Is $5 Trillion Economy Achievable?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- In his Independence Day speech, Prime Minister Narendra Modi reiterated his government's ambition to make India a 5 trillion dollars economy in the next five years. However, the reality is that most of the sectors are suffering from dwindling growth figures. The Auto sector is facing its worst crisis in decades. In the real estate sector, the number of unsold homes have increased. The tax collection has grown by just 1.4 per cent. The big question is: Is PM Modi's goal achievable?
NDTV is one of the leaders in the production and broadcasting of un-biased and comprehensive news and entertainment programmes in India and abroad. NDTV delivers reliable information across all platforms: TV, Internet and Mobile.
Subscribe for more videos: www.youtube.co...
Like us on Facebook: / ndtv
Follow us on Twitter: / ndtv
Download the NDTV Apps: www.ndtv.com/pa...
Watch more videos: www.ndtv.com/vi...
I can't tell how much I miss Dr Manmohan Singh as a finance minster and Raghuram sir as RBI governor
thank you sir
College lecturer made as RBI governor by scamgress haha
Yeah all those scams, minority appeasement. Yuckk..
What about all that scams.
@@keshorekumar6172 yeah chai wala made a pm by right wingers and iliterate
No one is interested in such stupid debates about the economy, people want religious wars. People want to watch religious fights in TV studio. As you can see this video has much fewer views.
The irony is in your name as well..
Have you seen cabinet of Dr caligari
@@sirlordhenrymortimer6620 Yes I have.
Found a nice quote. "GDP is a metric that keeps going up regardless of how many people get left behind."
Yeh but if doesn't grow u will attack modi .
One of the better debates on current economic crisis.
We really miss Dr. Manmohan Singh today.
Ali Rasool :abe ch**tiye singh hun but manmohan singh nahin hun
rahul gandhi ko vote do indian economy upgrade ho jayege 🥴🤑🤣
Pharma industry is doing good says Geeta bhat. Probably due to increase in BP meds taken by more people now, thanks to the failing economy.
Oh god who says cricis period is serious from every victim a comedian born😄😄
🤣🤣
👌
All xtians and Muslims feel economy is bad. Rest are looking ahead for a strong india
@@rohitpant8893 your die hard optimism is appreciable. The unemployment is highest in last 45 years. Household savings lowest in 23 years. Job losses in millions. Instead of fulfilling promise of 2 crore jobs a year, this govt is unable to arrest the loss of existing jobs to the tune of many lakhs of workers. How do you think the govt will get India out of this rut? By sending in more troops to Kashmir?
Only ndtv is left asking hard question and bringing the real picture hope integrity of ndtv is protected
used to think ndtv was supporter NDA in my childhood.. 😝
Praying for their integrity is not enough, you should also pray for their survival.., future is very bleak for them..
Close your eyes and just say waah Modi hi waah
😂😂
Wahh modi ji waah
Hum kare toh kare.. bole toh bole.. 😇
Muslims get so happy criticizing him, and idolize rahul Gandhi. Keep this up, only helps to unite and bring back modi to power
Why don't they speak about serious issues like Hindu Muslim or Bharat matta ke jai or wether you should say jai shree ram people are more interested in them issues
@HARD FACTS don't worry about pakistan it's a small country or state but it's a shame that india need money and is in the dumps being such a big country we have to admit that india is in big trouble no one has work and people think twice wether to purchase or not because they don't have any money and you dream to be a 5 trillion dollar economy keep dreaming best of luck
@HARD FACTS because I'm not from india and am chilling in my jucuuzi would like to ask you if you have a toilet or not and do you have nice clean water coming through your tap ha ha ha ha ha ha
@HARD FACTS agreed, and now india is facing the rule of action and its reaction.
You're probably playing the minority card here. You guys are now pissed off as a right wing government has taken over. Also, your protectors are now going behind bars, hence one can understand your pain. This economic slowdown is temporary and will see a great push in coming days. It's not India that is suffering in its economy. Many European countries too are undergoing crisis. You may not notice this. It's Modi's target of reaching 5TDE, which will be definitely achieved by another 5 years for sure
Of course..the way we all got 15 lakhs last year..
