I 💀HATE💀 This Costume Piece (& It's EVERYWHERE)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 янв 2021
- Look, you're a super heroine like Wonder Woman or Black Widow or Gamora, you have special powers or cool gadgets and probably some kind of interesting or tragic backstory. But honestly, you could do without the Giant Wedge Heeled Boots. Giant Wedge Hell Boots, more like.
And I do know WHY you have all these poor women running around in Giant Clompy Wedges, but that doesn't mean I have to like it. Short people can be heroes too! 
Развлечения
I unironically want canonically correct 5'3" Wolverine.
It's not like we haven't all watched 5.5'' Iko Uwais dismantle multiple criminal organisations in The Raid and its sequel, at this point.
Even 5'7" or 5'8" (Tom Cruise's supposed actual height) makesa dude a shrimp compared to the heroic proportions of the carefully-picked population of "Actors". So the ideal would have been another 5'8" Aussie (to have the right level of crazy) that wasn't Mel Gibson (who is too old and too crazy, and too crazy in the wrong ways).
OH
I don't mind Logan not being 5'3" especially considering he's seldom even drawn as being 5'3" even in the comics (he typically looks like he's about 5'7" in the comics based on other characters' height), but I do think it'd be cool to have Logan be shorter than other characters.
I laughed the first time I saw the X-men movie, when Wolverine and Professor X were side-by-side and Professor X was so much more hairier.
That annoys me the most with Black Widow's character because letting the adversary underestimate her abilities is a big part of her arsenal, so looking shorter than everyone else would actually help her.
@@barbaragibson612 Why go for the face when you can hit lower? 😉
@@morgand.3809 Done that too! 😉 Don't know if Black Widow punching all the dudes in the tenders would fly with her male costars or the audiences? 🤣
@@barbaragibson612 Actually, throat punching sounds like a pretty brutal signature move.
@@barbaragibson612 As athletic and acrobatic as Black Widow is, I don't see why her jumping to reach the bad guy's face is a problem.
@@barbaragibson612 much easier to knockout or kill someone when you hit their throat, compared to their face.
My biggest pet peeve is that their hair is never tied back. If it's down there's no way it doesn't get into their face when fighting
There is a practical reason, namely it's easier to hide the stunt doubles if hair is covering the face, but yeah it's annoying to say the least.
It's part of the superhero look. It's the same with capes. They too get in the way but it is part of the look so it stays
That's the one that bugs me in any scenes with where women fight. You want that hair either short, or braided close to your head, so that it neither gets in the way, nor can it be grabbed. I play football, and I can tell you how horrid it is for girls who play offense and don't tie their hair well or hide it. You get grabbed by the hair, albeit accidentally, and it's not a good feeling.
@Shula B.
It's part of the design though. The hair is part of the silhouette and often the color balance.
Tie the hair back and you suddenly change core parts of recogniseable designs that weren't created with this limitation in mind.
It's situations like this where you just have to say fuck the realism. It's a fantasy anyway.
It's the same thing with Batman's cape. He is a normal human, that thing would get in the way during movement, weigh him down and be grabbed constantly.
No matter how many explanations they find for it being there, it is a hindrance in reality. (There is a reason it is constantly CGI'd into movies instead of being worn on set).
But he'd look shit without it.
You don't hear Batmam fans whining about the cape do you? Why would you whine about long hair?
I mean come on, Captain America, a soldier during WWII runs around in star-spangled stripes... in a forrest.
Recognisability and design come first, realism later.
One of the superhero webcomics I read poked fun at the "long loose hair in a fight" trope during one story arc as well. One of the characters, Anvil, is a huge woman with long hair. She was fighting against an even bigger and stronger guy, who grabbed her by the hair and just started yanking her around by it, while mocking her with, "Long hair is really dumb in a fight, you know."
The one excuse I can make for harley Quin is that shes crazy and just wears what she likes not what's practical
Harley Quinn is Harley Quinn, we don't know how she can do some of the shit she does, but she does
Or she's like me and finds heels to be comfortable, I wear heels all day everyday, no problem
@@bellaknightR597 same If there were a choice to get rid of all heels or flats I'd go with flats. I love wearing slipper heels indoors and outdoors and easily walk around with them around the house almost 24/7
There's no scientifical reason for Harley Quinn to do all the shit she does but Harley Quinn doesn't care and does it anyway
And we love her for it
Harley is just magic. She can break the laws of physics with her presence.
High heels were originally made for butchers to stay out of the blood of their shop. I like to imagine lady fighters apply this same principle to satisfy me slightly
Pretty sure the oldest high heels were for horseback riding, with the idea that the stirrup would wedge into the show. To call the Egyptian butchers' shoes "high heels" also seems misleading, since at least the examples I see are more like platforms, with both the toe and heel elevated. This makes obvious sense, since a high heel would only keep the ankle and upper foot out of the blood, while the toe and lower foot would still be stepping in viscera.
@@El_Rey_247 Well, yes and no. The modern history of high-heels actually goes back to France, and the fad was originally male. At the time just prior to the fad, military cavalry officers wore boots (as all cavalry do till today) with substantial heels to make use of the stirrups properly as you say. What happened was, the aristocracy of the time may or may not have been military officers, but it was a social advantage to be seen as being one. The aristocrats who were not military started wearing boots with heels in hopes of being taken as a cavalry officer. All too soon _every_ male aristocrat was wearing high heels, and the boots quickly became shoes. With high heels. After about a half-decade or so, _women's_ fashion started copying the male fad for high-heeled shoes, and the height of both skyrocketed. It was kind of an insane time. You can actually see some paintings of Benjamin Franklin wearing some of these high-heel shoes.
But as it happens, the fad among men to wear these high heels declined and within 10-20 years all the men were wearing flats again, or at least shoes with very low heels. However, the fashion for high heels remained with women's styles. While women's shoe fashion has changed off and on in the 200 years since this happened, high heels have remained a perennial favorite among high society.
@@El_Rey_247 This is what I was going to comment because I heard about this most.
There was also a lot of mud and dung on the ground at times and people really didn't want to track that in the house. Some cultures got around that by taking their shoes off before they go inside, but reports of people's shoes missing when they leave the Mosques kind of gives us why people would want to keep their shoes on.
@@orlock20 Mud and dung was why pattens were so popular. Kept your shoes above the mud, then leave the crud by the door when you go inside.
Meanwhile, Danny DeVito runs perpetually on bottom half of screen with zero problems.
I love Danny DeVito. What a guy.
*quacks violently* *puts on his top hat*
Can i ofcer you and egg in these trying time.
Do not like or comment this is my brothers account i lost my phone
Lol in always sunny he's always rocking crocs, even when he's wearing a suit.
Yeah but Devito isn't an intimidating guy you expect to save the world. He's no Dayman
"just let female characters be short" hell let the men be short too, and let tall women make it into the film industry in the first place. Sexual dimorphism really isn't that huge in our species but watching hollywood you'd never know it. To be a leading man it's practically a requirement to be over 6ft regardless of if they're action starts or comedy/drama stars meanwhile gender norms don't encourage women to be big or strong (to put it lightly) even though it'd make sense for them to be in a superhero movie. But these movies only ever use existing big names, so when it comes time to cast for movies where all the characters are tall but the actors with big name recognition all come from the landscape of ridiculously inflated sexual dimorphism that is hollywood, well suddenly the women are all too short for their roles. If hollywood actually captured the diversity of the human form this wouldn't even be an issue
Tom cruise is in trouble then; at 5'7".
@@sarasorensen2650 That's annoying. He is waaay closer to the avarage male height than the 6+ dudes. But everybody see him as short. So weird.
@@i.cs.zamodits It's because at 3" less than the average man in the USA, he is only 1" taller than the average US woman. As the OP kind of dances around, Hollywood likes to put people at the apex of human attractiveness on screen. This means exaggerating our dimorphism with pretty, smooth skinned, average or above-chested women and tall, square-jawed, muscular men. Comedies excluded.
Personally, I would very much like to see the Brianne of Tarth actress cast as Samus Aran before she ages out of the character because she is the right height for her and Metroid Other M offended me, in small part, for chopping 7" from her height.
