They could have easily solved the Starlight problem by putting her in the place of Derpy. It would fit Starlight's character of having enough unquestioning devotion to Twilight to throw herself in from of harm to save Twilight as well as explain her absense from the rest of the movie. Plus, it would add that extra motivation for Twilight to get help.
Wait, why didn't Derpy's hat turn into stone along with herself. I saw glimpse of Luna's crown turned into stone while on her head. Then, explain why the hat didn't
Here is how the movie would have been if discord was in it "Hello and problems here?" *snaps fingers* all the enimies are captured and the movie is over
Well Starlight didn't realize what she was doing. She thought she would just make six lives just less amazing. You know, normal pony lives. Once she realised the real consequences, she gave up. While Tempest 100% knew she was enslaving everypony, practically killing the princesses AND giving absolute power over the whole world to a mad tyrant who might just kill every form of life by playing with the sun. AND it took the villain not giving her what she wanted AND Twilight saving her life to make her switch sides.
shitlight glimmer deserves to have her magic riped away as pajnfuiiy as possible and neal her to a wooden bored and watterbored her and cute oppin her legs and yankee her bounes out and shatter them. Sprinkle some of the shards back into here legs and make her eat the rest of the shareds. And sow her legs back up with a kneedle thats been contamanatred with tetris. And laff and spjt and 3hjt in herface and mock her as shedies slowly and pajnfuIIy.
More sins: -Twilight, the master of teleporting, doesn't teleport, not ONCE in the entire movie. -Rainbow Dash, the fastest flyer, doesn't use her fast flying (or bravery, for that matter) in emergencies when it is needed, and flies at the same pace with everyone else. - Fluttershy only has one really good, and funny line. (When she makes the enemy guy/thing cry and open up to her.) And doesn't get animals to assist her in some way, shape, or form, when things start to get tough. -Applejack doesn't have too many lines either, and hardly any of them about some kind of honesty (if I'm correct on that? Not 100% sure) -Not having a better way to introduce Discord or give him a better excuse for not helping. Because clearly he is on the hero side by now and helped saved Equestria once, he would help again and has no signs of going back to his old ways. -(This one adds on to what you said about the two legged thing) Along with the not being able to go on two legs, like they can sometimes in the show, they also move way more like horses instead of cartoons like their cartoony show counterparts, and most of the antics cut down. I get it's a "serious" movie and all but would have been nice to do a little more movement with the animation. -Some animation is too slow in some places, too fast in others for the given situation. -Mouths are left hanging open for a little while after saying a sentence quite a few times, from a few different characters. Normally ponies close their mouths when they are done talking in the show. -Spike is used as a flame thrower and murders two or three of the enemy people. That's right, they lay down and burn to DEATH. Ya know, murder, for kids! xD -When Tempest says they waste their powers on parties, she's pretty much correct. There is so much they could fix with other countries and races and the like if they got out of their little comfortable, harmonic bubble, without the need of Twilight and her friends and map. -They had a dick joke (which I'm surprised you didn't talk about!) -Has a deleted opening that is way, way better than the one they put in it. This movie is wayyyy flawed but idk, I still loved it.
Actually, I WILL correct you on one point, About Rainbow not using her fast flying in an emergency. If you look very closely during the attack on the Princesses, you will see, when the Orb attacks Twilight, we see it actually gets Derpy. But if you look closely, you will see Rainbow's rainbow trail.....she saw that Derpy wasn't going to save Twilight in time, so she pushed Twilight out of the way to safety and the Orb hit Derpy instead.
In regards to Spike becoming a puffer fish: that is literally just the writers not caring about Spike at all. If anything, he should have turned into a sea dragon. But, nooooo. Just like with EQG making Spike a dog for incredibly stupid reasons, he's given the shaft here too.
Your right dude twilight should teleport because twilight know who to teleport in the show with starlight and many more episodes. That's what I think while I watched this movie and mostly I kinda upset that twilight cannot teleport Useless powerful princess of Friendship Learns so much of friendship and spells #BOOTWILIGHT #WEAK And also Twilight should use that spell while she's in that cage
Discord would of Easily beat every one there plus he could return Tempe’s horn as he seen he can freely remove and return horns and wings seen in his first episode
@@princessstarlaixyarixes8103 literally, when most problems that could be solved easily by Discord arise, they either kick him out of Equestria for a bit or strip him of his powers lmao
Indeed. Not to mention, WHERE is Shining Armor during all this? You would THINK, as Twilight's brother AND Captain of the Queen's Guard, he would be at the Festival, no? Especially since his wife is also in attendance? And WHERE was baby Flurry Heart during all this? Her Mom is frozen and her Dad is incognito.....so WHO was protecting the baby?
Above the cloud layer isn’t always 30k feet up, clouds are normally just a little more than 1000 feet up... the only clouds that would be that high up are Cirrus clouds but those were clearly Nimbus clouds which are low in the atmosphere.
I honestly loved this movie, went to see it at the cinema and even brought my plush Twilight. It's not flawless but I'd say they did really good all things considered. And the soundtrack is ADDICTING!
Eremikashipper 4ever I saw it in the cinema too. What's kinda funny is when I went, counting myself, there were only 5 people in there: myself, and elderly couple and a mother and I'm guessing 5, maybe 6 year old daughter
The abandoning that Tempest was talking about, was that all her friends left her when she couldn’t use her horn anymore to play with the stupid ball. Instead of finding other games that she could partake in, they stopped being her friends. Which is the reality for a lot of us disabled folks.
24:22 your complaint is invalid because if you fallowed the movie you’d know her magic was TAKEN out of Twilight. However you could have mentioned how Rarity still had magic and could’ve levitated the staff instead.
1:19 maybe it's a nod to how old MLP as a whole is. 11:49 "How would she know it was the mountain?"? It's Pinkie Pie. Don't question it 24:27 the spell didn't take her magic like Tirek, but it bound hers and the other princesses' magic to the staff. Until the magic within it is released, anyone who wields the staff has control of the Alicorns' magic, while they're unable to stop their own magic from being used. Happy New Year Moliminous
To explain the animal thing, there are anthro species which are sapient and capable of speech, while animals are sentient with capability of problem solving yet are unable to speak. So, Opal is an animal while Capper is not, the bird pirates are not animals, and so forth.. so yeah..
