Which Commentary of the Quran is Best? | Dr. Shabir Ally
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Q&A with Dr. Shabir Ally. A viewer asks, “Which commentary of the #Quran is best?” Dr. #ShabirAlly explains that each commentary is good for a different purpose, so it depends on what your needs and interests are. He mentions a few that are available in the #English language. He also reveals which commentary he uses and which one is his favourite.
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks...
► SUBSCRIBE: www.youtube.co...
COMMENT, LIKE and SHARE
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks
Dear friends, please subscribe to our email newsletter for details about our Ramadan programming. Visit our website quranspeaks.com to subscribe. Thank you!
instablaster...
1-Tafsir ibn kathir
2-mufti Mohammad shafi(translated by mufti taqi usmani
3-Mohammad Asad
4-Imam Al razi
Al-Kashshaaf by Al-Zamakshari.
Tadabbur-e-Quran by Amin Ahsan Islahi is a treasure. Absolute gold.
Dr Shabir Ally is so honest.
Dr. Shabir MashAllah! you are doing a great job with your "Let the Quran Speak" team. JazakAllah Khair.
Please remember him and the entire team in your duas :)
would like to request u Sir , to make a tafsir with modern approach
Please look at the work of Sayyad Abul Ala Maududi- Tafheem ul Quran
thank you for letting me know about this. I am from a Hispanic country and most are Catholic so we don't have this ( that i know of) in Spanish. Most of it I was relying on my brain to understand Quran
Assalamu alaikum, puedes encontrar el tafsir Al-Qurtubi traducido al castellano, son 10 volúmenes si no me equivoco, es mejor comprar los libros, pero si no es posible, encontrarás los archivos en pdf haciendo una búsqueda en Google.
@@ajazin gracias un montón 🤗
Beautiful! JazarkhaAllah khairan! May Allah bless you always, ameen! Jzk for the reminder of the excellence that Tafsir Authors spent to help us attempt to access and understand the meanings of our beautiful holy Quran🌻🌺🌻
Ameen to your duas! Thank you for watching.
May Allah help all the people. Aameen.
Just to respectfully update the Shiekh,
Al Qurtubi has now recently been translated upto the end of of Juzz 4 Alhamdulillah by Aisha Bewley I have it on my bookshelf at home, Masha Allah.
Agree, with the comment that Mariful Quran is a more modern and easier tafsir to read Alhamdulillah,
May Allah swt give us sound knowledge Insha Allah.
Does Vol.4 have the commentary on 4:159? Could you please share it here if it does? Thanks
@@imgguru1277 sura 4:157-159 is controversial tafseer lol. Some people might say someone else was substituted of jesus and some people would say jesus was swooned. But sura 4:157 is mostly denying that Jesus was not killed. Only Allah knows best what exactly happened in the crucifixion.
Isn't it fully translated?
@@parvezkewar Al Qurtubi tafseer is not fully translated into English.
Other languages i dont know.
What about Tafseer Al Razi? Available in English?
I look forward to this event.
Jazakum Allah alf khair...
I love your balanced and moderate approach
Tadabbur e Quran is by Amin Ahsan Islahi. He was the student of Imam Hamiddudin Farahi.
Farahi sahab was best scholar of recent era. He was versatile in Hebrew and Aramaic text. He had discovered Nazm (sequence-tarteeb) in Holy Quran.
Amin Ahsan Islahi completed the milestone achievement in the form of Tadabbur e Quran started by Imam Farahi.
Video summarized:
Tafsir by Ibn Kathir (RH) - English and Arabic
Tafsir by Al-Tabari and Al-Qurtubi (RH) - (Advanced) Arabic only
Mufti Taqi Usmani (I recommend Abdullah Yusuf Ali) - English
Jazakallah Dr Shabir, educational as always
You forgot tafsir Tabari for advanced level students, more so for scholars though , barakallahu feek for the great video
One of the best Tafseers is Tafhemul Quran, by Syed Abul Aala Moodidi. Its English translation is - The Meaning of Quran.
We definitely need a version with Dr. Shabir's translation of 4:34!
