Dan Carlin’s Hardcore History 63 - Supernova in the East 2

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
  • The Asia-Pacific War of 1937-1945 has deep roots. It also involves a Japanese society that's been called one of the most distinctive on Earth. If there were a Japanese version of Captain America, this would be his origin story.
    Itunes download link: itunes.apple.c...
    Buy past shows here: www.dancarlin....
    Follow Dan on Twitter: Ha...
    www.dancarlin....
    / dancarlin

Комментарии • 1,1 тыс.

  • @kaiserschnitzel89
    @kaiserschnitzel89 3 года назад +466

    What cracks me up about Dan is how he delivers exposition in a pleasing, reasonable and sonorous tone; but reads from documents - ANY documents on ANY subject from ANY source - like a boxing ring announcer from the 1930s.

    • @finished6267
      @finished6267 2 года назад +42

      Ya love that. It used to bug me but that's because I was wrong back then😅

    • @Zombielokii
      @Zombielokii 2 года назад +14

      Makes me smile every time now, lmao

    • @OleHickory69
      @OleHickory69 2 года назад +7

      Boy is that whimsical

    • @Mukawakadoodoo
      @Mukawakadoodoo Год назад +4

      @@OleHickory69 I love it. Brings the subject to life.

    • @bvyup2112
      @bvyup2112 Год назад +9

      annoying at work where all of a sudden he starts screaming but im used to it by now hahhaa

  • @jeffwalker6815
    @jeffwalker6815 5 лет назад +438

    Every episode of this show is a chilling reminder that most of us live like kings in a cushy little lives...

    • @nicksmith3431
      @nicksmith3431 5 лет назад +33

      "Silk slippers"

    • @kennycampbell1256
      @kennycampbell1256 4 года назад +2

      True that

    • @animaetmateria3578
      @animaetmateria3578 3 года назад +5

      *covid-19 slowly creeps into the room*
      "Surprise!!!! =)"

    • @markb8468
      @markb8468 2 года назад +14

      I like covid much more than I'd like having my village raped and tortured to death.

    • @brittneystreeter493
      @brittneystreeter493 2 года назад +43

      @@animaetmateria3578 not even a comparison…

  • @TwentyNineJP
    @TwentyNineJP 4 года назад +127

    In case anyone's wondering, the Japanese in the art says "Give me liberty or give me death" (large text on right and left) and "Supernova in the East" (small text in bottom right)

    • @nomdeguerre7265
      @nomdeguerre7265 3 года назад +5

      Thank you! Interesting...

    • @scottyelliott5709
      @scottyelliott5709 3 года назад +6

      That is cool, thank you

    • @aomukai
      @aomukai 2 года назад +17

      Actually it says "Freedom please. Otherwise death". Slightly lol.

    • @finished6267
      @finished6267 2 года назад

      Brilliant. Liberty or death.

    • @drastik_M.C.
      @drastik_M.C. 2 года назад

      He received death.

  • @thegreatbakchod32
    @thegreatbakchod32 5 лет назад +82

    I got the hardcore history compilation (the first 50 episodes) as a holiday present from my wife, best gift ever!

    • @iladelproductions8820
      @iladelproductions8820 5 лет назад +24

      Nice!! I torrented the first 40 or 50 episodes a while back when i was unemployed. i actually felt guilty about it so i donated the money through pay pal when i got back to work lol.

    • @alliearscott3978
      @alliearscott3978 5 лет назад +6

      thegreatbakchod what a awesome wife man ! Give her a nice smack on the ass for me, for being so great !

  • @bob13373
    @bob13373 5 лет назад +95

    Damn, that last quote from Churchill was incredible.

    • @DaveSCameron
      @DaveSCameron Год назад +2

      Check out the others he made against us, the working people of his own country and it will surely temper any ideas on him, he was simply the right man at the time..

    • @rickwrites2612
      @rickwrites2612 Год назад +6

      ​​​@@DaveSCameron He did have a way with speaking and words though, just really good at speeches. Some people just have that gift, and to have it and be in such a position as he, AND during the height of radio... Doesn't have to mean he was a good person tho.

    • @DaveSCameron
      @DaveSCameron Год назад

      @@rickwrites2612 Cheers for the reply and I agree 👍

  • @DorkKnight99
    @DorkKnight99 5 лет назад +522

    Fantastic episode.
    God, I'm sorry but there is nothing - NOTHING - more badass than the Pacific Fleet in ruins, Japan celebrating an unprecedented victory, the admirals slapping themselves on the back... and Yamamoto silently standing in dread knowing that they didn't get the Carriers and that somewhere out there the Enterprise, Lexington, & Saratoga were fully armed, fueled, and pissed as all hell.

    • @franktothemax
      @franktothemax 5 лет назад +47

      This scene paints so many intense emotions from the entire spectrum of feels. Dan did a brilliant job giving us the scope from both sides of the story, and Yamamoto done fucked up something fierce.

    • @Healermain15
      @Healermain15 5 лет назад +14

      @@franktothemax It was a long shot to begin with though, and they had pretty bad luck that the carriers just happened to leave.

    • @DorkKnight99
      @DorkKnight99 5 лет назад +27

      And they were on their own for over a year during the fleet build up. The best part of the story is the nearly entire year where it was simply "Enterprise vs Japan."

