I think rather than the question of "when did islam came to India?" the question of "when did mass conversions or large scale conversions started in India?" would be more relevant.
the muslim saints like Khwaja Mueen, Khwaja Nizam, Hazrat Ali Hajveri, Shehbaz Qalander, Shah wali ullah, Shah Shamas and dozens of others are major spreaders of islam in subcontinent. And their period is integrated, they were present during whole period, even before Mehmood Ghaznawi...
Irony is in India, the oldest mosques still exist, would love to know the what is the oldest surviving Hindu Temple or Buddhist Prayer Hall that stands today in Pakistan and what's the status, considering Hinduism and Buddhism predates Islam in Indian Subcontinent.
There is 2500 years old Buddhist ☸️ complex in my hometown. If you have any doubt, google Buddhist complex in Takht bhai. Its name is not even changed. Don't watch Arnab Goswami!
Hi Hamid. Being from Kerala, I find it interesting that you have choses the history of Islam in the Indian sub continent. Cherman mosque in Kodungallur (Cranganore) is indeed very much active even now. Since you have touched on this subject & the evolution of religiouns in the sub continent, I would also suggest that you do a video on the history of Christianity in the Indian subcontinet. It will be a refreshing surprise for may. You could also do one on why & how the muslims got aggressive by poor leadership which also is a huge trigger for the public perception towards them.
If muslims forcefully converted hindus to Iskam so why in 1941 census hindus were 30% in Sindh...how 30% hindus after 1400 years of muslim rules ...How Delhi sultanate, Mughal capital Delhi, Agra is still 80% hindu majority
@@muzaffarhussain754 Asia. The American historian Will Durant asserted in 1935 that “the Mohammedan conquest of India is probably the bloodiest story in history,”
مسلمان جو دوسرے علاقوں مثلاً ترک ایران یا افغانستان سے آ ے وہ بہت کم زیادہ تر مقامی لوگوں نے اسلام قبول کیا تھا مثلاً میں نسلی طور پر سندھی ھوں اور سندھی تمام ہندو تھے اور ہمارے بزرگوں نے اسلام قبول کیا تھا زیادہ تر مسلمان تو مقامی لوگ ہیں
The Cheraman Juma Mosque (Malayalam: ചേരമാൻ ജുമാ മസ്ജിദ്) (Arabic: مسجد الرئيس جمعة) is a mosque in Methala, Kodungallur, Thrissur in the Indian state of Kerala. A legend claims that it was built in 643 CE, which makes it the oldest mosque in the Indian subcontinent which is still in use.
It's a shame it was rebuilt in Disney Aladin style rather than restored in It's orginal style which was similar to indigenous style of architecture. Thankyou for sharing
Fun Fact: Before islam these arab traders used to trade with southern Indian (kerala). But once he noticed that arabs have adopted a new religion. He allowed them to build a mosque. This mosque was usually built for arab traders who now converted to IsLAM. When Kerla king noticed this. He asked an arab merchant to take him with him and show him that who is your prophet. And in India. Kerla king is the only guy who actually met Prophet Muhammad in person.
Excellent narration about history. A good step Mir Sahib. My stance about your personality now changed. Amazing. Please continue this effort to clear the misconceptions about Muslims. A commendable work. Brilliant step towards clear the all doubts and islamophobia concept. Thanks
@@Prakash20031 the militant groups like RSS and BJP doing same act as call fundamentalist since their creation before partition. Who give this slogan Alkhunds Bharat Maata? Go to the history especially Indian parliament and you will find the first resolution against the creation of Pakistan in her first assembly meeting. All members accepted that we take this division on the instructions of Mahatma Gandhi and we sworn that we will make Akhund Bharat to emerged the Pakistan into India. So be prepare yourself about history and then passes your comments . Thanks
If muslims forcefully converted hindus to Iskam so why in 1941 census hindus were 30% in Sindh...how 30% hindus after 1400 years of muslim rules ...How Delhi sultanate, Mughal capital Delhi, Agra is still 80% hindu majority
@@eden55272 One of the biggest migration took place in 1947 between Pakistan and India. Go through the history and then understand why the populations decreased in Sindh. Forcefull conversion is a myth and all Hindu historian claimed the same thing. Just understand the reality in which you and we Muslims are lived together and what are the causes for a new country? Accept the reality and than talk. Thanks
Sain G.M. Syed, a great thinker, and leader, wrote about Shaheed Raja Dahir, the true hero of Sindh. His books clearly show that Raja Dahir bravely fought against the evil forces of Bin Qasim. This story fills us with pride and reminds us of the bravery and strength of Sindh.
اپ کی یہ ویڈیوز کمال کی ہیں اپ جو میسج جو نالج شیر کر رہے ہیں کہ کمال ہے اس سب کا بہت مثبت اثر ہوگا سوسائٹی پر یقینا ان شاء اللہ اللہ اپ کو نیک اجر عطا کرے
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂 Tell me one this will you change your religion now ? When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india. Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂 Tell me one this will you change your religion now ? When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india. Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
Great .Do try to Speak truth about what's Happening in the country .Along what #Eastablistment is doing with people .Misusing it's power ....Vo Tou Atni detail mah nai Bataty ap...
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂 Tell me one this will you change your religion now ? When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india. Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
Hamid Sir, You are an islamist zealot. Your knowledge is based on Islsmic narrative and on very limited perspective. Islam has been always a religion that belevives in conversion through coersion or by the power of sword. This is seen even today within some educated Muslim people. All these has led to uneasiness and awareness even among so called kafirs in Europe, Americas. They now hate followers of Islam because of this mindset. Muslim don't integrate with culture of their state. They belive in the culture of their Aka Saudis or Turkyees Converted muslims like pakisthsnis have lost their self esteem and suffering from grave identity crisis. They are ashamed of their original religious and cultural identity Please read books by eminent Pakistani scholar Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed and get enlightened with proper knowledge. ISLAM FORBIDS ITS FOLLWERS FROM RATIONAL AND LOGICAL THINKING, PARTICULARLY BECAUSE OF ITS INFLUENCE BY PEOPLE LIKE YOU, ASHRAFS AND MULLAS. YOUR FAILED ATTEMPT THROUGH YOUR SPEECH WILL NOT HELP THE ENLIGTENTED MUSLIMS NOT TO LOOK RATIONALLY OUTSIDE THE ISLAMIC COCOON AND THINK OUT OF THE BOX WHICH YOU ALL ARE NOT SAYING OR PREACHING. 😊
Thanks for bringing proper perspective to the issue. Even post-Mohammad bin Qasim, Islam was spread by sufis and saints and not by swords. For almost a 100 year RSS has been trying to forcefully convert Muslims to Hinduism with practically no success. This in itself proves that the Muslims are Muslims because they like their religion, not because someone had used sword to convert them to Islam.
RSS is nationalist movement not religion.....Hindu Muslim Sikh Christian are all it's members... Jis bare mein knowledge na ho pehle Jano... VHP, Bajrang Dal etc are religion parties or movements... This is reason Pakistani dunia mein chitar kha rahe han. Juth freb, Gumrah, dokha, Jihad... 6 lakh Bengali ( Muslims) girls been raped in 1971, Baloch girls been prosecuted, KP girls complaint for sexual abuse.... It's a shameful past of Pak Army... But now Pakistani Army has got educated good officers they trying to wash kukarm done by Ayash Generals in past
Even your f@lase prophet Muhammad and imaginary character Allah did exactly the opposite of what you are saying. These are the proofs of that. *1) Non-Muslims have to pay jizya in dishonorable conditions* *Quran 9:29* "Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued." *2) Call to fight against the infidels* *Quran 98:6* "Indeed, those who disbelieve from the People of the Book and the polytheists will be in the Fire of Hell, to stay there forever. They are the worst of ˹all˺ beings." *3) Paradise under the flash of the sword* Narrated `Abdullah bin Abi `Aufa: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Know that Paradise is under the shades of swords." *Sahih al-Bukhari 2818* Chapter 22: Paradise is under the blades of swords, Book 56: Fighting for the Cause of Allah (Jihaad) *4) Killing if you don't read Kalema* It was narrated that Abu Hurairah said: "The Messenger of Allah [SAW] said: 'I have been commanded to fight the people until they say La ilaha illallah. If they say it, then their blood and wealth are prohibited for me, except for a right that is due, and their reckoning will be with Allah, the Mighty and Sublime." *Sunan an-Nasa'i 3976* Chapter 1: The Prohibition of Bloodshed, Book 37: The Book of Fighting [The Prohibition of Bloodshed] *Grade: Sahih (Darussalam)*
No Indian is asking Hamid mir to tell us our ancient history. He is doing so for his domestic audience only to build a counter narrative against the truth of "forceful conversion of muslims" of the sub continent. By islamic invaders. We indians are well aware of our 7000 years old history that itself is 5000 older than Islam.
I am preety sure no one knows much about saraswati civilization, indus Valley civilization, Vedic periods, Maha janapada, Chanakya, emperor Chandragupta Mourya, Ashoka, Vikramaditya, Kanishka, Samudra Gupta....etc etc. Islamic history starts from 7th century but our Hinduism history starts from 7000 BCE. 👇👇👇👇👇👇👇 ruclips.net/video/wysIgN6oIqc/видео.htmlsi=73gfVWo9NVECRx3X
In Gujrat and South India shafai muslim were Arab traders who introduced Islam without force however, in north India present day Pakistan Islam came through Muslims invaders. You can see the result. Mir Saab bring something else by the way Hussiani Brahmins story has no historical proof.
The oldest mosque in the Indian subcontinent is generally considered to be the Cheraman Juma Mosque, located in Methala, Kodungallur in the Thrissur district of the Indian state of Kerala. It is believed to have been built in 629 AD, making it one of the oldest mosques in the region. According to historical accounts, it was built by Malik Deenar, a companion of the Prophet Muhammad, who is said to have introduced Islam to the region.
