Anuj Dhar on Netaji Subhas and ‘The Mystery’ with Sanjay Dixit
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- Anuj Dhar speaks to Sanjay Dixit on the mystery of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose's disappearance, and his impact on India's independence.
#Netaji #SubhashChandraBose #TheTashkentMystery #Live #JaipurDialogues
💸Support Sanjay Dixit and Jaipur Dialogues - www.jddigital....
🖊Ask Questions via WhatsApp - +91 8619317791
📰Jaipur Dialogues Indic Portal - www.thejaipurd...
👉Follow Us On - 👈
👉Telegram - t.me/thejaipur...
👉Facebook - / thejaipurdialogues
👉Instagram - / thejaipurdialogues
👉Twitter - / jaipurdialogues
💸Support Sanjay Dixit and Jaipur Dialogues - www.jddigital.in/support/
Is Q & A video intentionally delayed ?
Please highlight this issue.All Indians should know the true liberator of country and he was indeed gumnami Baba. This would a great tribute to the greatest son of motherland.
Anuj dhar is telling all cooked all false and fabricated stories of Gumnami Baba.
There was no Gumnami Baba.
What nonsense has Anuj Dhar spoken. He is attempting to prove that Subhash Chandra Bose was Coward.
@@SandeepKumar-nn6prAnuj dhar is not talking shit. He has given all proofs by which any normal human being can clearly understand that the Saint was Netaji in disguise
Subhas is not just another forgotten hero. He is the actual reason for independence .
Gandhi is not the father of nation in true sense, who else agrees with this !!!!!
Azad hind fauj ke dar se Angrejo ne 1932 se hi Constitution committee ki rachna Kar rakhi thi, aur world war jitne ke baad bhi na sift Bharat par doosri sabhi colonies ko bhi Azad Kar Diya. Yeh dar itna prabhavi raha hi sirf Angrej nahi French bhi apni colonies chod ke chale gaye
@@g.gautam7617 i
Absolutely agree
मेरे पास शब्द ही नहीं है, जयपुर डायलॉग आप प्रशंसा के पात्र हैं 🙏🏻
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose followed Swamy Vivekananda..It is unfortunate for India that India could not have Netaji as her first PM..
The fact that Netaji had declared Independence of our motherland from the British Raj and pronounced himself as PM in 1943 and what we got was " separation of powers" that separated India from British occupation. Therefore, whatever the history may record but the truth is that Nataji was the first PM after declaration of Independence.
@@ggfg8570 right
Both were bengali kayasthas like me✌😇. Proud to be a kayastha
@@sidharthadey5781
🌹JAY PARSHURAM 🌹
@@shandilyakumar7470 Jay parshuram, jay chitragupt. Brahman kayastha eakta zindabad
Anuj Dhar is one of the best 🙏👍 respect for his work
Indeed he is. Back in 2007 during my college days I worked for Mission Netaji and met all these guys . There commitment level is 200% .
Yogi ji future Prime minister 🔥
Cartoon man
Modi hai tho Mumkin nhi
Hindu ek hai tho Mumkin hai
Always remember this 🙏🚩💪
@@Sunny-rh6ik jee haa
@@Sunny-rh6ik Shree Modiji 70 ke ho gaye hai. Aur BJP ke policy hai ke PM ko 2 term ke baad change karte hai BJP me. Shree Yogi ji Maharaj 50 saal ke hai. Vohi banenge ab Future Prime minister 🔥🚩💪✌️
Thank you very much Jaipur Dialogues for this session. Anuj Dhar and his colleagues have done fabulous research. This subject is very close to my heart. I also recommend everyone here to please watch the movie 'Gumnaami' on Amazon Prime based on the same.
Extremely clear cut presentation, Anuj ji separates the wheat from the chaff with admirable precision, ample demonstration of his deep expertise on the subject. True Pandit, not the fake chacha variety. We can call him the only Bosologist!! 🥰🇮🇳🙏🏽
Bosologist, haha love that
Nehru is the only corrupted kashmiri pandit i know
One of your best sessions. What a tragedy for our country. My all-time hero Netaji.
I followed Abuj Dhar for 4 years.