    • @Dave-mk9bw
      @Dave-mk9bw 5 лет назад +2

      What would have happened if the carriers were there? Could the US recover?

    • @fenderOCG
      @fenderOCG 5 лет назад +20

      @@Dave-mk9bw they built another 27 carriers by wars end so would have been fine. Port Moresby would have fallen, and therefore Australia threatened, but even Japan knew they couldn't invade Australia with their limited manpower and supplies

  • @EmperorTigerstar
    @EmperorTigerstar 5 лет назад +478

    I already heard this on my phone but man this was a good episode to listen to.

    • @amishshark3549
      @amishshark3549 5 лет назад +10

      Glad to see people of intellectual mindedness present at my purists of interest

    • @Voo504Doo
      @Voo504Doo 5 лет назад +3

      I remember reddit was nothing but a shadow of what 4chan once was lol seems the tables have turned now

    • @oflionsquarrel2277
      @oflionsquarrel2277 5 лет назад +4

      Whooooo. New Hardcore History. Your the man Dan Carlin. Thank you for your hard work on these. You basically write an audiobook every 6 months. That is amazing

    • @johnb.8687
      @johnb.8687 5 лет назад

      I didn't like this one so much. Didn't learn anything I didn't already know

    • @Dave-mk9bw
      @Dave-mk9bw 5 лет назад +3

      This was so good I'm going back to listen to Ghosts of the Ostfront series to see what is happening on the Eastern Front while we wait on Supernova 3.

  • @NotDave_x
    @NotDave_x 3 года назад +450

    "We could have the uigher version of the final solution happen over the next year and have the world sit around like what do we do" Actually prophetic.

    • @Guitarisforgrins
      @Guitarisforgrins 2 года назад +21

      Indeed

    • @glorioustigereye
      @glorioustigereye 2 года назад +3

      We could have finally started a conversation during the olympics if Russia didn't try to invade Ukraine and all our media being simps for China

    • @firingallcylinders2949
      @firingallcylinders2949 2 года назад +43

      @@glorioustigereye The Olympics were utterly bizarre. Everyone attending China acting like nothing was happening

    • @iainhittel
      @iainhittel 2 года назад +8

      organ harvesting…..

    • @chago4202000
      @chago4202000 2 года назад +28

      Even worse, people KNOW and don't care. Literally just don't care.

  • @Fatttkot
    @Fatttkot 3 года назад +47

    Interestingly enough, one of the first lessons you’re taught in the Australian army is what happened during the My Lai massacre, the objective of the lesson is to teach soldiers about the accountability that they bear to disobey orders if you consider them wrong/unethical

  • @_Mordion_
    @_Mordion_ 5 лет назад +168

    Dude you rock! Keep these coming man! I love the way you explain history. If only schools had history teachers like you... on second thought.. if only schools still taught history.

    • @Trollificusv2
      @Trollificusv2 3 года назад +2

      What do they need Dan for? They can make up history on their own, just fine.

    • @bolby0280
      @bolby0280 3 года назад +1

      @@Trollificusv2 you were here 5 hours ago? Damn weird timing

  • @DeborahRosen99
    @DeborahRosen99 2 года назад +13

    When I was stationed in Pearl Harbor fifteen years ago, I noticed that the majority of the tourists who came to visit the Arizona Memorial were Japanese. It always puzzled me, until I learned how little information about Japan's actions in World War 2 is available even now to the general Japanese public. Now, it's my thought that they know very and painfully well how it ended - they come to Pearl Harbor and walk the Memorial, watch the oil floating on the serene harbor waters above the rusted-out hull and read the names on the marble wall of the men whose bodies are just a few feet below them... because they are trying to understand how it began. Without that, it's hard to fully make sense of it all. Pearl Harbor was a national tragedy for the United States, but WWII in its entirety was a national tragedy for Japan, from its bloody beginning to its horrifying end. I thought about that one evening, a December 5th evening at sunset on the Memorial when I had volunteered to help the Park Service get the place ready for the December 7th observations, the Missouri a few yards away standing guard over her fallen sister ship and the cool breeze rustling the water against the Memorial and the wreck beneath just enough to sound like the indistinct whispers of ghosts, and I wondered... did all that really have to happen? The deaths of the men below, who are about half of the recognized death tally from that day, and the long bloody trail of foxholes and shipwrecks from Bataan to Iwo Jima, the deaths of two cities in nuclear flame, the generation of Japanese men lost and American men twisted by hatred... could it have been avoided? And that is they key question to all of this, if one chooses not to take the declensionist view of "inevitability" and accept human choice, however self-limited and limiting, as an active factor. Where were the inflection points that could have changed this? What might have happened instead if the tragedy of Pearl Harbor had been averted? And, in the way that history has of eventually singing the same refrain in a higher octave, would we recognize similar inflection points if and when they come again?

    • @mrques2x115
      @mrques2x115 2 года назад +1

      The fact that your comment hasn't been recognised, by the supposed history lovers of RUclips, should provide a solemn answer to your question.

