When I was young and in schools I attended few public functions of RSS in Shivaji park in Mumbai. One of them was presided by Shri. Guruji Golwalkar. At the background of the podium it was written that - विजय ही विजय है ( It's all triamph) and as a scholboy I just wondered what it means. Now at the ripe age of post 60 years what it means. It was meant to develop a confidence in nation that - We can do it. Now at this age I am glad that I ses glimpse of it... We will do it to become a Vishwaguru.
After Jaishankar sir 's podcast, this is the next podcast that has made me think about the India I want to leave for my son. People like him give me confidence that things will be different. Kudos for this excellent podcast
From Chennai , Tamil Nadu. I standby his ideas. India needs to progress. We now have the highest level of confidence among fellow Indians and we will do better than in the past. Jai Hind.
This has been the most impactful podcast I have heard in your series of podcasts. Shaurya and his thoughts, ideas and convictions have brought such a lot of pride and self esteem in my person, it is difficult for me to even begin to explain. I am from the same era as you and Shaurya, and I always had this niggling thought at the back of my mind regarding our national mindset, why is it that we - as a society - have no pride in our own work, why don't we celebrate our own achievements and value our own civilization? Why do we always need "White" validation to applaud ourselves and consider ourselves worthy. Thank you Smita Prakash, for having this Conversation.
To be honest RSS sounds more sensible and forward looking than many other BJP people especially in the online space. For a large and diverse country like ours any attempt to impose an ideology will fail. The best way forward is through open exchange of ideas and fair play to all view points from hindu rashtra to communism and different shades of secularism in between. Personally am an atheist, so i think secularism is very important and should be preserved.
Agreed. Secularism in its true meaning and form should prevail not what congress used to practice in the name of secularism. Many of the hindu extremism we see today is a direct result of such filthy politics.
Communism is anti diversity and democracy, communist manifesto and das kapital officially advocate banning foe, corporatised family system is the worst thing to happen in india we need to allow prenupitals etc too, u r intellectually dishonest secularlism and bias for muslim, christian and sikh viewpoints and not understanding the dangers of one or ALL just for hating the other, funding etc be it by anyone are two very different things, what is progressive in your opinion just hijacking resources and wanting a forced labour class?
I had seen Shree Ajit Doval in Surrey in 2014/ 2015 when he was with the PM and I had screamed his name to which he was courteous enough to acknowledge it by waving his hand.
Thank you ANI for this episode . Wow I appreciate the thought process of mr doval who brings a experience of global exposure, and agree to the perspective he says for bhartiya to march ahead with self confidence self reliance and conviction in it. 🙏🙏🙏
You can stop an invading army, but not an Idea whose time has come - VH The idea of a progressive, intellectual, prosperous and can do bharat, which is proud of its ancient origins and heritage has come. Excellent conversation.
Very enjoyable discussion on evolving India from the cycle of darkness to a promising future.Thanks to Smita ji for conducting a soul searching talk with an educated nationalist.
My grandfather used to say we are a developing country, my father says that we are a developing country. I am sure that I will say to my grandson that we are a developing country, not a developed high income country. thank you for the productive podcast.madam could you please invite an expert who will give a realistic opinion about Indian education system mainly government schools and reforms needed in place for greater India
Very sensible, I had. It hear him so far and he absolutely makes sense. I see that confidence in an average Indian who believes he/she can do things which they didn’t thought of few years ago. The leadership has provided that feel, platform to the citizens.
It's really nice to see a person who doesn't mince words. He is very very clear about what he stands for , like proud of our past and wants young minds to introduce them to such knowledge.
Absolute truth, the journey has just begun, we have to travel a lot more to transform ourselves from the Colonial mindset to the Nationalist mindset. We are improving and we cannot sleep, The 2024 elections are crucial, hope we give the best mandate for the NDA government yet again so that the journey continues and our future generations see the fruits.
Excellent discussion! Highly relevant for some of us working at the intersection of policy, academia, and practice without being highly and predictably critical of the current government.