I believe that M k Gandhi was a British agent planted and transported from South Africa and there is no doubt that Nehru was a British agent.
कतई ब्रेनवॉश हो गया है फिर तो आपका!
@@anand1311 Bilkul logical baatein hai ye. Aapko bhi gaur karna chahiye.
@@anand1311 NCRT kid?
plz plz do one more session with him,n specifically ask him to put light on gumnami bsba's role in 62,65,71 war plz
You can read conundrum
@@realspirit4915 yes i will for sure,but give an opportunity to here it from his own mouth,i can read it but nt everyone:s gonna read it 🙏
Being a senior Citizen and follower of Subash Chandra Bose I would like to give Many many thanks to Anuz Dhar for discussing about the un solved issue since more than seventy years. Simple matter made critical by our top ranking leaders causing save guard their conspiracy. It is very shameful matter that Still our Govt/ front side leaders or any party have no any good intention about the sensitive matter
Sanjay Dixit ji, Request : Please try not to cut-short a conversation (esp involving Netaji) when the guest is in flow...let him continue. Anuj Dhar saab is a gem, rational, non-emotional & straight. I know superchat revenue is important for sustaining the channel & listening to donors, but still make a exception once in a while. please dont time-bound a conversation, let it go on. A little more longer will not harm. there are podcasts that go on for more than 3hrs in youtube. anyways,Keep doing the good work.
I also feel sometime sanjayji should let them speak without any time bounds Or he can continue it in next episode/podcast
Fully agreed✌️🙏
Yes sir plz give them more time
Or make it in two parts. 1hr each video.
Should continue in next episode
अनुज जी ये हमारी गलती नहीं है कि हमे याद नहीं, ये इसलिए याद नहीं क्यूंकि ये बात कभी बताई गई ही नहीं गई. अब आप लोगों जैसे महा अनुभवों द्वारा पता लाग रही है. अब ये है कि बच्चों को भी बताएंगे. आपका धन्यवाद 🙏
👁️🇮🇳🎈🎊🎉🎀YES! YOU ARE RIGHT SAYING ❣️🙏 WE SHOULD AWARE OUR NEW GENERATION 💞🤹OUR NEW BHARAT ZINDABAD 🇮🇳🔥🏇✍️
Thank you Sanjay ji for giving platform to a true Desh Bhakt like Anuj Dhar🙏
Finally anuj dhar my favorite person and writer
धन्यवाद सर, आप जैसे लोग ही हमें सही हिस्ट्री बताते हैं और ये आजकल बहुत जरूरी है जब हमें दूसरों को जवाब देना हो/ सर आपकी बातें wrong narrative से लड़ने में मदद करती हैं/
Sanjay ji, next time request you to bring Vikram Sampath to your platform. He is one of the few who has written honestly about Veer Savarkar ji, one of India's forgotten heroes 🙏
सर, मैं सुभाषचंद्र जी जैसे देश भक्त की इतनी बड़ी प्रशंसक हूँ लग रहा है आपकी एक एक बात लिख कर रखलूं/ I hate congress, Gandhi and Nehru.
mere Liye bhi sirf BOSE aur SAVERKER aur BHAGATSINGH jaise VEER KRANTIKAREEO aurSARDAR VALLABH BHAI PATEL hee PUJYA aur SAMMANIYA VYAKTITVA hai aur koi nahi bas.🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Madam Ji Aap log yeh jaankar hairan ho jaayenge Netaji Aaj bhi zinda hain, Woh abhi Gyanganj Siddhashram yani ke Sambhala Mein aaj bhi deep meditation mein hain. Aur woh aayenge, samay aane par.
Hate k list me communist bhi jod lijiye ma'am.... ye congress aur gandhi , nehru sabhi communism k admirers thhe....
Shalini, if you want to spread the word; do a book report/summary of his book with timeline
@@technologytodays425 bro logically Neta ji abhi 100 years ke ho chuke he ...possible nahi lagta ab vo jinda hoge
Neta ji and savarkar theory seem more practical if future the narritve change entire history will change.
The topic and presentation was so engaging that I never got bored and at the end I felt that many facts were not brought to my knowledge and I feel that this video should havd been longer. However, I thank you Dixit Sir, for bring such topics to light.