    • @joehubbard4405
      @joehubbard4405 Год назад

      I don't think we will see them. Refer to Ukraine. How do you drop a nuclear bomb on a population? You have to work up to it. 🤦😳

    • @jason.larsenthedanishgreek1226
      @jason.larsenthedanishgreek1226 Месяц назад

      Beautiful

    • @tommeliusbthaprofit6157
      @tommeliusbthaprofit6157 3 дня назад

      I imagine it's a popular way to investigate their history because it's an example of real military fighting/'honorable' fighting. A smaller wart to go see than a place where they bayoneted babies/experimented on humans/spread plagues to cities.
      I'm guessing they wouldn't be taken very kindly to taking pictures of some site in Korea or the Philippines. Probably wouldn't be given a visa to go to China lol

  • @professorchong2762
    @professorchong2762 5 лет назад +29

    Highest replay-value series on the planet.

  • @Elmarby
    @Elmarby 5 лет назад +66

    For those interested in the Pearl Harbor attack, a guy with the channel name Montemayor has an excellent video giving a detailed and informative play by play of the attack. Best account of Pearl Harbor that I have seen and a good companion piece to Dan Carlin's.

    • @stanstanislav1471
      @stanstanislav1471 5 лет назад +5

      Thank you "Elmarby". You are CORRECT! Montemayor is awesome and he goes very well with Dan Carlin!!!!

    • @spencerpace8313
      @spencerpace8313 5 лет назад +6

      Elmarby His Midway video is really good as well

    • @billmamer4863
      @billmamer4863 3 года назад +1

      8

    • @j.d.5626
      @j.d.5626 2 года назад +1

      Indeed, excellent channel

    • @noahswanigan9350
      @noahswanigan9350 2 года назад

      Check out World War Two channels 10 episode compilation (I believe it's 10?) Pearl Harbor Hour by Hour, with digital recreations from I believe War Thunder of how the attack took place, it covers the attack, on both sides, the news, it's effect on the public, everything .. Probably the most in depth look at Pearl Harbor I've ever seen, and they've got their D Day episode coming up next year, that covers the 24 hours around the ENTIRE WORLD has to how the D Day invasion was having effects. Hosted by a guy named Indy Neidell, dudes a savant. Every Saturday morning they post a video, covering the war week by week, in real time, as it happened 75 years ago. It's truly amazing.

  • @newschoolerbrent
    @newschoolerbrent 5 лет назад +105

    Mr. Carlin,
    Your podcastst are some if dopest decibel dope ive ever smoke. They are drugs for your ears. Im addicted to your audio coke. More is good.
    Signed, Everyone

  • @franktothemax
    @franktothemax 5 лет назад +12

    Dan Carlin is a national treasure. I can’t properly express just how excited I get when I see that you’ve posted a new segment, and this second part was glorious to listen to. Can’t wait for the third!

  • @lasthairbender1667
    @lasthairbender1667 5 лет назад +347

    *Clicks on the video faster than the 1941 offensives*

    • @Deridus
      @Deridus 5 лет назад +7

      You must be insane, and why are your messages in code?

    • @stormbreak13
      @stormbreak13 5 лет назад

      if Churchill could so clearly, and instantly recognize that Pearl Harbor meant "the war was decided" and that it guaranteed America siding with them, against the Japanese, why did the Japanese think - even for a moment - that small "victory" or no, Pearl Harbor would do anything other than make things much worse for them? Especially if it was considered acceptable to judge Japan as 1/20th the military potential of America?

    • @nicholascecil6733
      @nicholascecil6733 5 лет назад

      @@stormbreak13 they were foolish enough to think they could scare us away from entering the war by destroying the majority of our Pacific naval capability. Shortsighted Japanese underestimated the American fighting spirit!

    • @Dave-mk9bw
      @Dave-mk9bw 5 лет назад +4

      That insane ending from Dan Carlin after reading Churchill's speech.
      End Quote. *Ominous boom*

    • @MartinRodriguez-cu6vl
      @MartinRodriguez-cu6vl 4 года назад

      @@nicholascecil6733 unfortunately for them, our aircraft carriers weren't at dock during the attack

  • @brolaireofastora5293
    @brolaireofastora5293 5 лет назад +26

    Great timing, got a 3.5 hr journey ahead of me tomorrow!

    • @kingnothingx7890
      @kingnothingx7890 5 лет назад +3

      Have fun being traumatized

    • @xczechr
      @xczechr 5 лет назад +4

      Did you sit in the car and finish listening for 30 minutes after arrival?

    • @Dave-mk9bw
      @Dave-mk9bw 5 лет назад

      @@xczechr Yeah did you?

    • @joshuacarr6517
      @joshuacarr6517 5 лет назад

      @@xczechr Yeah did you?

  • @mattdavis7876
    @mattdavis7876 Год назад +8

    Dan never whitewashes brutality, but neither does he deny the humanity of the offenders either. And that's a tough thing to do.

  • @morecoffee998
    @morecoffee998 5 лет назад +23

    Mind blown within 10 minutes of a 4 hour podcast, ah yes, this is the Dan Carlin I know and love.

  • @stephen9869
    @stephen9869 5 лет назад +9

    *Thank you Mr. Carlin!!* Looking forward to listening to this podcast in my new job as a trucker, please keep 'em coming!

    • @dfiala9890
      @dfiala9890 5 лет назад

      This is probably not the best time to get into trucking.

