🔹Many thanks to Gold Mining Inc for sponsoring today's video. You can read more about their latest projects here: www.goldmining.com/investors/ 🔹Subscribe to my Geopolitics newsletter here: cyrusjanssen.substack.com
What Sachs never mentions is the real cause of the US Cold War with Russia, he keeps saying the US wanted dominance but never says why, It's clear the US is doing the same thing with China, The US knows it can't go to war with those countries the reason is clear no one wins and everyone will die, The only reason Sachs never mentioned is the Dollar Reserve statute it's a leverage they don't want to lose the only countries who can say this is a scam and needs to end are China and Russia,
This war in Ukraine will end the same way the USA's wars in Vietnam, and in Afghanistan (aka the graveyard of empires) ended in 1976, and 2021 respectively.
@@Roland_Deschain Because empires DIE a SLOW DEATH after being DEFEATED in Afghanistan also known as the GRAVEYARD OF EMPIRES, and is nicknamed that for a very good reason. It did NOT work out well for Alexander the Great in 330BC, The Ottomans in 1890, The British in 1919, The Soviet Union in 1989, and The USA in 2021. Also STUDY YOUR HISTORY !!! Have a nice day pal.
Trump's will surely stop Ukraine War however it's the start of another chapter .... _" ( China & Iran better careful b4 Trump's gonna crush you both in 2025 ) "_
Unfortunately a large part of the western world is misinformed, really breaks my heart. I feel bad for the Ukrainians, stuck in the middle of all this, and dying for the US in droves… let’s hope it doesn’t escalate any further… 😓
The Ukraine War was also a business campaign for the military industry. I can only imagine the insane amount of profits those war companies have earned in the past three years. The American economy is partially a war economy, it's no wonder they have been in endless conflicts since the end of WW2, and if there's peace , they made sure conflict needed to be manufactured. There is simply so much money to be made.
That’s not completely true. It’s a sick symbiotic relationship where we want them as our spies and foothold in the Middle East to meddle into middle eastern politics.
just another client state set up by the US oligarchy- is using a decoy to escape the bitter truth, you're fucked! Always were just nazi's of different stripe from England! Same old trick of the pommes Bait n Switch!
His first term as president and all the warmongering he did back then is the precident. It also makes no sense that the Republican Party under Trump is no longer part of the oligarch-run uniparty that loves war and hegemony. If he really was a threat to this, he would be like Bernie Sanders, and never be allowed to run. The same goes with his economic policies. If his economic populism was real, the oligarchs would prevent him from running.
Russia and China are facilitating the global transition towards a *multipolar* world dominated by multiple voices, instead of the *unipolar* world dominated by a single voice (namely that of the US's).
Multipolarism doesn't really work. It will usually end with redistributive wars and it will be ordinary people who get the worst of it. The only two times the world was truly multipolar was in 1914 and 1939. We all know how that went. The goal shouldn't be multipolarism, ie. more imperialists who "share" in the exploitation and domination of the working people, but the dismantling of the Capitalist system.
He has been speaking only facts the past few years but he is very much a member of the globalist elite and has done horrible things... No doubt why he knows so much of the truth too.
Jeffery Sachs is a war criminal...go look up his history and the things he now denies he said and did in the 90's!!! GO ON...I DARE YOU!!! UNLESS WISDOM IN YOUR WORLD IS POLICIES THAT RESULT IN THE DEATH OF MILLIONS (Tens of millions to hundred of millions of people... DON'T TAKE MY WORD FOR IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
He wasn't d*mb. If you understand that time period. There are many informal agreements which have solved problems & create peace. It's called gentlemen agreement. But in the trans world no one cares that's where it became a problem. This Gorbachev is the last informal agreement which should keep peace in the world. To understand things you need to learn history not west hypocrites education.
Gorbachev was not naïve, at best he was simply stupid, but most importantly he was a traitor, fully high on "western values". There is a reason why he is hated in Russia. He has destroyed Soviet Union, that was corrupt and inept, but offered nothing in return. If he would have bee naïve, then as times passeed he would learn. But he just kept on pushing same idiotic ideas and narratives, with pretty much all of them being detrimental to Russia. He was like modern celebrities, zero understanding of real world, but plenty of ego and delusions of grandeur.
If you're in Germany and you want PEACE, you need to tell Putin to STOP invading other Countries, then we'll have less problems. Russia has a well known Habit/History of invading other Countries like but not limited to, Ukraine, Georgia 2008, Eastern Europe and Russia also annexed several states by force, including Crimea, Turkestan, Yakutia, Belarus, Alash Autonomy, Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the Emirate of Bukhara. Have him to explain all of these!!!
@@rumpraisin I know a lot of "NATIVE AMERICAN INDIANS", And they every one of them also say the same thing: "WHITE MAN SPEAK WITH FORKED TONGUE". Even my GRANDMOTHER (R.I.P) (Who was full blood CHEROKEE INDIAN) told me when I very young: "POLITICIANS WERE NOTHING BUT LAZY GREEDY POWER HUNGRY DICTATORS WHO WERE NOTHING BUT HABITUAL LYERS, AND TO NEVER TRUST EM." And as the "COMANCHE WAR CHIEF TEN BEARS" In Clint Eastwood's "OUTLAW JOSEY WALES" said: "IT IS SAD THAT THE GOVERNMENT IS CHEAP WITH THE DEVIL TONGUE." Because it is true fact that: GOVERNMENT DOESN'T LIVE TOGETHER, "PEOPLE DO." And it is really stupid why GOVERNMENTS START THE WARS, BUT IT'S THE PEOPLE FROM EACH COUNTRY WHO ARE THE ONES WHO DOING THE KILLINGS AND ARE THE ONES WHO ARE BEING KILLED FOR SOMETHING THAT'S TOTALLY STUPID LIKE: "SELF NATIONAL PRIDE!" We in America have seen too many wars have murdered thousands, And have lost thousands in the process, And what have THE WARS, THE KILLINGS, THE MAIMED, THE SCARRED, THE DESTRUCTION, THE BAD MEMORIES, ETC TAUGHT US: NOT A DAMN THING BECAUSE MOST HUMANKIND IS TOO STUPID TO LEARN FROM PAST MISTAKES LET ALONE UNDERSTAND WHAT ARE THE CONSEQUENCES OF IT!! POWER, LIES, GREED, CURRENCY, SELF CENTEREDNESS, PRIDE, PATRIOTISM, ARROGANCE, HATRED WILL GUARANTEE WARS WILL ALWAYS BE IN OURS AND THEIRS FUTURES. HOW SAD IT IS.
He’s coming across as a Putin stooge at present - these are EXACTLY Putin’s talking points. Let’s be clear Putin Attacked Ukraine, just as he attacked several other countries recently.
Yes, ordinary people who said these things for decades did not gain the privilege of visibility. You are his audience and he is the elite privileged speaker, we, the left suck on bitter pills and are invisible since before 1950.
I respect professor Jeffrey Sachs a lot. I think he is the one to succeed professor Noam Chomsky in this quest of putting more reason into the American foreign policy.
Unfortunately with people choosen by Trump 2 for State Secretary, Defense Secretary and National Security Adviser, I am not expecting any improvement towards peace with Russia and I am fearing that the Middle East situation is going to get worse in involving Iran in it. I am convinced that Russia and China have talked to Iran to avoid triggering the war with US and or Israel but if those rogue countries launch a war against Iran, they will support Iran against them
I agree... The perception is that Trump is going to step back, but I dont think Trump would want to look weak. So, Trump will push for an agreement that would probably require Russia to give some land back but Russia will not accept and the whole saga will continue.
Mr Sach's patience is commendable. Interviews, lectures, Q& As all having to repeat the truth, over and over again. Yet, if one MSM outlet had the intergrity to interview him fairly it would be over for the elites and they know it. Still, he doesn't give up.
