@@wtf776 I mean technically not cuz before Soojin was in the group they never cared about improving Shuhua’s Korean or her lines but now suddenly it’s happening?! It’s like Shuhua does everything herself now without caring what cube tells her to do
I saw a comment under certain idle's video talking about shuhua's vocal. it wrote 2 years ago, the writer seem know much about vocal/music. they said that shuhua's vocal has wide range, and it's matter of time she will surpass other members vocals. now after listen to this comeback I start to believe what they said.
Okay, I'm calling it. The stars of the NXDE era has to be Soyeon and Shuhua. I feel the message is personal to all of them, but Soyeon especially giving two rap breaks to basically shout out to the heavens about it shows her passion. Shuhua, like wise is giving A LOT of facial expressions here and doing so much to give another level and a deeper meaning of the song. I also love that she's comfortable enough now to take equal part in singing, as I really feel she's giving her everything and shining here. Some standout moments (aside from them) is Yuqi's growl and perfect white Marylin-look , Miyeon's "How do I look", Minnie's " Yeppi Yeppi" and of course Animated "Marylin" (but it's really Soojin).
This whole music video was filled with fascinating imagery and references, plus the song is a bop. The fact that they sample Habanera from the opera Carmen in the chorus just brings that extra little spice and another layer of meaning to the song since Carmen is often considered as a femme fatale character because in the opera she seduces and brings about the ruin of a naive soldier.
Amazing song and amazing MV! Soyeon really is a genius! All the members did such a good job, but I was so happy and proud of Shuhua, she sounded incredible!
I don't think Minnie's starting verse is tongue-in-cheek: as you said, it is a stage persona. She is performing, just like Marilyn Monroe was, surrounded by audience. Marilyn was a shrewd businesswoman and a brilliant actress who managed to persuade the whole world that she was dumb, shallow and available. Remind you of something? (khm aegyo khm) Soyeon has the next verse and it is in the dressing room, showing the actual, behind-the-scenes persona - a voracious reader, interested in philosophy, a self-made woman.
It was also a huge trend in the film and musicals of that era for women to have mature, overly sexualized physiques but have ditzy, infantilized voices. I figured the song was making a tongue-in-cheek reference to that.
This music video is so powerful and impactful, the message is conveyed so beautifully; I think sometimes powerful messages are put into music and music vidoes as subtext rather than text, and this is, pun intended, explicit in its meaning. Celebrity as art to be consumed, the way they put the video together, the line about being born nude-- Not to mention they look stunning, sound stunning, seriously it's so amazing if I think about it too much I get emotional. And I'm with you, I hope this song resonates and does well in Korea, because I think it's such an important message--for all of us.
It's not my favourite track musically (although I do love how quirky it is), but I just love all these girl groups who are breaking out of the established KPOP boxes in recent years and I'll support that all the way. Also, the song's actual message is great
If you watch the movie "Blonde" basically Marilyn's private life but with a lot of fictional parts you will understand more why they choose that title and scenes of her.
yeah soyeon is a f***ing genius. but I'm gonna thank you for that grass of leaves book, I only thought its for props but no!intentional and have a very deep meaning
OH MY GOODNESS YES YES YES!!! First of all so sorry that I'm late, second THIS WAS A STATEMENT HOLY COW! The first time I watched this my jaw was just dropped I was legit SPEECHLESS, THEY ALL ARE SO STUNNING- the only thing missing is Soojin (she would've ate, hatred CUBE- and now learning that she loves Marilyn Monroe so much makes it even worse, but I did hear that the cartoon was supposed to be her?) I legit don't know who looked best they all killed it and when I saw our Maknae Shuhua my heart stopped I needed CPR because WOW she looked PHENOMENAL and her Vocals have improved so much just stunning, Soyeon always just WOW she can step on me and when she started taking off her shirt I was just even more stunned, Minnie ATE her vocals holy cow and just her whole look I just love everything about it and her bangs just UGH, Miyeon is so underrated HOLY COW her Vocals always hit me like a truck and her Visuals- (WHY DO THEY ALL LOOK SO GOOD IN BLONDE) just everything, and Yuqi with the blonde and her DEEP voice AND HER GROWL she can step on me and I'd say Thank You! Anyways I can't wait for you to react to more (G) I-DLE such as more Music Videos, B - Sides, Live Performances, Covers, Dance Practices, Moments, and of course Ships! I can't wait for more Content from you and I hope that you are doing well and staying safe and healthy! P.S. If you ever need any good Videos I could totally help you out if you need it, also I just have to say at 13:38 I can't stop replaying that part- Miyeon's voice is just so good!
