How I accidentally met the Prime Minister
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 дек 2024
- Sort the easiest Christmas present of the year: gift.nebula.tv...
So... this is a thing that happened. I was expecting a briefing from a junior member of the government about climate change. I ended up meeting the Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer.
You can support the channel by becoming a patron at / simonoxfphys
As I say in the video, this simply would not have happened without the support of this community. Thank you so much for giving me this opportunity. I look forward to holding this government to account on its actions to combat climate change - I welcome this target but let's see it become action!
--------- II ---------
More about me www.simonoxfph...
My second channel - / simonclarkerrata
Threads - www.threads.ne...
Instagram - / simonoxfphys
Twitch - / drsimonclark
--------- II ---------
Music by Epidemic Sound: nebula.tv/epidemic
Some stock footage courtesy of Getty.
Edited by Luke Negus.
Huge thanks to my supporters on Patreon:
Norm Zemke, Eric A Gentzler, Glen Monks, Gary Stark, dryfrog, Marcus Bosshard, Peter Reid, bitreign33 .
Bastian Pranzas, Jeffry ., Whitefang, Marius Kießling, Jon Arlov, Artem Plotnikov, Paul H and Linda L, Andy Hartley.
Richard Swain, Hernando de Sá Silva, Zr0w3n, Duffman, Claudia Kapp, Cy 'kkm' K'Nelson, Baerbel Winkler, OldGreyWolf, Oscar Hoffmann, Steamrollerman , Andy Parr, Ricky Jones, Guy Markey, Nicholas Hamdorf, Katharina Hartmuth, Mark Phillips, Jor Eero Raico Svederic, KJ Xiao, Matt Beer DFC, Tschäff Reisberg, Tobias Ahsbahs, James Gaskell, Denis Kovachev, Victor Gordan, Tanner , Dominik Rihak, Nico Casal, Mark Harper, Ryan, Inten, Tyler Schwartz, John, James Haigh, Bailey Cook, Sergio Diaz, Christopher Mullin, I'm stuck in a PhD and I blame Simon., Joseph , Nicklas Kulp, Thomas Newman, Anže Cesar, Josef Probst, Kevin B, Phineas, Ishaan Shah, Circuitrinos, Mark Richardson, Brian Moss, Knut Nesheim, AYS , Forever Bulking, Crisan Talpes, Pawel Piwek, Ted CLAY, Mike, Seb Stott, Diederik Jekel, Jan-Willem Goedmakers, Samat Galimov, Ashley Hauck, Nico Kempe, Thibault , GGH, FireFerretDann, Ciotka Cierpienia, Sam, szigyi, Marcin Wrochna, Tom Painter, Phil Saici, Ashley Steel, Simone, Tomás Garnier Artiñano, Steffan , Adam Gillard, Christopher Hall, Miguel Cabrera Brufau, Sylvus , Florian Thie, James Gurney, Eddy Torres, Clemens, Andy Giesen, Jacob Speelman, Robin Anne McDuff, Jean-Marc Giffin, Cifer, Felix Winkler, Christian Weckner, Thomas Charbonnel, Sekhalis, Mark Moore, Philipp Legner, Zoey O'Neill, Justin Warren, Heijde, Trevor Berninger, streetlights, Gabriele Siino, David Mccann, Leonard Neamtu, James Leadbetter, Rapssack, Dan Sherman, Adrian Sand, Morten Engsvang, Haris Karimjee, Alex, Cody VanZandt, Igor Francetic, Sean Richards, Michael B., Thusto , Lachlan Woods, Dan Hanvey, Andrea De Mezzo, Real Engineering.
I cant say how happy I am that Simon is an actual ambassador for climate change, his practical and intelligent approaches to topics will surely be a force for good. Thanks Simon, glad I subbed all those years ago. (will donate when i can).
I started liking him I had thought that he was a populist prime minister.Scrap or amend leasehold ,because it needs reform...
And how much CO2 does the UK produce? I'll give you a hint, it's the first number from 1-10.
hahaha ''I did a Journalism''
10:54 lmao
"I am something of a press, myself".
'I journalised'
I am a press
“I’m stuck in a PHD and I blame Simon” at 5:47 lol
Could have been stuck in that PhD for 8 years now.