Only news channel who has gutts to discuss this topic
31:00 Here is the point Demonetization was the starting point and it has snowballed with GST and impact of global slowdown
9
Interesting to see the satirical smile, disbelief writ large, on face of Dr Geeta.
Poor audience i feel pity... They look pretty much depressed😔
After 5 years of strong govt, we have weak economy but religious josh is high! Modi ji u r great! working 24hrs/day
People use to say Rahul Gandhi a pappu but the same guy who is far more intelligent then other Andh Bhakat that GST is nothing but a Gabbar Singh Tax . People are suffering and econmyy is bad shape due to demonetization and GST and worst is yet to come but it's unfortunate that despite of all these Pathetic decision Andh Bhakat and EC supported BJP.
Please wake up BJP Hatho Desh ki econamy Bachaoo
@@akashagarwal829 Typical andh bhakt - dharti pe bojh... when they do not have a counter argument, they resort to paying compliments to the rational voice's mothers and sisters. Shame on people like you, this is reflective of how your parents and family have brought you up !!!
@@akashagarwal829 Ok, teri bhejo abhi.
@India Rise and Reclaim by 2047 dude, you are taken in by sanghi propaganda completely, get well soon bro !
Till then please don't propagate your rubbish any further. For our country's sake please stop if you love India.
@@prashanthb6521 so u mean to say giving a single taxation system rather thn every state having own form of tax is bad . That's why we call Rahul a pappu and u people pappubadi.
RSS might have some economists. Stop inviting a political analyst to discussions on economy.
NDTV can get better panelists (than her)
More pakora factories coming soon
😮😮😮
I find this achor really attractive ....she looks so classy
LOL
She looks very intelligent too...
@sheldon pereira I watch her debates 25% becuace of her n 75 % becuace of topic
Name of this anchor
@@winnerchampions814 Sara jacob
"Arun Jaitley is the reason behind slowdown" ― Su Swamy
But he is now in AIMS so who to blame now😕 may be Nehru
One idiot calling another idiot..... Makes absolute sense
Yes it is achievable but only in dreams
@India Rise and Reclaim by 2047 People don't have money to buy parle g biscuits and then you are saying 5trillion dollar economy. The growth was not 7% ,infact it is 4%. BJP manipulated the data.
@India Rise and Reclaim by 2047
Wake up, get well soon. Blind love is dangerous.
So, India cannot rally behind an Idiot just because one family is to be hated!!
Demonitisation to bring back black money !!!
Joke of the century.
Oh yeah, Freely roaming EVM machines during election time !! Where other countries don't bother to use these EVM's, RSS will take democracy out of India. And keep dreaming.
When Modi promises something, it means it won't happen. hahaha
True.
Same thing Naysayers said about 370 and 35A so now go cry :D
@@msdadsfsx if we go in your way of thinking it's true...
What about
Triple tallaq
Caa
Article 370
Our Generation will be remembered in the History of Our Country as the Generation that destroyed India.
Reality - Jai Hind
Audience of ndtv are looks pessimistic & depressed...I Carefully observing them
being worried about a situation is better than believing in a good for nothing fellow to do good..
They are indian citizens and reflect what common people feels
Same
RIP English
Lady= i am facing problem since 2014 man= this man know she has been facing since 2009 😂😂
Narendra Freestyler the man is a product of rss
Modinomics not working on ground.
Doesn't work on paper as well
Cry louder.
We don't want anything except cow maa and jai shri ram jai modi
So apparently the who whole right is just one single group
Sometime we are over critical of the Govt., discussion should be objective, criticize govt policies no problem, but back the govt when it is due. On the dais are the professionals, and the audience seems to be hand picked in between these two there is NDTV.
BJP alone spent 27000 crores on a single election. What are they talking about no funds? How much was spent on just the kedarnath jaunt?
It is possible if you increase GST to 50% for all items and services.
Let's take it upto 100%...... cuz you know you should go all out and not half hearted you DIM WIT!
hahahhahahah
Sara Jacob speaks excellent English and knowledge of subject she speaks on ??
prince kamboj I like Nidhi Rajdan though.