Professor Sachs is a rational person. Good. The US needs at least one rational person who speaks out, and the political class is sorely lacking in such people.
Mr. Sachs IS rational and makes perfect sense. The problem is, is that Biden and his administration either aren't listening to him or they don't care. Biden's greenlighting Ukraine to use long-range missiles is one of the most dangerous, not to mention dumb decisions he ever made. But what do you expect from a stubborn, short-sighted, cognitively-challenged man who can't see or won't see the potentially catastrophic consequences of his stupid foreign policy? The sooner he leaves office, the better.
Sovereign countries can make their own decision to join NATO. Why are those countries with the most historical interactions with Russia been the ones most eager to join? Who are we to say Yah or Nay.
The American people voted for Dems and Republicans who don't need leftists. The country never voted for any leftist. So don't expect left wing actions and never underestimate how much Americans love all wars. They voted for wars this year.
This guy is full of it. Russia has a well known habit of invading other Countries like but not limited to, Ukraine, Georgia 2008, Eastern Europe and Russia also annexed several states by force, including Crimea, Turkestan, Yakutia, Belarus, Alash Autonomy, Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the Emirate of Bukhara. Have him to explain all of these!!!
@QuizPulse57 you can't really be unfamiliar with the promise not to expand NATO and the US aggression, regime change etc in Ukraine. We stopped trying to influence our country in war long ago - it certainly belongs to a bellicose minority.
This commentator says its all NATO's fault that Russia decided to attacked its neighbor, then why did Finland and Sweden join NATO and join very quickly ?
Simple. In geopolitical power-struggles between alliances, border states have two choices: 1)Joining a side, and having a reasonable expectation that any future conflict will be confined to the borders of their territory and that of the adversary. 2) Remaining neutral and having absolute certainty that a future conflict will be fought across the entirety of their territory. This certainty would have been pointed out clearly to the newly independent countries of Central / Eastern Europe by the original NATO countries when their membership of NATO was being solicited. It's what we call a 'Hobson's choice'- i.e.a choice made under duress. Finland and Sweden, being border states, are in exactly the same position.
He's a Putin stooge. Finland and Sweden changed their stance on NATO because they saw what Putin was doing. There are many flavors of imperialism. Sachs only opposes the US version.
Forget the "20 year period". Russians will never accept something like this. Never means never not something else in the middle with timetables. The arrogance of some people thinking and assuming that others are that much naive and stupid always gets me.. And is even worse considering that is coming out of the mouths and minds of supposedly the high level politicians that we intrusted our future.
To change for the better one must acknowledge one's weaknesses. After World War II US have been creating enemies. Much of US resources are used to support regime change in other countries and invading countries. US made money selling weapons to countries around the World. Hence the war related industry grew at the expense of other industries. So much attention and finances were diverted to war mongering effort outside that local needs and developments are being neglected. Whereas in China the opposite happen. In the last 40 years their profits were put to good use to develop the infrastructure of the country. They focus more in developing self sufficiency. Hence they improved trade between countries and were able to support the various important industries and their achievements in a few decades surpassing all expectations. Meanwhile in the US inflation is shrinking the once middle class to poor. People cannot afford to buy US products. They welcome Chinese products which are cheaper.
Proposal about Ukraine not joining NATO for 20 years just means 20 years for NATO to rearm Ukraine for next war. Same thing as Mints agreement in 2014 just to buy time to rearm Ukraine. It will not fly the second time. Russia want a permanent solution in peace talk otherwise they can continue the fight. They are winning and EU army is nothing without Americans.
Не надейтесь что опять вам удастся всех перехитрить . Взять тайм аут на 20 лет и втихаря перевооружить Украину для реванша. Вам никто не даст шанса еще раз.
It's not about any NATO, but about russian nazism and fascism towards ukrainians as a nation. Russia openly claims for genocide of ukrainians based on their identity. As for NATO, Finland and Sweden joined NATO and? Finland is closer to St.petersburg and Moscow than Ukraine. NATO was never a reason for anything in Ukraine. russia doesnt want Ukraine to be in NATO because NATO means protection.
This guy is full of it. Russia has a well known habit of invading other Countries like but not limited to, Ukraine, Georgia 2008, Eastern Europe and Russia also annexed several states by force, including Crimea, Turkestan, Yakutia, Belarus, Alash Autonomy, Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the Emirate of Bukhara. Have him to explain all of these!!!
@@QuizPulse57 - And all these invasions you mention took place on Putin's watch? And how many people have US military and proxies killed during the same time span, since 1999, including participating in a genocide?
@@QuizPulse57 USA also did that, for Europe don't tell me. The Professor speaks about what led to the present conflict. He does not go 1000 years in history. Learn to understand within the context.
NO, NO, NO... NO 😂"PISS PRIZE"😂 FOR JEFFREY SACHS. Please DON'T SULLY Prof. Jeffery Sachs' GOOD NAME & HIGH INTELLECT With This BS PRIZE which was Also Awarded To Obama for Nothing. 😊
You're absolutely right ,and also winning ! Furthermore I'd like to add they'll never accept a deal with a demillitarized zone whilst Ukraine maintains a military force and re-arms itself to fight another war in the future so good luck Donald 😂😂 this deal will not happen Russia had said as much.
"I've always said that, keep the oil. We want to keep the oil, $45 million a month. Keep the oil. We've secured the oil." ~Donald Trump, comments about stealing Syria oil
I can see no reason why a single penny of US tax dollars should go towards an Israeli, a Ukrainian, a Taiwanese, a European, an Australian, a Japanese, a Filipino, a South Korean, etc. They should take care of themselves!
The Taiwanese are not getting charity from the US. Let's be clear about that. The Tsai administration has paid a hefty sum of money to buy defense weapons from the US. The sudden affection for Taiwan stems from the precious semiconductors and microchips. How convenient! The entire setup of cozying up with Taiwan and the Philippines is to provoke China into a war.
Tony, all US aid has been spent in the US providing USJobs And US profits. Its the EU and for the most part Poland that pay money to the Ukraine so that the government can existence and the economy of the Ukraine doesn’t completely collapses. No US tsx money goes to Ukraine the tax dollars go tobthe heavy industries and shipping companies in the USA.
You realize America is fundamentally insolvent without exporters storing surplus dollars into US treasuries and financial assets? The US will absolutely crumble to bits when it goes all in on isolationism. We may be the second largest manufacturer on paper but we source so many components and raw materials from the outside world and those figures include things where we just put the finishing touch on an imported good and say made in America.
Taiwan is not a UN recognized country and it is always considered an internal civil war of the Chinese. US support by arming Taiwan is like supporting a rebel group within China, according to China point of view. Ukraine is just a proxy puppet of USA whereas Israel is the master of USA. 🤣
To say Ukraine will not join NATO for the next 20 years is not settling well with Russia. Russia will not agree to that proposition. Because it would mean the neocons just have to wait 20 years to execute their plans. Russia is still where it is 20 years from now.
That 800 mile buffer zone would be occupied by NATO troops. Plus, delaying Ukraine from joining NATO for 20 years is just giving them a chance to rebuild their military, with NATO's help. None of this will be acceptable.
You lost me at "the war began because Russia felt surrounded" or whatever. The truth is probably more simple and goes back to Euromaidan. It also draws parallels with the China-Taiwan situation (democratic neighbor on authoritarian's doorstep). Whatever you believe, tyranny cannot be allowed to prevail.
I love Sachs simply because he advocate peace instead of conflict to resolve issues. He is spoke very eloquently, knowledgeable and wise. He's also very sincere in his pursuit of spreading peace.
хохо, поэтому с русскими надо дружить, в не создавать из своей страны военный полигон для Нато ) пока к украинцам не пришли их новые лучшие "друзья", они жили в мире с русскими и с Россией.