You haven't looked at the heights of Hollywood men have you ? find me some one over six feet in the top 10 earning list ... ;) you will find that most are under
@@agnidas5816 well only 12% of men are 6 ft plus but most girls and arrogant guys think it’s “average height” or “bare minimum” so it would make sense if 9/10 were in the highest paid by it’s usually like 3/10 under 6 feet
Another reason to hate “action heels” the stunt doubles sometimes have to wear them. And stunt doubles have gotten VERY hurt doing stunts in heels. It’s actually infuriating.
Edit: yes they get paid to perform stunts but that doesn’t mean people should be getting badly injured because of stupid decisions behind set. In sports if players are getting injured because of bad protective equipment or unsafe rules the equipment and rules change to keep them safe.
@@jfoster8624 yeah, there job is to do the hard stunts. Not to get broken ankles in stupid ways.
@@jfoster8624 The job of the person who hires them is to make their job as safe as possible while still getting a good shot. Just because their job is dangerous doesn't excuse employers treating their bodies as expendable
High heels should be outlawed. I've seen people get hurt walking down the stairs in heels.
@@davinwilliams3130 We should make it so people don't feel pressure to wear them, but people who genuinely like wearing them should still be allowed
@@ellie8272 I was joking.
With Karen Gillan as Nebula, the high heels are even weirder because she's already 5'11".
My thoughts exactly.
Although it does make her more intimidating which is fitting as she's still scary when she's one of the good guys.
Does she have many scenes with Thanos or other tall aliens in the same frame? Maybe they wanted to have her more on the same level for group shots.
@@mitsusah2612 When we get to huge characters like Thanos and Hulk, those few inches aren't going to make much difference. Plus, you want those characters to look huge anyway and they're CGI, so they can be manipulated however they want anyway.
@@fv2977 Oh, I didn't mean that they have to be the same height. Just that their faces would have to be in the same frame. Idk it just seemed like the only even mildly logical reason to make her taller.
@@mitsusah2612 I know what you meant. When the size difference is that big, a few inches aren't going to affect the framing much, and the filmmakers will want to add in a few shots that emphasise their height anyway.
My favorite example of getting a character to be taller is the White Witch from Narnia. There's a hilarious picture of behind the scenes of her actress putting on these giant goth-style boots under her elegant ice dress 😂
@Astroblaze the Reality Traverser I totally agree; I absolutely love the aesthetic.
Lets be real, they should have added those heels to rdj's official costume.
They did in the Iron Man suit. Go back and look sometime. Iron Man has heels.
They did lol, he wears heels on set
It would actually work, it's a slightly practical way to store his feet repulsors if he wanted to make them more powerful although he can't make the technology more powerful while remaining the same size
hes 5-8 ironman is probably 6-6.
The ironman suit is pretty big isn’t it
Here's my problem with "We have to give the ladies wedges because the actress isn't the same height as the character". Hugh Jackman is 6'3", Wolverine is canonically 5'3".
And I'll bet a lot of actresses over 5'10" are overlooked because they're too tall, for a variety of reasons but probably including the male actors complaining the women are as tall or taller than them
@asdrubale bisanzio
The guy that did 90% of Gimli's scenes was this tiny kiwi guy. Only the close ups were the actor.
Source: met the guy years ago. He went with the rest of the cast to get fellowship tattoos after the movie
But she is saying is so that they can be in the same shot as the actors
@asdrubale bisanzio huh dint knew that
So, you're say we should slice off 12' of Jackman's shin?
I'm amused that the ladies that you named as having practical shoes (specifically Supergirl, Captain Marvel and Scarlet Witch) just happen to be the ones who can fly... and so might be able to get away with more impractical shoes.
Maybe because they can fly the designers didn’t feel like they had to put them in heels to match the height of the guys 🤯
They can fly, which means they can get away with being shorter.
@@marisalee194 that’s what the comment said
I forgot the part in Black Panther when the ladies were flying around the screen
Maybe the only thing worse than running in heels is a superhero landing in heels
Gosh I remember seeing people justify wonder woman in heels because "it gives her height which is an advantage in battle" I died inside
*Ahem* ruclips.net/video/t9E1sNl0lVY/видео.html
She's is Canonical 6'2 . She doesn't need the boost.
She's already an Amazonian, any threats that she might struggle against are either similar height or fucking massive, so a height advantage doesn't matter.
Wonder Woman is already tall! She's an Amazon and the Amazons, by nature, are tall. What surprised me is that Gal Gadot is the same height as Lynda Carter when she was Wonder Woman in the 1970's: 5'9"
Heels are legit weapons you can use if they're pointy enough.
Top Gun: Uses every trick in the book to make Tom Cruise as tall as everyone else.
Superhero Movies: Heel Boots go brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
I was so shocked to find out how short he was. He always seemed like someone that was around 5'10-6'2 just based on what I've seen from his movies
For an ex military/spy character like Black Widow, high heels make absolutely no sense. If she goes to combat, she should wear tactical combat boots that would give her speed and agility.
It’s prob cuz she’s trained to seduce people and supposedly dudes like that?
And the costume department could chuck some thick insoles in there to make her 3 or even 4 inches taller without it looking too weird cause the boots are so big. Would have made more sense
@@markskaggs5572 I'm fairly sure dudes would still like Scarlett Johansson even if she was barefoot and wearing a potato sack.
@@dagmarbelesova4284 Yes, please.
No, but see, her advanced training means she can somehow ignore all the drawbacks that high heels give her. And she decides to wear high heels into combat instead of something more comfortable and practical because...it's less impractical than it sounds?
I haven't heard this exact argument all together, but I've heard functionally the same logic for various female characters, usually with enough padding to make it less _obviously_ stupid.
Heels are such a stupid choice for fighting. Like imagine if frodo was wearing heels while climbing mount doom to destroy the ring lmao.
Exactly! He was barefoot which must be WAY more impractical
@@fellowspacemarine hobbit feet bro
@@mikaelthebard5068 is there something special about em? Sorry I'm not the biggest LOTR fan
@@fellowspacemarine Actually joking aside not really they're just really durable ig.
@@mikaelthebard5068 ight
Ever since this was pointed out to me I wasn't able to unsee it. Which is why, I was very pleased with Sylvie's shoes in the Loki series, she has COMBAT BOOTS.
Sylvie also tied her her up before battle, it was only half up but still was very practical compared to Wanda/Black widow in early movies and others. These little details I'm sure were added in because they had a woman director who cared about what they made. That's why the show was so good. The little details make a difference.
The only exception to the impracticalities of heels is Bayonetta
Bayonetta wears a suit made from her own hair and fires guns with her feet. You can ask so many more questions about her wardrobe before “How does she run” and the answer to all of it is “magic and style”
@@noonedream9333 She also has inhumanly long limbs.
@@noonedream9333 lol yeah its crazy
She's 100% hammy and she knows it.
Bayonetta's feet are the least impractical thing about her
i thought it was going to be the uncomfortable looking crotch armor
On guys it's sometimes called '"self-castration plate"
What do either/the two of you mean?
@@xCorvus7x The metal piece that looks like a belt, but is made of metal or has a big metal piece in the middle. Sure it looks nice when they stand straight, but imagine bending down and being stabbed by your metal belt right at the crotch. Wonder Woman's classic outfit has it, if you need an example.
@@mitsusah2612 Ah, okay.
I can't quite fathom it but I guess that could be an issue, even if you do bend down at the hip/bend forward by flexing your hip.
@@xCorvus7x It does depend a bit on the character, but it's often one of the two:
1. So low on the hips that sitting down or lifting their legs high might be impossible.
2. Higher on the stomach, blocking the ability to bend their lower back as the edge would stab the flesh above or below the belt.
Not to meantion that practically all movement changes the exact shape of the stomach area, but a metal belt would not allow any significant changes in form. Kinda like an uncomfortable, badly made corset. :/
This explains why me (6'3") and my old college girlfriend (5'2") never really made it as a crime-fighting duo
I hope you understand what a high-caliber comment this really is.
