[Special] 서툰 이별을 하려해 (Cover by 문별)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 окт 2024
  • [Special] 서툰 이별을 하려해 (Cover by 문별)
    편곡 - 코코두부아빠
    영상 - 강수영
    Instagram: bit.ly/2TrQPJD
    Facebook: bit.ly/2OYoA1W
    Twitter: bit.ly/2TuKNbo
    About MAMAMOO.
    MAMAMOO(마마무) OFFICIAL CHANNEL
    #MAMAMOO #MOONBYUL #서툰이별을하려해
    MAMAMOO.
    SUBSCRIBE: bit.ly/2PFdfsI
    / mamamoo_official
    Don't forget to subscribe, like and leave a comment.

Комментарии • 7 тыс.

  • @j-hooooope8628
    @j-hooooope8628 4 года назад +3492

    It’s more like “moonbyul making me forget that she is a rapper for 4 minutes straight "

    • @jisooturtlerabbitkim3013
      @jisooturtlerabbitkim3013 4 года назад +202

      moonbyul making me gay over and over again for four minutes gay

    • @laurelfisher5932
      @laurelfisher5932 4 года назад +150

      she was originally a vocalist who learned rapping because otherwise they wouldnt let her be in mamamoo :) put some respect on her name and her hard work, shes ALWAYS been a vocalist as well as a rapper

    • @cam_nu681
      @cam_nu681 4 года назад +15

      @@laurelfisher5932 exactly ♡

    • @laurelfisher5932
      @laurelfisher5932 4 года назад +42

      @@nathanvitha If youre trying to say solar encouraged her after she started rap training, you're right. But mamamoo had 3 vocalists already and so moonbyul was given the option of becoming a rapper. It was a business decision, not some dream on the whim of someone's encouragement. Solar and Moonbyul didnt know each other before mamamoo

    • @Awakening_Sunshine
      @Awakening_Sunshine 4 года назад +18

      Laurel McHeck didn’t they know each other as trainees when Moonbyul was still training to be a vocalist? But then RBW thought the other three would outshine her vocally so they made her a rapper?

  • @yolandamoreirarodriguez1505
    @yolandamoreirarodriguez1505 4 года назад +643

    Mamamoo👑🎶🌈💜:
    4 Vocals
    4 Rappers
    4 Dancers
    4 Beagles

  • @actuallyexomemberxiuminunn8928
    @actuallyexomemberxiuminunn8928 4 года назад +826

    Karen: No rapper can sing well
    Moonbyul: Hold my beer

    • @deitypersephone1838
      @deitypersephone1838 4 года назад +25

      actuallyexomember xiuminunnie because moonbyul is a real vocalist, she just trained to become a rapper of their group😁

    • @Kiwi18707
      @Kiwi18707 4 года назад +36

      hold my main rapper, main dancer AND main vocalist

    • @actuallyexomemberxiuminunn8928
      @actuallyexomemberxiuminunn8928 4 года назад +13

      @@deitypersephone1838 ya, I know kinda sad because she wasn't givin what she wanted yet I'm also happy that she became a rapper

    • @Unshavedd
      @Unshavedd 4 года назад +12

      Moonbuyl and Dreamcatcher's Dami! They are their own damn league, both are unreal! Super pretty, super talented, super good dancers, super good vocalist and amazing rappers!

    • @laurapaolino212
      @laurapaolino212 4 года назад +5

      Her mini album is really nice with rap and vocal songs

  • @야빵구
    @야빵구 2 года назад +81

    나는 이 버전이 더 좋아 ㅠ 문별 랩 들어가서 ㅠㅠ

  • @seolas__2252
    @seolas__2252 4 года назад +2321

    They weren't joking when they said Mamamoo 4 rappers, 4 dancers, and 4 vocalists.
    I'm so proud of Byul!!!

  • @sorelleperez9324
    @sorelleperez9324 4 года назад +1134

    She is so special!
    Her voice is like an angel💓
    Like if you agree

    • @juliparedes1454
      @juliparedes1454 4 года назад

      @thank u previous why?

    • @shinhussey4842
      @shinhussey4842 4 года назад +7

      @@juliparedes1454 it's because, she looks like
      Begging for likes

    • @mii3977
      @mii3977 4 года назад +2

      Everything was nice until she said the last part

  • @rosellecatague7872
    @rosellecatague7872 4 года назад +387

    Others: Moonbyul can't sing
    Moonbyul unnie: *mic drops*
    Serving us high notes. ❤

  • @oohsparkling
    @oohsparkling 2 года назад +38

    [NEWS]
    Moonbyul has joined 722 studio’s ‘방구석 캐스팅’ and will release a remake of Yountoven’s song ‘Trying To Say Goodbye’.
    It will be released on March 28th, 6pm KST
    😭😭😭 it's finally happening

  • @nicob8705
    @nicob8705 4 года назад +2368

    A drama needs to contact her because her voice is suitable for a OST

    • @wafflower6448
      @wafflower6448 4 года назад +62

      OMIGOSH YES. her voice is suttle and conveys so much emotion (like in this song).

    • @goodnot4814
      @goodnot4814 4 года назад +59

      Can't help it, I already pictured a kdrama scene in my mind while she's singing... Such a beautiful voice ❤❤❤❤

    • @nuggetnougat
      @nuggetnougat 4 года назад +15

      YES PLEASE

    • @Jadelepe740
      @Jadelepe740 4 года назад +12

      IKR!!! THIS.

