Reid, McVay and Shanahan headline top head coaches list | NFL | Speak
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 авг 2024
- Andy Reid, Kyle Shanahan and Sean McVay headline the list of top head coaches. Emmanuel Acho, James Jones and David Helman weigh in on the list and discuss their biggest issues with the rankings.
#Speak #NFL #Chiefs
SUBSCRIBE to get all the latest content from Speak: sprtspod.fox/SU...
The all-new FOX Sports App, built for the modern sports fan: tinyurl.com/y4...
►Watch the latest content from Speak: sprtspod.fox/Th...
▶ The Carton Show's RUclips channel: sprtspod.fox/Su...
▶ First Things First's RUclips channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
► UNDISPUTED’s RUclips channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
▶ The Herd with Colin Cowherd’s RUclips channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
► The Skip Bayless Show RUclips Channel: sprtspod.fox/SU...
► What's Wright? with Nick Wright RUclips channel: sprtspod.fox/wh...
See more from Speak: foxs.pt/SFYFoxS...
Like Speak on Facebook: / speakonfs1
Follow Speak on Twitter: / speakonfs1
Follow Speak on Instagram: / speakonfs1
Follow Speak on TikTok: / speakonfs1
About SPEAK:
The revamped SPEAK takes over the airwaves with Emmanuel Acho, LeSean McCoy and Joy Taylor covering the day’s hottest topics in sports and offering their unfiltered takes.
Reid, McVay and Shanahan headline top head coaches list | NFL | Speak
• Reid, McVay and Shanah...
Speak
/ speakonfs1
Subscribe to First Things First now: www.youtube.com/@FirstThingsFirst
The fact that McVay isn't even 40 yet is insane.
Facts to me he’s the best coach
Ikr. Young dude
Hes the best Coach. If he had Mahomes they would've won every single year
He’ll never eat as many burgers as Reid will buddy. Not in a million years .
But there's also always rumours he'll retire or is burnt out
can actually watch the show without shady
How is Shanahan ahead of a coach that actually won a Super Bowl. Shanahan’s horrible play calling allowed the Patriots to come back from 25 points down and beat Atlanta.
His horrible play calling also has them in SBs.
lol horrible play calling lol that’s funny but he sure does make it to championships and superbowls with our without good quarterbacks. I think he has something with Purdy though because it was only his first full year and he helped the niners to the superbowl so to me that’s badass.
Shanahan wasn't the HC nor was he the DC. If the defense can't hold a big lead, thats on the DC and HC. He put up 28 points in a superbowl Brady won a superbowl scoring 13 points vs the Rams.
That was 100% Matt Ryan choking 😂. His career never recovered.
With out Shanahan the falcon wouldn't even make it too the superbawl.
Mcdermott, Stefanski, O'Connell all too high.
McDermott has never sniffed a super bowl with josh Allen Pederson won 5 playoff games with Nick foles
@AlexRosner-v8t dude that defense was also loaded. Thr eagles teams the past 3 years also had been loaded. And they fricken fell apart last year. Absolutly fell off a cliff.
The defense gave up 38 points and Pederson still won with foles
I am a Bills fan but Mcdermott has a ceiling and that's playoffs divisional
I would Sorryanni lower!! I would have Doug top 10, not 4 though. Mike McDaniel should be top 10 as well
The fact that Jim harbaugh is ranked 7 despite not coaching in the nfl for 10 years is disgraceful. He shouldn’t even be too 15 until he proves himself
The Herbert treatment extends to the coach too apparently
I like how Jim Harbaugh is in the top 10 of NFL head coaches. This definitely can't go wrong for the Chargers.
JJ speaking bars🔥🔥
feels good that mcvay never gets disrespected in this category but the last season he did take a whole team of rookies to the playoffs that to me is more impressive than the super bowl win i thought this last season was going to be a disaster
The Chiefs won Super Bowl 54 with 10 rookies having significant playing time, which was the most for a Super Bowl winning team in more than 3 decades.
@@thefiguredudehe’s not hating on Reid I’m a chiefs fan but he’s just trying to give mcvay his praise which he deserves
Real talk -----I agree "Dougie P" should be number Three...