629 me makka bhi fathe nahin huatha 629 se leke 30 ke bich hua exact date kisiko pata nahin ginti bhar musalmaan the tab aur Indian me masjid ban gayatha kansi gandu se sune ye history
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂 Tell me one this will you change your religion now ? When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india. Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
ماشاءاللہ بہت خوب صورت پیغام خوبصورت ترین معلومات اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے آمین یارب العالمین اسلام ذندہ باد پاکستان پائندہ باد بھائی حامد میر صاحب ۔ ھمارے نبی کریم صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کے آخری خطبہ کو اگر غور سے پڑھیں تو معلوم ہوگا کہ ھمارے نبی صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم نے اپنے صحابہ کو اسلام کی تبلیغ کے لئے حکم دیا تھا کہ وہ پوری دنیا میں پھیل جائیں اور دین اسلام کی تبلیغ کریں تو صحابہ کرام رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین بھی یہاں ھندوستان کے مختلف علاقوں میں پہنچے اور دین اسلام کی تبلیغ شروع کردی ۔ جسکا ثبوت ھنزہ کے علاقے میں صحابی رسول کی قبر مبارک کا حال ھی میں مجھے معلوم ہوا ہے اس لئے ھم ختمی طور پر کوئی آخری بات نہیں کہہ سکتے اسمیں مزید تحقیق کی گنجائش موجود ہے میں جو چند الفاظ لکھے ہیں وہ صرف معمولی سی معلومات ھیں اللہ تعالیٰ ھمیں استقامت عطا فرمائے سچ اور حق گوئی کی طاقت عطا فرمائے آمین یارب العالمین عالم اسلام ذندہ باد پاکستان پائندہ باد
CHATGPT: The first mosque (masjid) in the Indian subcontinent is believed to be the Cheraman Juma Mosque in Kerala, India. It is thought to be the oldest mosque in the Indian subcontinent and has a history dating back to the 7th century. According to historical accounts, the Cheraman Juma Mosque was built during the lifetime of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) by Arab traders who were visiting the region. The mosque underwent subsequent renovations and reconstructions over the centuries, but its origins are traced back to the early period of Islam.
Arguable though, India's oldest mosque is not Cheraman but the Juni Masjid or Barwada Masjid in the ancient port town of Ghodha. The reason to consider this as oldest mosque in India is that its facing towards 'Baitul Muqaddas' in Jerusalem therefore historian believe that it was built before 623 AD when the Qibla was still Baitul Muqaddas.
@@Shicore2010 Allah has moved to 4 BHK in Mecca from one room of Jerusalem... One God concept, Azaan, Spl food, 10 Commands of creator, Nawaz all this is stolen from Musa. Jews are child of Israel ( Yakoob) whom Musa saved from Firon, not Muslims, After Qatalo-Garat of 1500 years Both original Abrahamic religion Jews Christian back to democracy. Copy cat Islam still going stone age.
اس کا مطلب ھے کہ یہ مسجدیں حضرت محمد مصطفیٰ صلی علیہ وسلم کی زندگی میں بنائی گیں کیونکہ آپ دنیا سے(AD) 632 میں اس دنیا سے رخصت ہوئے تھے اور تقریباً 632سے 634 تک حضرت ابوبکر صدیق رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ کا دور تھا 634 سے 644تک حضرت عمر رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ 644 سے 658تک حضرت عثمان غنی رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ اور 658سے ( AD )662 تک حضرت علی کرم اللہ وجہہ کا دور حکومت تھا
Mujhe lagta h yaa mere samjh me india or pakistan ke muslim ki soch Islam jaisi nhi h bahut danger mood ka muslim dikhta h arab ko jyada follow karta h ies jagah se khud ko nhi jod paa rha h abhi Tak arbi me hi ajan deta h khud ki language nhi bna paya kya karan h
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂 Tell me one this will you change your religion now ? When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india. Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
I don't agree with everything that has been said in this vlog, but it is a thoughtful video. It is worthy of attention by scholars in both countries. I would take the liberty of suggesting to Mir Sahib to interview some Indian scholars on these issues, in particular on Akhand Bharat.
Good idea aisi debates honi chahyen q k hamen pata hi nhi sach kia hy or jhot kiya hy Ab mujhy chand din pehly hi pata chala hy k Muhammad bin qasim jis ham hero samjhty thy asal mein hazrat imam Hussain k khandan ko wapis lejany k liye aya tha ta k unhen qatal kia ja saky its mean k Raja Dahir imam Hussain k khandan ki hifazat ker raha hoga Agar ye bat sach hy to hmara hero to phir Raja Dahir hona chahye Berhal ye debate honi chahye
Very informative video. As you have a good reputation and access in state running personals, I request you to take steps for the correction of atleast our historical textbooks so young generation and school going children can get the right information about history. Thank You. 😊
Our history books taught in schools clearly say that many Muslim Arab generals tried to secure safe return of the kidnapped women and children by Raja Dahir but not successful but Muhammad bin Qasim was successful that's why he is regarded as hero
There are 2 graves of Ashab e Rasool RA in Mehboob Goth which is bordering village of Districts of Sukkur and Shikarpur. That means they had come here to spread Islam.
Asalam alaikum sir If Masjid of Kerala was built in 622 ad it means Islam came to India during Prophet's s.a.w era because the death (wisal mubarak) of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w was 632 and I also mentioned in my other comment that the qibla direction is towards Masjid Al Aqsa
کیا آپ نے حامد میر کی پوری ویڈیو دیکھی ہے۔۔۔؟ برائے مہربانی پوری ویڈیو دیکھیں جس میں وہ یہ بتا رھے ہیں کہ تقریباً 25 کے قریب صحابہ کرام محمد بن قاسم سے پہلے ھندوستان میں آ چُکے تھے؟؟؟؟
Some books tell that the Maharaja of Kerala saw the Miracle of the splitting moon of Holy Prophet Hazrat Muhammad (peace be upon him ) with his eyes and he asked to investigate the matter, upon revealing of Prophet Miracle he embraced Islam at that time.
One family lived in a house for a thousand year. Suddenly few outsiders came/attacked the house and grabbed it. The original family had to share the house with the outsiders because they were defeated. Long way down the line in time, outsiders grandsons and granddaughters started claiming the house as their own as they were born and brought up there. No one remembered how the house came to be shared by 2 distinct families. No one was outsider now as the no one had invaded the house in the first place. Original inhabitants had welcomed another family with open arms, thats how, half the family of the house remember things now. Other half's feelings are not added. Claim of attack of force is rejected by by the historians who belong to other half of the family. Fast forward now, the very house is divided in 4 parts. 3 parts of the house are inhabited by members who are not the aboriginals. The only remaining part has members who dream of their house which was complete once. There are enlighted members of other family who term them as bigot, racist, blind, ignorant , BJP and RSS members.
your analysis exactly fit on Rajputs of hindus. because these aryan white skin nomadic tribe came from europe through iran invaded you and given you a name Hindu which means black...they burnt your cities (their Reminiscences and the ruins are still in pakistan)... when it is felt by your ancesters that they are really Hindu so that they decided to imerge Aryans into subcontinent by "parishification"... so a party were arranged and relationship made by giving them daughters of native Brahmens and named them as rajputs... it is a fact everyone know that.... the concept of Islam is totally different.... because excluding a few (may be some thousand or less then 5 lak currently), most of them contains of native indians and they changed their religion. However the people who are still following their old religion impudently claiming that due to the change of religion you are no longer native (it does'nt metter that maybe so called native hindu's forefathers came in subcontinent after the converted muslim, sikh or chrisitian's forefather) so you have to change your faith and religion by force or i would banish you out of the subcontinent....
Hindus are named by Arabs who used to mispronounce "Sindh" (the Aryan river) as "Hind". According to Hindus, Hinduism is the World's oldest religion as there is no historical proof of its establishment. Due to this reason, many Hindu scholars consider them as the followers of ''Sanatan Dharma'' instead of "Hinduism".
@@AbThinker You are wrong, the word Brahman means followers of lord Brahma, who is Lord Brahma? he is Hazrat Ibrahim A.S. The last Ayah of Surah Al A'lA, mentions "Suhufi Ibrahima wa Musa" translates the verse as "The Books of Abraham and Moses". The Scriptures of Ibrahim and Musa. We know the Script of Musa but where is the script of Abraham, most scholars believe it is contained in Hindu books but they concealed it. Why are they concealing it? I know the reason if you ask me then I tell you.
@@healer1000040 but Brahman is not a religion. Religion is an English language word and founded significance after English language was introduced before that people just used to practice different way of life without giving it a name.
Jats were the earliest people in the Indian subcontinent to have interacted with the Muslims. The multiple trading communities of Jats already existed in pre-Islamic Arabia. Jats were referred to as Zatts (Arabic: الزُّطِّ, romanized: Az-Zutt) in early Arab writings and Jat-an in Persian. They and the Buddhas were prosecuted by Rajputs therefore they fought alongside Muslims against Raja Dahir.
Because our ancestors gave jaziya or ready to give their heads but will never surrender our religion to invaders and you are one of the by product of tha Islamic Invasion@@healer1000040
@PavitShokeenIf muslims forcefully converted hindus to Iskam so why in 1941 census hindus were 30% in Sindh...how 30% hindus after 1400 years of muslim rules ...How Delhi sultanate, Mughal capital Delhi, Agra is still 80% hindu majority
@@eden55272we Hindus and our ancestors have fought hard to save our pride , our Dharma, our culture inspite foreign Islamic invaders demolished our temples, universities. Ram janmabhoomi temple was demolished by Babur, but Hindus got temple back after 500 yrs.
Aslkum sir for your kind information Islam arrived in India when Muhammad peace be upon him split the MOON in two parts one Indian Raja was watching live because he was walking on his palace rooftop next day he called his darbar jjutish and he explained about Arab prophet Muhammad peace be upon him he send his son with companions to Makkah and Harat Ali host them and converted them Muslim he was Rajput Chouhan clan’s his mizar in India you can find evidence or reference in Takbeer resala in jamat e islami and lot of historical references
One thing which I didnt get from you is how that hindu raja knew about the cause of moonsplitting and next day he talked with his jotish about Muhammad PBUH that he ia responsible for this incidenence.
