Pro Scripter vs Roblox AI... (Should you be Worried?)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 окт 2023
- Check out my asset store! (Free Stuff to!): shoprobuilder.com/
RoBuilder Games (second Channel): / @robuildergames8563
RoBuilder Discord
- / discord
RoBuilder Fan Shirt
- www.roblox.com/catalog/642374...
- Thanks for watching! Discord -- / discord
It is useless when u asking an AI for scripts and have 0 knowledge about scripting
What are you yapping about
@@FrogKing831 he means if you dont have basic knowledge of scripting the AI is basically useless because you will get a lot of errors with the AI
@@enziiiiiiiii yes as a part time roblox dev ai its only good to use if u can’t find ur error ai can find it
Okay thanks since I had no clue what that meant 😂
That’s true. You need to give a lot of information to the AI for the script to work. Also it can’t do advanced scripts like at all
I like how you put subtitles for everything you say, but not any subtitles for when Robo talks (i can barely understand him)
I don't think he understood him either 😂
As someone learning english i understand every thing he said, maybe you did not understand what he say because you dont know what he's doing...
I didn't understand anything he said either
I didn't understand anything he said either
I didn't understand anything he said either
As someone considered to be a “Pro scripter”, in my experience AI will not take our jobs anytime soon because anytime I make a game using only AI it never works, I only use it when my scripts don’t work I always put it in AI asking for ideas to fix the script.
9:40 The problem is that the part is not defined. It is trying to use part.Parent but I think it meant to use script.Parent and the breakjoints() is supposed to break the weld for the chair but there is no weld on the chair and is basically useless because it is anchored
AI Has definitely came a long way, and its more reliable when it comes to scripting, but I still dont think we should be worried about AI. AI Would be a good tool to get the job done faster instead of just using it with no scripting knowledge. To use this AI you'd have to understand basic LUA and errors.
🤓
@@epicgamer11717 thanks for the compliment
🤓@@TooIstep
sup mommy@@TooIstep
sup daddy @@TooIstep
Saw you talk about wanting to make this video on last stream. And it turned out to be another banger video
Hey! these are my versions of the script aswell , "local KillPart = workspace:FindFirstChild("Part")
local function onTouch(input)
Character = input.Parent
Humanoid = Character:FindFirstChid("Humanoid")
if Humanoid then
Humanoid.Health = 0
end
end
KillPart.Touched:Connect(onTouch)"
This is such a easier way of doing it ^^
not sure why you had to use FindFirstChild to get the part, could have just done workspace.Part
Your right , im just very used to typing it out like that , thanks though ill start doinf that from now on!
@@yal1621
my version (the best obv). typed this here in the yt comment section btw
script.Parent.Touched:Connect(function(otherPart: Instance): void -- typing!!! I love it
local character = otherPart:FindFirstAncestorOfClass("Model") -- the parent of the touched part won't always be the character, and although this model still might not be, it's better than just otherPart.Parent
local humanoid = character:FindFirstChild("Humanoid")
if character and humanoid then
humanoid.Health = 0
end
end)
also, since I'm not using studio to make this, I'm not sure but I think character:Destroy() also works, so shorter and simpler but again Idk
@@qwerty_qwertywhat no char destroy wont work it just deletes the model or kinda i think the camera just stays frozen
Pd: it deletes it and locks the parent, so it cant be restored, i think only way is to use loadcharacter on the player whose character was disconnected and removed
thats such a long way of doing it
script.parent.touched:connect(function(hit)
if hit.parent:findfirstchild("Humanoid") then
hit.parent:findfirstchild("Humanoid").health = 0
of course u could use variables but i do it this way
i think ai is very useful for people that are new to script, but a little knowledge is still required. ty for the video, this was a so interesting. new sub
AI right now isn’t that bad for developers. Sure it can make cool GFX and simple codes but it’s not better than a human could do…yet
The gfx don't look nearly as good as the real thing, not even CLOSEEEEE. Its super buggy and glitchy, and thats good for GFX designers like myself.
open na noor
The problem with ai gfx is it cannot make it of specific characters so you would have to get a gfx artist
Cool Video! I really think it just depends how you word the prompt and how well it understands it. And I agree with you need atleast some scripting knowledge before using the AI.
Question: Do you think A.I is going to take your job as a modeler?
It prob won’t it’s very rare to see AI create 3D models and if it can it will be hard cus u won’t be able to create items from specific shows and stuff
Question:
How do you build things that are to the scale of the character I have been struggling making building and houses to the scale of a player.
You can take a rig to scale it, just put the rig next to your creation and compare the scale (rig are like the character of a player)
Question, why do mediocre games, like very casual and reskinned, even rip off of rip off tends to be popular than quality games in roblox? I am a bit concerned on games that were given effort not being give the recognition they deserve, does this thought also affect your game that you are developing in some way?
