It's easy to understand why people who aren't specialists in music would think she's "out of tune", which she is not. It's always uncool when your vocal chords are tired and you get this raspy, and it's very disappointing to the singer not being able to deliver what she intended. Raspy or not, Nina is divine!
Fleetly agree I’m a singer, and sometimes my high notes are completely gone. Let alone hit one and then be able to go down register and still keep singing. She’s amazing.
De Melkweg, Amsterdam, 1980s, concert was sold out. Me and my then girlfriend had no tickets, still went waiting outside the entrance Just in case we could get in.... with numerous others. So no real chance to get and see the band. Just some dealer trying to get customers by saying if I wanted "cocaine running around my brain", told him to f**k off, that I only wanted Nina...
she can reach the high notes easily but she's struggling to add distortion to them for an effect, traditional training wouldn't have covered how to do this safely she's wrecking her voice here :/ she's brilliant though
Eine Diva der superlative, die allerdings total underrated und unknown geblieben ist.. When ich jedoch die beste 50 singerinen der Welt nenne, ausser Maria Kallas Anna Netrebko und anderen, Nina Hagen ist immer dabei....
I think the amazing thing is ... how does she keep GOING when the high notes give out!? She can pull off ANYTHING with style. That's why we love her. She's just pure entertainment.
Obviously clear, Nina was making fun with her opera voice and she never took it too serious. Sometimes she hits the high notes, often not and listen to the chicken talk at the end - that was pure fun. Don't forget, she is a rock singer. So never mind on anything. By the way, she really was a cutie on her younger days and even today with 64 she looks great!
I never heard her "out of tune"; rather she had trouble hitting high falsetto octaves that night, yet stayed perfectly on pitch just at one and two octaves lower.
@@hobbygamer6220the aproach. She was hitting the notes with too much pressure plus her Voice sounds dry ( literally dry, because of not drinking water)
Maybe her voice was SLIGHTLY rusky in this performance, but didn't lip sync just like every other "artist" out there which makes me respect her even more
Great to see the lyrics for the first time, I love this song and always play it when going out. the 1978 version includes the high notes she didn't make that day. this video and audio are priceless thanks for archiving such a treasure from the last century.
The effort from the bass player goes into doing something interesting while playing the lamest bass part I´ve heard, lol...but I love Nina Hagen and this song kicks ass!
Tears of Nature Open window presents Clouds of sparrows, fluttering of heaven Wind blows, my nose is freezing And a few exhaust pipes rattle Ah, then sun is going down Red, with gold, so it shall be When I look down onto the street I remember my acquantaince Promptly now, my heart is getting heavy I only need to see birds fluttering And if my gaze then flies heavenwards The soul will hurt as well, how nice Nature in the evening, silent city Wrenched soul, tears running All of this makes you mighty weary And I just keep on whining Aaaaahhhhhhh...
@SonofMrPeanut well, there sure is a lot of exposure to music but man is there a lot of writing...it is college thou. The more i listen to this song the more i love, that voice!
@philipjrichardson no problem. :) yes, she is completely amazing. her mother is a pretty famous opera-singer in germany, but nina has (in my oppinion) more talant then her mother... says quite a lot.
First she smoked a lot, and second try that punishment with your voice until 70 years and you will know why? In that respect she is parallel to Ian Anderson.....
you can notice from the beggining her voice is not in the condition it should be for that song, everyone has bad days with their voice, this was nina's... (of course then the smoking and 80's decade drugs came in and she lost that voice ._.) still, I love her! amazing!
Tag Nina Hagen wie geht`s ? Heute 11 March ich glùckwunsche zum deine geburstag ! Mit liebe , ich bin Argentinisches, Argentinien, Argentina and i think besides Mercedes Benz , you are the only wirklich autentique Deutsches stern .
goooood would be the best with the high parts...fuck! anyway, great performance and great song, amazing artist, amazing voice, but maaaaan, I miss those parts..
No, she was not seriously trying. It was always clear, she was making fun of herself with her opera trained voice. Listen to the chicken "talk" at the end. At least, she is a rock and punk singer.
It's easy to understand why people who aren't specialists in music would think she's "out of tune", which she is not. It's always uncool when your vocal chords are tired and you get this raspy, and it's very disappointing to the singer not being able to deliver what she intended. Raspy or not, Nina is divine!
Fleetly agree I’m a singer, and sometimes my high notes are completely gone. Let alone hit one and then be able to go down register and still keep singing. She’s amazing.
De Melkweg, Amsterdam, 1980s, concert was sold out.
Me and my then girlfriend had no tickets, still went waiting outside the entrance Just in case we could get in.... with numerous others. So no real chance to get and see the band. Just some dealer trying to get customers by saying if I wanted "cocaine running around my brain", told him to f**k off, that I only wanted Nina...
My favourite Nina Hagen song, too bad this one isn't on spotify
now it is!
@@andrewhammel2 it is?? I can't see it!