If Russia wants to end an alleged Russia/US conflict, all they have to do is pull out of Ukraine. This video has hammer and sickle stamped all over it.
He was instrumental in Russia becoming what it is now. He was advisor to Yeltsyn/Gaydar goverment and prescribed a shock therapy as panaceum. They listened, because similar thing worked in Poland, maybe not without issues, but acceptable. Gaydar treated Sachs advise literally and switched the system to capitalism overnight in a country in which nobody, but a few individuals had any idea about normal business. It caused total chaos, poverty and extreme crime rate. Russians felt humiliated. They associate this period with democracy and Putin's era with recovery. Democracy is a dirty word in Russia. They blame the US for everything - traditionally.
I have deep admiration for the Ukrainian people. It's heartbreaking that the greed and selfishness of a few, not Russia, are destroying this beautiful nation.
Look at the movie doc. (ASP footage) How Russians goal in Mariupol were civilians and their infants dying in the hospital close to the first line.There were no soldiers or army devices just mother's children and old people.
Professor Sachs has a great interview with Tucker Carlson. Since some of the responses in the Comments Section seem to be unaware of who he is, Sachs is the lead author in the study of the Origins of COVID 19 in the British Medical Journal Lancet. He does not shy away from the truth no matter how inconvenient or politically incorrect they are.
He has zero medical expertise and that article is BS, to be polite. And Tucker Carlson, as Fox "news" admitted, is an entertainer, not a journalist. Carlson is another Putin stooge.
It's like the Russian promise to Ukraine to respect their borders, independence, and refrain from use of force against them if Ukraine gave Russia all their nukes in 1994.
Great video, Cyrus! Professor Sachs is so clear and has so much experience-I love to hear him speak. Fingers crossed for this one! I live in Britain (Scotland) and I agree with him that the UK government is totally irresponsible!
It's because they continue to live in the post-Soviet Union dissolution era, where they viewed themselves victorious, no longer faced any opposition from an equal power and could do whatever they want. They fail to understand how much the world has changed since then.
YOU HAVE TO MURDER HUMAN BEINGS IN ORDER TO STEAL THEIR RESOURCES "People said to me, 'Why are you staying in Syria.' Because I kept the oil, which frankly we should have done in Iraq." ~Donald Trump, comments about stealing Syria oil
Zelensky didn't try to prevent the conflict through diplomacy because he lacks honor and integrity. In 2014 there was a coup. Soon after, there was a massacre in Odessa (dozens of people were burned alive). Ethnic Russians living in Ukraine were treated as subhuman. Their language and culture was being oppressed. A civil war broke out due to the rise in ethnic tensions. For 8 years the Ukrainian military was indiscriminately shelling civilians living in Donbas. If Zelensky honored the Minsk agreement and pledged neutrality, none of this would have happened. The 8 year civil war would have ended and Donbas would have remained part of Ukraine. War is the ultimate failure of diplomacy. Zelensky, Poroshenko, Merkel and Hollande admitted that Ukraine had no intention to honor the Minsk agreements. Who didn't want peace? Who advised against the 2022 peace talks in April? Hint: someone visited Zelensky in Kiev at that time Russia's national security was compromised once NATO began to expand eastwards. Russia clearly stated that Ukraine joining NATO was a red line (November 2021) and unfortunately this concern was never taken seriously. The Russians openly stated: if nothing changes, we will be forced to act in order to defend our national security. Enhancing the national security of one country at the expense of another is unacceptable. The Russians have legitimate security concerns. 20th September, 2021: Ukraine launched military drills with US and NATO. NATO is not a defensive alliance. NATO illegally bombed Yugoslavia (a direct violation of the U.N. Charter). We should never forget what they did to Libya, Afghanistan, Iraq etc. Who blew up the pipeline causing an environmental disaster? Zelensky banned all opposition and arrested a leading priest. Zelensky tried to invoke article 5 under false pretenses. Remember the incident in Poland. Ethnic Russians living in Ukraine were treated as subhuman. Their language and culture was being oppressed. Poroshenko said, “Our children will go to schools and kindergartens-theirs will hide in the basements”. Russians will never forget the 2014 Odessa massacre. The whole world needs to know about it. Why was Denis Kireev eliminated? He was a member of Ukraine's negotiating team during the peace negotiations. He wanted to help his country. Ukraine has a hit list. They target artists, journalists and ordinary citizens. Hundreds of children are on this list. 13 year old Faina Savenkova was placed on this list. Pink Floyd's Roger Waters is on this list. Jimmy Dore (American stand-up comedian, podcaster) and Aaron Maté (Canadian writer and journalist) are on this list. There is evidence that Ukrainian troops have been indiscriminately shelling civilians in Donbas (they used petal mines and targeted areas where there was no military presence). The azov troops trapped in the azovstal steelworks in Mariupol used human shields. They refused to allow civilians to leave despite of humanitarian corridors being present. Russia held a proposed cease fire in order for the civilians to leave, but azov would not allow the civilians to leave. Ukraine has committed many acts of terrorism (car bombs and other forms of assassination). Darya Dugina (journalist) R.I.P. The first terrorist attack on the Kerch bridge killed the truck driver and the individuals in the adjacent car (innocent civilian victims). The second terrorist attack on the Kerch bridge killed two parents and severely injured their young daughter. I have done a lot of research and it took me a long time to write this comment. I have stated a lot of facts and I have given my honest opinion. I have provided a brief summary of events that took place. In order to explain this whole situation in great detail, a book would need to be written. Hopefully someone will write an UNBIASED book, stating facts and allowing the readers to form their own judgments. Everything I said can be fact checked and verified.
Jefrfrey Sach s does not care about Urkainian people or for that matter about of people of countries oppressed by Russia. Eastern Europian countries fled from Russia as soon as they could after the fall of soviet union.
they say US send 60 billion to Ukraine but only 10% of that was send not the full amount! still nothing to sneeze at but still not what was promised for support aid
While I have great respect for Sachs work, I am somewhat disappointed in his analysis of this situation. Having visited Ukraine number of times, the Ukrainians have no love for Russian control and voted decisively in a democratic referendum to leave the Russian union. The 1994 Budapest Memorandum was signed by Ukraine, Russia, the United States, and the United Kingdom. Under it, Ukraine agreed to give up the nuclear weapons in return for security guarantees. Russia violated this agreement when it supported separatist movements in Ukraine's Donbas region and subsequently invaded Ukraine in 2014 and again in 2022. The UK and the US are protecting international law by living up to the 1994 agreement. NATO expansion was and continues to be the result of decisions by sovereign nations to seek security against the threat of future Russian aggression from which they suffered following WW2. Does anyone in the West really think that NATO is an aggressive pact and will invade Russia. Ukraine is not blameless with regard to its treatment of its Russian-speaking minorities and it would have been better served by a federal government that provided linguistic and cultural protection to its Russian-speaking regions. However, in this conflict it is not a US puppet state nor the aggressor.
Read paragraph 5 of the Budapest Memorandum after the word "except" The country had no right to act in concert with one guarantor against another guarantor. In turn, Ukrainian President Yushchenko already in June 2008 asked the Secretary General for an action plan for joining NATO. He also proclaimed Bandera and Shukhevych as heroes of Ukraine. President Yanukovych cancelled these decrees. He was overthrown in 2014.
Those nukes weren't theirs to begin with, they were only on their territory, but they didn't have the codes and didn't have the means of maintaining them.
He was there , face to face with Yeltzin, during the dissolution of the USSR by the Stalinist bureacratic ruling elites and the transformation from a command econmy to a market bases, aka oligarch based, capitalism economy. I was there, lived through and followed those events, as they happened.