I think it's because most of popular games are played by kids who prefer playing a low effort game made for kids than a good game which took lots of time to make and have original ideas.
Also people don't know how much time the good games take to make, they can't know because they're not developers.
Bright colors and popular trends attract children like a moth to a flame.
@@gunipotys you do have a point, they are still young so they don't know how to make a game yet
@@OverSimplifiedScripting tons of flashy games tbh
Cuz they're more fun
i really love the new roblox assistant, it helps me out a ton
as a programmer myself, AI will never beat the brains of theyre creators, the problem with ai is that when you script you need to think of a idea originally if you want to code a game yourself. some times ways people script unlocks more complex ideas
but with ai they can only learn by what they are given and ai still doesnt have even the understanding of a 3 year old since it cant do stuff in its own way it can only do things that people teach it to do, so yeah humans win, unless someone makes an ai with ideas they will not beat us humans.
I tested the AI and its actually really good at stuff
what it made was
A Board that can be summoned by pressing F when you click R the board goes to your location and follows you around when you hold Q it goes up and when you hold e it goes down when you press T you get teleported to the board which has a teleport animation using tweenservice and stuff and then you click Z u can send the board to your mouse when you click C you can change modes for the board Q and E now resize the board
-- It did take a while for the ai to correct it and there werent errors just no checks which i had to specify for the ai to do
Would be nice to see more videos like this one ❤
NAH BRO TRY THE BING AI USING PRECISE OPTION, ITS SO GOOD I ASK IT TO MAKE A DAY AND NIGHT CYCLE AND IT DOES ITS SO GOOD
Is the scripting done in Roblox studios? If it is, is that some sort of add-on that explains what you type or is that a base function? I have never tried scripting in Roblox before, but I do understand some basic similarities between programs languages. If Roblox studios gives tips on the program your writing, then it doesn’t seem to hard to learn. I may try scripting in Roblox studios later.
AI coding a scary game VS a pro scripter, and you make map?
Question: can you tell me how to advertise my game without robux?
I mean like in my opinion it’s not useful for a normal person as it messes up like a lot of times and ofc it can generate with like a killer prompt, but a normal person doesn’t know that 😅 I feel it makes SCRIPTER job easy? As they can generate main of it faster ngl.
Team agree
👇
I liked my own comment ig
For new people, AI is better(I have a working but boring game and I know nothing in the scripting department) but pro scripters have way more capabilities and don't have to do deal with useless yapping from ai
There is 2 problem about ai taking in roblox its that alot of people would lose ther job also getting robux would be very common which means robux would be cheaper and other games are gonna make ther gamepasses cost more basically inflation but in roblox
When is robo gonna fix his tycoon kit ( I haven’t forgotten mate )
9:37 pretty sure the chair had to be welded together and not anchored. Still the ai technically failed
15:44 i love that
I love your vids RoBuilderkeep up the great work
Hey robuilder, i got a problem. I’m trying to do a 6k robux commision but i can’t import any 3d models from import 3d object. It says something like “error, try again and report if this keeps happening” this happend yesterdary. Do you know what’s wrong
u don't worry about that I'll introducing AI CHAT DEEPAI the AI CHAT DEEPAI is so powerful and much better than OPENAI since start 2015-2018 and u can show ur picture and video and anything u want
i have 0 knowledge of scripting and i asked ai to make that when you touch a part a gui saying : thanks for playing pop up and then it kicks you after 5 seconds and it all worked
I kinda get how AI is helpful, but to take what creative geniuses have to offer on platforms and make that somewhat assessable to people might get annoying. I feel like creators that actually have talent should be respected and make game development mostly user generated.
Here's how I see it: I want to make a game. I don't know how to script. I can either spend a long time learning how to script (not happening), or hire someone who can script (expensive).
0:20 why you get rid of the subtitles as soon as robo talks lol
Wow! liked robo font! can you ask him what is his font?😮❤
i think the ai is very practical if you have some basic scripting knowledge
I think AI Has come along way but I don't think it will match the uniqueness of our scripting (I am not a scripter) Ai neither has the imaginaton as us humans I would say It can help you but not do it entirely. ❤ ❤ Keep in mind I am not a scripter I just think this
edit : it can do cool gfx and help sometimes with codes but It could become better then us at some things
some constructive criticism for robo!
on the first script, there was no reason to get the player instead of the humanoid, getting the humanoid would not just be easier, but also make the killbrick work for any npcs you may have in the game.
for the second script, there was really no reason to put that end bit in a task.spawn function, when .touched fires it automatically creates a new thread anyway. if you really HAD to make a new thread you could have just used task.delay instead of task.spawn + task.wait
for the third one, robo is doing an extremely bad practice, as hes setting the parent of the new instance within instance.new(), instead of manually setting the parent after you've set the position and etc. Im not getting into detail on why this is bad, you can find reasons online pretty easily
fourth one is mostly fine but there's still a few issues. instead of defining the chair variable as script.Parent.Parent, you could have just done seat.Parent. also, there was no reason to use pairs() in that for loop, it would have worked fine without it. you could have also used :Once() instead of :Connect() as the chair is only going to unanchor once
fifth is fine, probably how I would have done it, it's just that you copied the touch detection from the killbrick, which I said was flawed (use humanoid over plr)
You got discord?
