How AI Could Reinforce Biases In The Criminal Justice System
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024
- Increasingly, algorithms and machine learning are being implemented at various touch points throughout the criminal justice system, from deciding where to deploy police officers to aiding in bail and sentencing decisions. The question is, will this tech make the system more fair for minorities and low-income residents, or will it simply amplify our human biases?
We all know humans are imperfect. We're subject to biases and stereotypes, and when these come into play in the criminal justice system, the most disadvantaged communities end up suffering. It's easy to imagine that there's a better way, that one day we'll find a tool that can make neutral, dispassionate decisions about policing and punishment.
Some think that day has already arrived.
Around the country, police departments and courtrooms are turning to artificial intelligence algorithms to help them decide everything from where to deploy police officers to whether to release defendants on bail.
Supporters believe that the technology will lead to increased objectivity, ultimately creating safer communities. Others however, say that the data fed into these algorithms is encoded with human bias, meaning the tech will simply reinforce historical disparities.
Learn more about the ways in which communities, policemen and judges across the U.S. are using these algorithms to make decisions about public safety and people's lives.
» Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/Subscrib...
About CNBC: From 'Wall Street' to 'Main Street' to award winning original documentaries and Reality TV series, CNBC has you covered. Experience special sneak peeks of your favorite shows, exclusive video and more.
Connect with CNBC News Online
Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedI...
Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Twitter: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Google+: cnb.cx/PlusCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/Instagra...
#CNBC
How AI Could Reinforce Biases In The Criminal Justice System
Peace and prosperity shouldn't be left in the hands of the justice system alone. The severity of the crime should be equal to the punishment. The best way to stop future crime is to invest in the youth and infrastructure. When a community is left impoverished or with little opportunities crime flourishes.
i bet many comments don't understand low level implementation of machine learning
They probanly think its like a super complex AI singularity they are scared
The FBI is going to have a field day with this
Those “biases” are a reflection of reality.
Donald Trump: WRONG!
Partial reality. Not everything is 100%
All this proves is you have no concept if statistics, socioeconomic, or anything related to the subject. Stay stupid I guess tho.
@@Kai...999 Put your money where your mouth is, instead of saying "Oh you're stupid and you don't know any of the statistics" how about you elaborate on your point.
miki77YT why should we entertain points with evidence when they have not met that standard themselves.
End private prison then corporation won't be able to lobby government, empty cells will cost nothing. And fully fund the police so they don't have to look for people to give tickets too
Tickets provide funds for city funds, you are a slave to the system. This guy is lying, without crime he is without a job. Police sometimes create crime to boost numbers
Dude. Stupid person. That our prisons are private is what makes them cheaper. You literally do not understand that basics of economics or life.
This sounds like a computer program that does the exact same thing that law enforcement has been doing forever. Generating crime maps. If you have armed robberies mostly in one part of town, naturally you are going to focus patrols in that area. That will reduce the number of armed robberies in that area. Doesn't take a million dollar computer program, it takes someone compiling the reports of crime to law enforcement. I have been in shift briefings where patrols are focused in specific areas because of the crimes being reported in those areas.
Era of skynet begins
1984(G.Orwell) :
big brother ai
The movie minority report is taking place live in America
NO. Algorithms are fair and unbiased. Those examples were based on flawed logic. These people are just trying to sneak affirmative action into AI.
Well, everyone knows that statistics are racist sooooo...
That’s false. ROC/AUC analysis shows that the models are significantly biased.
This will be abused, almost every police dept has curruption issues. Precrime will be a thing. You won't even have to be doing a crime. Just thinking about it.
Precrime will not be a thing. This will simply guide police officers in their monitoring decisions, allowing them to not waste time monitoring people who are unlikely to commit any serious crime.
So wait, AI going after my job, AI controlling the Stock Market, AI watching me drive, shop and entertain myself, now AI policing... it's getting scary
SkyNet is taking over civilization one piece at a time.