حامد میر صاحب سلامت رھیں آباد رھیں میں نے ڈاکٹر عبدالقدیر خان صاحب کا کالم پڑھا تھا جس میں انہوں نے بھوپال کی ایک مسجد کا ذکر کیا تھا جو دور نبوت میں بنی تھی اور سب سے پرانی ھے واقعہ مجھے یاد ھے نام بھول گیا مہاراجہ کا جس نے بنوائی تھی
Sir thank you for your personal explanation, I don't agree with Akhand Bharat we have seen enough bloodshed of innocent people but there is a mention of Hindu kings of Qandar in Mahabharat, as much as I would like to agree with you that Islam did not spread in India with sword, the fact is in today's Pakistan population of non Muslims has declined to non existence in most parts of the country except Sindh, and the education policy of Pakistan today doesn't educate about Sikhs and Hindus they only teach hate, hope you will make another episode to explain this so we can move forward in peace, many thanks ji,
You are right 😢 brother . To be brief there are extremists on both sides. They want to gain cheap popularity. Actually there is mostly politics behind it.
Are juth ki bi had Hoti he Islam ke age Tumne talwar ke dar se salwar paheni he varna 1 achhai dikha de only one jiski wajah se koi khooshi khooshi ye arbi ghu khate only one wajah kishi ko Pagal kutte ne kata he Jo esa third class religion follow karega
Islam is spread by many ways ....by Kings ,By invaders ...sword .....and Dalits acceptance of Islam bcoz Hindus don't give access to temples....so we are brothers......this is a reality....and Akhand Bharat is the reality...... u accept it or don't it doesntbmatter❤❤❤ everyone
If muslims forcefully converted hindus to Iskam so why in 1941 census hindus were 30% in Sindh...how 30% hindus after 1400 years of muslim rules ...How Delhi sultanate, Mughal capital Delhi, Agra is still 80% hindu majority
Why are the people of Balochistan being killed in a cruel and merciless way, Mir Sahib, please make a video on this also on your personal RUclips channel. And I thank you very much for speaking up for the people of Balochistan in your show Capital Talk.
The people who have natural resources in any form, like geography, minerals, agriculture, water, gas, and petroleum are being declared as terrorists, and it is happening all over the world, The Punjabi army doing the same thing in KPK, Sind, and Baluchistan. Indian army in Kashmir, Nagaland, and Punjab, and the USA all over the Middle East.
I am a bit confused. Mir says that Islam didn’t spread through sword, and goes on to to give examples of three mosques spread across three states. Then he admits 25 sahaba attacked different parts of India, which is clearly what Hindus are saying - that Islam spread by the sword. Yes, there could have been some conversion due to sufis, but it is very evident that a majority of the conversions were due to threats, coercion and incentives.
There's nothing to be confused about it as 1st Arab traders came and that's how Islam spread and after that some wars might've happened but Arab traders followed Islam entrance
@@afrazamjad1644 Entrance - yes. But Arabs were not the only traders coming to India. There were Romans, Chinese, Africans and Malay traders too. Did their religions spread as much as Islam did? No. The spread is because of the invasions, and the subsequent coercion.
@@patmclaughlin107 Even if I accept your logic for a while then it would be at par with British and how they spread Christianity. But your politics would never be at the cost of that!!
@@afrazamjad1644 No, they are not equivalent. The British were mercantilist. They wanted to build an empire that can supply them commodities, taxes and soldiers. They did not let this mission be diverted by religious conversions and temple desecration. What benefit did Bakhtiar Khalji derive by destroying Nalanda? What was the monetary benefit in building Quwwat ul Islam mosque on top of Hindu and Jain temples? This was purely to show the dominance of Islam over the native population. Spanish and Portuguese did it, but not the British.
@@patmclaughlin107 just understand this simple concept. Islam does not allow forced conversions, but it allows muslim governments to collect jeezia tax from nonmuslims in exchange of religious and social freedom, and that tax must not be too much of a burden. but when a foreign army invaded a country in the old days, converting to their religion was the norm, the religion of the rulers was the religion of the state, in indias case, converting to islam meant no jeezia tax and favourable positions in the eyes of the rulers, and that is why they converted. forced conversions dont even make sense as governments wanted to collect those taxes. in egypt, the muslims rulers didnt allow the population to become muslims for a long time as they wanted to keep collecting the jeezia tax so why would the rulers want to convert indians?
Sir, Take My Salam. I'm from Bangladesh. It is a very valuable short summary of high light at this moment. But really it's very valuable. I think it's necessary & highly priority to view commercial all the channels & Media. At least Turkey all the channel & Media.
Sanatan dharma is the oldest religion on earth.. Islam came just before 1400 years... I am very proud of my ancestors that they fought, they resisted Islamic invaders like khilji, gaouri, Gajnavi etc and saved their identity, religion and culture... and we remain as proud sanatan followers and NOT forced converted zealots..😊😊😊
Kerala masjid is oldest mosque in the world. The land was offered by the king of Kochi, Arab would come to Kochi for spice trade, this masjid was constructed for Namaz. Other two mosques...there are no reference in India. The three masjid (you referred to) basically were near the sea shore for Arabs to offer namaz. It doesn't mean that Islam got its roots in India. MOHAMMAD Bin Qasim invaded India to spread Islam with violence, latter on many other invaders came to India to demolished temples and forcefully convert Hindus to Islam. Hamid now you are parroting establishments narrative. 😅😅
@@BABA-ORUC1761 رام کتھا تو تم شروع کررھے ہو؟ چسکے لینے اور ٹھرک جھاڑنے کے لیے۔۔۔۔۔ جو بات تم نے کی ہے۔۔۔ کیا وہ اس وی لاگ کا موضوع ہے؟ اگر نہیں ہے تو پھر وہ اس بے تُکی ، گھٹیا بات جس کا اس موضوع سے کوئی تعلق ہی نہیں، کے بارے بات کیوں کرے؟؟؟؟ اگر تم نے یہ واقعہ پڑھنا ہے تو یحییٰ امجد کی کتاب تاریخ پاکستان کا صفحہ نمبر 29 سے 47 پڑھ لو۔۔۔۔۔۔ تم معلوم ہوجائے گا کہ اس نے شادی کیوں کی اور دُمبوں (بکروں) پہ مٹی لگا کر گھاس اُگانے کی کوشش کرکے لوگوں کو کیا پیغام دیا۔۔۔۔۔؟؟؟؟
اسلام تو اللہ کے رسول صلی ۔ کی حیات مبارکہ میں سندھ کے لوگ اسلام قبول کرنے اور حضور کی زیارت کرنے گئے تھے ۔ اور اپنا روایتی تحفہ اجرک بھی حضور کی خدمت میں حاضر کیا گیا تھا ۔ یہ سنی تاریخ ہے اپنے حساب سے بیان کرتے ہیں آپ دوسرون کی طرف مراجع بھی کیا کریں ۔
حضرت سعد بن ابی وقاص کا مقبرہ چین کے صوبہ سنکیانگ میں ہے جو اس بات کی نشانی ہے کہ چند اصحابِ رسول حضرت عمر فاروق کے دور حکومت میں برصغیر پہنچ چکے تھے بلکہ نہ صرف برصغیر وی چین تک رسائی حاصل کر چکے تھے، اور کچھ تاریخی کتب اس بات پر متفق ہیں کہ ان اصحابِ رسول کا راستہ سندھ سے پاکپتن جھنگ اور ٹیکسلا سے ہوتا ہوا سنکیانگ تک تھا، یعنی یہ جو کہا جاتا ہے کہ صوفیاء نے برصغیر میں اسلام پھیلایا بھی ٹھیک نہیں ان سے پہلے اصحابِ رسول اس خطے میں پہنچ چکے تھے
حامد میر صاحب بڑے احترام کے ساتھ عرض ہے کہ 1) حضور صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم کی پیدائش کا سال 571 عیسوی ہے۔ 40 سال کی عمر میں نبوت ملی، مطلب 611 عیسوی میں۔ نبوت کے پہلے 13 سال مکہ میں گزارے، مطلب 623- 624 عیسوی تک مکہ میں رہے۔ ان تیرہ سال میں حضور نے طائف کا سفر کیا۔ اور مسلمانوں نے صرف حبشہ کی طرف 2 ہجرت کئے۔۔ مدینہ سے آیا ہوا وفد حج کے موقع پر مکہ میں ہی حضور سے ملا تھا اور پھر اگلے سال دوبارہ بھی حج کے موقع پر۔ تب تک مسلمانوں نے اپنے لئے الگ مسجد تو دور کی بات کھل کر دعوت دینے پر بھی مشکلات کا سامنا کرنا پڑتا تھا۔ مسلمانوں نے اپنے لئے پہلی مسجد ہجرت کے فوراً بعد بنائی جسکا نام مسجد قباء ہے۔ اب میرے لئے یہ سمجھنا بہت مشکل ہے کہ حضور نے خود اپنے لئے مسجد 624 عیسوی میں بنائی اور برصغیر میں 623 عیسوی میں بن گئی جبکہ ابھی اسلام کی دعوت و تبلیغ صرف حجاز میں ہی تھی۔۔۔ عجم تو بہت دور کی بات ہے۔۔۔۔ 2) دوسری بات یہ کہ برصغیر میں اسلام حضرت عمر رضہ کے زمانے میں آیا تھا وہ بھی بلوچستان کے علاقے تک۔۔۔ برائے مہربانی تصحیح کرکے جواب دیجیئے گا ۔۔۔ شکریہ حوالہ جات 1) الرحیق المختوم ۔۔ صفی الرحمٰن مبارک پوری 2) سیرت النبی ۔ ۔ سید شبلی نعمانی 3) الفاروق ۔۔ سید شبلی نعمانی 4) nabataea.net/explore/cities_and_sites/barwada-mosque/
آپ کی معلومات بہت حد تک صحیح ہیں. 630.31 عیسوی میں رسول اکرم کی وفات ہوئی. 660 میں حضرت علی علیہ السلام کو شہید کر دیا گیا. 670 عیسوی میں نواسہ رسول حضرت امام حسن کو شہید کر دیا گیا 680 عیسوی میں حضرت امام حسین علیہ السلام کو کربلا میں شہید کیا گیا. بہت سے مسلمان خاص طور پر محبانِ اہل بیت امویوں کے ظلم سے تنگ آکر مکران اور سندھ کی طرف ہجرت کرنے لگے. حجاج بن یوسف جسے بنو ثقیف کا قصاب کہا جاتا ہے اور جس نے ہزاروں بیگناہ مسلمانوں کا قتل کیا ہے عراق کا گورنر تھا اس نے اپنے بھتیجے یا بھانجے کو ہجرت کرنے والے مسلمانوں کو قتل کرنے کے لئے آیا جنہیں راجہ داہر نے پناہ دے رکھی تھی...سرکاری اور درباری تاریخ میں بنی امیہ کے حکمرانوں کو ہیرو بنا کے پیش کیا ہے. جبکہ اصل میں بنی امیہ کے حکمران بادشاہ تھے جنہوں نے حصولِ اقتدار کے لئے نواسہ رسول کو خاندان سمیت تہہ تیغ کر دیا..
