You asking to bring back the "normal person goes to fantasy world trope" is so funny to me because as an avid anime fan all I want is more traditional fantasy and less "normal person in fantasy world" because every show coming out lately is just an exact copy paste of that trope.
I'm more into web comics, and they're also really heavy in isekai right now. I enjoy a good isekai plot line, but I feel like most of the ones being churned out are really basic without any complex characters or compelling stories. They exist just to saturate the market with the trope which really sucks because then you get so many poorly done stories with no effort really put in when they could have been actually interesting stories and it turns so many people off enjoying the genre at all.
I think there can be some cool Isekai but as of right now all of the main characters have been average gamers with a harem or at least some type of girl fawning over the average main character. I'm sick and tired of the perverted ones and the ones who buy slaves for the "better" 💆🏽♂️💆🏽♂️
So true!!! I open Crunchyroll and there's like 10 new isekai every time 😭😭 I've developed a severe hatred for the titles too. It's "House of x and y" all over again except this one goes "I woke up in x world as y creature and I'm the strongest one here!!" Please release me from this hell
Librarian here. The fairy tale retellings are still going strong. Seems like a quarter or third of all juvenile or young adult books we get in are fairy tale/legend/myth retellings. And the adults get plenty of retellings of their own.
I tried to read cinder like 4 times as an early teen and it was totally a right book wrong time bc I was so obsessed with the concept but could never focus long enough to actually read it. I read it for real back in January and I just finished the second book. It's actually one of my favorite books I've ever read in my life. So good
I picked it up in 2014 for the first time and stayed up until 4 AM to finish reading it in one sitting. The Lunar Chronicles quickly became my favorite books and I reread them multiple times each and recently started reading it to my girlfriend so she can understand how important they were to me for so long.
i started reading Cinder for an English assignment and i got so invested in it after a long time of not reading and it ended up becoming my favorite book serious.
Thank you for Barbie Rapunzel shout out. Those movies were my jam as a kid and Rapunzel was one of my favourites! That horse Boticelli was my introduction to Italian renaissance painters lmao
There's a 2021 Little Mermaid retelling called Skin of the Sea, which is a duology, and integrates West African folklore, making the mermaid a Mami Wata, if anyone's interested.
Yes I read that one! Absolutely loved it, so immersive and has taught me a lot about the culture. I haven't read the second book yet, but can highly recommend the first 😁
I took a fairytale class in college and let me say that the history of Fairytales is quite interesting and fun to delve into. I’m now a bigger fan of the brother Grimms fairytales vs Charles Perraults. I also found it interesting that one of the brothers (Jacob) was a linguist who created the “Grimms law” which helped linguist to pin point when consonants shift between Proto-Indo-European and Proto-Germanic. One more interesting thing is the brothers took out all the sex and the moral meanings that Charles had and made it more gruesome (which I appreciate) and apparently they did this because it wasn’t for the children but for anthropological study (Wilhelm was the Anthropologist). Fairytales do have a cultural and linguistical importance in society and I love the fact that they get retold multiple times in different lights because it’s a reflection of not what only the author thinks but what society also values as well.
The fairytales also were for children. They even edited some of them for later editions of "Kinder- und Hausmärchen" (the book they released the fairytales in) to make them more into what they thought was appropiate for children. They studied them too, but the book they released was meant as a book that children either read themselves or get read to.
ABSOLUTELY, THE BARBIE MOVIES ARE SO IMPORTANT. Princess and the Pauper and Barbie and the Nutcracker were my first Barbie movies as a kid and it's shaped me as the hopeless romantic creature that I am.
There’s a Cinderella retelling that came out in 1999 called “Just Ella” by Margaret Peterson Haddix that takes place after she is found and brought to the castle, and not everything is as good as expected. It’s in a similar vein of “Ella Enchanted” for reading level and stuff, and it’s so good. Those 2 books shaped my childhood.
I love retellings if they do something actually unique that's more than "female character now gets a sword and drives the plot forward but still ends up as the prince's bride in the end". Give me the perspective of a character that was side-lined or villainised in the original. Make another person/the villain the love interest. Turn the original love interest into the new villain. Make it queer and feminist (actual feminism, not the girl now has sword kind). Take the original and put it into a whole new genre. One I loved more recently was Malice, which is a queer Sleeping Beauty retelling from the perspective of the villain, which is a perfect example of "villains are not born but made". Back in the day, I absolutely loved the Lunar Chronicles and while I do remember the retelling aspect getting progressively less good with every book (the wolf is just a streetfighter named Wolf - really? And what of Snow White was even still present in Winter at the end?), I imagine especially the first book still holds up in many ways (turning Cinderella into a cyborg who loses her entire artificial foot is a choice that I cannot help but stan to this day). I long for more creative and queer retellings that do not just repackage the original in a feminism light version or pretends to be a retelling but bears so little resemblance to the original it's barely recognisable as such, like many retellings end up being.
The protagonist in Little thieves is the villain in the original Goose girl tale and the whole book does, besides all the fun, really really good non-preachy commentary on patriarchy, class devide etc
16:20 'isle of the lost' was originally a Disney original movie named Descendants which they later adapted into a book which gave them a opputunity to dive more into the characters lives before moving out of the island from where the movie takes place
I have been on a fairytale binge lately. Recently read The Bear and the Nightingale, Juniper and Thorn, The Lost Story, The Book of Gothel, and now an illustrated version of the Grimms fairytales
I honestly love this sort of genre(?), I've always loved fairytales growing up so getting to enjoy newer yet similar versions of them as i get older gives me such a feeling I can't describe. It's nostalgic in a way. P.s: your hair looks GORGEOUS it brings your features out a lot more and especially your eyes,you - ironically enough - look like you came straight out of a fairytale book, in a snow white or a belle-esque kind of way. so pretty!
when i was younger i absolutely adored the ever after high book series which is more middle grade but felt so complex and interesting the lens of a fairy tale re-telling. i also really love how the stories not only explored the main characters but also the other kids in the school and how they are struggling with accepting their 'destined' role in the world :)
Something she said about changing trends in what women and girls want/ who they relate the most to in stories made me wonder if similar forces are what gave rise to the "villainess" genre in manga/ light novels.