SELF PRIDE, SELF BELIEF....is true starting point. I 💯 % agree with Shourya....how IAF was operating in 80'$ vs today. I am a witness. I left India 🇮🇳 cos I was hopeless in 2000.......today I feel totally different. PROUD 👏 OF MY BHARAT What changed???? Language, self respect and VISION
Excellent. Hope every parent of Bharatavarsha produces such sons of calibre and have such deep love for their country. Jai Hind Jai ho Bharat Jai Hind!!!!
Hi Smitha, a request for the coming "Podcast" , can you interview Agriculture and Tourism ministry. I think we need to hear from them too what is their contribution to our economy. I trust these 2 segments can hugely contribute to increase our GDP. We can see the work done from Mr.Gadkari, Mr.Piyush Goyal, Mr.Ashwini ... however the important ministry of Agri and Tourism should be successful to have a robust economy.
Shaurya is so right in the way he explained the difference between his success and pariwaar wadi concept how it is different. Anyone with common knowledge would understand it easily.
Absolutely agree , it’s utmost important to have self esteem & we have started believing & progressing towards the Vishwa Guru🙏 Love & respect to the guest 🙏
Doval Ji's time is better utilised in National/Civilizational/Public interest far better away from the shameless useless, self bashing, distasteful media that our country has. Even if he comes, engaging with a nationalist media channel such as The Jaipur Dialogues would empower, attract youth and sync the aspirational energy of nation with the larger and more civilizational causes.
Top notch and huge respect to Shaurya Dobhal, if he can exhibit and repeat the hugh contribution of his father to Bharat, then Bharat would be truly blessed. It's also heartening to note that he has joined BJP, and is running a foundation funded by RSS that ensures that future of Bharat is in safe hands. And now I feel Bharat achieving 20 Trillion$ Economy looks a achievable target. 🙏👋 Jai Shri RAM
Good discussion. One correction, Dr. Manmohan Singh DID NOT get punished after his inaction, UPA still won the LS elections. That says a lot about Indians. I do not think there are many countries around the world who will elect the same Govt who presided over such a humiliation.
I would really wish one more change in our attitude which is towards the corruption, we must also inculcate the principle of honesty and integrity among everyone specially the children, youths who are aspiring to be in civil services, in the area of public or private services in the area of management, engineering and other influential areas for not getting cowed down by any corrupt individual or group who are trying to pressurize these people.
After enduring a millennium of invasions and slavery, we've developed a resilience comparable to the preparation for vaccines which is prepared from antigen to protect against the antigens. Our strength has grown through the adversities we've faced, and regardless of who governs in the next 50-100 years & that will prevail for next millenniums, we are poised to flourish.
I have been watching your podcast for very long , i haven't seen any of them coming to your program and have to answer such questions. This itself is testimony of their what we know/call them . I remember someone asked Raul " Nadda said so " his answer was " who is Nadda ? Is he my professor?? " ...since then i have been trying to know "who's his professor? Or he listened to no one and will thus answer no one ".
Always enjoy your podcast , but a non Hindi speaker, I am seriously handicapped whenever the guests switch to Hindi in between. I hope English subtitles will be added whenever the switch occurs.
👏👏👏🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽👌💐‼️ The future of the nation will be in good hands! Unselfish and service minded people the nation needs he is an example of it! There is one running the country now with such values! Gandhian vulgarity of passivity that was the position of Mr Manmohan Singh was appreciated by Friedman. The guy had nothing to lose!
In case of Karan Thapar you have always desisted from considering the fa.ous modi interview left in between highlighted here when mr. Modi was suggesting to move on because he had answered the stale question umpteen no. Of times. The gue insisting to answered once more, even after knowing that modi had stopped answering as a policy matter even the topic was subjudice after he had been questioned by CBI. recall the Adda meet of India Today while modi had been attending such conclaves. When He pointed to digvijay question not matching with topic on banner. And made a journalist cum congress rajya sabha MP look sheepish on mr. Modi questioning him about gandhi taking every body along with respect to Subhash Chandra Bose.
