for u guys who keep demanding fx comeback in the comment section , can u just please leave a nice comment or appreciation first on how great lunber been doing here? better stream this bcs the mv,song is beautiful and to make sm giving fx comeback.
Love Amber and Luna together especially when they're producing quality like this. SM still holding off on that f(x) comeback, so Amber straight up directs this whole thing for us, could not be more grateful.
People need to realize that this is most likely a test of sorts, to see if F(x) has the staying power for a comeback at this time, especially given the crazy schedules of the other two members with Victoria and all of her promotions in China, as well as Krystal with all the acting and advertisement work she's been getting. Luna is of course popular for her vocals, and Amber with her alternative style and popularity with the international fan basis. So I feel like they potentially COULD comeback, but only if SM sees the financial potential for them to do so. I'm not particularly crazy about this song, but I support them because I would love to see a real F(x) comeback. It definitely seems possible, but only if they make the right milestones in the proper amount of time. It's known that plenty of groups will start to work on a comeback, only to be placed on the back-burner by companies if they don't feel their investment will be returned and then some.
...Amber didn't rap this time...LOVE IT!!! I'm so glad she chose to show us more of her singing voice! If y'all don't support LunBer and their fabulous voices, you're crazy!
She’s never been a full rapper. She sings as much as she raps, but most of the older singing was among all them. Sm realize many people like her singing, so they brought it out more.
When it comes to Luna, there is only one worthy singer to compare - this is BoA. Please listen carefully to both singers. You will find many similarities between them. I find only one difference. The difference is in advertising. More advertising and more popularity. Luna will become the next great singer of Korea! 💕
Yes truly 😭😭 she is worthy of becoming a superstar. But sm has her in its shackles. But its amazing to see her always cheerful and growing more and more. A human like her is rare to find❤️
The sad reality is that with her definitely being more modest and having a less sexualized image, that will never have mass appeal anymore with the current kpop stars that make it big. While few are exceptions to this rule, it really is a minority and most successful solo acts that are pushed heavy already have a strong backing or following... like Taeyeon from Girls Generation. Luna is one of my favorite singers - period. I always think of her as a successor to BoA in terms of voice. Her stage presence just puts her well beyond everyone else in kpop today.
SM have the greatest and talented artists in kpop industry, HOW CAN THEY MANAGE THEIR IDOLS SO BAD??? Little promotion, barely any variety shows, lost Henry and Amber. Recently Jonghyun and Sulli (RIP angels). They need to step up...
GUYS! Listen up. We all miss f(x), our girls deserve soooo much better. But let’s support their individual works, cause they have wishes and solo projects that want to make, don’t let them disappointed. Support “Lower”!!!
My favorite thing in this video that no one's talking about is the fact that you can see Amber's breath during the outdoor shots of her second verse parts - the fact that you can tell she was actually singing out loud while filming :')))
Its 2024, and I still would like to see this choreography better Cuz this song is iconic, and the little choreography that we can see is also iconic aaaaaa
Gheed Emad at least 2 of them are already well set and fine on their own.They don't need sm at all so I feel more for the other 2 becuse they didn't gain much as the other 2 and yet needs to prove themselves whic it sucks.Sm and some or say most fake MeUs/stans do not deserves them tbvh.
Luna shine like always, for me she is the best vocalist in SM and one of the best in K-pop, but she's so damn underrated, i'm not a MeU but i love the girls and i know they deserve more love and promotion.
You can tell luna's is the most powerful dancer in f(x). Her moves are so sharp, clean , powerful and enjoyable to watch. Her presence is so demanding when she dance tbh. I could watch her dance all day and i won't get bored. Amazing.
They are all amazing -- they have to be, to keep up with "Miss Flexible" Victoria. Even Sulli, possibly/technically the weakest, could still keep up (meaning of course, that she was as good or better than most others in the industry...for all the good it did her)
You're right. Go back through all the f(x) vids and her dancing is tight. But the part of her 'presence' that grabbed me and made her my bias is her smile. Go back thru their stuff, and look at her smiles in the vids. They all scream she's having a fucking blast and just make you *have* to smile yourself. It's Luna's smile that made her my bias. Her amazing voice and sharp dancing was just icing on the cake.
She sang on all the tracks of their last album (and did the rap parts of course) and she released a few covers on her YT channel. It's not that rare, but it sure is beautiful ;)
Amber did great job directing this movie. Somehow I feel like she's showing her own 'colour' little by little. I can see it by the videos that she made.