This all just gets me thinking about how storytelling in general is just such a core part of humanity and human history and they're like windows of truth to who we are as beings on this earth. Like even archetypes and tropes that aren't fairy tale inspired are all just passed down ideas from one thing to another and can probably be traced back to who knows how many thousands of years. It's just so cool, I love thinking about what it means to be human and stories is one of my favourite things to connect to it.
Hello I am an old. Ella Enchanted was my fave book when I was a kid, it's so sweet. I'm shocked none of Robin McKinley's fairy tale retellings were above the threshold. I feel like fairy tale retellings have always been hugely popular, it just looks like a trend because the Internet came to be and Goodreads favors more recently published books.
Retellings in a fanfic component also reflects the commodification of our stories by big corporations. Like you said, our stories started as oral traditions - now they are owned by billion dollar companies. We push back by reclaiming these stories and tropes.
I was taking a break from my thesis and decided to watch this video, only to realize that the whole introduction to this video is the whole concept for my thesis xD (it's about Cinderella's retellings in image and video)
a queer fairy tale re-telling that i enjoyed at the time was cinderalla is dead which actually went viral for some time during quarantine. it was a very refreshing take on the original tale and the plot was pretty good as well. also at this point marissa meyer is just the queen of re-tellings because her recent duology 'gilded' which is a Rumpelstiltskin re-telling was also well recieved. it wasn't really my cup of tea but i can definitely see why people would like it
i'm at the tail end of writing my masters dissertation on classical myth retellings with a special focus on Medusa, and this video was so cool to watch. you touched on some of the things I mentioned in my dissertation as well which was really cool. if anyone sees this video in my references, MIND YA BUSINESS!
The amount of Peter Pan retellings that exist is WILD. I went down a researching rabbit hole not too long ago and now I have a list of almost 50 books XD
I disagree that in grimm cinderella that the prince pushed the story forward. Cinderella pushed the story by refusing to give up and going to the ball, which by then pushed the chain of events that followed. Without her going, the story wouldn't have progressed
And if the ball hadn't been organised, her assertion etc wouldn't have happened either (she was basically resigned to her fate until this point) so I say they both played their parts. One picked up where the other left of
Not me thinking the retelling of Aladdin, where Aladdin falls in love with the (male) genie sounds really interesting and progressive for its time and it then turns out the genie is changed to be female :(
there's actually a retelling were Aladdin falls for a male genie tho his name isn't Aladdin. He lives in a cruel kingdom and find a golden lap were his find a genie; its called 'wish of the white tiger' by joseph Harkreader on kindle for kindleunlimted
My off the wall retelling of Beauty and the Beast is where, after the beast turns back into a man, Belle decides she liked him better (aestheticly) when he was a beast, so they try to find the witch to turn him back. You also said you wonder where the genre of people going to fantasy worlds went. The answer is Japan. It's goes by the name Isekai. (Although, Isekai can be anything where a person travels from their world to another, be it a normal person to wonderland, or Tolkien dwarf to modern Japan).
Big fan of the idea of just printing out a cover image of a book you're talking about on cheap paper and sticking it to the wall!! MUCH cheaper than buying each one and/or tryna get them from the library, depending on where you live.
Tiger Lily is one of my favourite books ever!! Although it follows Tiger Lily it’s told from the perspective of Tink, it’s fantastic 🥰 thank you for talking about it, it’s such an underrated gem!!
The 2010s were fairy tale reimaginings and adaptations galore. Not only in books, but other media as well: Ever After High in dolls with an animated web series and books, RWBY as an anime-inspired web series where fairy & folk tale characters are badass hunters, Grimm, Once Upon A Time, and other television shows that were centered around fairy tales and/or monsters & myth, Tangled, Frozen, and Disney’s live-action remakes as silver screen adaptations, and one of my favorite book series, The School For Good and Evil, in which young people attend a magical school to become the next heroes and villains in fairy tale storuws (it got an awful Netflix movie adaptation). I don’t know why the fairy tale reimagining craze was EVERYWHERE during that decade, but I got a lot of my favorite media out of it! I wonder if the next reimagining & retelling trend will be classic novels and stories that are in the public domain, like how we’re seeing bad horror media retelling of classic children’s tales like Winnie The Pooh or Steamboat Willie. I think this trend will continue this decade as more and more old IPs enter the public domain and people seek to make money off of them.