When an idea matures, when there is a set of ideas accumulated for a while, space is created for new ideas! See for instance, this guest's father has had a golden opportunity to look and learn from his father!
As usual Smita, great discussion. Always fun to listen to these "young" people. I am calling them young as the average age of our political class would be over 60. The numbers of India GDP is shocking. Congress and these presstitutes ruined this country.
Smita: What’s funny if people get food stamps? PM Modi helped poor people during the pandemic and is still helping. USA being a rich country shouldn’t give Indians the false impression that EVERYONE IS RICH. I’ve been here for more than 56 years and I see firsthand what’s happening. I like your show. A mind is a terrible thing to waste. Please remember that. In the Gita, Krishna talks about Gyan which shrouds Agyan and lightens it. Try it, you’ll like it!
I agree. Sometimes Smita asks very stupid questions. Once I saw her asking questions over petty things and even though I thought that a common person would understand that answer but still she was too much concerned over that petty issue.
Thank you Smita Ji for getting a person of substance. A superb podcast. I gained a great deal... It's not Parivarvad that I am against. It's the compromise of MERITOCRACY on the alter of Parivadvad or Jativad or Reservations. I had stopped viewing ANI for a month because of the guests, not because of Smita Ji.
When I was young and in schools I attended few public functions of RSS in Shivaji park in Mumbai. One of them was presided by Shri. Guruji Golwalkar. At the background of the podium it was written that - विजय ही विजय है ( It's all triamph) and as a scholboy I just wondered what it means. Now at the ripe age of post 60 years what it means.
It was meant to develop a confidence in nation that - We can do it. Now at this age I am glad that I ses glimpse of it... We will do it to become a Vishwaguru.
Good experience shared.
You reminded me of the saying "Sometimes I win, sometimes I learn". In that sense, even a loss can be turned into learning, and thus a win.
After Jaishankar sir 's podcast, this is the next podcast that has made me think about the India I want to leave for my son. People like him give me confidence that things will be different.
Kudos for this excellent podcast
Well said!
The Ankhor now turns to face-saving arguments!
Another brilliant episode. This podcast has become the gold standard for Indian media to emulate. Insightful, well researched he'd and slick. Kudos.
An excellent discussion. The country needs more such people for the good of the nation to inculcate self confifence and pride.
0
Like FATHER like SON ❤ Brilliant thoughts worth listening from a able son of Great Father ! Laurels to you Smita too for this podcast.
From Chennai , Tamil Nadu.
I standby his ideas. India needs to progress. We now have the highest level of confidence among fellow Indians and we will do better than in the past.
Jai Hind.
This has been the most impactful podcast I have heard in your series of podcasts. Shaurya and his thoughts, ideas and convictions have brought such a lot of pride and self esteem in my person, it is difficult for me to even begin to explain. I am from the same era as you and Shaurya, and I always had this niggling thought at the back of my mind regarding our national mindset, why is it that we - as a society - have no pride in our own work, why don't we celebrate our own achievements and value our own civilization? Why do we always need "White" validation to applaud ourselves and consider ourselves worthy. Thank you Smita Prakash, for having this Conversation.
A man with good ideals and vision. The best part of this podcast was Mr. Doval gave very apt examples to support his answers and opinions.
To be honest RSS sounds more sensible and forward looking than many other BJP people especially in the online space. For a large and diverse country like ours any attempt to impose an ideology will fail. The best way forward is through open exchange of ideas and fair play to all view points from hindu rashtra to communism and different shades of secularism in between.
Personally am an atheist, so i think secularism is very important and should be preserved.
Agreed. Secularism in its true meaning and form should prevail not what congress used to practice in the name of secularism. Many of the hindu extremism we see today is a direct result of such filthy politics.
Modern atheism is just another tribal religion.
