"Sometimes I feel that Irrfan did his job so effortlessly that we forgot that he was not that character." I'm sure Irrfan Sir somewhere smiled after watching this. It is that beautiful.
"Sometimes I feel that Irrfan did his job so effortlessly that we forgot that he was not that character." - Spot on. I feel like this is the primary reason why that after his death many people felt like they have lost a family member yet they don't know that they considered him as one. He so effortlessly blended in our everyday worldview which can only be consciously felt so deeply by its absence.
You may be right. Every few months since his death, I become aware that he's gone. And it breaks my heart all over again. So I binge videos about him or try to watch a movie of his.
Ur observation is good, but comparing amitabh, Irrfan is not quite right I think, I agree Irrfan is great actor but credit must also given to Mira Nair who is master in sculpting characters, and I believe if amitabh bachchan ever work with Mira Nair it would be one of the greatest performance of his career.
stop being delusional, yes irrfan is a great at acting without effort and just because he become known in hollywood doesnt mean hes higher than amitabh bachchan, they are both good actors
As an introvert man myself, I could see Irfan's soul through his eye. I felt like he had immense sorrow but somehow he had built wall around it. I have never cried even when my relatives passed away but I cried when Irfan passed away. I felt I knew that guy in and out and felt he was someone close to me.
Ashok telling his son that just remember it till the end...that we went to a place where there was no where left to go...how beautiful is that. Irrfan sir will stay in our hearts forever.
The "Namesake" is the first movie with Irfan Khan that I have ever watched. I immediately fell in love with his acting skills. His jodi with Tabu was amazing, no words needed to describe their mutual love, affection and respect, it was all about the aura. May his soul rest in peace!
@@varunitripathi6619have you seen the movie "A MIGHTY HEART"???. I have tried to find this movie everywhere but I couldn't. If you know about it then answer me in reply. It is one of the best movie of irfan khan.
This was lovely. I have mixed feelings about the Namesake but Irrfan and Tabu were flawless. For some reason I felt nostalgic about Irrfan today, and rather sad, so found your channel. A beautiful tribute to such a talent. At least we still have so many of his wonderful performances.
Honestly I have tried to live this charecter of ashok. His English has an impeccable bengali accent. I am sure this charecter is more bengali as in the cultural way of life (like their house in Kolkata bit broken and messy, the jamai soshti handfan with red dips on the ends,the curly usually uncombed hair, liberal traits in an orthodox setup, the loose pants style usually famous in Mithun Chakraborty movies in 90s , the shy romance, square and thick fram) than most people who are Bengalis like myself. Sometimes unknowingly I try to walk smoke and try to look( I never shave off my moustache trim it and keep it sharp) like ashok. It's weird but I find it quite liberating. I truely feel the pangs of separation from this amazing actor. Little would he ever know how deep he has impacted my charecter. Haha. Life's amazingly uncertain.
I was having my breakfast in my hostel, getting late to go to library. So i thought to watch a short video on RUclips to give me company while i eat. But i wanna tell you that i just took a bite of my bread butter and started the video. And after 10 minutes i realised i have been just holding my bread in my hand (with just the initial bite) and my mind was imagining what you were conveying. I know I am getting lil emotional but i think this clip deserves much more. Thank you so much to IRRFAN Sir and to you who made this video by clubbing your beautiful story telling art (pardon me... I dont know your). name).
You have done an incredible analysis. There are 3 scenes of Irrfan sir, from 3 movies, which will remain with me forever : 1. "Everyday since then has been a gift..." says Irrfan to his son (Kal Penn), as he explains the rationale behind the name 'Gogol' (Movie: The Namesake) 2. "Don't you ever cut your bloody vegetables on the office files" Irrfan chides Nawazuddin Siddiqui, without looking up at him , while just having saved him from getting fired (Movie: The Lunchbox) 3. "Burden, burden... emotional blackmail karke pata nahi parents ko kya sukh milta hai" Irrfan stops the car, visibly irritated, and looks neutrally to say it out, almost like a soliloquy (Movie: Piku)
Remember you and me made a journey where there were nowhere to go... We all came out from Gogol's Overcoat... being a vivid film follower and interested in Indian Diasporic literature, this has been one of the best movie.. and I would thank you for making such an analytical work.
Still today i could not come out of heart breaking shock of the passing away of this versatile actor and generous human being from this earth.. Miss you IRRFAN SIR
Are u in anyways related to the Governor of New York Mr. Andrew Cuomo? If u are, then I'd like to say that he is doing a pretty good job against Corona Virus. Wishing u well from India.
Genius portrayal of Irfaan. He was indeed a gem. I watched this movie long ago, when I wasn't even a fan of his. You are true in saying that he does his work with such subtlety and finesse that he blends in completely to the story.
