The Most Blatantly Fake Trombone Playing...EVER
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- Anna Kendrick has some explaining to do... Hilton Hotel too. This kind of Trom-foolery will not be tolerated!!!
Double tongueing, triple tonguing, trombone trilling, tuba, euphonium, trumpet players unite. We gotta look out for each other as there are fakers EVERYWHERE! Nyan Cat + Harp coming soon?
Wow. This "instruments never being animated accurately" format has already expanded outside of animation.
TwoSet Violin does this with a lot of live action fake violin playing if you're interested
@@ieattoomanyclementines2372 DADDY WHY SYOU SAD????
@@ieattoomanyclementines2372lol they are legit awesome violin players! One of them is even perfect pitch.
I found footage of an actress in my country half-faking drums at her concert. I couldn't comment on the video because her fans are very loyal, to say the least.
Bro in Peacemaker there's a whole scene of a depressed John Cena blatantly faking playing the piano. It was a good scene if you could ignore the fake aspect to it all, and the show is still incredible.
Moves slider: Trombonists call fake
Doesn't move slider: Everyone else calls fake
Tough call.
agreed! tbh, she caught me there, as a non-trombonist, i had no idea :,D. you gotta get the details just right, or the musicians are gna come and get you
ps didn't expect to see you here. love your compositions!
Most telling, even for a non musician, is that anyone can tell the first note and last note are the same, but she plays them in different positions
*if they’re paying attention
@@tristanhahn4902 there are plenty of alternate positions for notes on the trombone though
Facts lmao
The bad news is if she actually played it right you know there would be people saying "Oh look, she's not playing the trombone! She isn't moving the slide!"
Edit: oh my god where did all these likes come from?
Realism vs. verisimilitude.
How much you wanna bet that her slide came off at least once during filming?
@@tiyenin I'd bet a $1000 for that. Fist that happened to me playing the instrument
@@nucleargandhi2709 verisimilitude whats that
this is why we need to #spreadtromboneawareness
All she had to do was pick it up & not move slide positions, & she sill messed it up
still* lol
But... But... If you aren't sliding, how are you playing the trombone? /s
@@ard45387 it’s the same note so moving it is unessesary
@@el_priet0kun373 woooosh
@@ard45387 the note are in the same position so you don’t need to move the slide
(I play trombone so I know)
Note: I’m not professional and not the best but I know the basics like the slide,how to blow and other
As someone who plays the trombone this hurts me mentally
I remember playing the trombone during school and this got me to cringe.
Same bruhh,
As a non trombone playing musician this hurt me mentally
same 😭
lmao yes
Oh, but if she didn't moved it would appear to be fake!
(I play the saxophone, and there's a little key on the back of the instrument that changes the octave, and back in highschool, two different times someone said I wasn't really playing, because the sound changed too much without I move my fingers)
Fun add on, you don't actually need to use the octave key, and with overtones, you can actually play several notes with just one fingering
True. To non-musicians, that is (or, I guess, non-trombonists).
I play the trumpet. And it has happened that people couldn't fathom how I could change note without using the valves. Everytime it has happened I was playing Taps or some other signalhorn piece
@@FishingForLife28 I guess a bugle would blow their minds.
Bro I play flute, and having an octave key sounds nice, instead people never believe how I make the note go an octave higher with my face
Something I also notice was the fact it's 3 notes but she goes to 4 slide positions (1st then 2nd then 3rd lastly 4th)
Bring me the mklk
Dude what if she played the sad trombone...
@@okjohn314 then she played it at the wrong tempo xD
Almost everything from Hollyweird and marketers is fake. No one believes the real stuff. Also her "tone" is too good. Most people who just pick up a trombone sound like a 400 lb man just farted into a microphone.
To be fair, she's a vocalist not a trombonist... Not sure why they gave her a trombone when she could've sung but whatever
She's a computer generated vocalist lol. Her real singing is actually not good.
To be fair, it would have looked wrong to a layperson if she didn't move the slide. Should have just given her a bugle
Right. And they could have hammed it up with vikings or some shit.
It was probably made to give the impression that she was playing it, since most people (including me) don’t know how a trombone works.
If she played it correctly it wouldn’t have the impact the marketing team was looking for, since, like you said, sliding the trombone isn’t necessary to play those notes.
A trombone has 7 slide positions (including 7 trigger positions) the notes shes playing are b flat to a higher b flat. This doesn't require positions to move. It's just an octave jump in the harmonic series. The only reason that she moved the slide is because normies don't understand that we can play more than one note per position. If I actually moved the slide I would play a completely different note.
@@Trainlover-pk9hn Well, yeah! That’s what I said.
It's good enough to be instantly recognisable that the character is playing trombone. If a person sits in front of a piano and presses some keys with fingers, it will look like they plays piano. If you hold a flute similar to how a flutist holds flute, even to the wrong side, it's still good enough depending on how accurate it should look.
I completely agree, like slamming on piano keys in a commercial even though it’s a soft melody, just to give the bold impression that hey, this person is playing it
@@Trainlover-pk9hn there were zero B-flats played in her clip’s audio
Wow. Never caught that. As a fellow trombone player it looked a littler weird but never thought how wrong she was.