I watched Simon's videos back in my first year of undergrad and now I'm in the final two months of my PhD haha
It happens
I would've most likely had a moderate panic attack when the PM suddenly walked into the room
Well, is Starmer, so... like being surprised by a white wall.
Politicians as Pop Stars is the New 'Feudalism of Four': Pope - King - Sherif - Scienter. Each requires 10% of your base income. So here's my question. The Homeless are Zero Carbon. That's worth 'Carbon Credits' to al-Goreia's Carbon Cap & Trade Scheme (legal name). Why can't Homeless sell their carbon credits? Here I am, hudded around the electric radiator. as winter rages. I stand in the snow to ride the bus. I eat cold rice and pulses. That ought to be worth US$100 a week in carbon credits!! *Why can't the Poor sell their carbon credits?*
Like, I personally would feel uncomfortable meeting someone like him who should have helped protect trans rights but is doing the opposite
@@batbite_ Bruh, trans right is absolutely nothing compared to the issue of climate change, come on, really? It's not like he's said the most transphobic shit ever, judging by the way you phrased your comment, so do you really care that much? Jesus christ
@blackflash9935 labour should be the ones who stood up for queer people against tory bigotry but he has abandoned supporting lgbtq rights and it's quite a personal issue to me tbh. I of course still think it's good to be slightly more progressive on climate change than he could be.
Not surprised by the reaction of the press to the 95% goal. It's a common theme that conservative pundits (and therefore sometimes the mainstream) adopt to discredit non-extremist progressive policies. As long as conservative governments are in power, the policy is too ambitious. Once there's a power shift, the policy is not ambitious enough and a betrayal of promises. It fuels disillusion in progressive voters, making them regret their choice at the polls.
On the one hand it's not unreasonable to think that clean means 0% FF. On the other hand I think the previous target was 0% by 2035 so shifting that to about 5 years away was very ambitious. I think 5% is a very reasonable target for that timeframe. If they had said 95% FF free by 2035 in the manifesto I don't think anyone reasonable would have had a problem with that. But I suppose it's possible they didn't have the ability to get the report that led to the 5% figure until they were in government.
@@adrianthoroughgood1191 The compromise of "low carbon" energy and just to 95% make it a good stretch goal. It'll be difficult but not entirely absurd.
@@handsomecaveman it's the last 5% that's always the hardest anyway
@@adrianthoroughgood1191 To be fair, if the world reduced its emissions to just 5% of normal, we'd have a lot more time to figure out the remaining 5% (most likely with carbon capture).
@@General12th if the world reduced it's emissions to 5% we'd be almost finished! What we're talking about here is only electricity generation, which is about 1/3 of emissions. The other stuff is harder.
I would rather have met Ed Miliband but I guess you can't complain with meeting Starmer.
Edit: hey you did meet Ed.
he did briefly meet miliband too
@@anyaakovalchuk Yes, I just got to that part of the video.
I really dislike starmer for his abandonment of trans rights
@@batbite_not abandoning trans rights would have required him to be consistent on an issue which he’s physically incapable of
@@batbite_ To be fair, Starmer never had any convictions. Labour didn't have a manifesto.
Y'know, as much as I'm not a particular fan of some of this government's political stances, I am certain that the previous government would not have had this kind of discussion, so props for that at least. Let's see if they can follow through.
Agreed
The Tories did have similar "talks" with experts and influencers, particularly in the Cameron years and even some when Boris was in Number 10. It's a common tactic politicians of all sides use to seem authoritative and like they actually listen to expert advice.
Did they actually act on anything brought up on said discussions? Hell no. Hopefully Labour will be different, but we'll have to see.
Now we can have a little microphone before they pull their neoliberal shit
As a non-Brit, most of what I've heard about Starmer's government has revolved around the word "competent". And competence has my approval.
@@vigilantcosmicpenguin8721 This may shock you but competence as a reason to support a party is meaningless in relation to what they actually want and the outlets praising said competence aren't neutral.
"Better than the last government" is a low bar to stumble over, but they do seem to be managing it.