Hamid bhai i am a history student and jat boy ,haryana india.hindustan me islam arab businessman,s ke thru laya gya lekin uska asar jyada nahi tha,712 me mohmmad bin qasim ne sindh raja dahir pr hmla kr katlo garat kiya lekin uska asar bhi sindh k kuchh ilaqe pr raha bad me Mahmud gaznavi 1001 or uske bad 1198 or 1199 me mohmmad gori k bad delhi k sultan 1526 k bad mughlo k bad jyada conversion hua jo talwar kdam pr hua,
اولیاءاللہ نے اسلام برصغیرمیں پھیلایا حضرت علی ہجویری رح بری شاہ لطیف قادری حضرت محمدحیات قادری پیرمہرعلی شاہ رح حضرت معین الدین چشتی رح جیسے دیگر بزرگوں نے انہوں نے محبت اور امن سے اسلام پھیلایا
حامد میر سلامت رھیں آباد رھیں میں نے ڈاکٹر عبدالقدیر خان صاحب کا کالم پڑھا تھا جس میں انہوں نے بھوپال کی ایک مسجد اور مہاراجہ کا ذکر کیا تھا جور دور نبوت میں بنی تھی اور سب سے پرانی ھے واقعہ مجھے یا ھے نام بھول گیا مہاراجہ کا
Very Intellectual Talks Hamid Sahab - You have raised a very Important Subject & I must say you are now become a Historian as well and this is good for any Journalist like you. Off course there are too many Fiction Stories circulates around us which needs to be revisit.
Jazaak Allah kullo Khair Male sahaba singular= عنه anho Male sahaba plural=عنهم anhum Female sahabiyaat singular=عنها anha Female sahabiyaat plural=عنهن anhunna Both for dual=anhuma عنهما
حامد بھائی آپ کا دعوی محل نظر ہے کہ پہلی مسجد 623 عیسوی میں قائم ہوئی ،کیونکہ 622 عیسوی میں تو مسجد نبوی تعمیر کی گئ ہے،کیونکہ 632 عیسوی رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کی تاریخ وفات ہے
Thank you for touching the topic. During the last days of Caliph Omar, after conquering Iran, he sent an army to Sind. This army didnot reach Sind (I am not going into details) but it did conquer parts of Makran which are under Pakistan now. When the Caliph recalled the army, a part of it was left behind to continue to control the area.
پیارے نبی کی پیدائش اپنے والد کی وفات کے 4 سال بعد ہوئی۔ اس کو ممکن بنانے کے لیے پورے محلے نے امینہ کے ساتھ بہت محنت کی۔ 30 باپوں کی وجہ سے رسول اللہ ﷺ کو 30 آدمیوں کی طاقت تھی۔
First mosque in kerala during prophet Muhammed ( PBUH).
Nahi sir gujrat m h sabse purana masjid.
During Muhammad al aqsa masjid bhi nahin tha Jahan se momin kehte hai Navi jannat gaye the😂😂😂
Acchha Muhammad jab sadi pe sadi kar rahatha tab India me masjid banithi😂😂
Muhammad ko mango ke bare me pata nahin tha nahin toh wo bhi jannat me dal deta aur uske time pe hindustan me Islam agaya thas kya chutiyapa hai
@@Blogspot.. do your research
I think rather than the question of "when did islam came to India?" the question of "when did mass conversions or large scale conversions started in India?" would be more relevant.
I think the question is why were hindus so piss weak? Such peasantry is unbeknownst to man.
Forcefully,whenever it ...
Mere Bhai agar aysa hua hota to India main Hindus ab na hoty
the muslim saints like Khwaja Mueen, Khwaja Nizam, Hazrat Ali Hajveri, Shehbaz Qalander, Shah wali ullah, Shah Shamas and dozens of others are major spreaders of islam in subcontinent. And their period is integrated, they were present during whole period, even before Mehmood Ghaznawi...
@@MIANQAASIM Hindu Raja the unhone hindu dharm ko protect kiya isliye hindu dharm bacha
Irony is in India, the oldest mosques still exist, would love to know the what is the oldest surviving Hindu Temple or Buddhist Prayer Hall that stands today in Pakistan and what's the status, considering Hinduism and Buddhism predates Islam in Indian Subcontinent.
Good luck bro! Just try to understand the thinking and mindset of journalists like Hamid Mir. And he is among the relatively better ones.
There is 2500 years old Buddhist ☸️ complex in my hometown. If you have any doubt, google Buddhist complex in Takht bhai. Its name is not even changed. Don't watch Arnab Goswami!
bhai credit is given where credit is due
Asia. The American historian Will Durant asserted in 1935 that “the Mohammedan conquest of India is probably the bloodiest story in history,”
😂it's huge six by sourav.
Well said
جزاکاللہ بھائی ایسی انفارمیشن دینی چاہیے سب کو تاکہ مسلمانوں کو صحیح انفارمیشن ملے
Ye mir Hamid batayega history isse Pakistani gaddar mante hai
Hi Hamid. Being from Kerala, I find it interesting that you have choses the history of Islam in the Indian sub continent. Cherman mosque in Kodungallur (Cranganore) is indeed very much active even now. Since you have touched on this subject & the evolution of religiouns in the sub continent, I would also suggest that you do a video on the history of Christianity in the Indian subcontinet. It will be a refreshing surprise for may. You could also do one on why & how the muslims got aggressive by poor leadership which also is a huge trigger for the public perception towards them.
Your have a misconception about the muslims and muslim agression Mr. Abraham.
One of Jesus disciple Thomas brought Christianity to Kerala. Legend says
If muslims forcefully converted hindus to Iskam so why in 1941 census hindus were 30% in Sindh...how 30% hindus after 1400 years of muslim rules ...How Delhi sultanate, Mughal capital Delhi, Agra is still 80% hindu majority
nice to meet you on this way, dear
@@muzaffarhussain754 Asia. The American historian Will Durant asserted in 1935 that “the Mohammedan conquest of India is probably the bloodiest story in history,”
سر اسی طرح موضوعات لایا کریں اس سے نوجوانوں کو مطالعے کا جذبہ اور شوق پیدا ہوگا اور یوں ہم بہت سے تاریخ کی کتب اور علم سے استفادہ کرتے رہیں گے
اب جا کر لگتا ہے
ہمیں اپنا سابقہ حامد میر صاحب مل گئے
اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو صحت عزت دولت ترقی عطا فرمائے آمین
❤
اسکا کیا مطلب ہے
This is the education that Pakistan needs, thank you so much for this.
indeed, thanks to you
I read this book mahmmad bin qasim .. very interesting book when was reading book i was amazed to know how islam spread
مسلمان جو دوسرے علاقوں مثلاً ترک ایران یا افغانستان سے آ ے وہ بہت کم زیادہ تر مقامی لوگوں نے اسلام قبول کیا تھا مثلاً میں نسلی طور پر سندھی ھوں اور سندھی تمام ہندو تھے اور ہمارے بزرگوں نے اسلام قبول کیا تھا زیادہ تر مسلمان تو مقامی لوگ ہیں
The Cheraman Juma Mosque (Malayalam: ചേരമാൻ ജുമാ മസ്ജിദ്) (Arabic: مسجد الرئيس جمعة) is a mosque in Methala, Kodungallur, Thrissur in the Indian state of Kerala. A legend claims that it was built in 643 CE, which makes it the oldest mosque in the Indian subcontinent which is still in use.
It's a shame it was rebuilt in Disney Aladin style rather than restored in It's orginal style which was similar to indigenous style of architecture. Thankyou for sharing
جبکہ اس مسجد سے قبل ایک اور مسجد جو گجرات میں 623 عیسوی میں بنائی گئی تھی وہ سب سے پُرانی مسجد ہے۔ یہ 643 عیسوی والی مسجد سب سے پُرانی کیسے ہوگئی؟
Fun Fact: Before islam these arab traders used to trade with southern Indian (kerala). But once he noticed that arabs have adopted a new religion. He allowed them to build a mosque. This mosque was usually built for arab traders who now converted to IsLAM. When Kerla king noticed this. He asked an arab merchant to take him with him and show him that who is your prophet. And in India. Kerla king is the only guy who actually met Prophet Muhammad in person.
Oldest mosque of South Asia is in bhambhore sindh.older than Indian mosques
These are only tall claims. No clear evidence to back them.