Stop Ludacris
@@giffondhall9214 That cute...🤣🤣🤣
No way. He allowed his team to choke away a huge lead in his division, and couldn't even make the playoffs last year but he should be top 5. That is so laughable I just can't even. Grow up.
@@joannlewis8101 you really think he is all that? 😄
That’s because press Taylor Sabatoged the season
Acho out here delivering soliloquies and things!! He the truth! 😂
All that talent and Kyle Shenanigans can't win a superbowl
It's not his fault mahomes is always who he got to play against in the SB. And I'm a chiefs fan
What the heck are you taking about mahomes only scored 20 points the first 4 quarters it has zero to do with playing mahomes
@@AlexRosner-v8t it does have alot to do with mahomes. You think alot of QBs winning that SB off that last drive? That's was basically mahomes on that last drive.
It has nothing to do with mahomes they only scored 20 points the first 4 quarters 20 points is the same whether it’s mahomes scoring 20 points or minshew scoring 20 Shang an offense choked that’s why he lost
@@AlexRosner-v8tstupid take. It had everything to do with playing the chiefs. Number one ranked pass defense. They're rush is absoluyly insane. It's hard to get to a superbowl. And think he took 3 different qbs to superbowls and 2 of them shouldn't have even been there. You think they havr all that talent without shannahan. Nah.
The fact Stefanski is coming off a second coach of the year when he got his team to the playoffs having 4 different starting QB’s, missing his best offensive weapon in Chubb and a bunch of other injuries to key players yet he’s behind guys like Jim Harbaugh and Dan Campbell already is crazy. Even Sean McDermott with his failures shouldn’t be above him honestly.
Why is Jim Harbaugh so high I’m confused???
Lamar effect.
@@JuanJose-jb2hz I said Jim not John
@@Cheeze410He turned around the 49ers franchise made a super bowl with Kapernick
@@davis2k1234Then what? He tucked tail and ran until he could come back into another ideal situation. The 49ers were getting stomped out so bad in that Superbowl, the NFL killed the power to give them a break 😂.
@@nikeguy2 Michigan just won the National title he turned around that program and came back to turn around chargers he is one the best coach’s of the last 20 years I just wish Bears would have got him
Nick Sirianni above Shane Steichen is brazy.
Shanahan living off his name. They fired Doug Peterson after he won a superbowl and fumbling the quarterback situation. Shanahan lost a superbowl and fumbled the quarterback situation.
Fumbled? They had a roster where they could take a chance BECAUSE of Kyle. Also, he made Jimmy look competent, look at him now. And Purdy was just in the MVP convo…. Yall sound slow asf
Doug Pederson won 5 playoff games with Nick foles stop
@@AlexRosner-v8t who’s better Jimmy G or Foles??
you dont know football. kyle built a bottom 30 roster into a contender every year
Jimmy g is better than foles so is purdy and foles was throwing to Agholor and Jeffries sganshan has mccafrrey Debo ayuik kittle
mike tomlin outside the top 5 is crazy...you got some guys who havent done nowhere near what he has done
Overrated
No
What he done? 9-8. Evwru year. No playoff wins in forever.
@@wakingforbacon6439Look at the quarterbacks he’s had over the years since Big Ben retired in 2022
How many playoff wins did he have with Ben from 2016-2022?
He voted Cleveland coach over Demeco Ryan’s of coach of the year.👀
Sirianni is the exact opposite of his quarterback you nit wit. SMH. That was the problem down the stretch…he couldn’t provide “answers to the test” as they say. Great guy to have in your corner but not the most knowledgeable as it pertains to certain particulars.
I think he’s a good coach I think they had a bump in the road with the coordinators he does the same thing as Mike Tomlin he’s the glue to the team because we know he’s not a good play caller but we know his culture for the team works
@@Throughmyeye_entertainment Mike Tomlin knows what he’s doin and is a defensive mind. Sirianni is not doing what Tomlin is doing
@@757CitiesReppa he’s doing exactly what he’s doing just on the offense of side and Mike is not in charge of the defense he helps all around and put everything together
@@Throughmyeye_entertainment nah, amike Tomlin KNOWS what he’s doing. How do you know he’s not in charge of the defense🤔. Either way…I wish y’all would stop trynna find some LIKENESS for Sirianni..oh he’s like Tomlin, oh, he’s like Harbaugh. NtfhN
People calling Kyle Shanahan overrated are smoking something strong. He's been to 2 super bowls and 4 NFC championships with Jimmy G and Brock Purdy. Anyone that's watched Receiver on netflix has seen how terrible Jimmy G is. If you gave him a QB like Mahomes or Josh Allen he'd be counting rings.