It’s only scary if it’s legit AI. It just uses parameters and data.
Read "Weapons of Math Destruction" if you'd like a survey of how bad bias in algorithms can really get.
I read it. Awesome book. When they say algorithm doesn't have any biasses they couldn't be more wrong.
@ Exactly. As soon as you have a human in the loop, bias is liable to appear. Can I also recommend "Technically Wrong" in case you haven't already read it? While "WoMD" focused on racial and economic biases, "TW" focuses more on built sexism and tone deafness. It is just as good.
The biases reflect the data used to train the AI model and can be reduced by data cleansing
Lemuel Hui how can you cleanse data when the bias isn’t binary but universal?
AI only knows correlation, not causation.
No ad interruptions. Very classy, CNBC.
everyone is biased in one way or another, you cannot actually create something completely unbiased we can only try to minimise it as much as possible.(IMO)
A.I is not bias
Nothing racist about ai systems. They work off of trends, events, facts and probable outcome.
Just reduce your crime coefficient so they cannot fire their dominator
They have to have funding to expand and grow this program if they don't have a quota they will create one this is ground level to an full blown authoritarian rule
"work smarter.." ???
so how do these cops works before this predpol implemented?
Disproportionate is such a misleading word in this context. It’s EXACTLY proportionate. Lol...
Uk police have been biased about Starmer’s drinking party don’t you think?
i live in Jefferson county and i didn't know we had this
There goes my dream of being a prosecutor
Over policing doesn't hurt you if you don't commit crime
* reinforce
Seen it. Minority Report. 😎
What does overpolicing even mean?
Too many police patrolling areas, where crime isn't that frequently reported.
It would be like having 1 million police officers in the middle of the Sahara desert, hundreds of miles away from any other people.
reinforce*
NOOOOOO! YOU CAN'T JUST LOOK AT STATISTICS TO ANTICIPATE WHERE YOU WOULD BE MORE EFFECTIVE IN STOPPING CRIME!
6:21 That's css code, not for algorithms
If your against this then you should also be against climate change theory.
It the same technology used in both
Here from school
Over Policing? Do you mean that more cops is bad?
No, that's not what over policing means.
So explain to me what is the difference
@@PresidentialWinner More cops can be bad. Imagine having millions of cops patrolling a desert, hundreds of miles away from any people. The issue here though is having police officers patrolling areas where crime is unlikely to occur, when those same officers could be patrolling areas with a large proportion of people who have been identified as being most likely to commit serious crimes.
8:12 ... what does he care if its effective or not? hes converse
Since the used training dataset reflects past decisions, or observations, a strict observance of its outcome will lead to controls that will presumably increase counts in the controlled areas, perpetrating a feedback loop that is difficult to break
Minority report in real life.
i don't believe in overpolicing
Can it get more biased?
👍
"From that time Jesus began to preach, and to say, Repent: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand." Matthew 4:17
"Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth: But I say unto you, That ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also." Matthew 5:38-39▪︎
Predpol
*سجن مؤبد **#ولا** يشملهم اي عفواً*
*يموتون في السجون و تعويض اهالي الضحايا*
Translation:
Life imprisonment do not include any pardon
They die in prison and compensate the families of the victims
@@Omar-em7rl
*Oh thank you very much* ☺😘🌷🌷
AIR SALT BHEIYIGJHEIYIN SS EA SEAIRNS
*نطالب بتحقيق طويل مع الارهابيين يبلغ سنوات حتى نقضي على الارهاب من الجذر و عقوبة وحصار و عزل المؤسس و المسؤول*
Translation: We demand a long investigation with terrorists for years until we eliminate terrorism from the root, the punishment and the siege and the isolation of the founder and the official
The hell is going on over here?
@@kristenpaul7159 i have no idea, just wanted to be nice and translate for others to see..
@@Omar-em7rl
*thank you dear very much* 💕💖
@@Omar-em7rl wow such a nice guy. Is it Arabic or Urdu?
1984 hahhahahha