Excellent narration about history. A good step Mir Sahib. My stance about your personality now changed. Amazing. Please continue this effort to clear the misconceptions about Muslims. A commendable work. Brilliant step towards clear the all doubts and islamophobia concept. Thanks
Commendable research work but what we know is that historically there two countries Hind and Sind, there was no any akhand bharat.
Aap Pakistan ko sudhar lo puri duniya sudhar jayegi
@@Prakash20031 the militant groups like RSS and BJP doing same act as call fundamentalist since their creation before partition. Who give this slogan Alkhunds Bharat Maata? Go to the history especially Indian parliament and you will find the first resolution against the creation of Pakistan in her first assembly meeting. All members accepted that we take this division on the instructions of Mahatma Gandhi and we sworn that we will make Akhund Bharat to emerged the Pakistan into India. So be prepare yourself about history and then passes your comments . Thanks
If muslims forcefully converted hindus to Iskam so why in 1941 census hindus were 30% in Sindh...how 30% hindus after 1400 years of muslim rules ...How Delhi sultanate, Mughal capital Delhi, Agra is still 80% hindu majority
@@eden55272 One of the biggest migration took place in 1947 between Pakistan and India. Go through the history and then understand why the populations decreased in Sindh. Forcefull conversion is a myth and all Hindu historian claimed the same thing. Just understand the reality in which you and we Muslims are lived together and what are the causes for a new country? Accept the reality and than talk. Thanks
Sain G.M. Syed, a great thinker, and leader, wrote about Shaheed Raja Dahir, the true hero of Sindh. His books clearly show that Raja Dahir bravely fought against the evil forces of Bin Qasim. This story fills us with pride and reminds us of the bravery and strength of Sindh.
استغفر اللّٰہ قومیت سے باہر نکلو ایک امت بنو اپنے پیارے نبی صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم کی
محمد بن قاسم کا سندھ فتح کرنے سے بہت سے لوگ اسلام میں داخل ہوئے۔
G.M syed to kud b Arab tha....
@@faheemabid2463wonderful bro! Really insightful to understand your thinking and mindset 😂
@@faheemabid2463 chale Arabo ka gulam
Islam zindabad Quran zindabad sunnat zindabad tablighi jamaat zindabad 🌎🇺🇸😍🇳🇮🇺🇦🇨🇫🇨🇻🇨🇻🇩🇲🇩🇲🇨🇱🇫🇰🇭🇲🇫🇰🇭🇲😍🥰😘🤣😭🇵🇷🇺🇸🇲🇰💐💐🥰🇵🇲🇸🇷🇨🇩🌏🇺🇾🇹🇦🇼🇫❤🇨🇳
Fat mat Jana yrr bhai kahi tu bomb laga k
اپ کی یہ ویڈیوز کمال کی ہیں اپ جو میسج جو نالج شیر کر رہے ہیں کہ کمال ہے اس سب کا بہت مثبت اثر ہوگا سوسائٹی پر یقینا ان شاء اللہ اللہ اپ کو نیک اجر عطا کرے
Mr. Mir . Your last 2 vlogs were excellent work . Please continue with this kind of valuable contribution
💯👍
thanks for the support
Sir please a video on plight of uigher muslims@@rehmani786k
These videos will be used a autentic reference ! Hamid mir is an encyclopedia in itself! Much power to you ❤
😂😂😂
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂
Tell me one this will you change your religion now ?
When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india.
Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
Thori aur chaat lay hamid ki g.and
Astonishing historical facts.Keep sharing factual research
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂
Tell me one this will you change your religion now ?
When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india.
Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
For you, even the story of flying horse is factual history.
بہت اعلیٰ میر صاحب
Great sir informational velog
Excellent work Meer sb.. this type of VLOGS are very informative and important for today's generation.. keep doing good work 👍
¹😊q
Great .Do try to Speak truth about what's Happening in the country .Along what #Eastablistment is doing with people .Misusing it's power ....Vo Tou Atni detail mah nai Bataty ap...
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂
Tell me one this will you change your religion now ?
When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india.
Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
good comment
Hamid Sir, You are an islamist zealot. Your knowledge is based on Islsmic narrative and on very limited perspective.
Islam has been always a religion that belevives in conversion through coersion or by the power of sword.
This is seen even today within some educated Muslim people. All these has led to uneasiness and awareness even among so called kafirs in Europe, Americas. They now hate followers of Islam because of this mindset. Muslim don't integrate with culture of their state. They belive in the culture of their Aka Saudis or Turkyees Converted muslims like pakisthsnis have lost their self esteem and suffering from grave identity crisis. They are ashamed of their original religious and cultural identity
Please read books by eminent Pakistani scholar Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed and get enlightened with proper knowledge.
ISLAM FORBIDS ITS FOLLWERS FROM RATIONAL AND LOGICAL THINKING, PARTICULARLY BECAUSE OF ITS INFLUENCE BY PEOPLE LIKE YOU, ASHRAFS AND MULLAS.
YOUR FAILED ATTEMPT THROUGH YOUR SPEECH WILL NOT HELP THE ENLIGTENTED MUSLIMS NOT TO LOOK RATIONALLY OUTSIDE THE ISLAMIC COCOON AND THINK OUT OF THE BOX WHICH YOU ALL ARE NOT SAYING OR PREACHING. 😊
Thanks for bringing proper perspective to the issue. Even post-Mohammad bin Qasim, Islam was spread by sufis and saints and not by swords. For almost a 100 year RSS has been trying to forcefully convert Muslims to Hinduism with practically no success. This in itself proves that the Muslims are Muslims because they like their religion, not because someone had used sword to convert them to Islam.
good comment in the line
its historical fact 15lam spread by sw0rd
RSS is nationalist movement not religion.....Hindu Muslim Sikh Christian are all it's members... Jis bare mein knowledge na ho pehle Jano...
VHP, Bajrang Dal etc are religion parties or movements...
This is reason Pakistani dunia mein chitar kha rahe han. Juth freb, Gumrah, dokha, Jihad...
6 lakh Bengali ( Muslims) girls been raped in 1971, Baloch girls been prosecuted, KP girls complaint for sexual abuse.... It's a shameful past of Pak Army... But now Pakistani Army has got educated good officers they trying to wash kukarm done by Ayash Generals in past
صوفیوں نے بھی حملہ آوروں کی حمایت کی
Even your f@lase prophet Muhammad and imaginary character Allah did exactly the opposite of what you are saying. These are the proofs of that.
*1) Non-Muslims have to pay jizya in dishonorable conditions*
*Quran 9:29*
"Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued."
*2) Call to fight against the infidels*
*Quran 98:6*
"Indeed, those who disbelieve from the People of the Book and the polytheists will be in the Fire of Hell, to stay there forever. They are the worst of ˹all˺ beings."
*3) Paradise under the flash of the sword*
Narrated `Abdullah bin Abi `Aufa: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Know that Paradise is under the shades of swords."
*Sahih al-Bukhari 2818*
Chapter 22: Paradise is under the blades of swords, Book 56: Fighting for the Cause of Allah (Jihaad)
*4) Killing if you don't read Kalema*
It was narrated that Abu Hurairah said: "The Messenger of Allah [SAW] said: 'I have been commanded to fight the people until they say La ilaha illallah. If they say it, then their blood and wealth are prohibited for me, except for a right that is due, and their reckoning will be with Allah, the Mighty and Sublime."
*Sunan an-Nasa'i 3976*
Chapter 1: The Prohibition of Bloodshed, Book 37: The Book of Fighting [The Prohibition of Bloodshed]
*Grade: Sahih (Darussalam)*
Overall a very Good effort to clear the concept about history..❤
Excellent talk Hamid Mir sahib well done.
بلکل درست معلومات ۔۔۔۔
حامد میر صاحب سلامتی ہو آپ پر
Indians asking Hamid Mir to tell them about their own history as they know their own govt has twisted history🤣
No Indian is asking Hamid mir to tell us our ancient history. He is doing so for his domestic audience only to build a counter narrative against the truth of "forceful conversion of muslims" of the sub continent. By islamic invaders.
We indians are well aware of our 7000 years old history that itself is 5000 older than Islam.
I am preety sure no one knows much about saraswati civilization, indus Valley civilization, Vedic periods, Maha janapada, Chanakya, emperor Chandragupta Mourya, Ashoka, Vikramaditya, Kanishka, Samudra Gupta....etc etc.
Islamic history starts from 7th century but our Hinduism history starts from 7000 BCE.
👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
ruclips.net/video/wysIgN6oIqc/видео.htmlsi=73gfVWo9NVECRx3X
INDIANS KY HISAB SY SIRIF WOHI INSAAN HAI JOH GOBAR KHAYE!
یوتھیا لگ رہے ہو اپنے میسیج سے۔ 45٪ دماغ والا یوتھیا۔ اگر نہیں ہو تو معذرت۔
In Gujrat and South India shafai muslim were Arab traders who introduced Islam without force however, in north India present day Pakistan Islam came through Muslims invaders. You can see the result. Mir Saab bring something else by the way Hussiani Brahmins story has no historical proof.
The oldest mosque in the Indian subcontinent is generally considered to be the Cheraman Juma Mosque, located in Methala, Kodungallur in the Thrissur district of the Indian state of Kerala. It is believed to have been built in 629 AD, making it one of the oldest mosques in the region. According to historical accounts, it was built by Malik Deenar, a companion of the Prophet Muhammad, who is said to have introduced Islam to the region.
629 me makka bhi fathe nahin huatha 629 se leke 30 ke bich hua exact date kisiko pata nahin ginti bhar musalmaan the tab aur Indian me masjid ban gayatha kansi gandu se sune ye history
Such a great analysis ❤
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂
Tell me one this will you change your religion now ?
When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india.
Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
ترجمہ: دین تو اللہ کے نزدیک اسلام ہی ہے۔
ماشاءاللہ بہت خوب صورت پیغام خوبصورت ترین معلومات اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے آمین یارب العالمین اسلام ذندہ باد پاکستان پائندہ باد
بھائی حامد میر صاحب ۔ ھمارے نبی کریم صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کے آخری خطبہ کو اگر غور سے پڑھیں تو معلوم ہوگا کہ ھمارے نبی صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم نے اپنے صحابہ کو اسلام کی تبلیغ کے لئے حکم دیا تھا کہ وہ پوری دنیا میں پھیل جائیں اور دین اسلام کی تبلیغ کریں تو صحابہ کرام رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین بھی یہاں ھندوستان کے مختلف علاقوں میں پہنچے اور دین اسلام کی تبلیغ شروع کردی ۔ جسکا ثبوت ھنزہ کے علاقے میں صحابی رسول کی قبر مبارک کا حال ھی میں مجھے معلوم ہوا ہے اس لئے ھم ختمی طور پر کوئی آخری بات نہیں کہہ سکتے اسمیں مزید تحقیق کی گنجائش موجود ہے میں جو چند الفاظ لکھے ہیں وہ صرف معمولی سی معلومات ھیں اللہ تعالیٰ ھمیں استقامت عطا فرمائے سچ اور حق گوئی کی طاقت عطا فرمائے آمین یارب العالمین عالم اسلام ذندہ باد پاکستان پائندہ باد
Very Informative ❤❤❤
Excellent video, keep it up Mir Bhai hope to see more such videos,GOD bless India and Pakistan ❤
Tusi kyo enne khush ho rahe ho 😂
Tere baap arbhi thaa aur teri maa " Male galimat thee " 😢😢😢
CHATGPT:
The first mosque (masjid) in the Indian subcontinent is believed to be the Cheraman Juma Mosque in Kerala, India. It is thought to be the oldest mosque in the Indian subcontinent and has a history dating back to the 7th century.
According to historical accounts, the Cheraman Juma Mosque was built during the lifetime of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) by Arab traders who were visiting the region. The mosque underwent subsequent renovations and reconstructions over the centuries, but its origins are traced back to the early period of Islam.
Arguable though, India's oldest mosque is not Cheraman but the Juni Masjid or Barwada Masjid in the ancient port town of Ghodha. The reason to consider this as oldest mosque in India is that its facing towards 'Baitul Muqaddas' in Jerusalem therefore historian believe that it was built before 623 AD when the Qibla was still Baitul Muqaddas.
Hamid Mir, you did not mention the sufi orders who propagated Islam in the sub continent, specially Suharwardia and Chishtia sufi orders.
thanks for the support
@@Shicore2010 Allah has moved to 4 BHK in Mecca from one room of Jerusalem...
One God concept, Azaan, Spl food, 10 Commands of creator, Nawaz all this is stolen from Musa. Jews are child of Israel ( Yakoob) whom Musa saved from Firon, not Muslims,
After Qatalo-Garat of 1500 years Both original Abrahamic religion Jews Christian back to democracy. Copy cat Islam still going stone age.
@@gs7458cope 😂
Dr. Tahir ul qadri nerated this issue that is great material
اس کا مطلب ھے کہ یہ مسجدیں
حضرت محمد مصطفیٰ صلی علیہ وسلم کی زندگی میں بنائی گیں کیونکہ آپ دنیا سے(AD) 632
میں اس دنیا سے رخصت ہوئے تھے اور تقریباً 632سے 634 تک حضرت ابوبکر صدیق رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ کا دور تھا 634 سے 644تک حضرت عمر رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ 644 سے 658تک حضرت عثمان غنی رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ اور 658سے ( AD )662 تک حضرت علی کرم اللہ وجہہ کا دور حکومت تھا
❤ Great explanation of History. Thanks 👍
Mujhe lagta h yaa mere samjh me india or pakistan ke muslim ki soch Islam jaisi nhi h bahut danger mood ka muslim dikhta h arab ko jyada follow karta h ies jagah se khud ko nhi jod paa rha h abhi Tak arbi me hi ajan deta h khud ki language nhi bna paya kya karan h
thanks dear
Asia. The American historian Will Durant asserted in 1935 that “the Mohammedan conquest of India is probably the bloodiest story in history,”
Yes they were a decedent of arab incestory.. " Male galimat" 😃😃😃😃they feel ashmed when they know the truth 😃😃😃😃
It doesn't matter how and who bring Islam in sub continent. But the matter is that how we distract from true spirit of Islam
Goodone
What is the true spirit of Islam?
good lines
@@himmsingz its not about destroying temples, thats for sure.
Great effort. Thanks for sharing your knowledge.
Lifafewala 😂😂 better you see islamic history . 2nd minority population in Pakistan 3rd why cant minority become PM n prisident in Pakistan 4th Islam is religion of peace 😂😂 ? See the history? West mai Islam kase aya😂
Tell me one this will you change your religion now ?
When your country name is islamic republic of Pakistan then why you have problem with HINDU india.
Fact is outside islamic republic of Pakistan you need democracy and equal rights 😂 shameless but jn Pakistan and Muslim countries you dont give equal rights.
Wa alaikum assalam❤
Aap Nai Bilkul Correct HIstory Bayan Ki Hai.
I don't agree with everything that has been said in this vlog, but it is a thoughtful video. It is worthy of attention by scholars in both countries. I would take the liberty of suggesting to Mir Sahib to interview some Indian scholars on these issues, in particular on Akhand Bharat.
Sir ise kuch nai pata 😂 ise pucho rajput Muslim kyu hue...
Good idea aisi debates honi chahyen q k hamen pata hi nhi sach kia hy or jhot kiya hy
Ab mujhy chand din pehly hi pata chala hy k Muhammad bin qasim jis ham hero samjhty thy asal mein hazrat imam Hussain k khandan ko wapis lejany k liye aya tha ta k unhen qatal kia ja saky its mean k Raja Dahir imam Hussain k khandan ki hifazat ker raha hoga
Agar ye bat sach hy to hmara hero to phir Raja Dahir hona chahye
Berhal ye debate honi chahye
I think he is suffering from the Stockholm Syndrome.
He is trying to make us believe that history taught in Pakistan is true. Their version of history starts from 700 AD..
@@akkihomestudio1051for power and to rule
Very informative video. As you have a good reputation and access in state running personals, I request you to take steps for the correction of atleast our historical textbooks so young generation and school going children can get the right information about history.
Thank You. 😊
Our history books taught in schools clearly say that many Muslim Arab generals tried to secure safe return of the kidnapped women and children by Raja Dahir but not successful but Muhammad bin Qasim was successful that's why he is regarded as hero
Asia. The American historian Will Durant asserted in 1935 that “the Mohammedan conquest of India is probably the bloodiest story in history,”
There are 2 graves of Ashab e Rasool RA in Mehboob Goth which is bordering village of Districts of Sukkur and Shikarpur. That means they had come here to spread Islam.
شکر ہے کسی نے تو سچ بولا
محمدم بن قاسم کا نواب اتارا
=Dear Sajid Mir=
Thanks for such an interesting and important topic.❤❤❤
Asalam alaikum sir
If Masjid of Kerala was built in 622 ad it means Islam came to India during Prophet's s.a.w era because the death (wisal mubarak) of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w was 632 and I also mentioned in my other comment that the qibla direction is towards Masjid Al Aqsa
کیا آپ نے حامد میر کی پوری ویڈیو دیکھی ہے۔۔۔؟ برائے مہربانی پوری ویڈیو دیکھیں جس میں وہ یہ بتا رھے ہیں کہ تقریباً 25 کے قریب صحابہ کرام محمد بن قاسم سے پہلے ھندوستان میں آ چُکے تھے؟؟؟؟
Some books tell that the Maharaja of Kerala saw the Miracle of the splitting moon of Holy Prophet Hazrat Muhammad (peace be upon him ) with his eyes and he asked to investigate the matter, upon revealing of Prophet Miracle he embraced Islam at that time.
this is absolutely wrong information.just simple search on google @@sfmpeer
@@sfmpeer
سبحان اللہ العظیم
جزاک اللہ خیرا شکریہ
One family lived in a house for a thousand year. Suddenly few outsiders came/attacked the house and grabbed it. The original family had to share the house with the outsiders because they were defeated. Long way down the line in time, outsiders grandsons and granddaughters started claiming the house as their own as they were born and brought up there. No one remembered how the house came to be shared by 2 distinct families. No one was outsider now as the no one had invaded the house in the first place. Original inhabitants had welcomed another family with open arms, thats how, half the family of the house remember things now. Other half's feelings are not added. Claim of attack of force is rejected by by the historians who belong to other half of the family. Fast forward now, the very house is divided in 4 parts. 3 parts of the house are inhabited by members who are not the aboriginals. The only remaining part has members who dream of their house which was complete once. There are enlighted members of other family who term them as bigot, racist, blind, ignorant , BJP and RSS members.
your analysis exactly fit on Rajputs of hindus. because these aryan white skin nomadic tribe came from europe through iran invaded you and given you a name Hindu which means black...they burnt your cities (their Reminiscences and the ruins are still in pakistan)... when it is felt by your ancesters that they are really Hindu so that they decided to imerge Aryans into subcontinent by "parishification"... so a party were arranged and relationship made by giving them daughters of native Brahmens and named them as rajputs... it is a fact everyone know that....
the concept of Islam is totally different.... because excluding a few (may be some thousand or less then 5 lak currently), most of them contains of native indians and they changed their religion. However the people who are still following their old religion impudently claiming that due to the change of religion you are no longer native (it does'nt metter that maybe so called native hindu's forefathers came in subcontinent after the converted muslim, sikh or chrisitian's forefather) so you have to change your faith and religion by force or i would banish you out of the subcontinent....
یہ اکھنڈ بھارت انشاءاللہ مسلمانوں کی حکومت بنائے گی ہر طرف اسلام ہوگا انشاءاللہ ❤
Exactly
First joint afganistan and Pakistan
MashaAllah o Akbar.....Love ISlam.....❤❤❤
Nahi asi karna nahi hai ham sab ek Hain matlab yah hai❤
Hindus are named by Arabs who used to mispronounce "Sindh" (the Aryan river) as "Hind". According to Hindus, Hinduism is the World's oldest religion as there is no historical proof of its establishment. Due to this reason, many Hindu scholars consider them as the followers of ''Sanatan Dharma'' instead of "Hinduism".