The Anthro species are sapient, the animals are sentient.. read what I said, there is a difference between the two, animals on our world are also sentient to a degree, while humans are sapient, though we do use the term Homo Sapien, sapient is also used to describe creatures capable of complex thinking and communication. We can't say it describes creatures with a form of civilization since ants and some mammals are capable of basic civilization, yet aren't sapient, but are sentient... so..
Well thats how it works in both MLP and the furry fandom, in reality if anthros became a thing we would still have normal animals, so technically yes it could and would work
8:05 - "All this power... wasted on parties." Well, I can think of very few better uses for it! :-b 10:43 - Good point! Why is Capper able to walk upright on two legs but the ponies can't??? 15:52 - Since the bubble-helmets are magical, maybe they constantly create new oxygen for the wearers? 22:02 - Not all primates in our world are Anthro (if I understand that word correctly.) Look at the difference between a human and a small monkey or a lemur! 23:14 - *TSUNAMIIIII!!!* 23:51 - Tempest turned bitter and gave up on trusting anyone, and yet trusted an obviously villain to keep his end of a bargain? 25:13 - I keep waiting to see Pony!Cameron to go along with this Pony!Mitchell.
Being scarred emotionally hurts more than being scarred physically no matter how lewd it is Scarred emotionally hurts forever Being scarred physically hurts for a while
EXACTLY. I was emotionally abused by my best friend and it was horrible. I hate how people downplay emotional abuse and act like it's trivial compared to physical abuse. I honestly wish my friend had physically abused me instead.
It was about depending on others. When Tempest needed the emotional support of her friends the most, as she was recovering from the psychological and physical trauma of a bear mauling, they turned their backs on her.
Moliminous, the clouds at the beginning, judging by shape and color, could have been under 6,000 feet above the ground, and judging by the scene when they dove through, I'm pretty sure they were. Many mammals have "beards" (like goats), so why can't a pony have one?
About the thing with the kids telling Tempest to go in the cave, it was never said but hinted at. The green one with the swirly hair (I think) was motioning for Tempest to go in. She trusted her friends to still look at her the same, and not a weirdo who couldn’t do magic and has a broken horn. But, here I am arguing about a movie about talking horses.
I just can't get over the fact that there is no to none of a royal guard appearing even cadance husband is not there to help. bbbbbbbruh, If the movie had logic it would end earlier.
You don’t mention how werid it is as other species treat ponies like livestock and property while ponies are an intelligent race with humanized qualities just as the other species.
There is an Earth Pony in g3 named Fizzie pop, so there is a chance that Tempest was based on her given Tempest's real name. Surprised Minty hasn't been given that treatment since build-a-bear releases her every year around christmas
Probably at home in the Crystal Empire with Shining Armor. Who also wasn't at the festival to support his sister.... Or protect his wife.... Huh, weird.
U know something is wrong when friendship isn't a magic, also the movie villains are not stronger than Sombra. Discord should have heard Fluttershy cry and scream bc he's looking at her for 24/7 in the show. Starlight too, one of the main characters. Is not include in the movie twice.
What you said about Tempest is true but I’d like to also say is that she tried to take over the world because two kids wouldn’t play with her. She also went into the cave even though there was all those signs. Also it’s never implied that she tried to get her horn fixed after she broke it, so she just sat around moping and never did anything and she blamed her friends even though her horn getting broken is completely 110% her fault.
So in the new generation, what'sherface the Unicorn literally pecks a tree down with her horn and no magic, which means that not only are uncorn horns sharp as fuck, they're sturdy enough to withstand that sort of force. How did Tempest break her horn again?
4:35 she saved the day only once on his own. Stop giving her credits she doesn't deserved. 7:18 she didn't save the day, she was just behind Twilight when RD saved her. Good question though XD 12:28 It's funny how Twilight, who was not originally born with wings, use them more often than Fluttershy who has always been a pegasus XD 14:00 Kids don't know about that, they think pirating is just about sea adventures. 19:27 Not to mention abandon her but also their mission, their peoples and families. All that because they react childishly to the truth. 20:14 Also Twilight is a princess, the highest social statut a pony could ever hope to attain. She's a revered hero with ties with with the royalty of Equestria, immortal with god-like powers. what more exactly could Tempest have?
24:26 wouldnt the storm guys staff have taken her magic, then again she can fly, oh frick it, magic ponies in a magic world tryna stop a magic guy tryna get his staff to be magic
I think if they included Discord, they would have had to have a completely different introduction for Tempest, such as using the stone thingy on him before actually asking for surrender. Using him as an example. Which would do two things. First, undermine Tempest's character and force a fight scene that previous didn't happen.
Holy Celestia, the ponies' eyes are even bigger in the movie than they are in the TV show! The get any bigger and there won't be any head left! 7:15 - Derpy is Best Pony! (Well, except for Zecora, but she isn't here.)
It's almost embarrassing how this turned out...seven going on eight seasons and yet they derailed the perfectly competent Mane Six into idiots when they weren't being shoved to the wayside (Rainbow Dash is impulsive, yes, but she has common sense and I highly doubt she would give away their presence to the enemies!), recycled elements from one episode point-for-point, littered the plot with cliches, and locked out the non-fans. Nothing is sadder than wasted potential, and that is all this movie did. They were so concentrated on impressing merely the fanbase they forgot about the overall audience and critics. And, judging by the fact that most bronies I talked to just saw it as okay, not even THAT worked out well. Worst case scenario, this shrunk the demand for a return of 2D movies to theater, and the franchise's already tattered reputation has gotten yet another blemish. Heavily disappointing.
I hated what they did to Twilight, I would've hated this movie if it wasn't for Tempest lol, Tempest managed to become my favourite pony after this movie lol
When Twilight and her friends had to get the staff together it wasn't just for the whole "friendship is magic" thing it was because Twilight lost her magic after it LITERALLY being drained from her and we all saw it. Also I did the biggest face palm ever.
18:55 True but hasn't this happened before? Haven't they dealt with enemies/been in situations exactly like this while messing up in the past? What's different now?
I'd like to know how the hell the Mane 6, on their makeshift hot air balloon that Rainbow Dash was pushing, could've made it to the bottom of Mt. Aris, climbed it, then met the hippogryphs and resurfaced ALL before Tempest could reach Mt. Eris on her flying skiff?