Fig itself, is wrong in 2014 they started with 2.2 trillion & its 2.8 trillion
2 Killers of Indian Economy.
1. DEMO
2. GST
Dude...GST isn't killing the economy. The poor implementation of it is. But on the whole, it probably made it much better than what would've been. Pre-GST, you had a hodge-podge of taxes between states. In what other country do you have to stop at the border of each state to basically go through "customs"? It was complete idiocy, and GST reigned it in. The only thing is that they should've made it one rate rather than the stupid 4 or so rates we have now.
@@tstcikhthyss he just heard this slogan somewhere and commented here. No point making him understand the technical aspects.
The punchline as Mr Gurcharan aptly put it - " go thru the pain ". A change will stem from a realistic mind-set. Very well said Sir.
My Indian fellows, you should know that RSS is having top HINDUTVA economist educated from RSS university of Nagpur, you will see when they will take charge of Indian economy, country will grow by 30% for Ambani Adani & Modi Brothers, but your & my Brothers will die hungry, this is HINDUTVA govt.
Will d andh bhakts die too or will they get tips for abusing or arguing, will they benefit from the govt..
Action.....Speaks Louder than WORDS... Let's see
Is this time good to invest in stock like coal India and ashok layland for long term investment?
Let BJP rule for 10 more years our economy will be on ventilator just like our FORMER FM Arun jaitley who currently is counting his breath .......I hardly agree with subramanyam Swamy but in case of Arun jaitley he was BULLS EYE......I think only thing which can bail our economy is EVRY ONE SHOULD sip one tea spoon of GAU MUTRA I mean esp brahmins n CHANT Bharat Mata ki jai
So, Gurcharan Das is saying don't even try to attack money-launderers only because they are investing in pennies even though they are earning in crores !!! Do you guys think no investors and industrialists pay taxes in the USA and in other advanced countries !!!
It is called real and meaningful debate on genuine issues, other anchors and channel should learn from Ndtv that how to debate.. Specially. Arnabghoswami.
I'm just here to listen to Geeta Bhat. Where could one find such brilliant comedy?! Wonder why they mentioned her as an analyst!
What an healthy debate on economy, unfortunately most of the people won’t be able to digest as they are used to seen crazy people arguing in a louder voice with each other...
Good to here Rohit Azad JNU I think here so many economists guys from JNU all r best top level knowledge in the field of economics country need these who know very well what prec we need and our GDP Inc these guys knows well..
This stupid regime has tagged India's best brain JNU as anti national still people are not able to figure out and just following to propoganda ....GOD KNWS WHEN INDIAN MAJIRITY WILL WAKE UP ....I think they are having excess of GAU MUTRA SHAKE and it's showing effect now
The current slowdown in the economy is cyclical and the growth will pick up in one to years. As per IMF's latest projections, Indian economy is expected to grow at 7 percent in 2019 and 7.2 in 2020.
A voice of dissent and debates are the foundations of the democracy, as for this debate it apprises one well of the current situation but lacks a vision of future.
Government has already announced many reforms, now there implementation is what we have to look forward to, especially in terms of investment.
A common man doesnt have puchasing power, due to unemployment abhi to auto sector barbaad ho raha dhire dhire baki sectors ka number bhi aayenga..
Rather than gdp we should talk about per capita income.
Haha socialistic policies are part of history now.
@@theguy3888
How?
GDP and GNI only differ by about 1-2%, so it's not that different. And GDP & GNI and GDP per capita & GNI per capita are directly proportional respectively, so if one goes up, then the other one does proportionally as well. So it's all basically the same thing.
