what if...

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 дек 2024

Комментарии • 91

  • @pyrofrog368
    @pyrofrog368 6 дней назад +327

    World eater:...
    Guilliman:...
    World eater: so he-
    Guilliman: yep
    World eater: to the legions-
    Guilliman: yep
    Deathguard: ...and the emper-
    Guilliman: yep...
    Thousand son: ...so my brothers really-
    Guilliman: yeah...
    All of them: ...
    Guilliman: ...say you ever heard of the rubricon?

    • @zacaritest
      @zacaritest 4 дня назад +24

      _The Word Eater seriously considers putting the same garbage his brothers put on their heads for no apparent reason._

    • @cherryrook8684
      @cherryrook8684 3 дня назад +26

      @@zacaritest This makes me remember the last stand of the loyalist marines against their traitor legion. Sons of Horus, Emperors Children and even a few lost looking World Eaters.. 🥲

    • @MrRay568
      @MrRay568 5 часов назад

      I think it'll be more funny if the World Eater was referred to as a War Hound (AKA Pre-Angron)

  • @gamechanger8908
    @gamechanger8908 6 дней назад +245

    *Guilliman voxes Cawl*
    Guilliman: hey Cawl. Can we talk about those Traitor Geneseeds you had in store.

    • @lalthamuon6720
      @lalthamuon6720 5 дней назад +27

      Cawl : well well well, look you decided to show up

    • @leonardorodrigues827
      @leonardorodrigues827 5 дней назад +19

      Now the Children of the Phoenix and the Silver Skulls are no longer alone, it would be nice to see that and I think the first thing they would do is take the butcher's needles from the World Eaters as they are not the same as Angron's it should be possible to take them out and the Thousand Sons would be equivalent to the Grey Knights the difference is that they would not kill if you knew they existed and would make peace with the wolves.

    • @LamiaLover
      @LamiaLover 3 дня назад +3

      ​​@@leonardorodrigues827well they could use some traitor genestock since their Primarchs are dead or have no aura. World Eaters are a safe bet but I'd think they'd have extreme trauma and more violent tendencies due to how vicious Angron was.
      Now you got me wanting to finish my loyalist WE successor chapter.

    • @alquimistafriki
      @alquimistafriki 2 дня назад +3

      ​@@lalthamuon6720 also Cawll: btw I'm already a head
      Gorillaman: OK... Wait what

  • @TORBIN0
    @TORBIN0 5 дней назад +189

    There is a story of a Luna Wolf coming out of suspended animation. When they explained the situation to him, he took a ship into the Eye of Terror cursing Horus and Abadon.

    • @gasmonkey1000
      @gasmonkey1000 3 дня назад +6

      Damn what was it called?

    • @TORBIN0
      @TORBIN0 3 дня назад +12

      @gasmonkey1000 Soul of Damnation. It's not an actual full story.

    • @gasmonkey1000
      @gasmonkey1000 3 дня назад +5

      @TORBIN0 Awww come on Black Library! That could have been a hell of a trip for a novel!

    • @ondururagittandeska2004
      @ondururagittandeska2004 2 дня назад +8

      Comic idea. Him, Corax and Russ slaying Demons together

    • @gasmonkey1000
      @gasmonkey1000 2 дня назад +2

      @@ondururagittandeska2004 I thought it'd been funnier if he stuck with the Flesh Tearers, kinda like how the Salamanders adopted a Black Dragon

  • @terryliliana
    @terryliliana 4 дня назад +53

    The deathwatch suddenly getting 3 new members who are a little too pissed off.

    • @Dozarman
      @Dozarman День назад +4

      Deathwatch deals with Xenos, not Chaos. I'd say they'll be part of Black Templars, though Thousand Son will have to hide the fact he's a Psyker.

  • @samsarex4318
    @samsarex4318 5 дней назад +171

    "Um alright then"
    *17 hours later*
    HE DID WHAT!!

    • @kresovk5
      @kresovk5 4 дня назад +16

      ...WITH A WHAT?!

    • @cumlord._.
      @cumlord._. 3 дня назад

      ​@@kresovk5 "GUILLIMAA- i mean... HORUUUUUUS"

    • @dragodx8238
      @dragodx8238 18 часов назад

      FATHER!!!

  • @synergy8879
    @synergy8879 5 дней назад +104

    “we were told to report to istvaan 3 for the initial assault under the orders of warmaster horus. do you know where he is?”
    “oh boy…..”
    “and i was ordered to return to prospero, but I cant find an imperial vessel willing to take me, what happened?”
    “about that….”

  • @user-ro2sg6jb6u
    @user-ro2sg6jb6u 3 дня назад +30

    And after that few new chapters were founded claiming to be Ultramarine stock. War hounds, Dusk raiders and Hundred Sons

  • @TruculentSheep
    @TruculentSheep 6 дней назад +100

    "My Lord, why did you just take out a breeze block-sized slab of Moroccan?"

  • @RobbyVogel
    @RobbyVogel 6 дней назад +224

    He did whaaat!!!! No! He couldn't betray grandfather he couldn't!