Amber has such a beautiful voice and its so underrated also i didn’t know my girl could dance like that im so in love. Also this song is a whole masterpiece thanks.
HELLO THIS IS 2024 HERE.. ANYWAYS, HAPPY 15TH ANNIVERSARRY FOR F(X), THANK YOU SM FOR BRING THIS GROUP TO REALITY SO I CAN SUPPORT THEM UNTIL NOW NO MATTER WHAT!
How can Amber be so cool like guy cool and sexy graceful in the same video??? Luna and Amber's song is a mix and match of masculine suave and feminine sensuality. Their voices, choreo, and even the simple yet with subtle depth MV completes it! Love from a Petal and ELF
I remember I used to listen a lot to this song back in 2018. It was definitely one of the best songs of the year and I can’t believe it didn’t chart very high. It has one of the best beats and it can easily become a globally famous song. I don’t understand why people slept on it.
Patience SM still has to wait for Vic to finish some stuff in China but Luna & their producer already confirmed it & said it will happen in the 1st half of this year
King Aesthetic if you let lunber flop do you really think sm will give f(x) a comeback? you know what keep sleeping lunber and then complain about sm not doing anything for the members i am completely speechless this fandom will cause f(x) downfall i swear
bling bling is jonghyun what are you talking about lmao y’all #dramatic 💀 asking for a comeback isn’t gonna make them flop, if it’s anything it’s telling them we want more of them lol and people are still supporting them so what’s wrong with letting the company know we want to see them as a group again lol
WOW. This is really good. Amber and Luna should have a subunit because they just complement each other's voices. It's been too long for an f(x) comeback and I am honestly loosing hope about it but even with only 2 members, I still want them to continue making music. I'm glad the two of them who were underrated and weren't as popular than the other two before are now being recognized. Amber's voice is smooth like butter.
HOW CAN AMBER BE SO CUTE AND HANDSOME AND PRETTY AT THE SAME TIME. LUNA SLAYED ME WITH HER BEAUTY AND DANCING. her body is goals in this mv she looks so healthy and stunning :O AHHH
이노래나왔을때 정말 많이들었고 에셈의 선곡 진짜 세련됐다고 감탄했었는데. 진짜 안타까운건 이것도 그렇고 wow thing도 그렇고, 그룹의 정식 싱글이 아니라 이렇게 유닛곡이나 콜라보곡으로 한두곡씩 나오는 곡 중에 진짜 개 명곡들이 많은데. 그때 화제성으로 잠깐 반짝 인기 얻다가 시간이 지나면 진짜 기억속에서 완전히잊혀져서 다시 재생하는 기회조차도 받지 못하는거같음. 에프엑스도 그렇고 레드벨벳도 그렇고 진짜 얘네 앨범 지금까지도 엄청 많이 듣는데 이렇게 개개인 멤버별 유닛곡 같은건 있는지도 까먹어서 듣지도 못함. 그룹 멤버 이름 굳이 검색해서 들을 기회도 없고. 진짜 명곡이 일회성 음악처럼 버려지는게 정말 안타깝고 이런건 사소한 기획의 문제라고 생각하는게. 루나 앰버의 lower가 아니라 그냥 차라리 에프엑스의 lower로 내보내는게 맞았다고 생각함..... 이런건 진짜 그냥 그룹내 팬들만 듣고 일반인들한텐 아예 접근조차도 못하는 싱글임. 그냥 이런 싱글들 전부 모아서 정규앨범이나 미니앨범에 그냥 수록곡으로 넣어주세요. 사소한 차이이지만 솔직히 팬도 이러는데 일반 대중들은 개인 멤버 유닛활동에 전혀 관심이 없을 뿐만 아니라 멤버이름은 알지도 못해요. 이런노래가 있는지도 모르는애들이 태반... 와 진짜 이노래 있는것도 완전 잊고있었음. 기획사가 솔직히 그룹명으로 인지도를 쌓아서 사람들은 그룹명밖에 모르는데 개개인 멤버 인지도는 완전 바닥이라 이런건 그냥 팬들만 찾아 들으라는 뜻이고. 너무 기획낭비임. 지드래곤 처럼 개인멤버로서도 스타성이 화려한 애라면 모를까 진짜 가성비 안맞는 기획인거같음. 에셈은 제작은 잘해놓고 기획떄문에 손해보는게 너무 많은거같음.