Also him and Lynch built this team from the ground up.
Pederson won a Super Bowl with foles and Agholor stop
Kyle shanahn had mccafrey ayuik kittle Debo and lost Doug Pederson had Nick foles Agholor and Jeffries and beat Brady shanahn is an embarrassment to professional sports .
And his play calling has cost his teams in all the big games. You can’t keep losing. And hey does he need Josh Allen? Much less QBs have won and without the talent around
@@Triggered_TV24 And other coaches playcalling lost them games earlier in the playoffs/season to where they don't even make it there. But Shanahan gets more criticism? That's stupid, I'm not criticizing the guy making it to NFC championships and super bowls over the other coaches who don't do half as much.
As a Ravens fan, Tomlin is ahead of Harbaugh.
Why? 9-8 evwry year. The most mediocre coach ever. Your not gonna win but your not gonna havr a losing season either. Mediocre. This year he's most definitly gonna havr a losing season. Dude has burrow twice at the end of the year lamar. Mahomes allen all at the end of the year. About 8 brutal games to finish off the season. He's probably gone after this year.
He's going too be fine, every good coach need a good quaterback too win asap joe Gibbs
Harbaugh is overrated. He could have all the talent in the world & find a way to lose when it matters. Tomlin is at least consistent IMO, no matter how unorganized the team is. Lack of continuity & talent is holding him back. I have the Ravens winning a chip already if they switched places.
I can tell u what ACHO does well…. He’s the man!!!!
Dont Forget Mike Tomlin
@ jones please stop with the disrespect in Campbell, sirianni took over a franchise that was at minimum decent. He got them to a superbowl and after that with all the talent players gave up on him. Dan started with nothing and players still will do anything for him so don’t compare coaching with him because your a packer
This man said Peterson is a top 4 coach. The foh Acho lol.
The top 6 is correct but number 7 should be Kevin occonell and pederson should be top 10
How is Jim Harbaugh already in the top 10? 😂
Kyle over mcvay
Never thought id see the day when James Jones was actually defending the Eagles😂
Zac Taylor is a top 10 coach in this league. He’s winning seasons the last 3 seasons, 2 in which went to back to back AFC Championships and a Super Bowl.
We literally watched the jaguars implode last year and went from the 1st seed to out of the playoffs in a couple weeks
Because of press Taylor
@@AlexRosner-v8tnah because the jags couldn’t finish.
It’s fantastic to see Sean Payton at #18.
I like the fact that most of these coaches are in the AFC.
Some of these coaches aren’t proven enough in the current NFL…
Tomlin TOP 5!!!
No way, when was the last time he won a playoff game....I'll wait.
Siriani is the absolute worst coach in the league. Period. Has ZERO qualifications. In his first year, he had the play calling taken away from him or be fired. Steichen took over in the middle of the year and changed everything. He left, and everything fell apart. Siriani was on the verge of being fired again this past off-season. Instead, management took ALL his powers away, and THEY hired a whole new staff under him so as not to fire him and look like they made a huge mistake in hiring him in the first place.
Totally agree! Siriani got EXPOSED last season. Can't design or call plays. Was incapable of changing anything in response to what the other team was doing. Let his team get injury after injury because he had no plans to counter the defense.
What exactly is Siriani's role if he doesn't have any of the skills required to be a coach?? Give Andy Reid a pen and the back of a napkin, and he could come up with a plan on the spot. For Siriani to be put ahead of Dougie P on this list is an absolute joke.
Agreed he showed in the second half of the season that he's not a good coach. The 49ers showed the league how to beat his team and he couldn't do anything to counter it, causing his team to collapse worse than any team in the last 15 years.
Kyle lives off regular season. How many big games has his change of play calling cost his teams? Countless. And harbaugh at 7 is embarrassing
For the People who are calling kyle Shanahan overrated should really take a seat and learn some football.
2020 - made miracles with jimmy g who would eventually overthrow Emanuel sanders in the super bowl.
