Or sabhi civil services barabar h sbhi ki salary same kr deni chahiye or powers bhi saperate jisse ki egoclashes Na ho or janta ki bhalai ho ske
@@Sharmaupesheng Dear brother, the senior most officer of police in state (IPS) that is DGP also reports to home secretary who's senior most IAS officer. Now, you can decide.
@@rohitkumarpandey7430 yes brother they report to secretary but the post of secretary not only made for IAS they may be IPS,IRS etc. But in most of the cases secretary is IAS. If a IRS is secretary then all IAS , IPS report to IRS but it doesn't mean that he became more powerful. Only he got more responsibility and all civil services are equal to each other because we need all of them that's why they still exist. Even in postings in UPSC and Election commission all services are equal whichever is suitable they grab that officer irrespective of their cadre rather it is IAS ,IPS ,IRS etc. And when they posted in these elite institutes they became equivalent to judges of Supreme Court. Which is greater post then even cabinet secretary the seniormost IAS in India.
@@Sharmaupesheng One more thing is that a DM covers more than 55 departments in the district as the sitting chairman of all of them as well as formulates the budget of more than 5000 cr. INR. That makes his more responsible. Though IPS also plays a major role, we should not forget IAS with more of the major responsibilities.
@@rohitkumarpandey7430 yes he handle 55 department I agree but you know law and order is the biggest department in state and even a ips is the member of most of major departments like disaster management and justice and equality , animal husbandry and head of Law and Order. role of IAS in law and order is just supportive not directing. And all officers are equally important because work of a IPS can't be done by IAS and vice versa
ias officer सबसे ज्यादा marks वाले या हर बार सबसे कठिन परीक्षा में 1st rank लाने वाले ही बनते हैं । जिम्मेदारी भी बाकि सभी विभागों से ias officer पर काफी ज्यादा होती है । अतः उनके साथ विशेष ब्यवहार हर मामले में तो करना ही चाहिए ।
i would say that ias ips are equal power. yes according to the protocol ias stand a step higher than ips.. in reality people will respect an ias officer but incase of ips people will get fear also..in ias only some post are given more prestige like collectr chief secretary etc..But ips has most recognised post like commissioner, ig dgp etc .Ips has power over ias, mla, mp even ministers. bcz when these people committed crimes it is d duty of ips officee to invetigate d case and that eventually get them punish by law..
Abe chu par wo log dete to yek hi exam hai na sirf fitness ki wajah se IPS bante hai aur jo fit nahi hote hai unhe IAS banaya jata hai...... aur ha IPS hi desh ki surksha karta hai agar IPS na Ho to IAS ko kon protect karega isiliye sabhi ki salaries same hi honi chahiye
IAS के पास रेवेन्यू डिपार्मेन्ट आता है यह काफी है और डिफरेंस ज्यादा नहीं होगा इस लिए सामन वेतन होना चाहिए. आज तक टोटल काम तो क्लास 2 और 3 के अधिकारी ही करते है फिर मेरी तेरी क्यों ? एक हिसाब तो लगा लो IAS और IPS के पीछे खर्च कितना होता है ॥
Work of IPS is tough than IAS
Depends on situation.
@@dibyajeetptarai2740 In no situation IPS is easier than IAS
I think IPS is more importance than IAS because IPS have both mentally and physically fit but In case of IAS only mentally fit not physically nessesary.
Nagendra Dubey
IPS have their uniform on duty which has too respect and power
No IAS officers is most powerful 👍
IPS ❤️❤️❤️ IPS hi hota h bro.
@@Rishabhpandt IAS is more powerful
@@uditraj8290 only Dm post par lekin ips ssp se aage bhi power Full 🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️❤️😀😀😀
To dono ct****ye ho ips protect the country from inside ans Ias develop the country both are important
Ips risk their life for the service
Ias bara hai yar
asli maza too politician lay leta haaaay bina koi exam diye
Leader ki 5 ही साल इनकी औकात होती हैं बट ias इस always बॉस...
mehnet karta hai chunaw ladne ke liye tab jitta hai
Right
Unhe harr 5 saal baad exam dena hota hai bhai....🙏🙏🙏
IPS >IAS , because IPS is real life hero..