I wonder if he has read Tadabbur-e-Quran by Amin Ahsan Islahi. It is so far my favourite and most unique tasfir. There is an English translation by the name ‘Pondering over the Quran’
do you have a copy of it? may you share it with us?
Jazak Allah Khayr
My best tafsir is Albayan written by Javed Ahmad ghamidi
What about tafsir Mohammad Tahir Ibn Ashoor?
@Let The Quran Speak can you please make a video of the best/most accurate English translations of the Quran?
0:44
The pronunciation is مفتى محمد شفيع
So, does anybody know what version I would read in order for the message alone to “hit” in the same way it did or would have all those centuries ago? I know I’ll never get the same impact and beauty as I would being born into the culture and psyche, but I’d like a version with the historical context and poetics and culture and history, which I am entirely divorced from, as best explained as possible, and I’m not sure where to begin.
Quran is for every time, and so Inshallah it will resonate with you as much as it did for the people of the past.
For example, now we can understand some things in the text, which people of the past did not know. Some scientific wonders and evidence, like the space explosion or water density. And there are still things veiled from full understading, until the time comes, I believe.
I couldn’t recommend more The Meaning of Quran for kids and same one for Adults… it includes the background of each ayat so you completely understand the context.. it gets you really close to the message.. I would def start with the kids one for sure then graduate to the adult one…
Tafseer MATALIBULFURQAN by Ghulam Ahmed Pervez(r.h) is an updated Tafseer having all the answers of the questions and confusions of the new generation.we must study scholars like Mufti Muhammad Abduhu,Rasheed Ahmed Raza,Molana Aslam jeerajpuri,Sayyed Jamulluddin AFGHANI,Javaid Ahmed ghamdi,Allama Muhammad Iqbal,Ghulam Ahmed Pervez etc.Knowledge is power when it is updated and mix up with love and affection,but un updated and expire knowledge gives birth only to sects,quarrels,frustrations, confusions,terrorism,extremism,exaggeration,and all these evils making the EARTH like a HELL. AS ALEXANDER POPE SAYS "THE LEAST CONFUSION BUT IN ONE, NOT ALL. THAT SYSTEM ONLY,BUT THE WHOLE MUST FALL.
Syed Mawdudi’s tafsir is rational and traditional at the same time.
I heard from many scholars that after ibne kathir the second best is tafseer Saadi.
Is sister safiyyah Ally daughter of Dr sabbir Ally? May almighty Allah bless both of them
Ameen
He is a professional preacher
Wonderful! By the way, I'd *love* to hear Dr. Shabir's take on the Pope's recent, historic trip to Iraq if he hasn't offered it already? As always, assalamualaikum!
We're in the middle of planning for our Ramadan programming, so this may not be possible, unfortunately :( Sorry about that.
@@QuranSpeaks Well good luck with that, maybe some other time then.
@@ericjorgensen4032 thank you for the excellent suggestion, and sorry we weren't able to take it up ☹
@@QuranSpeaks No worries at all ! I appreciate everything you do
@@ericjorgensen4032 thank you!
I would be grateful if the list of tafsirs spoken here is included at the bottom of the video as part of additional information. Thank you!
@Rayrad 696 STOP Trolling a group with your irrelevant comments. If you do not have any relevant comments to the topic of discussion, stop your advertising and evangelizing. WE WILL NOT WALK BACK.
I want to hear more from Dr. Shabir about other tafasir.
Love you from pakistan sir Dr sahbir Ally
Pity Imam Razi's tafseer is not available in English. I think Muhamamd Asad's is the best in the English language. Dr Shabir didn't mention most of this tafsir is really an adopation of Muhamamd Abdhu and Rasheed Rida's tafsir 'A'Manar' The light house. Most of the commentary follows Imam Tabari, Imam Zamakshari, Imam Razi , Ibn Hazm and Muhammad Asad's own insight. Thus this tafsir puts more weight on the Arabic language and rules of grammar, as opposed to ahadith.