    • @yomomz3921
      @yomomz3921 5 лет назад +2

      Yeah, I just got off the road myself. I'd say, save for a rainy day. Whatever you think you'd need if your job ever went * poof *, double it.
      Also, Dan's a stellar road companion. Check out the back-catalogue at DanCarlin.com if you haven't already. 👍

  • @superposition3717
    @superposition3717 5 лет назад +88

    happy to see an episode, sad to know another is not coming for like 6 months

    • @RandomPlaceHolderName
      @RandomPlaceHolderName 5 лет назад +8

      Yeah, the last 90mins of the episode really flew by and then this sound hit me 3:59:50 ... filled me with dread.

    • @northspack
      @northspack 5 лет назад +4

      Dude that's what makes them awesome, there work the the wait

    • @method0123
      @method0123 5 лет назад +2

      Here we sit... waiting... wanting....

    • @JG-id5vi
      @JG-id5vi 5 лет назад +2

      So you guys think theres a part 3?

    • @method0123
      @method0123 5 лет назад +1

      @@JG-id5vi yes, absolutely.

  • @nomdeguerre7265
    @nomdeguerre7265 3 года назад +1

    All-in-all another superb Dan Carlin Hardcore History production. Agree or disagree with any detail, I'm sending this guy a few Yen. His products are wonderful literature and very passable popular history with credible scholarship and editorial honesty. Bravo Mr. Carlin. Another outstanding program!

  • @arrinmixon5190
    @arrinmixon5190 5 лет назад +11

    Fantastic again Mr. Carlin, I really could visualise the stampede in Shanghai and was incredibly touched for the Chinese lose of life. It really does help ones understanding of the way there society is organised today, in regard to its strict drug laws and military parades.
    Thank you

  • @jbfrodsham
    @jbfrodsham 4 месяца назад +1

    Love Dan. His take on history is wonderful. His voice and delivery is perfection.

  • @RaidsEpicly
    @RaidsEpicly 5 лет назад +48

    Was hyped to listen to this and then realized I remembered NOTHING from last episode...guess I have to listen to part 1 again first

    • @dragatus
      @dragatus 5 лет назад +3

      There are worse fates in life.

    • @northspack
      @northspack 5 лет назад

      Dude me too 😭

    • @BubblewrapHighway
      @BubblewrapHighway 4 года назад

      Just did! I has forgotten so much about the early modern history of Japan. The First Sino-Japanese War and the Russo-Japanese War are particularly crystallized in my mind now.

  • @jayf3675
    @jayf3675 3 года назад +9

    Wow Churchill at the end gave me goosebumps

  • @ThaBukkakeCatapult
    @ThaBukkakeCatapult 4 года назад +8

    This dude is such a treasure! All the love from Finland!

  • @kauster
    @kauster 5 лет назад +27

    "As for the japanese? They would be ground to powder" wow, what an ending.

  • @volusiasorange
    @volusiasorange 5 лет назад +27

    Shanghai resident, super interesting, know all the places you are talking about

    • @rachelspanties5400
      @rachelspanties5400 3 года назад +1

      I am jealous of the perspective you have by being there but hate this was an incident having happened. Stay Zen

    • @Zwijger
      @Zwijger 3 года назад

      @@rachelspanties5400 Literally every place in the world has cool history in some way, whatever place you live in too, he has a better image of this story, you on another one, I don't think there's need for jealousy.

  • @rixd8226
    @rixd8226 5 лет назад +123

    Just found out today that Dan Carlin’s Hardcore history may have been BANNED FROM iPhones that are used by Chinese users. My wife who is Chinese can no longer access this podcast on her iPhone but I can. We don’t even live in China. If you have Chinese friends, be sure they do not use QQ email for Apple App Store just Incase

    • @Hadrexus
      @Hadrexus 4 года назад +33

      Sometimes I think I can't be more disgusted by the CCP but they always manage to find a way

    • @TheQuallsing
      @TheQuallsing 4 года назад +23

      #fuckchina

    • @LAK_770
      @LAK_770 4 года назад +27

      Kind of ironic, considering he's critical of the IJA (realistic) about Nanking on this podcast, and almost universally sympathetic about China. Entirely different government though. But no doubt multiple points here depart from CCP orthodoxy, and any fact-loaded Western source is sure to be unpopular with those fuckwits.

    • @lbfourtwenty4163
      @lbfourtwenty4163 4 года назад +7

      @@LAK_770 They would dislike people hearing how completely dominated they were by japan maybe?

    • @CDSutherland
      @CDSutherland 4 года назад +4

      Communists

  • @blahblahghost
    @blahblahghost 5 лет назад +26

    Holy shit, that Churchill quote at the end...

  • @dcred123
    @dcred123 5 лет назад +79

    What a Dan Carlin way to start the episode about Japan, a little bit of Babylonian sacking for context
    "I'd *like* to make a 3 hour episode..." -Dan Carlin on a 4 hour video

    • @SivakAurak
      @SivakAurak 5 лет назад +8

      One of these days he's going to start a show without bringing up Babylon or the Mongols.
      One of these days...

    • @Healermain15
      @Healermain15 5 лет назад +2

      @@SivakAurak And then he promptly brings up the WW1 trench wars and the WW2 Russian front.

