Nadu is powerful but the other players had plenty of time in this game to knock him out before it went off. The creature with the swords needed to stop swinging at a thopter for two rounds in a row.
Yeah I agree with this. Nadu was a bigger threat the entire time and knowing he wouldn't get damage through it was not the play to attack him two turns in a row when nadu was there just being let unchecked.
i know everyone is commenting about nadu, which i feel the same about, but brotherhood scribe is not +1/+1 per energy counter gained. it says: “Whenever you get one or more [E] during your turn, creatures you control get +1/+1 until end of turn”. so they could have been +6/+6 with two copies if you got three separate instances of energy, but in most cases they were only +1/+1 or +2/+2, which would have definitely changed life totals and board state.
Yep. I’ve faced the bird six different times. It won the first two games but the next four, we kept it under control. You’ve got to destroy its free targeting cards. I main red in most of my decks so plenty of burn and artifact destruction. I just wish the bird had 3 hp instead of 4 hp 😅😅😅
@@Asianmike8402 Yup, this is exactly right. I have an Ivy deck and I got Nadu for the 99 of said deck but wanted to see how he’d fare as the commander and when I compare that gameplay(no free equips, no untap targeters, etcetera because the deck isn’t built around him) to any gameplay I’ve played against or seen, it is those cards that generate the absurd value. Also, targeting stuff like lightning greaves, swift foot boots or any of the cheap equip stuff notably doesn’t trigger Nadu since they aren’t creatures which means you don’t have to be worried about surprise lands giving them mana for protection spells!
You can equip a creature with the equipment it is already wearing to save you a bit of time moving the mantle back and forth. Just equip twice and move on.
@@maxbodifee3263 you can. Equip just has to have a target which is why you can’t unequip. Only something like lightning greaves wouldn’t work because it can no longer target the creature it’s attached to since it has shroud.
Funny bird goes ''draw your entire library and put all lands you own even in real life, like your inheritance and most of the territory owned by you and your ancestors are put into play''. Great content guys per usual guys :)
Nadu is clearly not a casual card. I will respectfully leave a table if someone brings Nadu out of not the rest of the table is not bringing out at least high power decks. Even the cheapest version of this deck has most of the broken cards in it. Honestly I don't know what Nadu in casual will look like but it definitely doesn't have scutes, lotus cobra, any of the free equipcost equipment, any way to blink your commander. And to any who says I am over reacting I goldfished this deck a lot. I really really liked it. It is a really fun deck to pilot and does something I love in my abdel Adrian. When someone removes I get at least one card back. But the deck is stupid strong. Maybe a landfall cantrip deck? Something really really not obvious might be playable in casual tables. I don't blame the game. The game was great. You are playing with new commanders. It is great to see Nadu make an appearance. But I don't want to see that commander in my lgs any time soon unless we are actively playing cedh.
I’m glad to see that it’s not just people at my store I play at that have horrible threat assessment. Jason has made an an active Seeker…you kill him NOW before he gets 16 triggers over the next 2 turn cycles. Sorin is a problem eventually…Nadu is a problem NOW.
Well each player gets a turn, rounds are usually used to represent a full turn cycle in a game. It can also be used in the way you’re referring to as well though.
So, Sword player needed to actually do something with his combats, Like kill the NADU player, his comment of "If I take him out then you'll just kill us" was really the wrong mindset when he tried to swing in twice already and got blocked both times by a thopter, taking out the Nadu player who had a win con in hand seems more pressing then the energy player who "MAY" be able to win. Also the Sorin player shoulda just exiled the creature so no tokens were made and the attack was stopped. but I am not there, I do love your content keep it up.
Sorin, Ravenous Nenonite. Was getting worried Nadu was about to be unpunished for tapping out to drop him turn 2. Not nonstop murdering Nadu/the player was a big oof. Absolute remove commander/player asap. Nooooo, Abtuse is COLORLESS! First thing on there is Devoid. Could have hit the pony.