@@admiralofcuteness he does
You sound like the cinema sins guy
@@evaetzel347 ha! that was totally unintentional, but you're right, I accidently stole his joke
😩💀
Jeez, yeah, normalize shortness already! Most shorter men and women are just excluded from acting and modelling, or at least from achieving much in those areas, because of current norms and ideals
Robert Downey Jr is sort of wearing heals in that photo with Gwyneth Paltrow. The shoes are designed to look like sneakers, but internally, the heal is raised quite high, so you look taller. Like wedges, they don't allow for flexion, but they're as wide as a regular sneaker, so at least they provide a stable surface when you walk. I agree that these would be a far less distracting choice for a heroine's costume, if height must be accounted for.
Tony Stark's heels are now canon in my head.
The guy who built a power armor to fly around and fight would be totally ok using heels.
"You don't like my heels? Then build your own robot suit, smart guy."
Not to mention, a chunky heel would be a convenient place to hide secret Iron Man tech.
At one point, in the comics he also used roller skates. He would ABSOLUTELY wear heels
"IF HULK WANT WEAR WEDGED HEELS, HULK WEAR WEDGED HEELS."
Let's face it, he would rock those heels.
True.
What size would he have?
Rock 'em with those hard shapely calves of his.
Pretty sure that he'd still walk flat footed, just leaving holes wherever he walked.
That's my secret, Captain. I'm always slaying.
I think you mean he would SMASH those heels.
It's kinda silly anyway- if lord of the rings can make people look believably 3 foot+ different in height with clever camera tricks it seems doubly stupid.
Fun fact, the actor who played gimli is actually several inches taller than the actor who played legolas- he's 6'1", and they managed to do a load of action type stuff with him
Also return of the king had like half the budget of ww1984, so it's not even that they can't afford it
Yes, exactly, what happened with the editing. Hobbits appear short too but the actors aren't in real life, like why couldn't more advanced technology do this. 🤔
So, instead of Legolas getting the box for Gimli in Helm's Deep, it is actually Legolas who needs a box if he wants to be the same height.
This hurts my head. I'm 5'1 and have been teased all my life about being short. I did the stupid thing of looking at women on tv and believe that that is what womanly looks like, long and tall. I'm three decades old and feel like I look like a preteen. It blows my mind to hear people like Scarlett Johansson and Reese Witherspoon are short, not much taller than myself. I would have never guessed from their movies yet it was them I was holding up as an example of adult female. I feel heaps better hearing Scarlett Johansson is only three inches taller than me. Thanks for this.
Likewise, the fact that most of the men in the MCU are well above average height yet are normalized as well... normal in height. Average height for men is around 5'9" 5'10". Which then makes below average height dudes seem even more unusually short.
As a 6'2" female past 40 years of age, all I can say is be *glad* you're not tall. Clothing is a joke, but at least I prefer men's clothing and shoes so I'm generally okay there (but even their pants can be short on me). Back problems suck, and since we're girls, we have extra weight on our chests throwing everything off. I used to play the shortest races in online games purely to experience life at a height where I had to jump onto countertops to interact with vendors. Yeah, that's a bit extreme, but I loved it.
@@tirsden I suppose all things are relative and there are advantages and disadvantages to either side of the equation. :)
There's a poster for a Reese Witherspoon movie (with Vince Vaugn) where she's in stilettos AND standing on a box, and she's just about his height.
A lot of classic women movie stars were on the short side too, not model height.
If I remember correctly Gal Gadot wore trainers for some of the scenes in the original WW which were then digitally edited into heels.
Her being really tall makes sense as an Amazon, but if LOTR managed to pull off dwarves and elves and hobbits 20 years ago you'd think this wouldn't be an issue now.
But also: let characters be short!!
"Her being really tall makes sense as an Amazon, but if LOTR managed to pull off dwarves and elves and hobbits 20 years ago you'd think this wouldn't be an issue now."
This is a really great point. If you're going to make a film about an Amazon, and you decide that means she needs to be tall, commit to it.
@@JosephDavies The difficulty ramps up trying to get close action scenes making someone look taller. In the LOTR, when they couldn't use perspective tricks to show the height difference or some digital editing, they swapped out the Hobbits for kids (such as seen in this photo i.redd.it/5odws603jsq41.jpg). You have more options for making someone look shorter. To make them look taller, you have to either luck out and find a taller body double, or go full CGI.
The fact she couldn't wear them for action scenes is just proof of how dumb it is. Alternatively they could also hire women who are actually tall like Gwendoline Christie (or others who probably don't even get auditions because they're considered "too tall")
In the BTS she doesn't look that significantly shorter than the guys, I bet they crank up a dude's height and tone it down for the ladies ...
It can be done, but you have to factor in how much it costs to do this frame-by-frame at native 6-8K at about $1,000/day per technician at least. LOTR did a lot of old-school trick photography as much as they did digital augmentation. There was more face replacement than there was shrinking. Remember: it was 2000 when they were doing those fer Chrissake.
The only sensible solution to high heels being hard to run in is high heels with built in heelies.
Superheroines can roll around kicking ass
OMG I'm 160cm (5ft 3) and have wanted heelies for ages to keep up with my long legged friends. I would DIE HAPPY seeing a superheroine kick out a pair of heels than skate past the baddies going *bop bop bop* then tap the rollers back in before walking away like "that's how you do it boys"
That sounds very harlequin
it's not really used but penny in into the spiderverse has heelies :)
Pretty sure Dazzler used to have rollerskates back in the day.
Oh, and Iron Man's armor had built-in roller skates as well. Because of course it did.
OMG I need to see a superhero/ine with heelies, that would be the coolest thing ever with some editing!
I was able to tell whenever they used a stunt double bc Wonder Woman’s heels would suddenly become practical shoes
I've noticed this myself, and while in most cases it looks pretty dumb (I'm not a fan of heels just in general), I honestly don't mind it with Gamora. With the funky, heavily-stylized aesthetic of the Guardians of the Galaxy films and other MCU stuff set in space, it kinda works for Gamora to be rocking the big, chonky-looking boots. Plus, she's supposed to be this heavily-enhanced warrior, so appearing short would work against that part of her character (Zoe Saldana is above-average height for a woman at 5'7", but that would still look short relative to her 6'+ co-stars).
That said, I think platform boots would have been a better way to lean into this aesthetic while also providing the height boost.
Black Widow should just have been left at ScarJo's natural height; she's not meant to be a beefy bruiser anyway. Gadot as wonder Woman probably just should have been scaled-up (digitally or with other tricks) as a whole if they wanted to be true to the character.
They should've used whatever tricks they pulled for Robert Downey Jr. on the female characters. When the female characters are secretly being made taller but the shoes look normal height from the outside, it's a movie trick. When they are wearing wedged heels or even actual HEELS (Catwoman...) it's no longer a movie trick. It becomes a character trait because it's visible.
When you show that the characters are wearing heels, it becomes a choice that the character made. Meaning characters like Black Widow and Wonder woman, otherwise very smart women, somehow found it practical to choose wedge heeled boots/sandals over the more practical shoes. And that just seems out of character for them.
Harley Quinn is an entirely different category because I'm sure she actually would wear stilettos into battle.
If we’re going to talk practicality of the costumes, you can throw out pretty much all of them anyway, so adding heels or not doesn’t seem to be a deal breaker to me :| (immersion wise that is, it’s not any stupider than Thor having a cape, no or little armor for his arms legs and hands, Wonder Woman having her head, shoulders, and upper arms, and legs exposed, Batman having a cape and a latex full body suit that looks uncomfortable as hell to wear >
@@nathanjora7627 WW skin is practically unbreakble, thor is royalty a cape is a status symbol, the batman shit is explained as being for intimidation although i agree its dumb
afaik, the thor costume with no armor on his arms was what he was wearing at the start of ragnarok, where he was on a stupidly hot lava planet with the fire demon guy, had no chance to really change at any point, he wore armor on his arms for everything else, hands idk? thats probably just an aesthetic thing, i agree he barely ever has leg armour, i think ultron is the only film where he has leg armor.