Dear Cinemawali: Just found this channel. How beautifully you write and express, but more than that it is your eye---you noticed it ALL. Thanks. This movie is a master piece. I will forever be angry that this was not nominated for the best movie of the decade--Thanks for such a wonderful tribute!! Beautifully written. Hope you write articles as well.
Both played Bengali uncles of totally different kind. While Irrfan's character in Namesake was calm, subtle yet vulnerable at times, Bachchan's character was that of a loud mouth, cranky, critical, living life on his own principles. Even though I agree Irrfan Khan's level of acting is higher than BigB, but still comparisons shouldn't be made between 2 characters because the characters are poles apart at the very script level.
I accidentally watched the video and Now I would like to thank you for giving us this beautifully analysed video....What an actor he was!!!!! Our bollywood industry is really unfortunate that it didn't explore his talent in right time....and when it started realising the legend, he left us forever.......loved the video, love his acting, he will be there in our mind forever ......💓💓💓💓💓💓💓
It breaks my heart every time it dawns on me that Irrfan Khan is no more in this physical world. Yet, work such as yours will enable him to remain more and more etched in our hearts and minds.
@Cinemawali,This isn't just a movie review; it's a reflection on finding inner peace. I've watched this video nearly ten times in the past year. You are the Irrfan Khan of your field. The voice and background music are soothing, and I hope others find it as calming as I do. The use of the right vocabulary at the right time leaves a lasting impression on everyone.
OH MY GOD..,!! you have such an acute observation, it's as if you give a voice to all the unsaid ways we could have appreciated him. Reminds me of a song " inside you lives every song that you never sang" You give voice to those melodies of appreciation. Thank you.
i accidentally hit upon this video while frantically looking for this movie. Well so say in short, you have done a fabulous job working on the body language of this wonderful actor. Excellent analysis and I am glad that you subtly said that Big B performance in PIKU was quite irritating and could not handle the brashness of Irrfan
Beautifully explained about the legends work...my favourite actor is no more is like something dying inside me ..we will not be able to see him alive...but the way he proved himself in the field of film industry is outstanding...his magnanimous personality will never be forgotten by Indian and whole world
His small detail were phenomenal, I remember in a seen from hasil where he is beating the minister with his slippers, if you notice it’s so delicately done as, the intention is not to hurt him, but insult him and make him feel vulnerable. Amazing.Rip mate!🙏
What an amazing video and how beautifully you have analyzed his performance... This is how we should discuss cinema or actors... Sadly in india film journalism is in such a bad shape but channels like this are blessing for film lovers... Thank you...🙏😊
Unfortunately you lost me when you displayed the desperate urge to compare the two actors and did so. It was unnecessary. Comparison shouldn't be considered intelligent or needed for any purpose. Perhaps editing/ deleting the first few minutes of this video will give it some credibility.
Thank you for reminding that thus was the first movie of Irrfan Khan which I saw, and this movie did planted a seed of a different life all because of his role he played in that movie from that train accident to the ending... Really appreciate.
Thank you for sharing such a beautiful video where we can see Irrfan’s brilliant art minutely. As we now he is an actor who do his art effortlessly using his eyes. Now come to know how excellent way he is using body too. Amazing gem as an actors as a human being true, honest, god of simplicity, humble, give so respect to all, hard working, his life is open to all. He is so real in his life and in his act. Definitely no one can match him. Today’s actors can’t copy him too. He will be always around us. We can learn so many things from him.He must love this video!
Describing irrfan khan's acting in words is difficult. though i found his work mesmerizing i always thought how his acting is unique from others but watching your video just removed all the confusions No doubt your observation and research is extensive and well presented.
Wow ! I am feeling relieved, I would watch any artistic movie multiple times 10 times or even more because I am never satisfied with what I learn as various aspects of acting skills. People would label me as weird and stupid for doing so, but your analysis shows me I am not doing anything wrong. It is an art to do so and not getting bored unlike all. I loved Irfan Khan for his simplicity, on the day I received his news I with mom watched his aap ki adalat episode watched 2 of his great movies - Maqbool and Madaari. May he rest in peace and his work will always be an inspiration and also a tutorial for all those who aspire greatness !
I was thinking of watching Namesake when suddenly ur video popped up ! U ve done a great job going through the minute details of Irrfan kahan's beautiful acting through his eyes and gestures!! Ur video was also very touching and I know how much u also miss him!!
Thank you so much ma'am, after his recent very unfortunate passing. Everyone made something about him especially news channel and not very respectfully to be honest. But you did job really well here. But this makes me sad regardless because we had yet to see lot from him.