    • @Gekkko
      @Gekkko 4 дня назад +4

      Exactly

    • @hexfart4562
      @hexfart4562 День назад +3

      Grandfather sounds like some nurgel grox to me heresy

  • @Uberkatze-
    @Uberkatze- 4 дня назад +22

    tzeentch decided to do a prank and kept them in the warp for 10 thousand years for shits and giggles

  • @EatRick
    @EatRick 5 дней назад +42

    "If only you knew just how bad everything really is." -Robot Guiltyman

    • @UtubeH8tr
      @UtubeH8tr 4 дня назад +1

      That 4chan spook post was unreal.
      In real time.

  • @MRVN-
    @MRVN- 5 дней назад +30

    Corvus actually had that talk during the heresy

  • @JackoHak
    @JackoHak 6 дней назад +171

    And thus, the thousand son became the first blood raven

    • @gamechanger8908
      @gamechanger8908 6 дней назад +19

      Or formed a Chapter of his own that claims to be of Blood Ravens Descent.

    • @GloomyMime
      @GloomyMime 5 дней назад

      Blood Ravens are Word Bearers successors.

    • @erwinsetyo1061
      @erwinsetyo1061 5 дней назад +9

      ​@@GloomyMime then Blood Ravens should've plenty of Chaplains, not plenty of Psykers

    • @GloomyMime
      @GloomyMime 5 дней назад +3

      @erwinsetyo1061 Word Bearers had a good number of psykers too and love knowledge.
      Also, Blood Ravens colours are very similar to the colours of the WB and one of the planets they recruited was called Aurelia.
      And the Ravens don't suffer from the Thousand Sons' flesh change.

    • @JackoHak
      @JackoHak 5 дней назад

      @@GloomyMime officially its unknown who the Blood Ravens primarch is, but all their psykers and interest in knowledge suggest that they're TS descendants.
      The covenant of fire who are officially presented as a Salamanders successor are the ones who are most likely of Word Bearer gene-seed

  • @سیدامیرسجادحسینی-ف4و
    @سیدامیرسجادحسینی-ف4و 8 дней назад +103

    New chapters on the way.

  • @henrywhitmore8344
    @henrywhitmore8344 4 дня назад +12

    In SM2 I painted my vanguard to be a pre-heresy world eater and my canon is that his battle cruiser got lost in the warp before the legion was forced to implant the butchers nails

  • @jojogold8294
    @jojogold8294 6 дней назад +70

    I thought of this idea for the Rouge trader game (you find a space wolf being kept prisoner as a gladiator in commorragh) and thought instead of a space wolf it could be a lunar wolf that got stuck in a warp storm and you discovered he ship in real space being attacked by demons. Then after you save him you’d get 2-3 options, telling him the truth of the Horus heresy, lie and say we’re still in 30k, or tell him a half truth half lie (that some time has passed and his primarch is dead but don’t tell him what he did or that the emperor is a zombie)

    • @randomdude8202
      @randomdude8202 4 дня назад

      Nah, it wouldn't work. He would want to parade is legion colors in 2 of those, and that would rise suspicion quick.

    • @jojogold8294
      @jojogold8294 4 дня назад +3

      @@randomdude8202 ah, but that would bring tension to the story, since it’s been 10 thousand years since anyone has even heard of the word “lunar wolves” or seen what they look like.
      So if you picked the option where you lie, he finds the out the truth at the end of the game and turns to chaos (bad ending). If you speak the truth he’ll go on to verify/try to deny and find out entire truth (since he wouldn’t believe you) (good ending since he would see his primarch in a more evil light). And the third option would have a mix of both where he stays with you since you didn’t outright lie to him (heretic/loyalist path)

    • @randomdude8202
      @randomdude8202 3 дня назад +1

      @@jojogold8294 maybe

    • @GarkKahn
      @GarkKahn 2 дня назад +2

      ​@@randomdude8202 not really, depending on what his legion is
      One thing would be "sons of horus" and luna wolves may pass as just some son of leman russ in one of the trillion successor chapters

    • @randomdude8202
      @randomdude8202 2 дня назад

      @@GarkKahn never underestimate inquisition and ecclesiarchy

  • @Samcoop-t8p
    @Samcoop-t8p 7 дней назад +69

    This needs to happen

    • @Maxsmack
      @Maxsmack 6 дней назад +16

      It already has, just subtly.
      This is where successor and second founding chapters with mixed or traitor gene seed come from.

    • @Samcoop-t8p
      @Samcoop-t8p 6 дней назад +9

      That makes me a happy camper

    • @GarkKahn
      @GarkKahn 2 дня назад +2

      Robot gorillaman and rogal dorn already have a few LOTS of these guys

  • @xm214-aminigun9
    @xm214-aminigun9 4 дня назад +5

    There are like 100 soldiers in a drill machine in deep sleep waiting to one day be freed.

  • @issacfreeman74
    @issacfreeman74 5 дней назад +13

    Plot twist: They’re all alpha legion.