I’ve been watching this MV whole day, but still enjoy it, can’t get it out of my mind. It was so good, either in the aspects of meaning or visual production. Love it.
I feel like they are one of the best kpop groups at the rockish/dark concept (idk really how to explain it). Also I personally read lyrics a lot because I want to know what the song is about before I sing it or listen to it and honestly I love their lyrics.
I feel sorry for those close minded people who can't appreciate something different....this song is a masterpiece, it's catchy as hck....it's an amazing song 1st listen - I was confused then after a few more, I am obsessed.......
Soyeon is a genius!!! When she said about doing this concept inspired by Marilyn Monroe in a Home Alone episode back in May, I didn't know what to expect but a masterpiece!!
I've said this in another video, but I truly believe it's Shuhua who has brought something special to this comeback (and in no way am I downgrading all the work, talent and effort that every other member has brought to make this possible.). What I mean about that, is finally she has blossomed into a new form, and her charisma brings this slight viciousness? like she's confident, but in the way that it seems that she's looking down on you - which PERFECTLY suits the message of this song. It's this harshness that's almost like 'fuck you'. I especially love her delivery at the end of "you have a dirty mind". Every member brings their own charisma and performance to he group, and now shuhua has brought something unique and new to them, and it rounds it out perfectly. Not to mention, aside from performance, her voice is finally shining and she is rounding out Yuqi's deep voice with her own, as well as bringing lightness when needed. Just. Shuhua makes this comeback and deserves all the praise and hype she's receiving. And again, I'm in no way downplaying the efforts and work of all the other members. All together they make this what it is and is not possible without each of them. Another side note - by classifying Shuhuas presence as 'bitchy' or fierce, I am not saying she is like this as a person. Don't twist me. EDIT: Also, to add to my point. The fact that she went blonde, when before she said she never would and we believe she wouldn't, adds weight to this comeback and the message of WHY they are all blonde. It makes you think about the blonde.
Sad to say, if Soojin is still in (G)-IDLE and this is the MV, it will break the whole internet for sure, this is a perfect concept for her but sadly 😥.
It got a choke hold in the general public. Its now their 2 song to reach more than 100 PAK. Making them the only girl group in history to do it. Also the only girl group to have 2 PAK in one year last done in 2016. Gidle revolution 💜 And Soyeon now has 73 songs, among the most in K-Pop boys and girls taken together.
The Banksy reference: I think it was related to one of his auctioned work, was immediatedly shredded, as a sarcasm to the current art auctioning. However its price went way up after it was shredded. He built a shredder into the painting! Here's the link ruclips.net/video/eXKE0nAMmg4/видео.html&ab_channel=InsideEdition
Suggested? I’ll do more than suggest. Copying and pasting my comment. People are trying to say the animated woman is Marilyn Monroe. Except it’s blonde Soojin. 1. Where is Marilyn’s iconic hair? When Norma Jean became Marilyn you never saw her with long hair again. Never going past her shoulders. 2. The mole/birthmark. Marilyn Monroe had hers near her lips low on her cheek. The animated woman has it under her eye. Do you know who else has a mole/birthmark under her left eye? Soojin. 🫶
Is it just me or does the "dda-dda-lat-dda-da" sound dark and sarcastic? Especially since the whole theme of the song is how women are pushed to be as beautiful as possible, but their viewers are ready to tear them down at any moment or look down on them whenever they see fit.
watch the video till the end!!!!! why ppl still dont learn u has always to aspect something on the end... this is like tomboy when no one undestand or watch the ball with the G -.-
People are trying to say the animated woman is Marilyn Monroe. Except it’s blonde Soojin. 1. Where is Marilyn’s iconic hair? When Norma Jean became Marilyn you never saw her with long hair again. Never going past her shoulders. 2. The mole/birthmark. Marilyn Monroe had hers near her lips low on her cheek. The animated woman has it under her eye. Do you know who else has a mole/birthmark under her left eye? Soojin. 🫶
Okay, so here we finally have a song from I-DLE that I really don't like at all. It was bound to happen sooner or later. I like the message, but not the song itself.