@@IsaihaRapid why
I do not see why on the 2nd script you would use task.spawn with a task.wait, task.delay exist for a reason...
@@Iceministerq yea, thats why i said "you could have just used task.delay instead of task.spawn + task.wait"
@@yal1621Woops mb i read it too fast, tho his pro scripter is a little wacky...
question: will you extend the offer?
Noticed the chair thing in the background started to move 14:56
I made a AI write a Phyton code (forgot the name) And it gave A lot of errors 💀
thats very cool and very scary at the same time.
guys can anyone tell me how he made his 2:04 roblox studio like that the search onject the writting and all
I only use ai for scripts when my teacher is on vacation and I have an update deadline to do something I don’t know how to script
How to access Roblox ai assistance it is not showing in my.
Honestly, I don't think we should be worried about AI taking scripters jobs if it can't make a simple script without errors.
4:58 How do he have textourse when you click on leaderboard
Hi
Can you Make me a roblox map and it has events
@@_TechMaster_ima wish you luck.
@@Drago-jk2kn Thanks
Question:How to make a game more fun?
Try making games that you enjoy, or a popular theme
Add gameplay features
the ai assistant is CHEEKS.. chat GPT plus ON TOP!!! I've made like 10 unfinished games just testing stuff out and some are semi comlicated that I wouuld never be able to do without Chat GPT.
when is the asssinst rolling out for everyone
don't worry scripters. I tried this out too it's good for the simple scripts but when you ask for something just a little bit difficult it gets it wrong. so don't worry and like robuilder said a pro is always the way to go
no, robuilder's prompts are just trash. AI can easily script very advanced concepts using the correct prompts. You could even provide an entire API reference for AI to read and then give a prompt based on that. My point is that you need to be half decent at scripting before AI is useful
@@simvoid4347 i’m saying about the prompts i told it, not robuilder’s.
@@SneakyyBoxing then you probably dont have a good understanding of scripting and gave it trash prompts 🤷
@@simvoid4347I Agree Roblox was founded for a vision and now Generative AI became that what it's founder wanted so yea it makes sense that they have made it better so that we don't get confused in it + They also made this AI so we can learn more about Lua and get Helped in Scripts from Basic to Advanced scripts like Lua Armour and in my opinion if it can code Lua Armour scripts it's just op.
If you still need better results you need to become a prompt expert or prompt engineer (kinda)
ai is good as automatization for workflow, as an idea.
but the realization just sucks imo
Day 12: Asking RoBuilder How Roblox Algorythm Works
Bro i started scripting 7 days ago, now ai is taking it away, i think i might leave roblox forever😢
don't worry ai is actually VERY BAD at scripting
"Professional" sure.. These are easy questions a toddler can even create
As a wise man once said if you are scared that ai will take your job then you are not that good at what you are doing
Question for robuder: Question?
Lol i actually learned Lua in this video!
Here's my opinion on each of the rounds:
FIrst Round:
The AI won in the first challenge as Rebuilder asked for the programmer to "Make a Kill Part" which by definition should kill anything that touches it. While the AI did do this successfully by looking for anything that has a humanoid and setting the humanoids health to 0, I can't say the same about Robo as he made a kill part that specifically looks for if the model that touched it is a player then killing it, completely disregarding NPC's.
Second Round:
In the second round Robo won the round. This is solely due to the fact that the AI had an oversight where if the part was larger and the player triggered multiple touch events on the part it would glitch out and constantly swap between a fast walk speed and a slow walk speed, and when the player steps off of the part the player would instantly lose their walk speed. On the other side Robo's approach was still flawed but less so, so I would give it to Robo. (It's to be noted that the language on RoBuilder's task was very vague, so I assumed that the timer should start once the player fully stepped off of the part, and restarted when going back on to avoid visual issues)
Round Three:
In the third round the AI won, even though it had an error. While most of the logic was there for the AI it had the one issue where it was looking for a part to replicate when ever the player pressed the main part, this issue was quickly fixed by robuilder (but not really in the most efficent way). On the other hand Robo lost easily as the task was completely misinterpreted even with quite clear instructions.