Amber said the night of filming, it was below zero. During Luna’s filming, it got even colder with wind. Luna was wearing less costume than Amber. We love these girls’ dedication!!!!
tangnee I could only see it when I watched her mouth form the word ‘lower’ and you see her lips are very pouted because she’s cold, but I only saw it because she had the same thing happening while filming a drama a few years back. Otherwise I wouldn’t have noticed
Parkmiyoung Yes, these girls are so professional that we can't tell how cold it was. Amber said it was very cold and and was in awe of Luna. Luna was wearing like a red "shirt." We know they are talented, but their professionalism set them apart for the success they have had.
Every time I watch this again and still can't take my eye off Luna. Seriously this girl is a born performer. Her expressions and stares, the way she dance and her smile u can feel she's really into this into this. Imo she suited the vibes and this concept the best. I wonder how it will turn out if she did it alone. Amber did great too sometimes i love her voice more than Luna but I've noticed after multiple watch as if she wasn't much into it the same as luna or not comfortable perhaps cold idk but overall she gives different vibes but still she did ok. And let's not ignore the hight difference between these 2. It's so cute. I wish to hear more of them. They are my favourite.
Everyone saying "F(x) comeback" better be streaming this song. SM is testing to see if y'all can finally support f(x) members especially amber & Luna who despite being talented are the least supported members in the group. If SM sees y'all don't care for them then they won't bother with them and you know what that means. They'll retire f(x). So stop complaining bout f(x) for a minute & be grateful amber & Luna came back.
PLZ listen up Meus!!! use a RUclips account while doing these steps: 1)search the video on RUclips then click on it. 2)watch it with with high quality (480p +) AND higher the volume. 3)NEVER click on repeat after the end of the video. but DELETE it from ur story and repeat the steps above. ps don't forget to like and comment and u can obviously use deferent accounts it would really help! keep streaming and watching guys!! they absolutely need the support for their hard work and for new releases soon!!
Okay but can we talk about how SMOOTH AND ON POINT AMBER'S DANCING IS AAAAAAAAAAAAAH. And all of Luna's remind me of her solo stage @ one of the SMTown's (I think?) where she had her blue hair from Red Light Era!!! AAAAAAH I LOVE THIS
I accidentally found this, and had no idea this was coming out, and let me tell you, for the first time in a long time I felt the joy I used to feel finding a new k-pop gem on YT. I was randomly watching Amber videos and this popped up and I suddenly realized it was new. I'm an old-head K-pop fan since like 2007, and f(x) was my jam, and finding this new song, which is a BOP, is dope!
This was literal perfection. If this isn’t proof enough to SM that F(x) deserves a comeback then idk what will convince them. Amber,Luna,Victoria and Krystal are so talented and deserve a company that believes in them. I don’t understand why SM treats them the way they do. I’d do almost anything for an F(x) comeback. I miss them so much. As a proud MeU I say F(X) FOREVER!!!!!!💜💜💜
Even though i stan Amber, i can never deny Luna's attractiveness as a performer. She's born to be on stage Btw do you feel there's always something special about Amber's MV? Like, i cam recognize her direction immediately. The edit is just too Amber-ish. Lol
![[STATION] f(x) 에프엑스 'All Mine' MV](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Z0S3knWIdrY/mqdefault.jpg)
I actually teared up a little. I miss Fx so much its not even funny
Me too😢
Can you believe luna and amber single handedly saved 2018
Coumba Diagne but 2018 just got started?
how could you be surprised, though?
for u guys who keep demanding fx comeback in the comment section , can u just please leave a nice comment or appreciation first on how great lunber been doing here? better stream this bcs the mv,song is beautiful and to make sm giving fx comeback.
J Hsn. I
It's high time SM brings back f(x) for a comeback.
well
@@wan4327 yeah ..... Amber's gone.
...sorry but its imposibble right now (sorry for my bad english)
Its not possible anymore 😢
it's impossible... even they were still under SM they only came back as SM station project only.. it was so sad
Love Amber and Luna together especially when they're producing quality like this. SM still holding off on that f(x) comeback, so Amber straight up directs this whole thing for us, could not be more grateful.
Well SM gave them station song (fx members almost get the most station songs!) and they let Amber to direct MV. SM.