Excellent analysis. The analysis is accurate, well documented and persuasive. Getting rid of the Ukraine problem, is vital to world stability. Trump will forever be great if he does what he promised. Quickly.
Nothing could be farther from the truth. Russia has a history of aggression towards its neighbours. See Georgia 2008 and Crimea (that was just to beautiful and important not to annexe it). They also invested heavily in trying to influence the elections in the Republic of Moldova. The reality is that all the small nations which were once in the Soviet block want to be part of NATO to avoid further aggression from Russia, including my own country, Romania. These nations want to be independent, to decide their own future and they want democracy. They are ready to die for this. Ignoring all these facts and saying it's a war between the US and Russia is deliberately lying.
🔹Many thanks to Gold Mining Inc for sponsoring today's video. You can read more about their latest projects here: www.goldmining.com/investors/
🔹Subscribe to my Geopolitics newsletter here: cyrusjanssen.substack.com
What Sachs never mentions is the real cause of the US Cold War with Russia, he keeps saying the US wanted dominance but never says why, It's clear the US is doing the same thing with China, The US knows it can't go to war with those countries the reason is clear no one wins and everyone will die,
The only reason Sachs never mentioned is the Dollar Reserve statute it's a leverage they don't want to lose the only countries who can say this is a scam and needs to end are China and Russia,
This war in Ukraine will end the same way the USA's wars in Vietnam, and in Afghanistan (aka the graveyard of empires) ended in 1976, and 2021 respectively.
the biggest conception is the US (Utterly Shameless) - your country - is the good guy, while the truth is the total opposite.
@@robertko5425 If it was a graveyard of their empire why are they still alive?
@@Roland_Deschain Because empires DIE a SLOW DEATH after being DEFEATED in Afghanistan also known as the GRAVEYARD OF EMPIRES, and is nicknamed that for a very good reason. It did NOT work out well for Alexander the Great in 330BC, The Ottomans in 1890, The British in 1919, The Soviet Union in 1989, and The USA in 2021. Also STUDY YOUR HISTORY !!! Have a nice day pal.
Zelenskyy: _"You promised to support Ukraine until the end!"_
Biden: _"Well, it's the end of my administration, so there goes your support."_
Trump's will surely stop Ukraine War however it's the start of another chapter .... _" ( China & Iran better careful b4 Trump's gonna crush you both in 2025 ) "_
😭😭😭
At first it’s funny but now…
A good lesson here, never trust the US!
BUT.....Trump will continue .. unfortunately
@@Shenzhou. next on trump's list, Iran and China...... G luck
请让世界和平吧，不要无辜百姓继续牺牲！💖🥺
别做梦了。你恐怕不知道前南就是美欧势力在后面挑唆，拱火，支持了民族敌对与分裂战争，让他们无限升级，光一个南斯拉夫就有2000万人伤亡，二战后的历史中，美欧导致全世界5亿人伤亡。并且还将继续，来几场更大的。
Continue peace activism efforts everywhere - in person and on social media
Unfortunately a large part of the western world is misinformed, really breaks my heart. I feel bad for the Ukrainians, stuck in the middle of all this, and dying for the US in droves… let’s hope it doesn’t escalate any further… 😓
自由与民主是项传大的事业。现在也许有误解，以为美国人的自由与民主需要非美国人的血来灌溉。但当你看到朱莉高呼：他们得到了自由。你就会明白，美国在做的实际是项，为全人类共同富裕的慈善事业。但这项计划需要5亿人献身，目前名额还没有凑齐。
@@kenoding118 5亿？我一天出5亿！
The Ukraine War was also a business campaign for the military industry. I can only imagine the insane amount of profits those war companies have earned in the past three years. The American economy is partially a war economy, it's no wonder they have been in endless conflicts since the end of WW2, and if there's peace , they made sure conflict needed to be manufactured. There is simply so much money to be made.
The corrupted politicians are in the same game.. billions in kickbacks. War creation is a lucrative business for the rotten politicians
Oh yeah the MIC made Putin invade a sovereign nation.
@@BDJPCarr-mu4jc Tryied into sarcasm but actualy spit truth here lol.
Suckered...again.
++wall street
"Forget about Russia, the real threat to America is Israel and the Israel Lobby " - Julian Assange
That’s not completely true. It’s a sick symbiotic relationship where we want them as our spies and foothold in the Middle East to meddle into middle eastern politics.
And how does that contradict the comment above?@@Arnsteel634
@@Arnsteel634Both are true though
@@Jack-c2d8w yeah.
just another client state set up by the US oligarchy- is using a decoy to escape the bitter truth, you're fucked! Always were just nazi's of different stripe from England! Same old trick of the pommes Bait n Switch!
I want to believe Trump wants to avoid WW3, but his decision to surround himself with neocons like Bolton and now Rubio raises serious doubts.
His first term as president and all the warmongering he did back then is the precident. It also makes no sense that the Republican Party under Trump is no longer part of the oligarch-run uniparty that loves war and hegemony. If he really was a threat to this, he would be like Bernie Sanders, and never be allowed to run. The same goes with his economic policies. If his economic populism was real, the oligarchs would prevent him from running.
Trump is maybe worst than all others , he’s big mouth Karen
Bolton is out, but you still need neocons to show your enemies that you havent gone soft
His support of zionism is also concerning.
I think trump just wants marco to be in his cabinet so he can fire him.
Russia and China are facilitating the global transition towards a *multipolar* world dominated by multiple voices, instead of the *unipolar* world dominated by a single voice (namely that of the US's).
❤Precisely well said
Not really, only reason they do this is so they can have a voice.
namely that of the United States of Israel.
Multipolarism doesn't really work. It will usually end with redistributive wars and it will be ordinary people who get the worst of it. The only two times the world was truly multipolar was in 1914 and 1939. We all know how that went. The goal shouldn't be multipolarism, ie. more imperialists who "share" in the exploitation and domination of the working people, but the dismantling of the Capitalist system.
More precisely US-UK
Jeffrey Sachs, a wise man and with a moral code . Thank you for the interview Cyrus.
My pleasure...he is an excellent guest!
yeah his pocket and greed
@@buddy3886 is definitely not as deep as your pocket and as greedy as your greed.
He has been speaking only facts the past few years but he is very much a member of the globalist elite and has done horrible things... No doubt why he knows so much of the truth too.
Jeffery Sachs is a war criminal...go look up his history and the things he now denies he said and did in the 90's!!! GO ON...I DARE YOU!!! UNLESS WISDOM IN YOUR WORLD IS POLICIES THAT RESULT IN THE DEATH OF MILLIONS (Tens of millions to hundred of millions of people... DON'T TAKE MY WORD FOR IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jeffrey Sachs is a patriot and world citizen.
Agree 💯 %
❤A voice of knowledge and reason.
If he got a correct translation of Putin, ... Very naive!
@@elisabetbarth5573 kiev propagandist get out
@@elisabetbarth5573 shut up cia bots
North Korean troops are in Russia, but Not deployed !!!! How many NATO troops are in Ukraine ?!? Deployed , fighting and dying ?!?
none other than volunteers actually
Edit: apparently I'm a bit out-of-date
It's always the other side, it's never "our" side. The hypocrite label doesn't come lightly.
не так давно в приграничье были уничтожены наёмники из разных стран,среди трупов был опознан американский рейнджер.
Not deployed? Where does the Korean BBQ come from? 💀
@@Global-yt :D sure sure wake up
Gorbachev was easily one of the most naive politicians to ever have lived 😂
A politician dumb enough to trust other politicians and bureaucrats 😂😂
Gorbachev had a vision of a world at peace. He didn't realise that it's Washington & the corporations who are the real power in America.
The U.S were after Russia's resources and ports by charming gullible Gorbachov and now, with their Eukraine proxy war.
