Electoral Bonds : Biggest scam in Indian History? : Explained in 15 mins
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 май 2024
- Register for ChatGPT & AI workshop for FREE: link.growthschool.io/TSM
👉 100% Discount + ₹5000 BONUS for first 1000 people 🔥
👉 Become the top 1% professional by learning ChatGPT and AI today 🔥
❤️ Reshare this with your friends who will need this 😇
⭐️
VIDEO INTRODUCTION:
Hi Everybody,
On the 15th of February 2024, the Supreme court passed a landmark judgement and declared that the Anonymous Electoral bond scheme was unconstitutional. And this sparked a major controversy about the political funding in India!
While on one side, the electoral bonds were considered to be a safe instrument of political donation, on the other side this electoral bond scheme is considered to be the biggest scam in democratic india! While on one side, it is considered to be an instrument to curb black money transactions, on the other side, it is considered to be a legal instrument of extortion in India!
So as usual, let's break through the chaos and understand step by step,
What exactly are these electoral bonds?
Why were they introduced by the NDA government?
What are the disadvantages of these instruments because of which it is considered to be a threat to the democracy of India?
And as usual, we will put out both sides of the argument so that you can decide which side you want to favor!
Our Best Indian Business Case Studies:
1. Asian paints - • How Asian Paints Built...
2. Amul - • How Amul beat its comp...
3. Haldiram - • How did Haldiram Build...
4. Lijjat Papad - • How 7 Mumbai-based wom...
✅Study Materials:
www.eci.gov.in/disclosure-of-...
dea.gov.in/sites/default/file...
www.scobserver.in/cases/assoc...
www.scobserver.in/wp-content/...
Think School is a Digital School that we all deserved, but never had
►►Check out Think School's Online courses: www.thethinkschool.com
#electoralbondscheme #electoral
#thinkschool #businesscasestudy #geopolitics
👉 Register for ChatGPT & AI workshop for FREE: link.growthschool.io/TSM
👉 100% Discount + ₹5000 BONUS for first 1000 people 🔥
👉 Become the top 1% professional by learning ChatGPT and AI today 🔥
❤️ Reshare this with your friends who will need this 😇
Agar tum godi yutuber nahi hue, to definately un companies ke baare mein zarur bataoge jinhone ED aur CBI Chhaape ke baad Croro Rupaye donate kiye bjp ko.😅
I hope you are not godi youtuber, and talk about those companies who donated money after ED and CBI raid.😅
@@nareshkumar3526 According to new data published by ECI , its getting revealed that DMK actually received 90% of its donations from Future Gaming and not BJP. As a bengali myself i can say even TMC received donations from Future gaming which was raided by ED.
Rabbish is silent on this data!!
@@nareshkumar3526 According to new data published by ECI , its getting revealed that DMK actually received 90% of its donations from Future Gaming and not BJP. As a bengali myself i can say even TMC received donations from Future gaming which was raided by ED.
According to new data published by ECI , its getting revealed that DMK actually received 90% of its donations from Future Gaming and not BJP. As a bengali myself i can say even TMC received donations from Future gaming which was raided by ED.
My only problem with Electoral bond was the unlimited donation. Donations beyond one' s capacity is shaddy business
True they should had a limit👍
Yeah foreign donation also possible by this method.
Bjp bought this Resign Modiji
Without bond also one can donate unlimited money to the party and it has happened since 1947.. please understand bond is only a way to send the money ( and there are unlimited ways to send the money )
😂😂😂
There was not one mention of the fact that there exists a hidden unique sequencing system for each bond that can help track which party has redeemed which bond, and from which entity/company. This information is available to SBI and it can be requested by the central government. Thus giving the central government an advantage over other parties. They can for example, pressure companies to reduce or completely end any funding for parties other than funding for the central government's party.
but tries to be presenting both sides of the coins 😂
Good point.
I thought he will touch that point when he said about Vedanta where raids happened after donating too. One possible reason could be Vedanta has also donated to opposition parties - so to curb that, investigative agencies started their work.
Great point 💯
Where did you learn this
@@hussainattarwala2011 SBI themselves gave the combined list, of which company donated to which party. this means SBI has the data of matching a donor company with the party.
I have no problems with BJP receiving funds from companies. It becomes problematic when they raid a company, harass them and then the company donate the money to BJP. Also since SBI is the only bank permitted for doing electoral bonds and since the chairman of SBI is controlled by the ruling government it becomes very easy for the ruling party to harass the companies who donate the opposition. Here it really hurts our democracy.
not to forget that those donations indirectly increase the voting power of certain individuals/companies because what most partys do with the money is donating it to people who voted for them in the election period
@@doomfistXD 😂😂 nice joke
@@kaali123 listen to the speeches BJP candidates or pretty much any party in your local are give 💀
Despite multiple instances of companies buying electoral bonds after/before ED raids, he said they are isolated and not correlated incidents. He didn't criticize BJP for incidents like companies donating hundreds of crores even though their balance sheets showing minimal profits. And why didn't he mention how BJP gave contracts to fraud companies like the one building the Uttarakhand tunnel that collapsed after they donated to the BJP in bonds? The fact is he made this video just to downplay one of India's biggest scams in a subdued tone, so people just brush it off like it's insignificant.
Great, he made the video on electoral bonds without getting his big brother angry. Just as we thought he was going to share some hard truths with facts, he diverted.
Who removed the cap 7.5%?
Who started using ED, CBI to such an extent?
What happened to the amount that went in the PM relief fund?