Since no concept of religion then hence no names.
Exactly
@@AbThinker You are wrong, the word Brahman means followers of lord Brahma, who is Lord Brahma? he is Hazrat Ibrahim A.S. The last Ayah of Surah Al A'lA, mentions "Suhufi Ibrahima wa Musa" translates the verse as "The Books of Abraham and Moses". The Scriptures of Ibrahim and Musa. We know the Script of Musa but where is the script of Abraham, most scholars believe it is contained in Hindu books but they concealed it. Why are they concealing it? I know the reason if you ask me then I tell you.
@@healer1000040 but Brahman is not a religion. Religion is an English language word and founded significance after English language was introduced before that people just used to practice different way of life without giving it a name.
@@AbThinker Religions originate from prophets.
Jats were the earliest people in the Indian subcontinent to have interacted with the Muslims. The multiple trading communities of Jats already existed in pre-Islamic Arabia. Jats were referred to as Zatts (Arabic: الزُّطِّ, romanized: Az-Zutt) in early Arab writings and Jat-an in Persian. They and the Buddhas were prosecuted by Rajputs therefore they fought alongside Muslims against Raja Dahir.
Just like Islam
Murtads are persecuted first.
Each nation hates its traitors.
It is but natural.
@PavitShokeen Then why did force convert revert back during RAj.
Because our ancestors gave jaziya or ready to give their heads but will never surrender our religion to invaders and you are one of the by product of tha Islamic Invasion@@healer1000040
@PavitShokeenIf muslims forcefully converted hindus to Iskam so why in 1941 census hindus were 30% in Sindh...how 30% hindus after 1400 years of muslim rules ...How Delhi sultanate, Mughal capital Delhi, Agra is still 80% hindu majority
@@eden55272we Hindus and our ancestors have fought hard to save our pride , our Dharma, our culture inspite foreign Islamic invaders demolished our temples, universities. Ram janmabhoomi temple was demolished by Babur, but Hindus got temple back after 500 yrs.
Aslkum sir for your kind information Islam arrived in India when Muhammad peace be upon him split the MOON in two parts one Indian Raja was watching live because he was walking on his palace rooftop next day he called his darbar jjutish and he explained about Arab prophet Muhammad peace be upon him he send his son with companions to Makkah and Harat Ali host them and converted them Muslim he was Rajput Chouhan clan’s his mizar in India you can find evidence or reference in Takbeer resala in jamat e islami and lot of historical references
Good information
One thing which I didnt get from you is how that hindu raja knew about the cause of moonsplitting and next day he talked with his jotish about Muhammad PBUH that he ia responsible for this incidenence.
@@tehseenanjumkhan8650 first he called jjuitish then jjuitish told him about prophet peace be upon him read again carefully please
This is supposed to be correct
Please read again "one Indian Raja was watching live because he was walking on his palace rooftop "
انہیں جانا انہیں مانا ❤️💯🙌#TLP_#Sad_hussain_rizvi#Khadim_hussain_rizvi#Vote4Crane
Asslamualaikum ❤
حامد میر صاحب سلامت رھیں آباد رھیں
میں نے ڈاکٹر عبدالقدیر خان صاحب کا کالم پڑھا تھا جس میں انہوں نے بھوپال کی ایک مسجد کا ذکر کیا تھا
جو دور نبوت میں بنی تھی اور سب سے پرانی ھے
واقعہ مجھے یاد ھے نام بھول گیا مہاراجہ کا جس نے بنوائی تھی
Sir thank you for your personal explanation, I don't agree with Akhand Bharat we have seen enough bloodshed of innocent people but there is a mention of Hindu kings of Qandar in Mahabharat, as much as I would like to agree with you that Islam did not spread in India with sword, the fact is in today's Pakistan population of non Muslims has declined to non existence in most parts of the country except Sindh, and the education policy of Pakistan today doesn't educate about Sikhs and Hindus they only teach hate, hope you will make another episode to explain this so we can move forward in peace, many thanks ji,
You are right 😢 brother . To be brief there are extremists on both sides. They want to gain cheap popularity. Actually there is mostly politics behind it.
Are juth ki bi had Hoti he Islam ke age Tumne talwar ke dar se salwar paheni he varna 1 achhai dikha de only one jiski wajah se koi khooshi khooshi ye arbi ghu khate only one wajah kishi ko Pagal kutte ne kata he Jo esa third class religion follow karega
Islam is spread by many ways ....by Kings ,By invaders ...sword .....and Dalits acceptance of Islam bcoz Hindus don't give access to temples....so we are brothers......this is a reality....and Akhand Bharat is the reality...... u accept it or don't it doesntbmatter❤❤❤ everyone
If muslims forcefully converted hindus to Iskam so why in 1941 census hindus were 30% in Sindh...how 30% hindus after 1400 years of muslim rules ...How Delhi sultanate, Mughal capital Delhi, Agra is still 80% hindu majority
Asia. The American historian Will Durant asserted in 1935 that “the Mohammedan conquest of India is probably the bloodiest story in history,”
Why are the people of Balochistan being killed in a cruel and merciless way, Mir Sahib, please make a video on this also on your personal RUclips channel. And I thank you very much for speaking up for the people of Balochistan in your show Capital Talk.
Why are people being slaughtered in kashmir and khalistan
Bhai then he has to leave Militristan 😂
Stop raising guns In front of security forces. You don't live in the 1900s it's 2023 and if you just raise a gun you might be killed or disappear .
The people who have natural resources in any form, like geography, minerals, agriculture, water, gas, and petroleum are being declared as terrorists, and it is happening all over the world, The Punjabi army doing the same thing in KPK, Sind, and Baluchistan. Indian army in Kashmir, Nagaland, and Punjab, and the USA all over the Middle East.
Why myslims being skinned alive in gujrat
I am a bit confused. Mir says that Islam didn’t spread through sword, and goes on to to give examples of three mosques spread across three states. Then he admits 25 sahaba attacked different parts of India, which is clearly what Hindus are saying - that Islam spread by the sword.
Yes, there could have been some conversion due to sufis, but it is very evident that a majority of the conversions were due to threats, coercion and incentives.
There's nothing to be confused about it as 1st Arab traders came and that's how Islam spread and after that some wars might've happened but Arab traders followed Islam entrance
@@afrazamjad1644 Entrance - yes. But Arabs were not the only traders coming to India. There were Romans, Chinese, Africans and Malay traders too. Did their religions spread as much as Islam did? No. The spread is because of the invasions, and the subsequent coercion.
@@patmclaughlin107 Even if I accept your logic for a while then it would be at par with British and how they spread Christianity. But your politics would never be at the cost of that!!
@@afrazamjad1644 No, they are not equivalent. The British were mercantilist. They wanted to build an empire that can supply them commodities, taxes and soldiers. They did not let this mission be diverted by religious conversions and temple desecration.
What benefit did Bakhtiar Khalji derive by destroying Nalanda? What was the monetary benefit in building Quwwat ul Islam mosque on top of Hindu and Jain temples? This was purely to show the dominance of Islam over the native population. Spanish and Portuguese did it, but not the British.
@@patmclaughlin107 just understand this simple concept. Islam does not allow forced conversions, but it allows muslim governments to collect jeezia tax from nonmuslims in exchange of religious and social freedom, and that tax must not be too much of a burden. but when a foreign army invaded a country in the old days, converting to their religion was the norm, the religion of the rulers was the religion of the state, in indias case, converting to islam meant no jeezia tax and favourable positions in the eyes of the rulers, and that is why they converted. forced conversions dont even make sense as governments wanted to collect those taxes. in egypt, the muslims rulers didnt allow the population to become muslims for a long time as they wanted to keep collecting the jeezia tax so why would the rulers want to convert indians?
چونکہ حجاج بن یوسف اہلبیت کے خون کا پیاسا تھا اس کے ایک واقع کو بہانا بنایا تاکہ ان سادات تک پہنچ سکے جنھیں راجہ داہر نے پناہ دی تھی۔
Sir,
Take My Salam.
I'm from Bangladesh.
It is a very valuable short summary of high light at this moment. But really it's very valuable.
I think it's necessary & highly priority to view commercial all the channels & Media. At least Turkey all the channel & Media.
Sanatan dharma is the oldest religion on earth.. Islam came just before 1400 years...
I am very proud of my ancestors that they fought, they resisted Islamic invaders like khilji, gaouri, Gajnavi etc and saved their identity, religion and culture... and we remain as proud sanatan followers and NOT forced converted zealots..😊😊😊
Kerala masjid is oldest mosque in the world. The land was offered by the king of Kochi, Arab would come to Kochi for spice trade, this masjid was constructed for Namaz. Other two mosques...there are no reference in India.
The three masjid (you referred to) basically were near the sea shore for Arabs to offer namaz. It doesn't mean that Islam got its roots in India. MOHAMMAD Bin Qasim invaded India to spread Islam with violence, latter on many other invaders came to India to demolished temples and forcefully convert Hindus to Islam.
Hamid now you are parroting establishments narrative. 😅😅
I think these mosslims were more fond of hindu girls than we brits. 😅
Nobody is interested in karela warela. It is as irrelevant to Pak as anything happened in Sri Lanka. Buzz off!!!!
WHY DID RAJA DAHIR MARRIED HIS OWN SISTER????
USKI EXPLANATION DAAY, RAM KATHA NA SUNAA!