Generally the following are the tafsirs considered the foundational ones even today:
1. Tafsir al Tabari
2. Tafsir of Fakhr al din Razi
3. Al Kashshaf by Zamakhshari
Tafsir al Qurtubi is an honorable mention as well.
Tafsir of ibn kathir is second after tabari
@@issaissa4974 That's a very basic and easy tafsir for new students. These are the heavy ones if you want a deep understanding
First we should know the simple translation. As I used.
In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious and Most Merciful
وَالَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا بَعْضُهُمْ أَوْلِيَاءُ بَعْضٍ ۚ إِلَّا تَفْعَلُوهُ تَكُن فِتْنَةٌ فِي الْأَرْضِ وَفَسَادٌ كَبِيرٌ
And those who disbelieve are allies of one another, (and) if you (Muslims of the whole world collectively) do not do so [i.e. become allies, as one united block under one Khalifah (a chief Muslim ruler for the whole Muslim world) to make victorious Allah's religion of Islamic Monotheism], there will be Fitnah (wars, battles, polytheism) and oppression on the earth, and a great mischief and corruption (appearance of polytheism). 8: 73
Why are we Muslims not talking about reestablishing the power and control Allah SWT give us from the beginning.
The number one concern on every Muslim's mind is the tragedy in Gazza. The destruction in Gazza is worse than that of Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined.
We have to listen to what Allah SWT is saying to us in the above ayah and from the beginning.
"Remember when your Lord said to the Angels, I am going place Khalifah on earth".... 2: 30
You see the UN is dead body in the muddy water as every resolution passed by majority, is vetoed by USA. Which means we have to reestablish the Caliphate. So we have to start our own The League of Muslim Nations under one Khalifah. And it's easy to do it.
It will be the Council of Muftis, from which they will choose the Khalifah. Under the Khalifah will be a seat for a Mufti from every country in world with 300,000 plus Muslim population. From every municipality we will choose a representative till we have the Council of Muftis for that country with a Grand Mufti of that country to sit in the Council of Muftis under the Khalifah. All communication can be done remotely with everyone working from home. Most effective and real democratic way of governing where all decisions are made by the Council of Muftis but the Khalifah having the final say. Under the Khalifah, the LMN will have its own army, navy and Air Force under one commander for defending the entire ummah. We already have the hardware from major Muslim countries. They just have relabeled "LMN" when they out to defend any part of the Ummah like removing the Mediterranean Sea blockade by Israelis.The three letters "LMN" will be enough to deter anyone from doing what is happening in Gazza today. But we have to be the Nation of Al Muttaqun for Allah SWT is saying now:
"You are the Best of People ever raised up for Mankind, enjoining what is Good, forbidding what is evil and believe in Allah SWT" .... Quran 3: 110
How can we go wrong when the fear of "LMN" will overwhelm the hearts of our enemies?
That is what Islam is and we are Muslims to resolve every matter in a Peaceful manner, Insha Allah. Alhamdu Lillah.
I sincerely invite all Muslims to join me in this effort, for if we fail, we will still get one Hashanah for our intentions, Insha Allah
Jazak Allah Khair
Your brother
Abu Saad
Khalifah-to-be (as Son of Adam, AS)
Can u make a tafsir on Quran Dr Shabir Uncle keeping in consideration the modern approach
I don’t understand 5:33. I read Muhammad Asad’s explanation found a PDF. He didn’t explain 5:33 just repeated the verse.
fakru din al razi was a really intelligent polymath. Its a shame that his exegesis isnt translated in english. This needs to be done !
Al-Kashaaf from Al-Zamakshari is a Master work. Al-Razi's Tafseer is based upon Al Kashaaf.
Assalamualaykum warahmatullahi wabarakatuhu. Please remove the music at the end. Jazak Allah khayr
Great to be here first
So i'm not a religious person nor have i ever really cared because i always felt religion did not mix with science how ever hearing this guy is making me to start rethinking alot of stuff i just ask how evolution is thought about with this religion if i could get an explanation thats explains this to me might have full on convert and become religious so far i think this guy the only guy who could explain this in a way for me to get on bord
Okay, first things first I'm not here to convert or something, you're free to believe whatever you want to, aight?