    • @isabelleparanhos7014
      @isabelleparanhos7014 4 года назад +39

      When i listened "Absence" for the first time i thought the music was for an OST, that proves her voice really suits for an kdrama music

  • @thanhnganguyen1099
    @thanhnganguyen1099 4 года назад +276

    RBW: “Who are we going to give this song?”
    Also RBW: *pick Moonbyul - the main rapper of MAMAMOO - and she fcking nailed it*

  • @AP-qd9dq
    @AP-qd9dq 4 года назад +2175

    moonbyul - a vocalist
    moonbyul - the main rapper
    moonbyul - performer
    moonbyul - visual
    moonbyul - composer
    moonbyul - lyricist
    + highest credited female artist of the 3rd gen

    • @Flopped69
      @Flopped69 4 года назад +50

      @mars Soyeon is 4th gen

    • @beatrizterra1279
      @beatrizterra1279 4 года назад +57

      @mars actually last time I checked (january) moonbyul had about 60 credited songs and soyeon something around 30, so not yet, though soyeon definetly has potential to reach her since (g)i-dle debuted quite recently

    • @tyarsyad
      @tyarsyad 4 года назад +23

      Jeon Jungkook nope. MMM was debuted in 2014. If I’m not mistaken, 3rd gen started around 2011 or 2012. Thus, MMM is a 3rd gen GG.

    • @AP-qd9dq
      @AP-qd9dq 4 года назад +45

      @mars nope. Moonbyul ranks the 4th most credited FEMALE idol of ALL time (63 songs credited under her name) She is 4th on the list behind BoA, LE, and Miryo.
      While Soyeon ranks the 11th with 31 credited songs under her name.

    • @AP-qd9dq
      @AP-qd9dq 4 года назад +24

      @Jeon Jungkook fyi
      second gen = debuted from 2000-2010
      third gen = debuted from 2011-2017
      snsd debuted in the year 2007 and 4 minute debuted in the year 2009 while mamamoo debuted in the year 2014. google is just a minute away for u to do a lil research. Pls do so

  • @gogoomagamja
    @gogoomagamja 3 года назад +73

    목소리 자체가 슬픈 드라마 ost 찰떡인데.. 드라마 관계자들 뭐하세요 ㅠㅠ

  • @lmfc759
    @lmfc759 4 года назад +931

    okay but she gave us her delicate voice in the beginning, her beautiful lower register, her self-written melodic rapping, then she started belting out those high notes??? her power??????? moonbyul's just on another level. mamamoo most talented group EVER

    • @jeanjlf1840
      @jeanjlf1840 4 года назад +43

      agree! not all can handle low notes esp those that do power belting. It's easy for them to hit high notes but struggle with low notes. Byul can do both.

    • @azertytores
      @azertytores 4 года назад +7

      @@jeanjlf1840 They all can do both...
      Even hit whistle notes like if it was nothing...
      Moomoo stan Queens ^^ < 3

    • @MC-ko2mx
      @MC-ko2mx 4 года назад +13

      Yes, and she's the *rapper* of the group.
      Most soloists would kill to have her voice.
      Mamamoo truly are vocal powerhouses.

  • @ataleoftwomeows8086
    @ataleoftwomeows8086 4 года назад +272

    If anyone says mamamoo members aren't versatile and talented show them this.

    • @sheMessages
      @sheMessages 4 года назад

      Only a non kpop fan could say such thing of MAMAMOO's queens

    • @rangshi
      @rangshi 4 года назад

      @@sheMessages only a *toxic kpop stan* could say such a thing of MAMAMOO's queens

  • @inthe_a.m.
    @inthe_a.m. 4 года назад +537

    the people who disliked this couldn't see through the tears made by byul's beautiful singing

    • @jhkang9227
      @jhkang9227 4 года назад +3

      Lets not focus on the people who voted down. Why emphasise it? We should just focus on positives! Her soothing soft wonderful voice full of emotion. That her true talent for both singing and rapping are emerging more and more. That she rocks!!!! ❤️😍

  • @Sndbdfbs
    @Sndbdfbs 6 месяцев назад +7

    You can hear the pain in her voice

  • @Saba-vt3is
    @Saba-vt3is 4 года назад +334

    Plot twist : She was actually trained to be a vocalist

    • @idk-xv1oh
      @idk-xv1oh 4 года назад +49

      She was supposed to be a vocalist but the company made her rap instead because there were too many vocalists

    • @jofires
      @jofires 4 года назад +21

      She actually really was!

    • @arieanna2197
      @arieanna2197 4 года назад +14

      That’s a fact actually

    • @chiakitm5955
      @chiakitm5955 4 года назад +12

      All rappers go through vocal training as well. (Atleast now a days) due to production and melody purposes as well

    • @theresiasianipar5726
      @theresiasianipar5726 4 года назад

      That's a fun fact actually 😂

  • @magickpopshopxxxkband5941
    @magickpopshopxxxkband5941 4 года назад +570

    *the people who disliked were crying and being blinded by her singing and looks*

  • @ykbkykbk
    @ykbkykbk 4 года назад +2365

    Byul isn’t just a “good vocalist for a rapper” she is a good vocalist for a vocalist. The way so many kpop idols labelled as main vocals couldn’t do this. This isn’t shade to anyone at all in particular, she just deserves to own that vocalist title...

  • @skyhideaway
    @skyhideaway 2 года назад +263

    People need to realize that high notes alone doesn't make a good vocalist, and someone who doesn't hit high notes often isn't a weak vocalist.
    Compared to the other members, Byul's high notes are not as high, but none of them can replicate her vocal control when it comes to lower register. She has such a soulful and emotional voice, her vocals are stable and she has amazing breath control.
    Moonbyul isn't just a rapper who can sing well, she is a vocalist qualified to be a vocalist.