@@yizzf7430 the song is not by nina tho 💔
@@jocyponce5192 ik I just like her rendition! Also I’m not the original commenter lol
@@yizzf7430 i know you’re not. and yea i like hera better too
She had trouble hitting high notes during this concert, but even then she sounds way better than most singers
Is lady Gaga considered punk?
she can reach the high notes easily but she's struggling to add distortion to them for an effect, traditional training wouldn't have covered how to do this safely she's wrecking her voice here :/ she's brilliant though
Eine Diva der superlative, die allerdings total underrated und unknown geblieben ist..
When ich jedoch die beste 50 singerinen der Welt nenne, ausser Maria Kallas Anna Netrebko und anderen, Nina Hagen ist immer dabei....
Tough notes to hit every night. Always good.
I think her Voice was dry, that's why it was cracking
I think the amazing thing is ... how does she keep GOING when the high notes give out!? She can pull off ANYTHING with style. That's why we love her. She's just pure entertainment.
Obviously clear, Nina was making fun with her opera voice and she never took it too serious. Sometimes she hits the high notes, often not and listen to the chicken talk at the end - that was pure fun. Don't forget, she is a rock singer. So never mind on anything. By the way, she really was a cutie on her younger days and even today with 64 she looks great!
It's a bit sad in a way how she didn't take care of the vocal gift she had, but after all, the lady is a punk at heart !
Shut up
I never heard her "out of tune"; rather she had trouble hitting high falsetto octaves that night, yet stayed perfectly on pitch just at one and two octaves lower.
was that the END of that ability or just a off night ? ( hopefully )
@@hobbygamer6220the aproach. She was hitting the notes with too much pressure plus her Voice sounds dry ( literally dry, because of not drinking water)
Maybe her voice was SLIGHTLY rusky in this performance, but didn't lip sync just like every other "artist" out there which makes me respect her even more
Nina war ein unglaubliches Talent. Leider hat sie ihre Stimme nie geschont und damit relativ früh kaputt gemacht...
Beautiful lady, a ruge talent. Her voice failed on the high notes, but who listen when she get there fall in love. It's amazing the way she performs.
She is tremendously beautiful. The May Queen.
In High school my brother and I found a DVD of this whole concert. We used to watch it or play it in the background all the damn time!
I think the Rockpalast version also here on youtube is better. Totally brilliant stuff.
Great to see the lyrics for the first time, I love this song and always play it when going out. the 1978 version includes the high notes she didn't make that day. this video and audio are priceless thanks for archiving such a treasure from the last century.
I wish we had those days back !
and I knew of Nina hagen .
un fair .
Que grande Nina...
Wirklich h e r r l i c h e Stimme..4 CALLAS in einem❤😊
This performance is amazing! I can watch this over and over again!
Just stumbled on this...she's got herself another fan now
The effort from the bass player goes into doing something interesting while playing the lamest bass part I´ve heard, lol...but I love Nina Hagen and this song kicks ass!
It's no joke singing like that,, I accept the flaws as human perfection..
Tears of Nature
Open window presents
Clouds of sparrows, fluttering of heaven
Wind blows, my nose is freezing
And a few exhaust pipes rattle
Ah, then sun is going down
Red, with gold, so it shall be
When I look down onto the street
I remember my acquantaince
Promptly now, my heart is getting heavy
I only need to see birds fluttering
And if my gaze then flies heavenwards
The soul will hurt as well, how nice
Nature in the evening, silent city
Wrenched soul, tears running
All of this makes you mighty weary
And I just keep on whining
Aaaaahhhhhhh...
I love how the german sounds
Love it in 79 love it 2019 thanx for sharing 👍
Nina forever ❤️😻
La queremos igual. ♡
xd
@@Lucases19 ola bb 😗😗
OUT OF TUNE MY ASSS SHE SOUNDS AMAZING
I don't know why I LOVE Nina Hagen but I do!!!
That's whom Lady Gaga should thank every day of her life
y ?
Her best rendition of Naturtraene. Thanks for putting the lyrics!!
A masterpiece❤❤❤
She's wonderful.
I've been a fan of Nina Hagen for more than 20 years. She i sincredible to see performing in person.
Fantastique Nina!.....merci!
It's a pity there are a few nina songs on Spotify, brings more please
damals ihrer zeit weit voraus...sie präsentierte wirkliche kunst, nur haben das die leute leider zu dieser zeit nicht wirklich verstanden...
at 1:53, did she happen to be losing her voice? In another video she sang through that part with no problem.
Smoke
Yes her voice started to crack and once dat happens more cracks would normally follow unless you cough to clear the voice.
sehr gut!❤🇩🇪
Ich liebe Sie. Sie ist zu süß. ❤️
do a duett with rammstein! :P
yes she DOES reathe through her nose very quickly to hit those notes!!! i knew it!!
@SonofMrPeanut
well, there sure is a lot of exposure to music but man is there a lot of writing...it is college thou.
The more i listen to this song the more i love, that voice!
crazy crazy and crazy. you are fantástic. no word congratulation.