A few simple things that can be done 1. If anyone has been to Thailand , korea , japan and Taiwan you will see the following . Every 1 Km a 7/11 , followed by family mart and a mini Tesco . All these have uplifted quality and allows other small vendors to sell around them with uplifted quality. Now if you take the size of India and have the above please calculate the jobs that will be created and all transactions to be taxed. Now it cannot be done in india as we have low quality and only global chains will bring quality and then the sector is open for anyone to invest. If you travel in thai interiors this has not negatively impacted small traders as all are prospering. 2. We all know how much illegal betting is going in IPL etc. Lets legalise it so we can control it and collect tax.3. Crypto and blockchain current investement is $272,119,620,945 . That's 272 billion in a bear market. We all know its a technology and will come one day. There is trading that happens globally. Invite the global exchanges to operate from India and development to happen here. We can tax the transactions. That's a lot of money. 4. Taiwan wants to be friends with India . We are too scared to be friends with them to offend China. Check out the investments from Taiwanese in china. If we can get 50% of that here by being friends we can offset made in china to produce in India. Moreover it will help made in India defence exports if we export to Taiwan and codevelop say Tejas 2 together. There are a lot of low hanging fruits here and I am hoping Modi government will act now and they have the mandate of people of India.5. Non performing government units ? Sell please unless there is a core reason not to. 6. Tie up with Japan , Korea , Taiwan , Israel , Singapore , US for duty free Singapore or Hongkong in Andaman developed by these countries with Indian public/private partnership.
Auto down 41%, Agri growth down from 7% to 2%, Banking in crisis mode moving towards Bankruptcy. India has not seen this decline in 2 decades. Some experts say that actual Growth figures could be around 3.5% !!
Need to take immediate remedial steps like slashing GST across the board, stabilizing Banks, to give relief to Bussinesses and restoring confidence of the markets.
Lastly, you can have all the arrogance you want, when you achieve $5 Trillion target but not before. India has a great example to follow; China.
Good job.....
Excellent presentation
There were a series of statements which brought some negative sentiments in auto market. First the BS6 norms due to which Maruti Suzuki has decided to stop its production of diesel engines and that would definitely impact a buyers decision to go for a diesel car now even if its available cuz he will think of its resale value. There is another information regarding discontinuing all petrol and diesel cars in near future and making it completely electric. First electric vehicles are not completely proven. Needs some time to auto manufacturers to do some r and d to comeup with cost effective solutions. That one statement has made buyers to wait and go for a used car for a shorter run till they have some electric car options. If government wants to revive the auto sector. Cut down a little bit on BS6 cuz anyways the pollution from auto is far less than others in the country right now. Secondly, if govt want electric or alternative fuel solutions, give the buyers some tax benefits as an incentives.
Thank God the government has reacted to this and reduced it to BS4 for now. This will definitely help although the damage has already been done. Now it depends on how consumers react to this. Keeping my fingers crossed.
Let all the old vehicle go.
Let modern vehicle ply.
Possible? Government fully working COW, Triple Talaq, Ram Mandir. By achieving, 10 Trillions Dolors🇮🇳💰
Difficult but not impossible
Modi Ji hai to jhuth hai..
Bechara jhuth bhi ab to modiji ke samne shrma jaata hai..
India should follow Kautilya. He suggested a mainly public sector based economy with complete control of the government over the financial matter. Thus, Kautilya suggested renationalization of coal and other mines, of all banks, create a state trading organization to control imports, promote agriculture using subsidies and tax reduction.
A private sector-based economy cannot promote employment and it is anti-Kautilya.
GST is a disaster for most small and medium scale industries; Nationalized banks are not giving loans to small and medium scale industries. Small and medium scale industries have no choice but to the loan sharks. China is destroying the economy. China is exporting everything from railway carriages to mobile phones to India.
We Indians just want Rashtravaad.... We don't care about Low GDP, Auto crisis, High unemployment rate, Development etc.... Welcome to modi 's new India
Puja Bhatt sister why you are always sad, if you do n't like to tell lie on the behalf of RSS, if you
feel ashamed, then sister resign from RSS & join some NGO, or just tell people that we are going in rong direction & then feel good & happy.
Why there is no debate on how each individual should contribute
It can be achieved by manipulating the reality
True passismist or you just don't like this govt
I cannot comprehend how someone can have such high aspiration with what is happening around. Is this all "Eyewash" for Indians ?
I hope so, all the best-est.
The man sitting beside the anchor doesn't even know what is going on here
5:55 Ambani's sister
Possible if every body sell pakoda and tea. When bullshit is the government. You can't ask for more.