Now let me ask you few things first:
1) According to science/biology:- Where did the life start? At what particular place like land, wind, water?
2) Big Bang explains the origin of universe, right? I agree, it does. But whatever is created has a driving force right? Just like driving force for evolution is Natural selection, in the same manner there must be a driving force for Big bang too, what was it?
3) What was before Big Bang? How did Singularity come into existence all of a sudden itself?
Just ponder over these, and answer me. I'm not debating or something,its just a friendly convo. And moreover I wont be able to tell you much above Big Bang as my knowledge is limited, but I am well versed with biology, as I'm a biology student myself.
وَلَا يَأْتُونَكَ بِمَثَلٍ إِلَّا جِئْنَاكَ بِالْحَقِّ وَأَحْسَنَ تَفْسِيرًا
[25:33] Whatever argument they come up with, we provide you with the truth, and a BETTER UNDERSTANDING.
THE BEST TAFSIIR!
Is there english translate of Fakhruddin Razi's great commentary of Qur'an? And where can I find it? Thanks
Sadly no, but here's a translation of the first chapter of the Quran: www.amazon.ca/Great-Exegesis-al-Tafsir-al-Kabir-Fatiha/dp/191114121X
@@QuranSpeaks Thank you very much for the information. I am suprised that exist only first chapter in english, and still there are so many pages. Do you know how big is whole Tafseer al Razi actually on arabic?
Where is tafsir of abul ala moududi
And sayyad qutub?????
Assalamualaikum Dr Shabir, I would like to know your thoughts on Elon musk. Do you like him or dislike him? What are your thoughts?
Would the Q&A be between 5-7pm Greenwich Mean Time?
Greenwich where? Connecticut?
@@Iammram London, England (UK)
@@PlanetaryCitizen So then you're right, 5 hour difference.
@@Iammram okay
@Planetary Citizen, yes, that's correct. Sunday, April 4 at 5-7 pm your time. We'd be honoured to have you join us!
javed ghamidi, hamid uddin farahi, muhammad asad all are good
Anyone read Thomas cleary's translation ?
Alhamdulliah the topi is back from the laundry .missed it
Maarif-ul-Quraan of Mufti Taqi Usmani is the most rational tafseer.
He is an innovator please don't listen to him, he thinks celebrating christmas is okay. Christmas aka the day the supposed "son of" God was born wa li adhubila.
Read these tafsir instead:
Ibn Kathir
As sa'di
These are perfect alhamdoulilah.
Follow those who follow in the footsteps of the prophet (ﷺ)
Love the showwwwwwwwwwwww.
Mohammed Asad Tafsir confuses me.
I was really interested to know who shabbir ally follows.
Thank u for this video......it's very clear he is a Deobandi
No he's not!
❤❤❤
@ 27-08-2024
Many people in many religion have dedicated there life in translation, and other great work, due to there love for God, there definition of understanding of God is quite different than Islam , like Hindus , Sikhs and even Christian's
, This amazes me, every religion thinks they are better
I have a question...rather, I need clarification.
The Quran, when written in Arabic, is considered a perfect book and is copied precisely as it was 1400 years ago. However there are many translations in English and other languages that do not contain the mathematical anomalies.
Is this why we are encouraged to learn the Quran in Arabic?
Thank you for your time and knowledge Dr. Ally!
Thank you for your question. Can you clarify what you mean by mathematical anomalies?
@@QuranSpeaks the certain math equations that are found from counting the Aayats vs Chapters and the occurrence of specific multipliers, like the ones mentioned in earlier videos.
@@kandirussell5024 the so called mathematical miracle of 19 has been disproved. Muslims don't need mathematical miracles to prove anything.
@@mohamedrahaman9238 thank you so much for your immediate, precise and well formed answer.
@@mohamedrahaman9238 I've seen quite a lot of information to the contrary but nothing supporting your statement. Could you link that information so that I may increase my understanding. Again, I am extremely grateful to receive an answer in such a reasonable time frame. Thank you!