    • @escott3829
      @escott3829 5 лет назад

      Yeah.. History STARTS The Day before the day of which you are Briefing.

  • @PhoenixT70
    @PhoenixT70 2 года назад +17

    3:58:11 is quite possibly the single best excerpt of this entire series.

    • @nfsm07
      @nfsm07 Год назад +1

      What a fucking quote. He could really string some words together that old codger....

  • @AndyDSmithuk
    @AndyDSmithuk 4 года назад +2

    How can one man talking for 4 hours be so engaging!? Obviously he's got some great source materials but his delivery just sets him apart from the rest.

  • @leonleydershnayder6337
    @leonleydershnayder6337 3 года назад +5

    Completely unplanned but I'm grateful to have finished this episode today, just two days prior to the date which will live in infamy. What a tremendous body of work!

  • @SteveLaneGalway
    @SteveLaneGalway 5 лет назад +356

    Decembuh 7th, nineteen fauty one, a date which will live. in infamy.

    • @henkjanwolvega
      @henkjanwolvega 5 лет назад +52

      Steve Lane if we dig deep in our history and our doctrine, and remember we are not descended from fearful men.

    • @lastword8783
      @lastword8783 5 лет назад +33

      @@henkjanwolvega People have got to know whether or not their president is a crook. Well, I'm not a crook.

    • @wutang9641
      @wutang9641 5 лет назад +28

      Last Word I take pride in the words "Ich bin ein Berliner!"

    • @bobojangles22
      @bobojangles22 5 лет назад +21

      @@wutang9641 mr gorbetrov tear down that wall!!

    • @SteveLaneGalway
      @SteveLaneGalway 5 лет назад +1

      :-D :-)

  • @robgoose8126
    @robgoose8126 5 лет назад +10

    Woohoo! Ive listened to Blueprint twice since Armistice Day and finished Kings of Kings today. I love your content Dan, keep up the good work!

  • @rickwrites2612
    @rickwrites2612 Год назад +1

    This is so impressive. I am not someone who suffers audiobooks easily, and when I do read nonfiction, it tends more towards the natural or social sciences. If you had told me I'd listen, enrapt, to 6 episodes of 3 hrs each, specifically about the Pacific theater in WWII, I would never believe I'd have the attention span or continuing interest. Very commendable acievement.

  • @notyourenemy7633
    @notyourenemy7633 5 лет назад +6

    What a great history of Japan's involvement leading up to and through WW2. Good to get the back story in how, why, when etc. Wow, must listen to part 1!

  • @joshh8395
    @joshh8395 5 лет назад +44

    Thank you Dan! I've been waiting for this and I'm just beginning a 12 hour shift. Perfect timing 👌

    • @JohnSmith-mx8wp
      @JohnSmith-mx8wp 5 лет назад +1

      @Right-Wing Listen to it two more times!

  • @rainbowspeqtrum6989
    @rainbowspeqtrum6989 3 года назад +3

    Not gonna lie, as Dan was describing the destruction of Pearl Harbor with such conviction, I got legit goosebumps. Absolutely fantastic episode, and chilling reminder of something that happened not so long ago in the near distant past.

  • @CraftyChicken91
    @CraftyChicken91 Год назад +1

    Churchill's quote at the end gets my red white and blue, rock fucking hard.

  • @alecro2112
    @alecro2112 4 года назад +239

    That beginning when he perfectly summarizes what’s happening in China with their Muslim minorities. He even name drops China, and boy was he right.

    • @ranchero1707
      @ranchero1707 4 года назад +19

      China's been doing this exact thing for millenias, even before the communists

    • @Rickblaine1942
      @Rickblaine1942 4 года назад +25

      Funny how you are concerned about muslim populations in China but like most Americans you don't give 2 shits about the Christians and Jews in North Africa and Middle East. Christianity and Judaism are Middle Eastern religions yet until 1948 there was not a Jewish country in Middle East and to this day there aren't any Christian majority countries. What about those 2 groups that have suffered so much at the hands of the muslims? What about the Indians that were slaughtered by tens of millions by the muslims?

    • @alecro2112
      @alecro2112 4 года назад +48

      Rudens Sinjari I don’t like any form of human suffering, I don’t like that Jewish and Christian religious minorities have been persecuted in the Middle East, and I don’t like how millions of Indians have died to Islam either. I’m not defending Islam or any other religion, I just don’t like minorities being persecuted and people killed over religion, or human suffering in general. The difference is that what you’ve mentioned are past events, that suffering cannot be undone, unless you have time travel. But the suffering in China is happening now, something can be done about it. It would be very hard to get China to change their ways, but it’s not as impossible as changing the past.

    • @Kunfucious577
      @Kunfucious577 4 года назад +11

      @@Rickblaine1942 yeah yeah. Same with feminists who ignore womans rights in the middle east or people who seem to ignore slavery today in libya. Kind of sick of the preachingbfrom people who dont do anything about it themselves.

    • @danielbylund8937
      @danielbylund8937 4 года назад +4

      Well, trouble always seem to arise wherever individuals following that faith congregate in larger numbers.

  • @UltiEd
    @UltiEd 5 лет назад +7

    I haven't listened to the episode yet, I'm waiting for that perfect time. Dan Carlin time is Christmas time

  • @prestonmoore2209
    @prestonmoore2209 5 лет назад +24

    I'm so excited, my commute is awesome now!! Thanks Dan.