Anser Sheikh got more than 500 rank but got ias ,just because of reservation ,
Even a general person having rank 100 don't get IAS
He got 361 Rank...
Work of IPS is tough and in my opinion IPS is most respected job than ias
IPS ki salary badha deni chaahiye
Me agree hu
IAS ... IPS ... IFS ... IRS
Ye Sab Desh Ki Prestigious Jobs He ... Sab Apne Apne Hisab Se Mehnat Karte Hi He .... All Are Required For Better Governance .
IAS के पास वर्दी नही होती ओर IPS के पास वर्दी होती है ओर वर्दीका Power क्या है सब जानते है.
किसी जिल्ले मे जाके IAS का नाम पुछो किसी को पत्ता नही होता लेकिन IPS का पुछो बचा बचा जनता है IPS को.
Ips is fire🔥🔥🔥.
Aur jb IAS ki salary utni hi rahegi air baat sirf ips aur irs ke salary ko ias se same karne ki hui toh IAS ki jal uthi😂😂😂. Actually reporyer ne sahi kaha ki agar salary air promotion sabki same ho toh logo ka first preference ips hogi na ki ias . And ips sbki baat nhi hai , usske liye guts courage and everything chaiye . Mai toh yahi kahunga ki jinki ips first preference rahti hai usse ulajna nhi chaiye kiuki usse power se khelne aata hai .
Actually,,it should not to compare...
My choice is ips...
IAS is more powerful....🔥🔥🔥
@@uditraj8290 no it is not...
@priyank7593 how???
@@uditraj8290 bcoz they are not the boss they are the coordinator that's why they don't have any Power...
All are equal no one more or less to any one.......thanks.
Both IAS and IPS are fantastic services
All civil servants are equal in rank it's like cabinet ministers are equal in rank but prime minister known the head otherwise they are equal. similarly IAS and IPS are equal both services gives Secretary rank in government and this rank is bigger not the service .Both are bigger in their field. Law and order is the subject of IPS and administration is the subject of IAS. So they should be awarded by equal salery and benefits.
Ips is head of all..
Ziyada marks lana koi bodi bat nhi hai,, maidan pe utarke ladne wala asli hero hota hai
tum bhai abhi bacchey ho ias bdaa isiliye hotah h kyuki uskey paas ek ips ko suspend krney ki taaqat hotih h aur ias ko upar isiliye rakkha gaya h kyonki beta agar police vaalo ko ssaara authority di jaaaye toh pakistan bnjayega india
IAS is head of district but IPS is head of only district 's police. So you understand
Pata hai ye neta kaise itna achha rules banate hai kyunki ias unki rules banane me help karte hai ips bas police station me baith ke order dete hai par ias ke karan hi pura rules Nana hai aur ips kisi se khud ni ladta hai wo police ke madad se ladte hai ias ke karan pura desh chal raha hai and people like u who are happy with any post are called midiokers aur jo ips Bhai bante hai unhe bhi ias banna hota hai par kam marks ane ke Karan unhe ips banna padta hai my father is ias and many ips officers are under him like servant
Kuch ni ata hai tumhe Tum padne me kamjor hoge isliye tumhe ias se jalan hoti aur tum jante Ho ki tumhari aukat ni hai ias banne ki
@@pineapple9644 abe Chutiya only president can suspend
IPS 24 hours duty.....
Janak Basumatary ias also
beta i.a.s have also 24 hour
nhi ips apni duty time k baad off duty hotah h but ias humesha on duty hotah h even on holidays
Ias
sabse jyada kam ips officer krte hi
Even if I get one meal a day for serving with their posts, I would work without complaint......these people are disgrace to officer's society of india...
That's not right i am preparing for IAS but it doesn't mean i should hate IPS or IRS
Both are very useful services,If there will be no IPS who will give protection to IAS?
IAS officers are physically not strong as IPS so i believe All services are same and best in their niche.