Cap was removed so that the companies do not give amounts over and above 7.5% in black money. ED, CBI, GST raids have been happening since quite sometime and even before 2017. You cannot co-relate 2 events just for the sake of proving a point that they raid only for extorting money.
the last question that's literally the first page of pm relief fund if you are not lazy enough you can do the research the issue is today people like to question to much than doing a research for example avg dhruv rathee and the leftist logic is just as believed but did you went through the facts he sourced or did you do some efforts to hear the oppositions of the debate and do the research so to give the answer Floods
Fly-over collapse
Rail accident
Storm
Explosion
Fire accident
Bus accident
Earthquake
for all these !!!!!!!!!!!!
title of this video is incorrect. It should be just "what is Electoral bond and why SC called it unconstitutional" . To call something scam or not with so many youtube followers, he definitely going to get backlash 😆
@@suryasingh4817 Usually his videos are educative. But few questions no one is raising like who first started EB?, what changes made in it over a period of time? Who made these changes? Why and when those changes are made? And consequences of those changes etc...
Great, he made the video on electoral bonds without getting his big brother angry. Just as we thought he was going to share some hard truths with facts, he diverted.
It doesn't seem a fair video
He is trying to justify that BJP is right
I believe all the political parties are wrong in this case.
Exactly glad some individuals have critical thinking left.
Respect to CPI who did not take money from bonds.
did u understand the video 🤦♂🤦♂
BJP is definitely right in their approach...but they were not Perfect...thats what i would say...
Dhruv rathee discussed nicely about this matter
@@atanubhadra4032 nicely 🤣🤣🤣🤦🤦🤦
The problem is not govt receiving electoral bond but the sequence of receiving it. ED, IT & GST raids in a company office and all charges are removed after that company make donation by purchasing electoral bond
Nd who proved the sequences ?
A genuine question because there are still not all information available as to who gave to who and who received from whom.
All information available is mere speculation currently.
Don't comment on the basis of internet videos lol
Where did you get this information?
No such thing as a GST raid friend.
Please show paper trail and clear timestamps to support your claims, use logic and research.
@@shubhamksingh-ti4emsbi not submitting the serial numbers of the bonds and BJP defending the electoral bonds itself says who got the majority chunk. But still you know the total amount received. First of all why BJP brought this shady method for receiving funds?
Hes playing very safe.. He doesn't want his growth to be affected at this stage of his career. Only a well established powerful player can openly speak on this topic truthfully with more emphasis on the negatives.
Its all about power and political influence . RUclips influencers has very little and too risky for their growth.
Propaganda school, most of the viewers hardly think
He is not playing safe. He is biased. He has never ever called out the government. All he do is praises. And when they git caught he is trying to play safe ?
Centre can know who donated whom but the opposition can not. Now the centre has upper hand here
There is no problem in Centre having a upper hand in anything. They need to have it. After all they have mandate of the people. Effective governance requires it.
For example, Centre will have lot of information about foreign affairs that will remain secretive. Can opposition demand the same in interest of democracy? The ruling party and the opposition are not equals.
@@Viswadrik Very nice logic💀
@@muhammadmusthafa1801 Not logic. Fact. Let us not live in a world of illusions.
@@Viswadrik this is known as false analogy fallacy. You are comparing two non comparable things that is donation and foreign affairs. One is related to election competition and the other one is governance. In cases of governance, the ruling party NEEDS to have an upper hand, but in election competition no one should. Thats the whole point of having an election right?
@@muhammadmusthafa1801 Your logic is correct but is it practical? That is why I said it is not logic, but fact.
Can any Govt allow a system over which it has no control?
Supreme court decision on Electoral bonds and Chandigarh mayors election results is a milestone in the recent days
Also, the Ram Mandir and article 370 abrogation
and now funding through black money again going to start ....thankyou supreme court ...😆
Yet Supreme Court will not take suo moto on Waqf Act , RTE and POW Act which are true religious law for minority appeasement
@Diasaster there should be transparency, which the bond didn't have, but your point is valid. Now, there will be even less transparency.
@@rajakshay8776 and public their own assets...
Bro you missed an important point
Which party received funds from which company in relation to Ed raids
Man u must know that even if you are donating bjp still if you corruot ed will raid you
skirted this gracefully!
Scamgress party
@@karthikreddy8567PeeJp
Bro tumko bss aadhi adhuri info mili h bcoz future gaming ke liye kch chatukar log bol rhe the ki isne BJP ko Diya hoga donation but ab pta lga h ki wo DMK ko Mila tha 500 cr ke approx... Soo you can wait a little bit more
Thank you from "Andhbhakt community" kudos to your work , we want bjp to do more corruption and rule for 100 years , you deserve best creator award from modi ji
BJP governance is far better than useless I.N.D dacoit gang
@@viveknair2125all money and projects going to Gujarat only. What about other states? 16 lac crores bad loans of Gujarati Scammers and billionaires were waived off but not of poor farmers and people. Why?
Absolutely right Sir 🇮🇳🚩 but still the modi hater clan will disagree 😊 my lord and judicial system is corrupt 😔
@@viveknair2125 history has shown coalition governments are much better than authoritarian rule. There's check on government under coalition rule.
@@ahsaannetwork There is a difference between WAIVE OFF & WRITE OFF go and read Banking terms & economics ,u madrassa chap
Why SBI is hiding details?
The data has been released!
Because that was instructed by their master Modi.
@@ashutoshvats3948when? After getting scolded by SC again and again
because they got free gobar cakes from bhrastachari jumla party
@@chainrxn9479this jhumla party is the only one that's gonna prevent from waqf board from ringing bell in front your house or 10 PhD degree brain from getting hit by a stone.
Since 2019 Bharti Airtel is in loss of thirty thousand crores and still they have donated 200-400 crores directly and indirectly.. there are many such examples that too in just 4 years..
May be Bharti Airtel investing in Congress, so that when it comes to the power they will become profitable 🙄
@@user-hi1rt4zr3c it's highly unlikely to bet this amount on Congress especially for a loss making company..
@@user-hi1rt4zr3cwahh kya logic hai..