Thanks
I come from a family whose generations have worked in the national security establishment. And I can say one thing with 100% surety that Babaji never had PTSD. He was all-seeing and all-knowing. His works and his sadhna will bear fruit soon. Wait till the country finds about his followers in Pauri Garhwal district. After reading Conundrum, all I can say that Anuj Sir has done commendable research and persuation but have only scratched the surface.
I pray to god that this matter becomes a national issue in the coming bengal elections, so that people start talking about this issue. Our hero should get his due.
@@uttkarshmishra4944 His followers across the world outnumber those in India itself. You will see very soon. His work never stopped. Watch the United States during January very closely. 'THE START'.
what do you mean by "the start"
@@kunikrajput1457 You will see. The world is about to change.
Can you please explain
Anuj Dhar we respect for your work and dedication.keep it up.we want to listen more and more.Thanks Sanjay Sir for this platform of truth.
रोमटे खड़े हो गए हैं शत शत प्रणाम हमारे नेता जी को 🙏🙏😭😭😭 अनुज सर आपके साथ में मरते दम तक ये लड़ाई लडूंगा। हर समय खड़ा हूँ आप बस हमारे नेता जी को उनका ओहदा वापस दिला दो और इन हरामजादो की औकात देश के सामने लाओ।🙏🙏🙏🙏
सर, आपकी देश भक्ति अलग तरह की है आपको हृदय से प्रणाम🙏/आप राष्ट्र के दीपक है जो समाज के पथ प्रदर्शक हैं/
जयहिंद जयसनातन जयसीयाराम
Fabulous job you done by giving us the knowledge we proud and very very sad to loose such great leader like Neata Subash Bose
🌹NETAJI SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE (TIGER) AMAR RAHE 🇮🇳
Now Putin is close to modi ji , why not this matter disclose .
My grand parents told me Gandhi is main guide to destroy Subhash to stabilised nehru.
You are absolutely right gandhi was nehrudas he did everything to divide india give pakistan 55 crore rupees in 1947 netaji and azad hind fauj collected treasure for india nehru looted that money and deposited in Singapore in his own account
Very shrewd cunning both gandhi nehru
Anuj Dhar ji you did a great work for the unforgettable hero Subash Chandra. He was really hero.🙏🙏
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose Amar Rahe 🇮🇳
Thank you sir for giving us this knowledge.
Very blatant and interesting sharing of facts. I wish some day, we indians will have courage to openly accept it
After hearing this ,why some day you all should accept the truth and facts now as the research shows the fact.thanks to anil dhar , hoping you all respect his work.
@@rohinibali6662 I have accepted the fact. So much efforts are taken, so many proofs are given. Yet it's not reached the majority and the respect he deserves is not given. That's why I said, It should be officially and publically accepted.. there should not be any ambiguity
@@vibs99 thanks and it's clearly stated.maybe one day good you will be heard and appreciated. Keep pushing.
A learning of whole 70 yrs of research on Shubash "the Leader", thank you ! I am buying ur book
I'm working right now and after listening facts over here I can't stand and can't work. I'm completely emotional. I watched a short video of GD Bakshi sir and he was saying we all are of NETAJI and INIDAN NATINAL ARMY'S. And now it's clear why we are.
Jai Hind.
There should be a detailed talk on INA trials with Anuj Dhar
I am becoming a big fan of you guys compare to filmstars and politician
. Cricketer is atleast loyal to their respective countries . But our real hero are our true freedom fighters. Thank u sir .
कादम्बिनी के भूतपूर्व संपादक स्वर्गीय श्री राजेंद्र अवस्थी ने मुझे बताया था की उनकी गुमनामी बाबा से भेंट हुई थी और वही नेता जी थे।
कादम्बिनी बुक जो आती थी उसके सम्पादक
@@happylife1382 हां
Anuj Sir is very factual and Practical.
Please do today's session with anujji only its a spark on a long sleeping history talk about all the things which came up in this talk!