People need to realize that this is most likely a test of sorts, to see if F(x) has the staying power for a comeback at this time, especially given the crazy schedules of the other two members with Victoria and all of her promotions in China, as well as Krystal with all the acting and advertisement work she's been getting. Luna is of course popular for her vocals, and Amber with her alternative style and popularity with the international fan basis. So I feel like they potentially COULD comeback, but only if SM sees the financial potential for them to do so. I'm not particularly crazy about this song, but I support them because I would love to see a real F(x) comeback. It definitely seems possible, but only if they make the right milestones in the proper amount of time. It's known that plenty of groups will start to work on a comeback, only to be placed on the back-burner by companies if they don't feel their investment will be returned and then some.
trogdorthe8th preach
true so i hope you guys can support them to the fullest, try to stream here and on digital charts too~ fighting~
trogdorthe8th I think they mostly Want as a group me too .. but I'm here supporting them
Well said
Luna and Amber saved 2018 before anyone else could.
And when no one else would.
Rhiannon Edwards yeaaahhh
Crush saved it too
Yahhh
Yes they did, preach sista
3 years after im still listening to this song every single day
It's timeless
It was psted 2 yrs ago😆
Do u still listen to this everyday?
Same!!
u're a legend
CAN'T BELIEVE AMBER AND LUNA ALREADY SAVED 2018
Yess and right now I'm very very very kiss them and f(x) comeback this year 2019 : (
...Amber didn't rap this time...LOVE IT!!! I'm so glad she chose to show us more of her singing voice! If y'all don't support LunBer and their fabulous voices, you're crazy!
She’s never been a full rapper. She sings as much as she raps, but most of the older singing was among all them. Sm realize many people like her singing, so they brought it out more.
This really sounds like something worth of playing at fashion shows' runways. Love it.
I’m so mad that I only just discovered this song. SM did f(x) dirty. They were so unique in their lineup and deserved more promotions.
Luna is one of the most criminally underrated Kpop stars out there
When it comes to Luna, there is only one worthy singer to compare - this is BoA. Please listen carefully to both singers. You will find many similarities between them. I find only one difference. The difference is in advertising.
More advertising and more popularity. Luna will become the next great singer of Korea! 💕
Yes truly 😭😭 she is worthy of becoming a superstar. But sm has her in its shackles. But its amazing to see her always cheerful and growing more and more. A human like her is rare to find❤️
Remember BoA is signed to SM, as well. It's not so much "shackles" as it is "favoritism". All of f(x) are pretty much an afterthought to SM.
The sad reality is that with her definitely being more modest and having a less sexualized image, that will never have mass appeal anymore with the current kpop stars that make it big. While few are exceptions to this rule, it really is a minority and most successful solo acts that are pushed heavy already have a strong backing or following... like Taeyeon from Girls Generation. Luna is one of my favorite singers - period. I always think of her as a successor to BoA in terms of voice. Her stage presence just puts her well beyond everyone else in kpop today.
Same with Amber
Can we give Amber an award for being the most beautiful k-idol? Like, please. She deserves it.
Jimgenius agreed
Jimgenius And Handsome
Jimgenius sure let's give her the award of most beautiful and most handsome
amber's singing gives me life
SarcasticWellSuga Nice comment!
SarcasticWellSuga Amber dancing gives me Life
there's more on her channel Amber Liu (wtp)! Check out Rogue Rouge, the songs are lovely + there are amazing mvs that come with each one
SM have the greatest and talented artists in kpop industry, HOW CAN THEY MANAGE THEIR IDOLS SO BAD??? Little promotion, barely any variety shows, lost Henry and Amber. Recently Jonghyun and Sulli (RIP angels). They need to step up...
*This is the definition of perfection. Enough said*
Wow I keep seeing you everywhere lol! Nice profile name!
ur username lol
You are everywhere, but i always like your comments 😁
LilPistachio I guess we're just everywhere as well
luhan's nipples your name tho #LUHANFOREVER
Amber and Luna's gorgeous vocals together? Yes please.
Amber and Luna sound so good together
Exo Forever they should be a couple💕🌚
Carla Chiapino More be like duet when they sing a song :)
BTS FAMILY
I gave u a thumbs up.
Dalia Tello thank you :)
BTS FAMILY thx u to and your welcome
I am dalia tello but changed it to bts forever
2023년에 다시 봐도 여전히 멋져요.
This is the bop of the new year glad to see amber and Luna again
Luna is such a freakin boss, man. She's the best!
and amber.
I agree ^.^
We love a powerful woman Luna!!!
airbear320 can we get this to 5 million? 💕
Luna IS the best!
GUYS! Listen up. We all miss f(x), our girls deserve soooo much better. But let’s support their individual works, cause they have wishes and solo projects that want to make, don’t let them disappointed. Support “Lower”!!!