WOW.... what an analysis. Stumbled upon this video accidentally but every minute of this video was worth the accident. I always thought that not many would understand the beauty of Namesake, Irfan and Tabu but I am immensely pleased and happy to see someone with an even deeper insight into the legends. Does that make @cinemawali a legend? Well after watching this video, I will nod to that ;)
Thanks ma'am for this beautiful explanation and such a beautiful voice of you..... The acting of a legend and the voice of representative made this video memorable... Thanks...
Amazing analysis!! I couldn't hold back tears while you're analysing Ashok's phone conversation with Ashima. And rightly pointing out the difference of portraying a common Bengali man between the two stalwarts, one a mega star of commercial films and another for whom I don't even have superlatives! The fact that his demise means so personal to millions of movie lovers is a testament to the fact of his mastery over his craft. Thanks for the video
A really beautiful analysis! Through your video i consciously looked at his nuances which, earlier, i had only absorbed subconsciously. Even the film you chose for analysing is perfect, because Namesake is the one of the few films that really shows the brilliance of this wonderful actor. On the day we got his news, and while watching this video and The Namesake, there was really a lump in the throat and an emptiness in the heart! Great video! :)
Bacchan saheb kaam itna Kar chuke hai na ki koi bhi unke saamne chota lagta hai .. par aap agar contemporary cinema dono actor ka dekh ke match Kare toh Irrfan Bhai jayada layered acting kiye hai aisa lagta hai .
I am so glad you made this video, I hv always felt namesake to be irfan's greatest silent performances ever and I am not taking credit away from Jhumpa, mira or tabbu it was one of the best portrays of a Bengali NRI family and the migration that happened in 80s, but irfan was the best in that movie, those long pauses, longing and expected looks, not enough credit is given to tht performance of his
Really cant get over , watching his movies again and again, just to see those subtle and nuanced expressions of this legend!! You have done a good job! The point that you made on Piku was right...he was living in that character...there is one scene in which he talks to his mother, the pitch, tone .....but bollywood is about stardom, lineage , and he was right that he wanted to do something with substance...he did magic and left with beautiful memories and moments that one would cherish in reel and real...
irrfan k aas paas bhi koi nhi pahuch sakta,he is awesome !!!! Sorry to say ki Amit ji bhi nhi😷 irrfan u will always alive in Hearts of ur fans,we adore u😍😍
I really loved the way you broke down each scene and the way Irrfan acted to give justice to the scene. Somehow, I always felt that acting is so easy but now I realize the effort that goes into each scene. The little things that aren't noticeable is really important and it's something that builds the stage for that scene. Thank you for this enlightenment.
Thank you making this appreciation video., had me in tears!. This film and Irrfan’s character strikes a deep chord within me..all his films have some lines and scenes which are so deep and hard hitting that they move us completely..Namesake is one of those rare gems..One has to be a really genuine, authentic human being to be able to bring such characters to life and make them so memorable and real. Long life His Highness and our dearest Sir Irrfan Khan!🌈💐
Just the way you have described the scene sooooo perfectly - would love you doing many more scene - it’s a perfect acting school to learn for all actors - thank you 😊
He is a great actor we know.But some people who don't deeply analyse and understand his greatness you make it extremely easy for them and make people to think about him again and again. How beautifully explained his each action....lots of love from Bangladesh...
Wowww i have never felt this jealous ever in my life before , after hearing the way you studied irfan sir character from movie ‘Namesake’. So pleased at the same time that we have such genius reviewers of true master pieces like Sir Irfan . Thankss alott . It helps 🙏🏻
Hey, the way you have described every minute detail does justice to him, so much is being said about him but not as beautifully as you did it. It's truly a huge loss for the entire cinema kind.
Meticulously researched and then beautifully analysed. Very rare to find such detail, profound acting decoction either on print or electronic media. Kudos to you👍
पहली बार मुझे youtube पे कोई अच्छा समीक्षक मिला है जिसने इतनी खूबसूरती और बारीकी से समीक्षा किया हो मैं अक्सर ये देखता हूं कि ऐसे लोग समीक्षा कर रहे होते है जिन्हें अभिनय के बारे में जानकारी ही नही होती है। मैं एक रंगमंच का विद्यार्थी हु और मुझे 2 साल लगे अभिनय को समझने में और जब मैं बकबास समीक्षा देखता हूं तो बुरा लगता है ।मैं हमेशा से अच्छा समीक्षक के खोज में रहता हूं क्योंकि इससे मैं कुछ सीखता हु । धन्यवाद मैम
I think such deconstructions or analysis is a must and will help create a bent and help people to become artists or at the least appreciate and enjoy the art to the fullest.