Yes ..we should bring this to light and get our history books straight at least for our future generations
Salute Anuj Sirji
बोहोत ही सोर्य💪 पूर्ण रहा ये वाला संवाद 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Anuj sir research is excellent👍👍👍 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
अनुज जी आपके काम को शुभकामनाये. सुभाष जी के बारे मे जब भी सोचता हू तब आखोंमे आसू आजाते है. जिस इन्सान के लिये लोग अपना खून देने के लिये तयार थे वो इन्सान ने देश के लिये अपने आप को 40 साल तक गुमनामी मे रखा.
मैं भी सुभाष चंद्र बोस चंद्रशेखर आजाद यहां तक की राजीव दीक्षित जी के बारे में भीहमारे मन में है कि इनके मौत का भी इंक्वायरी किया जाए
@@komalshukla1134 और शाश्त्री जी कि भी होनी चाहिये
Great work anuj ji 🙏.. Jaipur dialogue always good👍
It is crystal clear that Bhagwan ji is our Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. There is no doubt.
Anuj sir aapke hardwork ki wajah se netaji subhas Chandra bose ke bare me itna knowledge mila.Thank u🙏
OMG lots of knowledge and Information , thank you Anuj ji 🙏🙏
Outstanding.
Ones I saw a vedio, that subash bose's dougter (kid) (anitha bose)(her mom German) visited kerala. "what they saying, about subash bose's death??? “
No words to say about your work only salute
After listening such great things about Netaji Subhashchandra Bose, i feel the present Government is waiting for right time to reveal/declassify all the documents relating Netaji to public. It will be like opening of a Pandora Box which will open all things/secrets. Wait & Watch at present.
And when will this right time come ! . Maybe during the elections time ?
Or maybe never ....
Only we can make this in limelight.
Agar social media pe kuch bhi ulta sidha trend hojata h to why not Netaji's issue . We all should stand alongside eachother to rise this issue ..
Anuj Dhar ne sabko Dhar liya..
I support #Netaji
#SubhashChandraBose
Great work and effort by Anuj Dhar Ji in raising the conscience of the Bharat in recognition of the truth that has been hidden for such a long time.
👏👍🙏
We need more knowledge on the topic which all are left because of the time line.
Please make a session on those sir.
I wish Anuj ji study veer Savarkar and write a book on him. 🙏 Sanjay ji, I wish you make one more program with Anuj ji on Netaji. And one program on Shastriji. 🙏🙏
We have got Independence of India mainly for the greatest mother land Lover & the All in All of Azad Hind Government, Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose!
We are also proud of Sanjay Dikshit ji, for his on-going work.
Most excellent discussion! Excellent information here
I have read all the books written by Anuj Dhar ,Chandrachur Ghosh..I believe in his theory regarding Netaji..He is actually absolutely right that even Bengal also worships Gandhi.. I am a fan of Modi ji but I can't understand that he can make Patel's statue but not Netaji's statue..Mere dilme to Khudiram Bose, Bhagat Singh,Bagha jotin,Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose hai.. ..So books me kya likha hai I don't care ..Mai to mere bachche ko shikhaungi ki hamare desh ka asli hero Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose, Baghajotin, Khudiram Bose, Bhagat Singh hai..
The only reason we r free from british rule is netaji, I wouldn't call it independence but still this was also achieved mostly because of netaji and his works...
Sir.. we have complete belief in your work on Bose. Hopefully that our history can be re-written and not be the Lal salaam people and Congress.
अश्विन सर आपने वादा किया था कि अनुज जी को फिर बुलाएंगे कुछ बाते अधूरी रह गई थी🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
As Mark Twain said " It is easy to mislead people, but it is tough to explain people that they have been mislead".
Thank you so much.... My blood is boiling and tears in my eyes
Truth must prevail..! ✊
Awesome discussion. Anuj Dhar is very compelling.
Gratitude...Respect ...Thanks . God Bless You
Subhash Chander Bose is a True Neta ji EVER !
No doubt Mam
Anuj and Sanjay ji please bring the truth that India got independence due to Subhash and not by Gandhi, please destroy the false edifice of Gandhi and Nehru's India.
Real hero of india....
Real soul of india...
Great work Sir.
Great work ❤️❤️we love जयपुर डायलॉग 🇮🇳
Live video was perfect it wasn't getting stuck, but this uploaded video has this problem; whenever Anuj Dhar is speaking his image is freezing.