Loved this video!! I feel like people often forget Gilded by Marissa Meyer, even though it has the perfect dark forest fairytale retelling, mist and folklore vibes. (It’s a rumplestilskin retelling). Just throwing that recommendation out there ;)
5:18 Disney's Cinderella was actually drawing from the Charles Perrault retelling of Cinderella rather than the Grimms Brothers (The Rodgers and Hammerstein musical is also drawing from the Perrault retelling, whereas the Into the Woods musical draws from Grimms Brothers)
Books by order : 8:53 - Ella enchanted (1997) :Cinderella retelling where she's cursed to be obedient 9:33 - Cinder (2012) Cinderella retelling. She's a cyborg and tries to overthrow the queen as a cyborg. 11:47 - The goose girl (2005) more complex character 12:20 Thorn (2012) goose girl retelling 12:25 the forbidden wish (2015) Aladdin falls in love with the genie who's a woman 13:00 a thousand night (2015) 13:50 (continue later my phone is lagging)
I will say here what was said to me once about fanfiction: You take characters that are already familiar and special for you and take a walk with them. It's makes easier to bond with them instead of characters absolutely new (if there are really any new characters at this point).
what I love about the lunar chronicles is the girls are all these badass fighters who save the world and their boyfriends tag along and obsess over them lmaoo (although they helped too 😭)
I’m super into fairytales/folklore and The Lunar Chronicles has always been my favorite book series. I started to actually really study fairy tales after I read it the first time but truthfully doing that makes those books better each time I come back to them and one of reasons it’s still my favorite to this day
i love fairytale retellings its really the only way i can read fantasy as I struggle so much with many tropes. maybe its just the disney lover in me. i have been focusing more on indie books though, i just like the freedom authors have and the tone that I am looking for.
I loved this so much!! You are so good at creating a through-line in these videos and summarising your thoughts at the end. It’s so satisfying!! The only thing that’s not satisfying is the blank 2013 space 😭 I need to know what was meant to be there!!! Please!!
I'm surprised Frank Beddor's Looking Glass Wars trilogy didn't make the Goodreads threshold! It's early 2000s, Alice in Wonderland, parallel worlds with characters crossing (like you mentioned wanting more of)
The book "East of the Sun & West of the moon" sounds very much like a Greek mythology retelling of the story between Eros and Psyche. (Suggestion: you could watch the video "Miscellaneous Myths: Eros and Psyche" by Overly Sarcastic Productions, it's only 6 min. and 28 sec.)
They all exist within the same tale type of the ATU index. They are ATU 425A ("Cupid and Psyche") and 425C ("East of the Sun, West of the Moon"). Then the "Beauty and the Beast" that is popular today was directly inspired by both of these. It was written by Madame Le Prince de Beaumont and was directly inspired by an adult version of the same story by Madame Gabrielle de Villeneuve.
if you are interested, I highly recommend Disfigured by Amanda Leduc, which goes through the ways in which disability is shown in traditional fairy tales but is used to signpost villainy/punishment for misbehaviour. As a disabled person, I very much related to the memoir aspects of it, and the fresh perspective on how the signposting harms disabled people.
Regarding Scheherazade, I cannot more highly recommend John Barth's _Chimera._ The first part of the book is about Scheherazade and her sister. It is largely an exploration of the nature os stories and storytelling. I won't say more for fear of spoiling it. Don't forget to put Rimsky-Korsakov on the stereo while reading.
The dried flowers hanging above the burning candle stressing me out 😅 (also I love how you said it was 2014 towards the end. So many people I know keep saying 2014 instead of 2024, it's impressive) aaand as someone who isn't quite old enough to remember the "golden years" of YA fiction, it's endlessly fascinating to see the timelines you've made and what books influenced what trends (thinking of your YA fantasy timeline video).
This was such a good overview of the trends and importance of fairytale retellings! Love your way of explaining such an intricate topic. I watched it once for the context, and twice to note down all the new books I discovered!
22:08 isn't this more in the style of the myth of Eros and Psyche? Awesome video!!! I LOVE retellings, not only of fairytales and myths, but also historical events (though it's more possible to disrespect the real people behind the events)
Exellent analysis! Thanks for sharing Also: I'm half asleep and completely fascinated by how the blouse you're wearing under that corset style bodice straight up looks like a fishu. Very 18th-century vibes.
I recommend Six Crimson Cranes by Elizabeth Lim. Thanks for the video. I could be happy reading nothing but fairy tale retellings and cozy fantasy for years.
Totally agree! historically knowledge has been shared through retellings of songs and stories (folklore) tribally. This can almost be seen as a global representation of the need to have a shared lore amongst humanity as these stories may be told from childhood, and then we may pass it on to friends and family down the line.
loving this YA eras tour videos by Leonie!! i always feel nostalgic watching these type of videos, brings me back to my golden age of reading (when university hasnt ruined my reading life yet lmao)
It's perfect timing. I'm currently listening to the audiobook For The Wolf by Hannah Whitten, which seems to be a retelling of Red Riding Hood but in fact it's so much more like Beauty and the Beast
I feel like the wild swans (there are multiple very similar stories from Denmark and German, but this version is written by A.C. Andersen in 1838, Denmark)is a really underrated story about family love and a girl being the saviour. The main characters puts years of love and effort into trying to change her swan brothers back into humans, eventually finding out that in order to do so she needs to knit them shirts of poison Nessel, despite the pain that Labor brings her she keeps going, on the thought to have her brothers by her side again. In the end, she’s being accused of witchcraft, and while burning tosses the shirts in the air where her brothers are flying, saving them and turning them back into humans, who then are able to untie her and save her from the fire. He also wrote the little mermaid, which, plot twist, is a fairytale retelling of his own life and the longin he felt for love, especially from his male coworker, but with it being 1800s that wasn’t possible, and writing about the loss and grief he felt when being rejected by him. In the original story the prince doesn’t fall for the mermaid, and loves her unconditionally but as nothing more than a little sister. He instead falls in love with and marries a princess, who he believed saved him from drowning. On land, her feet are bloody and hurt like walking on glass shards, which amazingly symbolises the pain of being around someone who does not feel the same for you, as you for them. In the end the sea witch offers her a knife, to kill the prince and his bride, or to die herself instead. She chooses to let the man she loves live a happy life with the woman he loves, and perishes into sea foam. Disney did not tell us the tragic and gay part of the story.
