Good job but you missed the part that Finrod helped Beren and they were captured by Sauron in tol sirion... There luthien helped Beren escape.. Also Beren tried to take another silmaril from the crown and the tip of his knife broke and hit Morgoth in the face waking him up
Thanks so much! Yep, i had to resume the story because it's too long, my plan was tell that when i'll tell Finrod story. For not show the same in two videos. Again thanks so much for your time here!
Great job I to couldn’t wait to hear when Finrod saves Beren and the battle of Sauron and Huan .But I totally understand you can only get so much into a video .👍👍👍
I just realised this channel might end up being the flagship of consistent and lore accurate videos of Silmarillion content. You'll definetely be big if you keep this quality up!
I just wanted to point out that Luthien's cape was made out of her hair; it was Kvothe's cape which was made out of shadows. There, I made my nitpick; now keep up this awesome work, and may God bless you. 🙏🏻👍🏻💪🏻👊🏻🤩
These are well done. Much is missing. Someone mentioned Finrod, and his fate. Beren cut the Silmaril from Morgoth's crown with a knife he took from Curufin, and awakened Morgoth when the knife as he tried to cut out a second Silmaril. And the wolf's name is Carcharoth (pronounced CAR-ca-roth). My apologies for nitpicking.
thanks a lot! Due to the number of beautiful details in the story, I have to leave some things out, because of the difficulty in generating the correct images and movements, very summarized versions are necessary. People think you just input a prompt and get exactly what you want, but it doesn’t work that way. You have to repeat it many times to get something decent. I'm not exaggerating when I say I’ve spent around 5-6 hours just to get about 20 seconds of correct footage. It gets tedious and very laborious to create a 3-minute video like this, to the point where I make mistakes, like missing pointed ears, etc. This happens because of the large number of images I have to process, and it's normal for certain details to slip by after 10 or 20 hours with a video. Sorry for this long explanation XD. Anyway, as technologies and my understanding of them improve, I'll probably redo some videos, as they will look outdated and old.
I agree! 😊. Other channels you may enjoy are the Numenorean channel and shadow of war/shadow of Mordor game clips videos. Got to love Talion but didn't like the ending.
please do a video with beren and finrod disguised as orcs and finrod fighting the werewolf and werewolf sauron vs huan and him changing into a serpent and bat creature (it can be a ret-con prequel' to this video, thanks!)
Great storytelling, love how you bring Tolkien's first ages to life! out of curiosity, what AI tools are you using to make these? Would love to play around and create more engaging videos for my philosophy channel, these look unreal
This is awesome but you have missing parts because you proceed so quick and please dont forget the dialogue. For example like morgoth and luthien dialog before luthien's song.
Thank you very much! The problem lies in the generation of images; the more detailed the narration, the more images need to be analyzed. Keep in mind that for this video, I had to generate around a hundreds images to select only the best and most suitable ones. It’s a slow process since the AI often produces results that are not usable.
Luthien Tinuviel, daughter of a high elf and a maja. One of the most powerful beings in Middle Earth. Bewitching even the nearly almighty Morgoth Bauglir to sleep. This could be - well scripted of course - one of the best stories for a great movie. So Hollywood and Amazon: keep your hands off of this story, okay!
Yea and morgoths will was so strong that he made them Show them out of hiding he just became too distracted by her beauty thats why she could use her maia gifted powers on him too☝🏻
ROP gets shat on by an AI slap-together. I loved it. Eventually, hopefully, we can rely on AI to make the Silmarillion as close to as intended as possible, and get Tolkien's brilliance out of the hands of Amazon's identity politics. Looking forward to the next!
Dude this is actually really good even though I don't know how you do it. Looking forward to new stories! I wonder if your program allows you to keep some visual consistency between characters and reuse them across various videos, that would be great for immersion. I am talking more about the various Iluvatar scenes in the other video.
Thank you very much for your time here! Yes, I use various AI programs to generate the images, and sometimes the AI is capricious with the results, although I always try to choose the best ones to maintain more consistency.
Thank you very much! I will be creating the stories of the Silmarillion and filling my playlist in a more or less chronological order. I want to tell the missing part of the journey from Doriath to Angband when I cover the story of Finrod!