    • @KittyTsundere
      @KittyTsundere 2 года назад +9

      I believe her tessitura is set lower compared to the rest of MAMAMOO (she’s like a low soprano to me).
      Also, in terms of technique, I do hear shallow support in her mid-range though inconsistent, and she does have decent/good coordination for someone of her own ability.
      ***EDIT: actually she could be a mezzo, she seems to have G3 down just fine lol.

    • @moonbyulschair9533
      @moonbyulschair9533 2 года назад +6

      very true. She's extremely talented and overlooked because she does have the typical high notes. Her voice and songs is my favorite in Mamamoo

    • @KittyTsundere
      @KittyTsundere 2 года назад +4

      @@moonbyulschair9533 You mean she doesn’t have the typical high notes (or even high-pitched voice because she’s a mezzo)? I’m not even biased towards her (even though I’m OT4 all the way), but I like her solo songs and her deep voice (since MMM is my most favorite group in terms of voices/vocal palette) too. :)

    • @moonbyulschair9533
      @moonbyulschair9533 2 года назад +3

      @@KittyTsundere yea like hitting a C6 or whistle notes that some may consider as what is required to be considered a great singer (I don't agree on this). I love Moonbyul's range and she can go pretty high too which may be a surprise to most plus she has a very stable voice. The emotions she evokes when she sings is everything to me.

    • @el_kabong
      @el_kabong 2 года назад +7

      The difference between Byul and the rest of them, in a general sense at least, is that they spent years training as vocalists and she spent that time on rap. They all entered on roughly equal grounds and then split at that point. She doubtless received some vocal training along the way, hence her ability to keep up when required of her, but she spent considerably more of her time on rap.
      If Kim Do-hoon wanted four vocalists, he would have had them and Byul would have been there the whole time.

  • @she-an8464
    @she-an8464 4 года назад +681

    I'm so proud of her, look how confident she is now. Vocal training paid off.

    • @moonsunmichaengisthegayest177
      @moonsunmichaengisthegayest177 4 года назад +38

      Yeah, now she's not only a rapper but also a vocalist. She proved that she can sing. Don't get me wrong I'm not saying she can't sing, what i mean is now she have a confident to sing and i'm proud of her. 😭❤

    • @liying1440
      @liying1440 4 года назад +5

      I had goosebumps because you've said what I want to say

    • @cloudv.2108
      @cloudv.2108 4 года назад +14

      I've heard she is really a vocalist but the company assign her to a rapper.. sorry for my grammar

    • @she-an8464
      @she-an8464 4 года назад +8

      @@cloudv.2108 yes she is. she said that she taking a vocal training after the concert. (I don't know if it's her solo con) solar was even suprise

    • @mamn5587
      @mamn5587 4 года назад +8

      Sherine Angelie yes she started very recently to take vocal training and training to showcase emotions while singing .. for this project I believe.. Moon-Moobi season 2 will be the the death of me if this is the first one 😭😭😭😭

  • @TokuPonii
    @TokuPonii 4 года назад +341

    "are people still doubting Moonbyul's vocal abilities?"
    "uh...no, i don't think so"
    "hmm...yeah, better flex her vocals again, just in case"

  • @BlackRose-yi2zz
    @BlackRose-yi2zz 4 года назад +476

    Them: A rapper doing highnote? Impossible.
    Moonbyul: Lemme show you how you do it

    • @krystine269
      @krystine269 4 года назад +29

      It just reminded me of Byul's Cleopatra lol

    • @ataleoftwomeows8086
      @ataleoftwomeows8086 4 года назад

      Her and swae Lee are on another level.

  • @퐝피슉
    @퐝피슉 3 года назад +23

    별이가 한 번 더 각 잡고 발라드 커버해주면 좋겠다. 별이 음색.. 별이 감성... 정말 유니크해..

  • @holywaterofskz3681
    @holywaterofskz3681 4 года назад +158

    Wheein and Moonbyul literally shift whatever they are doing in their life. Wheein rapping and dancing while Moonbyul singing and belting.

  • @My-gu7mx
    @My-gu7mx 4 года назад +159

    No one:
    Byul's comforting singing voice 😭

  • @uzeev
    @uzeev 4 года назад +2726

    Her voice has a story of its own. She has such a pain in her voice that even though I cannot understand the language, still i can feel everything.
    Edit : (copy)
    It is released today, officially. A melodious remake of
    this lovely song. It's available on various music
    platforms like melon and spotify. The song is called
    'Trying to say Goodbye Listen to it and bless your ears
    for free!!!

    • @roseregalado1495
      @roseregalado1495 4 года назад +19

      Yeees ♥️

    • @thicclasagna3415
      @thicclasagna3415 4 года назад +57

      it’s called singing with emotion most good artists can do that lol

    • @camcamcam2569
      @camcamcam2569 4 года назад +5

      yessss I agre

    • @demigarcia4852
      @demigarcia4852 4 года назад +5

      Totally agree

    • @uzeev
      @uzeev 4 года назад +21

      @@thicclasagna3415 and she is one of them✌✌..

  • @jinakang8888
    @jinakang8888 2 года назад +46

    진짜 하루에도 몇번씩듣는 서이해.... 어떻게 보컬이 저렇게 담고있는 스토리가 많지 이별 10번은 더한 목소리야....

