Iraq Uncovered: Investigating Shia Militias’ Alleged Abuse of Sunni Civilians (full doc) | FRONTLINE
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 май 2024
- As ISIS was pushed out of areas of Iraq, FRONTLINE correspondent Ramita Navai made a dangerous and revealing journey to investigate allegations of abuse of Sunni Muslim civilians by powerful Shia militias. (Aired 2017)
This journalism is made possible by viewers like you. Support your local PBS station here: www.pbs.org/donate.
The Shia militias were a crucial part of Iraq’s fight against ISIS and were supposed to answer to the country’s prime minister. But “Iraq Uncovered” investigated how some of the groups were accused of kidnapping, torturing and even killing Sunni civilian men and boys, whom the militias often saw as ISIS suspects.
Navai traveled to areas of the country where few journalists went, talking to Sunnis who said their relatives were abducted and abused at the hands of the militias. She found a makeshift militia prison crammed with men the militia admitted had been held there for months without any charges. Navai found that people in refugee camps were “as scared of the militias as they are of ISIS,” and she spoke to leading Sunni and Shia politicians as well as militia members themselves.
Explore additional reporting related to "Iraq Uncovered" on our website:
www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/do...
“Iraq Uncovered” was a Quicksilver Media production for WGBH/FRONTLINE in association with Channel 4. The correspondent was Ramita Navai. The director was Patrick Wells. The producers were Mais Al-Bayaa, Ramita Navai and Patrick Wells. The senior producer was Dan Edge. The executive producer for Quicksilver Media was Eamonn Matthews. The executive producer for FRONTLINE was Raney Aronson-Rath.
#Documentary #Iraq #ShiaMilitias
Subscribe on RUclips: bit.ly/1BycsJW
Instagram: / frontlinepbs
Twitter: / frontlinepbs
Facebook: / frontline
FRONTLINE is produced at GBH in Boston and is broadcast nationwide on PBS. Funding for FRONTLINE is provided through the support of PBS viewers and by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. Additional funding is provided by the Abrams Foundation; Park Foundation; the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation; and the FRONTLINE Journalism Fund with major support from Jon and Jo Ann Hagler on behalf of the Jon L. Hagler Foundation, and additional support from Koo and Patricia Yuen.
CHAPTERS:
Prologue - 00:00
The Shia Militias Fighting ISIS - 0:58
Disappearances of Sunni Men and Boys From Iraqi Towns - 10:29
Shia Militias Accused of Abusing Sunni Civilians - 22:29
The Secret Prisons Run by Shia Militias - 33:31
Preventing the Next War in Iraq - 43:53
Credits - 51:59
![Minecraft but Players Can Upgrade [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QRRgLJs4ZPk/mqdefault.jpg)
That poor mum. Imagine finding 5 of your sons dead, murdered like that? How she keeps going is beyond me.
the faith in Allah is too strong
@@seifeddinefardous8813allah the filthy sex god
and imagine you find your son slaughtered like an animal and posted on media!!
@@mohammedheideryeah they don’t know that Sunnah who start all that 😂
My point was the mother’s resilience just continuing life. No one should have to endure this. I don’t care what side you’re on. You’d think given humanity’s history exterminating one another for mostly stupid reasons, we’d have learned by now.
Brave woman if not of her reporting we would not have known of these type of stories from the outside world it's really a heartbreaking story,these are the casualties of war ,why can't people live in peace in this beautiful world of ours,hats off to this woman she's really 2 brave may God guard her in her life
Behind the American oils companies Boss send her Iraq financial details findings there 😂😂
Media channel owner oils company 😂😂don't rely on her 😂😂don't believe media, what show us
men without real belief in creator the almighty and judgement day after death , is just a big suitcase of ambitions and wishes no matter he deserves or not, good or bad. just self centralised, greedy, sexist and stoners
@@-rv4hj LIAR
Why doesn't PBS publish recent data about Afghanistan, how Sunni Taliban kill and mistreat Shias in Afghanistan (cp. my channel), and in Bahrain and Saudi-Arabia, U.S. allies, where Shias are oppressed. And in Palestine, how Sunnis get killed by U.S. weapons? Because it's all U.S. propaganda.
I am from Diyala Al muqdadiya but now we live in Germany.
Firstly i thank you for this doku and may god portect you where ever you are, you shows the people in out side of Iraq how is bad the situation there.
Because the majority could not illustrate savagery there and thay thought we exaggerate when we talk about the brutality of the regime in Diyala/Al Muqdadya.
i was kidnaped by militias when i was at beginning of 15th year.