So beautifully u have explained every bit of it. I agree with you that in piku amitabh was nothing infront of him in acting,nd not even in playing a bengali character. Irrfan is class and his acting skills r beyond perfection. Very few stands infront of him in acting regardless any age or experience. Thanks for this one, nice work. Please make few more such videos on Irrfan's movies. I feel more nd more of his presence through all these. Not just an actor but as a human being also he was beyond perfection.
I am amazed to see this video and your great analysis..... please do this kind of analytical video about irrfan khan's acting in 'The lunch box'.. keep it up ❤
Heere ki parakh johri ko Hoti hai, aap johri hi hai. Itni acchi observation har Kisi mein Nahi Hoti .Aap Kuch special hai .U will live Ur life to fullest
Aww. Irrfan Khan is amazing. This is a Beautiful video. One of the best analysis video of a film. Here for the first time, instantly love this channel, great content.
A phenomenal video breakdown of Mr. Khan's acting sensibilities. He will be missed. Look forward to seeing other such videos by you. Yes, I have subscribed (thanks to Aseem Chhabra for introducing me to your channel)
very well described , this is what internalisation and character building is all about , no one did or can do with such ease like irrfan used to do , that makes him the finest actor ever born in this country , thank you for the video
Yes , your work of analysing the artwork of Irrfan Sir is really good ...I completely appreciate the whole narration you have made for this acting talent of par excellence..We will definitely going to miss the many more new artistry n creativity from Irrfan... But, in whatever way he has enriched the audience, will surely keep Irrfan Sir alive in the hearts of people who loved him. RIP 🙏🙏🙏
I just watched this movie and now this video about character study. Thanks for making this video which explored my thought process to next level. Please make another such videos. May be on Forrest Gump, The Lunchbox etc.
"When a quiet man raises his voice, People take notice"
To all the introverted
People do take a notice even when a loud person adopts quietness, though may be for a shorter while.
when a nice guy loses his patience the devil shivers
"Sometimes I feel that Irrfan did his job so effortlessly that we forgot that he was not that character."
I'm sure Irrfan Sir somewhere smiled after watching this. It is that beautiful.
Exactly,any award for his action is less,what i feel that his presence only makes everything complete
"Sometimes I feel that Irrfan did his job so effortlessly that we forgot that he was not that character." - Spot on. I feel like this is the primary reason why that after his death many people felt like they have lost a family member yet they don't know that they considered him as one. He so effortlessly blended in our everyday worldview which can only be consciously felt so deeply by its absence.
Analysis is the hallmark of the bangali personality. Now I know!
True,My whole family is deeply disturbed after his demise.It is happend first time with all of us.Great loss.
I second you Chandrachur.
You may be right. Every few months since his death, I become aware that he's gone. And it breaks my heart all over again. So I binge videos about him or try to watch a movie of his.
So true it felt like a close family member has passed on to the soul world.
His level of acting is much higher than amitabh bachan
That is very true i agree
Ur observation is good, but comparing amitabh, Irrfan is not quite right I think, I agree Irrfan is great actor but credit must also given to Mira Nair who is master in sculpting characters, and I believe if amitabh bachchan ever work with Mira Nair it would be one of the greatest performance of his career.
Don't compare two legends please.
stop being delusional, yes irrfan is a great at acting without effort and just because he become known in hollywood doesnt mean hes higher than amitabh bachchan, they are both good actors
Amithab Bachan is the industry.... Irfan is a fine actor....
What a beautiful way you have shown Irrfan sir's character study!!
Well said madam...he is a great actor...
So beautifully you have explained! missing a great man Irrfan Sir
Sabana Ma'am you have given my thoughts into words. I liked the as much as you have expressed.
Now I have another strong source to gain knowledge of acting , keep making this , thumbs up to you 👍
Really beautiful.
As an introvert man myself, I could see Irfan's soul through his eye. I felt like he had immense sorrow but somehow he had built wall around it. I have never cried even when my relatives passed away but I cried when Irfan passed away. I felt I knew that guy in and out and felt he was someone close to me.
This is the reason he did is job flawlessly with utmost sincerity to the characters he played.
The way you have explained I am sure Irrfan would be very proud of this. This is a true tribute to the finest actors we all had. Great description
I am agree with you.
Great analysis... would appreciate the same with Lunch Box
I agree with the same. She described it so beautifully.
Irrfan never liked the word Proud.
How beautifully explained 👍👍💐💐
Ashok telling his son that just remember it till the end...that we went to a place where there was no where left to go...how beautiful is that. Irrfan sir will stay in our hearts forever.