@TheCottageofLostPlay it's okay we all waiting for your a beautiful video and I loved the way the story and design were presented, and it is much better
Great job! Though I understand you had to shorten the story, there are things I miss seeing like the sons of Feanor trying to kidnap Lúthien and Huan turning against them, Finrod helping Beren, or Lúthien's (and Huan) fight with Sauron. Lúthien looks a bit better here than in part 1 in my opinion, so good job there. Waiting for part 3.
Thank you very much for your time here! Yes, my intention is to fill in what is missing, review what is already there, and make the complete story in one long video, but later on. For now, I will upload part 3 tomorrow.
i use 3 AI programs for generate images, 2 for movement, 2 webs for music and sounds, and filmora for editing, all pay programs, easy around 150/200 usd per video
How many hours did you spend to produce this 3 minute video? Maybe the hardest part is to know which parts of the story will be told and which will not
Well done. But it lacks a bit of substance: for example Beren didn't just take the Silmaril he had to cut it out of Morgoth's crown. Then he tried to take a second but his knife Angrist broke. You should include the name of knifes etc. because names are magical in mythology. Names resonate with your audience. We like to her them, the story is not complete without them. You cant imagine Isildur without Narsil. And is has to be the reforged Narsil that Aragorn uses. I think you know what i mean.
thanks so much for your time here! Yes, that would be great, but the problem is that if a video like this takes me 3 days of work, if I were to include all the literal information from the book, it would probably take me a month to finish just one video, as the story is full of details. My intention is to provide a brief summary of the stories told in The Silmarillion, so that people can see and hear about certain characters and events without delving into all the wonderful details, because that would be a colossal project for just one person.
You missed out a bit of the story. Didnt Beren start his journey with a band of elves, including Finrod Felegon? They disguised themselves as orcs but got captured by Sauron and got eaten by werewolves. Also, Beren used a dagger to remove the silmarils. When he tried to remove the 2nd stone, he accidentally cut Morgoth and woke him. If such details had been missed in rings of p, then using the logic of all the haters on your site, your videos are dumb and you're an insult to tolkien. Obviously, that's all drivel. Your videos are epic! Absolutely love them. But now you've not stuck to canon, all those haters of rings of p should now start calling your videos rubbish. It's only fair. What's good for the goose... lol. Hope they dont though. I'm guessing you need to edit quite ruthlessly yet I and many others are still enjoying your work. Just a shame all these people seem to use your channel to insult rings of p. Lol i wonder if they'll all one person? Excuse my little conspiracy theory 😂. Couldn't resist.
Like others, the graphics, music, and somewhat for the narration are great. But trying to do this story in a few minutes skips way too much meaningful content. Check your pronunciations before narration as well. Please keep making these videos, as the genre is unique for Tolkien work and you will find a ton of fans.
thanks so much! summarized version in this moment it´s all i can get with actual technologies, image movement it´s a nightmare XD. someday i´ll make a video of all Outtakes i have XDXD
Great story telling! But Finrod's sacrifice can't be omitted in this epic passage.
Thanks so much! My plan it's tell it inside finrod's story
Эпично, эфектно, красиво, умно😊👍👋
Landscape shots are incredible ! Very good
thanks so much!
That is beautiful! Well done!
thanks so much!
@@TheCottageofLostPlay Welcome!
Good job but you missed the part that Finrod helped Beren and they were captured by Sauron in tol sirion... There luthien helped Beren escape.. Also Beren tried to take another silmaril from the crown and the tip of his knife broke and hit Morgoth in the face waking him up
Thanks so much! Yep, i had to resume the story because it's too long, my plan was tell that when i'll tell Finrod story. For not show the same in two videos. Again thanks so much for your time here!
I was going to say that. maybe u can use the book for the text because AI often misrepresents the story
@@TheCottageofLostPlay anyways man you are doing a great job! Keep it up!
Great job I to couldn’t wait to hear when Finrod saves Beren and the battle of Sauron and Huan .But I totally understand you can only get so much into a video .👍👍👍
yeah I was waiting for Finrod to appear, still very nice
What a nice job! I can see the hard work and a lot of respect in here. A truly Tolkien fan.
thanks so much!
Perfect for the material. Like hearing a bard tell an ancient tale. Keep up the good work!
Thanks a lot!
Wow! These videos are just epic!
Thanks so much!! Working on fall of gondolin part 2!
I just realised this channel might end up being the flagship of consistent and lore accurate videos of Silmarillion content. You'll definetely be big if you keep this quality up!
thanks so much for your words!! tomorrow i´ll update beren part 3!