Communism is anti diversity and democracy, communist manifesto and das kapital officially advocate banning foe, corporatised family system is the worst thing to happen in india we need to allow prenupitals etc too, u r intellectually dishonest secularlism and bias for muslim, christian and sikh viewpoints and not understanding the dangers of one or ALL just for hating the other, funding etc be it by anyone are two very different things, what is progressive in your opinion just hijacking resources and wanting a forced labour class?
@JustIndian-exMuslim 💯 Agreed
The vast majority in Bharat is secular to the core and very tolerant vis a vis politically propagated secularism.
I had seen Shree Ajit Doval in Surrey in 2014/ 2015 when he was with the PM and I had screamed his name to which he was courteous enough to acknowledge it by waving his hand.
Like father like son. Expressive, assertive.
Humble and logical in his discussion. Hats off Smita for getting clear and fearless narrative from all the speakers. Kudos to you and your podcast
Thank you ANI for this episode . Wow I appreciate the thought process of mr doval who brings a experience of global exposure, and agree to the perspective he says for bhartiya to march ahead with self confidence self reliance and conviction in it. 🙏🙏🙏
One of your best guests he is so intelligent eloquent very good that you invited him
You can stop an invading army, but not an Idea whose time has come - VH
The idea of a progressive, intellectual, prosperous and can do bharat, which is proud of its ancient origins and heritage has come.
Excellent conversation.
Amazing podcast ❤. Totally relate to everything Shaurya Doval said
Very enjoyable discussion on evolving India from the cycle of darkness to a promising future.Thanks to Smita ji for conducting a soul searching talk with an educated nationalist.
My grandfather used to say we are a developing country, my father says that we are a developing country. I am sure that I will say to my grandson that we are a developing country, not a developed high income country. thank you for the productive podcast.madam could you please invite an expert who will give a realistic opinion about Indian education system mainly government schools and reforms needed in place for greater India
Happy to see people like Shourya is contributing to India story 😊
Such a nice, pleasant and educated person. Ache baap ka achaa betaa..
Very sensible, I had. It hear him so far and he absolutely makes sense. I see that confidence in an average Indian who believes he/she can do things which they didn’t thought of few years ago. The leadership has provided that feel, platform to the citizens.
It's really nice to see a person who doesn't mince words. He is very very clear about what he stands for , like proud of our past and wants young minds to introduce them to such knowledge.
Thanks to Smita for giving opportunity to Shaurya for this lovely podcast .
I must appreciate the quality of Doval"s arguments.Shows quality .knowledge and conviction
The concept of think tank limits or cages our thinking (- legacy of intellectual servitude) which is limitless and endless. जय जय भारत, भारत के लोग!
Absolute truth, the journey has just begun, we have to travel a lot more to transform ourselves from the Colonial mindset to the Nationalist mindset. We are improving and we cannot sleep, The 2024 elections are crucial, hope we give the best mandate for the NDA government yet again so that the journey continues and our future generations see the fruits.
Shaurya is a brilliant, credible and honest person - a person of conviction. His principle centered thinking is the motivating force that drives him.
Superb discussion and analysis by Shaurya Doval...
Excellent discussion! Highly relevant for some of us working at the intersection of policy, academia, and practice without being highly and predictably critical of the current government.
As always a great conversation! But I felt that it was wrapped up kinda abruptly while Doval hadn’t yet finished his sentence…
SELF PRIDE, SELF BELIEF....is true starting point.
I 💯 % agree with Shourya....how IAF was operating in 80'$ vs today. I am a witness.
I left India 🇮🇳 cos I was hopeless in 2000.......today I feel totally different.
PROUD 👏 OF MY BHARAT
What changed????
Language, self respect and VISION
Excellent. Hope every parent of Bharatavarsha produces such sons of calibre and have such deep love for their country.
Jai Hind Jai ho Bharat Jai Hind!!!!
Future of India is bright and safe with such brilliant people.
Great conversation. Should share and nudge them to hear the podcast.
Hi Smitha, a request for the coming "Podcast" , can you interview Agriculture and Tourism ministry. I think we need to hear from them too what is their contribution to our economy. I trust these 2 segments can hugely contribute to increase our GDP. We can see the work done from Mr.Gadkari, Mr.Piyush Goyal, Mr.Ashwini ... however the important ministry of Agri and Tourism should be successful to have a robust economy.