This is GOLD lmaooo!! 😂😂😂Very weird and entertaining
@philipjrichardson no problem. :) yes, she is completely amazing. her mother is a pretty famous opera-singer in germany, but nina has (in my oppinion) more talant then her mother... says quite a lot.
You may not like Gaga, but she certainly doesn't suck. This is a Nina Hagen video, why are we even mentioning her the first place?
why she was a soprano and now she have the voice of a baritone???O.o
Age
no.. all the female singers aged but only she changed her voice so drastically. Bad habits, smoke, drugs ecc this is it
Age, over using extreme techniques, maybe some bad habits
First she smoked a lot, and second try that punishment with your voice until 70 years and you will know why? In that respect she is parallel to Ian Anderson.....
She didn't sound like a soprano here. Her lower notes sounded very strong, only her head voice may give an illusion that she was a soprano.
you can notice from the beggining her voice is not in the condition it should be for that song, everyone has bad days with their voice, this was nina's...
(of course then the smoking and 80's decade drugs came in and she lost that voice ._.)
still, I love her! amazing!
Hermoso ❤😊
sexiness and talent combined, and i sense some intelligence there too, good stuff
that´s in westberlin and she plays with her nina hagen band in this vid.
merci!!
Tag Nina Hagen wie geht`s ? Heute 11 March ich glùckwunsche zum deine geburstag ! Mit liebe , ich bin Argentinisches, Argentinien, Argentina and i think besides Mercedes Benz , you are the only wirklich autentique Deutsches stern .
Una grosa Nina , super vanguardista...
A qué bueno que haya otras personas que sientan la fibra de la Nina Hagen gracias por compartir. Y de qué país eres ? Saludos
hola soy de Argentina,vos?
+Simon Coralensis Republica Argentina tambien .
paisa :)
@pogleswood2 i saw her at the london forum in the niineties .it was excellent, she came on driving a little toy car.
Purposely zany but definitely not out of tune, much more of a real singer than most, pretty amazing all over the board
❤
これは出ないバージョンだ、しかし代替えのムーブがとても参考になる、thx
Mon dieu qu’elle était belle ..... 👍🏼
Nach 2014 lebendiges scrittum .
Bravo)
❣️❣️❣️
she best up
It sounds like " Wurthering heights " on meth . Love it .
What Freddie Mercury ?
This video is part of my music class homework, very interesting, i like it but on some levels i dont. :/
1:53 hahhahahhahhahaha cute
@CountessKitty18
Yes, she is a heavy smoker.
LOL...Nina's human after all...Sounds like me and my swollen sinuses...
But you can tell it's not playback 👌
"Out of tune" what clown wrote that?
This is classic Nina Hagen: a performance artist.
Nina Hagen Band underrated - especially the albums.
Algo pasò ahi que la garganta se le cerrò y no pudo alcanzar las notas mas agudas .
Wer hat eigentlich die Texte geschrieben?
goooood would be the best with the high parts...fuck!
anyway, great performance and great song, amazing artist, amazing voice,
but maaaaan, I miss those parts..
Pas besoin de commantaire ❤
Love it - she kicks the shit out of pompous German opera
Why is it sped up at the end?
Downvoted because this isn't out of tune
Dommage, elle est aphone ce jour là :)
¡Qué calidad...!
LA AMO A ESTA IPSSISIMUS ALEMANA PUNK LIRYC- EVA SHIVA INFINITA
Ouch she really skidded there
@philipjrichardson youtu.be /_AHV3611XWY (remove that spaces) that one was a weill-song, right?
ouch... she squeaked... shame cause this is a truly amazing song...
I instantly hear the guitar riff is a rip off of July morning by Uriah Heep
😜✊✌😆😍
The original Plava Laguna
@darien0extreme did she ever smoke? aging could also change your voice
no one these days has the guts to do things like this, to just put it out there, not a bunch of lip sync. Brittany, Madona crap. go Nina.
@BellTollsForThee I want to be in your music class. Please trade places.
Ah no fue mucho lo q le falto!!
amazing kkkkkk
@CountessKitty18 non so much. I think she had some problems at her vocal courds
1:53 fail
She was not in a good vocal day
I love it cuz she's like dude... I'm not getting that high, so I'll choke myself and everything will be alright, and it was :3
2:31 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I think this archive would be a real vvocal MV. Not a face sing a song...... maybe.... Her voice should be only by her own.
3:20 again hahahhahhahhahha
Wtf germany
prettiest song I ever heard
Aga bu türkiyede olsaydı düzgün söylese bile domates kundura fırlatırlardı aq snnabjkxnnnx
It seems she can't reach the higher notes here.
No, she was not seriously trying. It was always clear, she was making fun of herself with her opera trained voice. Listen to the chicken "talk" at the end. At least, she is a rock and punk singer.
@elesperma You are totally right,my friend.Lady Gaga makes no music,except that thing she drops inside the toilet.Nina Forever !!!!
Shun
1:54 FUNNY! KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK