Bucks was on another Fox Sports earlier today and he indicated that Weitering was discussed and selected but “didn’t have his magnet up on the board”, whatever that means.
This seems a strange method for selecting the team. Too much emphasis on the "vibe" of players. That said, this only enhances my opinion of Betts and Holmes. Very intelligent analysis.
Baffled as to why Patrick Cripps and Jacob Weitering weren’t even considered or mentioned in this footage 🤦♂️ Both are having excellent seasons so far!
Stewert and cameron in shows their insane biases. They need to stop getting media personal to do this. No Treloar or Weitering? "if he's good enough he'll get there" Exactly they are waiting for players they like to get into the team, players that are good enough already arent even in the conversation because they dont like them. Just like last year having Stewert in over Andrews, Stewert can have a mid season yet they'll put him in over the best intercept defender of the year because they like him more. If they want AA selection to be taken seriously they need to get unbiased selectors and get rid of the people in there with next to no knowledge like Laura. Mihocek has played a couple mid games and been injured, Pendles has been good but barely played, Josh Kelly hasnt played enough either, Fritsch has been bad, Steven May has been bad, Rozee has barely played, Butters has been okay, Ash has been okay, Liam Duggen has been mid. All of these players are somehow getting talked about above Treloar, Weitering, TDK ect.... How are players that have had a few mid games and been injured the rest of the time getting talked about above probably the most consistent player in the comp atm??
That's a good question imo. A lot of top ruckmen trying to be the Grundy "extra midfielder" model. Gawn is just good at hit outs and clunking contested marks. Just does those very basic aspects of rucking better than anyone
@@MZKPRODIGY Thanks Mate. I guess I look at him as “nothing special” but this just may be an off year. I remember him going up the ground and kicking a few goals here and there a few years back but haven’t really seen too much this year.
Most ppl would have Cripps over Bont bro. Hes definitely having an AA year. You're not #1 in contested possessions, and 2nd in the Brownlow predictor without being in AA form 😅😂@OveonfidentCromSupporter
@trentmahoney188 No deal. I'm a freo supporter so there is no bias and I love Crippa being a Northampton boy but Bont is having a far better season. I think both should be in but if I had to pick between the two I'd pick Bont
Just another lawyer who has been gifted a high ranking role at the AFL. This will be the demise of AFL, people who work in sport their whole lives and study the industry arent the ones who actually get put in prominent positions. Meanwhile the NRL who is cutting the gap between themselves and the AFL faster than Usain Bolt are actually utilising these people.
I just laugh looking at all these people sitting with their computers as though they're rocket scientists planning a space mission to Mars. The over analyzing these days of what use to be a simple exciting game to watch just a few decades ago is ridiculous.
Need more selectors like Buckley and Cornes
The disrespect on Jacob Wietering is wild
weitering not being mentioned is a disgrace
Absolutely correct bro 100%. This panel is definitely inept not to even consider weittering.
This is clearly edited. No commitee meeting lasts 5 minutes.
Bucks was on another Fox Sports earlier today and he indicated that Weitering was discussed and selected but “didn’t have his magnet up on the board”, whatever that means.
TDK is a lock Curnow is a lock P Cripps is a lock Walsh is a lock and Weitering is a lock
@@AndrewDean-rt8cvWalsh and Tdk are not mate but plenty of football to go.ps I’m a blues fan also
This seems a strange method for selecting the team. Too much emphasis on the "vibe" of players.
That said, this only enhances my opinion of Betts and Holmes. Very intelligent analysis.
Assuming Laura Kane hasn’t watched any footy this year.. not sure why she’s on the panel if she doesn’t have Bont in the team
Stewart LMAO. He hasn't touched it the last month.
Baffled as to why Patrick Cripps and Jacob Weitering weren’t even considered or mentioned in this footage 🤦♂️
Both are having excellent seasons so far!
Bucks said he had Cripps on watch 6:50
I'd have more faith in my mum's book club pickîng the team
The AA selection panel should be Sam Newman, Rex Hunt, Kane Cornes, Mark "Jacko" Jackson, Jason Akermanis and Warwick Capper.
2:23 Kane’s disagreement 😝
How come Kevin "Shifter" Sheahan didn't say anything?
