Old ROTARY vs RADIAL Engines Cold Start Smoke and Sound

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024

Комментарии • 90

  • @tholmes2169
    @tholmes2169 Год назад +18

    Rotaries are interesting but I love the sound of a radial.

  • @Technoid_Mutant
    @Technoid_Mutant Год назад +6

    Thank you! I discovered this motor in an issue of Automotive Quarterly which covered the Adams Farwell. This car had either a three or a five cylinder rotary radial in the rear, driving the rear wheels. The Rotary Radial Piston engine was instrumental in the advancement of early aviation. The type was sufficiently powerful and slight enough of weight to allow aircraft designers to make sturdier machines and advance beyond the box-kite type of structures possible with other engines. This engine type drove aviation for a decade.

    • @kmoecub
      @kmoecub 11 месяцев назад +2

      Either it had a rotary engine or it had a radial engine. They are separate types; defined by whether the crankshaft is fixed and the cylinders turn around it (rotary), or the cylinders are fixed and the crankshaft turns (radial).

    • @Technoid_Mutant
      @Technoid_Mutant 10 месяцев назад

      @@kmoecub It was a Rotary Radial Piston engine. Not the first, but very early. It spun under the rear bonnet in a horizontal plane. The engine had variable compression for throttling and the bay was shaped to collect the castor-oil thrown out of the exhaust ports.

  • @ulpilotrmh
    @ulpilotrmh Год назад +11

    That's not a rotary engine shown on the Sopwith Pup, it's a radial

    • @user-zx6xv3rc1v
      @user-zx6xv3rc1v Год назад

      А, может быть, РОТАТИВНЫЙ? Это двигатель, где блок цилиндров врашается в сторону противоположную винту.. Это была, очень, распостраненная схема двигателей на " заре авиации"

    • @bassbustingman
      @bassbustingman Год назад +2

      that's a bingo

    • @lanesaarloos281
      @lanesaarloos281 11 месяцев назад

      Thanks

  • @SNIXC
    @SNIXC Год назад +3

    4:04 my soul left my body 💀

  • @Raussl
    @Raussl Год назад +6

    IÄm no aviation expert, but the "plane" in 1:50 seems to miss something very crucial.

    • @gazratjackson
      @gazratjackson Год назад

      That's what I thought too but I just can't put my finger on it 🤔

    • @stuartburton1167
      @stuartburton1167 11 месяцев назад +3

      I am an expert and it is missing the windscreen. It will never fly without it

  • @argonwheatbelly637
    @argonwheatbelly637 Год назад +3

    @2:22 you can hear what eventually was used for the hyperdrive failure on the Falcon.

  • @vincent-wu7bw
    @vincent-wu7bw Год назад +2

    The pup footage appears to be a fail on the editors part.🤔 it looks to have a more modern radial installed.

    • @pylon500
      @pylon500 Год назад +1

      Looked a lot like a Rotec Radial from Australia.

  • @mitchgingras3899
    @mitchgingras3899 Год назад

    When I'm in Norman Wells, Northwest Territories, the Buffalo Air radial engine DC-3 cargo would shake the town on take-offs. But what a sound reminicent of every day WWll airfields!!!

  • @rajpawar9343
    @rajpawar9343 11 месяцев назад

    Those rotary engines are utterly mad spinners.

  • @5phutsangtao-iQ
    @5phutsangtao-iQ Год назад

    Extremely powerful engine

  • @HITNMISSNUT
    @HITNMISSNUT Год назад +1

    Think there both cool ,neat and interesting Would be cool on an airboat but may want to spin the boat around 👍🙃

  • @sensumcommunem4364
    @sensumcommunem4364 Год назад +1

    The Jacobs sounded good during high throttle.

  • @Brandonfportfolio
    @Brandonfportfolio 11 месяцев назад

    Imagine the gyroscopic presession flying with a rotary! All of the tail feather inputs would affect everything. 90 degrees later!