Honestly so true. People can disagree with the politics itself as much as they want but it's so refreshing having a competent government. Many of the controversies of this gov have either been 1) something the Tories were already planning to do bc it's probably really a good idea (think I remember hearing tories plan to cut winter fuel payments), or 2) something that isn't that big deal when you start thinking beyond the headlines (starmer handout controversy)
@@EvHocks I do think this cuts both ways though. They're competent, but they're competently managing a Capitalist system that is fundamentally (and possibly irreparably) flawed. That's itself a different problem.
@ yeah agreed trying to maintain socialist policies in a capitalist system just doesn’t work. Need real change!
Better than the last is all they've done. They are NOT competent. Competent would be massively investing in as much solar as the country can borrow the money for, immediately, kitting out all government buildings with solar and setting up a sovereign wealth fund. It would be buying our own wind farms instead of letting private companies own them. It would be building the interconnector that was supposed to land near Portsmouth and come up to Lovedean and was cancelled because moronic NIMBYs wanted the road closures not to happen while they dug a few trenches (not even that many) and wanted higher priced electricity and less capability to sell our abundant clean energy. They can't even work out that their figure of 4,000 elderly people dying if they don't get winter fuel payments, means cancelling any of those is probably a bad idea... all we can really hope is they don't do another Brexit (which they are also responsible for since they didn't bother campaigning hard against it), that they don't torture anyone this time as Labour did last time, that they don't start two wars that got us nowhere, and that if they do occupy any dictatorships, they actually have a plan to occupy them like we did Germany and put them back on the right track and not abandon them to terrorists.
Franky our best hope is that they do very little at all and stop causing damage.
@@EvHocks”competent”, I think you need to become competent at looking at what’s going on. Cancelled elections? Repeatedly wasting our money on other countries?
Both the new found support by the community and your recognition from the political world are well-deserved. You're doing such an amazing job. Thank you!
It wouldve been hilarious if the question was, "Who's your favourte primarch?".
Larry the Cat says, "Call my secretary and make an appointment. Casual dress code will be okay."
what is casual dress code for a cat
is it not the same as formal dress code
8:10 its a lot of skirting around the issue, but also he isn't likely to be briefed or know the exact nature of what you are discussing without knowing ahead of time. We have a similar price structure in New Zealand, and consistently government have failed to address the issue as somehow "too hard" when the reality is that its actually very easy to fix.
I totally get that Starmer is a politician and all, but I am kinda sad that he didn't really answer the question you asked. Cause you could have everything run on low-cost, clean energy.... that energy is still held by only a tiny handful of private corporations. Corporations that are massively profit driven, and very likely see no reason to lower those prices. And this isn't just a problem in the UK, but across the globe. Ofc a government won't always do things well, but saying "we want lower prices" whilst that power is still in the hands of profit driven corpos is not gonna work
Fortunately, with plans to nationalise the energy sector, this issue of price hiking for profit will be less of an issue. Additionally, as the question Clark asked was quite technical, it is understandable for the PM to not answer the question directly as he was likely not briefed on the specifics.
@@randomwaffler It's not nationalisig the energy sector, it's creating a new government energy company. Very different.
Starmer didn't answer the question, because he didn't know. He obviously will have only prepared answers to the "suggested questions", and as came out in Miliband's answer the final decisions in that space have not yet been made.
Starmer is a lawyer he has zero understanding of STEM or the nature of reality. There is now way on earth any PM understands the basics of the energy sector or electricity pricing. Partly because it's a crazy system that makes zero sense. They probably all think natural gas is a good idea - they're letting British Gas go ahead with their insane hydrogen plan after all.
Man it's almost like his interests are aligned with something else, crazy.
Good on you for not sticking to the provided question. Who were the other influencers?
I also want to know
I turned down chance to meet Tony Blair when he was PM cos I admitted what I would say to him 😂😂
Massive respect to you Simon, to echo what others have said, who were the other influencers and what were they there for? Also I don't think that the previous government would have done something like this, I don't agree with everything Labour are doing, but kudos for doing this with you and the other influencers.
Good to hear that your videos allowed you to interact with government - and that you were largely reassured by ministers' competence and commitment.
You've done a lot to help the Yogscast's links to the government, excited to see Kier Starmer on Jingle Jam next year :p
Bro thats sick gg
Wow he met the PM who was voted for by only 20% of the population
Jimmy the goat in the wild lets go
Oi jimmy, stop strawmanning the anti immigration argument!