The "Namesake" is the first movie with Irfan Khan that I have ever watched. I immediately fell in love with his acting skills. His jodi with Tabu was amazing, no words needed to describe their mutual love, affection and respect, it was all about the aura. May his soul rest in peace!
I have never seen such real and incredibly talented actor in my life so far, Irrfan Khan will be remain irreplaceable. ❤❤
I agree with you varun tripathi. He is God of acting
@@punitsingh5350 Indeed dear🙌 well it's Varuni Tripathi.. 😊
Oh I'm sorry i didn't realize that there is "I" After "n".
@@varunitripathi6619have you seen the movie "A MIGHTY HEART"???. I have tried to find this movie everywhere but I couldn't. If you know about it then answer me in reply. It is one of the best movie of irfan khan.
If you want to see shades of Irrfan Khan's acting, watch Vijay Verma.
This was lovely. I have mixed feelings about the Namesake but Irrfan and Tabu were flawless. For some reason I felt nostalgic about Irrfan today, and rather sad, so found your channel. A beautiful tribute to such a talent. At least we still have so many of his wonderful performances.
Honestly I have tried to live this charecter of ashok. His English has an impeccable bengali accent. I am sure this charecter is more bengali as in the cultural way of life (like their house in Kolkata bit broken and messy, the jamai soshti handfan with red dips on the ends,the curly usually uncombed hair, liberal traits in an orthodox setup, the loose pants style usually famous in Mithun Chakraborty movies in 90s , the shy romance, square and thick fram) than most people who are Bengalis like myself. Sometimes unknowingly I try to walk smoke and try to look( I never shave off my moustache trim it and keep it sharp) like ashok. It's weird but I find it quite liberating. I truely feel the pangs of separation from this amazing actor. Little would he ever know how deep he has impacted my charecter. Haha. Life's amazingly uncertain.
I was having my breakfast in my hostel, getting late to go to library. So i thought to watch a short video on RUclips to give me company while i eat. But i wanna tell you that i just took a bite of my bread butter and started the video. And after 10 minutes i realised i have been just holding my bread in my hand (with just the initial bite) and my mind was imagining what you were conveying.
I know I am getting lil emotional but i think this clip deserves much more. Thank you so much to IRRFAN Sir and to you who made this video by clubbing your beautiful story telling art (pardon me... I dont know your). name).
You have done an incredible analysis. There are 3 scenes of Irrfan sir, from 3 movies, which will remain with me forever
:
1. "Everyday since then has been a gift..." says Irrfan to his son (Kal Penn), as he explains the rationale behind the name 'Gogol'
(Movie: The Namesake)
2. "Don't you ever cut your bloody vegetables on the office files" Irrfan chides Nawazuddin Siddiqui, without looking up at him
, while just having saved him from getting fired (Movie: The Lunchbox)
3. "Burden, burden... emotional blackmail karke pata nahi parents ko kya sukh milta hai" Irrfan stops the car, visibly irritated, and looks neutrally to say it out, almost like a soliloquy (Movie: Piku)
Your criticissm is it self a literature of forgotten era.
I’m a Bengali and a filmmaker in Australia. This character study was to the point. I have seen this film so many time but never picked those nuances!
Movie name please
I never knew his loss would b such a personal loss to us all. Such an awesome video well presented
I found Meghan Fernandes, I hope you know what I am talking about 😀
Remember you and me made a journey where there were nowhere to go... We all came out from Gogol's Overcoat... being a vivid film follower and interested in Indian Diasporic literature, this has been one of the best movie.. and I would thank you for making such an analytical work.
Still today i could not come out of heart breaking shock of the passing away of this versatile actor and generous human being from this earth..
Miss you IRRFAN SIR
Are u in anyways related to the Governor of New York Mr. Andrew Cuomo? If u are, then I'd like to say that he is doing a pretty good job against Corona Virus. Wishing u well from India.
Genius portrayal of Irfaan. He was indeed a gem. I watched this movie long ago, when I wasn't even a fan of his. You are true in saying that he does his work with such subtlety and finesse that he blends in completely to the story.
Dear Cinemawali: Just found this channel. How beautifully you write and express, but more than that it is your eye---you noticed it ALL. Thanks. This movie is a master piece. I will forever be angry that this was not nominated for the best movie of the decade--Thanks for such a wonderful tribute!! Beautifully written. Hope you write articles as well.
This and the lunchbox too
Both played Bengali uncles of totally different kind. While Irrfan's character in Namesake was calm, subtle yet vulnerable at times, Bachchan's character was that of a loud mouth, cranky, critical, living life on his own principles. Even though I agree Irrfan Khan's level of acting is higher than BigB, but still comparisons shouldn't be made between 2 characters because the characters are poles apart at the very script level.