Very informative episode. I was absolutely not aware about work being done by him.🎉
I am so impressed by his explation that i will summarise by 1 word: excellent !!
I was talking to an American on the flight. India’s poor, middle class, and rich coexist. We’ll rise together. Vande Bharat.
Excellent. We need more Dovals in the country. We are proud of you........
Brilliant, brilliant episode. I'm sure, Mr. Shaurya Diwali will go places in Indian politics. He surely knows how to ignite a sense of national pride.
Thank you Smita for making such informational podcasts🙏
Absolutely eye opening discussion!
Great discussion helped me to learn many things ❤
Loved the podcast!
Shaurya is so right in the way he explained the difference between his success and pariwaar wadi concept how it is different. Anyone with common knowledge would understand it easily.
Brilliant talk.. SD has amazing clarity of thought.
Excellent and brilliant conversation. Every Indian young and old should listen to this conversation. Especially the opposition parties should listen.
Very well articulated Shaurya- Kudos 😅
Excellent oratory skills and factual discussion
Absolutely agree , it’s utmost important to have self esteem & we have started believing & progressing towards the Vishwa Guru🙏
Love & respect to the guest 🙏
Even a movie cannot keep me bind like this blockbuster conversation.
Smita ji please try to bring honorable Ajit Doval ji in your podcast 🙏🔥
Doval Ji's time is better utilised in National/Civilizational/Public interest far better away from the shameless useless, self bashing, distasteful media that our country has.
Even if he comes, engaging with a nationalist media channel such as The Jaipur Dialogues would empower, attract youth and sync the aspirational energy of nation with the larger and more civilizational causes.
Top notch and huge respect to Shaurya Dobhal, if he can exhibit and repeat the hugh contribution of his father to Bharat, then Bharat would be truly blessed.
It's also heartening to note that he has joined BJP, and is running a foundation funded by RSS that ensures that future of Bharat is in safe hands. And now I feel Bharat achieving 20 Trillion$ Economy looks a achievable target.
🙏👋
Jai Shri RAM
What a personality 👌🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Smita, to dream big is the right thing to do, unconstrained by the 200 or 900 years of history or the Western narrative.
🙏. Very good information about recent news analysis 👍.
Very good narratives 🇮🇳🇮🇳🕉💐🙏
Time very well spent. Very Informative and as always Smitha Ji asking the right questions.
Fantastic guest. Fantastic discussion. Fantastic hostess.
Insightful! What Shaurya Doval said makes absolute sense. Thank you for the podcast.
देश तो बदल ही रहा है साथ मे विश्व मे फार राइटिष्ट विचार बढ रहा है , यह एक अच्छा संकेत देश और दुनिया दोनो के लिए है ।
Good discussion. One correction, Dr. Manmohan Singh DID NOT get punished after his inaction, UPA still won the LS elections. That says a lot about Indians. I do not think there are many countries around the world who will elect the same Govt who presided over such a humiliation.
I would really wish one more change in our attitude which is towards the corruption, we must also inculcate the principle of honesty and integrity among everyone specially the children, youths who are aspiring to be in civil services, in the area of public or private services in the area of management, engineering and other influential areas for not getting cowed down by any corrupt individual or group who are trying to pressurize these people.
Enjoyed this thoroughly. I am sure this is making many Indians at least give a thought they have to come back to their country to contribute. Jai Hind
I love your podcasts and watch regularly
Good interview...good guest... Gives a insight into how indian people overseas are looking at their motherland... 👍
Fantastic discussion
With such people in think tank…country is really in good hands….we r going to lead the world shortly
After enduring a millennium of invasions and slavery, we've developed a resilience comparable to the preparation for vaccines which is prepared from antigen to protect against the antigens. Our strength has grown through the adversities we've faced, and regardless of who governs in the next 50-100 years & that will prevail for next millenniums, we are poised to flourish.