So you're ripping her for already having mastered alternate positions? You're just envious
0:23
“Infinitely less kosher..”
Imma use that phrase daily from now on
The ending got me 😂
But seriously, people need to start playing these right.
Sincerely,
-A tenor trombonist
The trombone is also backwards - she's holding the slide with her left hand 😂
Not to defend her atrocious form in the video, but... she is left-handed
@@joshmiller3055 it's the same for everyone. You won't see someone play the french horn backwards just because they're left-handed
@@okjohn314 nah not necessarily
I mean, even left-handed pianos exist, somehow
It would make sensr if left-handed trombones existed too then
@@doctorsir4976 they don't since you can simply assemble it the wrong way, but a big majority of left-handed trombonists still play the regular way
@@okjohn314 oh thanks, i didnt know that
Love the tone on the full arpeggio set. It sounded good throughout the horn's range.
She did the ultimate flex with those alternate positions 😂
Not sure why this is even worth making a video for. She obviously doesn’t know how to play, anyone with a brain would also know she can’t play.
If she didn’t move the slide, it would be more unbelievable to the majority of the people who don’t play trombone.
I’ve played trumpet for 20 over years in bands and wind orchestra and I don’t even feel a need to nitpick on such stuff.
This is just like a bunch of like minded people gathering together to laugh about a subject that they only know of but the majority of the people around them don’t care about.
Mano, foi só um vídeo de curiosidade. Ele até desmentiu algo que a maioria das pessoas acreditam, justamente para não ter que fazer errado para convencê-las.
The lazyness have take me, so I will not translate in english.
I wonder why they went with a tuning in the slide horn for this
I play French horn and I know this. SMH 😩
But if you don't move the trombone around how are people supposed to know it's being played?
Well, any awake and cognizant director I can think of would have her move the slide to indicate she is playing. As opposed to "ok Anna, in reality this bit can be played in first position on the harmonic series, so don't move the slide at all, ok? No action. Folks will KNOW!". Not much of a mystery.
The worst is Cliff Huxtables dad on the Cosby Show.
ruclips.net/video/kevX7EoniA4/видео.html
Also the instrument has been assembled wrong
I feel like they would ask her to do the movement even if she knew how to play the trombone correctly. Kinda like how bald eagles are given hawk calls in movies (real bald eagles sound like seagulls)
As a tenor trombonist, yep.
I cant believe how many people even take this seriously 😂
after you fight your way through the rest of the trombone players, you have to face this guy
you know Ive watched a bunch of these "the trombone is never animated correctly" videos lately and I have a lot more respect for trombone players now. haha :)
Never shame an Anna Kendrick, even if she holds it wrong.
Interesting! Very obvious aswell
Suddenly want to play trombone lol
I played the trombone like her before.
Not in the sense of messing it up, but in the sense of holding it wrong. I still played fine.
I'm used to people just butchering how you actually play a trombone. But this is one of the worst examples ever.
Is the bell even on the correct side of her body? Did they reverse the shot, or have her hold it incorrectly so as not to block her face?
100% had her hold it incorrectly to not block her face; the whole point of having a celebrity rather than a trombonist is so that people can recognise them.
I'm just used to people butchering playing any instrument in general. They just gotta look like they're playing it.
Day 131 of commenting
Madlad 👏
The way she holds the trombone makes me want to file a restraining order against her on behalf of all musical instruments.
huh. well it's called marketing, acting and pretending. so i don't see what the big deal is? And why is this whyte boi saluting? that's basically stolen valor.
I never knew you can change the notes with out moving anything.lol..i have absolutely zero knowledge about the trombone.
The more of these I watch, the more of an idea I have: if I ever animate an instrument, I'll look up a crash course on that instrument so that I at least know the correct fingering and can (hopefully) not upset the players of that instrument.
You'll have a fun time when you realise most instruments have several diffrerent fingerings they can use for each note, and they are sometimes used for different purposes. For example if a woodwind player is doing a scale run very quickly, they may choose easier fingerings with worse intonation for some of the notes depending on the scale.
I think it's almost worse that her grip is mirrored. Who holds the trombone over their right shoulder?
I guess they did it because people that don't now how the trombone works would think it is fake when it's not beeing slid around
I felt physical pain on her part
He showed you don't normally move the slide but he also showed you can get the sound by moving the slide. If you are in a band or orchestra you want to minimize movement, but if you are alone on a balcony and you want to be dramatic, you move the slide. different methods for different effects.
god i’ve seen these types of posts for drums but i love that there’s one for trombones!! i feel like it’s the worst instrument to fake play bc it looks so horrendous it’s so distracting
Where's the COUNTERWEIGHT????
I mean shes an actor. Actors are just there to make money and leave, and they dont need to be that smart to do it.
Kids out droppin facts! His game with the ladies must be lit!
She was probably just told to look like she's playing the trombone. The sound was added in later and she doesn't even know what it's going to sound like.