2022- Defeated the rams in a win or go home OT game in week 17, took a hobbled 49ers squad on the road to beat the cowboys, went into the frozen tundra and defeated the #1 seeded packers, eventually losing to the rams after running out of gas. all with dealing with jimmy g’s inconsistent play.
2023- lost trey lance, inserted jimmy g once again, lost jimmy g, inserted mr irrelevant who people would say couldn’t run, couldn’t throw like a franchise quarterback. ended up making it to the NFC championship game and lost because purdy got injured.
2024- Lost to Patrick mahomes and the Kansas City chiefs who had a stellar defense, same defensive coordinator who took down the all mighty 17-0 patriots.
The same clowns saying he was never going to make it to the NFC championship game or even the Super Bowl in the first place are literally the same ones laughing about him not winning the NFC championship or super bowl.
TALK TO EM!!
For Real!!!
@@SatAttack they don’t wanna hear it bro.
@@cameronzwicke5761 🗣💯
Where is the ring 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
James argues that Siriani is higher because he wins (due to the roster). Shady is bashing Belichick and says he is overrated despite having the most wins (due to the roster/QB). why do certain stats only matter when they suit your narrative?
James doesn’t realize eagles went 1-6 with sirriani before Steichen took over play calling
Shady's only consistent in being an Eagles homer.....other than that he has no consistency and constantly contradicts himself from earlier in the week/season.
Peterson above John harbaugh is crazy, the execs got it right
Nick Siriani easily top 10, I’m taking him over 7-14 EVERY SUNDAY! The Eagles disrespect is FILTHY watch us bounce back. We got a OC & DC now 🦅🦅🦅🦅
That's the point, Sirianni sucks when he calls the plays and requires others to do it. That's why he shouldn't be in the top 10. Before Steichen took over he coached them to a mighty 1-6...
It's his job not to lose the locker room, and he lost the locker room after that loss to the 49ers. The 49ers showed the NFL how to beat Hurts and the Eagles, and Sirianni couldn't make adjustments to stop every team after that from beating them and making both Hurts and that defense looking lost. That's why he's not that good, and everyone could see it. He's overrated and will be fighting to keep his job this season.
Eagles offense is described as elementary and simple. That's the reason the "Brotherly Shove" is their best play. That "family" is why they're being "disrespected" TODAY
I’m a ravens fans and John over Tomlin is crazy to me. John should be ranked 10
No. That’s way too low. He’s where he should be on the list.
@@acephas3 you think? I think John is a product of his environment. The only fruit off the ANDY tree who don’t know how to beat him. Where’s the special team genius at. Tucker saved your job LJ saved your job. Tomlin won with defense his specialty with a trash quarterback. Made the playoffs, off of general fear of the Steelers there were not really good, there reputation makes teams play timid and close and they win
@@acephas3 i like John but show me a coach highlight besides trusting LJ on 4&10. You got the best kicker ever and will only try a 55 n up at the end of half or the end of a game. He’s good at letting coaches do their own thing that’s it.
@@davidhall3530 Here’s the thing. You and I BOTH know that everyone in Baltimore agrees with you. But, we can’t just judge Harbaugh off of losing to Andy Reid. He’s done well against the best coaches in the league (save Tomlin).
This is the 3 I would like to see every day. Ocho talks smarter and Joy and Shady are just annoying extras.
Agreed.
Doug Pederson is a top 10 coach
Peterson won a superbowl and got fired while Shanahan lost 2 and gets more hype
@@bishopsmith3796 I have Pederson above Shanahan in my rankings
@@bishopsmith3796I'm curious who you would have the 49ers hire as his replacement? It's almost impossible to find someone better than Shannahan. It would be just as dumb as when they fired Harbaugh.
@@Travis89-ob5ttthey found Kyle so how was firing Jim dumb?
@@Travis89-ob5tt not saying fire him but he isn't this almighty genius. He has had the best team for 3 years and hasn't won. His roster is the best top to bottom. Name a better team. So why hasn't he won. Any top coach would have won now. Reid, Peterson, Tomlin, are examples.
List is kinda wild
Shanahan has no SB but he’s ahead of John Harbaugh?!?! How SWAY!?!?! 🤔
LaFleur over Tomlin is egregious
I’m a eagles fan but Nick is honestly not that good just leave it to the coordinators that why Doug got fired he wouldn’t change coordinators
Put some respect on Dan Campbell
The disrespect to Mike McCarthy is Ludacris
Hes never done anything without Aaron Rodgers. Absolutly incompetent.
