Mystery of FRB 121102 - Probably Not Aliens, But Here's What We Know
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 сен 2024
- You can buy Universe Sandbox 2 game here: amzn.to/2yJqwU6
Hello and welcome to What Da Math!
In this video, we will talk about a new developed in the ongoing mystery of Fast Radio Bursts - specifically FRB 121102
Read the paper here: blpd0.ssl.berke...
Support this channel on Patreon to help me make this a full time job:
/ whatdamath
Space Engine is available for free here: spaceengine.org
Enjoy and please subscribe.
Twitter: / whatdamath
Facebook: / whatdamath
Twitch: / whatdamath
Bitcoins to spare? Donate them here to help this channel grow!
1GFiTKxWyEjAjZv4vsNtWTUmL53HgXBuvu
The hardware used to record these videos:
CPU: amzn.to/2LZFQCJ
Video Card: amzn.to/2M1W26C
Motherboard: amzn.to/2JYGiQQ
RAM: amzn.to/2Mwy2t4
PSU: amzn.to/2LZcrIH
Case: amzn.to/2MwJZz4
Microphone: amzn.to/2t5jTv0
Mixer: amzn.to/2JOL0oF
Recording and Editing: amzn.to/2LX6uvU
Great content anton. You deserve more views and subscribers!
Agreed
This FRB is a natural FRB in our Universe. This natural FRB we can use this for communication in milliseconds signal for cellphone and internet etc. to communicate from Galaxy to Galaxy.
Anton I don't understand how you don't get more views. Your videos are absolutely amazing.
The signals may look random because of the motions of the source and receiver (us) and interference (gravitational and electromagnetic) during the signals' travel through interstellar space. Huge power is needed to get the signal across interstellar space relatively undamaged. We can probably only detect remnants from relatively close sources. Most likely these are just escaping photons from a civilization's power sources, not forms of communication. That's what most human signals are. They should be random.
Wrrooooong. MOST LIKELY?? STOP CONFUSING WISHFUL THINKING WITH RATIONAL THOUGHT. The MOST LIKELY thing is a natural occurrence. Sorry :( :( mwaa
3 million years ago, in a galexy 3 million light years away, a young, optimistic civilization started broadcasting a becon to the rest of the cosmos to say "Hello? We're here! Anybody else out there?"
They decided to make the signal random to let other civilizations know their broadcast wasn't a natural event...
Extreme speculation:
Could FRB's be the light burst from some type of FTL-Drive...
Kind of the way, a aircraft makes a sonic boom when it bust the sound zone...
Or maybe, a natural way of FTL-jumps, from some type of worm whole.
Just a guess..
Here's a thought. If we humans were beaming an encoded message, wouldn't that data look random? Any computer nerd has probably tried to open a video file with Notepad. What you see is random garbage. If you don't have the proper key, you can't decode it. So if we go down the alien rabbit hole, I'd guess it was an encoded message.
It's interesting that with these new radio telescopes that we haven't picked up any definite 'Alien' signals or something that could be from an intelligent source,why would that be? Because 'they' are either not anything like us,or there's nothing else out there at all. Great video Anton,thanks for that.
Could it be a collection of black holes very close to the super massive black hole at the center of the galaxy all consuming stellar material and the change in frequencies are varying due to which of the black holes are consuming it but also their relative positions altering the frequencies with relativistic effects?
I love you bro!!! You are by far my favorite channel on RUclips!!!! I could watch you all day!!! Keep it up brother!! Your videos get me through my day!!! Much love my man!!!
I really enjoy all your videos. Keep up the great work!
I wonder what would happen if two magnetars collided and subsequently merged. Would it collapse into a black hole, would it simply become a more powerful magnetar, would it turn into a garden-variety neutron star, or would something entirely unexpected occur?
I think it would collapse into a black hole.
telephony two objects so powerful and dense would most likely explode in to a hyper Nova and then form in to a black hole... I’m probably wrong though.
Anton your a very smart guy and also up to date on space events... I know your above all this but can you please put to bed all the theorys of Niburu entering our solor system... Thank you and love your channel.
This isn't a conspiracy. These are real signals that we have received. Since we don't know what causes them it's natural to assume it's some type of alien communication until we have found evidence that suggests otherwise.
You're smarter than most, Anton, so if you posted a theory of yours about everything unknown, I'd be cool w/ it, right or wrong
I would love to see a theory made by anthon, he knows maths and knows astronom, he has the enough knowledge to make one
@@Kiromony i hope you understand the difference between a scientific theory and some theory posed by someone on youtube
Great video , I love your content keep it up!