Crystal Gazer Clairvoyant brother I hope u success on ur upsc exam I appreciate fully with ur point
Dul Saikia yes i know because i have goals in my mind to achieve for your information i have already cracked State PCS Rank 56 IAS-
Crystal Gazer Clairvoyant from where do you taking preparation for ias??
and who told you ips officers are responsible to give protection to ias..very bad mentality..you should repair your brain..gourav agarwal saloni rai both were top rank holder even gourav sir stood first hence chooses ips.
might be you are looking for ias..its appreciating but some people's wants ips because they are mindsets..
subho roy u idiot entire civil india is protected by ips
Crystal Gazer Clairvoyant yeah i know that you illiterate boy.
I think both are deserve same salary...please don't compare them..
Bilkul aisa he hona chahiya
IPS officer is best of all
All are equal.
Both are okay in their own ways,post, positions and duties.Please do not make any comparison.
IAS is head of all departments and he had many types of works from IPS
Sanjeev Tiwari hi
Galthai
Ghanta wo coordinator hai paper push kerega aur kuch nhi...
IAS and IRS do not have the same job profile as IPS. IPS officers head paramilitary forces in the country, which is no less than Military work. I think IPS should be given more preference among all
Ips ki salary bodaa honaa cahiyee
Ias or ips dono ka kaam apni apni feild m important hota h lekin ek ips officer ias officer se jyda mehnet krta h...... Dono ko barabr salary milni chahiye
OLYMPIC MEDAL TOH SABKO MILNA HAI .0006 ke diffrence pe gold medal milta hai
IPS above everything. They work 24x7. Unlike ias who sit in ac rooms and take money illegally.
Rahul sorry to interrupt u bro but IAS don't sit in ac rooms only
Even I m supporting salary issue in favour of IPS n IRS but IAS is not like that u described here
police vaaley jis din chalaaney lgein gey toh india pakistan bn jaaye ias is better
Ups, ias salute
There are many examples who join IPS IRS by their choice.
Rank 3 in 2010 - R Varun is an IPS
Rank 13 ,Rank 25 , Rank 55 in UPSC CSE 2017 are in IPS
Rank 78 in UPSC CSE is in IRS.
But in same UPSC CSE 2017 an OBC Candidate AIR 424 is in IAS.
upsc doesn't discriminate any service,its the local people who have thought IAS is great.
Service is based on demand ,who gets good rank will get his preferred service.
As many nerds and most of the girls feel they're unfit for IPS chose IAS .Thus ias got more demand.
Ias needs only mental power but IPS needs Both mental &physical strength.
IPS ke powers sabse jyada hai
ips is also good but IAS is always boss it is bitter truth .
IAS, IPS, IFS, IRS all should not be given directly with only marks. Experience also matters they should be promoted based on performance not but by marks.....
IPS Rocks,IPS should not salute any IAS
IPS.....
only I.P.S
Dono ko ek hi hona chahiya..
.. Ias or ips dono ka apna alg alg kam ha... But real hero ips khaki wardi..
I think IAS and IPS both are very challenging so salary should be equal because there are many people who are eligible for IAS but they didn't take IAS as an profession what about them.....
There should be no interference of ias in ips work
Sahi bole rhe hain sir
very good I.a.s
Wardi ki pawar kuch alag hi hoti hai isi liye I P S ka sowagat karte hain
IAS ki power jyada h or shi h
ALL CIVIL SERVANT ARE SAME ... EQUAL
Ias ki selery ips or irs ki tulna me Jada ka deffranca nhi hona chahiye
ips best
Ips zinda baad ips ke salary bara dena chahiye
IPS Bidra hota ha ias galat ha
Bsdkk ias district ka malik hota h
kumar
आईएएस को और पावर देना चाहिए नहीं तो आईपीएस मनमानी करना शुरू करदेंगे हमेशा आईपीएस को आईएएस से नीचे होने चाहिए आईएएस के पावर में कमी नहीं होना चाहिए
Bhai city mein police ki chalti hai isiliye ias ko jalan hota hai aur district mein ias bada hai bolke dhindora pittei hai agar kal se sp district nahi samhalega toh district nahi handle kar payega ias
Most of the IAS officers can't doing his/her Job in our country.they are important to our country.
raman kumar good you
It is just a silly exam.. monetary compensation should be according to the performance of civil servants. Although I would like to add in times to come IRS will become backbone of the nation as every superpower relies on revenue to project its powers. One just has to see how internal revenue service operate in US to see how much revenue service is important. IAS instead should focus more on demanding that they could specialise in some field of policy making like agriculture or education or health so that more well read and thoughtful policy can be made and IPS training should be prolonged to 4 years as Armed forces officers train 3 years in NDA and 1 year in IMA.