I think everyone should be Shuri and just put on some Nikes, be comfortable and practical
What are thooose!?!
you mean... *sneakers* ?? xD sorry. couldn't help myself
To be fair, Shuri isn’t normally a combatant, so her footwear is never really something the production team needs to think about
Have the super DRIP
Or very comfortable battle boots... like many women would if they had to run, kick or do the things that these ladies do, unless you're Catwoman.
it’s funny that Wanda is one of the most practical considering she’s the one who probably needs them the least. Sure she’s quick and in age of ultron when she was at her weakest power level she would run around a lot but ever since then if she’s needed to get anywhere quickly she would just fly. And she doesn’t do any hand to hand combat either it’s all with her magic. So while she’s making a sensible choice just wearing combat boots for yknow combat she’s the one that needs then the least.
6:15 "It's okay to be short"
*Happiness noises* thank you :)
Spider-Gwen in Into the Spiderverse had excellent shoe choice
She has an excellent design in general. 🥰😆
@@Monie71793 frr
@@Monie71793 everyone in spiderverse has excellent character designs. miles' jacket outfit is sooo aesthetically pleasing
@@gatomeong Yeah 😆
@Rebecca Lauren Baxter I disagree, but I see your point. For one, they’re not even wood, it’s just extra strong papier-mâché out of fabric - which could actually be good, it means less force is absorbed by the shoe when kicking however that means less absorption for when she lands from the top of a building. Secondly, given their composition of fabric and paste, they would be more flexible than traditional shoes, tho probably not ballet flats
As a chick who’s been in a wheelchair her entire life, this discussion of the physics of walking in heels is incredibly fascinating. Who knew you flex your foot when walking!
I had a friend in a wheelchair her whole life and when she watched me do pointe ballet she would call me a witch 😂
@@catleatherwood4770 😆 When my sister was a baby, I remember noticing when she curled her toes. My 3-year-old brain thought of them as “parrot feet,” since they reminded me of a parrot gripping a branch with its talons.
@@catleatherwood4770 Wow 😩💀
(Then again, when I was in my 1st ballet class as a kid, I saw older pointe dancers for the 1st time & thought they were magical & majestic. 😅😂)
@@DrFranklynAnderson that is so adorable! “Parrot feet”. You are kind of right though. Good observation, 3 year old you
there's actually a medical condition called flat feet
Personally, I think it's less about how tall they are, and more about heels giving the leg a more feminine shape. It's a cultural thing. If it was just about height they could have spread the height difference across the entire foot, instead of putting it all in the heel. Eg, 2 inches in the front and 4 in the back, for example. Making only a 2 inch difference between the toe and the heel.
I think fighting in heels is stupid and I'm a guy.
I'm a girl and I think that heels, for all their impracticality, look really cool and not only on women (seriously google Starscream from the Transformers Prime series). Bayonetta and her pistol heels are one of the best stunningly goofy and absurdly gorgeous designs out there.
This! Whenever I watch Jill's videos, I ask myself why she doesn't realize that the reason most female characters wear heels is that they "look better." They're still impractical, but it's just sort of expected that women in movies wear heels.
See, when they were doing the Jeremy Brett Sherlock Holmes series, they just put the lifts INSIDE the boots to create the needed heights (in this case, to make Jeremy Brett taller than his two Watsons, so an opposite example.) There's a memorable behind the scenes moments where the actors are running and the lifts kept sliding in Brett's shoes during their first scene filming together, so what's his name just said "This is absurd! Take the lifts out and I'll bend my knees more!" Or something of that. There have got to be more subtle solutions than full heels - a combination of posing, much shorter heels, and lifts
They aren’t putting the women in 4-inch wedges to make them taller. They’re putting them in wedges to give them the “I’m in high heels” sexy butt and calves without making them look like they’re running around in impractical heels.
even though heels do that, its adding to the muscularity of the figure.
Came in looking for this comment thanks, that's exactly it. We complained about the stupid stilettos, the actresses kept getting injured or having to go barefoot anyway so they said "Ok we'll just put them in different heels! But not too many combat boots lol those are for goths, feminists, and lesbians" and went from there
Yes! Was starting to write a comment then thought someone MUST have pointed that out.
Nah.
If it's for sex appeal then it is for height not just butt and calves.
As a 5' 4" woman, I second normalizing "shorter" actresses' heights
I stand with you on this as almost 5'3
As also a 5’4 woman... is that short? 😯
@@terra_the_nightingale135 depends on where your from, different places have different average heights. But despite your height, I'm sure you're still a wonderful person. Height is just height, and don't let it let you down.
Im a 6ft tall man but i stand with your cause........or like a foot above your cause
4'11" woman here, and yes please
Yeeeeeeeees. I may have cried a bit when I saw the sandals being worn by WW and the fact she was going on horseback. Wedges and horses are a really good way to break your feet. All of her other fellow sisters have these perfect sandals with a nice 1/2” heel - perfect for horses (many of them actual equestrians) - and I’m wondering why no one stopped them from putting wedges on Gal Gadot.
I'd argue that it may also be to make their legs and butts look a certain way. You tend to hold yourself very differently if you're wearing high heels which comes across as more 'elegant' and 'feminine'. Plus it lengthens the look of the legs, slims the thighs and clenches the butt a bit more. Which is great if you wanna look super sexy in a tight fitting outfit, but yea, its totally ridiculous if you're fighting. Given that a lot of the characters that these shoes are given to are supposed to be more 'badass' or sexy , it can also project a kind of attitude.
However, espicially for height related issues, I think that they could take a leaf out of the goths look book and just wear some big chonking New Rock boots or something similar. They look badass af and even the more flat soled ones have a bit of platform on which easily add a couple of inches. (I say this from a lifetime of wearing them myself). Theres plenty of examples of these styles of boots that allow for a natural position of the foot with the ankle slightly raised but the boot itself is big and the height of the platform is disguised by the shape of the boot. They look far more like something you'd fight in and plenty of them have metal plates affixed which pack a nasty punch if you kick someone in them.
The thing is theyre a lot less elegant, and despite these characters being all about fighting, they still insist on a very petite and elegant silhouette for the sake of sexiness. I really enjoyed Gal Gadot in wonder woman but I was a little disappointed that they didnt cast someone a bit more chunky and muscular in body shape. I love the way comic artist Stjepan Šejić draws her as a tall brawny woman who looks like she could lift a truck with one hand. And honestly I rolled my eyes when i say another willowy petite actor who, although could be strong even with that body type, just didnt really scream powerful Amazonian to me. Dont get me wrong, im a very small and petite person myself, im not saying this for my own representation, I just want to see a female super hero who actually looks like she can bench press a house. I feel that theres this idea of what can be attractive and what isnt in hollywood, and unless youre petite and dainty, you dont fit that and you wont be cast in these kinds of films.
SAAAAAAAME! I was so bitterly disappointed in Wonder Woman, all the other Amazons looked incredible and here was picture 'perfect' Diana looking like she was ready to take to the catwalk. Putting women like Ann Wolfe and Brooke Ence in as background extras when they are just complete badass women and deserve to be stars was just so, so disappointing. And I say this as someone who is thick and desperately wants that representation
“Let female characters be short.” Bruh... yes.
And for that matter, male characters even more so.
They all have to be only inches away from 7 feet tall apparently even when the actor is only 5’9. I mean that’s not even short but it’s treated like it is.
@@jfoster8624 What are you talking about? The comment I responded to was talking about letting short people be short.
@Stella Hohenheim Who are you referring to?
I think short women are adorablee
@@Axxidous and have actors of the same age the role is, not having an almost 30 y.o. actor doing a 15 y.o. role.
It would also be cool if they would just hire some taller women actors. It seems like tall women are often passed over because they are "too manly." It really annoys me.
If they ever do a Metroid move I want Samus to be played by Gwendoline Christie.
A cast of exclusively scandinavian women, and asian men.
@@Lhorez where do I have to sign for this?
I've never once heard of a woman that didn't get a job as an actress for being too masculine.
Imagine having tall woman with big muscles cast as their tall strong big muscle comic book characters that they're supposed to be. Idk why everything needs to be about being stereotypically pretty. All those women in the comics are already gorgeous and they arent super skinny and flawless.
The shoes for female super heros has frustrated, angered, and annoyed me to no end SINCE THE BEGINNING!!!! Thank you for this lol just let the ladies be their own damn height!!!
don’t forget that Robert Downey Jr’s Iron man suit has heels built in like wonder woman’s suit
Suit feet can be built with platforms and inside lifts. They might look a little clunky but given that's where the thrusters are, it would make sense.