Thank you for talking about this! Talking to the right people, doing a journalism lol. Thank you for existing!! You give me so much hope!
Thank you for asking a unbriefed question! Had Keir answered this one actually I would have been massively impressed. But I have to say his non-answer was actually quite good and added to feeling reassured. He showed in his answer that he and his team take the concerns serious that some people might have, but more importantly he argued, why most people and companies will actually win from the transition. Very good video!
I think labor's plan is very ambitious considering they are a major party who are actually in power. It's easy to be an idealist when you are a small opposition group.
Thank you for trying to get an answer to this. It means a lot to a lot of people.
Thanks soooo much for asking so concretely about a very important and specific question! (And ignoring what was suggested to ask.) 😊👍 So cool of you!
Well done Simon - the success you’re having and the impact you’re making is really inspirational.
I'm proud of how far you have come this year! Look at you, doing a journalism! Keep up the good work, will always be here for your videos.
8:27 I'm impressed how thoroughly they decided brief him. It'll be nice if he actively followed you, but I don't think thats the case. That he mentioned you infant is impressive. But... It is also a manipulation technique to get you on his side. Doesn't mean that he has bad intention necessarily, but it is what it is.
Simon probably brought it up in conversation beforehand and he remembered.
@@DaPlodEither that or Simon's child was part of Starmer's briefing
Or - and here me out - Simon's child is the Prime Minister
Yeah, I'm a little less impressed than Simon is by Starmer's reaction. It's the standard "I wasn't briefed about this question so let me cram as many keywords from our policy bulletin as I can instead of answering" move. Mentioning Simon's kid is another form of keyword stuffing. Show that you studied the exam to impress your interviewer, instead of admitting you don't know the answer to this specific question. It's a very politician move; eg Macron does it all the time.
@@Olivman7you'd be less impressed if he was honest and said "look I don't know what you mean exactly so I can't give you an answer"
This is amazing, thank you for being so active and passionate in such an important topic. Wish all the best for your future and this channel!
Who'd have thought that Keir Starmer's answer was a blazé platitude. If we want to stave off Nigel Farage and Elon Musk's murky influence over UK politics - Keir Starmer needs to be more fucking radical on these points.
Yall in the UK are so lucky to have a PM who wants action on human caused global warming. Our incoming president here in the US thinks our planet is not warming because one tiny part of the globe saw anomalous cold temperatures for a brief period of time.
I wouldn't be so sure Keir Starmer actually wants half of the changes he proposes, and he doesn't propose very many concretely.
I'm very happy and would love to be proved wrong on this, especially since I did vote for his party, but I'm not holding my breath for Keir as a Brit. Although anything has to be better than what you guys have had and are getting soon...
It's not just him. Adult-child politicians are appearing everywhere. And what's revolting is that people even idolize these lunatics
@ still light years better than our orange bafoon. He literally wants to gut the agency that studies climate change (NOAA) and the agency that enforces environmental protection (EPA) to lower government spending. NOAA also provides our country with all our weather forecasts and climate data. The entire field of climatology and meteorology would collapse without NOAA and its child agency the National Weather Service. Which sucks for me as that is the field I was wanting to go into (I’m a 19 year old college freshman in New Jersey). The fact that my president wants to tear apart all the research and data critical to my major has given me a bit of an existential crisis lol Earth Science is literally my passion.
Even if your PM isn’t perfect, it’s at least progress. We had the same with Joe Biden, not perfect on climate change, but he was so much better than Trump. I’m still dumbfounded half of the American people were bamboozeled yet again. Still makes me sick. Can’t believe people put the price of groceries (which were, relative to wages, getting cheaper the past few months) over the health of our democracy and planet. 😔
@@sirdiesalot2975 tbf I think many politicians talk about things they don't actually care about, but the fact that they do talk about them (and hopefully do something) is more important than whatever they in reality think, in my opinion
our PM isn't known for his honesty or following through on his promises. but yeah it's great he wants that.
great video again! what am amazing turn of events form this year. Really proud that you asked your own question to the prime minister. thanks for this work Simon, your making an impact for sure
That's awesome. I'm glad to have adults back in charge as well.
Congratulations Simon! That was such a cool surprise opportunity and you did a good job handling it.