Hi Leo! When you mentioned the fairytale the Bear, it is maybe retelling from Eros and Psyche. Other than that this is wondefull video. Have a nice day. 😊
For everyone who likes fairytale retellings i recommend Ever&After by Stella Tack. ALL the Grim Fairytales are in their, the characters are sooo good portrayed, it has a strong main character, there is a love story AND IT'S JUST EPIC.
I really love the vibes and music and your outfit that fits every video subject sm I really enjoy your videos and it makes my day to see new ones. also there's Cinderella is dead which is also a queer retelling it held a really good message for queers
I love fairytale retellings. They are just so comfortable. Its nice to read through it and be able to connect it to the fairytale and find whats the same and different
I am yet to finish this video but I am currently re reading the lunar chronicles. I read them originally when they came out and I'm amazed to say they still hold up like I am enjoying them just as much like 10 years later
Loved the video. Didn't know that some of those books were retelling buts also upon a frosted star by M.A. Kuzniar is a retelling of the Swan Lake which has been retold many times (by barbie aswell) and midnight Evenwood by same author I'd a retelling of a nutcracker whisky also is obvious retold multiple times aswell
As always, queen of aesthetic and digestible and interesting deep dive into a topic. I love the way people reformat the telling of a story to make it their own, to a degree it's also a form of "writing" back either to the original authors story/fairytale or the society that created them!
Hoi Leonie, super leuk onderwerp, heel veel nostalgie 😊 ik wil je een boek aanraden binnen het genre "retelling" en omdat je van wat duistere verhalen houdt: The Child Thief geschreven door Brom Het is een herschreven Peter Pan verhaal maar, zoals de titel doet vermoeden, steelt hij de kinderen ipv dat ze geheel vrijwillig met hem mee gaan. Vervolgens zet hij ze in zijn leger in met de hoop de fae wereld te kunnen redden. Peter is hier een heel duister karakter en ik vond het ontzettend tof om zo'n populair verhaal met een duistere twist te lezen!
“If he's trying to kiss her while she's asleep, that's weird; but if he's trying to actively kill her, now that's hot.”
😂
20:57
P 5:0 5:32 5:315 😊 5:05 @@EmyN
P 5:0 5:32 5:32 5:315 😊 5:05 @@EmyN
your hair ate and left ✨zero ✨ crumbs
The hair the top the earrings *chefs kiss* ❤
#FACTS!
and her dress too. i literally screamed when i saw her
truly, I kept getting distracted by how nice it looked!
I got the same cut yesterday, anyone know how to get those like waves at the bottom?
When you said the most important and culturally iconic retelling --- I immediately went "SHREK."
What is that a retelling of? 😂
@@Thenoobestgirl
...all of the stories they could think of? LOL
You asking to bring back the "normal person goes to fantasy world trope" is so funny to me because as an avid anime fan all I want is more traditional fantasy and less "normal person in fantasy world" because every show coming out lately is just an exact copy paste of that trope.
I avoid isekai like the plague ngl 😅 Enough is enough
@@kiczcock fr like isekai is so overdone these days
I'm more into web comics, and they're also really heavy in isekai right now. I enjoy a good isekai plot line, but I feel like most of the ones being churned out are really basic without any complex characters or compelling stories. They exist just to saturate the market with the trope which really sucks because then you get so many poorly done stories with no effort really put in when they could have been actually interesting stories and it turns so many people off enjoying the genre at all.
I think there can be some cool Isekai but as of right now all of the main characters have been average gamers with a harem or at least some type of girl fawning over the average main character. I'm sick and tired of the perverted ones and the ones who buy slaves for the "better" 💆🏽♂️💆🏽♂️
So true!!! I open Crunchyroll and there's like 10 new isekai every time 😭😭 I've developed a severe hatred for the titles too. It's "House of x and y" all over again except this one goes "I woke up in x world as y creature and I'm the strongest one here!!" Please release me from this hell
Librarian here. The fairy tale retellings are still going strong. Seems like a quarter or third of all juvenile or young adult books we get in are fairy tale/legend/myth retellings. And the adults get plenty of retellings of their own.
i miss how my life felt when Cinder first came out
it was such an innocent time
I tried to read cinder like 4 times as an early teen and it was totally a right book wrong time bc I was so obsessed with the concept but could never focus long enough to actually read it. I read it for real back in January and I just finished the second book. It's actually one of my favorite books I've ever read in my life. So good
I picked it up in 2014 for the first time and stayed up until 4 AM to finish reading it in one sitting. The Lunar Chronicles quickly became my favorite books and I reread them multiple times each and recently started reading it to my girlfriend so she can understand how important they were to me for so long.
i started reading Cinder for an English assignment and i got so invested in it after a long time of not reading and it ended up becoming my favorite book serious.
The lunar chronicles have to be in my top 10 series, it’s been forever since I’ve read them and I still think about them all the time!
Thank you for Barbie Rapunzel shout out. Those movies were my jam as a kid and Rapunzel was one of my favourites! That horse Boticelli was my introduction to Italian renaissance painters lmao
This!! I still have my VHS for nostalgia only 😭
an improtant part of my childhood!
I see Cinder on the cover, I click.
I SEE LEONIE UPLOAD AND I CLICKKK
ALSO OMG girl where did you get the flowery corset shirt thingy I NEED JT.
i got it at the london vintage market at brick lane! they have a lot there!