How did he draw so many times with nadu when the card says triggers only twice each turn? No audio while watching if someone can explain how this got so busted
Naw, doesn’t deserve a ban. But it doesn’t belong at casual tables. If someone plays it, just refuse, or make an agreement with the whole table that he is the #1 target.
Nadu is powerful but the other players had plenty of time in this game to knock him out before it went off. The creature with the swords needed to stop swinging at a thopter for two rounds in a row.
Yeah I agree with this. Nadu was a bigger threat the entire time and knowing he wouldn't get damage through it was not the play to attack him two turns in a row when nadu was there just being let unchecked.
WHAT IS NATE'S PLAN?!?!?!
i know everyone is commenting about nadu, which i feel the same about, but brotherhood scribe is not +1/+1 per energy counter gained. it says: “Whenever you get one or more [E] during your turn, creatures you control get +1/+1 until end of turn”. so they could have been +6/+6 with two copies if you got three separate instances of energy, but in most cases they were only +1/+1 or +2/+2, which would have definitely changed life totals and board state.
God I wish I was at the table for no reason in particular 0:54
Best commander content on youtube.
Thanks!
15:47 it has Devoid
doesn't devoid get around protection from white?
Yes
The removal spell that the sorin player cast had devoid so he could have cast it on the pro white creature
Of course Jason would play Nadu.
15:46 This spell has devoid, so it gets around protection from white, doesnt it?
Oh good point!
@12:50 SHOULD'VE KILLED NADU AGAIN...Haven't even finished the video but I know this would have been the correct choice...
Yupp, I was right...
Yep. I’ve faced the bird six different times. It won the first two games but the next four, we kept it under control. You’ve got to destroy its free targeting cards. I main red in most of my decks so plenty of burn and artifact destruction. I just wish the bird had 3 hp instead of 4 hp 😅😅😅
@@Asianmike8402 Yup, this is exactly right. I have an Ivy deck and I got Nadu for the 99 of said deck but wanted to see how he’d fare as the commander and when I compare that gameplay(no free equips, no untap targeters, etcetera because the deck isn’t built around him) to any gameplay I’ve played against or seen, it is those cards that generate the absurd value. Also, targeting stuff like lightning greaves, swift foot boots or any of the cheap equip stuff notably doesn’t trigger Nadu since they aren’t creatures which means you don’t have to be worried about surprise lands giving them mana for protection spells!
You can equip a creature with the equipment it is already wearing to save you a bit of time moving the mantle back and forth. Just equip twice and move on.
Can you? I don't think so
@@maxbodifee3263 you can. Equip just has to have a target which is why you can’t unequip. Only something like lightning greaves wouldn’t work because it can no longer target the creature it’s attached to since it has shroud.
@@danriemer9724yep, only lightning greaves can't be used this way.
Watching this after watching the rematch and man Eddie cut Nate some slack jeez 😂😂😂
Funny bird goes ''draw your entire library and put all lands you own even in real life, like your inheritance and most of the territory owned by you and your ancestors are put into play''. Great content guys per usual guys :)
12:55 Arna has two ward triggers, the discard from her original text and ward 2 from cods worth.
Everyone tried to say Nahhh Duude to Nadu. Great game as usual.
Nate, going with the standard magic player strategy. Love a traditionalist.
Nadu is clearly not a casual card. I will respectfully leave a table if someone brings Nadu out of not the rest of the table is not bringing out at least high power decks. Even the cheapest version of this deck has most of the broken cards in it. Honestly I don't know what Nadu in casual will look like but it definitely doesn't have scutes, lotus cobra, any of the free equipcost equipment, any way to blink your commander.
And to any who says I am over reacting I goldfished this deck a lot. I really really liked it. It is a really fun deck to pilot and does something I love in my abdel Adrian. When someone removes I get at least one card back. But the deck is stupid strong.
Maybe a landfall cantrip deck? Something really really not obvious might be playable in casual tables.
I don't blame the game. The game was great. You are playing with new commanders. It is great to see Nadu make an appearance. But I don't want to see that commander in my lgs any time soon unless we are actively playing cedh.