  • @h4n423
    @h4n423 4 года назад +904

    I hope one day, she as a solo vocalist will sing for ost kdrama 🙆‍♀️

    • @zacharythund6055
      @zacharythund6055 4 года назад +27

      Smol world with the same dp hahaha. But yep hoping shed try out for a OST as well but damn those vocals totally inlove

    • @emi-rv4jc
      @emi-rv4jc 4 года назад +18

      I hope this too,her voice give me vibe of old kdrama

    • @vanessadwia.z424
      @vanessadwia.z424 4 года назад +15

      Yaps...that would be so perfect. Her voice and emotions will suits drama

    • @h4n423
      @h4n423 4 года назад +1

      @@zacharythund6055 omg hahaha i thought its a bug 😂😂

    • @zacharythund6055
      @zacharythund6055 4 года назад +1

      @@h4n423 Hahahaha same here

  • @ByulsDisciple
    @ByulsDisciple 4 года назад +1464

    Please can Moonbyul have a solo OST one day. Her voice and the way she can portray emotions through her voice is so special. She truly is the hidden gem in mamamoo when it comes to vocals and they really need to let her shine

    • @emmar.7716
      @emmar.7716 4 года назад +50

      Yes! Her tone is great for a drama. I just hope that people would recognize her talent :(((

    • @youtubecomments5951
      @youtubecomments5951 4 года назад +8

      Emma R. Uhh. Don’t they already. She’s in a famous group and she is famous etc.

    • @shortboypinoy
      @shortboypinoy 4 года назад +15

      @@youtubecomments5951 The meaning of solo means.... by herself......

    • @youtubecomments5951
      @youtubecomments5951 4 года назад +5

      shortboypinoy isn’t this a solo? I meant she is already recognized since she is in a group and is famous. And this is a solo

    • @emmar.7716
      @emmar.7716 4 года назад +38

      @@youtubecomments5951 a solo OST for a movie/drama. Hwasa, Wheein and Solar had one; Moonbyul is the only one that hasn't participated in one yet. Let's hope that knets appreciate and recognize her talent soon!

  • @ilan6240
    @ilan6240 4 года назад +93

    At 2:39 When she change her voice for her “rap voices” it just give me chills, she’s so talented

  • @hjhj_moomoo
    @hjhj_moomoo 2 года назад +126

    리메이크 음원으로 발매된다는 소식듣고 다시 들으러 왔는데 너무 좋다..❤️ 문보컬 사랑해❤️

  • @웅이-j4f
    @웅이-j4f 4 года назад +168

    야 이게 마마무 래퍼의 노래 실력이다

  • @s9angela
    @s9angela 4 года назад +125

    Moonbyul is made to be a singer even though she’s a rapper

    • @boood3064
      @boood3064 4 года назад +5

      she is an awesome rapper too.

    • @eunjilee5740
      @eunjilee5740 4 года назад +4

      She origninally even was a vocalist but because the group therefore would've consited of 4 vocalists, she then became the rapper of mamamoo!

    • @eunjilee5740
      @eunjilee5740 4 года назад +1

      @Katz And that is totally fine, before anyone comes here attacking you! because everyone has their own preferences and that's totally valid and fine!

  • @KB42moomoo
    @KB42moomoo 4 года назад +576

    as terribly sad as the song is, byul's voice is also so comforting. it's like, she knows it's sad but it's also going to be okay, eventually...

  • @나는야멋쟁이-s2l
    @나는야멋쟁이-s2l 3 месяца назад +2

    진짜 들으면 들을수록 소름돋음 어떻게 이렇게 노래를 잘할 수가 있는거지 .... 너무 멋있다....

  • @hailholyhwasa3773
    @hailholyhwasa3773 4 года назад +95

    MOONBYUL VOCAL QUEEN

  • @harpercatboycatboy6966
    @harpercatboycatboy6966 4 года назад +114

    the fact that she's the main rapper but still is more stable than a lot of other groups vocalists

    • @ikra291
      @ikra291 4 года назад +1

      I know right!

    • @vvolleylife279
      @vvolleylife279 4 года назад +5

      Ikr!! No rapper is doing it like Byul

  • @AP-qd9dq
    @AP-qd9dq 4 года назад +1364

    *we really went from only having a 30 secs rap part to a whole 4 minutes of byul's vocal and belting those high notes. how do i keep these tears from falling?*

    • @kiim1593
      @kiim1593 4 года назад +15

      I never thought we'd be here 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

    • @dreamcatcherthebestdiscogr1934
      @dreamcatcherthebestdiscogr1934 4 года назад +6

      30 secs rap part? i don't understand😿

    • @sophiarosalind
      @sophiarosalind 4 года назад +61

      @@dreamcatcherthebestdiscogr1934 Byul's part in MMM songs used to consist of short rap breaks and that was it. She didn't sing in MMM songs, except for harmonies, for several years. Most songs she released had a lower vocal register. Nothing like this, with full-on, belt-it-out parts or higher parts. So hearing full songs from her with a wider vocal range is really wonderful.

    • @rangshi
      @rangshi 4 года назад +39

      @@sophiarosalind not to mention what she went through; she always felt unneeded/irrelevant, and she CRIED when they made her a rapper, she didn't want to rap, she wanted to sing. ofc this was all a LONG time ago, but she really made it :')

    • @directorraven
      @directorraven 4 года назад +5

      Trick question. You dont

  • @포도별언니의포도알
    @포도별언니의포도알 3 года назад +180

    아직 들으러 오는 분 있나요..? 살면서
    들어온 문보컬은 하나하나 다 감격스러웠지만
    처음 들었을 떄 그 느낌이 너무나도 강렬했던
    서툰 이별을 하려 해 커버..무엇보다 고음 쭉쭉 뻗고완성 > 성장 > 퍼펙트.. 로 와버린 문보컬..
    대체 언니의 한계는..

  • @nocimnotcreativewithnames1014
    @nocimnotcreativewithnames1014 4 года назад +88

    Did anyone else get the image of a proud leader solar when Moonbyul hit the high note?

    • @joannaofficial2013
      @joannaofficial2013 4 года назад

      No, I recall her laughing at Byulie because she finds her singing comical, especially when doing the high notes-WOAHHH😂。

  • @cinthiaMP
    @cinthiaMP 4 года назад +475

    it's crazy to see how confident byul is in her singing nowadays and for good reason!! she's amazing!!