On a few of your points: 1) Cloudsdale is a literal city above the cloud layer. Made of clouds. And all weather that exists, is literally set up by pegasi. That's cannon. So both flying that high, fast, and turning (if the Wonderbolt Academy Episode, and Wonderbolts are anything to go by) is as common for them as walking to the fridge would be for a human. 2) We see Twilight Sparkle (thanks to being an Element Bearer) survive a piano, anvil, and other odds and ends dropped onto her skull from cloud height. So we know that at least for the Element Bearer's, magical talking ponies can take more damage than normal. So that's not that surprising. A few of them have quite literally survived worse. 3) How does Spike know which way is south? How does anyone know which way is south? Not much of an error. Unless you meant to say "How does Spike know they live in the South"? In which case. Books. 4) Capper can walk on two legs because his species over there is bi-pedal (like a minotaur) rather than built like a quadruped like Griffons or ponies. 5) You're asking how the reality warping, precog knows something (your thing on Pinks at 11:45)? It's honestly a given that she'd know. 6) Your bit on them putting things far higher than they'd be able to go. But if you accept that all weather is made by pegasi, then it's not really all that much out of canon. And not that much higher than Once Upon A Zeppelin's Zeppelin. 7) On the birds bit. The same question can be applied to Diamond Dogs, Deer (not sapient), Goats (not sapient), and Pigs (" "). Or similar animals. They, kind of like humans vs every other primate, simply evolved like that. Or how Capper's species is a bipedal cat, where other cats are normal (much like Diamond Dogs vs normal dogs). 8) Definitely agree on the Balloon Rig. Definitely not Purple Smart's smartest plan. And she's had some doozies over the various seasons. 9) 15:58 ... a land of magical, talking ponies. With something that was literally constructed out of magic. You don't think that maybe ... I don't know? It opperates differently than Earth's non-magical stuff would? I mean a few sins you bring up are ignoring the obvious. As well as the fact that this is a super common trope (with an IRL example) tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/OxygenatedUnderwaterBubbles. 10) ... yes. Yes ponies are assholes. 11) About Spike's transformation. The answer's the same as with the Crystal Mirror, the multiverse (aka writer's) love screwing Spike over. He goes around life with a giant Kick Me sign on his back. And everyone in his universe laughs when life kicks him repeatedly in the nads with steel toed boots. 12) On the breathing / talking underwater bit. How's that a problem? I mean A) Talking magic ponies, and B) Mermaids. One of the most common mythological creatures on our earth (or some variant. Usually Octopi for some reason) never had gills, and are commonly depicted as able to talk under water. Again. Magic. 13) 19:05 ... of course Twilight did some bungles of her own. But yeah, her friends did kind of help screw over everyone. 14) On the song question ... well she is a pony. And ponies have a cultural addiction to singing randomly. Usually over the most inane things. That and it's probably been awhile since she's given in to that addiction being surrounded by non-ponies for so long. 15) On the playing there bit ... I point at Pinkie Pride and Boast Busted (and even partially to Flight to the Finish). Parents are quite literally the most negligent, child endangering, and crappiest beings on their planet. Other than a very select few. Snips and Snail's folks let them wander into Pony Murder Forest, then blamed Trixie later. Cheese Sandwhich was literally a run away, and noone cared. So yeah, as much of a sin as that is. Canonically, parents over in Equestria care nothing of their young. 16) Yeah that is about making smarter decisions. But this is the same planet where Glimmer became a super villain with a grudge against Cutie Marks because she was too stupid to write a letter to Starburst. 17) As competent as Tempest may be as a villain. She's still a pony. She may seal a person in stone (as earlier), be negligent to others, or even be an asshole. But straight up murder (well directly murdering someone) just doesn't seem to be in their repetoire. Either that or it was pony negligence rearing it's ugly head like her with the cultural addiction to singing (lamp shaded in All Bottled Up that when they sing it's actually done IRL (for them). 18) She made Glimmer a Friendship Student after she repeatedly hate fucked the timeline with magic. And almost destroyed (and technically did on multiple occassions that now have never happened) all of Equestria. Her making Tempest a friend after almost being killed by her is par for the course. 19) But yeah, all of those other's could've tried helping but ... Griffon's are more dicks than ponies. I doubt they'd help. Yak's give 0 fks about anyone who's not yak, unless it's to scream at them while destroying their property. Dragon's might've helped if the price was right. But is a 50-50% chance of them making things worse. It's kind of like asking Discord to help. As for Changelings? After Chrysalis left, they became a bigger group of pussies than the entire female population of Equestria put together ... per Changeling. ____________ Still, all in all. Nice vid. Thanks for putting in the effort of putting it all together.
they shoulfd all ripaway shitlight glimmers magic and brake her horn and and ingect her with rabbies and locsk her in a dungin cell with a watterfall and a river runing thru it. and use levatashion to watterbored her everday from a safe distince. and anytime the watterboreding kjIIs her my oc can use magic to bring her back to life so herdeath is slowwer and moore pajnfuII and she can sufare longer. and have camras with auddio hidden evrywere to liverstream her slow pajnfuIIdeath. and anyone can come vistit her and spray her with watterguns and thro watter balloons and accjd balloons at her thru the barres while laffing and mocking her and spjtjng at her. and she cant figt back or infact them becuz her magic is gone and shes behind too sets of irom bears. and she covered in bII00d and bruces from rabbidly bangjng herslef agenst the bares becuz of all the terifying rabbid hallusinashions and from trying too eskype. And after she finalydead from the rhabiees my oc brung her back to like to give her corollavires 19 and a magic helth bubble arond evry one else so they wont catch it when they laff in her face and jear at her. And shoove a ventalatiur down her throyte without annathsesha and us magic to make shure she stay alive for along time so she can fell all the pajn. and evenchually shedies and my oc just keep brining her back to life over and over so she can be torchered toodeath over and over for all eternaty cuz hes immortial. and shell be in the worst most excrusheating nonstop agginny forever and anyone how wants to can join in torchering her or just wach and laff and mock her and rellish in her udder missarry. i have lots of fanart lol
I mean, I actually think the other five are right. Twilight was so focused on her people that she didn't realize that other creatures where suffering because of the storm king too. Instead of understanding that, she was greedy, and treated everyone as an enemy, not very "princess of friendship"-y of her.