@@user-hi1rt4zr3c aapki opinions ache h bas thoda sochke bola kare
fun fact: Vedanta limited which is also involved in this EB donations is being partnership with Foxconn to setup semiconductor industry in India but due to their mismanaged shares and no trust of debt value,Foxconn broke the venture... Today if this company has to setup our first semiconductor plant instead of Tata then we have to lose the revolution of first semiconductor plant in India...thank god it didn't happen..
I'm sorry but first semiconductor fab unit is not in order right? Or Tata is making it? Let meknow. Thanks.
@@aaquibraza5600 Tata is setting up first and Third semiconductor unit in partnership with PSMC in Dholera (Gujarat) and independently under TSAT(Tata Semiconductor assembly and test pvt ltd ) in Morigaon(Assam) under the vision of PM Modi under 'Viksit Bharat' with investment of GOI...
foxconn is setting industry in chennai and this year they are hiring their first employees from my college.
Dhruv explained it with more clarity.
@@Vinupai Because BJP is biggest party and have highest powers. Others don't have that much powers and can't misuse it. So what's point of speaking against them when they are not a danger ?
You should have mentioned how only the Ruling party can know who donated money to which party as there is a secret unique number in every EB which can be tracked through the SBI database. Also it is very shady how the bill was passed as money bill and thus bypassed certain parliamentary scrutiny processes, in what was alleged to be a violation of Article 110 of the Indian constitution.
Only if Mr. Ganesh had conducted analysis like the white paper would he be fair. In this video he says why ED dropped charges is subject matter of judiciary. But for White paper he made a conclusion without the court saying so. Hypocrisy
this guy is smartly one sided!
He was giving a logical reason for that , you should have opened your narrow mind to look at a bigger picture he showed
@@satyammishrasr1822 and what is this logical reason exactly? The fact that SBI is trying to hide data or ED stopping the proceedings once the money was credited.
This guy very smart, indirectly fooling and influencing.
This chap has been very smartly masquerading as an unbiased and original content provider. Glad to see that finally his viewers are unmasking him.
To make video on trending topics not only one need to come up with content very also one need to go through all arguments.
That's so good to see a channel from Pune is growing.
Ayega Bhai. Thoda sabar.
Election ke baad ayega LOL@@yourindiankid1298
What argument? Everything was already in public domain. This process of donation should not at all exist. These same money goes to the troll army. To compensate for the donation company will charge the customer. Indirectly public is funding the politicians lavish lifestyle. Personal capacity me jisko Jo donation dena hai do, company should not be allowed to give any donation.
Average thinking sab karte hai, think thoda beyond, it's Think school isn't it?
@@pratikdedhia Funding won't stop, business and politics go hand in hand.
Now it will happen how it used to be before 2019, i.e. via cash, possibly black money.
According to me, instead of banning best decision would have been to stop foreign players, bring more transparency, bring more regulations into this like limiting the donation amount, only profitable companies allowed, etc sort of things.
Exactly I felt this was a Iess researched video and what is being claimed by the government that there is no correlation between ED raids and purchase of bonds was just cited in favour of the government. And please why take a congress example, I don't favour congress but that is just mean and trying to brainwash the audience against Congress. :)
Upon encountering a video in my native language, Telugu, I became aware of the "Electoral Bonds" issue. Intrigued by my proficiency in data analysis, I procured the PDF data from the official website of the Election Commission. As I delved into the analysis, numerous thoughts surfaced regarding the significance of data analysis in comprehending, predicting, and unearthing intriguing facts by connecting the dots within the freely accessible data of the companies involved in Electoral Bonds. Upon watching your video, I realized that you addressed crucial points often overlooked by many regional content creators. It would be beneficial if you expanded your content to other prominent regional languages in India. Issues of national importance such as this are essential for everyone to grasp, particularly our younger generations and current youth voters. I appreciate the thorough analysis conducted by your team, Ganesh. Kudos to you and your entire team for the excellent work.
Edit: I lately realised that Think School is already extended to other Indian Languages, cool!!
Brother can you share me the link of the data. I can also use it for doing data analysis.
It'll be of great help. Thanks.
All you enlightened people who think electoral bonds are a scam, please care to elaborate what existed before that? Also, what replaces this scam? How did CONgress received money in the past and will receive going forward? No one said (not even BJP) that this was the fool proof system but the alternative is even worse. Just like the dumb SC judges didn’t care to provide an alternative but removed this system hence taking the country back to limitless cash exchange with ZERO paper trail of any kind. In case of electoral bonds, the buyer and receiver had to pay taxes on the amount this the black money was getting converted and tax payer was getting benefitted due to extra money in govt coffers. Now what do we have? Plain old hard cash like the ones found in Congress Neta’s house. Congratulations 🎉
Even though the biggest players dominate the field in any scenario, there's no reason to shift the playing field in the favour of big players.
Whether Think School defends a party or opposes it, the real reason to watch is because he brings a different perspective. It's always valuable to consider different viewpoints.
Are you gonna listen to the perspective of Earth is Flat at least it's different perspective Your logic
@@cyborg6282what a baseless argument, flat earth theory was disproven a long time ago and that is why no one listens to their pov, this is a different matter don't connect different dots to prove your point
@@ayshplayes5098 but it still prevail and be taught in Madarsa University 😂
@@cyborg6282bro... You comparison is as dead as flat earth and earth being centre of universe ☠️
deep down we all know , think school always making videos on particular party's favour!!!
qwik supply ...how were they able to donate so much money. While their profit was too low doesn't it sound suspicious??😅
I think they are shell company of a large company
Btw these are allegations only same as some opposition puppies were saying that future gaming donated to BJP but recently we got to know that they donated 500cr to DMK 😂
Qwik supply chain is the sister concern of reliance
@@shivankursharma7999 the question isn't to whom they have donated. The question is how they have donated this much. You are missing the point. Stop pandering for political parties and think of the country for a change.