@@sparkledragon6216 please look up RDJ heels
As a 5’2 woman, I am tired of the idea that short = childlike or cute. Short woman can be just as daring, witty and impactful.
Lol nop. Same thing for men, short men are not imposing.
Honestly short women will kick your booty more than tall women 😂😂 In Uncharted Chloe Frazer is the tallest woman at 5"7 she's smooth flirty cocky, she's meant to be like exotic super model type but actually a badass so it works. And the shortest female character Nadine Ross at 5"5 who is very tough, beats the main character's arse multiple times, takes on two 6"3 buff men in a fight and dominates for most of it (until one got a gun). I love them. Theyre also an adorable couple.
@@eloisecole3579 which is why Wolverine is such a good character. Taller characters underestimate him and get fucked.
Fellow 5'2" woman... I've come to embrace my height and make fun of it myself, because at least for me it helps to endure the stigma. :')
I'm 5foot5 and if I kick a 6foot10 guy in the crotch, he'll go down like he's been shot.
So being "short" has nothing to do with someone's ability to incapacitate another.
I hate WW’s new costume because there’s that metal piece that goes straight down her torso. She wouldn’t be able to bend forward at all
I keep wondering how she lifts her legs considering how far down the armor goes over her hips/ hip joints
It's pretty impractical, but remember: it took Warner Brothers 6 Batman movies before someone finally thought "Hey what if we make his mask a separate piece from his armor, so he can actually turn his head like an actual human being would need to do?"
@@z-beeblebrox To be fair, in the 1989 version, Burton made that specific choice to keep the cowl a rigid part of the body armor to create a distinct movement when comparing Batman to the rest of the cast. I'm not saying as judgement one way or the other but that it was intentional for Batman being unable to move the head as an artistic decision. Batman Begins has not such excuse.
@@dawnmcauley6411, the cowl being separate from his Batman armor wasn’t introduced until the events of the Batman Telltales games, and up until those games were released all of the Batman comics, video games, live action films/tv series, and cartoons/animations all had the Batman armor/costume and cowl being completely combined in one armor/costume set whereas it wasn’t until after the Batman Telltales games is whenever the Batman cowl and the armor/custom were separated from each other.
@@RoronoaZoro-ur6hr Batman Telltale come out in 2016, The Dark Knight come out in 2008 and specifically made it a minor plot point that the Cowl be detached from the body armor so Bruce could move his head.
Feminist brain: wedged heels are impractical in superhero movies and shouldn’t be used
WLW brain: heehoo pretty woman s t e p
Not a feminist and I still find heels in action sequences dumb as fuck. But coming from you, I guess it makes sense-
Why not give them practical boots and then use heels in some not-suprehero scene... the impact would be so much bigger imo
@@anonme_ That is just plain stupid, Superhero costumes aren’t meant to be practical, they are meant to show strength and power.
Keatons rubber suit isn’t practical.
Batman’s stone neck isn’t practical.
Flash costumes are never athletic.
Capes aren’t practical.
They’re just for show.
@@hailpickens2454 jugding that they are showed fighting people, it should have a little o realism.
@@hailpickens2454 The actors still have to move around in the stuff. You still want to make it comfy for them. Also realism makes everything better.
Then there is Option C: stop the stigma against casting tall actresses.
But they are casting tall actresses. Gal Gadot is 1.78m, which is quite tall for women anywhere.
@@Antares2 It's tall-ish, but there are not a lot of 6'0+ actresses that get to find work unless it is for a niche role. Then when it calls for a tall character, we still get shafted. Tell me again why Halle Berry played Storm?
@@EvanSnowWolf I imagine it's for much the same reason they cast Hugh Jackman to play a character a whole-ass foot shorter than him. Because actor popularity and recognizability trumps accurate heights.
@@funnyvalentinedidnothingwrong Hugh Jackman wasn't very famous or popular when he was cast as Wolverine. It's the role that made him internationally famous. And he wasn't even the original actor for it. Dougray Scott was. :P
I remember someone saying that the stuntmen were in awe of the stuntwomen who had to do the same stuff but typically with less opportunity to be padded up and often wearing a dress and in silly heels! They managed to make Stallone look tall in Judge Dredd and he's reported to be somewhere between 5' 8" and 5' 10", not short by any means but short compared to most Hollywood A list actors. Allegedly they did this by cutting trenches for the other actors to walk in! It would have been much easier just to put Stallone in heals but I suspect no one wanted to suggest it to him!
Oh right, I saw those videos of stuntpeople (is that a word? Well, who cares XD) reacting to some scenes and oh boi, poor stuntwomen, they really have to work on the higher difficulty all the time :'(
It's been a trope as long as Hollywood's existed, like that old line, 𝐆𝐢𝐧𝐠𝐞𝐫 𝐑𝐨𝐠𝐞𝐫𝐬 𝐝𝐢𝐝 𝐞𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐲𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐅𝐫𝐞𝐝 𝐀𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐢𝐫𝐞 𝐝𝐢𝐝, 𝐦𝐚𝐭𝐜𝐡𝐞𝐝 𝐡𝐢𝐦 𝐬𝐭𝐞𝐩 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐬𝐭𝐞𝐩, _𝐛𝐚𝐜𝐤𝐰𝐚𝐫𝐝𝐬 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐢𝐧 𝐡𝐢𝐠𝐡 𝐡𝐞𝐞𝐥𝐬._
@@xheralt And don't forget, Ginger Rogers also did all that backwards and in high heels, while wearing a skirt with something like 10+lbs of weights sewn into the hem to make that nice, fancy swish happen. Weights banging against her legs at every step, twirl, kick, and sway. I can only imagine the bruises, along with the risk to knees and ankles going on.
@@Mokiefraggle Mentioning the costuming is just gilding the lily, and draws out the point unnecessarily. Ginger is far from the first to suffer for fashion's sake...
If there's one thing we know for certain, good sense is in critically short supply in hollywood
For the first minute, I was just thinking "you better not hate the head band thing." And then I thought about how little the head band thing appears in live action superhero movies and then I thought about how much I need Scarlet Witch to get her head band thing, and then I reevaluated why I'm so defensive about the head band thing when I'm not even sure what it is
I felt the exact same way
When you mean head bang thing, is that the thing that's like Sailor Moon's tiara?
well scarlet witch did get her tiara thing and I am also way too happy about it
BC THEY LOOK COOL :(
@@appymay8702 hair ties
It would be better if everyone was just slippin around in their socks on wooden floor
This is so funny, because I was recently watching Thor with my daughter and we noticed that Sif was wearing high heels with her armour when they went to attack Jotunheim. So weird! At least now I know why.
Everyone should replace their feet with wheels, because that would be cool.
Men and women will go zoooooom
I believe a few people took that route in Alita: Battle angel
That’s what Heelies are for lol
Vsauce
Have you met the "Wheelers" from "Return to Oz"?
Man they won't even put female Transformers in the damn live action films for more than eight seconds.
Literally went "why does her armour have heels?!?" *In the cinema*
Same but in the trailer. I didn't see it because of it, I'm so tired of it (that and boob plate)
@@Ailieorz what’s wrong with breast plates that actually fit women? Would you rather women force themselves into a male shape for no reason other than that’s what men wear? It doesn’t make sense to just deny a woman’s anatomy for the sake of replicating how *men* wear armor.
@@clownfromclowntown I may not be the person you originally put the question to, but I'm a partial convert from the 'boob armor is dumb' camp.
In all but the most extreme cases of anatomy, the 'standard' for armor wouldn't change the shape of the breastplate unless it is unsafely molding to the shape below, not leaving enough room for padding and underlayers. Those people with a lower amount of fat, like most warriors, have as a standard smaller breasts than those with more fat.
That being said, I agree with arguments that having 'boob plate' isn't a detriment for melee combat, as long as they don't go comically large. That there's not enough force that is going to be applied that would make it through both armor and underpadding that wouldn't just smash through it without the cups. Leaving it down to the culture around the design of the breastplate as to if they wanted to accent the femininity of the warrior wearing it (which makes sense for Wonder Woman and the Amazons).