  • @williama.3752
    @williama.3752 5 лет назад +3

    Amazing podcast. Podcast as a word fails to describe what this was.
    If you could revisit the pacific theater after war broke out between the US and Japan in a part 3 of this serie, that would be amazing. I learned quite a lot of things about the European theater, but so little about the Pacific side of WW2, that would be beyond great.

  • @samuelr.6046
    @samuelr.6046 5 лет назад +49

    Can we get one on the Arab and the Ottoman Empire?

    • @kevanbrose1356
      @kevanbrose1356 5 лет назад +2

      @DebbyAbqNM not the same at all

    • @kevanbrose1356
      @kevanbrose1356 5 лет назад

      @DebbyAbqNM it was definitely a masterpiece that's for sure

    • @robdela3632
      @robdela3632 5 лет назад +1

      kings of kings is about persian/greek wars. not arab but a bit closer

    • @rangerdoc1029
      @rangerdoc1029 4 года назад

      I was just thinking this today

    • @nomdeguerre7265
      @nomdeguerre7265 3 года назад

      Which 'Arabs'? The Umayyads? The Abbasids? The Fatimids? The Mughals? I think Islamic Spain and the Cordoba Caliphate might be a candidate for 'Fall of Civilizations' though.... The Islamic conquest of the Levant, Asia Minor, West Asia, and all of northern Africa and as far as the border regions of France, would make an awesome Dan Carlin podcast.

  • @truthbusteryeah5166
    @truthbusteryeah5166 Год назад +2

    The best in depth honest analysis that can be found, thank you Dan

  • @TrevorKeenAnimation
    @TrevorKeenAnimation 5 лет назад +5

    My father spent his childhood in Tiensin (now Tianjin) in the 1930s and was there when the Japanese occupied the city. He has many stories, probably the best of which was on the day after the Pearl Harbour attack. To make a long story short, two Japanese soldiers burst into my grandparents' house with machine guns but didn't shoot anyone. They just boasted about the Pearl Harbour attack, got drunk from my grandfather's liquor cabinet, stole a few things (including a set of brass finger bowls, my father remembers) and left. My grandparents reported them to the officers in charge and some time later, there came a knock at the door. It was.a Japanese officer who returned all the stolen stuff and invited my grandparents to come and watch the two soldiers being flogged. We have other stories, worse than that.
    My father eventually made it to Canada, and for his whole life has never bought a Japanese car or TV or stereo or anything else.

  • @KnifeCursed
    @KnifeCursed 5 лет назад +1

    You have by far the single best history show extant. Keep on doing what you do Dan.

  • @JoshuaKevinPerry
    @JoshuaKevinPerry 5 лет назад +24

    Anyone know where the Nazis documents on US industrial capacity can be viewed? I understand the US produced HALF the war materials, but I'd love to compare estimates with results.

    • @Healermain15
      @Healermain15 5 лет назад +1

      Half the materials from both sides combined no less. No idea where those documents can be found though.

    • @gatosyratones
      @gatosyratones 4 года назад +3

      If you’re in the US maybe the library of Congress otherwise it’s in Europe stashed in a museum.

  • @astroboy6515
    @astroboy6515 Год назад +1

    16 minutes in.
    Ive never heard of the My Lai massacre before, i think.
    Thank you for helping me be more aware.

  • @jp-ty1vd
    @jp-ty1vd 3 года назад +4

    My Lai vs Nanking; not even close. Comparing a rouge company to a rouge army is apples to oranges, imo. I am not excusing the US troops for a second, but 550 people isn't even in the same galaxy as 250,000 (+/-). The Us soldiers left after 4(?) hours, the Japanese soldiers didn't leave for 3 MONTHS!
    It would be like comparing one person in a fit of rage killing his neighbor and a serial killer murdering 500 people over a lifetime.

  • @nobody2021
    @nobody2021 3 года назад +2

    I have never felt much of an attachment to pearl harbor until listening to this. It puts it into such a relatable perspective, as an american. Dan carlin is a master story teller.

  • @mikevieira8583
    @mikevieira8583 10 месяцев назад +3

    It's eerie how well some of the discussion here fits Gaza today. 2 million people have no water. Will the world powers intervene? Will Israel decide to end their atrocities? Will either happen before genocide occurs?

  • @Peterhistoryman69
    @Peterhistoryman69 Год назад

    It's keep on so absolutly intens like you can read a history book, but Dan you take history on a total new level and please don 't stop

  • @TECHNOBOG
    @TECHNOBOG 2 года назад +3

    Listening to the beginning bit of this podcast (minute 8ish) after the Russian invasion and you were completely right with the whole "ummm I don't know maybe sanctions or something" being the only response for the most part

  • @cowboyhank456
    @cowboyhank456 5 лет назад +2

    Brilliant episode! I watched the first one on a windsurfing road trip through Europe last summer along with many others of yours, and it was such an experience to talk about these topics with good company while witnessing the changing landscapes from dawn till dusk.

  • @kacijames6714
    @kacijames6714 5 лет назад +9

    Thank you! You're doing amazing work!