    • @mihailgavrishchiv7972
      @mihailgavrishchiv7972 4 года назад +8

      She said somewhere that she stated vocal trainings to improve.

  • @trsrxnctxexoxmmm6303
    @trsrxnctxexoxmmm6303 4 года назад +509

    She's not holding back anymore. Like her emotions and talent, her confidence is overflowing.
    edit: Moonbyul is so talented

    • @oliv5580
      @oliv5580 4 года назад +12

      Thinking back to the time where she feels put down and doubts herself to this.... T_T this is just priceless

    • @trsrxnctxexoxmmm6303
      @trsrxnctxexoxmmm6303 4 года назад +12

      @Chin back to the time where she hide her voice because she doesn't have enough confidence but look at her now letting herself sing and hit those high notes.

    • @jhkang9227
      @jhkang9227 4 года назад +4

      Lets not focus on the people who voted down. Why emphasise it? We should just focus on positives! Her soothing soft wonderful voice full of emotion. That her true talent for both singing and rapping are emerging more and more. That she rocks!!!!

  • @지나가는한국인-k6r
    @지나가는한국인-k6r 3 года назад +25

    음색도 좋은데 와...감정표현을 아주 지나가는 파리보고 눈,콧.물만드네 ㄷㄷ
    +
    별이언니가 연애를 많이 안해봤다고 하는데 원래 연애 많이 안해본 사람이 그 감정을 더 잘기억한다는 썰이 있더라구요..

  • @PemujaDuitSugai
    @PemujaDuitSugai 4 года назад +696

    Dear MAMAMOO,
    I dont know you will read this or not, because it's full of english and i didnt know korean well. I just wanna tell you that i'm tired but everytime i tired, i will look for Mamamoo. Mamamoo giving me a strenght so i can do all things and protected you and others!
    I love you and i will keep protecting you!
    Please loving us more and more!

  • @bakasamaaaaa
    @bakasamaaaaa 4 года назад +189

    Ah damn I'm crying for real ㅠ ㅠ Someone give Byulie an OST please I'm begging

  • @dianaluvschrist
    @dianaluvschrist 4 года назад +94

    *the 5 people who disliked are just mad they aren’t Moonbyul😌💅*

  • @ssomsomm
    @ssomsomm 2 года назад +10

    문별했네..진짜 너무좋아..음원버전도 좋고.. 커버버전 랩파트도좋고ㅠㅠ 보컬,랩 더블링된 부분도 듣고싶어요ㅠㅠ🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

  • @astralblast6627
    @astralblast6627 4 года назад +330

    3:03-3:30 Dman those high notes...is this what Heaven feels like🥰. Moonbyul you have worked so hard...throughout the years you have constantly improved on your vocals and look at you now, you are shining at the top. I am so proud and happy that I get to see this development. You are a top-tier rapper and at the same time, your vocals are an absolute gem. You deserve all the love in this world. We moomoos will stay with you till the last day🥰.
    Moomoos can we show more love to this video because the vocals here are no joke...she served us with a wonderful song

    • @lollol-hw1fo
      @lollol-hw1fo 4 года назад +12

      She was made to feel that she can't sing but look at her...her voice is so soft and delicate...she makes me cry everytime

    • @burstlimit149
      @burstlimit149 4 года назад +10

      The feels you get from her voice, is heart touching

    • @astralblast6627
      @astralblast6627 4 года назад +7

      @@lollol-hw1fo She has come a long way and she is basically flexing her vocals in this song

    • @repz9190
      @repz9190 4 года назад +3

      maybe in mmm next comeback we will see more vocalist byul than rapper byul.

  • @taeslilclown9801
    @taeslilclown9801 4 года назад +714

    she could literally be a main vocalist in any other group

    • @kikikoko5014
      @kikikoko5014 4 года назад +43

      In blackpink and twice for sure..

    • @taeslilclown9801
      @taeslilclown9801 4 года назад +39

      kiki koko idk about twice. Byul’s probably around the same level as Jihyo (not a weak vocalist; just not given the chance to show off so often gets overshadowed)

    • @T355V
      @T355V 4 года назад +87

      @@kikikoko5014 let's not bring specific groups into this.. let's maintain a peaceful fandom

    • @kikikoko5014
      @kikikoko5014 4 года назад +13

      @@taeslilclown9801 byul techniq much better than Jihyo..

    • @marcosalves2422
      @marcosalves2422 4 года назад +25

      @@kikikoko5014 why mention the groups? So rude...

  • @alicesandra3891
    @alicesandra3891 4 года назад +147

    Those dislikes is just some people who doesn't know how to sing and jelous of how wonderful Byul voice are.

  • @가가-m6w
    @가가-m6w 3 года назад +23

    문별의 목소리는 진리다

  • @kayluvlyz
    @kayluvlyz 4 года назад +105

    the way i still click to turn on english subs... I'm a clown

  • @ujema
    @ujema 4 года назад +57

    For those who wondering, the title of this song is Trying to Say Goodbye by Yountoven

  • @piieck
    @piieck 4 года назад +87

    She's just a little hamster.......🥺🥺💛💛💛💛💛💛

  • @kosmos8014
    @kosmos8014 Год назад +7

    Byul is really a great vocalist. I'm so sad every time I listen to this.