I only played trombone for a couple months(for jazz) but this hurts my soul as a brass player
She's got that 6th grader grip too lmao look at the start
Imagine being worse than a middle school trombone player 💀💀💀💀💀
Wow
Man trombone players have it infinitely harder than guitar players
You've clearly never seen Wycliffe Gordan improvise... tsk tsk tsk
When you salute you put your middle finger to the end of your eyebrow.
Literally nobody cares
Issa fuckin commercial
In my head played the opening to another episode of itwpi( if they were plugged in)
at least she played a fast version of the intro of scheharizade(?)
0:36 XD
to be fair, even if she held it correctly, and used the correct position, we all should know it was fake just by the fact that someone like her who definitely is not a trombone player would have nailed that with good intonation.
Do Lanky Kong in DK64
If yall non-musicians are confused how he's making a different sound without moving his slide well. Its called "Embouchure"
Nerd alert.
I love people who bust on movies for totally messing up the instrument parts xD
Plot twist: She played it perfectly, but she just ACTED like she was terrible.
Does that make any sense whatsoever? Only if you don't use your brain.
remember lads, women like musicians not because of their talent or fame, but because of their fingering..... or toung-ing... and rythm
It's a commercial starring an actress who plays fake characters for a living. Good catch Sherlock 🙄
P.s. She gives me a tromboner.
At the least she could've moved the slide to the fourth position for the D before sliding back to the first position. Solves both problems.
WOW I don't know if you people that play the trombone are being sarcastic or just snow flakes all butt hurt over someone faking just for a fricking commercial!
Wow the “insulting” comments on here of Anna are just ridiculous
It is a “advert” for heaven’s sake
Yes we know she “can’t” play the t.bone but that’s not the point it’s only a bit of fun
The least she could have done was be told how to hold it correctly. For the best fake trombone work you have to go back to The Glenn Miller Story - James Stewart's authenticity in depicting the trombone was faultless.
For me, I just move the slide to the “muscle memory spot” regardless of not moving the slide when u don’t hav to
For example I play D B D 4 4 1, not 4 4 4
To be fair it's a comedic commercial that depicts a goofball character.
I hate to be a know it all, but it is not entirely uncommon for alternative positions to be used. I have been with multiple teachers who have recommended using alternates like c in 6th as opposed to trigger 1st extended. For me, that was on Fancy Free by Clay Smith (arr. Blair Bollinger). The reason for this is more ease when getting to positions near by like c sharp in 5th. It's easier to go from 6 to 5 instead of 1 to 5. But I understand why we all have different takes and methods. I just wanted to throw that out there.
Also... It's assembled backwards i think? The slide is in her left hand? And also the text isn't backwards so the image isn't flipped either.
I feel like trombone has been portrayed incorrectly so much and its probably because the instrument is very visual (the slide moving) and easier for actors to fake, which is ideal for film and television. As opposed to string instruments and sometimes even piano. Of course people who do play trombone will tell in an instant. But even fake violin playing can look so awkward to a non-musician
Good catch. Even people who are familiar with seeing it played may not have noticed this. I don't play trombone, but have several dear friends who do, so I was quite used to seeing it, but not knowledgeable enough to notice what's wrong here, just to get the impression it might be a little off.
So is the trombone just like a big kazoo? Meaning all the different notes are actually "sung" by the player?
About time someone exposed this fakery for what it is!!! 'Bone and Baritone Horn man here!!! 👍👍👍
Because i bet you think your doing it right , what ever works for them , and why would you judge a musical tallent thats worlds and worlds infront of your career 😂😂 but keep up the good work
That's nothing. You should see Howie Long parachute with a pulaski in his hand in Firestorm.
Idgaf she's completely gorgeous and she's from my state, so she can fake play trombone whenever she damn well feels like it xD
I’ve long said the future is quintessentially trombonic.
All the people behind this ad had to do was look up how to play a trombone for free on RUclips, but instead...
Dude it's a commercial. She's being paid thousands of dollars to not care how to play the trombone.
there was a drug commercial that had a young marching trombonist that obviously did not play trombone (as well as a drummer that didn't look like a real drummer).
Wait till you find that one bad Eastern drama series where the violinist didn't play anything right. TwoSet Violin covered that already tho.
Yeah, but does Anna Kendrick play the "rusty trombone"?
To be fair nothing is ever fair in the minds of people that think everything should always be fair because fairness leads to every outcome being fair. To be fair.
Would u not actually know what she played? Since she could blow it in a different pitch or something?
Calling out the charlatans when TRULY necessary.
People blaming her but really it's the director who probably told her to slide around a bunch cause otherwise it "doesn't look like she's playing"
Too bad they covered up her beautiful arrangement of Scheherazade 2nd mov.
What brand and model is your horn?
Its an edwards trombone. Dont know the exact model
What are you talking about - she played lead in the UNT One O'clock band.
Ah the classic jaunt, buh bUB 🅱️🅰️🅰️🅰️
Unless I'm greatly mistaken (which I'm pretty sure I'm not) the farther down the slide position is the lower it is, in my class right now my lowest not is low f which is far down the slide
Knowing Anna Kendrick she probably researched how to do it properly so that she could do it wrong.
What's amazing are these comments. Folks, nobody these days knows what a trombone is.