Lower 진짜 명곡...엠룬도 정식 유닛 나왔으면 더 대박이었을 것 같은데 아쉽다ㅠㅠ그래도 언니들 사랑해 멍청이스엠
Luna is looking gorgeous, and Amber is so cool as usual.
Much love for f(x). Hoping for their grup comeback soon.
Thanks for this beautiful wish😍
My favorite thing in this video that no one's talking about is the fact that you can see Amber's breath during the outdoor shots of her second verse parts - the fact that you can tell she was actually singing out loud while filming :')))
Alex Zak You breathe out while lip syncing too 😂
She could have been whispering and that would still involve breathing haha
yeah and the fact it was the only shot that you could see her breathing
you might me correct but let her be 😂💜
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN MISS AMBER AND MISS LUNA STARTING THE YEAR WITH A BANGER!!!!
Its 2024, and I still would like to see this choreography better
Cuz this song is iconic, and the little choreography that we can see is also iconic aaaaaa
this is the subgroup we deserve
Totes agree
It's rumoured that there will be an official f(Amber+Luna) subunit debut in April. I really hope it's true
+hey ya and I hope soo! They are perfect combination 😍
W h y doesn't sm promote these two members more. They can sing, can dance, great on variety shows they deserve better. All of fx deserved better
Ruby Wang their solo activates has no big impact due to the lack of fandom support and lack of recognition/intrsts by puplic so they keep them low.
Ruby Wang All of f(x) deserve more💜 but sm don’t deserve them💔
Gheed Emad at least 2 of them are already well set and fine on their own.They don't need sm at all so I feel more for the other 2 becuse they didn't gain much as the other 2 and yet needs to prove themselves whic it sucks.Sm and some or say most fake MeUs/stans do not deserves them tbvh.
if krystal & victoria decided to join in they would
chels yo if they were the only 2 doing this u wouldn't see " we want f(x)", "why only krystal and victoria" 😪
AS A MEU I HAVEN'T SCREAMED THIS MUCH IN TWO YEARS
Rhiannon Edwards it's been two years, our screams have gotten louder 😂💜
hottestgotmeu IKR AHAHAHAH
i feel yah! lmfao!
Same ❤️❤️
SAME
Luna shine like always, for me she is the best vocalist in SM and one of the best in K-pop, but she's so damn underrated, i'm not a MeU but i love the girls and i know they deserve more love and promotion.
Ughh the fact that Amber directed and edited this MV...
HeyItsReality for real?! Daamnn.. the MV is amazing.. 😍😍😍
HeyItsReality what I didn't know that
You can tell luna's is the most powerful dancer in f(x). Her moves are so sharp, clean , powerful and enjoyable to watch. Her presence is so demanding when she dance tbh. I could watch her dance all day and i won't get bored. Amazing.
선영이 _ I agree with you! Our Lulu is amazing 💜💜💜
Ramsha N she is 💜 i hope she gets better recognition and more offers after this.
WHAT?!
They are all amazing -- they have to be, to keep up with "Miss Flexible" Victoria. Even Sulli, possibly/technically the weakest, could still keep up (meaning of course, that she was as good or better than most others in the industry...for all the good it did her)
You're right. Go back through all the f(x) vids and her dancing is tight. But the part of her 'presence' that grabbed me and made her my bias is her smile. Go back thru their stuff, and look at her smiles in the vids. They all scream she's having a fucking blast and just make you *have* to smile yourself. It's Luna's smile that made her my bias. Her amazing voice and sharp dancing was just icing on the cake.
Amber singing is a rare and beautiful thing
She sang on all the tracks of their last album (and did the rap parts of course) and she released a few covers on her YT channel. It's not that rare, but it sure is beautiful ;)
This song is so underrated! One of the best songs in kpop for me. And I miss f(x) 😭
i couldn´t stop thinking about BoA everytime i saw Luna, she is so talented, one of the most talented idols in the whole industry.
H&M would play this bop 24/7
your fave mole on taehyung's face TBSH LMAO
Amber did great job directing this movie. Somehow I feel like she's showing her own 'colour' little by little. I can see it by the videos that she made.
4 years has passed since this song come out and I’m still begging to SM make this duo official
I hope Lunber eventually make an album b/c their collabs are always bops. On a side note, they both look great, and I love the choreo. 😍
Vocals on point, video on point, outfit on point, dancing on point, personality on point.
So I played this at work today and saw my boss bopping along to it....nobody can deny true talent when they hear it 😂
Ben Drury where do you work ?!
Bryan Gonzalez he doesn't
where are my 2020 and beyond people watching this?
hello! welcome or welcome back to this masterpiece.