Okay I totally missed a Starlight glimmer Cameo seriously where the fuck was she she could have ended this in an instant just like Discord both of them would have been able to handle this problem in 0 seconds flat they are overpowered as fuk
Where does it say the Pearl changes them into whatever they desire? Oh, it doesn't. Spike was turned to a puffer fish because he's a dragon. Different species to the ponies. Like how he's a dog in Equestria girls.
Sin 52: OH MY GOD! WHY DOES EVERYONE THINK THAT ADDING TENTACLES INTO SOMETHING, IMMEDIATELY QUALIFIES AS A JAPANESE TENTACLE SEX JOKE!!!??? 20 FRICKIN' SINS FOR THIS ONE PARTICULAR SIN!!!
Honestly was so disappointed by this movie. I desperately wanted it to be good but it was just such a lazy cash grab and an opportunity for hasbro to make weird ass pony mermaid hybrid toys.
Wait, you forgot the mistake between #114 and 115! The green smoke spread out a lot, the others would have become rocks as well!! #100 is shown in the comic where Tempest goes back to the crystal empire and meets one of her friends again. Well, kinda, it doesn’t talk about the lesson from that, but it talks about how her friends never actually said, “Go in! We’ll just wait here for your horn to get broken!”
I have thought the same thing about all of these except for the one about Rainbow Dash's conga line. She says "longer thing" in reference to her conga line because it was a lot longer than apple jacks conga line
"Why didn't twilight use her magic or teleport?" um... maybe cause her magic is in the staff? Just spitballin' but I feel like that would make using her magic a _little_ difficult.
…your second sin…is talking about a movie derived from a show where a pony travelling at supersonic speeds grabs five other ponies and changes direction THREE TIMES before slowing down. The other ponies end up rather shaken AT WORST.
Now that I think about it, the Tempest spell that transforms the others into rock is the same one that the King Sombra used in the comics against Princess Amore
![Everything Wrong With My Little Pony Season 1 "Mare In The Moon" [Parody]](/img/1.gif)
I KNOW WE'RE LATE BY A BIT BUT I HOPE YOU LIKE IT ANYWAYS! much love and happy new years!
Moliminous I wonder how brony notion is doing
Happy new years!
Moliminous happy new year
Moliminous the definitions through the whole movie besides friendship: ironic, racist, idiots, logic broken, and a littler box :3
I don't know if they explain this in the movie or not but what happened to spike after he got captured
They could have easily solved the Starlight problem by putting her in the place of Derpy. It would fit Starlight's character of having enough unquestioning devotion to Twilight to throw herself in from of harm to save Twilight as well as explain her absense from the rest of the movie. Plus, it would add that extra motivation for Twilight to get help.
Exactly!
Yeah
Or the fact that a baby alicorn could have easily been abducted after the mother was captured too.
That's probably where shining is, protecting the baby
@Noah Maldonado thanks!
@@shadow_shine3578 he’s the only guard that does stuff
@@firepawx3779 yep.
@@shadow_shine3578 The only guard that actually guards.
Wait, why didn't Derpy's hat turn into stone along with herself. I saw glimpse of Luna's crown turned into stone while on her head. Then, explain why the hat didn't
Fluttershy1015 because she’s Derpy
She is the true hero of the movie
Because her hat I think was in the air and it didn't turn to stone......?
Because she was stone alread- Nvm
she was turned then the hat was put on her
Here is how the movie would have been if discord was in it
"Hello and problems here?" *snaps fingers* all the enimies are captured and the movie is over
😂😂😂
that's why they reformed discord for
hasbro wtf why didn't you include discord! Hes a cool non pony thing
Discord=no movie xD XD unless he decides to troll tht is
@@also_arles non pony thing? He's a Draconequus.
The forgiveness was a bit overboard, but um Starlight glimmer, becomes Twilights student right after she nearly destroys the world.
Well Starlight didn't realize what she was doing. She thought she would just make six lives just less amazing. You know, normal pony lives. Once she realised the real consequences, she gave up.
While Tempest 100% knew she was enslaving everypony, practically killing the princesses AND giving absolute power over the whole world to a mad tyrant who might just kill every form of life by playing with the sun.
AND it took the villain not giving her what she wanted AND Twilight saving her life to make her switch sides.
shitlight glimmer deserves to have her magic riped away as pajnfuiiy as possible and neal her to a wooden bored and watterbored her and cute oppin her legs and yankee her bounes out and shatter them. Sprinkle some of the shards back into here legs and make her eat the rest of the shareds. And sow her legs back up with a kneedle thats been contamanatred with tetris. And laff and spjt and 3hjt in herface and mock her as shedies slowly and pajnfuIIy.
More sins:
-Twilight, the master of teleporting, doesn't teleport, not ONCE in the entire movie.
-Rainbow Dash, the fastest flyer, doesn't use her fast flying (or bravery, for that matter) in emergencies when it is needed, and flies at the same pace with everyone else.
- Fluttershy only has one really good, and funny line. (When she makes the enemy guy/thing cry and open up to her.) And doesn't get animals to assist her in some way, shape, or form, when things start to get tough.
-Applejack doesn't have too many lines either, and hardly any of them about some kind of honesty (if I'm correct on that? Not 100% sure)
-Not having a better way to introduce Discord or give him a better excuse for not helping. Because clearly he is on the hero side by now and helped saved Equestria once, he would help again and has no signs of going back to his old ways.
-(This one adds on to what you said about the two legged thing) Along with the not being able to go on two legs, like they can sometimes in the show, they also move way more like horses instead of cartoons like their cartoony show counterparts, and most of the antics cut down. I get it's a "serious" movie and all but would have been nice to do a little more movement with the animation.
-Some animation is too slow in some places, too fast in others for the given situation.
-Mouths are left hanging open for a little while after saying a sentence quite a few times, from a few different characters. Normally ponies close their mouths when they are done talking in the show.
-Spike is used as a flame thrower and murders two or three of the enemy people. That's right, they lay down and burn to DEATH. Ya know, murder, for kids! xD
-When Tempest says they waste their powers on parties, she's pretty much correct. There is so much they could fix with other countries and races and the like if they got out of their little comfortable, harmonic bubble, without the need of Twilight and her friends and map.