Getting more questions than answers is to be expected with a title starting "Probably not aliens, but ..."
Having a feeling that you're wrong is the very essence of science. Good on you Anton.
Let's say it is an advanced alien race - you wouldn't want your advanced communications detected so you'd make it look like it isn't a communication. So for example if some distant world might detect you, you'd be happy knowing their primitive minds wouldn't be able to decipher you. Not that a radio signal travelling such a vast distance would be anything close to what it originated as.
Fantastic Anton. I had not even heard of this yet, and I keep tabs on most of the good science shows. It's amazing what machine learning can do. I wonder if the same machine learning could tell us what is producing the signal. Wouldn't it be wild if it predicted the source to be from an intelligent civilization!
My very first thought was perhaps it's an alien civilization that's only just learned to utilize radio waves and they're experimenting with em.
Far more likely: its something natural that once figured out will open whole new lines of study, yay!
If you can use your eyes as a camera connected to your Technologies, you can use also FBR as a WiFi in the universe. You understand now?
Alright, here’s a tricky question. So you know how the theory of relativity says how the further you approach the speed of light, the more mass you gain. And when you reach the speed of light you’d have infinite mass. But protons travel at the speed of light (and are light) but don’t have mass, yet they are influenced by objects such as black holes. But radio waves emit off of black holes, but they travel the same speed as light, right? Is this a paradox or am I wrong?
Our own radio signals wouldn't ever get detected due to how weak they are - fall apart over a vast distance. We don't use the power of a years worth of sun to send them.
Slightly crazy idea: maybe it's a new form of Blackhole that is causing dimensional faults to rupture and the resulting energy creates these bursts at random and often.
These repeated fast radio bursts make me wonder what would happen if you slowed down the burst like slowing down an audio recording. Could there be information in there that we can't detect at higher speeds?
Here's a question for you, Anton.
How big can a terrestrial planet truly get? What happens to it if it gets bigger than a "Super Earth"?
Fascinating stuff Anton, it's probably not aliens but, it's Aliens.
Even if somebody would find an alien trash in space, they will never say "it is aliens, but here it is what we know"...
I'm not a physicist or anything, but at such great distances how can they be anything but randomised? Like how visible light is "bent" (don't know the proper terminology) by gravitational lensing, it's the same light, but is perceived differently because of that interference by an object with great mass. Obviously I'm not saying that's what's happening here, it's just an analogy.
What if we are seeing the "scraps of what is left" after they (FRBs) have traveled across billions of lightyears, like how current is weaker in longer wires because of resistance. Have we ever detected any FRB's from this galaxy? It would be interesting to see what one of those would be like when compared to one sourced from outside the galaxy.
Really great content. Very well explained. Thank you !
This is fascinating. Thanks, Anton!
What's the name of FRB 121102 origin galaxy? I can't find anything on Google; it just mentions distant galaxies without names.
Who liked the old wat da math intro better I know he's had this one for a while but the old one was better
these signals ,or "events" happened billions of years ago, and moving at light speed, took billions of years to reach earth.
Since patterns are so common in the universe maybe aliens choose to make something repeat randomly with no predictable pattern. Sort of like saying, hey look over here at this weird thing going on.
They are at different frequencies, yes. But we use many different frequencies in our communications. I don't see why this would be a problem if someone else wanted to do the same thing.
Just a shot in the dark here, possibly a magnatar (I know I probably spelled that wrong) locked in a close elliptical orbit around a super massive black hole or possibly in orbit around a binary black hole
Can you teach what's a magnetor in a separate video?
If advanced communication signals are digital (i.e. using binary digits) rather than old-fashion analog signals, or if radio signals were FM and not AM, would we be able to tell them apart from non-alien signals?
Eyes and FBR is only a basic reverse engineering designed. You understand what I mean?
Isn't it possible for the signal to be distorted?
Thank you so much , you found my lost smartphone !
Great job and interesting analysis..
My pet theory is that the FRB source is actually the ghost of Douglas Adams
Assuming aliens have the same linguistic logic we have. Assuming they are not long gone, 3 billion lightyears away.
So this is just another name for the Lorimer Burst, right?
Going to do a video on the 'Vulcan Planet' found 16 light years away?
Thought it was supposed to be a pulsar lighting a galaxy in front of it.
What if it is aliens, but the variance is caused by the extreme distance the signal has traveled and it simply got garbled on its way through gas clouds and interstellar radiation?
What about Gina's footage from the sun Anton?
i hope it doesn't turn out to be the lunch room microwave oven at the observatory again like last time...... great video anton
Ok, is there any information encoded in the signals?