I accidentally watched the video and Now I would like to thank you for giving us this beautifully analysed video....What an actor he was!!!!! Our bollywood industry is really unfortunate that it didn't explore his talent in right time....and when it started realising the legend, he left us forever.......loved the video, love his acting, he will be there in our mind forever ......💓💓💓💓💓💓💓
There can be no greater tribute to the legend. We lost him too early. You've showed a way to rewatch his films. Much appreciated.
It breaks my heart every time it dawns on me that Irrfan Khan is no more in this physical world. Yet, work such as yours will enable him to remain more and more etched in our hearts and minds.
Brilliant observations! Thank you for the treat!
I don't think nobody can replace Irrfan. He was an exquisite actor...
Yes.... This will remain with me forever..... Thanks 🌹
I had forgotten in the middle of the video that he had passed away.... Great video!!! Keep it up❤❤
We lost him as soon as we started to understand him! That's too soon!
This review would surely make him happy!! So detailed!!!....
I'm sure he's looking from above and he's glad of the work he did.
@Cinemawali,This isn't just a movie review; it's a reflection on finding inner peace. I've watched this video nearly ten times in the past year. You are the Irrfan Khan of your field. The voice and background music are soothing, and I hope others find it as calming as I do. The use of the right vocabulary at the right time leaves a lasting impression on everyone.
Where was this channel hiding... I am so glad I found it
OH MY GOD..,!! you have such an acute observation, it's as if you give a voice to all the unsaid ways we could have appreciated him. Reminds me of a song " inside you lives every song that you never sang" You give voice to those melodies of appreciation. Thank you.
i accidentally hit upon this video while frantically looking for this movie. Well so say in short, you have done a fabulous job working on the body language of this wonderful actor. Excellent analysis and I am glad that you subtly said that Big B performance in PIKU was quite irritating and could not handle the brashness of Irrfan
I am so happy I found your channel. Great job.
I cried profusely the whole day when I heard about him.
You made me cry again.
He is a gem! ♥️
Indeed! :') And thank you. 💕
Everyone cried for them ,miss him .😭😭😭😭
whole day.. itna bhi maat fekko yaar
He is God of acting
ME TOO : LOVE FROM CANADA : Irfan Ji
cinemawali.. you are just awesome.. what a detail explanation !!! Thank you lady
Such deep observation about a charachter ...you are a gem too...
Whoever did the research and wrote down the script was excellently done. Cheers mate!!!
How beautifully put Ma'am.By the end of it, I had tears in my eyes feeling so, so empty..Thanks.
FATHER.... DESERVE APPRECIATION NOT LESS THAN MOTHER......... same feeling here bhai
You can't describe acting of such a natural actor because these things come naturally to him when he immerses in a character.
It's a void...A void that won't be filled ever... Irrfan khan was indispensable...
Nice information 👍 beautiful observation of Ashok s character
Beautifully explained about the legends work...my favourite actor is no more is like something dying inside me ..we will not be able to see him alive...but the way he proved himself in the field of film industry is outstanding...his magnanimous personality will never be forgotten by Indian and whole world
His small detail were phenomenal, I remember in a seen from hasil where he is beating the minister with his slippers, if you notice it’s so delicately done as, the intention is not to hurt him, but insult him and make him feel vulnerable. Amazing.Rip mate!🙏
What an amazing video and how beautifully you have analyzed his performance... This is how we should discuss cinema or actors... Sadly in india film journalism is in such a bad shape but channels like this are blessing for film lovers... Thank you...🙏😊
Unfortunately you lost me when you displayed the desperate urge to compare the two actors and did so. It was unnecessary. Comparison shouldn't be considered intelligent or needed for any purpose. Perhaps editing/ deleting the first few minutes of this video will give it some credibility.
Thank you for reminding that thus was the first movie of Irrfan Khan which I saw, and this movie did planted a seed of a different life all because of his role he played in that movie from that train accident to the ending... Really appreciate.
Thank you for sharing such a beautiful video where we can see Irrfan’s brilliant art minutely. As we now he is an actor who do his art effortlessly using his eyes. Now come to know how excellent way he is using body too.
Amazing gem as an actors as a human being true, honest, god of simplicity, humble, give so respect to all, hard working, his life is open to all.
He is so real in his life and in his act. Definitely no one can match him. Today’s actors can’t copy him too.
He will be always around us. We can learn so many things from him.He must love this video!
Absolutely delicate... Thank you so much for showing the minor details which we miss through each movie... Thanks a lot..
Describing irrfan khan's acting in words is difficult. though i found his work mesmerizing i always thought how his acting is unique from others but watching your video just removed all the confusions
No doubt your observation and research is extensive and well presented.