@@EdwinTylerthank you. Finally someone gets it. Arey sare politicians are gandus but we commoners must be clear that our fight is not against political parties. It is against exploitation... OUR EXPLOITATION. People dont understand, money doesnt produce out of thin air. It is the money of citizens that is being misused. Money that is extorted from us by crony capitalism.
@@EdwinTyler buddy plss be in reality.. and don't dream of Idea society.
Do you think that without electoral bonds business were not finding political parties...??
They were doing that in hard cash... And with electoral bonds at least they are showing donation in their balance sheets...
No way you can stop this bro
Forget BJP even one state party like TMC BRS DMK got soo much funding.
In USA lobbying is legal evryone do this.
Plss suggest something now bro.
The quality of content from think school has gotten worse. The level of depth and unbiased insights they used to offer in their business case studies are long gone.
Electoral Bonds scheme being struck down doesn't mean that there cannot be another solution to fair and transparent funding. In the US, political campaigns need to dislcose all the details of the donors for donations above USD 200. The problem is political parties may not want fundings to be transparent. Discloure of political fundings only bolsters trust of people on the system.
@ThinkSchool just tell us one thing, why electoral bonds were distributed via SBI and not via RBI?
😂😂
One thing i would criticize , if money can manipulate the government decisions!! Then you and we should consider where this money come from !! One day china will funding the election and start giving favour to chinese company. Right now loss making company able to donate so it begs the question. RBI have accountability
@@prashantgoswami5852 andwhat makes you think that they have not done in previous elections?
Because SBI is national bank of India. It is registered under RBI. Do you go to CBSE office and study or study in CBSE affiliated school?
@@sujaysawant868 using cash earlier... just imagine 6000cr in cash... you will need a fleet of trucks to carry those cash... now just digitally transfer any amount you wish
Maturity is when you realise although he presents both sides views he still favours BJP, I mean com on everyone knows how BJP tried to hide the fact from coming out!
Amazing Ganesh bhai! I was reading about this hot topic in newspapers since few days, but not getting detailed clear picture of it. Your videeo made it all clear now. 👍👍
According to new data published by ECI , its getting revealed that DMK actually received 90% of its donations from Future Gaming and not BJP. As a bengali myself i can say even TMC received donations from Future gaming which was raided by ED.
So what does it mean ?
BJP brought the scheme.
BJP benefitted the most other benefitted too but it was bjp which was making the law not tmc or dmk.
😂😂😂😂
@@offred6013 na baby its about that perticular company's money going where.....
Hi whatsApp university.. U missed 2 facts
1. It was not revealed by ECI Or SBI... both the organization are acting as pet dog for MODI... It was released by DMK Themselves
2. it's not 90% .. It is 37% from future gaming
Learn man
It's not ECI chomu it's DMK themselves
Don't forget BJP got 6986 cr which majority
I don’t know why he’s becoming a govt. puppet.
Yes he should become opposition puppet.
@@GamerZ-92 He shouldn't be anyone puppet. He should tell the truth. He is putting examples Congress make scam with Chinese money. What about the money which BJP got !? No example for BJP.
He is making this video to show BJP party doesn't make any scams
@@arunprasadh9213 coz they don't. Reply me when you know how the real world works.
@@GamerZ-92by owning ed?
My take is that BJP doesn't have the option of foreign funding like the Left and Congress which they get from foundations like Soros but since BJP doesn't get any such funding, electoral bond is very important for them to counter the Left Liberal anti-India lobby.
The Good thing about Democracy is we can come up with a solution, and when the solution has limitations/disadvantages, it can be pointed out and improved upon. EB was introduced to overcome blackmoney usage towards donations, which was an improvement then. Now we can further improve upon it. Invest in constructive thinking and improvements rather than being judgemental
Great work done by you thank you for detail explanation we learn something new and it's helps to increase our knowledge
Wow, So insightful video...
Electoral bonds indeed violated the right of free and fair election.
Instead it violated every citizen's right of knowing from where their voted parties and opposition are getting their fundings for such extravagant campaignings...
Also, I'd say the process should be revamped completely and make process more transparent and more addressable to public so that it would be a win-win for all in the end...
@@ratulsharma7029 Correct 💯
SC also told political parties to disclose their donors.
@@suraj_bini initially it promised anonymity. Just answer this, If a company discloses that it donated BJP will not the DMK in TN or CONGRESS in karnataka will create problems for that company and vice versa. This is why anonymity was suggested.
@@handle00725you have zero knowledge of democracy my friend.
Free and fair election? lol how
One of the most honest and sincere videos I've watched about Indian politics, without any hidden agenda. Thank you for such an unbiased video. India needs more content of this standard/quality
Appreciate don't worship
one thing is hidden agenda. the other is no clue. a video that ignores some basic common sense and confuses with minutae.
@@sonu72049would you mind elaborating on it please?
@@sonu72049 That's just appreciation, where do you think worshiping in the comment??
watch @6:00 even now black money transactions (Cash Money) happens... At 2019 General election BJP spent more than 25,000 crores after the Electrol bond was introduced in 2018, don't be a BJP supporter man be true to yourself 1st.
The only educational channel that makes me consume the content asap on seeing the notification.....The best analysis and explanation of electoral bonds I have ever come across....Keep growing and keep making us grow as well😊
Do u really think this was fair and unbiased analysis?
go for dhruv rathee video if your saying best explanation on electroral bonds
If bonds violate the RTI , then how do they plan to track it now. How was it tracked before? Supreme court made a real supid decision by scraping it as illegal. If the bond had flaws they should have asked to fix the flaws. Like unlimited donations, or anything that it found objectionable.
this man actually deserved the creator award. he keeps both the ardument and let us decide. great content. perfect centrist
he was nominated
@@vivaanreddy8771 under which category
Yes nomination is also a great achievement and the bigger rewards are just around the corner for this man and his team!