Mera fav channel Jaipur diolog
Anuj Sir,
I have great respect for you,
Ayodhya, by tradition, which is based on beliefs of many successive generation's, is what today you call faizabad - Ayodhya area.
Same way In Jewish oral and written Historic tradition there are many places which has disappeared or displaced.
finally in 20th & 21st century Archeology is coming catching up with answers.
Please carry on your good works.
Regards to you and Dixit Sir.
Vikrant Salunke
Nagpur
wo originally desh ke hero the chahte to sab sukh suvidha le sakte te salute to neta ji and Anuj Bhai fr yur great wrk
Dr.Anuj Dhar Bharat Ratna
मेरी उम्र ७३साल है,, अनुज आपके सारे लेख पढ़ी इस समय भी सुन रही हूँ हमारी ओर से आपको आपकी टीम को बहुत बहुत ashervad
Very high class discussion.Please carry on such programme in future as well All the best
Hum Bengali SAb bacche Netaji k bare main jante hai..lekin Baki state main bahut log Nahi jante
Why I can't control my tears? Because of the Greatest Freedom fighter of all time that is Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose. We have failed to give him his due credit till now.
Thank you so much Shri #Anuj_Dhar Sir for selecting my #Question and Shri #Sanjay_Dixit Sir for announcing it as the #Best_Question....!!
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
This is my 2nd Best Question award...!!!
👆🏼
Once again, Thank You very much Sir to you and #The_Jaipur_Dialogues....!!
I'm grateful to you...
💐🌷🌼🌹🏵️🌸
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
धन्यवाद, आपका बहुत-बहुत आभार...!!
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
gumnaami babai netaji subhas chandra bose thaa
Mr Anuj your Analysis is quite clear, after listening you my soul is crying for Netaji soul, from so many years we kept quite, it is disgrace to be an Indian this leaders has sold souls of all the Indian
Jai Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose
Very important discussion on Jaipur Dialogues. There is no one better to talk about the issue than Anuj Dhar and his colleagues who have done painstaking research on the subject and their actions are gradually raising awareness among the people which will one day compel the govt to act. Unfortunately, unless the curse of Gandhism is removed from the soul of India, there is no hope for the Hindus of rising from the stupor into which they have sunk.
I remember I first watched Anuj Dhar in some video on RUclips
Than I was watching taskhant file's
I was shocked ki are yar ye tho famous aadmi hai
And I was shouting ki I know this man
Special Force
No this ruclips.net/video/F0HQqmHk3Pk/видео.html
It was 4 years back
When is the question answer session due ?
Sir, अपने इस विडिओ में काफी बड़ा पार्ट कट कर दिया ,,,वो लाहौर वाला । plz उसको भी के छोटे vedio के फॉर्म में अपलोड कर दीजिये । निवेदन है 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Sir.. Can you do More sessions with Anuj sir and do more research with him..?
Great analysis by shri Anuj Dhar . It gives very nice feeling that our respected and dear Netaji was perhaps not tortured to death in Russia . However M. General G . D . Bakshi has a different view . I request kindly consider presenting another view by either Mr. Bakshi or any his associates who can present similar detailed analytical account or any other study about Netaji you deem fit .
S . K . Verma ( user )
I’ve waiting for this! Way to go! Sare Deshpremi ekjuth ho!
One of the best discussions
Great session. Sir when is the QnA video being uploaded for this one ?
To be totally honest due to my knowledge and the way I see this, history can be sensitive and very conversational subject. Everyone has a option and point of view which can be leading toward such a debate, people have the right to speak freely which is totally fine.
Salute to u sir
Rewrite India's history..netaji was phenomenal ❤️❤️
आदरणीय श्री अनुज देवधर जी को मैंने नेताजी सुभाष चंद्र बोस को लेकर पुष्पेंद्र कुलश्रेष्ठ सहाब जी की डिबेट में मैंने खूब सुना है🙏
anuj dhar ji aap great ho...aap jesa desh bhakt k lie subash chandra bose ji k bre m itna research kia hai...aal jese patriot sab koi ho...jai hind..