Amazing! Really impressed with that journalistic prowess!!!!
Man, I know sincerity in YoutTube comment sections is maybe some sort of internet faux pas, but I can't say how much I genuinely appreciate your work. Climate change action has driven pretty much my entire career - albeit mostly as it relates to cities/transportation - but it's hard at times to reconcile that specificity and scale of work with everything else that's happening, the actual environmental science behind it all, and to actually communicate it effectively to people at-large. To add to that - as a somewhat-guilty emigrant from the UK that feels a real sense of responsibility to that place and helping on this issue there specifically - it's inspiring to see people like you that are such credible and active representatives for the country and environmental issues there.
IDK a bit of a ramble but the moment I have some spare cash you can have some. Thanks for doing what you do.
I am a bit concerned that labour focuses solely on decarbonising the electricity sector which just accounts for about 10% of the greenhouse gas emissions and totally overlooks the transport and heating/ housing sector. Combined they account for about half of our emissions and are much harder to decarbonise.
I guess they become easier to decarbonise once you've sorted out your energy grid since it's pointless electrifying industries if your electricity is being produced by sources that release a lot of CO2
It's among the easiest things to decarbonize.
The glib answer is "you have to start somewhere". Energy security *has* to be a priority, as little can happen without that. Recent developments in decarbonising steel production are welcome, although *much* remains to be done. The construction industry's reliance on concrete is (obviously) a vitally important area, here Sweden is leading the way.
Does this government need to do more and more to communicate what it's doing? Hell, *YES* .... but after many of the last lot, these are positively progressive! Whatever you do though, don't rely on legacy media .... for the most part, their coverage of decarbonisation is past pathetic!
Once the grid is decarbonised then people can use electric heat pumps, electric cars etc
Errr... if you switch to 100% electric you would by definition not be using fossil fuels for heating or transport....
i think the crazy thing about the PM is how it's probably fairly easy for me to bump into him, what with him being my MP and all and him being a patron of my workplace...
50 min later and the comments are surprisingly civilized!
I like that your PM has less charisma than the pot in the foreground. I miss boring politics.
@@Mafik326 - many people say that our best ever PM was Clement Atlee. He ran the country while in coalition with our second best ever PM, Churchill. Churchill had charisma; Atlee didn't. , Atlee beat Churchill in the post-war 1945 election, and changed the UK forever, even though we were bankrupt.
Churchill described Atlee as a modest little man, with much to be modest about.
Long live boring politicians, I say.
@@petersmith2137agree. Good politics doesn't need personality, it needs brains and good decision making.
@@petersmith2137 I believe Thatcher once described Atlee as having been "all substance and no style" which I think is probably what we should want in a politician
@@petersmith2137Churchill is not the second best lol.
So proud of you Simon. Not only did you get to meet these people, you weren't afraid to follow up your question when it didn't get a direct answer. I hope to see much more of this, both you being heard and spoken to, and this serious and human style of government.
Simon, thank you. Awesome stuff. Your video quality is top grade and your content is eminently watchable and topical.
Thanks also for the Nebula idea. My wife has been asking what I want for Christmas and typically for a first world person I was stumped. I had been thinking Audible, but now I know a Nebula subscription is the best idea.
They won't remove marginalistic price setting. My hunch is that the UK will copy paste what the EU and ACER did.
This is a great video, legit is reassuring to get your detailed insight on all this!
Really happy this happened! Congratulations Simon!
It does give me more faith in the labour government (possibly) being proactive about this stuff. They really didn’t have to do this.
I bet Kier Starmer isn’t even aware of how it’s priced
Who were the other RUclipsrs there and what topics were they connected to?
Yes I didn't recognise any but they might also have relevant channels we'd be interested in. In fact, if they don't, that would be quite telling about the government's general incompetence which is already on display with their total lack of progress this year.
Wow, what an end to such a turbulent year! I'm so happy for you man.
When you made your video about quitting I was devastated. Your videos are of such high quality and the topics are so pressing, that they are a necessity on this platform. But I had no opportunity to support you on Patreon, and didn't support there to be enough any time soon. But damn I was wrong, and I can only imagine how you must have felt when you saw it go up. This year must have been insane with everything that happened, and you got to go out with a bang.