Nitish Rajput too is one of the most unbiased RUclipsrs! Pure n complete facts without brainwashing people with personal views n propaganda!
THERE IS ONLY GOOD AND BAD ,, THERE IS NOTHING IN MIDDLE
Sad to see that people are already calling this channel Godi media. I hope people use their common sense listen first before having baseless claim. I don't know how people can say this channel is Godi media when the person himself gave many business lectures in IIMS as well
seriously bro, these people dont even know whole knowledge and start judging. this is an economics case study channel if u think he is wrong cross check from the material he give or research on yourself, clowns.
They are brainwashed.
Kuch log nhi manne wale😂
One thing i would criticize , if money can manipulate the government decisions!! Then you and we should consider where this money come from !! One day china will funding the election and start giving favour to chinese company. Right now loss making company able to donate so it begs the question.
Because it is one
Thank you Ganesh for the great help you are doing to society by educating them on current affairs in the most engaging manner.
I am extremely interested in joining the master communication course and have been giving it a thought since few months. It would be really nice if there is a way to get the course at some discounted price, lately there hadnt been a mention of such options, in the thinkschool videos. But keep up the great work!
Just want to hug you and thank you for every single piece of information you shared💫
Those who screaming ifs extortion money the company mentioned is given to dmk 😅
Chomu it's a betting company and betting has been banned by DMK
whereas Modi got Money from the Construction company and gave the Gave Road Project to them we can see who scammed
Haan tu hi to hai DMK ka chairperson @@cyborg6282
@@cyborg6282Haan tu hi to hai DMK ka chairperson
@@cyborg6282 bro, pappubhakt hai kya, DMK admitted that Future Gaming gave them 510 crores 😂
@@cyborg6282 bruh, DMK themselves have agreed to recieving90% of their money from this betting company
8:00 You missed key detail here.
Lets say person A bought bonds for 1 cr in SBI branch with kyc .
Now person B can purchase those bonds from person A by cash. Person B hasnt done kyc so it could be black money.
Now person B can just donate to whichever party he wants without fulfilling kyc.
So the Electoral bonds money might be black money.
Moreover in my view no listed corporate should donate to any political party. If they need something let them have discussion with govt.
And why do these political parties need so much money?? No I dont want to see their faces in posters, no I wont their spam like in Whatsapp from Viksit Bharat , no I wont attend their rallies which most of the people are just there for money, anyway for most candidates they fund from their own money.
If any political party wants fund from public, it should disclose all info like their expenses, future plans same as a listed company.
Completely Agreed! Would you mind if I copy your comment and spam it here?
@@pranayjain._ lol sure
he skirts important points quite comfortable. also deletes a lot of comments.
yes it might be black but the black money went from b to a
both bank and party got white money only
so the black stayed black
if u take black directly as a party u can distribute it to people to buy votes
and all that black money entered the system and became white again
@@amalchandran6037 again we have person with no proof spreading his propaganda
This is why i love this channel. Zero bias, zero manipulation, just explaining the facts with sufficient material and let us choose/ decide our opinion ❤
maybe you just watch only this channel to gain information that is why you think like this
Great video Ganesh. It is a very complex topic to make a video on. A lot more could be spoken here but I respect your diplomacy for safety and wellbeing. Not very easy to speak on such matters on public domain.
Dhruv rathee electoral bond video
That's a different case mate. He is in Germany. He can make these videos freely. If an Indian content creator will make such videos he will be put behind the bars.
Ya, there is nobody with a spine in this country today
Hes playing very safe.. He doesn't want his growth to be affected at this stage of his career. Only well established players can openly speak on this topic truthfully
It's obvious he has sold out to the government. There's no 2 ways about it
Good video on highlighting political funding and explaining the questions and controversies around electoral bonds.
And you highlighted the real as well as shortsighted criticisms of electoral bonds.
I hope people can wait for more details before jumping to conspiracies and conclusions about electoral bond funding, and do a broader research for themselves.
Voting for Congress ✅ this time😢, bjp is as successful as their RS 2000 note😅
Situation 3. Corporate buy electoral bond because of ED raids and give them to the opposition party to bring down the incumbent.
All situation discussed so far were only national.
Situation 4. Local parties (read TMC) can create problem for corporates (like they did for tata)and extort bonds from them.
Man I am so thankful that you exist. Every single youtuber will pass on their biases , opinions and judgements and give very less information about their sources or how they are drawing certain conclusions . You are the only one who delivers facts without any coating and then give us the power to make a judgement. Please don't change EVER!
Great, he made the video on electoral bonds without getting his big brother angry. Just as we thought he was going to share some hard truths with facts, he diverted.
He is just another guy who appears to be neutral but subtly pushes the big brother's agenda forward. No one is neutral now, especially when the elections are just around the corner.
@@ankitvasman3928what are the hard truths with facts that Dhruv taught you..please care to explain?
@@raahul728 Why are you assuming I follow Dhruv Rathee
@@ankitvasman3928I agree with this. Humans are born with biases. The one who claims neutral is the most suspicious one.
Ganesh just did prove my biases were wrong. Kudos to your work bro ❤ continue what you are doing 😊
Like what? This is one off episode where I guess he is just giving already existing info. 😢 Expected more
@@hksghe already mentioned, it's a brief overview of the standings of electoral bonds and all the news around it...
In dept details will not be found on social media... You yourself have to take initiative to know even more and that becomes quite unmanageable for a common citizen
@@cool_buddy_take_it_easyShahjahan sheik is a better choice😂
@@hksg Just go to any social media, you will realize people aren't aware of even this existing/basic information regarding the issue.
@@cool_buddy_take_it_easy If RaGa is still a prime candidate for this, then anyone can be next PM 💀
thanks got the crucial info, i thought that this bond thing will remove black money because companies have to transfer money from their bank account but i did not thought that they can be blackmailed to donate also.
They were previously also blackmailed and deal were done in cash. Now they are on papers.
@@nitindua3022 so before= after, then whom we choose now
Veey clear and very informative. Thank you 🔥
A very diplomatic yet detailed video! Kudos,buddy!
As expected -- Ganesh will never say something critical about the BJP.
Pappubhakts
@@akhileshpatro8707 Pappu sucks too.
Agree. He in someway or other, ends up creating a defense scenario for the ruling govt.
@@akhileshpatro8707 Pappu too sucks.
@@aamirtajar4942 while pretending to be neutral
So far only your video showed fact without throwing allegation towards any party.... Love your content.... Great job
HEY PALKI SHARMA at firstpost also gave good amount of information ,u can also watch it
@cool_buddy_take_it_easyyou should take it even more easier buddy,,, because you are on a spree of commenting a person's name everywhere in comments which is totally useless first, and second, you are not earning from this spree (if you are not politically connected,, if yes then plz ignore my comments 😊 because it is a job afterall)
BJP was the one who brought this law with a malicious intent. How can you not blame them? Soon when the bond numbers are released, we can know how BJP sent ED to corporates and extorted money from them, and also how BJP sent ED to companies that donated to opposition. We will also get to know which company's got benefit from opposition states. The entire political system will be transparent in front of the public. But BJP is the one to blame here since they brought this law with the ultimate plan of extortion!! Biggest scam of the century. A scam that became a LAW!!!
Voting for Congress ✅ this time😢, bjp is as successful as their RS 2000 note😅
Sad to see that whoever makes video inclined towards Modi they are being called godi media . Your analysis is completely unbiased..🎉🎉
Godi media = anti Modi media
😂😂😂😂
Godi=Anti Modi
Facts laid thread bare .. while electoral bonds helps curbing black money transactions however the pitfalls of Quid Pro Quo is certain.. so has to evolve .. kudos to CJI on this topic to take this stance..
I don't think so...many influence youtubers have now been hired by bjp..now a days bjp ministers are doing pod casts also
More important question should be “is click baiting a scam?”
Brilliant video as always. The issue arises 1. When there is no cap on the total donations made , 2. Usage of shell companies to mask their identity of the real buyer, 3. no mechanism to blacklist a company from donating based on civil and criminal cases against them.
Somehow parties will gets funds from here or there. So it's better to be in a form of systematic way.🧐👍
That's like saying we are a nation of corrupt people, so let's legalize corruption.
Creating a legal way to lobbying is stupidity!
They are legally extorting money using these bonds with the help of ED and CBI. If you can't see what's wrong with this then my guy you need some help.
Andhbhakto main dimag nahi hota kisi buri chiz ko khatam karne keliye uska bura hona khatam nahi karte propoganda dekh news nahi 😂😂
Funding the parties is always there and it cannot be stopped. And they are done in large cash that no one can track. Atleast it can be tracked now. Congress done this with cash last 70 years. Atleast we have data thanks to bjp.
Is it just me or anyone else also feel that the recent videos have been very safe and not providing in depth information like we used to see when GST was introduced?
I would prefer quality over quantity even though RUclips algorithm is pushing for the other way around.
Well explained, thank you Think School Team.
Both sides (BJP govt and SC) have valid arguments on concerns and issues addressed. Now it needs to be seen which direction India wants to move towards.
Great Video Ganesh, very objectively coveyed, hats off to you team🙌🔥
Isn't electoral bonds better than before where cash was given increasing black money industry?
It is better as it is more transparent but still it is wrong
@@siddharthrawat955Tell me why it is wrong?? How will you run a National party without Money/funding??
Actually these is better , corruption is something comes hand in hand which is a problem but atleast bond gives update .
bro blind haters of modi dont like logics... @@ajinkya3780
nope only gov knows who give how much to them and if they want they can and they are extorting using ED and CBI
BJP ruling almost 20 states and country, seems the amount collected reasonable when you match other parties collections. See TMC(1 state), BRS(1 state) and Congress party(3 states) how much these parties collected. With the rate TMC and BRS collected, BJP easily should be 20k crore.
😂😂😂😂
Did TMC send ed cbi
ED or CBI does not comes under central govt fyi. Get out of that brainwashed facts XD@@offred6013
@@offred6013that is more dangerous. Even without ED, CBI they got this much amount of money.
Even though no big infra/industry project stated in WB.
TMC's hunger isn't satisfied by the tola baji(cut money) taken from normal people.. they need more .
1 lack crore Above BJP gatherd😂😂 uncounted😊
Do you understand why TMC and Congress got those bonds in high numbers? It is because they have power in states, and to get favors in states they could have also asked the companies to donate them. One problem here is that only central government can ask the SBI for the details of the electoral bonds, if you think it is a conspiracy then be very clear that SBI is a public bank owned by the government.
so called "unbiased education focused channel", refuses to say the obvious in the current scenario with quid pro quo.. tat being said, Ganesh is smart to side with the big guy.. But ppl do see wat ur doing...subtle but obvious
Things are very clear now ....great teaching skills you have.... impartial video
Lol, Supply n demand baby. U really know how to monetize the trend dude. GG.
i agree the amount of videos think school is doing, its looking like shartank india gaye the investmenet liya hai and ab investor pressure mein videos release ho rahe hai. Free advice Don't go for quantity over quality.
par yaha tera sense kya ban raha hai? Aise bol raha hai ki koyi party isko fund kar raha hai jo asal pe hai bhi nahi agar last kuch videos bhi dekho@@dcwarriorwithin
@@plusultra7258 no re i meant the amount of videos think school is pushing. its like investor is pressuring aur output nikalo that way.
So what is the issue ? is quality going down? I don't think so and its the perfect time to educate people about this controversial topic without being biased. so why wait?
@@dcwarriorwithin
It's biased
Insight is very good
In 13:32 its not 261cr, u should not add 130.99 authorised capital
Authorised capital is the maximum amount of capital that a company is authorized to issue to shareholders
Yes, even I thought that, he should correct it
He had to do that so BJPs image is not trashed too hard
I was waiting for someone to explain about electoral bonds.....and you came out with the best possible way of explanation. Thankyou.
Can anyone please elaborate on the fact that 'the money will be transferred to PM Relief Fund if it doesn't get redeemed within 15 days"? What the possible explanation or the need or the explanation?
BJP's fault is they legally took white money by cheque and disclosed it every year. They should have opened Rajiv Gandhi Foundations, National Heralds & Young India Foundations to collect black money from China & Zakir Naik and no liberal would have complained.
If Modi meets Adani, Modi is businessman.
But if Manmohan meets Yasin Malik, Manmohan is not terr0rist,
If BJP gets electoral bonds that is corruption,
But if Congress gets electoral bonds that is donation.
Hypocrisy level 786!!
According to new data published by ECI , its getting revealed that DMK actually received 90% of its donations from Future Gaming and not BJP. As a bengali myself i can say even TMC received donations from Future gaming which was raided by ED.
One thing i would criticize , if money can manipulate the government decisions!! Then you and we should consider where this money come from !! One day china will funding the election and start giving favour to chinese company. Right now loss making company able to donate so it begs the question.
PM cares fund?
@@adwaitvedant3297haha 😂😂😂
Lol this is copy paste 2 rupees It cell
@6:00 The problem is that Central Government knew that who was donating to who via the alphanumeric code, in fact SBI was regularly corresponding with the finance ministry,
Also the companies were donating major chunks of their profits, even the ones which were in deficit, also employees were donating on behalf of companies.
@11:00 ED/CBI scenario will never be more suspiciously correlated. It's absolutely possible.
Also there is correlation with companies getting Government contracts after donation.
Also electoral bonds made it possible for foreign players to influence Indian politics.
All in all good decision by Supreme court
Great comment. What is your view on the argument that 'if not electoral bond, cash or black money or some other means will always be there'?
Atleast there is a record of it. That was the use case of the bonds
@@akumpawatjr if not electoral bonds ..parties have to restort to kickbacks which is prima facie illegal ....electoral bonds legalize kickbacks
@@akumpawatjr It is to be noted that even after electoral bonds came into effect, parties can still donate in cash. There is no restriction on that. The government had clarified this in court. It is just a political argument that this has stopped cash.
Now coming to your question. One of the interesting solutions that has been proposed is the establishment of a political fund. Wherein, anyone can donate to the fund and the ECI can then allocate it to the parties as per their seat distribution. This will virtually end any Quid Pro Quo. But I don't think any political party will accept this as there will not be any benefit for them on an individual basis.
Thank you for explaining this much needed
Beautifully explained. Thank you
What about loss making companies donating money to political party..
Finance minister has agreed that it needs to be sorted out. But since the matter is subjucide govt hands are now tried.
Absolutely a different perspective, clearing biases, well done Think School and team.
This was one topic i was looking for study.. well explained video
Ladakh ka kya chaakr h koi ispe baat kyu nhi kr rha?
+1
Ganesh bhaiya .you complete the demand of voice of the public 😂😂 love you bhaiya
If electoral bond was extortion as per RaGa, then why did congress encash more than 1000 crore in electoral bonds?
😂 seriously behen or bhai whatevs get a brain. The issue is not about what anyone said it is about what is happening. We are done with whataboutery yaar. Sooo please take the cue and cut it aight?
Love the dialogue for haters..
@@cool_buddy_take_it_easy arey bhai ye mahoday kon h😅
Everyone loves him; he's such an endearing RSS worker. It's common to turn to AI for research these days. This guy believes crony capitalism is inevitable. He also believes that people just donate to parties like Congress or BJP, But he overlooks the fact that they donate primarily to support their ideological beliefs (whether it's left, right, socialist, communist, etc.). Not every donor seeks favours; many donate to ensure their ideology prevails. The moments at 12:40 (why like: Anant Ambani speech) and 15:29 explaining the concept of lobbying
The view and perspective provided is awesome 😎
Thanks for the knowledge ⭐️
Nowadays if u speak truth, other side of people if have nothing to say, then they will called it BJP mouthpiece, propaganda of bjp.
And, these all pushed mostly buy with ISI or chinese bots and people tends to believe those.
So, friends always remember one thing if गद्दारों की सेना में जब खलबली है, तब समझ लेना कोई बेहतर शाशक है तुम्हारे साम्राज्य में।
A beautiful quote of Chanakya.
Why would a company who is raided by current government buy bonds of ruling party willingly?? its counter intutive.
The fact is that future gaming gave their 60% of donation to DMK 😂😂
absolutely loved it
As always very unbiased videos, you guys doing great work, really appreciate it.
Very well explained. You earned a sub
Thank you so much buddy❤
Keep going
Ye Dil Maange More❤
What if company could buy electoral bond only 7.5% of their annual net profit(three years average), It can limit the donation.
why you want to limit the donation .?? then they bypass the 7.5% limit through black money. ..
why would any loss making business on earth do a donation to the govt? pathetic logic.@@Diasaster
@@amalchandran6037 for more tender and favour .....otherwise why would anyone with sane mind in this whole world would do any donation to the political parties ??.😆 just tell me
@@Diasasterwhy would someone donate all their money to govt if it’s not illegal? With electoral bonds political parties are legally getting involved in corruption.