@@TheBookLeo AHH TYSM
Literally clicked on the video because of the Cinder cover 🤩
@@bib4eto656same
There's a 2021 Little Mermaid retelling called Skin of the Sea, which is a duology, and integrates West African folklore, making the mermaid a Mami Wata, if anyone's interested.
Yes I read that one! Absolutely loved it, so immersive and has taught me a lot about the culture. I haven't read the second book yet, but can highly recommend the first 😁
Theres also another mermaid novel similar to that called The Deep by Rivers Solomon which I loved!
@@dearreaderrr i think i recently added that to my GR TBR! Can't find a physical copy of it yet, but I might try ebooks this year.
I read that one!! Can’t wait to read the sequel next. I love anything with mermaid folklore
❤❤❤❤
I took a fairytale class in college and let me say that the history of Fairytales is quite interesting and fun to delve into. I’m now a bigger fan of the brother Grimms fairytales vs Charles Perraults. I also found it interesting that one of the brothers (Jacob) was a linguist who created the “Grimms law” which helped linguist to pin point when consonants shift between Proto-Indo-European and Proto-Germanic. One more interesting thing is the brothers took out all the sex and the moral meanings that Charles had and made it more gruesome (which I appreciate) and apparently they did this because it wasn’t for the children but for anthropological study (Wilhelm was the Anthropologist). Fairytales do have a cultural and linguistical importance in society and I love the fact that they get retold multiple times in different lights because it’s a reflection of not what only the author thinks but what society also values as well.
there’s fairytale class in college? cool
The fairytales also were for children. They even edited some of them for later editions of "Kinder- und Hausmärchen" (the book they released the fairytales in) to make them more into what they thought was appropiate for children.
They studied them too, but the book they released was meant as a book that children either read themselves or get read to.
I’m a huge fan of fairytales and have taken classes as well and I totally agree
ABSOLUTELY, THE BARBIE MOVIES ARE SO IMPORTANT. Princess and the Pauper and Barbie and the Nutcracker were my first Barbie movies as a kid and it's shaped me as the hopeless romantic creature that I am.
20:47 "where the prince just falls in love with the prince", I want to read that!!
The best one of these is actually Till We Have Faces, CS Lewis' dark af retelling of the cupid-psyche myth from the girl boss sister's perspective.
There’s a Cinderella retelling that came out in 1999 called “Just Ella” by Margaret Peterson Haddix that takes place after she is found and brought to the castle, and not everything is as good as expected. It’s in a similar vein of “Ella Enchanted” for reading level and stuff, and it’s so good. Those 2 books shaped my childhood.
I love retellings if they do something actually unique that's more than "female character now gets a sword and drives the plot forward but still ends up as the prince's bride in the end". Give me the perspective of a character that was side-lined or villainised in the original. Make another person/the villain the love interest. Turn the original love interest into the new villain. Make it queer and feminist (actual feminism, not the girl now has sword kind). Take the original and put it into a whole new genre.
One I loved more recently was Malice, which is a queer Sleeping Beauty retelling from the perspective of the villain, which is a perfect example of "villains are not born but made". Back in the day, I absolutely loved the Lunar Chronicles and while I do remember the retelling aspect getting progressively less good with every book (the wolf is just a streetfighter named Wolf - really? And what of Snow White was even still present in Winter at the end?), I imagine especially the first book still holds up in many ways (turning Cinderella into a cyborg who loses her entire artificial foot is a choice that I cannot help but stan to this day). I long for more creative and queer retellings that do not just repackage the original in a feminism light version or pretends to be a retelling but bears so little resemblance to the original it's barely recognisable as such, like many retellings end up being.
The protagonist in Little thieves is the villain in the original Goose girl tale and the whole book does, besides all the fun, really really good non-preachy commentary on patriarchy, class devide etc
I know nothing of ACATOR, but this explanation also fits into Cupid and Psyche. Well all fairy tales are Cupid and Psyche variants tbh
16:20 'isle of the lost' was originally a Disney original movie named Descendants which they later adapted into a book which gave them a opputunity to dive more into the characters lives before moving out of the island from where the movie takes place
I have been on a fairytale binge lately. Recently read The Bear and the Nightingale, Juniper and Thorn, The Lost Story, The Book of Gothel, and now an illustrated version of the Grimms fairytales
I loved the Book of Gothel! I think it is a bit underrated in the online bookish community
Juniper and Thorne is one of my favorite books recently!
I honestly love this sort of genre(?), I've always loved fairytales growing up so getting to enjoy newer yet similar versions of them as i get older gives me such a feeling I can't describe. It's nostalgic in a way.
P.s: your hair looks GORGEOUS it brings your features out a lot more and especially your eyes,you - ironically enough - look like you came straight out of a fairytale book, in a snow white or a belle-esque kind of way. so pretty!
when i was younger i absolutely adored the ever after high book series which is more middle grade but felt so complex and interesting the lens of a fairy tale re-telling. i also really love how the stories not only explored the main characters but also the other kids in the school and how they are struggling with accepting their 'destined' role in the world :)
Yess, Ever After High is so good!
Cinder and Once Upon A Time (plus Wicked) being my teen years is so accurate.
Something she said about changing trends in what women and girls want/ who they relate the most to in stories made me wonder if similar forces are what gave rise to the "villainess" genre in manga/ light novels.