@@TheCottageofLostPlay can’t wait!
Also, is there any way to listen to the song/music that is used in the first half of the video?
on the description there are the links to music i use for the video, beauty music from great musicians
@@TheCottageofLostPlay Thank you! I’ll check it out :)
This is amazing ! Can’t wait to see more ❤
thanks so much!
I just wanted to point out that Luthien's cape was made out of her hair; it was Kvothe's cape which was made out of shadows. There, I made my nitpick; now keep up this awesome work, and may God bless you. 🙏🏻👍🏻💪🏻👊🏻🤩
thanks so much!
Yeeeeeeeeeeeeessssss!!!!!
Great job❤️❤️❤️❤️
thanks so much! more on my channel!
parabéns por mais um episodio lindo e fiel a historia .. faca um longa metragem
Thanks so much!
This looks better than anything Amazon would produce
thanks so much!!
If you enjoy AI created bullshit, sure.
@@redbarchetta8782 still tells more about Amazon than AI if you think about it.
That's a lie! The short story even omits some very important details. Like the knife he used to free the gem from the crown.
this video take 3 days editing work, you think you push a button and get a video like this? yes, obviously images are ia generated
This is beautiful.
thanks! more on my channel!
Please keep this up! We need this after the disaster that is RoP
Thanks so much!!
Lie, please don't quit your day job, this is terrible.
These are well done. Much is missing. Someone mentioned Finrod, and his fate. Beren cut the Silmaril from Morgoth's crown with a knife he took from Curufin, and awakened Morgoth when the knife as he tried to cut out a second Silmaril. And the wolf's name is Carcharoth (pronounced CAR-ca-roth). My apologies for nitpicking.
thanks a lot! Due to the number of beautiful details in the story, I have to leave some things out, because of the difficulty in generating the correct images and movements, very summarized versions are necessary. People think you just input a prompt and get exactly what you want, but it doesn’t work that way. You have to repeat it many times to get something decent. I'm not exaggerating when I say I’ve spent around 5-6 hours just to get about 20 seconds of correct footage. It gets tedious and very laborious to create a 3-minute video like this, to the point where I make mistakes, like missing pointed ears, etc. This happens because of the large number of images I have to process, and it's normal for certain details to slip by after 10 or 20 hours with a video. Sorry for this long explanation XD. Anyway, as technologies and my understanding of them improve, I'll probably redo some videos, as they will look outdated and old.
@@TheCottageofLostPlay Well done. You clearly care a lot about the lore. Keep it up!
Great work!!, Keep making more videos…maybe War of Wrath and downfall of Morgoth?
thanks so much!!
This was awsome❤
thanks so much!😍🙌
Dude, this might very well be the best thing i've watched on you tube. Well done my friend 🙌🏼 👏🏼 please dont stop what you are doing 👍🏼
Thanks so much!!
I agree! 😊. Other channels you may enjoy are the Numenorean channel and shadow of war/shadow of Mordor game clips videos. Got to love Talion but didn't like the ending.
Amazing. This would be the greatest epic fantasy movie ever made!!!!! Followed by Turin.
thanks so much! today third part!
Looking forward to part 3! ❤
Thanks! Working on it, will be ready this week!
Fantastic! Thank you! Please keep going.
thanks so much!! working on part 3
@@TheCottageofLostPlay Awesome. I wanna see it already 🙏
please do a video with beren and finrod disguised as orcs and finrod fighting the werewolf and werewolf sauron vs huan and him changing into a serpent and bat creature (it can be a ret-con prequel' to this video, thanks!)
thanks so much! yep. it´s on my plan, i think first i´ll do part 4. later that one and later the full version
Love it!!
thanks so much!!
Are you making more beautiful AI Tolkien topics?Just wonderful
Great work 👍
thanks so much!
Love your videos man! Please make an entire series! 😂
thanks so much! yes, that´s the plan, you can see part 1, ainulindale and fingolfin on my channel! today beren part 3!
Great storytelling, love how you bring Tolkien's first ages to life!
out of curiosity, what AI tools are you using to make these? Would love to play around and create more engaging videos for my philosophy channel, these look unreal
This is awesome but you have missing parts because you proceed so quick and please dont forget the dialogue. For example like morgoth and luthien dialog before luthien's song.
Thank you very much! The problem lies in the generation of images; the more detailed the narration, the more images need to be analyzed. Keep in mind that for this video, I had to generate around a hundreds images to select only the best and most suitable ones. It’s a slow process since the AI often produces results that are not usable.