_US promised a capitalism ideology which would surely enriched Russian* society at large, thus undeniably he took the baits with all his hearts_
He wasn't d*mb. If you understand that time period. There are many informal agreements which have solved problems & create peace. It's called gentlemen agreement. But in the trans world no one cares that's where it became a problem. This Gorbachev is the last informal agreement which should keep peace in the world. To understand things you need to learn history not west hypocrites education.
Gorbachev was not naïve, at best he was simply stupid, but most importantly he was a traitor, fully high on "western values". There is a reason why he is hated in Russia. He has destroyed Soviet Union, that was corrupt and inept, but offered nothing in return.
If he would have bee naïve, then as times passeed he would learn. But he just kept on pushing same idiotic ideas and narratives, with pretty much all of them being detrimental to Russia. He was like modern celebrities, zero understanding of real world, but plenty of ego and delusions of grandeur.
Greeting from Germany .Thank you Mr. J. Sachs for PEACE work .
If you're in Germany and you want PEACE, you need to tell Putin to STOP invading other Countries, then we'll have less problems. Russia has a well known Habit/History of invading other Countries like but not limited to, Ukraine, Georgia 2008, Eastern Europe and Russia also annexed several states by force, including Crimea, Turkestan, Yakutia, Belarus, Alash Autonomy, Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the Emirate of Bukhara. Have him to explain all of these!!!
scholz, like merkel are war criminals.
If you are from germany then im putin
@@QuizPulse57 aren't those countries part of USSR ?
The American Indians already said in the 1800, white men speak with fork tongue
Habitual liars.
Some of them do.
@@rumpraisin
I know a lot of
"NATIVE AMERICAN INDIANS",
And they every one of them also say the same thing:
"WHITE MAN SPEAK WITH FORKED TONGUE".
Even my GRANDMOTHER (R.I.P)
(Who was full blood
CHEROKEE INDIAN)
told me when I very young:
"POLITICIANS WERE NOTHING BUT LAZY GREEDY POWER HUNGRY DICTATORS WHO WERE NOTHING BUT HABITUAL LYERS,
AND TO NEVER TRUST EM."
And as the
"COMANCHE WAR CHIEF TEN BEARS"
In Clint Eastwood's
"OUTLAW JOSEY WALES" said:
"IT IS SAD THAT THE GOVERNMENT IS CHEAP WITH THE
DEVIL TONGUE."
Because it is true fact that:
GOVERNMENT DOESN'T LIVE TOGETHER,
"PEOPLE DO."
And it is really stupid why
GOVERNMENTS START THE WARS,
BUT IT'S THE PEOPLE FROM EACH COUNTRY WHO ARE THE ONES WHO DOING THE KILLINGS AND ARE THE ONES WHO ARE BEING KILLED FOR SOMETHING THAT'S TOTALLY STUPID LIKE:
"SELF NATIONAL PRIDE!"
We in America have seen too many wars have murdered thousands,
And have lost thousands in the process,
And what have
THE WARS,
THE KILLINGS,
THE MAIMED,
THE SCARRED,
THE DESTRUCTION,
THE BAD MEMORIES,
ETC
TAUGHT US:
NOT A DAMN THING BECAUSE MOST HUMANKIND IS TOO STUPID TO LEARN FROM PAST MISTAKES LET ALONE UNDERSTAND WHAT ARE THE CONSEQUENCES OF IT!!
POWER, LIES, GREED, CURRENCY,
SELF CENTEREDNESS, PRIDE, PATRIOTISM, ARROGANCE, HATRED
WILL GUARANTEE WARS WILL ALWAYS BE IN OURS AND THEIRS FUTURES.
HOW SAD IT IS.
Racist
SALUTEEEEEEEEE
Professor Sachs deserves the Nobel Prize for Peace several times!
He deserves jail for lying and facilitating Putin.
Professor Sachs to too peaceful and too humane to win the Noble Peace Prize...😅
Professor Sachs has to live in a building in Harkiv only for a week and he will change his perspective about the entire Solar system.
He’s coming across as a Putin stooge at present - these are EXACTLY Putin’s talking points.
Let’s be clear Putin Attacked Ukraine, just as he attacked several other countries recently.
Let Russians propose this. After all he prescribed shock therapy for Russia, which Yeltsyn goverment implemented. Ask Russians how they liked it.
Sachs is the voice of reason in middle of madness .....☠️☠️
Still coping about Trumps making America great and you're more pro slavic patriot who wants to bring back goold old Russian Empire?
Love listening to Sachs, he is brilliant
Yes, ordinary people who said these things for decades did not gain the privilege of visibility. You are his audience and he is the elite privileged speaker, we, the left suck on bitter pills and are invisible since before 1950.
He fits the russians so well
@@86Corvus I'll take that as you mean they are equally level headed and peace-prioritizing, which yes, they are.
Dear Sir Cyrus Janssen This insight from Prof Jeffrey Sachs is enough to drop selfishness and advance humanity to the next level. Thank you very much
I respect professor Jeffrey Sachs a lot. I think he is the one to succeed professor Noam Chomsky in this quest of putting more reason into the American foreign policy.
I would agree with that too
Noam Chomsky is a True Economic, Historian Spokesperson - TOTALLY AGREE. !!!
Great job doing this, Cyrus. This history needs to get out to the entire world.
Agree...so much history Western media fails to address and discuss
@@CyrusJanssen You should learn about Russia, the Gulag, the economics and killings on minorities.
Explain Kaliningrad?
Unfortunately with people choosen by Trump 2 for State Secretary, Defense Secretary and National Security Adviser, I am not expecting any improvement towards peace with Russia and I am fearing that the Middle East situation is going to get worse in involving Iran in it. I am convinced that Russia and China have talked to Iran to avoid triggering the war with US and or Israel but if those rogue countries launch a war against Iran, they will support Iran against them
Whoever US citizens chose...no difference
Citizens can only choose between "what's on offer ", in nato countries that always leads to same outcome 😅 and they are calling Russia dictatorship 😂
I agree... The perception is that Trump is going to step back, but I dont think Trump would want to look weak. So, Trump will push for an agreement that would probably require Russia to give some land back but Russia will not accept and the whole saga will continue.
Mr Sach's patience is commendable. Interviews, lectures, Q& As all having to repeat the truth, over and over again. Yet, if one MSM outlet had the intergrity to interview him fairly it would be over for the elites and they know it. Still, he doesn't give up.
Agree...I hope we can get his voice out even more
Professor Sachs is a rational person. Good. The US needs at least one rational person who speaks out, and the political class is sorely lacking in such people.
Rational? :)) A mouthpiece for China and Russia is anything but rational. :))
Mr. Sachs IS rational and makes perfect sense. The problem is, is that Biden and his administration either aren't listening to him or they don't care. Biden's greenlighting Ukraine to use long-range missiles is one of the most dangerous, not to mention dumb decisions he ever made. But what do you expect from a stubborn, short-sighted, cognitively-challenged man who can't see or won't see the potentially catastrophic consequences of his stupid foreign policy? The sooner he leaves office, the better.
@@zxc86zxc Yet US has 800 military bases spread around the world... How many does China has?🤣
We knew this, they just confirmed it
Congratulations. You succeeded in changing my mind on the war in Ukraine. Jeffrey Sachs I can trust.
Looking forward to the rest of the interview.
in which direction?
@@ekids.bassment He was pro ukraine
Its important to hear from all sides and learn as much as possible about every situation....always a lot more behind the scenes!
@@vvinterghost украина, это искуственно созданая территория в 1922 году коммунистами.До этого, понятия такого небыла !
Me too.
Jeffrey you are Gods messenger of truth!
Which god are you thinking off ???????
Sovereign countries can make their own decision to join NATO. Why are those countries with the most historical interactions with Russia been the ones most eager to join? Who are we to say Yah or Nay.