-They had a dick joke (which I'm surprised you didn't talk about!)
-Has a deleted opening that is way, way better than the one they put in it.
This movie is wayyyy flawed but idk, I still loved it.
Yeah, I noticed that with the talking thing. Especially Tempest.
Actually, I WILL correct you on one point, About Rainbow not using her fast flying in an emergency. If you look very closely during the attack on the Princesses, you will see, when the Orb attacks Twilight, we see it actually gets Derpy. But if you look closely, you will see Rainbow's rainbow trail.....she saw that Derpy wasn't going to save Twilight in time, so she pushed Twilight out of the way to safety and the Orb hit Derpy instead.
What was the dick joke? Also omg I didn't know there was a deleted opening!
In regards to Spike becoming a puffer fish: that is literally just the writers not caring about Spike at all. If anything, he should have turned into a sea dragon. But, nooooo. Just like with EQG making Spike a dog for incredibly stupid reasons, he's given the shaft here too.
Spike should have been a bearded dragon imo.
They're just as adorable, and have about as much personality.
No bonus round for every single time twilight could just simply teleport? XP
It would just be a replay of the whole movie
Nebuladark
Then the sin counter number would be off the chart.
Though towards the end, after the storm King takes her powers she can't use magic. Before that, yes, yes he could.
Your right dude twilight should teleport because twilight know who to teleport in the show with starlight and many more episodes.
That's what I think while I watched this movie and mostly I kinda upset that twilight cannot teleport
Useless powerful princess of Friendship
Learns so much of friendship and spells
#BOOTWILIGHT
#WEAK
And also Twilight should use that spell while she's in that cage
Nebuladark lol
Discord would of Easily beat every one there plus he could return Tempe’s horn as he seen he can freely remove and return horns and wings seen in his first episode
Yes! They need either an episode of a comic book issue where Tempest (Fizzlepop) meets Discord and he does this!
I meant to say "either an episode *or* a comic book issue..."
Tempest
When Discord is needed, Hasbro forgets about him..
@@princessstarlaixyarixes8103 literally, when most problems that could be solved easily by Discord arise, they either kick him out of Equestria for a bit or strip him of his powers lmao
The movie completely ignored they had military and the Wonderbolts did nothing too except get captured
Indeed. Not to mention, WHERE is Shining Armor during all this? You would THINK, as Twilight's brother AND Captain of the Queen's Guard, he would be at the Festival, no? Especially since his wife is also in attendance? And WHERE was baby Flurry Heart during all this? Her Mom is frozen and her Dad is incognito.....so WHO was protecting the baby?
Uh also aren’t the wonder bolts show ponies. What security could they fucking provide lol 😂
@@CeltycSparrow Shining was probably protecting Flurry Heart.
Above the cloud layer isn’t always 30k feet up, clouds are normally just a little more than 1000 feet up... the only clouds that would be that high up are Cirrus clouds but those were clearly Nimbus clouds which are low in the atmosphere.
Spike: "What happened to her horn?"
Moliminous: "What happened to your wings?"
Bane: "Now is not the time for wings. That comes later." #Season8
Considering how easy it was for tempest to take over. Maybe Sunset's plan to waltz in with a zombie teenage army doesn't sound to far fetched lol
I honestly loved this movie, went to see it at the cinema and even brought my plush Twilight. It's not flawless but I'd say they did really good all things considered. And the soundtrack is ADDICTING!
Eremikashipper 4ever I saw it in the cinema too.
What's kinda funny is when I went, counting myself, there were only 5 people in there: myself, and elderly couple and a mother and I'm guessing 5, maybe 6 year old daughter
When i went the theater was packed
"BEST! MOVIE! EVER!!!!!!!!!" Pretty good Pinkie Pie impression, huh?
Rainbow Rocks were better but this movie is ok.
Yeah. I really like the movie too.
It’s 7.6/9+
(I don’t do 10s)
Twilight couldn't use magic at the end while she was trying to get the staff because the staff absorbed it, r e m e m b e r ?
Pyrrhia Dragon yeah
fashion horse has no excuse
"Whose OC is this, and why are they talking?" xD
The abandoning that Tempest was talking about, was that all her friends left her when she couldn’t use her horn anymore to play with the stupid ball. Instead of finding other games that she could partake in, they stopped being her friends.
Which is the reality for a lot of us disabled folks.
Is no one gonna talk about how Fluttershy dresses angel as a bird at 3:22 ?
once I heard "fuck this shit I'm out" I started cracking up. I listen to that song like every day for some reason.
24:22 your complaint is invalid because if you fallowed the movie you’d know her magic was TAKEN out of Twilight. However you could have mentioned how Rarity still had magic and could’ve levitated the staff instead.
Or rainbow dash, who can break friggin mach 10, and fly through storms with no problem, doesn't fly fast up there by herself and grab it with ease.
Olivia Jachim thats like saying a jet could fly through a tornado because its fast. I dont think you understand how wings work
Rarity was like at the bottom or whatever....
0:17
Magic is dangerous. The staff would probably zap any non-princess-or-mithologocal-beast into ashes for daring to try touching it.
6:44 I Just saw them as tools Tempest developed to compensate for her broken horn to be able to do magic.
1:19 maybe it's a nod to how old MLP as a whole is.
11:49 "How would she know it was the mountain?"?
It's Pinkie Pie. Don't question it
24:27 the spell didn't take her magic like Tirek, but it bound hers and the other princesses' magic to the staff. Until the magic within it is released, anyone who wields the staff has control of the Alicorns' magic, while they're unable to stop their own magic from being used.
Happy New Year Moliminous
Twilight says: We're friends now.
Tempest: Why?
Twi: Because I said so.
Temp: But-
Twi: I'm the Princess or Friendship.
Temp: Okay.
You missed one
Me: Songbird Serenade is the only pony customized like her actor
To explain the animal thing, there are anthro species which are sapient and capable of speech, while animals are sentient with capability of problem solving yet are unable to speak. So, Opal is an animal while Capper is not, the bird pirates are not animals, and so forth.. so yeah..
The Anthro species are sapient, the animals are sentient.. read what I said, there is a difference between the two, animals on our world are also sentient to a degree, while humans are sapient, though we do use the term Homo Sapien, sapient is also used to describe creatures capable of complex thinking and communication. We can't say it describes creatures with a form of civilization since ants and some mammals are capable of basic civilization, yet aren't sapient, but are sentient... so..
that's not how that would work, in reality nor is it ever addressed.
Well thats how it works in both MLP and the furry fandom, in reality if anthros became a thing we would still have normal animals, so technically yes it could and would work
8:05 - "All this power... wasted on parties." Well, I can think of very few better uses for it! :-b
10:43 - Good point! Why is Capper able to walk upright on two legs but the ponies can't???
15:52 - Since the bubble-helmets are magical, maybe they constantly create new oxygen for the wearers?
22:02 - Not all primates in our world are Anthro (if I understand that word correctly.) Look at the difference between a human and a small monkey or a lemur!
23:14 - *TSUNAMIIIII!!!*
23:51 - Tempest turned bitter and gave up on trusting anyone, and yet trusted an obviously villain to keep his end of a bargain?
25:13 - I keep waiting to see Pony!Cameron to go along with this Pony!Mitchell.
SToP JuDGing EdGE HoRSe!
I’m not gonna lie, when I saw Derpy turn to stone, Amazing Grace started playing in my head.
Mare + Griffin = Hippogriff
M L P L O G I C
Actually hippogriffs are an actual thing.
Being scarred emotionally hurts more than being scarred physically no matter how lewd it is
Scarred emotionally hurts forever
Being scarred physically hurts for a while
EXACTLY. I was emotionally abused by my best friend and it was horrible. I hate how people downplay emotional abuse and act like it's trivial compared to physical abuse. I honestly wish my friend had physically abused me instead.
It was about depending on others. When Tempest needed the emotional support of her friends the most, as she was recovering from the psychological and physical trauma of a bear mauling, they turned their backs on her.
Also she was a child,they don’t make good decisions
And it could be implied that she was probably an orphan since we never see anything about her parents
Moliminous, the clouds at the beginning, judging by shape and color, could have been under 6,000 feet above the ground, and judging by the scene when they dove through, I'm pretty sure they were.
Many mammals have "beards" (like goats), so why can't a pony have one?
Also Skydiving will not murder someone.
@Palla and Tsarr maybe it's just darker fur
About the thing with the kids telling Tempest to go in the cave, it was never said but hinted at. The green one with the swirly hair (I think) was motioning for Tempest to go in. She trusted her friends to still look at her the same, and not a weirdo who couldn’t do magic and has a broken horn.
But, here I am arguing about a movie about talking horses.
I just can't get over the fact that there is no to none of a royal guard appearing even cadance husband is not there to help.
bbbbbbbruh, If the movie had logic it would end earlier.
You don’t mention how werid it is as other species treat ponies like livestock and property while ponies are an intelligent race with humanized qualities just as the other species.
You know what slavery is right?
@@MrBones-td6qn lmao
Spikes dragon, dragons migrate he probably has an internal compass.
Storm king is the combination of all the MLP haters in the world
There is an Earth Pony in g3 named Fizzie pop, so there is a chance that Tempest was based on her given Tempest's real name. Surprised Minty hasn't been given that treatment since build-a-bear releases her every year around christmas
I'm surprised you skipped "You're Selling us?!" (Twilight) Comment.
You're*
*R a r i t y
Seriously, where was Flurry Heart? Did she stop existing here or-?
Probably at home in the Crystal Empire with Shining Armor.
Who also wasn't at the festival to support his sister....
Or protect his wife....
Huh, weird.
I think shining armor was babysitting her! She could have been trouble
U know something is wrong when friendship isn't a magic, also the movie villains are not stronger than Sombra. Discord should have heard Fluttershy cry and scream bc he's looking at her for 24/7 in the show. Starlight too, one of the main characters. Is not include in the movie twice.
11:44 Haven't you learned NOT to question Pinkie Pie at this point?
24:23 no actually. The staff stole it remember? But that doesn't excuse rarity lmao.
I only got to watch this movie yesterday
GravityFallsdabest 1
I agree with ur pfn!
Whas it good
I am sure there was a Deadpool reference when Tempest told Pinkie pie her real name. Am I the only one that caught that?
Blademanunitpi you're not alone m8
Blademanunitpi kinda
25:42 you hope she can stay but she tried to hurt your friends and is not seen in the last 3 seasons of the show
What you said about Tempest is true but I’d like to also say is that she tried to take over the world because two kids wouldn’t play with her. She also went into the cave even though there was all those signs. Also it’s never implied that she tried to get her horn fixed after she broke it, so she just sat around moping and never did anything and she blamed her friends even though her horn getting broken is completely 110% her fault.
Yeah kinda lame villain
Tempest was a child. You're thinking children make good decisions..
Oh, and Pinkie knows it's Mount Aris because she's Pinkie Pie. Never question Pinkie Pie.
So in the new generation, what'sherface the Unicorn literally pecks a tree down with her horn and no magic, which means that not only are uncorn horns sharp as fuck, they're sturdy enough to withstand that sort of force. How did Tempest break her horn again?
Dude, you forgot to point the fact that Tempest friend abandon her because shes disabled
Let's talk about the first sin: pegasi are able to fly up to olympus, which is above the clouds.
Capper walks on 2 legs and the ponies don't because of something called a skeletal structure, and how it's assembled.
You said Twilight is the only one who did nothing wrong well… Fluttershy, applejack, rarity and somehow spike
All they did was join Pinkie’s song
4:35 she saved the day only once on his own. Stop giving her credits she doesn't deserved.
7:18 she didn't save the day, she was just behind Twilight when RD saved her. Good question though XD
12:28 It's funny how Twilight, who was not originally born with wings, use them more often than Fluttershy who has always been a pegasus XD
14:00 Kids don't know about that, they think pirating is just about sea adventures.
19:27 Not to mention abandon her but also their mission, their peoples and families. All that because they react childishly to the truth.
20:14 Also Twilight is a princess, the highest social statut a pony could ever hope to attain. She's a revered hero with ties with with the royalty of Equestria, immortal with god-like powers. what more exactly could Tempest have?
Skystar went to the surface to sing because she assumed she was alone. A valid assumption, given Mount Aris is abandoned.
24:23 twilight couldn’t use magic bc the storm king took it and that why he freed her she was useless but still he shouldn’t of freed her xD
24:26 wouldnt the storm guys staff have taken her magic, then again she can fly, oh frick it, magic ponies in a magic world tryna stop a magic guy tryna get his staff to be magic
I think if they included Discord, they would have had to have a completely different introduction for Tempest, such as using the stone thingy on him before actually asking for surrender. Using him as an example. Which would do two things. First, undermine Tempest's character and force a fight scene that previous didn't happen.
How are they breathing underwater.
Magic. Magic Pearl.
Holy Celestia, the ponies' eyes are even bigger in the movie than they are in the TV show! The get any bigger and there won't be any head left!
7:15 - Derpy is Best Pony! (Well, except for Zecora, but she isn't here.)
It's almost embarrassing how this turned out...seven going on eight seasons and yet they derailed the perfectly competent Mane Six into idiots when they weren't being shoved to the wayside (Rainbow Dash is impulsive, yes, but she has common sense and I highly doubt she would give away their presence to the enemies!), recycled elements from one episode point-for-point, littered the plot with cliches, and locked out the non-fans. Nothing is sadder than wasted potential, and that is all this movie did. They were so concentrated on impressing merely the fanbase they forgot about the overall audience and critics. And, judging by the fact that most bronies I talked to just saw it as okay, not even THAT worked out well. Worst case scenario, this shrunk the demand for a return of 2D movies to theater, and the franchise's already tattered reputation has gotten yet another blemish. Heavily disappointing.
though i enjoyed the movie, i must agree
I hated what they did to Twilight, I would've hated this movie if it wasn't for Tempest lol, Tempest managed to become my favourite pony after this movie lol
I mostly hate what they did to Pinkie Pie. Although that scene where Twilight and Pinkie fight was good.
It wouldn't matter if three of the six have wings if they were tied up before being thrown overboard
Rarity owns a cat. Capper is an Abyssinian. Not the same.
you also forgot at 15:41 there was a star in the shape of twilight's cutie-mark in the stone 'words'
Well... didn't expect this coming. Well, it's a nice gift for new year's
19:16 the truth hurts.
Mlp season 2, episode 1
All the truth does is make your heart ache,
Sometimes a lie is easier to take
When Twilight and her friends had to get the staff together it wasn't just for the whole "friendship is magic" thing it was because Twilight lost her magic after it LITERALLY being drained from her and we all saw it. Also I did the biggest face palm ever.
18:55 True but hasn't this happened before? Haven't they dealt with enemies/been in situations exactly like this while messing up in the past? What's different now?
"how did she even know thats the mountain!?"
Map: am i a joke to you????
Total sin: 1
Skystar is supposed to be leader of skyclan from warriors lol
I'd like to know how the hell the Mane 6, on their makeshift hot air balloon that Rainbow Dash was pushing, could've made it to the bottom of Mt. Aris, climbed it, then met the hippogryphs and resurfaced ALL before Tempest could reach Mt. Eris on her flying skiff?
Skystar.........New leader of Skyclan everyone...
Warrior cats
:D
On a few of your points:
1) Cloudsdale is a literal city above the cloud layer. Made of clouds. And all weather that exists, is literally set up by pegasi. That's cannon. So both flying that high, fast, and turning (if the Wonderbolt Academy Episode, and Wonderbolts are anything to go by) is as common for them as walking to the fridge would be for a human.
2) We see Twilight Sparkle (thanks to being an Element Bearer) survive a piano, anvil, and other odds and ends dropped onto her skull from cloud height. So we know that at least for the Element Bearer's, magical talking ponies can take more damage than normal. So that's not that surprising. A few of them have quite literally survived worse.
3) How does Spike know which way is south? How does anyone know which way is south? Not much of an error. Unless you meant to say "How does Spike know they live in the South"? In which case. Books.
4) Capper can walk on two legs because his species over there is bi-pedal (like a minotaur) rather than built like a quadruped like Griffons or ponies.
5) You're asking how the reality warping, precog knows something (your thing on Pinks at 11:45)? It's honestly a given that she'd know.
6) Your bit on them putting things far higher than they'd be able to go. But if you accept that all weather is made by pegasi, then it's not really all that much out of canon. And not that much higher than Once Upon A Zeppelin's Zeppelin.
7) On the birds bit. The same question can be applied to Diamond Dogs, Deer (not sapient), Goats (not sapient), and Pigs (" "). Or similar animals. They, kind of like humans vs every other primate, simply evolved like that. Or how Capper's species is a bipedal cat, where other cats are normal (much like Diamond Dogs vs normal dogs).
8) Definitely agree on the Balloon Rig. Definitely not Purple Smart's smartest plan. And she's had some doozies over the various seasons.
9) 15:58 ... a land of magical, talking ponies. With something that was literally constructed out of magic. You don't think that maybe ... I don't know? It opperates differently than Earth's non-magical stuff would? I mean a few sins you bring up are ignoring the obvious. As well as the fact that this is a super common trope (with an IRL example) tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/OxygenatedUnderwaterBubbles.
10) ... yes. Yes ponies are assholes.
11) About Spike's transformation. The answer's the same as with the Crystal Mirror, the multiverse (aka writer's) love screwing Spike over. He goes around life with a giant Kick Me sign on his back. And everyone in his universe laughs when life kicks him repeatedly in the nads with steel toed boots.
12) On the breathing / talking underwater bit. How's that a problem? I mean A) Talking magic ponies, and B) Mermaids. One of the most common mythological creatures on our earth (or some variant. Usually Octopi for some reason) never had gills, and are commonly depicted as able to talk under water. Again. Magic.
13) 19:05 ... of course Twilight did some bungles of her own. But yeah, her friends did kind of help screw over everyone.
14) On the song question ... well she is a pony. And ponies have a cultural addiction to singing randomly. Usually over the most inane things. That and it's probably been awhile since she's given in to that addiction being surrounded by non-ponies for so long.
15) On the playing there bit ... I point at Pinkie Pride and Boast Busted (and even partially to Flight to the Finish). Parents are quite literally the most negligent, child endangering, and crappiest beings on their planet. Other than a very select few.
Snips and Snail's folks let them wander into Pony Murder Forest, then blamed Trixie later. Cheese Sandwhich was literally a run away, and noone cared. So yeah, as much of a sin as that is. Canonically, parents over in Equestria care nothing of their young.