This Time It Actually is aliens
hahaha
keith irvine definitely
But they are mumberling can't talk clearly.
Some day it will be aliens.
Aliens long range "just one more video" wifi
Fascinating.
It’s probably a alien body (like a star) that’s disproportionate to its partner in a binary space and something is using the gravity wells it provides and shooting radio signals through that.
In other terms, it’s a shit post.
Cosmic shitposting, I love it lol
It's a giant space swastika
It’s the output from a “Hello World” program with a memory leak...
A memory leak... From a "Hello World" program, one of, if not, the simplest of programs to write. Well, we've all got to start somewhere, I suppose.
What if FRB 121102 are a bunch of random signals sent by aliens
In another words, what if those aliens are just sending random signals to different places
My thoughts exacty. I was thinking of something like switching through radio stations. Maybe these signals have different meanings. We don't know. It bothered me he says "We know it's not aliens". But....scientist who study this don't even know what it is. 🤷🏿♂️
Probably trying to discover life other than them just like us
You should keep in mind a couple of things. FRB 121102 is located in a dwarf galaxy 3 billion light years away. That means that whatever event is the source of those signals happened 3 billion years ago. Secondly the power that is needed for each one of those signals is equal to the total amount of energy produced by the sun in a year! So we are talking about something that produces the energy of a whole G type star in a year in just a few milliseconds or less. And it has done it dozens of times so far. I find very hard to imagine that that kind of energy output can be something artificial,especially signals. I mean what civilization would use energy enough to destroy a whole solar system just to communicate? It sounds absurd.
Or this signal is equal to "send nudes" in our languages.
Or they make it random to not be discovered as a communication method.
Looked like frequency hopping spread spectrum, sort of.
Weird.
I know it isn't, but it looked close.
I thought Stars and Gas Giants send out certain types of raidio waves from raidiation and magnetic poles.
Does anyone have a pointer to a high SNR, full-rate recording of one of these events.
The view/sub ratio matches the big youtubers' ones...
It's probably not aliens, but...
Let's be real. It's aliens.
Anton science is best science.
Hi 👋 anton great 👍 video of the universe plenty going on there but not any aliens 👽 yet ❤️🇬🇧🚀David
Question : Can we use the gravitational assist from the sun to get to Ouranos and Neptune?
Thanos*
@@SlyRyFry Thanos car*
In Soviet Russia they called Uranus Ouranos!
“Probably not aliens” but it probably could be too?
If it's aliens they are probably extinct by now and we're just picking up the signal now, them being at random frequencies doesn't necessarily rule exterrestrial origin
The differences in frequencies and duration just means they broadcasted at different times and at different frequencies and we're just now picking those up.
Hi anton :)
Interesting...
Definitively aliens!
Or it's an electric pulse!?
Challenge accepted !
yay aliens confirmed
Maybe it's doesn't make sense to us because we are not intelligent enough to understand,
Imagine sending signals to a fly
Being billions of years in the past, does it really matter what it is? Anyone's guess is just as valid or invalid as anyone else's.
My guess is likely something primodial to the universe. Maybe it's the baby hiccups of God. Who knows.
Actually, from their point of view we're the ones who mumble.
I had an Fast radio burst happen on my livestream on twitch i clipped it as well sent it to nasa and turns out it was that same galaxy you were talking about of magnatars as well which are highly radioactive and magnetic as well i got excited because i wasnt sure what it was i thought it was maybe regular interference and or game lag or something computer related but nope it came from a Galaxy
And all you said is impossible
Wroong.
You could have at least played the actual radio signal….. cant believe I watched the whole video to hear in broken English,what I’ve already read.
That's one werid name for some weird object
I haven't been on the channel for a while and I was the first person here
No
Yes
Decode it to discover alien memes
FRB GOD
what da FRB?
aliens:
-elyans-
*aylianz*
They admitted they only know about 4%....
Would you go to a 4% doctor, lawyer.... engineer.... heck gas station?
Yet you Be Lie ve
dont try to translate --- it`s a death ray --- :-)
My question, do you question?
convert kilobits/hertz in sound
First view I think
Edit : Maybe maybe not but I’m one of the first people
Roblox poohack87_isback well your thought is wrong
FYI...we will never ever ever understand "everything" coming from our universe. Please be more specific in your word choices Anton.
you can't see data........
Its another Donald Trump tweeting in another galaxy.
👁️👄👁️
Are you an astronomer?If not you should be,concidering how smart you are.
You look like Elon Musk
First like!
Roblox poohack87_isback and you got first comment
Probably not first view though but definitely first comment
ur other videos w/o showing u narrarating it are better . ppl dnt need to c u bruh .