Round Four:
In the fourth round Robo won by a land slide. To sum it up, the AI's code was riddled with flaws from using depricated methods like BreakJoints (Which also assumes that the chair is welded and not anchored which completely goes against the prompt given) and it assumed that the Instance:PropertyChangedSignal(property) would fire a parameter like BasePart.Touched, which if you check the documentation is completely wrong. While on the other side Robo gave a near flawless piece of code to unanchor each of the parts of the chair when sat on.
Round Five:
In the fifth round Robo won again, mainly due to the fact that Robo's code worked and the AI was trying to use method's that didn't even exist in the documentation.
Great opinions imo
You have a great future
Robuilder pls make another video about pro versus AI 😊
No because AI simply can’t think like a person, it uses data and predicts. AI is impressive and useful as a professional coder however.
Robo programs in a unique style from mine, but is very talented.
My thoughts as a beginner Roblox scripter: How can the AI not be able to code some easy scripts when it is being fed the entire API? (Fix your AI Roblox 💀)
AI: OK, here's the code (it doesn't work)
Me: This is so easy
Funfact: "Robo" or just "Robô" means Robot in portuguese, soo.. ARE BOTH AI??? 🤨🤨 /j
damn im doing a project for my university on ai use in game creation, wish i knew about this it would have been fun tow write about. But even before watching the video i bet the conclusion is "its a great tool for a programmer, but you still need knowledge of programming to use it"
Amazing Video as always!
There are some things that AI cannot do and scripters would be great at that I bet. So no, you should not be worried about them taking our jobs.
ai is really good but it might still be good to learn scripting aswell just like a calculator you need to understand how it works to use it
edit: its only for if it doesnt work other then that its good for learning from
bru tried making the ai make a script and it told me to google it. then it told me it dont understand. L chat GPT it is.
FINISH YOUR DREAM GAME and can u make cool ugc for the game too I want to play SOOOOOO BAD
question: Is making an Obby a great way for me to learn modelling and scripting?
(for starters)
In my opinion, it could be, especially for scripting. Spinning parts, kill parts, checkpoints, and UI are some very simple things you can script that can teach you stuff such as loops, events, (and CFrames!). For modeling, it may not be the best project for that case, but you can still use Blender for props and ramps. So in my opinion, yes.
thank you for your opinion!@@ProCodeGaming
@@gamewithog No problem!
can someone maybe say me whitch font he is using to script?
ehhh u just move in I'll introducing AI CHAT DEEPAI the AI CHAT DEEPAI is so powerful and much better than OPENAI since start 2015-2018 and u can show ur picture and video and anything u want
GUYS why is Db = {} and NOT Db = false?
Cuz you want create debounce for each player diffrent if you use db = false instead making table for each players, that's no sense cuz if Player1 touch the part he get speedboost but if Player2 touch the part the part still have debounce so the boost not gonna work for Player2 only when Player1 lost their boost and debounce back to true
Make ai versus you in blender modeling😂
Roblox ai is trash I remember one time I was scripting and I just wanted the ai to finish the the 3 ends at the bottom (at some point I accidentally deleted them) and it said something like elseif print (“goofyaa”) if Humanoid,health = 0 (for context I just randomly named the script goofy aa script)
When it comes to intertwined system human will always win, hell in terms of how clean code is human will win
Day 2: Question: Could you pls make a new section in your store and we can buy it with robux because I would love to help you out and also I love the things you make but I don't have paypal and my parents won't let me buy things with cash. But I have robux and I think that even more people could buy some. EXEMPLE: For lets say a chocolate cookie, you put the buy now and below a link of the model that we could buy it
how to open that ai?
Click file, "Beta Features", scroll until you find "Assistant Preview, click the little box to the left of it, then press save
Ai is too weak for more than 40 lines of code, I know because I tested. And without help it locks up already at 20 lines XD
Robo has a german accent
THERES 2 FUCKING PARTSSSSS NAMED PARTTTT
he is german i think he sounds like it
Mr Rabbit approves this video
ok
do more ai vids
Pls do more
uhh can you make me a game?
I’m Worrired
People that want to create their game won’t use AI, it’s better to use real life scripters.
Only problem one will want to get paid other don't
Its better to ask chatgpt💀☠️
woo
hes asking the easiest questions
4 MINUTES AGO 23 LIKES
Day 9 I've waiting for your reply from discord
banana
NOT TO BE RUDE BUT BROS HEAD IS FR BUILT LIKE A RECTANGLE BRO IM SORRY 😭
wow
you copied my video
naaa robo
Im not even that good but can win against the gpt
theodore
10 minutes gang
👇👇👇