Pre clear krke dikhao pehle
@@adityay6484 haha..I qualified UPSC railway traffic services 2016.. didn't joined as I am already MBBS MD medicine doctor!!
@@rj14053 bana li corona ki vaccine✌️😆railway service me hote toh madat toh krte😆🇮🇳
@@adityay6484 I think you are here purely for trolling.. medical doctor doesn't make vaccine, PhD researchers do!! and yes being a doctor is any day better than free ki tankhah babu shahi service
@@rj14053 nah nah the word in ur upper post touched my soul"silly exam"✌️upsc🤷♂️really
ips head of all
Gold n silver r not same
good
Ips ko salary ias k barabar ya zyada deni chahiye kyuki ips pe bhi kafi pressure hota hai life ka risk hota hai and ias k marks jyada hai to kya hua ias wale ips ki training thodi pass kre hote hai.
Agr apne bharat desh m police force ko salary jyada denge to to imandar log aayge nhi to imandar bhi rishwat lene lgte hai agr salary achi hogi to kyu krega koi aesa.
Ias is best
BHAI ik bat btao me 3d hu dsvi me me chahta ki 10000 rupe lu to nhi MIL sakta because 10000 rupe first division bale ko milta ha
Post nahi insaan pe depend hota hai,daya Nayak pe movies Banti hai IAS pe nahi.
Suraj Pawar are bhai hm logo ki awakat nhi is bare me bolne ki koun bdaha...jb tu ias ips bnega tb bolna...
Salary to SAB ki equal honi chahiye
सेना में प्रोमोशन का system तो बिल्कुल सही है। सेनिओरीटी के मुताबिक होता है। परन्तु जो जवान पढे लिखे होते हैं, उन्हें corps signal ,eme व् asc में भर्ती किया जाता हैं। corps में एक तो trade बहुत ज़्यादा होते है। कम पढ़ा लिखा NAIK बन जाता है, पढ़ा लिखा उसके नीचे ड्यूटी करता हैं । दूसरा sepoy की service retirement age 20 साल होती है। कई sepoy को तो qualified & बिना दाग (कोई भी सज़ा नहीं ) होने के बावजूद भी sepoy से घर भेज दिया जाता हैं ।कई trade surplus होने में भेज दिये जाते हैं,कुछ तंग आकर primature retirement ले लेते हैं क्योंकि सेना सब से ज्यादा duty @ working sepoy से ही ली जाती है। promotion नहीं तो इन्हें pay @ pension में तो benefit मिलना चाहिए।जो sepoy examplary remarks लेकर 15 से 20 साल में घर आ जाते हैं, आने के बाद कोई नौकरी नहीं या तो ठेकेदारों के पास 6000 रुपये salary पर चौकीदार की duty कर रहे या मज़दूरी करके अपना बढ़ी मुश्किल से गुज़ारा कर रहे हैं। मोदी जी, जेतली जी व पर्रिकर जी से निवेदन हैं इसके बारे में भी कुछ सोचें।
I AM EXSERVICEMEN CFN ( SEPOY ) EME CORPS NAME MEGH PAL SHARMA DATE OF BIRTH 21 JAN 1964 DATE OF ENROLMENT 29 AUG 1984 DATE OF RETIRMENT 31 AUG 2000 HOME ADDRESS # 252 DALIMA VIHAR RAJPURA DISTT PATIALA (PUNJAB ) PIN -140401 09530577246 (MOBILE ) PLEASE अगर मेरी corps का jawan या जिसको मेरी ये रिपोर्ट अच्छी लगी हो फोन जरूर करना जी। धन्यवाद sir.
IAS only
Anuj Tegwal good you
आईएएस निश्चित तौर पर सर्वश्रेष्ठ है। इस तरह के सवाल ही बेकार है
आईएएस, ओनली आईएएस
IAS सिर्फ दिमागी रूप से सर्वश्रेष्ठ होगा। लेकिन IPS दिमागी और शारीरिक दोनों रूप से सर्वश्रेष्ठ होता है। कानुनी दांव पेच ज्यादा अच्छी तरह जानता है।
Sabhi barabar hai
Subhash Singh Yadav
Sahi h Bhai
All 3 have same ranks...
jis prakar class me 100 me 99 lane wala 1st or 98 lane wala 2nd hota h 1st ko gold medal or 2nd ko silver medal milta hai vaise hi IAS ko Gold(jyada sailery or IPS ko silver(ias se thoda kam sailery) milna chahiye
Nagendra Raj aur jiski first priority ips hai? rank lane ke baad bhi?
Nagendra Raj tum pahle salary spelling thik se likho fir gyan bat na.
exam me compition h... service me Ni yanha
Salary shd b same
All are administrative services holders so wat if departments are different but they are supporting each other single department can't do anything alone
all should get equal pay good decision as many people choose IPS over IAS inspire of getting good rank in cse
All 3 are same...
IPS zindabad
Besak IAS ka post IPS se bda Hota h.
Yha baat kuch sallery ki nhi h. Yha baat post ki h, aur har insaan apne post k anurup hi Kaam krta h. Agar IAS ko IPS k equal sallery de jayegi to besak IAS apne ko kamjor mehsus krege
IAS KA JYADA HONA CHAHIYE
KYOKI IAS SABHI DEPARTMENT KA DEKH REKH KRTA HAI,
DUSRA CHIJ MEHNET BHI JYADA KARTA HAI IAS UPSC KE LIYE THAN IPS
सबसे सही कमेन्ट डाली है आप ने बाकी लोग ips को ज्यादा मेहनत वाला बता रहे है। जबकि ias के पास ज्यादा ज्ञान होता है। इस लिए किसी जिले के sp की गोपनीय चरित्रावली उस जिले का कलेक्टर (ias ) लिखता है। धन्यवाद
Abei chutiye district ek ias chalata hai par kabhi suna hai city chalatei huye. City mein commissionerate system chalta hai jisme ias se jyada power ips ko diya gaya hai. City police commissioner chalata hai cos ias ki training city chalane ki liye lack karti hai. District mein agar sp ko nikal diya jai toh district pakistan banjayega aur dm kuch nahi kar payega. Khoon kharaba wala kaam dm nahi sabhal sakta. Isiliye badei sehero mein sp level dcp hota hai jo city samalta hai. Dm jitna bhi department samale lekin sabse important law and order hota hai. Agar kal se police dharne pe beth jaye toh dm ki khud ki beti ka rape hojayega aur dm kuch nahi kar payega.
IAS .....FATHER OF ALL....IN UPSC IF ALL TOTAL APPEARING CANDIDATES R ASKED TO CHOOSE ONE SERVICE U WILL LOVE TO JOIN ...WHAT WILL THEY SAY ANSWER "IAS"
bhaisaab ye kisi insaan ke uper depend karta hai ki use kis area me jana hai ye uska ek aim hota hai...IAS EXAM- ias ips ifs is equl
IAS should be on top because They have to control IPS also
Ias is big post
IRS is not relevant with UPSC
Ofcourse their salaries should be same.bcz they write same test and its depend on the candidate's choice what they want to be an IPS or IAS or IRS. But power wise they all have power in their own departments, But somewhere IPS holds more power over people bcz of police department. Even after retirement an IAS will not that powerful as an IPS. I have seen few cases where IPS officers overide the IAS.
IPS ज्यादा महनत करते हैं
IAS YA IPS KE BICH 1 chaiwala jiski degree ka koi thikana nahi vo raj karta he
democracy means rule of people and he is the elected representative of people only.
He has more knowledge than that of them
Degree to bhagwan ram k pas b ni thi....Bhai degree sirf ek paper h aur kch ni ur talent skills matter
hahah sahi bat hai bhai
yhe aur pagal hai
Batti milni chahiye ias pcs officers ko field work MEIN bhut dikkat aati hai.. Agree or not.
IAS agar district me ho like DM to wo har department ka head even police ka v....... so inki salary to zayda honi hi chahiye ...