He just have to start from 3 Trillion to 5 Trillion and not from scratch 2Trillion more in 5 Years by these big talkers seems achievable
Chant Jai Shri ram 10001 times every thing will be ok
😂😂😂😭😭😭
Gurucharan Das analysis is reality, economy is falling steeply, suffering is large and clear. No chance of revival in near future. Hype
@anil oommen Then why another jumla of $5 trillion again? Tell whatever you can achieve. I'm pretty sure this $5 trillion jumla will be told to people and will ask people for their votes in coming elections.
Stop telling lies
Many educated people living the country,,, this is one of biggest problem,,,,
Let this situation continue until next election
Whose who r asking ,where's the coming from. ..the money has arrived from rbi
Even the lowest earner businessman tries to evade tax in India, and it has been going on for at least 30-40 years. The economic growth we saw in the past that was not the true representation of the actual growth, it was probably a certain percentage of the actual growth which happened due to the tax evasion. Now, after the demonetization and GST, it has become very hard for people to make dealing in cash and evade tax; that's the main reason of this economic slowdown. But eventually the Indian market will recover from this downfall and when it will happen the true economic boom will take place, because India will get the due money back as tax from each and every sell. When this will happen, only then India will take a step towards becoming an advanced country. Otherwise, the way the Indian economy and business were being run, India would not get close to any advanced economic countries in even 100 years. Now at least we have hope to become a great nation. Stop stealing money people and return whatever is due to the country. You help your country and country will also take care of you. If you guys have any doubt on whatever I have been explaining, I request you to do a little study on how business rules-regulations work in the USA and how the economy works in the USA. The USA gets money for the single penny spent. I have been living in the USA for 12 long years now, and have been experiencing it in real-time. I don't even carry cash here, max $5 in cash I would find in my wallet at any point of time. Most transactions happen via credit card in the USA, so, no one really can evade tax; this country runs on an economic cycle. Basically, whatever I spend, it will come back to me in a cycle. That's how the economy should be. But I am afraid to say that lately, I have been seeing many cash dealings are going on here and there, which is scary and could be a big reason of economic meltdown in the USA in future.
The discussion largely exposes the economic reality. Though there are optimisim and aspirational belligerence, the exodus of Indians to greener pastures is worrisome and bespeaks the doomsday approach. The red Taoism and beuricratic excess have to be contained immediately. Ease of doing business continue to evade us.
5 trillion is nothing for 1.3 billion people! India need to focus on very large scale, very expensive export opportunities to reach these numbers and then India can easily hit 15-20 trillion let alone 5 trillion. When you manufacture and sell/export 5 million plastic paper cups like China, barely 2.5 million US dollar comes in as a revenue because paper cup is .5 US$ or 50 cents item but when you build JUST ONE Nuclear submarine or Aircraft Carrier or Frigate or Miltary Tank or Missile, ATLEAST 20 MILLION US dollar comes in after exporting JUST ONE Warcraft! So focus should be on Defense Manufacturing, Infrastructure building, Modernization and Build, Buil, Build, Build, Build and only build!!!!! here is formula for 15-20 Trillion economy -----
---Build Nuclear Submarine and Export to others (15-200 Billion Market Potential)
--Build Aircraft carriers and Export to others (50-500 Billion Market Potential)
--Build Military Aircrafts and Export to others ( 500 Million - 15 Billion Market Potential)
--Build Fighter Aircrafts and export to others (100 Million to 5 Billion Market Potential)
--Build Diesel powered Frigates and Export to others (150 Million to 8 billion Market Potential)
--Build Diesel powered submarines and Export to others (500 milllion to 5 Billion Market Potential)
--Build Fighter Helicopters and Export to others ( 10 Million to 20 billion Market Potential)
--Build Indigenous Chinook Helicopters and Export to others ( 15 Million to 80 Billion Market Potential)
--Build Indigenous under-water drones and Export to others (45 Million to 100 Billion Market Potential)
--Build UAV, Drones and Export to others ( 100 Million to 50 Billion Market Potential)
--Build MT Arjun Tanks and variants and Export to others (10 Million to 3 Billion Market Potential)
--Build GPS Satellites and Launch, Export to others ( 500 Million to 200 Billion Market Potential)
--Build Indigenous Anti Missile System (THAAD) and Export to others (50 billion to 2 trillion Market Potential)
--Develop, train Nuclear Scientists, engineers, military technicians just like IT professionals and sell their talent ( 50 Billion to 1 trillion Market Potential) Indian need TCS, Wipro type firms who supply Nuclear Scientists, Military Aircraft Professionals, Pilots to other countries and export the talent!