The time I see an issue is regarding firearms, where we run into the problem of 'bullet traps', which the cups on 'boob armor' would cause an issue. The tl;dr of bullet traps is that they focus projectiles to a specific location, and the cups on a piece of boob armor focus them right on the sternum.
@@clownfromclowntown there's never been a reason to have your boobs housed in their own nooks during combat. historically, armor like this was accompanied by multiple layers of fabric and padding (including chainmail) underneath which hid the shape of the wearer's figure anyway-- it certainly would have hid most women's breasts. there is also the fact that breast armor was meant to deflect blade strikes, letting the blade slide off the metal. having breasts built into the armor just provides an area in which blades can catch. lastly, it was made entirely of metal which means that, with the boob armor, there is a strip of flatter metal resting directly on the sternum between each breast indent. this provides even further risk of injury and death from falling face down, melee blows, heavy projectiles, etc. because any force applied to that area could potentially shatter the sternum, which is meant to protect the lungs and heart.
now, the mcu and other dceu shows that do this often aren't using metal breast plates and it's purely aesthetic choice to design their armor this way which is fine. but for wonder woman in particular-- a literal warrior-- it's really fucking stupid. aside from all the skin she's showing, the metal breast plate she's using is extremely impractical and does way less to protect her than it does to harm her. this style of metal armor also bothers me in viking-era/style movies (like lady sif in the thor movies) because the vikings did have female warriors that wore appropriate breast plates that actually protected them.
tl;dr wearing metal boob armor in battle can actually kill you in a situation you would have lived had you wore regular armor
@@clownfromclowntown also, as i mentioned before, because of all the padding underneath, breast plate armor did fit women. modern desgins of this armor that still use metal (usually military equipment) is tailored to the shape of the individual. women still do not have breast indents with this type of armor because, as i explained, it's dangerous. but it does fit their form.
Ok I came across this on my feed randomly and I wasn’t prepared to watch the whole video but it was very interesting and now I’m wanting to watch a few more. I love when that happens here on yt, it’s rare for me at least :) thanks for putting this out there!
As someone that uses the metric system I'd like to thank you for showing both measurements in the video. Appreciate the thoughtfulness. :')
I’ll be honest, I never noticed Black Widow wearing heels so when you said it, I was like “HUH?????”
Heels would make all her movement so impractical, makes sense why they try to hide it now lol
I didn't notice it either so they don't want BW being dwarfed by the other male heroes look at her standing with her females costars out of makeup. Some of them are much taller than her so why not use her real height in the movie?
Based on the thumbnail, I thought you were going to talk about helmets/headpieces with those sections that cover the cheeks like sideburns
ME TOO
Me too!
SAME
Or that have an edge that actually presses into her face.
Same!
01:41 Now i'm imagining Wonderwoman standing on boxes everytime guys are around and it's hilarious if it happend during one of the dramatic shots 🤣
Lol at 6'7" with a 5'3" wife, the battle is real in cosplay too. Thanks for another great video!
Sad to say, I'm fairly certain a lot of the reason for high heels (versus any other solution) is to make their butts stick out. All of the non heel characters were either going out of their way not to sexualize them (Captain Marvel, Shuri, and Okoye) or their butts are covered (Supergirl, Scarlet Witch) :(
True.
I hate it
Right, it seems painfully naive for the first and only thought to be that it's to make the actresses taller. Obviously there are ways to make a character appear taller without making it obvious on-screen and a literal part of their costume. It's clearly to keep female figures in impractical heels without drawing quite the levels of disdain that were lowered at, for example, the lady in Jurassic World running from a T. Rex in stilettos.
@@molegoddess Jurassic world isn’t a good example. Her characters day was interrupted by that fiasco and she was wearing her work clothes and work shoes, so I can understand that she wouldn’t have had a change of shoes, because her heels were for her professional work wear. I can give that one a pass, because ultimately it made me feel like the disasters in that movie were all the more a big inconvience and everyone was actually struggling a lot. Imagine running in those! I thought.
I now want to see Captain America (Chris Evans) in high heels so "America's ass" sticks out/is more pronounced.
My main take away from this video: RDJ is adorably short.
Now this comment somehow makes me, at 5’4”, feel even shorter! 😶
@@Fitchant I'm sorry. I didn't mean to come off as condescending.
I just think that it's pretty cool that an industry as shallow as Hollywood has incredibly successful short men.
Shorter men in general need more love and recognition. :)
So can I, but that apparently still leaves me as a short man. 😆
@Elalae La Yes it is! :)
@@Fitchant Another 5‘4 guy reporting in. RDJ is still 12cm taller than I am.
As 5'0 tall man, i think it would be really nice to have more short people without “tricks” in their shoes, having someone in a group that is at least 5 inches shorter than everyone else is very realistic in my opinion.
THANK YOU for pointing this out! I never even noticed this problem before, but it’s always added to the overall aesthetic of female superheroes. They always appear more delicate, or more like a centerpiece for the team rather than, you know, a functioning asset. They’re so fashionable, while the men get to be practical-even militaristic. It’s FRUSTRATING so thank you for all the great examples! Also, those poor actresses and body/stunt doubles. They are DESTROYING their feet/ankles/shins wearing those all day every day.
It’s also really dangerous for the stunt performers who have to do the scenes wearing heels for the sake of consistency between shots
THIS
The stunt doubles for the males have to wear entire suits and helmets while doing stunts. The stunt double for Black Panther has literally experienced seizures and heat strokes due to having to wear an entire costume. If the men have to go through that trauma during shoots then high boots for women shouldn't be an exception
@@fellowspacemarine what are you talking about dude
@@elmondo-s1e I'm saying using "high heeled" shoes as an excuse for stunt performance issues is an irrelevant and over exaggeration for fair criticism
@@dovwallack4688 all costumes ARE designed for safety. they're modded for maneuverability, padding, and overall safety, but some hurdles are just more complicated to jump through to keep the illusion that the actor of the given hero is the one performing on screen. Stunt performers have high intensive training with professional experience in what they're doing and are aware of the risks given when performing with bulkier suits, extra gear, and surprise surprise, high heels. I'm not saying it's an overall ideal way of doing said stunts while maintaining safety, but the woman in this video is speaking on behalf of an irrelevant factor--that being stunt doubles--with no actual sense or experience of how stunt performering is handled.
*imagining tom cruise in giant heels just out of shot of the camera*
...running, because, Tom Cruise.
Love this channel, just subscribed. Came over from The Best Costumes where he did a response to this video and then suggested we check out your great content.
RDJ’s giant platform heels are the greatest thing ever😂 I think it’s even better when he’s around Gwyneth Paltrow because she is also wearing heels AND she’s slightly taller than him! It cracks me up every time I see it😅
On the old Wonder Woman show from the '70s, Wonder Woman's boots would change from scene to scene. If Wonder Woman was standing and talking, Lynda Carter was wearing high heels. But as soon as the action started: running, jumping, fighting, etc., whether it was Ms. Carter or her stuntwoman (Julie Eppers?), her boots were flats.
I didn't notice this in the first run (I'm old, I was 8-10 at the time), but I did notice the changing heels in the reruns in the 80s.
Its going to be hard not to notice these things in the future. The curse of knowledge.
Underrated fact. To be honest this make feel this like a regular mistake.
This was less blatant cheese, more of "who's going to be looking at her boots", and blink and you'll miss it. This was the 1970s. You might see an episode two or maybe three times if you watched the reruns in the summer, as well as first run. After that, they were just gone. Yeah, a show might get picked up for syndicated reruns, as 'Wonder Woman' did, but people genuinely weren't concerned about slightly obsessed fans who would watch the syndicated reruns enough times that they start to notice things like that. And packaged shows for home viewing... forget it.
One of the most blatant examples of "adaptive wardrobe" is Barb Wire. Good old Pammy is dressed up as a kind of kinky dominatrix with leather and high heels, but in the action stuff it's flat shoes and her costume looks completely different.