This all just gets me thinking about how storytelling in general is just such a core part of humanity and human history and they're like windows of truth to who we are as beings on this earth. Like even archetypes and tropes that aren't fairy tale inspired are all just passed down ideas from one thing to another and can probably be traced back to who knows how many thousands of years. It's just so cool, I love thinking about what it means to be human and stories is one of my favourite things to connect to it.
Ella Enchanted was my favorite book as a kid. I read it an absurd amount of times.
14:00 thats is the entire genre called Isekai and its mostly popular in japanese light novels but also its in western books too
The Malice duology is a great retelling of Sleeping Beauty from the villain perspective, and it’s also sapphic! Highly recommend
I love that duology! Takes morally grey to the next level.
Hello I am an old. Ella Enchanted was my fave book when I was a kid, it's so sweet. I'm shocked none of Robin McKinley's fairy tale retellings were above the threshold.
I feel like fairy tale retellings have always been hugely popular, it just looks like a trend because the Internet came to be and Goodreads favors more recently published books.
Also very surprised not to see anything by Robin McKinley! Beauty and Spindle's End are still huge comfort reads for me
Retellings in a fanfic component also reflects the commodification of our stories by big corporations. Like you said, our stories started as oral traditions - now they are owned by billion dollar companies. We push back by reclaiming these stories and tropes.
The corporations don't own the original stories though. Only the versions they themselves have "created"
I was taking a break from my thesis and decided to watch this video, only to realize that the whole introduction to this video is the whole concept for my thesis xD (it's about Cinderella's retellings in image and video)
a queer fairy tale re-telling that i enjoyed at the time was cinderalla is dead which actually went viral for some time during quarantine. it was a very refreshing take on the original tale and the plot was pretty good as well. also at this point marissa meyer is just the queen of re-tellings because her recent duology 'gilded' which is a Rumpelstiltskin re-telling was also well recieved. it wasn't really my cup of tea but i can definitely see why people would like it
bruh you hair.... IM OBSESSED 😭😭😭
The corset you're wearing is divine, such a nice touch to the fairytale theme haha
I was obsessed with Gail Carson Levene’s books when I was younger. I read fairest so many times
i'm at the tail end of writing my masters dissertation on classical myth retellings with a special focus on Medusa, and this video was so cool to watch. you touched on some of the things I mentioned in my dissertation as well which was really cool. if anyone sees this video in my references, MIND YA BUSINESS!
The amount of Peter Pan retellings that exist is WILD. I went down a researching rabbit hole not too long ago and now I have a list of almost 50 books XD
you should totally drop the list 😊
Pls drop the list. Idk what JM Barrie was on when he wrote Peter Pan but I will consume anything related to it
Avoid the never king unless you like good and slutty heroines and cringey writing
I can handle the smut but i draw the line at bad writing
Please drop a list. I am obsessed with anything and everything about Peter Pan.
The 10th Kingdom is the OG retelling show. It deserves more love.
I disagree that in grimm cinderella that the prince pushed the story forward. Cinderella pushed the story by refusing to give up and going to the ball, which by then pushed the chain of events that followed. Without her going, the story wouldn't have progressed
And if the ball hadn't been organised, her assertion etc wouldn't have happened either (she was basically resigned to her fate until this point) so I say they both played their parts. One picked up where the other left of
Not me thinking the retelling of Aladdin, where Aladdin falls in love with the (male) genie sounds really interesting and progressive for its time and it then turns out the genie is changed to be female :(
there's actually a retelling were Aladdin falls for a male genie tho his name isn't Aladdin. He lives in a cruel kingdom and find a golden lap were his find a genie; its called 'wish of the white tiger' by joseph Harkreader on kindle for kindleunlimted
DUDE IM SO GLAD YOU TALKED ABOUT THE GOOSE GIRL THAT SERIES DEFINED MEEE
My off the wall retelling of Beauty and the Beast is where, after the beast turns back into a man, Belle decides she liked him better (aestheticly) when he was a beast, so they try to find the witch to turn him back.
You also said you wonder where the genre of people going to fantasy worlds went. The answer is Japan. It's goes by the name Isekai. (Although, Isekai can be anything where a person travels from their world to another, be it a normal person to wonderland, or Tolkien dwarf to modern Japan).
what book was that beauty and the beast one?
Big fan of the idea of just printing out a cover image of a book you're talking about on cheap paper and sticking it to the wall!! MUCH cheaper than buying each one and/or tryna get them from the library, depending on where you live.
Tiger Lily is one of my favourite books ever!! Although it follows Tiger Lily it’s told from the perspective of Tink, it’s fantastic 🥰 thank you for talking about it, it’s such an underrated gem!!
The 2010s were fairy tale reimaginings and adaptations galore. Not only in books, but other media as well: Ever After High in dolls with an animated web series and books, RWBY as an anime-inspired web series where fairy & folk tale characters are badass hunters, Grimm, Once Upon A Time, and other television shows that were centered around fairy tales and/or monsters & myth, Tangled, Frozen, and Disney’s live-action remakes as silver screen adaptations, and one of my favorite book series, The School For Good and Evil, in which young people attend a magical school to become the next heroes and villains in fairy tale storuws (it got an awful Netflix movie adaptation). I don’t know why the fairy tale reimagining craze was EVERYWHERE during that decade, but I got a lot of my favorite media out of it!
I wonder if the next reimagining & retelling trend will be classic novels and stories that are in the public domain, like how we’re seeing bad horror media retelling of classic children’s tales like Winnie The Pooh or Steamboat Willie. I think this trend will continue this decade as more and more old IPs enter the public domain and people seek to make money off of them.