  • @UOOHi
    @UOOHi 4 года назад +150

    이 노래 한 곡을 불러내기 위해 어떤 노력을 했을까, 상상도 안되지만 예전과는 너무나도 달라지는 모습에, 점점 성장하는 모습에 감탄하고 갑니다
    우리의 곁에서 별처럼 빛나줘서 너무 고마워요
    당신의 존재 만으로도 정말 큰힘이에요.
    고마워요 사랑해요

  • @gabic3781
    @gabic3781 4 года назад +264

    Moonbyul is really out there, being a complete artist with her own style and identity.
    Truly an inspiration for all of us who are not considered within the "standarts"!
    Couldn't have chosen a better ultimate bias in Kpop

    • @anya0717
      @anya0717 4 года назад +3

      she can do it all. she's a full package literally.

  • @hanisfarhana9134
    @hanisfarhana9134 4 года назад +222

    She's now becoming a lot more better as vocalist. A lot more confident with her voice. I guess for their comeback, we will have her as vocalist. 😉

    • @loreimtb
      @loreimtb 4 года назад +7

      I hope so!

  • @csfung5208
    @csfung5208 2 года назад +6

    Byulcember~~ Don't forget to listen to her new song G999 ft Mirani!!!!

  • @imfreer1961
    @imfreer1961 4 года назад +56

    VOCALIST MOONBYUL👏👏👏👏👏🎉🎉❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @actuallyexomemberxiuminunn8928
    @actuallyexomemberxiuminunn8928 4 года назад +111

    Moonbyul is a complete package. She can sing well, dances well, raps well, makes our hearts flatter and she has a good personality.

  • @stefanysanchez6469
    @stefanysanchez6469 3 года назад +286

    You can cry listening to the song as you think about how many times Moonbyul wanted to show her voice, how much she has struggled to let go of her fear and insecurities about her vocals. She trained to be a vocalist and out of nowhere she was told that she would be the rapper of the group , she had to spend some time to find her place within the group , she spent performances standing for minutes while watching how the members performed , she fought against those who told her she didn't deserve to be in Mamamoo because she couldn't "sing" , she fought against herself in order to gain confidence in her voice again , she has fought a lot our Moonbyul and we can be proud of her. No one who doesn't know her story can appreciate what this means and will not cry over this cover and video.

  • @lovelove9388
    @lovelove9388 4 года назад +706

    완성형인 줄 알았던 내 최애가 사실 성장형이었던 걸 알았을 때의 쾌감이란..

    • @용띠-b2s
      @용띠-b2s 4 года назад +57

      ㅋㅋㅋ 요즘 보컬트레이닝 받고있다는데..후욱후욱

    • @현생살아라
      @현생살아라 4 года назад +26

      ㅇ ㅏ ㅜㅠㅠㅜㅠㅠㅜㅜ짜릿함,,.,,.............

    • @두니-e5z
      @두니-e5z 3 года назад +12

      어디까지 성장할건데 별아ㅜㅜㅜㅜ

    • @MB_1222
      @MB_1222 3 года назад +11

      문보컬 사랑해애애ㅐ애애액!!!! 놓지않을게 사랑하누 ㅠㅜㅠㅜㅜㅠ
      진짜 문보컬 노래 하루종일 들을수 있음 ㅇㅇㅇ 잘때도 들을수있을정도로 너무좋아 ㅠㅜㅠㅜㅜㅠㅜㅠㅜ

    • @백현서-m9m
      @백현서-m9m 3 года назад +9

      언니 진짜 나한테 왜그러는데,,,,뭐가 힘들게 했어??? 언제까지 내 마음 병원가게 할건데...

  • @botanicallyaberry6406
    @botanicallyaberry6406 4 года назад +164

    Can you imagine there was a time, years ago, when seeing her sing was a HUGE deal? Now we get so many vocal parts and covers now. I'm so proud of Moonbyul

    • @mysa6444
      @mysa6444 4 года назад +3

      Fr 😭😭

    • @lazypanda649
      @lazypanda649 4 года назад +13

      I'm a baby Moo and I can't imagine what Veteran Moos are feeling now..
      I think they're happy to see Moonbyul singing confidently.

    • @emeraldkee4541
      @emeraldkee4541 4 года назад +2

      Feel this so much! back then it was like a treasure hunt just to find her singing small harmonisation parts! 😭

    • @moonbyul6887
      @moonbyul6887 4 года назад +1

      Lazy Panda welcome to the fandom :))

    • @studytoreachsuccess
      @studytoreachsuccess 4 года назад

      Right!!!

  • @ikki8802
    @ikki8802 4 года назад +84

    remember how all of us go crazy whenever moonbyul is given singing lines? look at how far we've come T^T she's finally confident to do this

  • @moonwhinbyul_
    @moonwhinbyul_ 3 года назад +46

    전 가끔 고민이 많아지면 찾아온답니다. 오늘도 왔네요. 문보컬. 순수하고 포근한 목소리. 진정성있고 이런 목소리 좋아해요. 감정을 진짜 잘 담은것 같네요. 매일 들을때마다 생각한답니다.ㅎ

  • @emeraldaguirre6673
    @emeraldaguirre6673 4 года назад +59

    SHE'S FLEXING HER VOCALS AND IM HERE FOR IT!!!!!!!!!

  • @blissful605
    @blissful605 4 года назад +96

    I'm in tears..............Moonbyul has grew so much as a vocalist and now hearing her belt out high notes like that is really amazing and precious T_________T I support you in everything you do, rap, sing, dance, act, song writing, you amazing precious human

  • @fayem5394
    @fayem5394 4 года назад +60

    Still remember years ago she said "im nervous" when changing part in a performance, look at her now *clapclap

  • @sori6196
    @sori6196 2 года назад +46

    moonbyul's voice is the most comforting to me out of all the members...

  • @aminameheli5263
    @aminameheli5263 4 года назад +66

    X: How many talents do you have?
    Moonbyul: Yes!