Wow ! I am feeling relieved, I would watch any artistic movie multiple times 10 times or even more because I am never satisfied with what I learn as various aspects of acting skills. People would label me as weird and stupid for doing so, but your analysis shows me I am not doing anything wrong. It is an art to do so and not getting bored unlike all.
I loved Irfan Khan for his simplicity, on the day I received his news I with mom watched his aap ki adalat episode watched 2 of his great movies - Maqbool and Madaari.
May he rest in peace and his work will always be an inspiration and also a tutorial for all those who aspire greatness !
I was thinking of watching Namesake when suddenly ur video popped up !
U ve done a great job going through the minute details of Irrfan kahan's beautiful acting through his eyes and gestures!!
Ur video was also very touching and I know how much u also miss him!!
it seems that he is still with us.thanks for providing a glimpse of his wonderfull acting talent
Thank you so much ma'am, after his recent very unfortunate passing. Everyone made something about him especially news channel and not very respectfully to be honest. But you did job really well here. But this makes me sad regardless because we had yet to see lot from him.
"God is in the details" Stands True.
WOW.... what an analysis. Stumbled upon this video accidentally but every minute of this video was worth the accident. I always thought that not many would understand the beauty of Namesake, Irfan and Tabu but I am immensely pleased and happy to see someone with an even deeper insight into the legends.
Does that make @cinemawali a legend? Well after watching this video, I will nod to that ;)
Thanks ma'am for this beautiful explanation and such a beautiful voice of you..... The acting of a legend and the voice of representative made this video memorable... Thanks...
Really appreciate this video. The narration helped to appreciate his acting even more than ever. Miss you forever Irrfan Khan ❤️
Amazing analysis!! I couldn't hold back tears while you're analysing Ashok's phone conversation with Ashima. And rightly pointing out the difference of portraying a common Bengali man between the two stalwarts, one a mega star of commercial films and another for whom I don't even have superlatives! The fact that his demise means so personal to millions of movie lovers is a testament to the fact of his mastery over his craft. Thanks for the video
Amazing. A beautiful ode to one of the greatest ever!! Keep up the good job! Expecting more such videos.
Thankyou so much. I can't express why I needed this❤️
A really beautiful analysis! Through your video i consciously looked at his nuances which, earlier, i had only absorbed subconsciously. Even the film you chose for analysing is perfect, because Namesake is the one of the few films that really shows the brilliance of this wonderful actor. On the day we got his news, and while watching this video and The Namesake, there was really a lump in the throat and an emptiness in the heart! Great video! :)
Can't agree more with this Vineet! What a lovely thought.
@@Chubbychoo26 💕💕
Irrfan listening this from above will say “Mene bhi character to itna dissect nhi kiya jitna madam ne kr diya” Respect #Truefan
haha
I could feel it long back that even Amitabh bachchan doesn't stand as tall as Irrfan in acting ans as human being
True
Bacchan saheb kaam itna Kar chuke hai na ki koi bhi unke saamne chota lagta hai .. par aap agar contemporary cinema dono actor ka dekh ke match Kare toh Irrfan Bhai jayada layered acting kiye hai aisa lagta hai .
True
after death praise is inevitable but alive is difficult I wish it would be vise versa
why compare him. though i love irrfan a lot. And dislike amitabh
Thank you for this.. Wonderful work
I am so glad you made this video, I hv always felt namesake to be irfan's greatest silent performances ever and I am not taking credit away from Jhumpa, mira or tabbu it was one of the best portrays of a Bengali NRI family and the migration that happened in 80s, but irfan was the best in that movie, those long pauses, longing and expected looks, not enough credit is given to tht performance of his
Really cant get over , watching his movies again and again, just to see those subtle and nuanced expressions of this legend!! You have done a good job! The point that you made on Piku was right...he was living in that character...there is one scene in which he talks to his mother, the pitch, tone .....but bollywood is about stardom, lineage , and he was right that he wanted to do something with substance...he did magic and left with beautiful memories and moments that one would cherish in reel and real...
irrfan k aas paas bhi koi nhi pahuch sakta,he is awesome !!!!
Sorry to say ki Amit ji bhi nhi😷
irrfan u will always alive in Hearts of ur fans,we adore u😍😍
You earned one more subscriber. Irrfan was on whole another level. Still could not get out of the loss.
I really loved the way you broke down each scene and the way Irrfan acted to give justice to the scene. Somehow, I always felt that acting is so easy but now I realize the effort that goes into each scene. The little things that aren't noticeable is really important and it's something that builds the stage for that scene. Thank you for this enlightenment.
Thank you making this appreciation video., had me in tears!.