Loved this video!! I feel like people often forget Gilded by Marissa Meyer, even though it has the perfect dark forest fairytale retelling, mist and folklore vibes. (It’s a rumplestilskin retelling). Just throwing that recommendation out there ;)
I was living for the fairytale retelling era back in like 2015. It was my whole personality. Now, I’m all about cozy fantasy which feels right ha
the look, the background, the dressss, just chef's kiss!!
you with your new hair cut radiate Howl vibes (Howls moving Castle of course), i love it
There's already a secret history retelling, when we were villains has basically the same trope and vibes of the original
Imo Secret History is already a Dead Poets Society retelling
5:18 Disney's Cinderella was actually drawing from the Charles Perrault retelling of Cinderella rather than the Grimms Brothers (The Rodgers and Hammerstein musical is also drawing from the Perrault retelling, whereas the Into the Woods musical draws from Grimms Brothers)
Books by order :
8:53 - Ella enchanted (1997) :Cinderella retelling where she's cursed to be obedient
9:33 - Cinder (2012) Cinderella retelling. She's a cyborg and tries to overthrow the queen as a cyborg.
11:47 - The goose girl (2005) more complex character
12:20 Thorn (2012) goose girl retelling
12:25 the forbidden wish (2015) Aladdin falls in love with the genie who's a woman
13:00 a thousand night (2015)
13:50
(continue later my phone is lagging)
I will say here what was said to me once about fanfiction: You take characters that are already familiar and special for you and take a walk with them. It's makes easier to bond with them instead of characters absolutely new (if there are really any new characters at this point).
You had me at Cinder AND Little Thieves in the thumbnail 🤭
[Little Thieves, my beloved 💛 I will never stop recommending it to literally everyone!!!]
what I love about the lunar chronicles is the girls are all these badass fighters who save the world and their boyfriends tag along and obsess over them lmaoo (although they helped too 😭)
This was a perrrrrfect opportunity to talk about east by edith pattou !! Its a really good retelling of east of the sun west of the moon
I ADORED that book. There is apparently a sequel called “West” that I have been meaning to borrow from the library
I’m super into fairytales/folklore and The Lunar Chronicles has always been my favorite book series. I started to actually really study fairy tales after I read it the first time but truthfully doing that makes those books better each time I come back to them and one of reasons it’s still my favorite to this day
i love fairytale retellings its really the only way i can read fantasy as I struggle so much with many tropes. maybe its just the disney lover in me. i have been focusing more on indie books though, i just like the freedom authors have and the tone that I am looking for.
22:30 that story reminds me of the legend of Psyche and Cupid
I loved this so much!! You are so good at creating a through-line in these videos and summarising your thoughts at the end. It’s so satisfying!! The only thing that’s not satisfying is the blank 2013 space 😭 I need to know what was meant to be there!!! Please!!
I'm surprised Frank Beddor's Looking Glass Wars trilogy didn't make the Goodreads threshold! It's early 2000s, Alice in Wonderland, parallel worlds with characters crossing (like you mentioned wanting more of)
The book "East of the Sun & West of the moon" sounds very much like a Greek mythology retelling of the story between Eros and Psyche. (Suggestion: you could watch the video "Miscellaneous Myths: Eros and Psyche" by Overly Sarcastic Productions, it's only 6 min. and 28 sec.)
It really is basically a retelling. And Beauty and the Beast is in the same vein.
@@MistbornPrincess that is true.
They all exist within the same tale type of the ATU index. They are ATU 425A ("Cupid and Psyche") and 425C ("East of the Sun, West of the Moon"). Then the "Beauty and the Beast" that is popular today was directly inspired by both of these. It was written by Madame Le Prince de Beaumont and was directly inspired by an adult version of the same story by Madame Gabrielle de Villeneuve.
Honestly the amount of effort and work that went into this video… I respect it so much.
if you are interested, I highly recommend Disfigured by Amanda Leduc, which goes through the ways in which disability is shown in traditional fairy tales but is used to signpost villainy/punishment for misbehaviour. As a disabled person, I very much related to the memoir aspects of it, and the fresh perspective on how the signposting harms disabled people.
Once Upon A Time! Also loved the Wonderland spin off and the TV show Grimm!
I love the wonderland version i keep trying to tell my sister to watch it cyrus is a freaking cinnamon roll
I just finished „a court of thorns and roses“ an hour ago. This comes at a perfect time. So excited😍😍
I read “Rose Daughter” at a formative age and I still have such a special place in my heart for it.
I'm currently reading through the twisted tales of Disney stories and some are great some are bad but I'm enjoying it!
oh my god you unlocked a serious wave of memories with Goose Girl! I reread that book so many times as a young teen
Regarding Scheherazade, I cannot more highly recommend John Barth's _Chimera._ The first part of the book is about Scheherazade and her sister. It is largely an exploration of the nature os stories and storytelling. I won't say more for fear of spoiling it. Don't forget to put Rimsky-Korsakov on the stereo while reading.
The dried flowers hanging above the burning candle stressing me out 😅
(also I love how you said it was 2014 towards the end. So many people I know keep saying 2014 instead of 2024, it's impressive)
aaand as someone who isn't quite old enough to remember the "golden years" of YA fiction, it's endlessly fascinating to see the timelines you've made and what books influenced what trends (thinking of your YA fantasy timeline video).
Now it's stressing me out 😂
This was such a good overview of the trends and importance of fairytale retellings! Love your way of explaining such an intricate topic.
I watched it once for the context, and twice to note down all the new books I discovered!
22:08 isn't this more in the style of the myth of Eros and Psyche?