  • @AhmadMuhAhmad-nq3og
    @AhmadMuhAhmad-nq3og 11 месяцев назад

    Suhbanallah...God Bless You

  • @TheVersatileMindMedia
    @TheVersatileMindMedia 11 месяцев назад

    Love the sound, I could listen to their music all day long!

  • @fredvv44
    @fredvv44 Год назад +2

    The Sopwith Pup at 1:47 is not a rotary engine

  • @Allan_aka_RocKITEman
    @Allan_aka_RocKITEman Год назад

    Great video...👍

  • @linandy1
    @linandy1 Год назад

    Id like to see a Napier Sabre starting up. Sleeve valve type engine.

  • @DavidAmato-co5mx
    @DavidAmato-co5mx 11 месяцев назад

    Woo hoo! That looks fun! 😂

  • @TheMNrailfan227
    @TheMNrailfan227 11 месяцев назад

    The sopwith pup appears to actually be a radial engine, the crankcase doesn’t turn on a radial engine

  • @mpeg-8
    @mpeg-8 11 месяцев назад

    Интересно, интересно.

  • @stuartburton1167
    @stuartburton1167 11 месяцев назад

    Pity there wasn't a Bristol sleeve valve engine in the mix they sound so different to a poppet valve radial

  • @user-mt1uw8ks9c
    @user-mt1uw8ks9c Год назад +2

    Wonder what the engineers had in mind when designed an engine like this. 😊

    • @453421abcdefg12345
      @453421abcdefg12345 Год назад +7

      If you are referring to the rotary engine it is far lighter than any other type of engine at the time, it required no extra cooling at any time, on ground or in air, and was far less vulnerable than a liquid cooled engine.

    • @user-mt1uw8ks9c
      @user-mt1uw8ks9c Год назад

      @@453421abcdefg12345 Thanks for answering.🙂
      Why making it rotary, would make them lighter?

    • @453421abcdefg12345
      @453421abcdefg12345 Год назад +9

      @@user-mt1uw8ks9c Because the crankshaft is stationary and the crankcase /cylinder rotate the crankcase does not have to be robust enough to take the stresses, so it is a very thin cylinder with the cylinder barrels attached, this makes the rotary a very light for power output engine, ideal for aero use, engine revs were controlled by cutting out some of the sparks on the 9 cylinder ignition, that is what cause the stuttering sound when one is flown in an aeroplane,the only limit is that the capacity is limited by the fact that it induces gyroscopic force to the airframe, but in 1912 an engine with this much power was just what was needed I hope this makes sense. Chris B.

    • @jimfarmer7811
      @jimfarmer7811 Год назад

      ​@@453421abcdefg12345I've always wondered if part of the advantage of the rotary was the mass of the engine acted like a flywheel to help keep the engine running smoothly given the primitive ignition system.

  • @joelchaussivert3821
    @joelchaussivert3821 Год назад

    C'est peut-être un moteur que mon grand-père a construit !

  • @DeadNova_Gaming220
    @DeadNova_Gaming220 11 месяцев назад

    engine go brr so and plane go whoos so the and make brrwhoosh

  • @carbo73
    @carbo73 11 месяцев назад

    I've always wondered how's delivered the fuel to the cilinders, in a a rotary engine? Not by lines that's for sure.

    • @ToolofSociety
      @ToolofSociety 11 месяцев назад +1

      Kind of like a two stroke through the crankcase. In the first engine you can see it only has one valve.

    • @carbo73
      @carbo73 11 месяцев назад

      many thanks, it makes sense@@ToolofSociety

    • @ToolofSociety
      @ToolofSociety 11 месяцев назад

      @@carbo73 You're welcome the whole concept broke my head at first until I thought about other ways of delivering fuel in other engine designs. It still blow my mind how the designed and built those engines back then.