I have been watching your podcast for very long , i haven't seen any of them coming to your program and have to answer such questions. This itself is testimony of their what we know/call them .
I remember someone asked Raul " Nadda said so " his answer was " who is Nadda ? Is he my professor?? " ...since then i have been trying to know "who's his professor? Or he listened to no one and will thus answer no one ".
Can we please get a podcast with Ajit Doval sir?
Thank you
For presenting an engaging and resonating experience .
What an insightful man!
A wonderful podcast, as usual, from ANI. Keep going Mr.Shourya; you and your team are doing excellent job.
Very exciting discussion indeed. I am 77 as of now. Our fathers and grand fathers spoke on these lines. Nation building times.
Always enjoy your podcast , but a non Hindi speaker, I am seriously handicapped whenever the guests switch to Hindi in between. I hope English subtitles will be added whenever the switch occurs.
👏👏👏🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽👌💐‼️ The future of the nation will be in good hands! Unselfish and service minded people the nation needs he is an example of it! There is one running the country now with such values! Gandhian vulgarity of passivity that was the position of Mr Manmohan Singh was appreciated by Friedman. The guy had nothing to lose!
Wow. Enjoyed listening to him talk.
In case of Karan Thapar you have always desisted from considering the fa.ous modi interview left in between highlighted here when mr. Modi was suggesting to move on because he had answered the stale question umpteen no. Of times. The gue insisting to answered once more, even after knowing that modi had stopped answering as a policy matter even the topic was subjudice after he had been questioned by CBI. recall the Adda meet of India Today while modi had been attending such conclaves. When He pointed to digvijay question not matching with topic on banner. And made a journalist cum congress rajya sabha MP look sheepish on mr. Modi questioning him about gandhi taking every body along with respect to Subhash Chandra Bose.
When an idea matures, when there is a set of ideas accumulated for a while, space is created for new ideas!
See for instance, this guest's father has had a golden opportunity to look and learn from his father!
As usual Smita, great discussion.
Always fun to listen to these "young" people. I am calling them young as the average age of our political class would be over 60.
The numbers of India GDP is shocking. Congress and these presstitutes ruined this country.
Yes, every Indian ought to have the pride of what she or he is!
Very heartwarming talk. I'll have a good nights sleep
Logical discussion and huge respect to Shaurya Doval
Smita is clever in trapping people without them knowing about it 😊
She had put Dobal on defensive by talking about leftist intelligence and a commoners think tank in BJP AND RSS.
One of the best podcast…!!!
thanks to u SMITHA
Thanks to his parents and family for beautiful upbringing.
Great discussion,great dress code also 🎉
No Karan Thapar was harmed in this video
😂
Smita:
What’s funny if people get food stamps?
PM Modi helped poor people during the pandemic and is still helping.
USA being a rich country shouldn’t give Indians the false impression that EVERYONE IS RICH.
I’ve been here for more than 56 years and I see firsthand what’s happening.
I like your show. A mind is a terrible thing to waste.
Please remember that.
In the Gita, Krishna talks about Gyan which shrouds Agyan and lightens it.
Try it, you’ll like it!
I agree. Sometimes Smita asks very stupid questions. Once I saw her asking questions over petty things and even though I thought that a common person would understand that answer but still she was too much concerned over that petty issue.
Very proud of Shaurya ji
ideas need to be convincing!...so brilliant
🎉India has changed🎉
Smita is a true professional. She has very cleverly with the incisive questions managed to get to the mind set of Ajit Duval .
It is old fashioned to talk in terms of left, right. 😌😌😌😌😌🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thank you Smita Ji for getting a person of substance. A superb podcast. I gained a great deal...
It's not Parivarvad that I am against. It's the compromise of MERITOCRACY on the alter of Parivadvad or Jativad or Reservations.
I had stopped viewing ANI for a month because of the guests, not because of Smita Ji.
Nice enlightening video 👍🙏
❤fantastic ❤
Doosan part kb aayega sir