Awesome video!!! I LOVE retellings, not only of fairytales and myths, but also historical events (though it's more possible to disrespect the real people behind the events)
Exellent analysis! Thanks for sharing
Also: I'm half asleep and completely fascinated by how the blouse you're wearing under that corset style bodice straight up looks like a fishu. Very 18th-century vibes.
I love you a bit more every time you mention Once Upon A Time, this TV show has a grip on me 🤧💜
I looved the video, awesome job 😍🥰
YES ONCE UPON A TIME!!!
"Once upon a time "was one of a kind, trailblazer show for anyone who loved fairytales.
YOUR HAIR OMG IM IN LOVE YOU LOOK SO GOOD
Totally in love with your hair and outfit 🤎
I recommend Six Crimson Cranes by Elizabeth Lim. Thanks for the video. I could be happy reading nothing but fairy tale retellings and cozy fantasy for years.
Your channel is a beautiful side of youtube. Truly another level❤
Totally agree! historically knowledge has been shared through retellings of songs and stories (folklore) tribally. This can almost be seen as a global representation of the need to have a shared lore amongst humanity as these stories may be told from childhood, and then we may pass it on to friends and family down the line.
loving this YA eras tour videos by Leonie!! i always feel nostalgic watching these type of videos, brings me back to my golden age of reading (when university hasnt ruined my reading life yet lmao)
The lunar chronicles is one of my all time fav series to this day
It's perfect timing. I'm currently listening to the audiobook For The Wolf by Hannah Whitten, which seems to be a retelling of Red Riding Hood but in fact it's so much more like Beauty and the Beast
Loved this video! I took an oral exam about fairytale retellings in uni with a focus on Angela Carter. That was a fun exam to study for.
9:14 - I mean.... didn't the Ella Enchanted movie adaptation come out in the 2000s?? 🤔 😊
I feel like the wild swans (there are multiple very similar stories from Denmark and German, but this version is written by A.C. Andersen in 1838, Denmark)is a really underrated story about family love and a girl being the saviour. The main characters puts years of love and effort into trying to change her swan brothers back into humans, eventually finding out that in order to do so she needs to knit them shirts of poison Nessel, despite the pain that Labor brings her she keeps going, on the thought to have her brothers by her side again. In the end, she’s being accused of witchcraft, and while burning tosses the shirts in the air where her brothers are flying, saving them and turning them back into humans, who then are able to untie her and save her from the fire.
He also wrote the little mermaid, which, plot twist, is a fairytale retelling of his own life and the longin he felt for love, especially from his male coworker, but with it being 1800s that wasn’t possible, and writing about the loss and grief he felt when being rejected by him. In the original story the prince doesn’t fall for the mermaid, and loves her unconditionally but as nothing more than a little sister. He instead falls in love with and marries a princess, who he believed saved him from drowning. On land, her feet are bloody and hurt like walking on glass shards, which amazingly symbolises the pain of being around someone who does not feel the same for you, as you for them.
In the end the sea witch offers her a knife, to kill the prince and his bride, or to die herself instead. She chooses to let the man she loves live a happy life with the woman he loves, and perishes into sea foam.
Disney did not tell us the tragic and gay part of the story.
Ella Enchanted 🤩 My childhood memories of reading this book still warm my heart. ❤
i love your deep dives, they’re always so interesting and unique!!!
Watching your videos is like listening to a best friend talk about her hyperfixation and I love it
Hi Leo! When you mentioned the fairytale the Bear, it is maybe retelling from Eros and Psyche.
Other than that this is wondefull video. Have a nice day. 😊
For everyone who likes fairytale retellings i recommend Ever&After by Stella Tack. ALL the Grim Fairytales are in their, the characters are sooo good portrayed, it has a strong main character, there is a love story AND IT'S JUST EPIC.
I really love the vibes and music and your outfit that fits every video subject sm I really enjoy your videos and it makes my day to see new ones. also there's Cinderella is dead which is also a queer retelling it held a really good message for queers
I didn't read a lot when i was a teenager so in the 2010s so i actually love hearing about the different books I missed from your videos
I love fairytale retellings. They are just so comfortable. Its nice to read through it and be able to connect it to the fairytale and find whats the same and different
I am yet to finish this video but I am currently re reading the lunar chronicles. I read them originally when they came out and I'm amazed to say they still hold up like I am enjoying them just as much like 10 years later
Loved the video. Didn't know that some of those books were retelling buts also upon a frosted star by M.A. Kuzniar is a retelling of the Swan Lake which has been retold many times (by barbie aswell) and midnight Evenwood by same author I'd a retelling of a nutcracker whisky also is obvious retold multiple times aswell
As always, queen of aesthetic and digestible and interesting deep dive into a topic. I love the way people reformat the telling of a story to make it their own, to a degree it's also a form of "writing" back either to the original authors story/fairytale or the society that created them!
Your videos are so well researched and always so nice to watch! We can tell a lot of work goes into them, great job!
The on,y fairytale retelling I read was hunted and it actually also has Slavic folklore in it too with like the firebird
Hoi Leonie, super leuk onderwerp, heel veel nostalgie 😊 ik wil je een boek aanraden binnen het genre "retelling" en omdat je van wat duistere verhalen houdt:
The Child Thief geschreven door Brom
Het is een herschreven Peter Pan verhaal maar, zoals de titel doet vermoeden, steelt hij de kinderen ipv dat ze geheel vrijwillig met hem mee gaan. Vervolgens zet hij ze in zijn leger in met de hoop de fae wereld te kunnen redden. Peter is hier een heel duister karakter en ik vond het ontzettend tof om zo'n populair verhaal met een duistere twist te lezen!