DM police ka head nhi hota district me. Police ka head SSP hota h district me or state me DGP hota h no IAS. Or sabhi civil services barabar h sbhi ki salary same kr deni chahiye or powers bhi saperate jisse ki egoclashes Na ho or janta ki bhalai ho ske
@@Sharmaupesheng Dear brother, the senior most officer of police in state (IPS) that is DGP also reports to home secretary who's senior most IAS officer. Now, you can decide.
@@rohitkumarpandey7430 yes brother they report to secretary but the post of secretary not only made for IAS they may be IPS,IRS etc. But in most of the cases secretary is IAS. If a IRS is secretary then all IAS , IPS report to IRS but it doesn't mean that he became more powerful. Only he got more responsibility and all civil services are equal to each other because we need all of them that's why they still exist. Even in postings in UPSC and Election commission all services are equal whichever is suitable they grab that officer irrespective of their cadre rather it is IAS ,IPS ,IRS etc. And when they posted in these elite institutes they became equivalent to judges of Supreme Court. Which is greater post then even cabinet secretary the seniormost IAS in India.
@@Sharmaupesheng One more thing is that a DM covers more than 55 departments in the district as the sitting chairman of all of them as well as formulates the budget of more than 5000 cr. INR. That makes his more responsible. Though IPS also plays a major role, we should not forget IAS with more of the major responsibilities.
@@rohitkumarpandey7430 yes he handle 55 department I agree but you know law and order is the biggest department in state and even a ips is the member of most of major departments like disaster management and justice and equality , animal husbandry and head of Law and Order. role of IAS in law and order is just supportive not directing. And all officers are equally important because work of a IPS can't be done by IAS and vice versa
Sabsee zaydaa ips kam kartahai
ias officer सबसे ज्यादा marks वाले या हर बार सबसे कठिन परीक्षा में 1st rank लाने वाले ही बनते हैं ।
जिम्मेदारी भी बाकि सभी विभागों से ias officer पर काफी ज्यादा होती है ।
अतः उनके साथ विशेष ब्यवहार हर मामले में तो करना ही चाहिए ।
i would say that ias ips are equal power. yes according to the protocol ias stand a step higher than ips.. in reality people will respect an ias officer but incase of ips people will get fear also..in ias only some post are given more prestige like collectr chief secretary etc..But ips has most recognised post like commissioner, ig dgp etc .Ips has power over ias, mla, mp even ministers. bcz when these people committed crimes it is d duty of ips officee to invetigate d case and that eventually get them punish by law..
ips
Sabhi ko barabar salary milna chahiye
jjiis ka rank level high hota haay pr wo ias kay bajaye ips bana chahate haaa un ka kiya ......
jiski post jitna bada hoga uska income bhi utna hi bada hoga so don't comperidon to IAS
Ek IAS officer se jada kaam koi nhi krta... IPS only police department... IRS only revenue.... IAS officer has 76 department to control.....
IPS is biggest extornist.
Ias bara hai bhai
Mere anushar ias ko thoda jada 1000 /2000rupees ips officer se jada melana chahiye
Ye bewkuf News 24 ko itna bhi nahi malum ki IAS bada hota hai IPS se??
Pradeep Bantawa all 3 are same
Abe chu par wo log dete to yek hi exam hai na sirf fitness ki wajah se IPS bante hai aur jo fit nahi hote hai unhe IAS banaya jata hai...... aur ha IPS hi desh ki surksha karta hai agar IPS na Ho to IAS ko kon protect karega isiliye sabhi ki salaries same hi honi chahiye
Dono barabar hote h .. state k do hi sabse bade adhikari hote h.. collector and DIG.
Pese pese aray socho ias hee bht hai chaahay 10k bhi mile u r working for goverment dats it means working for nation
Ias and ips ka prilims ek hiya?
IAS के पास रेवेन्यू डिपार्मेन्ट आता है
यह काफी है और डिफरेंस ज्यादा नहीं
होगा इस लिए सामन वेतन होना चाहिए.
आज तक टोटल काम तो क्लास 2 और 3
के अधिकारी ही करते है फिर मेरी तेरी क्यों ?
एक हिसाब तो लगा लो IAS और IPS के
पीछे खर्च कितना होता है ॥
Mahesh Thakur good you