What has he done other than lose in the playoffs to worse teams according to standings, while having "an all-time great qb."
@@wakingforbacon6439 what aaron Rogers done without McCarthy?
@@cameronzwicke5761 what has an all-time great QB do without McCarthy?
4 is crazy. But top 10 for sure for Pederson.
At this point Antonio pierce should be on this list. We heard what his players said about him and how they played
Funny that Bill Belichick isn't on this list
Zac Taylor one of the best culture builders in the league. Have dudes above him who he has had way more success then. He also coaches for one of the least wealthy owners in the league. Bengals coaches have to do way more in scouting and other departments than other coaching staffs. All the Tee Higgins stuff and Trey Hendrickson stuff just disappears in the either because Zac Taylor has built such a good culture there.
Jalen played the entire season hurt.
No Hurts got figured out, he's a one read and run qb that panics if he can't run out of the pocket. The 49ers showed the NFL that if you contain him to the pocket, he panics and makes mistakes. The Giants used this to beat the Eagles last season, the Giants....let that sink in. He's very overrated and will end up like Foles and Wentz, in a couple of seasons.
@@cameronzwicke5761 he played with a knee injury the entire season 🤦🏽♂️. He didn't want to get paid and sit out like Joe Burrow.
Acho loves the Herbert Hate
As a Ravens fan…I hate The Steelers with a passion! But How is Mike Tomlin not in the Top 5?
McDermott at 9? He had grocery associates on defense and held it down last year. 4 straight afc east titles
Shanahan is the most overrated coach in the NFL tbh
You know what that's not a bad claim he always gets put into these top coaching subjects but unlike his legendary dad he has done nothing with sooo much talent!!
The guy made two super bowls and a bunch of NFC championships with Jimmy G and Brock Purdy. If he had an elite QB he'd be counting rings.
@@speedy9313-rv1dm he did with Matt Ryan and he blew it. Literally 🤣
You know what qbs he's dragged to super bowls? That's a wild claim 😂
@@justinlong5589 I mean took Andy Reid 20+ years to win he sure had a lot of talent
How do these Football websites really get these list
It’s not 5 coaches better than Tomlin
When's the last time he won a playoff game......I'll wait.
@@cameronzwicke5761 name me 5 coaches better than him ???
Apparently you can put him at ten.
Please tell me what Kyle Shanahan has done to be third besides choking every big game he’s ever coached in including the second half collapse against the Patriots. Stop it!!!!!
Honestly steichen is too low, it's known he called the plays and he absolutely was rolling this season.
The disrespect to Mike Tomlin especially since he’s made the playoffs every year since he’s been the Steelers head coach.
I’d probably go
Reid
Mcvay
Harbough
Tomlin
Doug Pederson
Campbell
Shanahan
Leflur
Demeco
Payton
Zac Taylor
Antonio Pierce
Stefanski
McDermott
McDaniel
Jim Harbough
Sirianni
O’Connell
McCarthy
Steichen
DQ
Shanahan and LaFleur are way too high
Jim harbaugh should be 18 or 19th lol rookie head coach shouldn't be this high he come back after so many years
Mcarthy should be 32nd
Shut up clown
James the king of excuse making and defending mediocrity
That's why he doesn't bring up Rodgers playoff record
Just think. Eight years ago Andy had no Superbowls, now he has 3. Mahomes put him and Kelce in the Hall of Fame.
Campbell should be higher than LaFleur and Jim Harbaugh shouldn’t be 8 under no circumstances. If they’re going off of past success, then there’s no way that 16-18 should be where they are if you have Jim as high as he is
Dude is wayyyy too biased for Doug Peterson. He’s good but not elite. Sorry not sorry, facts hurts.
How is not the Flus no.1? Asinine
How is Mike Tomlin not top 3. List should be Reid 1. Then Tomlin. Then McVay. Harbaugh and Shananan
Where’s mike Macdonald
Matt LaFleur in the top 5 🤣 He’s literally only relevant because he had the greatest passer in NFL history and another top 10 quarterback in the league in Jordan Love.