If govt has nk money, how did it build the multimillion dollar statue which is the largest in the world
Govt is squeezing money from public in whatever way possible. If money goes to Govt., it is used more inefficiently. But if it's with public (actual user) it will be more efficient, powerful and grows fast.
Be Calm and Say Jai Sree Ram...
Sarah Jacob was a weather reporter many years ago.... now she doesnt allow people to complete their statements........
Yeh jo writer hai jayda tej ban rha hia book likhkar ,. Ground reality isko pata nai hai, economy ki band baji hai mai khud 6 month se naukri nai mil rahi.
the poor youth who were made to ask a lot of questions...... and then no answers were given pretty much sums up the present state of things.
Land holdings law for farmers should change how can they compete with other countries farmers owning 100or even 1k acres , our politicians should read the book the wealth of a nation by Adam Smith :)
Modi hai to mumkin hai!
You did not hear the statistician word we were in pressure to show good no.s the current GDP data may not be same
if all tht the govt has to do is pay salaries and services with the tax payers money then what does the govt so with the natural resources available in the country..?! till the time the govts are not going to make india run on its own nothing will ever b achieved.. japan a small country can export technology and so many different types of goods to the world without deteriorating its nature reserves why cant india?! depending on taxes is real backwardness of india..
Geetha Bhatt all sectors are down 50%. We're manufacturers - we know - we live, its easy to use term as 'challenges' the fact is your party doesn't know governance or the first thing about economy all your party knows divisive drama giri.
I agree with the ground level problem with a common man faces in day to day business. But ndtv needs to get some people in audience who has some meaning full question to ask.. which can help viewers to get some good answers from the panel
Just stop loans to private companies who have already borrowed more than 10 cr. Give loan to small and medium size enterprises, change Pvt LTD company rule and make the owner liable for all loans. Remove GSt all together, govt should stop it's misadventures in Kashmir and Assam, Balochistan, Afghanistan and remove that fool Doval as security advise. He is in fact bring in more dangers to India
dear india friend，5 year double giant country GDP，need 15% growth rate per year！that‘s insanity！if india get it done，that will be a miracle！
NDTV is happy now
interest i.e sood, will collapse the indian economy, so abstain from any loaning or any thing from the bank and interest based companies
Modi ji just make Swamy fm and just relax
We made fun of Pakistan & now let's not become a jocker to the world
Wat type of debate is dis...we want debates on Hindu Muslim...mandir masjid...ndtv should learn from aajtak n republic...abp etc,😂😂😂
The RSS is stupid. Now after 5 years where is the Baggage!!
Geeta Bhatt is real bhakt why the wrote Political Analyst with their name . You have to write BJP supporter. Sameer Kocher is related to media which is feeded by BJP. you visit his company's website you understand himself. I also opened it for first time.
RSS lady is ruñning out of ideas and gonna talk utter rubbish ...m sire before coming for this programe she must have not one infact two tea spoons of fresh GAU MUTRA
What is khatna
@@jaygar9368 Khatna means when a sanghee' sister get fked by Mulla lund its call khatna, hope your question got answered.
It is a very thorny path.
1 lac crore in five years means 20 thousand crs per year. Why r u saying 20 lac crore each year. You should watch ur numbers unless i missed my division class
Did a blunder in Kashmir then playing war war in words brought whole world's attention on kashmir Whose gonna invest in such uncertain conditions.
Oh dear all Muslims and Christian s have become jittery....
It was good debate. Thanks.
The sky is falling... the sky is falling... India does not need more cars and pollution.
If that debate was in Hindi then many people will understand it