I hope you actually get to enjoy the feeling of looking back and seeing the progress, because I can imagine it might be overwhelming as well. But you deserve it all, Simon! Please continue to make these amazing videos. I'll be here to watch and someday you can expect me on Patreon :)
Hopefully Starmer did understand your question and that it was referring to how the market prices are what they are, because it would be worrying if he didn't considering it's one of the biggest issues with the country currently. It definitely wasn't too technical of a question like you suggest it might have been. I know we're watching someone who does mainly climate videos but I don't think any of us viewers wouldn't understand what you meant by the question so hopefully the person who has the power to fix it understood it too. Could you not have replied "thanks for the detailed reply but I think you misunderstood the question"? Just felt like watching a standard TV interview where the politician dodges the question and we're shouting at the interviewer to ask them again and push for an actual answer but they never do. It's good that you luckily got to ask miliband even if the answer was just "wait a few months and we'll announce plans". Have you said in a previous video what those plans could be or just solutions in general? I'd like to hear more about what the potential solutions are and im sure you have some.
amazing Simon 👏🏼 I have no real science knowledge just A Level biology & currently an accountant 👍🏼 but love your videos & glad you made a comeback! Especially as it seems you’ve got your mojo back / revenue up and amazing got to meet the PM! Exciting
You don't think that's more than Starmer has? You do understand you're good at maths on some level and he's just a humanities student, right? You definitely understand STEM more than he does, that man's a total muppet.
Excellent question glad you asked it.
Really interesting video! Even if you didn't quite get the conclusive answer you were maybe hoping for, it's always good to see genuine questions being asked, and politicians answering what they can to said questions. Often there's far too much sensationalism in questions asked and answers given. Keep up the good work!
Huh... I happened to accidentally bump into John Major at a service station a couple weeks ago. Not quite the same experience but still felt like "What were you doing here?"
I also voted for something more ambitious also.
We actually managed the trick in North Herefordshire.
I watch all your videos. Most of what is on RUclips is not with a candle, but I am so glad that you have managed to get through your crisis.
Best wishes from George
The Prime Minister should be extremely grateful for meeting Simon.
You're up with the best commentators on climate. Great, clear and honest. It's fantastic that the last year has turned around for you.
I randomly met my country's Prime Minister when I was flying home from my trip to Rome. He had a small weekend break and was on the same flight. We took a picture on the bus that took us from the plane to the airport.
The big barriers to Wind in this country is manpower. The offshore industry has a huge staff shortage, and it'll only get worse. I work for a company driving automation and robotics into this space to significantly reduce costs in the coming years!!! Honestly, the next few years is going to be bonkers, we're going to make wind power significantly cheaper!!!
It's quite clear that Starmer didn't understand the intricacies of the energy markets and electricity prices. And really as PM he shouldn't be expected to know those details.
its easy to think that but i think we expect to much from our leaders. they are only human and cant know everything. i think its ok to not know when you have appointed someone like ed Miliband who really knows whats going on.
Congratulations on meeting Sir Keir Starmer and kudos on following up with Ed Miliband. It’s cool and all that but I can’t help thinking that you’re now on their radar (or that of their staffs) and maybe you’ll have a chance, however slight, of influencing _them_ or at least influencing those who influence them.
And, since you mentioned how, at the start of the year, you came close to quitting YT 5:20 (something which I’ve kept in mind with every video of yours I’ve watched since), it might be good to do an update about that so we don’t have to think that it’s still touch-and-go and that any new video we watch might be your last.
With a large amount of electricity production that can not be regulated, there will be large differences in the price paid. No intermediate source should be directly connected to the grid like it mostly is at the moment. Instead there should be a short term buffer in between (1-2 hours) the source and grid. This will even out prices and reduce the average price. There is also a need for storage unit that can days of usage. This can also help reducing the average price, and increase the grid stability.
As someone who knows you most through random Yog streams, but keeps tabs on your content, this was so incredible to see! You’re doing good work Dr Simon!
oh man kudos to you, I would NOT have handled this as well as you did. I'm not a big fan of the prime minister, and I'd probably let him know. But it brings me hope to know good folks such as yourself are somewhat involved in the decision-making
Glad you had a good talk with the PM on the climate.