No idea why i'm subbed, as i don't have any of your stuff in my history, but good content :) i'll keep it
Nadu... kill it as soon as possible. 😂 as every simic commander lol
I’m glad to see that it’s not just people at my store I play at that have horrible threat assessment.
Jason has made an an active Seeker…you kill him NOW before he gets 16 triggers over the next 2 turn cycles.
Sorin is a problem eventually…Nadu is a problem NOW.
Satya gave me energy that’s for sure
The choices made during this game is worth studying 😂
3:47 you forgot to pay that 1 life for the grove
Nate the friend we all need but don't deserve. It's not gay if it's for the homies.
Is there any way to make the cards bigger on the screen I can't see them 🤣 jk love the videos
Ravenous (Knee-oh-nate)
damn we need a Nate in our play group
The nadu was just not punished all game, the nadu player is always the first to go with no exceptions.
How is Sorin white/black? Extort doesn't effect color identity
Google is me friend*
The new rulings for flipwalkers the planeswalker identity is what decides the color identity like tamiyo is simic aswell.
I’ll always just focus a nadu player
Codsworth also gives Arna ward 2
They keep using the word round instead of the word turn. Round would indicate a new game. Are they trolling us for interaction?
Well each player gets a turn, rounds are usually used to represent a full turn cycle in a game. It can also be used in the way you’re referring to as well though.
LOVE NADU!!
I'm surprised you grabbed the green dude instead of aphetto for the card draw. 🤔
That Bird is so freaking broken, omg
He really needs to be kept off board! The deck doesn't do a lot without him.
@@TheDankestDungeon I think the enablers need to be removed over the bird. Targeting the commander just ramps them back into recasting Nadu
They could have killed it ez
Nadu is a cool commander but boring to play against
So, Sword player needed to actually do something with his combats, Like kill the NADU player, his comment of "If I take him out then you'll just kill us" was really the wrong mindset when he tried to swing in twice already and got blocked both times by a thopter, taking out the Nadu player who had a win con in hand seems more pressing then the energy player who "MAY" be able to win. Also the Sorin player shoulda just exiled the creature so no tokens were made and the attack was stopped. but I am not there, I do love your content keep it up.
Sorin, Ravenous Nenonite. Was getting worried Nadu was about to be unpunished for tapping out to drop him turn 2. Not nonstop murdering Nadu/the player was a big oof. Absolute remove commander/player asap.
Nooooo, Abtuse is COLORLESS! First thing on there is Devoid. Could have hit the pony.
Nadu is a menace
Nadu is so broken xD
Threat assessment in this game seems dumb
Nadu is so fuc*ing busted!
How did he draw so many times with nadu when the card says triggers only twice each turn? No audio while watching if someone can explain how this got so busted
I think they forgot that part.
its twice per turn per creature. nadu gives that ability to all your creatures
why didnt you guys target jason?!?! lol Nadu is the dumbest thing I've seen since Time Walk
Was everyone's first game against him!
Nadu is gonna get banned
Why swords to plowshares during your own mainphase? You realize that card is an instant right?
I've yet to see Nadu lose. It really needs to be banned in commander.
yeaaa 😅 it needs to b hated out of the game b4 nadu ramps the controller 😅😅😅
I GOTTA AGREE
I've seen it lose many times, people are just dumb
Naw, doesn’t deserve a ban. But it doesn’t belong at casual tables. If someone plays it, just refuse, or make an agreement with the whole table that he is the #1 target.
Simic commander seems very annoying
Innit Duncan
Yep Nadu is wonky. Pulled him in a pack so gonna make him. Def need plenty of protection spells cuz he's a removal magnet
Ban.
Sorin’s color identity is just black not white
Nope because of its back side it's considered orzhov cause the backs color identity is black/white
Unleash Arna!
4:43 This is probably a top 3 worst mtg pronunciation of all time. It's even worse because neonate is a real word
Also, his name is literally NATE, how is this possible?!
@@TheDankestDungeon we'll say its because sorin's head covers part of the word 🤫