@asdrubale bisanzio IIRC, the Dukes of Hazzard had to reuse their car stunt scenes because they literally wrecked cars doing them, including the classic jump that basically demolished the suspension and undercarriage of the car. They were literally patching them together on-site to keep production running, from what I've heard, and the studio even would put out notice that they'd buy a '69 Charger from anyone willing to sell for it to be in the show. It's part of why the 1969 Dodge Charger is such a hard classic car to find at any price; many were damaged beyond repair, to the point that they even had to start taking '68 Chargers and modding them up to resemble a '69.
Honestly, I think that a shorter "average" height hero would make it more badass
@@darlalathan6143 and the point you two missed is that Wolverine is way way shorter than the average man. Even in the Phillipines men are taller on average.
Well, there's Wolverine who's famously short, and many foes make fun of it. And quickly realise of their mistake.
Wolverine and Vegeta would agree with you
THANK YOU! I don't think I've seen anyone talk about this (granted I haven't exactly been looking) and it always bothers the hell out of me when I see a female character who's suppose to be nimble, agile, and all kung-fuy and she's doing it in what is basically high heels. I've tried to walk in high heels and they are no fun so I can't even image fighting in them.
I've had a problem with Wonder Woman's heels since I saw the first saw her when she was in BvS. (I also found it striking that here were these big muscular men covered up from head to toe and Diana is in this skimpy outfit in HEELS) What it all comes down to is that the male gaze likes how women's boobs stick out with heels, not so much the height difference -- or they would use the magical lift shoes that men get to wear.
So you’ve got a problem with high heels “specializing women,” but not with the actually skin tight suits on Batman and Superman specifically? Moreover, you see *far* more of the men (insofar as a lack of clothes go) than you do Gal Gadot.
Oh, man, as someone who has cosplayed Natasha for over a decade, this is So Relevant To My Interests. The funny thing is she really does wear both wedges and flats in IM2, and there was a substantial volume of discussion on the RPF thread back than about whether the high-res images we had obtained of the flats were just stunt boots or would be seen in the finished film. In the end, they **were** seen, and even though it was almost certainly not supposed to be noticed (much like Laurie's Amazing Vanishing Stilettos in Watchmen), I ran with that choice and never looked back. When I eventually had to replace the replica boots I made that summer, I went with a thrifted pair in a similar style with a walking-shoe type sole that appears to have a slight wedge but really... doesn't so much. I fully intend to stick with those if/when the rest of my IM2 costume gives out and I finally make something more up-to-date, because of essentially the opposite issue the filmmakers have, i.e. my 5'9" self would look patently ridiculous wearing the big ol' wedges in group photos with cosplayers approximating the guys' heights.
The thing that always makes me scratch my head about the whole thing: I used to have two pair of Steve Madden clogs - one brown and one black - with platform wedge soles that (a) had a difference of less than 2" between ball and foot even though they totaled 4", and (b) were made of some kind of springy EVA foam that made them immensely comfortable for walking, running, or even a fair portion of dancing or fight work. And they were made in 1995, so surely things should have improved by now! (I wore those things to DEATH. Glued them back together multiple times before the actual leather started wearing through after a decade-plus.)
I actually give Gamora's boots a partial pass for exactly that reason, given that they do have a bit of platform in front and we can certainly presume the materials out there in the wilds of the galaxy are advanced enough to give her the, well, give that movement requires. The same goes for some of Natasha's later ones (without the advanced materials part, though of course we're talking Stark tech, and as established, hey, mass-market Steve Madden in 1995 was pretty darn good). So I can handwave some of them to a certain extent. But as you say, we shouldn't have to. Cover the platform (which, again, was all OVER fashion just a couple years ago!) and you're set.
Ahem. I guess I Had Some Thoughts. :-D
Do you find being a bit taller is an advantage when it comes to cosplay, since your head is nearer the correct level? 😁
I like Mara Jade and Rey cosplay best because canonically they are both within an inch or so of my actual height (Mara’s 5’4, I’m 5’5 and a bit, Rey is 5’6) and they don’t wear giant shoes. Also, lightsabers.
I once had a pair of cork wedges the same height as Gal Gadot’s in WW. Being taller was nice but I sounded like a My Little Pony everywhere I went 🤣
PS: I would say 'you're going to really enjoy an upcoming episode' but being a Patron, you have already seen it!
@@JillBearup The MLP thing suggests that maybe the sound guys have some say in what the shoes in movies are like, too. If only in the materials science side. Hrm. Thinks, thinks, thinks.
@@llearch Why would they though? Maybe back in the day, sure, but today that is entirely a non issue. In shots where feet are actually seen, good chances the audio is not recorded "live", but entirely done in post (even dialogue with studio quality dubs). In shots where the feet aren't seen, actors can wear whatever that won't be seen.
@@JillBearup You ladies are both lucky to be so tall!
If who you can cosplay is determined by your height, then I'm stuck with hobbits and Tyrion Lannister! XD
@@JillBearup It depends on the character - I often gravitate to the taller ladies for exactly that reason! Funnily enough, I love Rey because Daisy is only 2" shorter than I (at least according to most sources I've found), while I've never seriously considered doing Leia because just the thought of it makes me feel like a great galumphing galoot. (That's alleviated somewhat in my one Padme because the costume itself is so massive, but I still feel a bit oversized in it sometimes.)
Mara's height is pretty fungible depending on who's doing the illustrating. (She tends to be smaller in video games, but comics often showed her as taller than Luke, and I live for some of those images of the two of them!)
Noise is another reason I miss those Steve Madden clogs so much! They were quieter than most sneakers. I don't understand why more manufacturers haven't picked up on that marvelous springy/firm foam for platforms/wedges.
One of the many many many reasons I fell in love with John Wick was seeing them put Super Alluring Femme Fatale Ms Perkins in flat heeled boots when she knew she was going to be fighting.
She also had one of the most feral, brutal fighting styles in the whole movie.
Man I love John Wick.
Well, Adrianne Palicki is 5'11" so it's not a problem of height. Keanu Reeves is 6'1" so not that different.
Ms Perkins is AMAZING. John Wick did everything right!
YESSS IVE BEEN SAYING THIS FOR YEARSSSS. Like it can’t be that hard to at least pretend that the female character is just tall and wearing regular shoes. Or like you said just let them be short?????
You make a good point with that armor from Wonder Woman 1984. There was no need for the wedge heels because the only scene she had with that armor was fighting Kristin Wiig who is 5'5". The heels actually make her taller than Kristin. After that, the scene with her and Pedro is completely disjointed with her spending most of the time laying on the ground. There was no need for the heels at all in the armor.
i suggest we simply convince all the tall actors to squat down a bit in every shot for a change. get down to our level!
excellent idea! i second this
Have you done a video on breast plates? It would be interesting seeing an informed female opinion on the debate
I have one from way before I ever did fight analysis (back when Wonder Woman first came out)
ruclips.net/video/5FDZI7W2gL0/видео.html
...but I have plans for another crack at it in the future. I’d really like to do some experiments with armour and fencing chest protectors though, so it’s going to be a while in the planning.
I look forward to seeing the updated video
Boob-plate isn't a good idea if you're being attacked by swords (deflecting the sword towards your heart!) but it might be OK if you've being shot at by arrows or bullets or magical blobs of slow-moving bright light.
There is an interesting video by 'That Works' about Aesthetic influences on Armour design (ruclips.net/video/1l1jpFjXv4I/видео.html).
Now Ilya is a guy (despite the glorious hair), but I find his conclusion on hypothetical female Armour, at around 30 min, very interesting and nuanced.
He argues that (male) European style Armour follows a tradition to accentuate aesthetic (erotic) features of the wearers body.
Examples are the greek bell cuirass, lorica musculata, codpiece etc., and extrapolating female Armour probably would have accentuated the breasts in some way.
The whole video might be worth a watch, even if it is quite long.
@@AndrewBlack343 What about the "It will crush chest if you fall on it" argument?
Came over from The Best Costumes, they did a good response to your thoughts on why WW wears heels, and then suggested we watch your video. I am enjoying both of your content!
I'm so glad someone did a video on this because it's been bothering me for SO long
Catwoman gets to wear heels because actual cats walk with raised heels as well.