Would you accept RU miI. bases in Cuba or Mexico?
Professor Sachs would make an excellent Secretary of State.
Sure if you want russia to win the war !!
Tulsi Gabbard will do just as well. After all they are both reading the same script that Putin wrote for them.
The American people voted for Dems and Republicans who don't need leftists. The country never voted for any leftist. So don't expect left wing actions and never underestimate how much Americans love all wars. They voted for wars this year.
This guy is full of it. Russia has a well known habit of invading other Countries like but not limited to, Ukraine, Georgia 2008, Eastern Europe and Russia also annexed several states by force, including Crimea, Turkestan, Yakutia, Belarus, Alash Autonomy, Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the Emirate of Bukhara. Have him to explain all of these!!!
@QuizPulse57 you can't really be unfamiliar with the promise not to expand NATO and the US aggression, regime change etc in Ukraine. We stopped trying to influence our country in war long ago - it certainly belongs to a bellicose minority.
God bless you all, for tell the truth 🙏❤
This commentator says its all NATO's fault that Russia decided to attacked its neighbor, then why did Finland and Sweden join NATO and join very quickly ?
Simple. In geopolitical power-struggles between alliances, border states have two choices: 1)Joining a side, and having a reasonable expectation that any future conflict will be confined to the borders of their territory and that of the adversary. 2) Remaining neutral and having absolute certainty that a future conflict will be fought across the entirety of their territory. This certainty would have been pointed out clearly to the newly independent countries of Central / Eastern Europe by the original NATO countries when their membership of NATO was being solicited. It's what we call a 'Hobson's choice'- i.e.a choice made under duress. Finland and Sweden, being border states, are in exactly the same position.
Who sheIIed Donnbas since 2014?
He's a Putin stooge. Finland and Sweden changed their stance on NATO because they saw what Putin was doing. There are many flavors of imperialism. Sachs only opposes the US version.
excellent work, no wonder it's not on major media. Bravo!
Forget the "20 year period". Russians will never accept something like this. Never means never not something else in the middle with timetables.
The arrogance of some people thinking and assuming that others are that much naive and stupid always gets me.. And is even worse considering that is coming out of the mouths and minds of supposedly the high level politicians that we intrusted our future.
To change for the better one must acknowledge one's weaknesses. After World War II US have been creating enemies. Much of US resources are used to support regime change in other countries and invading countries. US made money selling weapons to countries around the World. Hence the war related industry grew at the expense of other industries. So much attention and finances were diverted to war mongering effort outside that local needs and developments are being neglected. Whereas in China the opposite happen. In the last 40 years their profits were put to good use to develop the infrastructure of the country. They focus more in developing self sufficiency. Hence they improved trade between countries and were able to support the various important industries and their achievements in a few decades surpassing all expectations. Meanwhile in the US inflation is shrinking the once middle class to poor. People cannot afford to buy US products. They welcome Chinese products which are cheaper.
So we don’t promote freedom anymore just whatever you want to is fine. History is an inconvenient thing.
This inconvenient has a secret behind it
The professor is knowledgable.
When two neighboring countries fight each other, just know the USA visited one.
Thank you so much for trying to get the truth out, so many people have been lied to and propagandized
Canuck here. I'm ashamed by the sheer stupidity of my "superior" brother who believes such slop
Proposal about Ukraine not joining NATO for 20 years just means 20 years for NATO to rearm Ukraine for next war. Same thing as Mints agreement in 2014 just to buy time to rearm Ukraine.
It will not fly the second time. Russia want a permanent solution in peace talk otherwise they can continue the fight. They are winning and EU army is nothing without Americans.
Не надейтесь что опять вам удастся всех перехитрить . Взять тайм аут на 20 лет и втихаря перевооружить Украину для реванша. Вам никто не даст шанса еще раз.
Americans are there too, with NATO.
It's not about any NATO, but about russian nazism and fascism towards ukrainians as a nation. Russia openly claims for genocide of ukrainians based on their identity. As for NATO, Finland and Sweden joined NATO and? Finland is closer to St.petersburg and Moscow than Ukraine. NATO was never a reason for anything in Ukraine. russia doesnt want Ukraine to be in NATO because NATO means protection.
God bless prof Jeffery Sach . Few good man like him . Nominate him for Nobel peace prize
Yes, one of the rare western intellectuals that deserves the non-corrupt Nobel Peace Prize.
This guy is full of it. Russia has a well known habit of invading other Countries like but not limited to, Ukraine, Georgia 2008, Eastern Europe and Russia also annexed several states by force, including Crimea, Turkestan, Yakutia, Belarus, Alash Autonomy, Armenia, Azerbaijan, and the Emirate of Bukhara. Have him to explain all of these!!!
@@QuizPulse57 - And all these invasions you mention took place on Putin's watch? And how many people have US military and proxies killed during the same time span, since 1999, including participating in a genocide?
@@QuizPulse57 USA also did that, for Europe don't tell me. The Professor speaks about what led to the present conflict. He does not go 1000 years in history. Learn to understand within the context.
NO, NO, NO... NO 😂"PISS PRIZE"😂 FOR JEFFREY SACHS.
Please DON'T SULLY Prof. Jeffery Sachs' GOOD NAME & HIGH INTELLECT With This BS PRIZE which was Also Awarded To Obama for Nothing.
😊
Cyrus with all my respect to you RUSSIA IT'S FIGHTING MORE THEN 35 COUNTRYS
You're absolutely right ,and also winning ! Furthermore I'd like to add they'll never accept a deal with a demillitarized zone whilst Ukraine maintains a military force and re-arms itself to fight another war in the future so good luck Donald 😂😂 this deal will not happen Russia had said as much.
Russia is fighting NATO...which is America, as America is in full control of Europe!!! Trouble is Europe is to blind to see the truth!!!
Head above water, Professor Jeffrey Sachs. He will always stand by the truth, no matter the pressure and gang up. My salute to him and few others.
This opinion piece seems to blame the U.S., ignoring the fact that Russia invaded Ukraine.
Mr Sachs should be on Trump's foreign affairs staff.
Most impressive and qualified person for the position.
Tsar Putin would probably allow his puppet to appoint him.
love your videos! (also first)
"I've always said that, keep the oil. We want to keep the oil, $45 million a month. Keep the oil. We've secured the oil."
~Donald Trump, comments about stealing Syria oil
Treachery and deception is much more than cheating it's downright evil
It’s also the true nature of the reality
Professor Sachs alwyas provides a level-headed perspective assessment of matters. He is, rightfully, highly respected.
I can see no reason why a single penny of US tax dollars should go towards an Israeli, a Ukrainian, a Taiwanese, a European, an Australian, a Japanese, a Filipino, a South Korean, etc. They should take care of themselves!
Ok roosky
@RyolithRandil ???????
The Taiwanese are not getting charity from the US. Let's be clear about that. The Tsai administration has paid a hefty sum of money to buy defense weapons from the US. The sudden affection for Taiwan stems from the precious semiconductors and microchips. How convenient! The entire setup of cozying up with Taiwan and the Philippines is to provoke China into a war.
Tony, all US aid has been spent in the US providing USJobs And US profits. Its the EU and for the most part Poland that pay money to the Ukraine so that the government can existence and the economy of the Ukraine doesn’t completely collapses. No US tsx money goes to Ukraine the tax dollars go tobthe heavy industries and shipping companies in the USA.
You realize America is fundamentally insolvent without exporters storing surplus dollars into US treasuries and financial assets? The US will absolutely crumble to bits when it goes all in on isolationism. We may be the second largest manufacturer on paper but we source so many components and raw materials from the outside world and those figures include things where we just put the finishing touch on an imported good and say made in America.
The only barrier to WW3 is Putin’s patience.