AMBER💕
Amber has that kinda androgynous beauty that basically anyone has the capability of being attracted too regardless of sexual orientation.
And Luna is second ONLY to BoA when it comes to serving EVER-Y-THING and making it look easy.
Amber has such a beautiful voice and its so underrated also i didn’t know my girl could dance like that im so in love. Also this song is a whole masterpiece thanks.
Yess agree
HELLO THIS IS 2024 HERE.. ANYWAYS, HAPPY 15TH ANNIVERSARRY FOR F(X), THANK YOU SM FOR BRING THIS GROUP TO REALITY SO I CAN SUPPORT THEM UNTIL NOW NO MATTER WHAT!
That moment when they aren't a sub-unit, but they are more active than half of the sub-units out there
KingSeonbae isnt sm planning on making them a subunit?
Is SM actually planning on anything when it comes to f(x)??
Sadly, not much.
Kosui Hydrogen This sad truth hurts ToT I need my Luna to comeback with the rest of f(x) TwT
They area sub-unit kinda?
Amber taking the male part in her dance with Luna like a boss
Rhiannon Edwards YAS 😍😍
Can I give you a like without messing with your perfect number of likes? You understand me😂😂😂
She is a boss
Rhiannon Edwards I do believe you mean - dancing with a friend . She's not taking a male part. Girls partner like this all the time so danf
She's taking the male part cause Luna is more feminine . And yas she's a boss she's a motha goddess
How can Amber be so cool like guy cool and sexy graceful in the same video??? Luna and Amber's song is a mix and match of masculine suave and feminine sensuality. Their voices, choreo, and even the simple yet with subtle depth MV completes it! Love from a Petal and ELF
I remember I used to listen a lot to this song back in 2018. It was definitely one of the best songs of the year and I can’t believe it didn’t chart very high. It has one of the best beats and it can easily become a globally famous song. I don’t understand why people slept on it.
SM, please give whole f(x) a comeback, don’t you see their talent? Their talent will be wasted if there isn’t a comeback soon.
Hwa 민 Victoria is still stuck in China 😞
Patience SM still has to wait for Vic to finish some stuff in China but Luna & their producer already confirmed it & said it will happen in the 1st half of this year
Omg I didn’t know about the news that they already plan to comeback this year omg thanks so much for telling me
i absolutely love how amber takes the masculine part in the dancing scenes. i love amber and luna ❤️❤️ such queens!
AMBER'S SINGING VOICE IS SO SOFT AND SMOOTH I CAN'T BELIEVE I'M BLESSED TO LIVE IN THIS CENTURY TO BE ABLE TO WITNESS THIS KIND OF EARGASM
이 노래는 정말 전설이다... 오늘도 보러 왔다...ㅜㅜ
damn amber. got me shook at the end
Anti-Social Ikr I legit was hyped @ the end of the song😍😷
stop asking for f(x) comeback and support lunber first they worked so hard for this
bling bling is jonghyun we only want a fx so we can support them even more
bling bling is jonghyun your name :(
King Aesthetic if you let lunber flop do you really think sm will give f(x) a comeback? you know what keep sleeping lunber and then complain about sm not doing anything for the members i am completely speechless this fandom will cause f(x) downfall i swear
Erik-chan yeah my name is cool thankyou
bling bling is jonghyun what are you talking about lmao y’all #dramatic 💀 asking for a comeback isn’t gonna make them flop, if it’s anything it’s telling them we want more of them lol and people are still supporting them so what’s wrong with letting the company know we want to see them as a group again lol
WOW. This is really good. Amber and Luna should have a subunit because they just complement each other's voices. It's been too long for an f(x) comeback and I am honestly loosing hope about it but even with only 2 members, I still want them to continue making music. I'm glad the two of them who were underrated and weren't as popular than the other two before are now being recognized. Amber's voice is smooth like butter.
Ezee Flores I agree👏
Sir Jøønie Don't we, right? Let's hope for an f(x) comeback.
또 들으러 와버림
Welcome back, ladies.
Raidanzoup
HOW CAN AMBER BE SO CUTE AND HANDSOME AND PRETTY AT THE SAME TIME.
LUNA SLAYED ME WITH HER BEAUTY AND DANCING. her body is goals in this mv she looks so healthy and stunning :O
AHHH
Amber’s voice is so beautiful
MinistressForMagic OMG same her voice is amazing😍
MinistressForMagic sameeeee
same
luna too
이노래나왔을때 정말 많이들었고 에셈의 선곡 진짜 세련됐다고 감탄했었는데.