Being ambushed by such a person would knock the wind and planning out of most people.
And good that they might want to be ambitious about improving the climate crises, I which they would feel the same on the health crises of a certin minority as well.
it's disturbing to see how easily woo'd you were by the people in charge doing awful, actually evil things being "decent people".
far to many mainstream journalists are distracted by their personal interactions with politicians and don't see that it doesn't matter how nice they are in person, what matters is what their policies are. disappointing to see you go down the same road.
You let politicians use you to help recuperate their image. You sat in a room with a man where you were told what question to ask, asked a different one, didn't get an answer and think you accomplished something. Now you're propping him up. Oh isn't he so nice, and normal, and good and he really cares very much. It's embarrassing. Given what is going on in this country right now, how much damage is being done to vulnerable people and communities by this government, given the varied genocidal actions they're either directly doing or passively funding, allowing yourself to be used like this is embarrassing. Absolutely shameful.
^^^
Incredible Simon! I’d love for you to have more influence on our government, hopefully now you’re on their radar maybe you will be! X
I'm very glad Simon gets to continue making the videos.
Glad your hardwork and honest communication is being recognised. Have they offered you a position as policy communicator?
Simon, will we get a follow up video on what happened in Busan on plastic pollution?
9:24 Politicians are drilled to never give answers, ever.
You can offend people with answers, both by being wrong or being right.
RE: More ambition on heating systems. I'm involved with a UK government funded electric heating project and, in short, the ambition is there too but there are 3 critical issues:
- Governments approach is not ideal
- We have an enormous skill problem
- Yes, the electricity price is too high!
On the approaches, currently the grant and regulation structure entirely prevents a range of alternate green heating systems such as (reversible heat pump) AC and this is actually by design to avoid excessive load on the grid during summer. Of course, blocking options means lower uptake. Secondly it also prevents a large, typically productive group of people in this country: DIYers. Despite being really just a large plumbing project, you can't fit any part of a wet heat pump system yourself without losing access to the grant schemes. Being able to prepare ones own house to receive one, provide proof, and then receive the units for free and have an electrician do the final hookup would likely help massively reduce cost and increase uptake, however, the electricity price is simply fatal at the moment.
5:47 “I’m stuck in a PhD and I blame Simon” lmao
I know very little about politics but I'm inclined to trust our government much more for inviting you, specifically, to this. What a fantastic nod to your work Simon, major kudos!
Credit where it's due; Starmer is getting at least some of his information from experts, and not just from corporate lobbyists.
Well done Simon
Did you not ask about the rosebank drilling licences and why they are continuing with that?
Getting to meet your country’s prime minister is definitely cool! Your work with all your videos paid of 😃
It's always fun for me to compare "Serious Climate Journalist Doctor Simon Clark" to "hanging out with Hat Films and all of their madness Simon Clark"
This was the first video of yours that I've seen, it was brilliant. Maybe next time you'll meet Larry
Quite refreshing to hear this!
I simply cannot imagine America's orange monstrosity doing such a thing. Good on him for it
It boggles my mind that the price we pay for energy has absolutely no anchor to the price of the inputs.
Can you imagine this in any other market... "WHY IS THIS MOBILE PHONE £40,000???" "Well sir that'll be because there is a tiny amount of gold in the circuit board, so we charge the final price as if the whole thing is made of gold. Would you like a carrier bag with that? £1000. (Trace amount of palladium in the manufacturing)"
Not impress with the UK Prime Minister, but at least you got a sort of answer from Head of Department of Security and Net Zero. Nice start at least. Cheer!
Very well done. We could use your intellect and your insights across the Pond!
Totally agree with you! And well done!
So glad your year has had such a turn around! Can't think of anyone better to be in that room - education is a huge part of the solution.
Yes Simon great work
11:50 "95% coverage" is quite a normal target when you're trying to say something has been eliminated. The Smoke-free Ambition, for example, is to get the smoking prevalence to less than 5% of by 2030 (a target which has been cross-party Government policy for a long time, and we're almost certainly not going to meet)
Just want to say thank you for your work - both your advocacy work and what you've taught me about climate science. Pleased to see 2024 has been a good one for you. - from A Fellow Exeter Alum 😊
I was once an intern in national politics in the Netherlands, I can confirm, they are normal people. Don't know if that is reassuring much though.