Tell USA, it is ok to be number 2.
Start thinking #3 or even lower. India will overtake the USA one day. Even Russia has greater manufacturing capability than the USA.
More likely 3 (after China)
🇺🇲#1 Always and Forever ✨️
@@larryc1616 It hasn’t been #1 since 2013 using PPP means.
Seriously, I don't minds 1 from the bottom
Jeffrey Sachs is a brilliant speaker. We are fortunate to hear him speak the truth,
Instead of arming Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan; US tax payer money should be spent on infrastructure, healthcare, education, homelessness etc.
US tax payer money stay in US boosting economi9cs. Ukraine doesnt get cash you id*ot. It's a cheap russian fake.
Taiwan is not a UN recognized country and it is always considered an internal civil war of the Chinese. US support by arming Taiwan is like supporting a rebel group within China, according to China point of view. Ukraine is just a proxy puppet of USA whereas Israel is the master of USA. 🤣
To say Ukraine will not join NATO for the next 20 years is not settling well with Russia. Russia will not agree to that proposition. Because it would mean the neocons just have to wait 20 years to execute their plans. Russia is still where it is 20 years from now.
Nope. Russia has 20 years to prove it can change and be peaceful and Ukraine won't need NATO then.
The problem with speaking truth to power is that it still just leaves you with the truth and them with the power." - Richard Wolf
That 800 mile buffer zone would be occupied by NATO troops. Plus, delaying Ukraine from joining NATO for 20 years is just giving them a chance to rebuild their military, with NATO's help. None of this will be acceptable.
Russia invaded Crimea because thy wanted a central port to the Black Sea. What part of Russia physically invading am I not understanding?
We have garbage leaders in the US
And a MacDonald chef.
All of the west not just US. The Western European leaders are all part of the swamp 🤮👿
Am glad im not the only one seeing it like Jeffrey
What about what the people of Ukraine wants they are the ones being oppressed
Mere collateral, I am afraid. The same happened in South Vietnam, but against the Chinese ....
You lost me at "the war began because Russia felt surrounded" or whatever. The truth is probably more simple and goes back to Euromaidan. It also draws parallels with the China-Taiwan situation (democratic neighbor on authoritarian's doorstep). Whatever you believe, tyranny cannot be allowed to prevail.
Correct.
Well the dictators are smart
I love Sachs simply because he advocate peace instead of conflict to resolve issues. He is spoke very eloquently, knowledgeable and wise. He's also very sincere in his pursuit of spreading peace.
Professor Sachs has to live in a building in Harkiv only for a week and he will change his perspective about the entire Solar system.
Ayup.
хохо, поэтому с русскими надо дружить, в не создавать из своей страны военный полигон для Нато )
пока к украинцам не пришли их новые лучшие "друзья", они жили в мире с русскими и с Россией.
Maybe singing "Our father is Bandera" can keep you warm? No?
When president Junukovich was replaced it was not about joining the NATO but about the association agreement with the EU.
Get rid of clown Zelensky. He is not funny anymore.
He soon will move into his expansive Villa in Miami, wife and kids already settled. Courtesy of US taxpayers. So I hear.
Don't know why but he continues to amuse me 😂
Money was laundered right before the world's eyes on the Ukrainian front lawn
If Russia wants to end an alleged Russia/US conflict, all they have to do is pull out of Ukraine. This video has hammer and sickle stamped all over it.
He was instrumental in Russia becoming what it is now. He was advisor to Yeltsyn/Gaydar goverment and prescribed a shock therapy as panaceum. They listened, because similar thing worked in Poland, maybe not without issues, but acceptable. Gaydar treated Sachs advise literally and switched the system to capitalism overnight in a country in which nobody, but a few individuals had any idea about normal business. It caused total chaos, poverty and extreme crime rate. Russians felt humiliated. They associate this period with democracy and Putin's era with recovery. Democracy is a dirty word in Russia. They blame the US for everything - traditionally.
You don't invade a sovereign country
Well, russia did and won.
THANK YOU!
There's nothing we don't know about American treachery
I have deep admiration for the Ukrainian people. It's heartbreaking that the greed and selfishness of a few, not Russia, are destroying this beautiful nation.
Look at the movie doc. (ASP footage) How Russians goal in Mariupol were civilians and their infants dying in the hospital close to the first line.There were no soldiers or army devices just mother's children and old people.
@@francine895 你能给我一个数据吗？ 俄罗斯军事行动期间发射多少炮弹 造成了多少乌克兰平民死亡？ 还有 如果你去看看乌克兰对平民的差别袭击以及中东发向发生的事情你会发现 俄罗斯从一开始就在避免平民的伤亡 当然战争难免会波及到平民
@@francine895 It was done before to Crimeans, sans hospital.
Professor Sachs has a great interview with Tucker Carlson. Since some of the responses in the Comments Section seem to be unaware of who he is, Sachs is the lead author in the study of the Origins of COVID 19 in the British Medical Journal Lancet. He does not shy away from the truth no matter how inconvenient or politically incorrect they are.
He has zero medical expertise and that article is BS, to be polite. And Tucker Carlson, as Fox "news" admitted, is an entertainer, not a journalist. Carlson is another Putin stooge.
A decaying empire's last gasp before total collapse.
I think that this man is not interviewing Prof' Sachs at all. I think that he is putting together a patchwork of Sachs interviews
A US promise that NATO won't enter Ukraine for 20 years is just as good as the US promise that NATO won't move 1 inch past the Berlin Wall.
It's like the Russian promise to Ukraine to respect their borders, independence, and refrain from use of force against them if Ukraine gave Russia all their nukes in 1994.
@@joebob-p3z That was before NATO conquered Ukraine in 2014. Now Russia is kicking NATO and their puppets out of Ukraine.
@@joebob-p3z I heard the 1990's agreement was based on NATO staying out of Ukraine. Or something like that...
Every time I see the Ukraine oblast flag, I think of IKEA. 😊
Actually that is the flag of Crimean's, why Ukraine is using that is beyond me.
Anyone who claims to know the TRUTH is highly suspicious...
Some people educate themselves with facts .. others with msm ~ Spot the difference 👨🎓📜~~ 🤪📰
Great video, Cyrus! Professor Sachs is so clear and has so much experience-I love to hear him speak. Fingers crossed for this one! I live in Britain (Scotland) and I agree with him that the UK government is totally irresponsible!
Pkease, also expain us why USA and its allyans do not want to understand gound reality of presend world. Thank you
Слишком много идеологии. Слишком много коррупции. Остальное доделал печатный станок.
It's because they continue to live in the post-Soviet Union dissolution era, where they viewed themselves victorious, no longer faced any opposition from an equal power and could do whatever they want. They fail to understand how much the world has changed since then.
@@СергейПетунин-о8щ US and it's allies are generally far less corrupted than most other countries in the world.
YOU HAVE TO MURDER HUMAN BEINGS IN ORDER TO STEAL THEIR RESOURCES
"People said to me, 'Why are you staying in Syria.' Because I kept the oil, which frankly we should have done in Iraq."
~Donald Trump, comments about stealing Syria oil
Zelensky didn't try to prevent the conflict through diplomacy because he lacks honor and integrity.
In 2014 there was a coup. Soon after, there was a massacre in Odessa (dozens of people were burned alive). Ethnic Russians living in Ukraine were treated as subhuman. Their language and culture was being oppressed. A civil war broke out due to the rise in ethnic tensions. For 8 years the Ukrainian military was indiscriminately shelling civilians living in Donbas.
If Zelensky honored the Minsk agreement and pledged neutrality, none of this would have happened. The 8 year civil war would have ended and Donbas would have remained part of Ukraine. War is the ultimate failure of diplomacy.