16) Yeah that is about making smarter decisions. But this is the same planet where Glimmer became a super villain with a grudge against Cutie Marks because she was too stupid to write a letter to Starburst.
17) As competent as Tempest may be as a villain. She's still a pony. She may seal a person in stone (as earlier), be negligent to others, or even be an asshole. But straight up murder (well directly murdering someone) just doesn't seem to be in their repetoire. Either that or it was pony negligence rearing it's ugly head like her with the cultural addiction to singing (lamp shaded in All Bottled Up that when they sing it's actually done IRL (for them).
18) She made Glimmer a Friendship Student after she repeatedly hate fucked the timeline with magic. And almost destroyed (and technically did on multiple occassions that now have never happened) all of Equestria. Her making Tempest a friend after almost being killed by her is par for the course.
19) But yeah, all of those other's could've tried helping but ... Griffon's are more dicks than ponies. I doubt they'd help. Yak's give 0 fks about anyone who's not yak, unless it's to scream at them while destroying their property. Dragon's might've helped if the price was right. But is a 50-50% chance of them making things worse. It's kind of like asking Discord to help. As for Changelings? After Chrysalis left, they became a bigger group of pussies than the entire female population of Equestria put together ... per Changeling.
____________
Still, all in all. Nice vid. Thanks for putting in the effort of putting it all together.
they shoulfd all ripaway shitlight glimmers magic and brake her horn and and ingect her with rabbies and locsk her in a dungin cell with a watterfall and a river runing thru it. and use levatashion to watterbored her everday from a safe distince. and anytime the watterboreding kjIIs her my oc can use magic to bring her back to life so herdeath is slowwer and moore pajnfuII and she can sufare longer. and have camras with auddio hidden evrywere to liverstream her slow pajnfuIIdeath. and anyone can come vistit her and spray her with watterguns and thro watter balloons and accjd balloons at her thru the barres while laffing and mocking her and spjtjng at her. and she cant figt back or infact them becuz her magic is gone and shes behind too sets of irom bears. and she covered in bII00d and bruces from rabbidly bangjng herslef agenst the bares becuz of all the terifying rabbid hallusinashions and from trying too eskype. And after she finalydead from the rhabiees my oc brung her back to like to give her corollavires 19 and a magic helth bubble arond evry one else so they wont catch it when they laff in her face and jear at her. And shoove a ventalatiur down her throyte without annathsesha and us magic to make shure she stay alive for along time so she can fell all the pajn. and evenchually shedies and my oc just keep brining her back to life over and over so she can be torchered toodeath over and over for all eternaty cuz hes immortial. and shell be in the worst most excrusheating nonstop agginny forever and anyone how wants to can join in torchering her or just wach and laff and mock her and rellish in her udder missarry. i have lots of fanart lol
She didn't make the balloon rig before jumping out because a hot air balloon is pretty big. The escape door was small.
I mean, I actually think the other five are right. Twilight was so focused on her people that she didn't realize that other creatures where suffering because of the storm king too. Instead of understanding that, she was greedy, and treated everyone as an enemy, not very "princess of friendship"-y of her.
If discord was in the movie it wouldn't even be a movie or even a episode it would just be short.
I prefer to have grogar in this movie or if there's another movie.
Hello! As soon as I saw Tempest I was like ‘Oooo! I like HER!’😍
Okay I totally missed a Starlight glimmer Cameo seriously where the fuck was she she could have ended this in an instant just like Discord both of them would have been able to handle this problem in 0 seconds flat they are overpowered as fuk
Technically they are hippocampi instead of hippogriffs
Sin 69: Ropes. Although, I'm pretty sure you would've made a bondage joke. So that's 2 sins: 1 for being stupid, and 1 for me knowing how you think.
Can someone tell me about the orbs? I found NO info on the Obsidian Orbs used to turn ponies to stone, i looked everywhere, nothin
Well Spike being a pufferfish is because they have spikes
Minus _every_ sin for Capper.
Where does it say the Pearl changes them into whatever they desire? Oh, it doesn't.
Spike was turned to a puffer fish because he's a dragon. Different species to the ponies.
Like how he's a dog in Equestria girls.
"what happened to your wings", that make my day xD yeah the sacrifice of derpy... So intense .O. "the truth hurt" xDD
Whoa wait, you are NOT sinning Fizzlepop Berrytwis?
Berrytwist*
No it doesn’t justify wallflower doing what she did BUT tricie is right it’s not enough to just not be mean you should be NICE
Sin 52: OH MY GOD! WHY DOES EVERYONE THINK THAT ADDING TENTACLES INTO SOMETHING, IMMEDIATELY QUALIFIES AS A JAPANESE TENTACLE SEX JOKE!!!??? 20 FRICKIN' SINS FOR THIS ONE PARTICULAR SIN!!!
Honestly was so disappointed by this movie. I desperately wanted it to be good but it was just such a lazy cash grab and an opportunity for hasbro to make weird ass pony mermaid hybrid toys.
Wait, you forgot the mistake between #114 and 115! The green smoke spread out a lot, the others would have become rocks as well!!
#100 is shown in the comic where Tempest goes back to the crystal empire and meets one of her friends again. Well, kinda, it doesn’t talk about the lesson from that, but it talks about how her friends never actually said, “Go in! We’ll just wait here for your horn to get broken!”
I have thought the same thing about all of these except for the one about Rainbow Dash's conga line. She says "longer thing" in reference to her conga line because it was a lot longer than apple jacks conga line
Twilight could have done better at the sea pony part
Here is the least place id expect a Wilson meme to appear in
I thought the scale of the Ponies was very off in the movie. They seemed much smaller than in the show.
"Why didn't twilight use her magic or teleport?"
um... maybe cause her magic is in the staff? Just spitballin' but I feel like that would make using her magic a _little_ difficult.
but keep the sin 'cause rarity could've got it.
…your second sin…is talking about a movie derived from a show where a pony travelling at supersonic speeds grabs five other ponies and changes direction THREE TIMES before slowing down. The other ponies end up rather shaken AT WORST.
Now that I think about it, the Tempest spell that transforms the others into rock is the same one that the King Sombra used in the comics against Princess Amore
You gotta admit the songs are amazing
Sqimi yeah i like the movie a lot of these sins are kinda stupid