This film and Irrfan’s character strikes a deep chord within me..all his films have some lines and scenes which are so deep and hard hitting that they move us completely..Namesake is one of those rare gems..One has to be a really genuine, authentic human being to be able to bring such characters to life and make them so memorable and real. Long life His Highness and our dearest Sir Irrfan Khan!🌈💐
Just the way you have described the scene sooooo perfectly - would love you doing many more scene - it’s a perfect acting school to learn for all actors - thank you 😊
He is a great actor we know.But some people who don't deeply analyse and understand his greatness you make it extremely easy for them and make people to think about him again and again. How beautifully explained his each action....lots of love from Bangladesh...
Wowww i have never felt this jealous ever in my life before , after hearing the way you studied irfan sir character from movie ‘Namesake’. So pleased at the same time that we have such genius reviewers of true master pieces like Sir Irfan . Thankss alott . It helps 🙏🏻
Mind blowing... U r amazing... Cannot stop myself to watch this report again and again.
You are really a movie genius. Thank you for touching my mind and heart! God bless you!
Hey, the way you have described every minute detail does justice to him, so much is being said about him but not as beautifully as you did it. It's truly a huge loss for the entire cinema kind.
Meticulously researched and then beautifully analysed. Very rare to find such detail, profound acting decoction either on print or electronic media.
Kudos to you👍
The best tribute ❤
पहली बार मुझे youtube पे कोई अच्छा समीक्षक मिला है जिसने इतनी खूबसूरती और बारीकी से समीक्षा किया हो मैं अक्सर ये देखता हूं कि ऐसे लोग समीक्षा कर रहे होते है जिन्हें अभिनय के बारे में जानकारी ही नही होती है। मैं एक रंगमंच का विद्यार्थी हु और मुझे 2 साल लगे अभिनय को समझने में और जब मैं बकबास समीक्षा देखता हूं तो बुरा लगता है ।मैं हमेशा से अच्छा समीक्षक के खोज में रहता हूं क्योंकि इससे मैं कुछ सीखता हु । धन्यवाद मैम
Bahut accha Hindi bhai
I think such deconstructions or analysis is a must and will help create a bent and help people to become artists or at the least appreciate and enjoy the art to the fullest.
So beautifully u have explained every bit of it. I agree with you that in piku amitabh was nothing infront of him in acting,nd not even in playing a bengali character. Irrfan is class and his acting skills r beyond perfection. Very few stands infront of him in acting regardless any age or experience. Thanks for this one, nice work. Please make few more such videos on Irrfan's movies. I feel more nd more of his presence through all these. Not just an actor but as a human being also he was beyond perfection.
Thank you.
It was amazing. The way you explained.
And the legend
I am amazed to see this video and your great analysis..... please do this kind of analytical video about irrfan khan's acting in 'The lunch box'.. keep it up ❤
Heere ki parakh johri ko Hoti hai, aap johri hi hai. Itni acchi observation har Kisi mein Nahi Hoti .Aap Kuch special hai .U will live Ur life to fullest
This movie made me cry so hard. I started loving my father more and more
same here
same here
Aww. Irrfan Khan is amazing. This is a Beautiful video. One of the best analysis video of a film.
Here for the first time, instantly love this channel, great content.
A phenomenal video breakdown of Mr. Khan's acting sensibilities. He will be missed. Look forward to seeing other such videos by you. Yes, I have subscribed (thanks to Aseem Chhabra for introducing me to your channel)
very well described , this is what internalisation and character building is all about , no one did or can do with such ease like irrfan used to do , that makes him the finest actor ever born in this country , thank you for the video
Yes , your work of analysing the artwork of Irrfan Sir is really good ...I completely appreciate the whole narration you have made for this acting talent of par excellence..We will definitely going to miss the many more new artistry n creativity from Irrfan... But, in whatever way he has enriched the audience, will surely keep Irrfan Sir alive in the hearts of people who loved him.
RIP 🙏🙏🙏
This made me cry, your attention to detail is so beautiful. Thank you for showing these details to us
I just watched this movie and now this video about character study. Thanks for making this video which explored my thought process to next level. Please make another such videos. May be on Forrest Gump, The Lunchbox etc.
Namesake is on which digital platform?
@@radhikamahimkar archive.org/details/TheNamesake2006
This was such a beautiful video. Thank you so much. He was the best and my favorite actor❤
Lovely analysis.
One of the best critical appreciation I have ever heard. Great! Keep it up!
Haven't seen a better tribute to Irrfan's mastery and worship of his craft. Thank you.....
Wonderful peice of work! Waiting for more such informative videos!
This video is a tribute that does justice to the genius he was.
Simply wow !!!! What a kind of explanation given ! Truely you nailed it !! Thanks for these kind of in-depth detailing !