Shuhua is improved soo much with her vocal, dance and facial expression all of it!!! 😭😭😭
Ngl it’s Shuhua’s revenge on cube for kicking Soojin out it’s like her beast mode now 🤯😩
@@markusfeindt if like that then cube happy with shuhua revenge
@@wtf776 I mean technically not cuz before Soojin was in the group they never cared about improving Shuhua’s Korean or her lines but now suddenly it’s happening?! It’s like Shuhua does everything herself now without caring what cube tells her to do
I really want to cheer for Shuhua!
I saw a comment under certain idle's video talking about shuhua's vocal. it wrote 2 years ago, the writer seem know much about vocal/music. they said that shuhua's vocal has wide range, and it's matter of time she will surpass other members vocals. now after listen to this comeback I start to believe what they said.
Soyeon is a genius. That's it, that's the comment
4:03 EXACTLY my reaction to shuhua like holy mother of god she killed it
HHAAHAHA SAMEEE
Lyric videos are going to have a field day trying to place Shuhua’s lines.
That's one of my favorite comments ever
I'm a fossil nevie who's shuhua biased and I STILL can't place all her line x_x
Okay, I'm calling it. The stars of the NXDE era has to be Soyeon and Shuhua. I feel the message is personal to all of them, but Soyeon especially giving two rap breaks to basically shout out to the heavens about it shows her passion. Shuhua, like wise is giving A LOT of facial expressions here and doing so much to give another level and a deeper meaning of the song. I also love that she's comfortable enough now to take equal part in singing, as I really feel she's giving her everything and shining here. Some standout moments (aside from them) is Yuqi's growl and perfect white Marylin-look , Miyeon's "How do I look", Minnie's " Yeppi Yeppi" and of course Animated "Marylin" (but it's really Soojin).
Shuhua and Soyeon killed This 😭
They all killed it!!
shuhua’s era
I’m so proud of Shuhua she’s getting confident so much
This whole music video was filled with fascinating imagery and references, plus the song is a bop. The fact that they sample Habanera from the opera Carmen in the chorus just brings that extra little spice and another layer of meaning to the song since Carmen is often considered as a femme fatale character because in the opera she seduces and brings about the ruin of a naive soldier.
Amazing song and amazing MV! Soyeon really is a genius! All the members did such a good job, but I was so happy and proud of Shuhua, she sounded incredible!
I'm so happy that Shuhua gets to shine this comeback like the star we know she is. 🌟
19:59 fr 😭i rarely change wallpapers and stuff but i'm about to change them all to these gorgeous ladies
I don't think Minnie's starting verse is tongue-in-cheek: as you said, it is a stage persona. She is performing, just like Marilyn Monroe was, surrounded by audience. Marilyn was a shrewd businesswoman and a brilliant actress who managed to persuade the whole world that she was dumb, shallow and available. Remind you of something? (khm aegyo khm) Soyeon has the next verse and it is in the dressing room, showing the actual, behind-the-scenes persona - a voracious reader, interested in philosophy, a self-made woman.
It was also a huge trend in the film and musicals of that era for women to have mature, overly sexualized physiques but have ditzy, infantilized voices. I figured the song was making a tongue-in-cheek reference to that.
This music video is so powerful and impactful, the message is conveyed so beautifully; I think sometimes powerful messages are put into music and music vidoes as subtext rather than text, and this is, pun intended, explicit in its meaning. Celebrity as art to be consumed, the way they put the video together, the line about being born nude-- Not to mention they look stunning, sound stunning, seriously it's so amazing if I think about it too much I get emotional. And I'm with you, I hope this song resonates and does well in Korea, because I think it's such an important message--for all of us.
They are amazing, music and MV amazing. Shuhua really showing how good she is, all amazing
finnaly she found her confidence!
Miyeon deep voice is everything
oh shit you were fast- hi, thanks for reacting!!
It's not my favourite track musically (although I do love how quirky it is), but I just love all these girl groups who are breaking out of the established KPOP boxes in recent years and I'll support that all the way. Also, the song's actual message is great
HAHAHA I love your reaction, i didn't know how to react on every second too 😂😂
If you watch the movie "Blonde" basically Marilyn's private life but with a lot of fictional parts you will understand more why they choose that title and scenes of her.
yeah soyeon is a f***ing genius. but I'm gonna thank you for that grass of leaves book, I only thought its for props but no!intentional and have a very deep meaning
They did what needed to be done. Shu KILLED ME
4:26 No Doubt This is SHUHUA ERA for sure, Her blonde hair gives me more Madonna Vibe 🥰
I've always liked yuqi, and shuhua but recently they have been DEVOURING these recent concepts, and I will never complain.
Nxde already my favorite (G)I-DLE title track, everything sounds and looks amazing.
It just hurts to imagine how Soojin would've fit this concept
can't wait for PD reaction of this. AND REACTTOTHEK CAUSE OF HABANERA
OH MY GOODNESS YES YES YES!!! First of all so sorry that I'm late, second THIS WAS A STATEMENT HOLY COW! The first time I watched this my jaw was just dropped I was legit SPEECHLESS, THEY ALL ARE SO STUNNING- the only thing missing is Soojin (she would've ate, hatred CUBE- and now learning that she loves Marilyn Monroe so much makes it even worse, but I did hear that the cartoon was supposed to be her?) I legit don't know who looked best they all killed it and when I saw our Maknae Shuhua my heart stopped I needed CPR because WOW she looked PHENOMENAL and her Vocals have improved so much just stunning, Soyeon always just WOW she can step on me and when she started taking off her shirt I was just even more stunned, Minnie ATE her vocals holy cow and just her whole look I just love everything about it and her bangs just UGH, Miyeon is so underrated HOLY COW her Vocals always hit me like a truck and her Visuals- (WHY DO THEY ALL LOOK SO GOOD IN BLONDE) just everything, and Yuqi with the blonde and her DEEP voice AND HER GROWL she can step on me and I'd say Thank You! Anyways I can't wait for you to react to more (G) I-DLE such as more Music Videos, B - Sides, Live Performances, Covers, Dance Practices, Moments, and of course Ships! I can't wait for more Content from you and I hope that you are doing well and staying safe and healthy!
P.S. If you ever need any good Videos I could totally help you out if you need it, also I just have to say at 13:38 I can't stop replaying that part- Miyeon's voice is just so good!
*()I-DLE* really gave Korean conservative culture a punch right in the patriarchal kidney. 🤣
SHUHUA SLAYED THIS
Shuhua is SLAYING
SOYEON DONT TAKE UR SHIRT
doit
I’ve been watching this MV whole day, but still enjoy it, can’t get it out of my mind. It was so good, either in the aspects of meaning or visual production. Love it.
Shuhua you did this!! I can not stop this MV....
the simple "oh fxck" when Soyeon appears in the box LMAO
I feel like they are one of the best kpop groups at the rockish/dark concept (idk really how to explain it). Also I personally read lyrics a lot because I want to know what the song is about before I sing it or listen to it and honestly I love their lyrics.
Minnie looks amazing with blonde hair
I feel sorry for those close minded people who can't appreciate something different....this song is a masterpiece, it's catchy as hck....it's an amazing song
1st listen - I was confused then after a few more, I am obsessed.......
SHUHUAAAA
Soyeon is a genius!!! When she said about doing this concept inspired by Marilyn Monroe in a Home Alone episode back in May, I didn't know what to expect but a masterpiece!!
I've said this in another video, but I truly believe it's Shuhua who has brought something special to this comeback (and in no way am I downgrading all the work, talent and effort that every other member has brought to make this possible.). What I mean about that, is finally she has blossomed into a new form, and her charisma brings this slight viciousness? like she's confident, but in the way that it seems that she's looking down on you - which PERFECTLY suits the message of this song. It's this harshness that's almost like 'fuck you'. I especially love her delivery at the end of "you have a dirty mind". Every member brings their own charisma and performance to he group, and now shuhua has brought something unique and new to them, and it rounds it out perfectly. Not to mention, aside from performance, her voice is finally shining and she is rounding out Yuqi's deep voice with her own, as well as bringing lightness when needed. Just. Shuhua makes this comeback and deserves all the praise and hype she's receiving.
And again, I'm in no way downplaying the efforts and work of all the other members. All together they make this what it is and is not possible without each of them.
Another side note - by classifying Shuhuas presence as 'bitchy' or fierce, I am not saying she is like this as a person. Don't twist me.
EDIT: Also, to add to my point. The fact that she went blonde, when before she said she never would and we believe she wouldn't, adds weight to this comeback and the message of WHY they are all blonde. It makes you think about the blonde.
Ma'am HOW CAN YOU BE SO BEAUTIFUL AND HANDSOME AT THE SAME TIME😭🥰
OMG MIYEONN
Jenius nya soyeon gak diragukan lagi 🔥🔥❤️❤️
Concept queens ❤️
Word one: Shuhua
They are representing the cartoon girl as soojin
Yuqis crowl oh my good. Ahhhhhh
the whole mv and the song should be a lecture length of discussion
Soyeon is pulling no punches this year
She really is sick of men lol
4:37 Soojin :')
Sad to say, if Soojin is still in (G)-IDLE and this is the MV, it will break the whole internet for sure, this is a perfect concept for her but sadly 😥.
It got a choke hold in the general public. Its now their 2 song to reach more than 100 PAK. Making them the only girl group in history to do it.
Also the only girl group to have 2 PAK in one year last done in 2016.
Gidle revolution 💜
And Soyeon now has 73 songs, among the most in K-Pop boys and girls taken together.
Im so glad I’m not the only one that noticed the Jessica Rabbit looking cartoon is Soojin haha
AAAAAAA YES, SHUHUA IS SOMETHING ELSE
(👩🏼)I-DLE SLAYYY 🎉🎉🎉
The Banksy reference: I think it was related to one of his auctioned work, was immediatedly shredded, as a sarcasm to the current art auctioning. However its price went way up after it was shredded. He built a shredder into the painting! Here's the link ruclips.net/video/eXKE0nAMmg4/видео.html&ab_channel=InsideEdition
Here Yoongi explains all the scenes and Monroe reference and their deeper meanings ruclips.net/video/J0Ck_HsZwoo/видео.html&ab_channel=dearyoongi
So good. Can we spare a thought for poor Mando though? I fear for his safety...lol
Shuhua is gonna kill me oh my
I really love your video♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Don’t you fucking growl at me Ugi…. I said exactly the same thing lmao
Did you notice that the animated girl in the MV look a lot like soojin in the "i trust" era?
It's been suggested that the animated woman is Soojin... Great breakdown.
Suggested? I’ll do more than suggest. Copying and pasting my comment.
People are trying to say the animated woman is Marilyn Monroe.
Except it’s blonde Soojin.
1. Where is Marilyn’s iconic hair? When Norma Jean became Marilyn you never saw her with long hair again. Never going past her shoulders.
2. The mole/birthmark. Marilyn Monroe had hers near her lips low on her cheek. The animated woman has it under her eye. Do you know who else has a mole/birthmark under her left eye?
Soojin. 🫶
Like it but don’t love it but visual wise you can’t beat it.
literally
네버랜드 특) 4:00에서 나오는 목소리 듣고 '누구지..?' 했다가 4:03 슈화인거 알고 광분
15:33 감격함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
(G)I-DLE💖💖💖💖💖💖
Great 😁👍
Do you know that Minnie was crying because Shuhua dye her hair.
can't help but to think of Paradisio Girls' "Who's my bi+ch", they also have elements of the same opera piece and a theme of rejecting objectification
Is my death this beautiful? I am ded... yeah
the animated woman is probably soojin. THEY PLANNED THIS.
"Probably"? Luscious lips, heart-attack body, and the birthmark under her left eye? There's no way it's a coincidence.
Second👀😎 Nxde BOP!!!!!!
This is not an ordinary K-pop song/mv, this is ART!
This is random but pls tell me your skincare routine
Is it just me or does the "dda-dda-lat-dda-da" sound dark and sarcastic? Especially since the whole theme of the song is how women are pushed to be as beautiful as possible, but their viewers are ready to tear them down at any moment or look down on them whenever they see fit.
watch the video till the end!!!!! why ppl still dont learn u has always to aspect something on the end... this is like tomboy when no one undestand or watch the ball with the G -.-
넘버원1
Lets all thank the kpop Gods that Soojin wasent in this... We would all be dead
애니메이션의 여자는 수진이 아닙니다. 안좋은 일로 그룹을 나간 멤버를 언급하는건 이제 그만했으면
People are trying to say the animated woman is Marilyn Monroe.
Except it’s blonde Soojin.
1. Where is Marilyn’s iconic hair? When Norma Jean became Marilyn you never saw her with long hair again. Never going past her shoulders.
2. The mole/birthmark. Marilyn Monroe had hers near her lips low on her cheek. The animated woman has it under her eye. Do you know who else has a mole/birthmark under her left eye?
Soojin. 🫶
am I the only person thinking the cartoon character is a nod to soojin?
Okay, so here we finally have a song from I-DLE that I really don't like at all. It was bound to happen sooner or later. I like the message, but not the song itself.