Is so beautiful see this level of dedication to make the history knows to people, even if on summarized form. Looking forward to more :-)
thanks so much!
Luthien Tinuviel, daughter of a high elf and a maja. One of the most powerful beings in Middle Earth. Bewitching even the nearly almighty Morgoth Bauglir to sleep. This could be - well scripted of course - one of the best stories for a great movie. So Hollywood and Amazon: keep your hands off of this story, okay!
Yea and morgoths will was so strong that he made them Show them out of hiding he just became too distracted by her beauty thats why she could use her maia gifted powers on him too☝🏻
Love it just subscribed too 👌
Thanks so much! This week part 3! You can see ainulindale on my channel!
May I kindly ask which AI you have used for this? It looks amazing!
a mix of differents AI to get images and movements like midjourney, leonardo, runaways...
@@TheCottageofLostPlay well, it looks fantastic!
Part 3 please❤❤
this week! thanks so much!
mano que incrivel.. se a Amazon tivesse feito algo similar a isso ia ser um sucesso absoluto!
thanks so much!
Simply beautiful
thanks so much!
ROP gets shat on by an AI slap-together. I loved it. Eventually, hopefully, we can rely on AI to make the Silmarillion as close to as intended as possible, and get Tolkien's brilliance out of the hands of Amazon's identity politics. Looking forward to the next!
thanks so much!
This is what we wanted RoP to look like, keep up the great work!
thanks so much!!! more videos on my channel!
Like crappy AI?
Dude this is actually really good even though I don't know how you do it. Looking forward to new stories! I wonder if your program allows you to keep some visual consistency between characters and reuse them across various videos, that would be great for immersion. I am talking more about the various Iluvatar scenes in the other video.
Thank you very much for your time here! Yes, I use various AI programs to generate the images, and sometimes the AI is capricious with the results, although I always try to choose the best ones to maintain more consistency.
I really love your channel make about sauron how he joing the dark side with morgoth ❤❤ we are waiting for this
Thank you very much! I will be creating the stories of the Silmarillion and filling my playlist in a more or less chronological order. I want to tell the missing part of the journey from Doriath to Angband when I cover the story of Finrod!
@TheCottageofLostPlay it's okay we all waiting for your a beautiful video and I loved the way the story and design were presented, and it is much better
thanks so much! soon beren part 3!
These videos are really cool and are a good pallet cleanser for a certain show. Any chance you’ll do any videos on Numenor later down the line?
Thank you very much! Yes, the plan is to continue filling out my chronological playlist until I have a more or less summarized version of the book.
Great job! Though I understand you had to shorten the story, there are things I miss seeing like the sons of Feanor trying to kidnap Lúthien and Huan turning against them, Finrod helping Beren, or Lúthien's (and Huan) fight with Sauron. Lúthien looks a bit better here than in part 1 in my opinion, so good job there. Waiting for part 3.
Thank you very much for your time here! Yes, my intention is to fill in what is missing, review what is already there, and make the complete story in one long video, but later on. For now, I will upload part 3 tomorrow.
@@TheCottageofLostPlay great to know the whole story is on its way!! Thanks a lot!!
But before the complete Beren and Lúthien project, what would you like to see?
@@TheCottageofLostPlay Tuors way to Gondolin. Or the Noldors rebellion and Feanors oath. Maybe the war of the Lamps.
@@mbeu15aor something about Turin? I know it is a long story, but i love it
Brutal
gracias!!
Part 3 please 😢❤❤❤❤
thanks! working on that one! i´ll show this week
@TheCottageofLostPlay you are so amazing and u deserve more thank u my friend . We except more from those videos
Excellent visualisations! A less abridged version with more detail would be nice, especially with more of the poetry of the lays. :)
thanks so much!
The only thing I would add is proper pronunciation of the names for the AI voices? That manly voice saying Carcharof's name wrongly was hilarious lol
What technology are you using? Is it free or paid? Again, very good, I am also interested in producing material if only I knew how to
i use 3 AI programs for generate images, 2 for movement, 2 webs for music and sounds, and filmora for editing, all pay programs, easy around 150/200 usd per video
Well done.
Missing parts are ok. The only issue was how Carcharoth was spelled
Thanks! I'll try tell missing parts in the future, when i tell Finrod story.