  • @tamalesftw
    @tamalesftw 4 месяца назад +1

    I love how Dan reads quotes

  • @clintwhitney16
    @clintwhitney16 5 лет назад +12

    I wish these podcast where louder.

  • @mIXsaz
    @mIXsaz 5 лет назад

    So just woke up, baked some eggs, sat down and casually, for the first time ever i guess, i hit Home button on youtube....and this pops up.
    My god what a great start of the day!!! ;)

  • @sdbullion
    @sdbullion 5 лет назад +25

    Thanks Dan for covering this often under taught subject matter. The few month long 1937 Imperial Japanese invasion of the then capital city Nanjing, China is to date still the largest documented GOLD ROBBERY in history (in that operation alone the Japanese took 6,600 tonnes or like 80% of the Official Gold Reserves the USA claims to have today). The Japanese did not have a central bank fiat currency financing mechanism like the German Nazi party did (Swiss mainly). Check out the 'Gold Warriors' book to see more sordid details. Was there a tacit agreement post 2 atomic bombs to not tell nor teach this Imperial Japanese story to westerners... save some face for this Japanese disgrace perhaps?

    • @kensenkensen7297
      @kensenkensen7297 5 лет назад +3

      Not Robbery.....
      Spoils of war......

    • @Healermain15
      @Healermain15 5 лет назад +4

      @@kensenkensen7297 "Heavily armed robbery" then.

    • @danielgyllenbreider
      @danielgyllenbreider 5 лет назад +4

      The first 3 months of US occupation of Okinawa, 10 000 women were raped. Go to the entire japan and what american soldiers did there and number of course grow incredibly. War creates opportunities for the psychopaths among us on both sides. This is why we must always be against war and do anything in order to avoid them.

    • @artsybugitch9261
      @artsybugitch9261 4 года назад

      @@danielgyllenbreider *anything?*

  • @RybecFromCanada
    @RybecFromCanada 5 лет назад +1

    There's something very comfy about playing Kaiserreich late night as the Japanese while listening Supernova part 1 and 2.

  • @canamman111
    @canamman111 5 лет назад +9

    Listened to part 1 to the point of memorization.

    • @Mixima101
      @Mixima101 3 года назад +1

      I really liked how he went in-depth about Japan's history and culture development to put WW2 into context.

  • @ianv2733
    @ianv2733 5 лет назад +1

    Carlin is the best of his breed, there is no question. Have enjoyed every single episode.

  • @anngo4140
    @anngo4140 5 лет назад +3

    You know, I'm gonna stay up to 3 am to listen to this.

  • @AQuietNight
    @AQuietNight 3 года назад +2

    John Rabe fell on very hard times after the war ended. When citizens of Nanking found
    out about it, they raised money and sent food to help him along.
    The movie John Rabe is worth viewing.

  • @terrygrossmann2295
    @terrygrossmann2295 5 лет назад +11

    Really thought provoking. What the Nazis did was bad. However Japan was every bit as bad. However Germany gets whipped for decades and Japan gets off relatively light. Many Japanese military in charge of POW camps who flat out murdered POW’s never even faced war crime courts. Plus we’re taught the Emperor was a God. His rule was not up for debate. Yet then we’re taught the Japanese military ran off and did what they wanted. So Which is it? In another RUclips historian talkies how a Japanese medical officer performed “medical test” on POW’s especially in germ war-fair yet he was never brought forth for war crimes because the U.S. made a deal that the medical officer turned over all his notes and observations in exchange for basically a wrist slap.
    There are many accounts where U.S. veterans have said it was very hard not to kill villagers in Vietnam then again in Iraq and Afghanistan due to no one warning them of an ambush or a trail/road being heavily booby trapped.

  • @rangerdoc1029
    @rangerdoc1029 4 года назад

    Had a 5 hour drive for work today & was delighted to see a HC History episode I hadn't listened to yet. Today was a good day.

  • @Ivan-td7kb
    @Ivan-td7kb 4 года назад +5

    The people who wanted Japan to acknowledge its crimes is not just China, but most importantly South Korea, a democracy and an ally of the United States, as well as from secondhand accounts of Western missionaries and embassies. Make no mistake, the crimes committed by Japan during WW2 is as much a top down crime and not just caused by the troop's bloodlust. The attitude of the Imperial Army to treat enemy troops and civilians as subhumans has been drilled into the soldier's mindset as a way to fuel their aggression and fanaticism.

    • @nomdeguerre7265
      @nomdeguerre7265 3 года назад +3

      Not to mention the Burmese, the people of Guam, New Guinea, the Philippines, and many other place 'liberated' by the Japanese military in WW2.

  • @brendanvb2597
    @brendanvb2597 5 лет назад

    I woke up this morning and thought, "I should see what Dan is up to." Maybe there'd be another short episode -- what's that? ! Part II of Supernova. Lucky me! Thanks Dan (and crew)!!

  • @Dsmith551
    @Dsmith551 5 лет назад +13

    Hell yeah I'm pumped Dan!

  • @JD-xo2wz
    @JD-xo2wz 5 лет назад

    Thank you Dan! Never stop doing these programs, they are immeasurably valuable and truly enriching. I can't wait for part 3, whether it takes six months or ten years.