@@Diasaster How is it stopping company from giving black money even if there is no limit?
With that money they could have helped millions of people
Hello ganesh,
Can you also make a video about the Data protection act, Telecommunications act and Broadcasting services regulation bill coming in 2024? And their negative impact on RTI act and digital freedom, journalism and right of privacy in India ?
Is there any way to evaluate the authenticity of data published??, just thinking bcz we know how SBI did contempt of court multiple times .
ECI published them you can get the PDF and verify them yourself
It's being submitted in the Supreme Court too, so you can atleast trust the court's side and ECI data should stand true to the court's order...
Truth always prevails so even if anything is fishy, there shall be justice for sure
If misinformation was submitted to Supreme Court than its a grave mistake which will have a severe contempt of court on SBI.
Every political party balance sheet/ donation made by the company's balance sheet the amount would be mentioned.
@@mai_Varun_hoon I am not getting it , can you provide the link pls
Absolute quality content… keep it up buddy… thats how you explain without taking any sides 👏
watch @6:00 even now black money transactions (Cash Money) happens... At 2019 General election BJP spent more than 25,000 crores after the Electrol bond was introduced in 2018, don't be a BJP supporter man be true to yourself 1st.
@@ashok92j That's the problem with today's youth, sense shree ram lay gaye unki.
@@ashok92j you’re well within your rights to think that way.. cheers buddy… but in my opinion, the reality of the situation is that no political party can exist without taking donations, be it black or white doesn’t matter. Today its bjp in the limelight, tomorrow it will be some other party.
@@Alihadi261it's not abt donations but how donations were taken and how govt. Used agencies to take donations.He didn't even mention a unique sequence which r on electoral bonds and can be used by the government to know who donated to opposition and they can use that in their favor
I would say be balanced and show the reality..
lots of people are watching you across the globe ..
we want to understand the issue by watching you ..!!
Keep up with good work ..!!
Very very aunthentic content...Tysm🙌🏻
Unpopular opinion
Ganesh knows where and how to place names in a video, Interesting choice of party names at important junctures.
For a guy who claims to be trained in using prompts for AI interactions, the choices seems interesting to say the least.
Will keep watching his videos though
Yeah I too felt so 😂
Yeah sometimes I feel he embarks his own narrative upon us by doing these small and simple things....what we need is unbiased info but I don't think that he is unbiased now
I think he is even afraid of taking a particular party name in an example also😂😂😂😂
Modi h tho sab mumkin h 💀
He is very biased. People with common sense will understand him. Placing congress name in negative examples in the video. Indirect brainwashing.
Simply brilliant... What an explanation ganesh... Kudos to the effort u n ur team puts in...
Voting for Congress ✅ this time😢, bjp is as successful as their RS 2000 note😅
Here’s the complete picture, Tmc has 19 mps which accounts to 3.5% of total seats in Lok Sabha, 13 seats in Rajya Sabha (5.3%), and 228 mlas(5.64%), whereas the electrol bonds raised worth 1609.50Cr which’s about 12.57% of total Electoral bonds. Congress has 47 mp (8.65%) 28 Rajya Sabha members(11.42%) 676 mlas (16.74%) 55 Mlc (12.9%) govt(or part of) in states and UT is 5 (16%). The electoral bonds raised is 1421.90Cr about 11.1% of total. BJP has 290 MP (excluding vancant seats , 303 including) (53.4,55.8%) 94 Rajya Sabha mem (38.36) 1,484 mla (36.77%) 165+23 mlc (43%) number of states and UT 18 (58%). The electrol bonds raised worth 6060.50Cr which accounts for 47.34%. BRS has 6 mp (1.1%) 39 mla (0.95%) has raised 1214.70 about 9.48% of total electoral bond. The point is, theis electoral bonds has to looked at whether they are proportionate to size and reach of party.
I love the quality and unbiased documentation of your channel
Seems Congress party and Rahul planning on campaign electoral bonds and Ambani/Adani, but both are not big donors in the list SBI provided. Big adisappointment for Rahul and his team before elections. Katam gaya 2024 bi 😂
There is so call shell company exist.
@SanjaiKrishna-yy8gz what about qwik supply which obviously is owned or operated by reliance
There's no proof of that, it's just speculations@@krishnanunni_7777
I guess U dont seem to know about the concept of shell companies..moreover do Adani and Ambani look so stupid that they will donate openly under their registered company names....?
Your innocent, soft minded (yes, you’re) comment reminds me of the dialogue- “baitho beta, abhi bahot kuch seekhna hai zindagi me.”
How many high courts and supreme court judges have declared their assets? How would we know that their decision is not influenced by money? Where's the right to information in this case?
Dy chandrachur is one of finest and influenced cji india have ever seen that too in period of where every constitutional bodies cbi , ed are being used
Cji is fighting for the right of a people who themselves are not aware they have rights 😂😂
Unko baad mein rajya sabha ki seat milti hai bas, no assets
@@SunnyKumar-fy4st agreed he is. But the concerns he raised about political parties, does the same concerns not applies to judiciary of the country? Plus we people in a democracy doesn't have the right to select judges, there's zero transparency in that. The system is flawed, n it has always been since independence n everyone one is just taking advantage of it instead of fixing it. Plus cji doesn't need cbi, ed that has always been tool for the ruling gov be it congress or bjp, whoever is in power has used them. CJI has the power above all of them, he can simply overturn any decisions taken by parliament, he can bend laws for his judgements benifit. What more power does he wants!
@@riskcatriax the moment citizen gets to choose judge .soon we will have rapist judge making judgement saying it's girls fault why do u think people are capable of making the right choice it's clear they are not look at the parliament and unconstitutional laws made by the parliaments judiciary system is flawless as it is now