Matthew Nick's would have to be in contention for head coach🤔
Rowbottom has to be there, he's the engine in the middle of the Swans.
Absolutely 💯
Abbey needs to revisit Rankins season he had a great game against the pies but had been good prior to that not a lock
Stewert and cameron in shows their insane biases. They need to stop getting media personal to do this. No Treloar or Weitering? "if he's good enough he'll get there" Exactly they are waiting for players they like to get into the team, players that are good enough already arent even in the conversation because they dont like them. Just like last year having Stewert in over Andrews, Stewert can have a mid season yet they'll put him in over the best intercept defender of the year because they like him more. If they want AA selection to be taken seriously they need to get unbiased selectors and get rid of the people in there with next to no knowledge like Laura. Mihocek has played a couple mid games and been injured, Pendles has been good but barely played, Josh Kelly hasnt played enough either, Fritsch has been bad, Steven May has been bad, Rozee has barely played, Butters has been okay, Ash has been okay, Liam Duggen has been mid. All of these players are somehow getting talked about above Treloar, Weitering, TDK ect.... How are players that have had a few mid games and been injured the rest of the time getting talked about above probably the most consistent player in the comp atm??
Cripps not in the side😂???
He wouldn't even make the blues top 6 right now 😂😂😂
@@OverconfidentCromSupporter he's 3rd favourite for the brownlow mate..
STEWART?????
Petracca could be out for the rest of the season so that's the end of that discussion...
no Jake Lever, only been the best interceptor in the comp. by a country mile
Is Max Gawn really that good or have the other rucks stagnated in their progression? Genuine question.
That's a good question imo. A lot of top ruckmen trying to be the Grundy "extra midfielder" model. Gawn is just good at hit outs and clunking contested marks. Just does those very basic aspects of rucking better than anyone
@@MZKPRODIGY Thanks Mate. I guess I look at him as “nothing special” but this just may be an off year. I remember him going up the ground and kicking a few goals here and there a few years back but haven’t really seen too much this year.
What about TDK
@@AndrewDean-rt8cv I’m a bombers supporter and I honestly think he is the best ruckman in the game. It’s crazy to think he’s Carlton’s second choice.
Nathan Buckley is biased against Carlton players he’s an absolute tool .
Would be no swans if David King and Leigh Montagna were picking the side
Jeremy McGovern surely deserves a mention!!
Laura Kane has Bont over Cripps in the side 😂
How does she even get a vote.
Both should be in squad. Bont being spoken about in Brownlow calculations this season if Bulldogs start winning more consistently.
Everyone has bont over cripps lol. Clearly a one eye blues supporter to think cripps has had an AA year
Most ppl would have Cripps over Bont bro. Hes definitely having an AA year. You're not #1 in contested possessions, and 2nd in the Brownlow predictor without being in AA form 😅😂@OveonfidentCromSupporter
@trentmahoney188 No deal. I'm a freo supporter so there is no bias and I love Crippa being a Northampton boy but Bont is having a far better season. I think both should be in but if I had to pick between the two I'd pick Bont
The heck is Laura Kane in there for? Footy boss but has no clue what so ever
Just another lawyer who has been gifted a high ranking role at the AFL. This will be the demise of AFL, people who work in sport their whole lives and study the industry arent the ones who actually get put in prominent positions. Meanwhile the NRL who is cutting the gap between themselves and the AFL faster than Usain Bolt are actually utilising these people.
I think you know the answer to that; they needed another woman and Daisys voice was too annoying
@@sammartin3955they are? 🥴🥴
The misogyny is jumping out
@@imalwaysrightright? People upset a woman who does this for a living has a different opinion to them
Weitering Cripps Walsh McKay curnow all AA form. Ridiculous.
Walsh missed too many games at the start of the season. Simple as that.
@@taliamason7986 yeh but surely hed get a mention like one of the most consistant midfielders there is
😂
@@DesyncGaming.Essendon not gonna have many in the aa😢?
@@bmanbb esseondon not have many in just A or BB
This is lame and weird, strange method in my opinion
I just laugh looking at all these people sitting with their computers as though they're rocket scientists planning a space mission to Mars. The over analyzing these days of what use to be a simple exciting game to watch just a few decades ago is ridiculous.