@@BABA-ORUC1761
رام کتھا تو تم شروع کررھے ہو؟ چسکے لینے اور ٹھرک جھاڑنے کے لیے۔۔۔۔۔
جو بات تم نے کی ہے۔۔۔ کیا وہ اس وی لاگ کا موضوع ہے؟ اگر نہیں ہے تو پھر وہ اس بے تُکی ، گھٹیا بات جس کا اس موضوع سے کوئی تعلق ہی نہیں، کے بارے بات کیوں کرے؟؟؟؟
اگر تم نے یہ واقعہ پڑھنا ہے تو یحییٰ امجد کی کتاب تاریخ پاکستان کا صفحہ نمبر 29 سے 47 پڑھ لو۔۔۔۔۔۔ تم معلوم ہوجائے گا کہ اس نے شادی کیوں کی اور دُمبوں (بکروں) پہ مٹی لگا کر گھاس اُگانے کی کوشش کرکے لوگوں کو کیا پیغام دیا۔۔۔۔۔؟؟؟؟
Okayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
We all must be ideally Muslims inshaAllah.....Love you All ❤❤❤
اسلام تو اللہ کے رسول صلی ۔ کی حیات مبارکہ میں سندھ کے لوگ اسلام قبول کرنے اور حضور کی زیارت کرنے گئے تھے ۔ اور اپنا روایتی تحفہ اجرک بھی حضور کی خدمت میں حاضر کیا گیا تھا ۔ یہ سنی تاریخ ہے اپنے حساب سے بیان کرتے ہیں آپ دوسرون کی طرف مراجع بھی کیا کریں ۔
حضرت سعد بن ابی وقاص کا مقبرہ چین کے صوبہ سنکیانگ میں ہے جو اس بات کی نشانی ہے کہ چند اصحابِ رسول حضرت عمر فاروق کے دور حکومت میں برصغیر پہنچ چکے تھے بلکہ نہ صرف برصغیر وی چین تک رسائی حاصل کر چکے تھے، اور کچھ تاریخی کتب اس بات پر متفق ہیں کہ ان اصحابِ رسول کا راستہ سندھ سے پاکپتن جھنگ اور ٹیکسلا سے ہوتا ہوا سنکیانگ تک تھا، یعنی یہ جو کہا جاتا ہے کہ صوفیاء نے برصغیر میں اسلام پھیلایا بھی ٹھیک نہیں ان سے پہلے اصحابِ رسول اس خطے میں پہنچ چکے تھے
Best job,I don't know reality of Islam before you
Salaam. Very informative. Allah Kareem apko jaza e Khair day
حامد میر صاحب آپ نے بہترین انداز میں اپنا موقف پیش کیا ہے
great analysis
بہت بہت شکریہ میر صاحب ۔
حامد میر صاحب بڑے احترام کے ساتھ عرض ہے کہ
1) حضور صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم کی پیدائش کا سال 571 عیسوی ہے۔ 40 سال کی عمر میں نبوت ملی، مطلب 611 عیسوی میں۔ نبوت کے پہلے 13 سال مکہ میں گزارے، مطلب 623- 624 عیسوی تک مکہ میں رہے۔ ان تیرہ سال میں حضور نے طائف کا سفر کیا۔ اور مسلمانوں نے صرف حبشہ کی طرف 2 ہجرت کئے۔۔ مدینہ سے آیا ہوا وفد حج کے موقع پر مکہ میں ہی حضور سے ملا تھا اور پھر اگلے سال دوبارہ بھی حج کے موقع پر۔ تب تک مسلمانوں نے اپنے لئے الگ مسجد تو دور کی بات کھل کر دعوت دینے پر بھی مشکلات کا سامنا کرنا پڑتا تھا۔ مسلمانوں نے اپنے لئے پہلی مسجد ہجرت کے فوراً بعد بنائی جسکا نام مسجد قباء ہے۔
اب میرے لئے یہ سمجھنا بہت مشکل ہے کہ حضور نے خود اپنے لئے مسجد 624 عیسوی میں بنائی اور برصغیر میں 623 عیسوی میں بن گئی جبکہ ابھی اسلام کی دعوت و تبلیغ صرف حجاز میں ہی تھی۔۔۔ عجم تو بہت دور کی بات ہے۔۔۔۔
2) دوسری بات یہ کہ برصغیر میں اسلام حضرت عمر رضہ کے زمانے میں آیا تھا وہ بھی بلوچستان کے علاقے تک۔۔۔
برائے مہربانی تصحیح کرکے جواب دیجیئے گا ۔۔۔ شکریہ
حوالہ جات
1) الرحیق المختوم ۔۔ صفی الرحمٰن مبارک پوری
2) سیرت النبی ۔ ۔ سید شبلی نعمانی
3) الفاروق ۔۔ سید شبلی نعمانی
4) nabataea.net/explore/cities_and_sites/barwada-mosque/
آپ کی معلومات بہت حد تک صحیح ہیں. 630.31 عیسوی میں رسول اکرم کی وفات ہوئی. 660 میں حضرت علی علیہ السلام کو شہید کر دیا گیا. 670 عیسوی میں نواسہ رسول حضرت امام حسن کو شہید کر دیا گیا 680 عیسوی میں حضرت امام حسین علیہ السلام کو کربلا میں شہید کیا گیا. بہت سے مسلمان خاص طور پر محبانِ اہل بیت امویوں کے ظلم سے تنگ آکر مکران اور سندھ کی طرف ہجرت کرنے لگے. حجاج بن یوسف جسے بنو ثقیف کا قصاب کہا جاتا ہے اور جس نے ہزاروں بیگناہ مسلمانوں کا قتل کیا ہے عراق کا گورنر تھا اس نے اپنے بھتیجے یا بھانجے کو ہجرت کرنے والے مسلمانوں کو قتل کرنے کے لئے آیا جنہیں راجہ داہر نے پناہ دے رکھی تھی...سرکاری اور درباری تاریخ میں بنی امیہ کے حکمرانوں کو ہیرو بنا کے پیش کیا ہے. جبکہ اصل میں بنی امیہ کے حکمران بادشاہ تھے جنہوں نے حصولِ اقتدار کے لئے نواسہ رسول کو خاندان سمیت تہہ تیغ کر دیا..
Excellent ❤
Imagine that Muhammad saw died in June 632 AD which means that these early mosques were made in india during his life time.
Mir Sahib ap ne bihtreen andaz men Islam ki India men ane ki history batai.
MashaALLAH
Mujahid Khan Daha from Punjab Pakistan Hamid sb you are great
اللہ آپ کو سلامت رکہے
Hamid bhai i am a history student and jat boy ,haryana india.hindustan me islam arab businessman,s ke thru laya gya lekin uska asar jyada nahi tha,712 me mohmmad bin qasim ne sindh raja dahir pr hmla kr katlo garat kiya lekin uska asar bhi sindh k kuchh ilaqe pr raha bad me Mahmud gaznavi 1001 or uske bad 1198 or 1199 me mohmmad gori k bad delhi k sultan 1526 k bad mughlo k bad jyada conversion hua jo talwar kdam pr hua,
بہت عمدہ ماشاء اللہ حافظ اللہ
Bismillah Ma’Shaa’Allah!
اولیاءاللہ نے اسلام برصغیرمیں پھیلایا حضرت علی ہجویری رح بری شاہ لطیف قادری حضرت محمدحیات قادری پیرمہرعلی شاہ رح حضرت معین الدین چشتی رح جیسے دیگر بزرگوں نے انہوں نے محبت اور امن سے اسلام پھیلایا
زبردست جناب حامد میر صاحب !❤❤❤
میرصاحب جزاک اللہ خیرا احسن الجزاء فی الدنیا والآخرۃ ۔کچھ چیزیں آج آپ نالج سے علم میں آئیں ۔
Im from from south indian state Karnataka , Kerala is our neighbouring state.
JazakAllah ❤
زبردست جناب
بہترین
حامد میر سلامت رھیں آباد رھیں
میں نے ڈاکٹر عبدالقدیر خان صاحب کا کالم پڑھا تھا جس میں انہوں نے بھوپال کی ایک مسجد اور مہاراجہ کا ذکر کیا تھا
جور دور نبوت میں بنی تھی اور سب سے پرانی ھے
واقعہ مجھے یا ھے نام بھول گیا مہاراجہ کا
Very Intellectual Talks Hamid Sahab - You have raised a very Important Subject & I must say you are now become a Historian as well and this is good for any Journalist like you. Off course there are too many Fiction Stories circulates around us which needs to be revisit.
Jazaak Allah kullo Khair
Male sahaba singular= عنه anho
Male sahaba plural=عنهم anhum
Female sahabiyaat singular=عنها anha
Female sahabiyaat plural=عنهن anhunna
Both for dual=anhuma عنهما
حامد بھائی آپ کا دعوی محل نظر ہے کہ پہلی مسجد 623 عیسوی میں قائم ہوئی ،کیونکہ 622 عیسوی میں تو مسجد نبوی تعمیر کی گئ ہے،کیونکہ 632 عیسوی رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کی تاریخ وفات ہے
Great......❤❤❤❤❤.....
تاریخ دان + صحافی + عالم صاحب حضرت عثمان رضی اللہ عنہہ کے زمانے میں 656 ہجری کہاں سے آگیا؟
بہت اعلیٰ
Highly knowledged, i am glad tha Pakistan has that much talent and a person with that skills and knowledge
MashAllah such kaha ap ne meer sb
Good job sir 😊
Love from India🇮🇳 🙏
Jazakallah🤲 sir❤
Hamid sb waallah u r doing great service for generations
Thank you for touching the topic. During the last days of Caliph Omar, after conquering Iran, he sent an army to Sind. This army didnot reach Sind (I am not going into details) but it did conquer parts of Makran which are under Pakistan now. When the Caliph recalled the army, a part of it was left behind to continue to control the area.
پیارے نبی کی پیدائش اپنے والد کی وفات کے 4 سال بعد ہوئی۔
اس کو ممکن بنانے کے لیے پورے محلے نے امینہ کے ساتھ بہت محنت کی۔
30 باپوں کی وجہ سے رسول اللہ ﷺ کو 30 آدمیوں کی طاقت تھی۔
Very good report.