진짜 안타까운건 이것도 그렇고 wow thing도 그렇고, 그룹의 정식 싱글이 아니라 이렇게 유닛곡이나 콜라보곡으로 한두곡씩 나오는 곡 중에 진짜 개 명곡들이 많은데.
그때 화제성으로 잠깐 반짝 인기 얻다가 시간이 지나면 진짜 기억속에서 완전히잊혀져서 다시 재생하는 기회조차도 받지 못하는거같음.
에프엑스도 그렇고 레드벨벳도 그렇고 진짜 얘네 앨범 지금까지도 엄청 많이 듣는데 이렇게 개개인 멤버별 유닛곡 같은건 있는지도 까먹어서 듣지도 못함.
그룹 멤버 이름 굳이 검색해서 들을 기회도 없고. 진짜 명곡이 일회성 음악처럼 버려지는게 정말 안타깝고 이런건 사소한 기획의 문제라고 생각하는게.
루나 앰버의 lower가 아니라 그냥 차라리 에프엑스의 lower로 내보내는게 맞았다고 생각함..... 이런건 진짜 그냥 그룹내 팬들만 듣고 일반인들한텐 아예 접근조차도 못하는 싱글임.
그냥 이런 싱글들 전부 모아서 정규앨범이나 미니앨범에 그냥 수록곡으로 넣어주세요.
사소한 차이이지만 솔직히 팬도 이러는데 일반 대중들은 개인 멤버 유닛활동에 전혀 관심이 없을 뿐만 아니라 멤버이름은 알지도 못해요. 이런노래가 있는지도 모르는애들이 태반...
와 진짜 이노래 있는것도 완전 잊고있었음.
기획사가 솔직히 그룹명으로 인지도를 쌓아서 사람들은 그룹명밖에 모르는데 개개인 멤버 인지도는 완전 바닥이라 이런건 그냥 팬들만 찾아 들으라는 뜻이고. 너무 기획낭비임.
지드래곤 처럼 개인멤버로서도 스타성이 화려한 애라면 모를까 진짜 가성비 안맞는 기획인거같음. 에셈은 제작은 잘해놓고 기획떄문에 손해보는게 너무 많은거같음.
This song deserves to be heard. It should be played at every radio !!
its trending. this is how much the fans miss f(x)
Amber said the night of filming, it was below zero. During Luna’s filming, it got even colder with wind. Luna was wearing less costume than Amber. We love these girls’ dedication!!!!
tangnee I could only see it when I watched her mouth form the word ‘lower’ and you see her lips are very pouted because she’s cold, but I only saw it because she had the same thing happening while filming a drama a few years back. Otherwise I wouldn’t have noticed
Parkmiyoung Yes, these girls are so professional that we can't tell how cold it was. Amber said it was very cold and and was in awe of Luna. Luna was wearing like a red "shirt." We know they are talented, but their professionalism set them apart for the success they have had.
4 walls, free somebody, all mine and lower.
These songs are just so cool!
I agree with u!!
Every time I watch this again and still can't take my eye off Luna. Seriously this girl is a born performer. Her expressions and stares, the way she dance and her smile u can feel she's really into this into this. Imo she suited the vibes and this concept the best. I wonder how it will turn out if she did it alone. Amber did great too sometimes i love her voice more than Luna but I've noticed after multiple watch as if she wasn't much into it the same as luna or not comfortable perhaps cold idk but overall she gives different vibes but still she did ok. And let's not ignore the hight difference between these 2. It's so cute. I wish to hear more of them. They are my favourite.
I'm so proud of Amber, she directed and edited the MV. Slay my queens! ❤
Pickles Noona Really?? And when I think she can't be more talented she comes and proves me she can 👏👏👏
Everyone saying "F(x) comeback" better be streaming this song. SM is testing to see if y'all can finally support f(x) members especially amber & Luna who despite being talented are the least supported members in the group. If SM sees y'all don't care for them then they won't bother with them and you know what that means. They'll retire f(x). So stop complaining bout f(x) for a minute & be grateful amber & Luna came back.
Shawol Get_It preach
Preach it
I think Victoria is much less known than Amber, but yeah...you're basically right about that testing.
Luna looks so pretty
This is perfect .. Amber and Luna our Queens .. we are waiting for FX comeback
THEY SNAPPED
carolina can we get this to 5 million? 💕
PLZ listen up Meus!!!
use a RUclips account while doing these steps:
1)search the video on RUclips then click on it.