Zelensky, Poroshenko, Merkel and Hollande admitted that Ukraine had no intention to honor the Minsk agreements.
Who didn't want peace? Who advised against the 2022 peace talks in April? Hint: someone visited Zelensky in Kiev at that time
Russia's national security was compromised once NATO began to expand eastwards. Russia clearly stated that Ukraine joining NATO was a red line (November 2021) and unfortunately this concern was never taken seriously. The Russians openly stated: if nothing changes, we will be forced to act in order to defend our national security. Enhancing the national security of one country at the expense of another is unacceptable. The Russians have legitimate security concerns.
20th September, 2021: Ukraine launched military drills with US and NATO.
NATO is not a defensive alliance. NATO illegally bombed Yugoslavia (a direct violation of the U.N. Charter).
We should never forget what they did to Libya, Afghanistan, Iraq etc.
Who blew up the pipeline causing an environmental disaster?
Zelensky banned all opposition and arrested a leading priest.
Zelensky tried to invoke article 5 under false pretenses. Remember the incident in Poland.
Ethnic Russians living in Ukraine were treated as subhuman. Their language and culture was being oppressed.
Poroshenko said, “Our children will go to schools and kindergartens-theirs will hide in the basements”.
Russians will never forget the 2014 Odessa massacre. The whole world needs to know about it.
Why was Denis Kireev eliminated? He was a member of Ukraine's negotiating team during the peace negotiations. He wanted to help his country.
Ukraine has a hit list. They target artists, journalists and ordinary citizens. Hundreds of children are on this list. 13 year old Faina Savenkova was placed on this list.
Pink Floyd's Roger Waters is on this list. Jimmy Dore (American stand-up comedian, podcaster) and Aaron Maté (Canadian writer and journalist) are on this list.
There is evidence that Ukrainian troops have been indiscriminately shelling civilians in Donbas (they used petal mines and targeted areas where there was no military presence).
The azov troops trapped in the azovstal steelworks in Mariupol used human shields. They refused to allow civilians to leave despite of humanitarian corridors being present.
Russia held a proposed cease fire in order for the civilians to leave, but azov would not allow the civilians to leave.
Ukraine has committed many acts of terrorism (car bombs and other forms of assassination). Darya Dugina (journalist) R.I.P.
The first terrorist attack on the Kerch bridge killed the truck driver and the individuals in the adjacent car (innocent civilian victims).
The second terrorist attack on the Kerch bridge killed two parents and severely injured their young daughter.
I have done a lot of research and it took me a long time to write this comment. I have stated a lot of facts and I have given my honest opinion.
I have provided a brief summary of events that took place. In order to explain this whole situation in great detail, a book would need to be written.
Hopefully someone will write an UNBIASED book, stating facts and allowing the readers to form their own judgments. Everything I said can be fact checked and verified.
Jefrfrey Sach s does not care about Urkainian people or for that matter about of people of countries oppressed by Russia. Eastern Europian countries fled from Russia as soon as they could after the fall of soviet union.
NATO needs to be disbanded
And what of the Ukrainian people, are you going to deny them the freedoms you have?
they say US send 60 billion to Ukraine but only 10% of that was send not the full amount! still nothing to sneeze at but still not what was promised for support aid
I guess the Professor didn't say anything about North Korean troops fighting in Ukraine because there is nothing to talk about!
Professor Sachs makes sense, the Trump Admin should listen to him, the special op must end before it gets out of hand.
While I have great respect for Sachs work, I am somewhat disappointed in his analysis of this situation. Having visited Ukraine number of times, the Ukrainians have no love for Russian control and voted decisively in a democratic referendum to leave the Russian union. The 1994 Budapest Memorandum was signed by Ukraine, Russia, the United States, and the United Kingdom. Under it, Ukraine agreed to give up the nuclear weapons in return for security guarantees. Russia violated this agreement when it supported separatist movements in Ukraine's Donbas region and subsequently invaded Ukraine in 2014 and again in 2022. The UK and the US are protecting international law by living up to the 1994 agreement. NATO expansion was and continues to be the result of decisions by sovereign nations to seek security against the threat of future Russian aggression from which they suffered following WW2. Does anyone in the West really think that NATO is an aggressive pact and will invade Russia. Ukraine is not blameless with regard to its treatment of its Russian-speaking minorities and it would have been better served by a federal government that provided linguistic and cultural protection to its Russian-speaking regions. However, in this conflict it is not a US puppet state nor the aggressor.
对于西部对东部犯下的罪行 你就这样简单带过？🤣 乌克兰现政府就是美国傀儡 毋庸置疑
Read paragraph 5 of the Budapest Memorandum after the word "except"
The country had no right to act in concert with one guarantor against another guarantor.
In turn, Ukrainian President Yushchenko already in June 2008 asked the Secretary General for an action plan for joining NATO. He also proclaimed Bandera and Shukhevych as heroes of Ukraine. President Yanukovych cancelled these decrees. He was overthrown in 2014.
That's correct only for western pro-Bandera regions.
Those nukes weren't theirs to begin with, they were only on their territory, but they didn't have the codes and didn't have the means of maintaining them.
Would your country silently accept RU bases near its borders? I don't think so.
Why are we asking an ECONOMIST about military and diplomatic matters?????
He was there , face to face with Yeltzin, during the dissolution of the USSR by the Stalinist bureacratic ruling elites and the transformation from a command econmy to a market bases, aka oligarch based, capitalism economy.
I was there, lived through and followed those events, as they happened.
Tell it to Tibet and the Uighers
Another US lie.
A hard dose of reality that many of the western world refuse to accept.
Lets clarify matters here: this is indeed a conflict, between the US oligarchy and Russian oligarchy.
Hey, US MIC needs to make a living!
Americans are sick of Americas foreign policies.
"Will not join NATO in the next 20 years" !? It's no go for Russia, it wont accept such a weasel article.. 200 might be acceptable.
haha....200 might be. Good one.
Excellent analysis.
The analysis is accurate, well documented and persuasive.
Getting rid of the Ukraine problem, is vital to world stability.
Trump will forever be great if he does what he promised. Quickly.
一个国家拥有自由民主的体制是最理想的, 但这个国家能否在这样的民主体制环境继续进步和发展，是须要各种条件支撑，如人民对民主的了解程度、国家经济状况和地缘政治等等。 很多国家转型到民主的过程都是跌跌撞撞，最终国家陷入长期战乱。很可悲的是， 自韩战以来， 美国都为了自己的地缘政治利益，便借着打民主之名，对世界各国上下其手，制造民运推翻人家的政府，甚至有些是民选的政府， 这些被美国西方伸手搞的国家，有那一个是转型民主成功和国家真的走向政治和经济稳定的发展？ 几乎每个都是失败，最终弃它远之，使它们的人民陷入痛苦！ 阿富汗、利比亚、伊拉克和现在将被丢弃的乌克兰！ 自己国内问题一大堆都不能解决，还要去搞乱其他国家！
For profit.
American economist is wrong on all levels, intentionaly or not..
Great thinker.
Objective understanding of history and today's reality
This is by far the most valuable information that need to be shown on TVs worldwide.
Nothing could be farther from the truth. Russia has a history of aggression towards its neighbours. See Georgia 2008 and Crimea (that was just to beautiful and important not to annexe it). They also invested heavily in trying to influence the elections in the Republic of Moldova. The reality is that all the small nations which were once in the Soviet block want to be part of NATO to avoid further aggression from Russia, including my own country, Romania. These nations want to be independent, to decide their own future and they want democracy. They are ready to die for this. Ignoring all these facts and saying it's a war between the US and Russia is deliberately lying.
Ayup.
History of aggr? You spelled USlsraeI wrong.
Rand report from 2019 - Extending Russia
Spot on
As a European, this all seems too much like conspiracy talk to me.
US is decaying.