Yes! Exactly it was just another way to make her look more cat like without putting her in an actual cat costume (just like how her goggles when raised up resemble cat ears)
@@Trendygal8 those cat ears were inspired! While I wasn't fond of her platform and stilletto heeled thigh-high boots, (must make it difficult to sneak around in) at least they were part of her fighting style.
ok that’s cool asf
I wasn't expecting a boot and high heels class today, thanks.
Anne Hathaway's catwoman is a curious case for me because, not only she walked, ran, jumped and fought while using heels, but she was also able to sneak away from a roof where Batman was without him noticing it. In a FEW seconds! Imagine her running away, trying to be silent while going down the fire escape stairs of that building, regretting every choice in her life that brought her for that moment.
Every time she wasn't in the movie, I imagined her in a rented and hided apartment taking care of her sore and probably hurted feet (Anne Hathaway too, but she was probably in her trailer. Probably.)
Catwoman is the only one on the list who I would expect to learn how to do it all in stilettos (like that one girl somewhere in the depths of 2008 RUclips who learnt how to do parkour in stilletos just to prove her brother wrong). But that’s a rare talent & every other heroine strikes me as... flats or chunky boot gals? Like, she should be the severe outlier to everyone else, not merely “odd one out”
I've been working on that batman vanish for a while and it is more of an illusion. You have to get to cover in that split second, then move farther when you have an opening. The only clear example I've seen in media is right after batman meets up with Gordon at the start of Arkham Knight. He only had to jump over a ledge onto a gargoyle to "vanish" even though he was still close.
@@timothyjacksondrake4454 Yes but the Batman appearing out of nowhere is just as fun. Especially when it's done to Superman.
@@Warvvolf Yeah, I don't think anyone can explain him sneaking away from superman in .5 secs.
Wow what a fantastic point for you to bring up I didn't see that one coming at all. But now that you've so brilliantly pointed it out it's definitely something I'm going to be taking more note of and film is going forwards and even on my return viewings
Well made well said well what else would I expect? Thank you as always for taking the time to do this. Fun and informative
As a 5' 5" male actor, I do generally agree with your "let characters be short" argument. However, I do think it's interesting how you address the complications that large height disparities between actors cause in shot composition and lighting.
I always thought it was strange that a lot of female characters had heels on cause they looked so uncomfortable, also jeez you criticise one thing and people just start blasting you for it. Yeah fantasy is supposed to be imaginative and crazy and stuff but like that doesn’t mean that it should completely ignore real world physics, especially if it’s supposed to be a more realistic and cinematic story.
Well, physics are always ignored in superhero movies. For example, Superman holding a building a building directly in the middle. Applying that much pressure to only the center of an object would break it clean in half, but...
I think when you see an action movie where the 120lbs, 15-20% body fat person beat a 200lbs, 20%-25% body fat person in a fight, you should probably not worry about very accurate fashion choices in the near future. 😂
@@polaris7346 tactile telekinesis
I agree. I get using the suspension of disbelief to make things look cooler (especially in fantasy/sci fi genres)... but the same rules are usually not applied to men as well. That double standard is very telling on whose eyes the impractical women/girl costumes are for. (Hint, it's straight guys.) If we want empowered women/girl characters, then they should be designed for actual women/girls. OR just give men/boy characters illogical but sexy outfits too. Equality for eye candy.
Explosive barrel effect. Literally first rule of games and entertainment is that it may ignore some stuff it it makes it more entertaining. so if it's that thing it's ok to comment if it's reality accurate, but boring about it is pain in ass. Just like one guy in my country was boring about stuff in games like explosive barrels. Which are for games' mechanics, plus actually many of them are propan-butan not gas and propan-butan explodes when shot.
I feel like I’ve been waiting for this video my entire life 💜 thank you!!
YASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS Thank you for making this video...especially Black Widow because she's supposed to be a spy...stealth hello????
If you check Maria Hill wears these wedge boots too
Catwoman (in Dark Knight Rises)'s costumer designer made those heels specifically that way that Selina can use the pointy part as a knife (best demonstrated in the scene with Daggett)
"Shoe-related jiggery-pokery" is an underrated turn of phrase...
Damn. Thank you! I've always disliked heels-for-heroines, but you're actually the first person I've heard give a compelling reason FOR them. I know that's kind of the opposite of ur main point (which I'm still all for) but daym, that actually makes me feel better about this XD The world suddenly became a teeny-tiny bit less sexist bcoz practical reasons I can stand behind XD
Yeah, now all I'm wondering is about the practicality of NOT having them in lifts. 11 inches is a lot.
No it's still sexist. It's really more about the look, esp since they're **trying** to make the men look huge so having a normal sized woman standing next to them would actually help.
Like how in the live action Hercules, they hired a short guy to play his sidekick, to make Kevin Sorbo look big and tall when he's actually kinda average
Having her be tiny but powerful would make much more sense than a human without superpowers needing to stand head height with a literal god, and a supersoldier
I never even thought of heels being used to keep women in the shot with taller actors. I always assumed they were used to accentuate the female silhouette. Maybe both?
Pretty interesting to get all the technical details on types of heels, what they actually do against the ability to walk/run and why they're used anyway. I knew heels were bad but I underestimated how much!
Sadly, I like watching people with a with a height disparity to their enemies take them down. Watching a average height woman take down a big guy seems like it would be empowering to average women. Making women feel that to have to be eye to eye in height to men to be considered equal, or even better, seems to remove the content of their character from the equation.
The need for every superhero to be above average height deprives average and shorter men and women of role models, or heroes they can see themselves reflected within. That being said, when creators make a shorter than average character they don't need to exaggerate and point it out at every opportunity. It just makes the character look freakish, which is still disheartening to the fan who sees themselves in that role.
Full Disclosure: I am 5'8" as man it is just short enough not to be tall, Just tall enough not to be short, but still considered below average.
The height disparity thing is something I’ll be touching on a bit next month in what I have cheerfully titled FLIRTY FIGHT FEBRUARY, because getting your romantic leads into a fight requires an understanding of power dynamics and size disparity, and how the audience feels about that.
@@NicoEm agreed. Hell, there's even a bit of that in the IM2 fights for Black Widow, when she suits up, towards the end. She's bumped up in height, but the movie does play her as kinda the underestimated badass, with Tony largely treating her like an object and not wising up to that she's totally playing him and essentially watching his back without his knowing it, or considering it. There's even a hint of it in her boxing match with his driver (former, I think, upgraded to security in the second IM film, right?), earlier in the film where he's clearly underestimated her and tells her he's gonna go easy, and then she flattens him in two moves. Why not just lean into that a bit, and allow her to be her actual height, which is lower than the tall tall mc-tall super heroes, and make it an understated addition to not misjudging people like her.
@@JillBearup I've got one word about size disparity fight scenes *AND* romantic lead fight scenes: *BUFFY!*
@@JillBearup Check out "Slug Street Scrappers" a parody/homage to side scrolling beat-em-ups.
Really, it's mainly an excuse for stunt-men and -women to do some pretty slick fight choreography.
Noted for not making any effort in hiding it's male lead (Micah Brock - "Bruiser Bom-Bash") is quite a bit shorter than most of the men and women he fights. With Katelyn Brooke "Peaches Powers" and Jessie Graf "Punchy McBritches".
It's as silly as it sounds.
It would... if they do it in a way that is somewhat realistic. If they have some diminutive twig walk up and just punch him out it's just dumb in much the same way I'm sure it would be for guys
There’s a solution here we’re not thinking of: cast shorter male actors
why?. males are generally taller than females, and it's not like short guys aren't in movies either. tom cruise is extremely short
@@84C4 it's dumb to actually care about how actors and actresses' performances are going to affect each other while casting?
There’s only so many hours in a day for Danny Devito to act.
@@rohithkumar8708 Yeah, but they aren't that many men over 6'2 in real life compare to the ammount you see in super hero movies.
Most (successful) male actors tend to be shorter, since it's easier to get them in frame.
I think superhero movies just tend to hire large men because it really sells the "larger-than-life" aspect of a superhero.
My solution to compensating for the height disparity in closeups is a 4:3 aspect ratio. Gives movies great verticality.
This isn't even a solution, just an excuse to talk about my fetish for the one true aspect ratio.
this is something I have been saying for ages thanks for bringing it up (and I have always been impressed that gal gadot could do her stunts in those things)