Ok just saw your awesome content, I Subscribe
Thank so much!! Tomorrow part 3! Stay tuned!
@@TheCottageofLostPlay will be watching it, I know the channel just started but any plans of stories beyond LOTR ?
I know the Luthian song is listed in description but I can’t find it anywhere:(
pixabay.com/es/users/hansotomodachi-40635205/ here you can find it
fantastic video, keep it up. this is a million times better than the amazon garbage
thanks so much!!!
Song of Luthien , who can tell the name ?
you have the music on description
@@TheCottageofLostPlay thanks 💪🏻✌🏻
Please do fingolfin vs morgoth
thanks! i have that one on my channel! someday i´ll make that story again with the AI improvement
Hi, whats the name of Lúthien song? the part where she sings?
thanks! you have all music on description
i watch this to see my most favorite character: Finrod Felagund. unfortunately he is not here 😢
I´ll redo this story in long format with all details i can put! thanks so much!
I’m sure it’s pronounced ‘Kar-Ka-Roth’ but great videos.
thanks a lot!
Luthien was a really empowered girl of Tolkien,and she doesn't need to act like a man as Wokeladriel.
yep
Begging pardon, I am *so* sorry. 1:54, "Angband"?
yep, sorry, small slip on subtitles autogenerated XD
But Finrod walks with Finarfin, his father, beneath the trees of Eldamar!
How many hours did you spend to produce this 3 minute video? Maybe the hardest part is to know which parts of the story will be told and which will not
thanks so much! around 3 days of work
where's Finrod?
I'll tell that part when i tell finrod's story
luthien also fingolfin have big balls 😄
XD
That sword only hit him....ha
Саурона пропустили, ну да ладно. Зато главные участники и сами события остались.
Well done. But it lacks a bit of substance: for example Beren didn't just take the Silmaril he had to cut it out of Morgoth's crown. Then he tried to take a second but his knife Angrist broke. You should include the name of knifes etc. because names are magical in mythology. Names resonate with your audience. We like to her them, the story is not complete without them. You cant imagine Isildur without Narsil. And is has to be the reforged Narsil that Aragorn uses. I think you know what i mean.
thanks so much for your time here! Yes, that would be great, but the problem is that if a video like this takes me 3 days of work, if I were to include all the literal information from the book, it would probably take me a month to finish just one video, as the story is full of details. My intention is to provide a brief summary of the stories told in The Silmarillion, so that people can see and hear about certain characters and events without delving into all the wonderful details, because that would be a colossal project for just one person.
Пока Моргот спал, Берену следовало убить его.
Csak az a baj, hogy Morgoth halhatatlan :))
You missed out a bit of the story. Didnt Beren start his journey with a band of elves, including Finrod Felegon? They disguised themselves as orcs but got captured by Sauron and got eaten by werewolves.
Also, Beren used a dagger to remove the silmarils. When he tried to remove the 2nd stone, he accidentally cut Morgoth and woke him.
If such details had been missed in rings of p, then using the logic of all the haters on your site, your videos are dumb and you're an insult to tolkien. Obviously, that's all drivel. Your videos are epic! Absolutely love them. But now you've not stuck to canon, all those haters of rings of p should now start calling your videos rubbish. It's only fair. What's good for the goose... lol. Hope they dont though. I'm guessing you need to edit quite ruthlessly yet I and many others are still enjoying your work. Just a shame all these people seem to use your channel to insult rings of p. Lol i wonder if they'll all one person? Excuse my little conspiracy theory 😂. Couldn't resist.
Like others, the graphics, music, and somewhat for the narration are great. But trying to do this story in a few minutes skips way too much meaningful content.
Check your pronunciations before narration as well.
Please keep making these videos, as the genre is unique for Tolkien work and you will find a ton of fans.
Better than rings of power.
Thanks a lot!
I would pay more attention to the pronounciation of names; it can be quite distracting. Other than that, it's looks good.
thanks!
I think it's pronounced KarKaroth
Watching this after being tortured by the last episode of RoP shows that there is still hope for the Tolkienverse.
XD thanks for your time here!
Luthien’s song…shit…
Her beauty seduced melkor
Beautiful imagery but oooph way to slaughter the story and the names. Still better than ROP.
thanks so much! summarized version in this moment it´s all i can get with actual technologies, image movement it´s a nightmare XD. someday i´ll make a video of all Outtakes i have XDXD
100% better than Rings of Power!😀
thanks!