  • @dougscott8161
    @dougscott8161 Год назад +24

    The main problem with a rotary engine is there is no throttle, it runs at full speed and then one needs to interrupt the ignition (coupee). It think that a rotary would also create a very high level of tourque when flying.

    • @user-mt1uw8ks9c
      @user-mt1uw8ks9c Год назад +2

      Why?

    • @markusjung2087
      @markusjung2087 Год назад +17

      The Problem is you're totally wrong also rotary Engines have a throttle

    • @PhilipEstan
      @PhilipEstan Год назад +6

      Where on earth did you hear that? Its wrong, I recommend reading some more material.

    • @453421abcdefg12345
      @453421abcdefg12345 Год назад +7

      Yes you are quite correct, the early rotary engines were throttled by cutting out the ignition to some of the 9 cylinder, but later rotary engines did have a throttle device. The torque was used to advantage in combat, it gave a much tighter turn in one direction.

    • @SNIXC
      @SNIXC Год назад

      @@markusjung2087prove that then.

  • @joemay2640
    @joemay2640 Год назад

    Cool

  • @clyneheretic
    @clyneheretic Год назад

    Sopwith Pup was a radial, not rotary.

  • @gregorydahl
    @gregorydahl Год назад

    That looks like 2x4's and plywood .

  • @edwardnedharvey8019
    @edwardnedharvey8019 11 месяцев назад

    Oh Jesus! The first thing we learn when learning to hand prop, is stand behind it, so if it starts, you get slapped by the trailing edge, not bashed by the leading edge. You're doing it wrong! Scary.

  • @abhayKumar-ms6fv
    @abhayKumar-ms6fv 11 месяцев назад

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @touchyu2
    @touchyu2 11 месяцев назад

    oh wow! that’s not too dangerous is it? I never understood why for awhile the rotary i.e. engine rotating WITH the prop was ever even conceived! The heavy engine would result in very dangerous even poor throttle response and would have very serious gyroscopic effec also dangerous in a light aircraft!

    • @ATSaale
      @ATSaale 11 месяцев назад

      rotary engines were light for the power they produced. Sopwith Camel pilots were well aware of the gyroscopic effects of the engine and would purposefully turn into the gyroscope effect to turn faster than otherwise possible. That ability combined with the massive power and light way made the Camel far more maneuverable than any other WW1 aircraft, which in turn allowed it to down more planes than any other allied aircraft.

  • @meherbabagod3732
    @meherbabagod3732 11 месяцев назад

    🥰🥰💗💗😍😍

  • @namvu1472
    @namvu1472 11 месяцев назад

    Chắc có lẽ từ đây nhà khoa học chế ra phi có

  • @godman-meherbaba359
    @godman-meherbaba359 11 месяцев назад

    😍😍💗💗🥰🥰

  • @tomskellern6128
    @tomskellern6128 11 месяцев назад

    all i see are expensive fan

  • @user-sg2uy7op6y
    @user-sg2uy7op6y Год назад

    ❄️

  • @clavo3352
    @clavo3352 11 месяцев назад

    I can't watch. I'm green with jealousy ! !

  • @bigturbochannel
    @bigturbochannel  Год назад +1

    Which ones do you like most, Rotary or Radial Engines? :)

  • @user-ng6vl3hh5u
    @user-ng6vl3hh5u 11 месяцев назад

    Небезопасный запуск, стартер ищите

  • @yt-xo4lb
    @yt-xo4lb Год назад

    STOP OIL

  • @PiechaczekJacek
    @PiechaczekJacek Месяц назад

    Abba

  • @user-sg2uy7op6y
    @user-sg2uy7op6y Год назад

    🛶

  • @pranabjyotikashyap6238
    @pranabjyotikashyap6238 Год назад

    Faltu 420

  • @mikebradley4245
    @mikebradley4245 11 месяцев назад

    that one has NO wings

  • @agostinopresutti6865
    @agostinopresutti6865 Год назад +1

    Occhio alle pa...