  • @saintxxem1896
    @saintxxem1896 4 года назад +72

    i don't know why, but every time she sings i feel like crying
    like im just so proud, she's no longer holding it back
    she's totally showing us what else she can do
    she's a total package
    obviously a mamamoo member
    we are so proud of you, byul unnie
    you sing it so good!!!!

  • @adlyn8648
    @adlyn8648 4 года назад +229

    Even if don't know what does the lyric means but this song, her beautifull voice, her high notes, her facial expressions made me cry.

    • @adlyn8648
      @adlyn8648 4 года назад +2

      Sorry for bad english lol

    • @filgypsy31
      @filgypsy31 4 года назад +6

      you english is good😀.. same here..I don’t understand anything but I like it😀

    • @adlyn8648
      @adlyn8648 4 года назад +2

      @@filgypsy31 thx! and Yeah ikr her voice and the song is so goood

    • @adlyn8648
      @adlyn8648 4 года назад +1

      240 likes, thx everyone! I didnt expect likes at all :o

    • @adlyn8648
      @adlyn8648 4 года назад

      @TwT wee thx for the infooo✌

  • @별구름-q3y
    @별구름-q3y 3 года назад +78

    감성에 젖어들고 싶을 때 계속 찾게 되는 노래, 서정적이고 듣기 편한 음색이 너무 좋아요. 나중에 꼭 드라마 OST 하나 했으면 좋겠다 ㅠㅠ

  • @gwynethdianne
    @gwynethdianne 4 года назад +159

    i haven't been a moo for a long time, but i know that it took her a long time to be this confident with her vocal abilities. and now, slowly but surely, she's starting to show her vocalist side even more. i'm just so proud of her for coming this far. her vocals are god-sent. SHE'S JUST SO GOOD. i'm so in love w/ her brb crying

  • @noname-ir4on
    @noname-ir4on 4 года назад +75

    문별의 이별노래를 들으면 이별한 적도 없는데 이별한 기분이 듦

  • @redmoon2853
    @redmoon2853 4 года назад +54

    하 언니..........
    목소리 진짜.... 랩이랑 노래중에 하나만 잘하라구여ㅠㅠ심지어 아련 슬픔 멋짐 그냥 다가지고 있어ㅠㅠ 오늘도 무무는 심장폭행당함ㅠㅠ 경찰차랑 구급차 불러주세요ㅠㅠ(우리 언니 한테 싫어요 눌른 놈 누구야!!!!!!!!!!!)

  • @정신차려이각박한-j9b
    @정신차려이각박한-j9b 3 года назад +201

    문별님 노래 이렇게 잘부르시는거 첨 알았다..

    • @김소금-i8w
      @김소금-i8w 3 года назад +13

      에이 첨 알았다뇨 서운하군뇨

    • @qqu99
      @qqu99 3 года назад +4

      ㅎㅎㅎ보컬로 오디션 통과하고 래퍼로 전향했답니당

  • @mimi_werty
    @mimi_werty 4 года назад +213

    I’ve been a Mamamoo fan since the pandemic and as a former kpop fan (SNSD, 2ne1, Shinee, T-ara, Miss A era) I can say that these 4 girls really set up a high standard when it comes to gg. I’m glad I discovered them. They are all so talented and unique. Moonbyul really did great here. Wish she could have more parts in singing on their comeback. 💞

    • @cathelyndiaz8980
      @cathelyndiaz8980 4 года назад +7

      Eyyy 😍 same here im a 2nd gen idol stan and a moomoo since 2016 😊

    • @noneyabiz1513
      @noneyabiz1513 4 года назад +5

      Dreamcatcher. Check them out. All their members could be the MD, and be the MC, and very talented too. Raw vocals too.

    • @sanspurple5621
      @sanspurple5621 4 года назад +1

      Ikr, i love them💕💕

    • @25beee
      @25beee 4 года назад +6

      I've been a Kpop fan since 2010 (I am an ELF for Suju) even though until today, I can't say that I know all about Kpop. But I can say that I found it rare to see a member performing differently from their destined position in the group. Like Moonbyul, her position in Mamamoo are a rapper and a performer, but here she performs as a vocalist. There some who also do that, but usually the artist already out from the group.

    • @cathelyndiaz8980
      @cathelyndiaz8980 4 года назад +3

      @@25beee yess agree.. I fell inlove with their introduction the harmonization is LIT !!

  • @CraigWinstanley1
    @CraigWinstanley1 4 года назад +48

    It has been great to see 문별, Moonbyul develop confidence and hone her singing skills since MAMAMOO’s debut. Moonbyul has depth, sensitivity and character in her voice like no other. I like Moonbyul sooooo much! Always, she is my bias in MAMAMOO.

  • @느그집엔문별이없지
    @느그집엔문별이없지 3 года назад +29

    음색이 진짜 미침 ㅠㅠ 이런 핫초코 같은 인간아 ㅠㅠ 따뜻하고 달달하다...진짜 겨울에 생각나는 음색 ㅠㅠ

  • @jyeirakit
    @jyeirakit 4 года назад +137

    I can't believe I'm hearing all these high notes from her... She said before that it was awkward for her to sing since she doesn't even know what to do with her hands or gestures... But now I'm crying over her song... 😭😭😭

    • @MMMMMM-wd7fu
      @MMMMMM-wd7fu 4 года назад +4

      Mamamoo Mamako Mamanya I'm not even singing and I don't know what to do with my hands. I feel you Byul!

  • @user-vl9pe8ds4w
    @user-vl9pe8ds4w 4 года назад +58

    아니 나 별이언니 가성으로 이렇게까지 고음 올라가는거처음봐..언니 진짜 왜 이렇게 잘해..?
    언니 다 잘해버리면 내가 언니땜에 심쿵사로 죽잖아..

    • @류성현-u1c
      @류성현-u1c 4 года назад +5

      저 심정지 와서 셀프 마사지중입니다

    • @Mino.s
      @Mino.s 4 года назад +2

      (죽은자는 말이없습니다.)

  • @californiabarkingmoose
    @californiabarkingmoose 4 года назад +82

    There's something about Moonbyul's voice that gets me so emotional like no other singer has done. When I listen to songs like ten nights and the osts with mamamoo where she sings, her parts always tugs at my heart and makes me feel the pain even though I can't understand the words. I'm so thankful that she's singing more now. Saranghanuuu Byulyi 🥺

    • @BlackRose-yi2zz
      @BlackRose-yi2zz 4 года назад +2

      yeah me too, when she sings sad songs i feel the emotions pouring like it will not end. She sings with lots of feeling, actually all of them the OT4

  • @bastetowl3258
    @bastetowl3258 5 месяцев назад +5

    her vocals! this is mamamoo's rapper everyone

  • @rohlui4337
    @rohlui4337 4 года назад +37

    I guess Moonbyul never rest. She’s such a blessing

  • @gabriellajung4612
    @gabriellajung4612 4 года назад +26

    Fact: Mamamoo's main rapper Moonbyul can easily be other kpop group's main vocalist!

  • @몰바-b6d
    @몰바-b6d 4 года назад +208

    와... 뭐야...? 마마무는 진짜 래퍼까지 다 잘 부르는구나...

    • @Fun_crew0619
      @Fun_crew0619 3 года назад +16

      원래 처음에 포지션이 보컬이였답니다

    • @다윤-i7r
      @다윤-i7r 3 года назад +11

      원래 포지션이 보컬이었어요!! 근데 보컬 쎈(?) 멤버들이
      있어서 보컬->래퍼로 바꼈답니다! 딴 영상 보시면
      보컬포지션 멤버들이 래퍼언니가 높은 고음하는거보고
      경악할정도 보컬이었어요!

    • @죠니-f5b
      @죠니-f5b 3 года назад +1

      @@다윤-i7r 무슨 영상인가요??!

    • @나무늘보전갈
      @나무늘보전갈 3 года назад +2

      @@다윤-i7r 여자친구랑 고음대결영상 말씀하시는 건가요??ㅎㅎ

    • @다윤-i7r
      @다윤-i7r 3 года назад +2

      @@나무늘보전갈 네

  • @mariakazzandra
    @mariakazzandra Год назад +13

    2023 and this is still my top 1 fav of byulie's cover. It just speaks with my soul beside the one she covered in 2nd world the song from psy

  • @paattita8835
    @paattita8835 4 года назад +49

    The fact she's getting more and more confident with her singing skill brought me to tears. Talented woman, So proud with Moonbyul I love you my Star

  • @_watermelon_0
    @_watermelon_0 4 года назад +38

    노래도 노래지만 정말 감정이 잘 나타난 것 같아서 괜히 듣는 나도 감정이입하게됨.. 노래실력 미쳤어.. 어쩜좋아 문별이ㅠ 사랑해ㅠㅠㅠ

  • @abegailquilario9850
    @abegailquilario9850 4 года назад +87

    Because of mamamoo. I left my ex because they made me strong to fight that evil person. I was stuck until i listen to them singin. I was free and happy

    • @boobsiez
      @boobsiez 4 года назад +10

      More power to you!!
      Sending hugs and kisses and also mamamoo is proud of you :))

    • @giang1631
      @giang1631 4 года назад +4

      I'm glad to hear that! Wish you a better life after left your ex 🙏 I'm sure MAMAMOO would also proud of you too ❤️ Stay strong 💪

    • @primitiveplanet8202
      @primitiveplanet8202 4 года назад +2

      Among the ways to get a like this is really innovative.

    • @ssunfool
      @ssunfool 4 года назад +1

      you got thiiisss yes!! all the power to you, you are so strong

    • @gideonapollob
      @gideonapollob 4 года назад +3

      "It's okay to not be fine!!"
      Go! go! bebe!

  • @자이렇게하면
    @자이렇게하면 2 года назад +10

    랩버전 들으러 다시왔다.. 랩버전도 앨범 내줬으면.. 갠적으로 이게 더 좋아..

  • @문초딩-y9x
    @문초딩-y9x 4 года назад +62

    별이언니노래소리들으니까제귀가녹으려고해요
    별이언니노래실력엄청많이늘어났어요!!!!!
    별이언니마지막쯤에높은음엄청잘했어요👍👍
    별이앞으로도화이팅!!!!!!!

  • @leemewbin
    @leemewbin 4 года назад +91

    안녕하세요!마마무에서 메인래퍼와 퍼포먼스 메인보컬을 맡고있는.....아니 걍 다 잘하는 ☆반짝반짝☆ 문별입니다!
    언니...걍 다해요......인간적으로 너무 잘하자나ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅜ
    4 with ☀️❤❤❤❤

  • @ikra291
    @ikra291 4 года назад +43

    Remember in November 2019 when Moos went crazy for a five second high note in Ten Nights and now we have this!

  • @규하하
    @규하하 3 года назад +5

    문별 알럽♡

  • @Samikpop
    @Samikpop 4 года назад +233

    *I’m really proud and happy that she is sharing pieces of her singing and that she’s getting more confident knowing that moos love her voice and that we will support her*

  • @남지현-k1f
    @남지현-k1f 4 года назад +197

    문별님이 이렇게 혼자부르는거 너무좋다

    • @김소담-r3o
      @김소담-r3o 3 года назад +7

      무무이신 것 같은데 문별이 문별이 라고 안하시고 님이라고 높이말 쓰시는거 너무 너무 존경스럽습니당..