Cost of living for the working class & wealth inequality are arguably the most important issues in the UK right now.
I’d say you asked the best question you could have, in reference to climate change.
If it was myself, I’d have asked something more relevant to costs of living:
improvements to welfare, maternity & paternity leave, scrapping the 2 child benefit cap, support for worker unions, raising the minimum wage, and return to council housing programs, housing first initiatives, etc…
But action on climate change is at least something reasonable to act on. And it’s putting us on the correct track.
Climate change is to me, a secondary issue moreso.
But it is far more significant than many other priorities.
Things like migration and crime, hardly concern me.
They are… not the most rational concerns to have, given crime rates are low, and have continued to decline.
And migration has a much smaller impact on society, both economically and socially than people commonly think it does.
Such a cool thing to happen, well done Simon!
I was initially going to pass on this one, but I'm very glad I watched it from the details offered.
keir is basically me going to exam without watching the lecture lol
Except it's not an exam and he'll have walked into rooms numerous times to meet people far more qualified in specific areas than he is. That's what good politicians do, it's how they come to informed consensus. None of them are experts in everything, you wouldn't expect anyone to be qualified in energy, climate, health, economics, innovation, manufacturing, science, public policy, justice, law and order, culture, international relations, etc, etc...
i cant lie if it was keir and not ed milliband id be fucking pissed cause ed is the only member of the govt with any sort of credibility
Well done you not sticking to the "suggested" script and actually putting forward a valid question.
The PM actually lives in 11 Downing Street, but do all their press announcements and photo ops in front of the 10 Downing Street door.
But the proper door to the residential area of the building is 11 Downing Street .
Sorry but I've never been able to like keir, he seems like he's hiding something and i think that something is rampant transphobia.
It would have been very difficult for me to ask a question about climate change had i have been in your shoes, instead of trying to hold the guy to account for completely unnecessary suffering.
This is such a cool thing to happen! Love it!
So ambitious about climate he fired the transport secretary because she was actually trying to make things better
That was a political decision. If you are going to win an election on a whiter-than-white law and order ticket, you are kind of screwed when it comes out your transport secretary has a fraud conviction. To clarify, I understand the politics and I think it was the right decision for the party and the government, I don't like that it's the case as I really liked Louise. I would not be surprised if she is shuffled back in at a future reshuffle. Yes it is a spent conviction and yes the tories did way worse but we don't live in an ideal world where all parties are treated the same, the press would have ran and ran with that story. The unfair truth is if you are a Labour minister in this country, you have to be purer than pure. It's a joke but hardly surprising when the majority of the media is owned by a few billionaires and unfortunately even the BBC at present has had 14 years of Tory appointments at the top.
Christ Badenoch opens her mouth about sandwiches and Milliband, instead of answering questions on, you know, his brief, was asked the other day "could we talk about sandwiches?". The man ate a bacon sandwich in an odd way and it is still brought up a decade later. Or donations, Starmer is donated clothes and glasses for campaigning and the use of a flat for a bit and it's front page news for weeks, yet the tories have received WAY dodgier "donations", christ if you donated over a certain amount to them you mysteriously became a party treasurer and then a year later were sent to the Lords (so actual corruption). If you want better politics we need media and electoral reform. Until that day Labour will be in a defensive crouch for a long while yet, they have no record to defend themselves with.
With politicians you always need to be asking WHY a decision was made and not just react to the story presented to you as unfortunately it is incredibly uncommon for our media to join the dots for you as they have their own narrative to push *shrug*.
There is one positive to the whole insane debacle, Louise leaving means we now have an entirely state-educated cabinet for the first time ever. A cra ppy silver lining but it's at least something.
we're having a bit of a mixed couple weeks with government decisions at the moment, some I'm definitely on board with, some seem tough but at least seem to have some good justification or thought behind them, and some are... frustrating, to say the least.
However I do think it is important to draw attention to what positives the change in government has brought. Regardless of who the people vote for in the next GE, I'm hoping the fact that we have affected positive changes by voting out a goverment that was mostly harmful will embolden more of us to take part in politics to try and affect more positive change, rather than falling foul to doomerism and apathy.