Mcvay the future goat 🐐
Sirianni is okay around 15th or 16th
Ravens were a kind of respected team until lamar came and everyone got lamar derangement syndrome and everything ravens is disrespected or hated now.
How bout Jimmy Johnson
Mike Tomlin is too high imo.
Can’t let these dudes paint the narrative. Sirrianni DID NOT hire any offensive or defensive coordinator the eagles have had since coaching the team. The front office puts every single last one of those coaches in place..
It's his job not to lose the locker room, and he lost the locker room after that loss to the 49ers. The 49ers showed the NFL how to beat Hurts and the Eagles, and Sirianni couldn't make adjustments to stop every team after that from beating them and making both Hurts and that defense looking lost.
I'm tired of James Jones it always lead back to someone who either coach or played for the Packers
guy who won coach of the year, is the last of the top 10 .. hahahahaha
Detroit won there first division championship last season and should of been in the superbowl last year. Dan Campbell is the man
Sorry but they blew the lead in the NFCCG. They were out coached, that's why he's not higher on the list.
@@cameronzwicke5761seems more like they outcoached themselves then
AP will be on that list soon enough…
James Jones is a jags hater for sure no cap 🧢. James Jones is biased for sure on certain teams.
Mike McDaniel is on this list how? What has he done? Also McCarthy, Taylor, Sirianni, and McDaniel all fired within 2 years. I will be back.
McDaniels will still be the head coach for the Dolphins, the rest will be gone. McDaniels only had the best offense in the league last year, they had no starting offensive linemen left in the playoffs, what team is going to win a playoff game with all of their starting o-line out.
@@cameronzwicke5761 he’s never won a playoff game. Me and you could coach the dolphins offense with all that elite talent. He’s not even winning divisions bro.
accurate
Whoever ranked this sucks at their job. First of all, we haven’t seen Jim Harbaugh coach in forever and he’s at 7, second Lafleur should not be above Tomlin and Shanahan shouldn’t be above John Harbaugh.
Get over yourself,when's the last time Tomlins team won a playoff game. Shanahan got to the Superbowl with trash a$$ Jimmy G, and 32 year old Emanuel Sanders. And the Same John Harbaugh that couldn't make adjustments to get that offense going against the Chiefs at all. No he's no longer great and is just riding on his reputation at this point. Lamar will never get to a Superbowl, he chokes and John doesn't have the right gameplan to thrive in the league right now. The last 5 seasons and playoffs have shown us he's not that good a coach anymore.
@@cameronzwicke5761 The same Tomlin who hasn’t had a losing season with garbage QBs for like the past 5 years, the same Shanahan who has been to the Super Bowl 3 or 4 times and can’t win one no matter how stacked his team is. It’s funny you bring up that Super Bowl to try and make Shanahan look like he’s built different but don’t bring up how he still hasn’t won a Super Bowl with Deebo Samuel, Aiyuk, and Kittle their forever and now with CMC and a great defense just to lose to Mahomes with one of the worst WR cores in the nfl.
Only two Black coaches and NOBODY better say Mike McDaniel
Get over race, this is about the best coaches in the league, period. Grow up.
@@cameronzwicke5761 shut up Devil
Jim Harbaugh is 2 High he hasnt Coached in the NFL in a long time.😆 🤣 And McDermott is top 5 Acho is a 🤡
Sirianni can't call plays
James Jones had a stinker
Please don't do another show without shady mane Mike Tomlin has done a Superbowl plus a stat no other coach can ever whisper #2 please
Nick siriani did exactly what pederson did. He started like 11 and 1 and then lost the rest or something like that
Nick sirriani had hall of fame talent all around him agholor and Jeffries aren’t close to an brown and devonte smith
Put more respect on Matt Lefleur’s name and Dan Campbell needs to be up there too, Sean McVay is overhyped imo, and so is Shannan. They can only when with stacked rosters
THE 2019 49ers was not a stacked roster. Jimmy G was always trash. Shanahan took a team with 3 different qbs to the NFCCG, and has gotten to 2 Superbowl in 5 years. Dan Campbell blew a 17 point lead and allowed the 49ers to comeback to beat him. That's why he's not top 5.
McVay literally came in and changed the entire Rams culture. You remember how bad they were before he got there? They were terrible with Goff and AD before McVay