  • @silverhand9965
    @silverhand9965 4 дня назад +20

    "Yeah you probably should have stayed lost in the warp ngl"

  • @thecommentguy9380
    @thecommentguy9380 5 дней назад +18

    Lord Guiliman, why isn't Prospero on the map anymore?

  • @vergiltheartofpower6616
    @vergiltheartofpower6616 6 дней назад +18

    Man, they've been stuck for 10000 years in the warp

    • @michasalamon8315
      @michasalamon8315 День назад

      Happens More often Than you Think. Zso Sahaal, terran born captain of the Night Lord’s first Company after Sevatar’s death, the Fallen, alpha legion, a handful of luna wolves, they all woke up or came out of the warp only to find out how bad things are.and pretty much go dark

  • @leonardorodrigues827
    @leonardorodrigues827 5 дней назад +10

    Well at least now the Sons of the Phoenix and the Silver Skulls are not alone and I think the first thing they will do is take the butcher's needles from the World Eaters, as they are not the same as Angron's it should be possible to take them out, the Thousand Sons would know that Leman Russ was tricked by Horus and would forgive the Wolves and the Death Guard would swear revenge on Nurgle and everyone his followers for what he did to his brothers. Guilliman will be a great father, he already is with the Silver Skulls.

  • @tyrothethird3081
    @tyrothethird3081 2 дня назад +2

    There’s actually a fan made chapter called the Knights Penitent who are pre-Heresy Word Bearers who got lost in the Warp and got sent on a Crusade by the Inquisition to redeem themselves

  • @zacker1590
    @zacker1590 4 дня назад +5

    Well hot dam, we need someone making a fanfic out of this!

  • @linhle8294
    @linhle8294 4 дня назад +4

    Oh i need a sequel to this goldmine of idea

  • @aditghifari5039
    @aditghifari5039 6 дней назад +20

    The trio of lost

  • @aldrixlevy228
    @aldrixlevy228 5 дней назад +7

    No fucking way Billy Herrington as robutt gilliman.

  • @dreadizek1386
    @dreadizek1386 2 дня назад +1

    I honestly would love to see a fanfic based on this.

  • @hexfart4562
    @hexfart4562 3 дня назад +4

    Continue this story of the three lost to the warp plz i need more

  • @kenan4370
    @kenan4370 4 дня назад +5

    Nice try, Alpharius

  • @samuelrodriguez9801
    @samuelrodriguez9801 3 дня назад +1

    I've thought of a similar premise before.

  • @arklaw8306
    @arklaw8306 6 дней назад +48

    If Horus is Warmaster shouldn't the World Eater already have nails imbedded? He sounds alright.

    • @jordanwebster4170
      @jordanwebster4170 6 дней назад +40

      Not all had the nails at first it was a build up over time, they could be from early in his career as warmaster

    • @johnnycracker640
      @johnnycracker640 6 дней назад +14

      Or maybe he’s just a really chill dude

    • @redeye4516
      @redeye4516 6 дней назад +13

      @jordanwebster4170
      IIRC, World Eaters Librarians actually couldn't get the Nails implanted either since it would mess with their abilities.

    • @jordanwebster4170
      @jordanwebster4170 6 дней назад +9

      @@redeye4516 more like the nails just hated psychers

    • @redeye4516
      @redeye4516 6 дней назад

      @jordanwebster4170
      I don't actually recall why they couldn't get them. May have been that because the Nails require removal of parts of the brain, or maybe their effects of constantly causing pain unless you kill something would mess with their ability to concentrate. Whatever the case may be, I shudder to think of how they learned that they couldn't implant Librarians with the Butchers Nails, or what may have happened to those psykers.
      These also could have been intentional and steered that way by Khorne, because we know how he feels about psykers. Except for Azariah Kyras, he gets a pass because Khorne likes him.

  • @MGBandit75
    @MGBandit75 6 дней назад +14

    That Alpha legionnaires’ World Eater impression is terrible.

  • @dororo101
    @dororo101 2 дня назад

    I love this idea

  • @TuShan18
    @TuShan18 5 часов назад

    A calm world eater actually makes me sad. They were better than this.

  • @zenknight4839
    @zenknight4839 7 дней назад +11

    Wait, what happened when they met horus first ?

    • @Joseph-mw2rl
      @Joseph-mw2rl 6 дней назад +15

      I'm sure they wouldn't be meeting horus lmao

    • @y.b4251
      @y.b4251 6 дней назад +3

      If they insist on seeing Horus after the explanation, without murderous intentions, lord g might as well send them straight to Horus.

    • @zenknight4839
      @zenknight4839 6 дней назад +1

      ​@@y.b4251 OH I get it now, this is the horus heresy, I thought it's before it during some obscure events

    • @Kaiser1782
      @Kaiser1782 6 дней назад +3

      ​@@zenknight4839This is pre-Horus Heresy era Space Marines stuck in the warp for 10 thousand years then coming out to meet Guilliman, unknowing anything that happened ever since.