2)watch it with with high quality (480p +) AND higher the volume.
3)NEVER click on repeat after the end of the video. but DELETE it from ur story and repeat the steps above.
ps don't forget to like and comment
and u can obviously use deferent accounts it would really help!
keep streaming and watching guys!! they absolutely need the support for their hard work and for new releases soon!!
They snapped, crackled, and popped.
*Shistar snapped*
Okay but can we talk about how SMOOTH AND ON POINT AMBER'S DANCING IS AAAAAAAAAAAAAH. And all of Luna's remind me of her solo stage @ one of the SMTown's (I think?) where she had her blue hair from Red Light Era!!! AAAAAAH I LOVE THIS
I would love to see just a pure dance video of this. The dance looks awesome!
Luna & Amber eran un gran dúo
Una combinación maravillosa en visual y canto.
Ojalá colaboren juntas ahora que ambas ya salieron de la SM
YOU KNOW THE THIRST FOR FX IS REAL WHEN IT'S TRENDING
I hope this is SM's way of letting us know f(x) will have a comeback this year!
Ramon Evans IKR!!!
Never :/
I think we got our answer...
well
wow Luna looks so good in the dance part!!
their voices are just beautiful and fit together so well, like their personalities
I accidentally found this, and had no idea this was coming out, and let me tell you, for the first time in a long time I felt the joy I used to feel finding a new k-pop gem on YT. I was randomly watching Amber videos and this popped up and I suddenly realized it was new. I'm an old-head K-pop fan since like 2007, and f(x) was my jam, and finding this new song, which is a BOP, is dope!
SAME HERE...literally been a kpop fan since 07 and like I lost that feeling but, right now as I’m going down memory lane I’m remembering the feeling
i agree. A lot of newer kpop songs have been just.... not giving me that
NOW ALL I NEED IS A F(X) COMEBACK TYVM FOR THIS MASTERPIECE
Snakeketchup SAMEEE
I was waiting for Amber's dance solo
AND IT FUCKING CAME!
I am happy now
cuz her dancing skills...
I miss my girls a lot. They deserve better.
OMG F(X) is alive
TY21 ENTERTAINMENT I’M ALIVE TOO
Or at least 2 of them
Keep streaming guys! Maybe we'll get whole f(x) together
I was thinking the same thing when I got the notice and clicked on it. =)
lower just hit #1 in brazilian itunes (kpop) yesterday and i was so proud our girls deserve all the love
Really OMG that's awesome. Here in Argentina no one cares about kpop :/
seventeen trash really??? 😭😭😭
Wooooow f(x) vem pro Brasil!! Aqui tem MeU!
hey f(x) if you're reading this cOME TO BRAZIL THANKS
Eu to sentindo falta dos brasileiros fazendo “spam” nos comentários em português 😂
Ah these two. Talent, beautiful. I love everything about it
Luna is so hot to a western standard, I'd say.
She is perfect! A petite girl with powerful voice.
SM wtf are you doing why hasn’t this been an official duo yet??? man this is beautiful! I miss F(x)! I miss all of them.
This was literal perfection. If this isn’t proof enough to SM that F(x) deserves a comeback then idk what will convince them. Amber,Luna,Victoria and Krystal are so talented and deserve a company that believes in them. I don’t understand why SM treats them the way they do. I’d do almost anything for an F(x) comeback. I miss them so much. As a proud MeU I say F(X) FOREVER!!!!!!💜💜💜
Amber! I missed ya honey
Here in 2023 because im still obsessing over Amber and Luna 😂
2018 IS SAVED
mochiwings That’s right 😍😍😍👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻😉😉
Even though i stan Amber, i can never deny Luna's attractiveness as a performer. She's born to be on stage
Btw do you feel there's always something special about Amber's MV? Like, i cam recognize her direction immediately. The edit is just too Amber-ish. Lol
GUYS DONT FORGET TO BUY THE SONG ON ITUNES!!!!!! LETS SHOW SM THAT LUNBER IS WORTH INVESTING IN
Samrawit Sisay omg lunber 😂😂😂😂
Everytime I watch this I wish I could like it more than once
Amber is really hot
She really is
ikr, he's so handsome.
handsgotnolemons she's a girl
Amber is amazing:)
handsgotnolemons Amber is a girl btw
BoA is crying like a proud mother but low-key shaking
AMBER IS AMAZING
AHHH I miss these gurls! 🥲🙌🏾 and yes I’m still listening it to in 2023 💜💜💜💜💜