  • @cqduck667
    @cqduck667 5 лет назад +14

    gosh darn American hero, Dan Carlin

  • @MichaelLukash
    @MichaelLukash 4 месяца назад

    One of the issues Chamberlain that is largely forgotten: The British Military told him upfront: They couldn't fight Hitler in their current state. They needed time to prep troops around the world and upgrade their military. Hitler hated the Munich agreement, because it stopped his progress. Nevil Chamberlain knew that he was sacrificing his place in history and in politics. Churchilll damn well knew this: That's why Chamberlain remained in the government.

  • @tarintino9911
    @tarintino9911 5 лет назад +3

    Listened to the podcast now for the RUclips!

  • @renegaderats
    @renegaderats 5 лет назад

    whenever dan uploads i make sure to hit like before i watch the vid so i dont forget after... he has never once made me regret that decision... thank you dan

  • @BattleBoots
    @BattleBoots 5 лет назад +3

    Man I've been so excited waiting for part two. Thanks Dan!

  • @feelingthislife
    @feelingthislife 2 месяца назад

    Some of the best content on the internet and it's free. I support Dan through his website, but this is FREE. Unreal

  • @victorivas4897
    @victorivas4897 5 лет назад +4

    excellent stuff, Dan. As always.
    Cheers from Romania!

  • @RedsKinDK23
    @RedsKinDK23 5 лет назад

    This just made my whole next 6 months. How funny that I had just relistened to Ep. 1 a week ago, all the while anticipating when the next release would be. How epic that it would be a week later. Thanks Dan. Thanks Ben.

  • @kscnc5994
    @kscnc5994 4 года назад +3

    Anyone else want Dan to do Vietnam from french indochina to their defeat of the khmer rouge?

  • @patrickscott3491
    @patrickscott3491 5 лет назад +1

    That last quote by Churchill...what a thing to hear.

  • @unktheunk1428
    @unktheunk1428 5 лет назад +13

    There hasn't been a hard core history scince LAST YEAR

  • @dakotahmartin2584
    @dakotahmartin2584 4 года назад

    Dan Carlin is an absolute legend. Thank you so much for your epic and gripping tales. You are a fantastic orator and historian. I love your work and you deserve all the praise in the world. Your videos are a work of art! I've listened to every video on RUclips. Some of them 2 or 3 times. I bought Wrath of the Khans and plan of getting every video that you have to purchase that you have produced. You are a pro and an absolute legend. Thank you for the work you do!!

  • @BringTheRain
    @BringTheRain 5 лет назад +3

    Episode 3 cannot come soon enough!

  • @elleneylers987
    @elleneylers987 2 года назад +1

    I listen to your podcast, feeling like it's a page turner...so good....thank you.

  • @anurbanartist1428
    @anurbanartist1428 2 года назад +3

    8:40 That aged well.

  • @astroboy6515
    @astroboy6515 Год назад

    Now you have me learning about Cremona.
    Learning about how war and history provide examples of psychology/sociology.
    Very telling examples.

  • @andrewbleackley1832
    @andrewbleackley1832 5 лет назад +14

    Arrrggghhh. To late at night. Well 30 minutes....

    • @bvyup2112
      @bvyup2112 5 лет назад +2

      Exactly how I feel, I was going to go to bed... maybe not.

    • @MrBeac0035
      @MrBeac0035 5 лет назад +6

      3.5 hours later......ooooh only 30 min left

  • @SuperAzeone
    @SuperAzeone 5 лет назад

    The best podcast out there.. If you guys haven’t heard his WW1 series yet, you are out for a treatment..

  • @PiusOnes
    @PiusOnes 5 лет назад +155

    I clicked faster than *witty history reference about speed*

    • @whoaitstiger
      @whoaitstiger 5 лет назад +15

      _(Witty_ _reply)_

    • @JB-op4ty
      @JB-op4ty 5 лет назад

      Lulz

    • @frasersnell6304
      @frasersnell6304 5 лет назад +1

      I clicked faster than your mom

    • @mebrlive
      @mebrlive 5 лет назад +1

      Im cooking pork chops

    • @bitgamer509
      @bitgamer509 5 лет назад

      Faster than Bill Clinton kicking Monica out of the Oval Office once he 'finished'?

  • @Alexei2539
    @Alexei2539 4 года назад +2

    16:00 There are similarities in the situations with the textbooks, but the big difference is that many Japanese don't know about what happened (though some do) while in the U.S., many more people here know about the things in our past and there tends to be more introspection that even goes down to outright self-loathing.

  • @justmyopinion2333
    @justmyopinion2333 5 лет назад +7

    I love when dan reads ancient b.c. emperors propaganda in the voice dan feels an thinks they sound aloud.

  • @stredent
    @stredent 5 лет назад +2

    Thank you Dan. Your work never fails to impress me.

  • @MrPanDacious
    @MrPanDacious 5 лет назад +5

    Praise carlin

  • @TheFlameoftheWest
    @TheFlameoftheWest 5 лет назад +2

    I've been waiting along time for this but I'm certain it will be worth it.
    Thank you Carlin for the work you do

  • @underpowerjet
    @underpowerjet 5 лет назад +3

    YES! FINALLY! Thank you Dan Carlin!

  • @E-Chap
    @E-Chap 3 года назад

    This episode was like a four hour war action movie. Loved it, Dan is a goddamn legend.