They kidnaped my 2 uncels after that and killed them even though we payed 250 000 $ and 2 kilo gold.
When i was 14 i saw with my eyes how militias of badr killed two persons near the police, and the police did not do any thing.
They let peopel free from the prison and killed them in the out side of the prison because they could not killed them in the prison so that no one say that they ( The regime ) kill prisoners in prison and act against human rights.
May God have mercy on my uncles where ever they are.
اخ العزیز انا اعرف کیف یقتلون اهل سنه فی بلاد رافدین کل خط ایزانیه الصفویه
What you saying is Iranian acts , these people you talk about belong to Iran, Iraqi civil people not hurt one , did you saw what happened in October 2019 ? when all the people protest against Iran and their dogs who rules in Iraq
@@sarahtaher9188you are 💯 right
Yea sure buddy….
@@HadiMohseni-ch8ql hhhh you are from Afganistan and you protct them because they are your Group
thanks you Frontline for amazing work and information n journalism and always getting the truth out there
This woman’s voice is on point keeps you glued to the phone 😅😅
The wonders of religion!
I wish we could live in a peaceful community where religion doesn't exist. like post revolution france, mao ruled china or car-tell run south/central america :(
Literally happened because America waged war on Islamic lands the fault is to the western world and the Shias who aren’t muslim to begin with
This is the wonder of Islam. They are brutal to themselves and to each other
This has nothing to do with religion, this is a terrorist group created by UN and supported with Fully american guns killing sunnies in name of sunnah, and another terrorist group from Iran which kills sunnah.
According to the Encyclopedia of Wars, out of all 1,763 known/recorded historical conflicts, 121, or 6.87%, had religion as their primary cause.
More and more brave journalist like is the need of time. Thankyou for the couragious reporting of the voiceless people.
One of best investigative journalist. She provided thorough insight the situation in Iraq
US state-run propaganda. How can it be journalism? Shias treated Sunnis badly (that's why they publish it in their news) and Sunnis treated Shia badly (that's why Saddam was bombed by USA). But what is not covered, is that both Shia and Sunni, were killed by USA.
Why doesn't PBS publish recent data about Afghanistan, how Sunni Taliban kill and mistreat Shias in Afghanistan (cp. my channel), and in Bahrain, where Shias are oppressed. And in Palestine, how Sunnis get killed by U.S. weapons? Because it's all U.S. propaganda.
Bro, you have no idea.... zionism is all about divide and conquer
As a Muslim for you sunni ,, shias are my brothers, this is only propaganda to promote hate between us by saying sunni & shaia are different... I love shias they are 1000% right
@@Kashur_lofi
أشكرك على هذا الكلام الجميل
@@Kashur_lofi You are guys all brothers but I what I don't get why a lot of Muslims countries are fighting among themselves? Take Iraq,Iran,Houti,Saudi Arabia.........Isn't there onle one Allah and aren't all Muslims pray to one ?But there are division took place among Muslims? Why some of you accept Muhammad and other his relatives?
Thank you PBS Frontline. Love your documentarys. I could watch anything you produce
Loving U.S. propaganda, ehh?
@@AAT786I’m not looking for a fight I just genuinely want to know how this is propaganda
@@AAT786 how is this propaganda?
@@veronicalapik8039 Sharing one side of the story with no evidences but just claims of a few people!
This stupid journalist could compare and investigate how people lived before and after US invasion in 2003.
Really sad . We pray for peace
Great reporting and documentary
As a Shia myself, we do not believe in hurting any innocent people. It doesn't matter what race or religion you identify with.
That you don't believe in all that doesn't mean that many others that will likely claim to be as Shia as you clearly don't, so it looks like it's either not a "I'm Shia ERGO I do/don't believe in X", or one side (either yours, not believing X, or those others', believing X) doesn't take the Shia instructions to their true meaning.
How do I know which side is the true Shia, yours or the others'?
I 'thought' that was the core belief of ALL Muslims?
@@Eli_Muwahhid what the hell does that mean? "Sunnis don't lie"? Like NEVER? ALL of them? Hundreds of millions of people you say don't ever lie about anything? I'm calling big time BS on that one, my friend.
Dude this is a propoganda piece by a liberal irani woman who is most likely sponsored by western media group.
They simply cant accept the fact that iranian backed groups working with iraqi army defeated isis (a organization usa created and funded)
Also keep in mind that why a documentry from 2017 is post now when tensions are quite high in palestine and shia and sunni countries are both campaigning together for palestinians
@@Eli_Muwahhid you saying something is haram like that magically makes it impossible not to be that way is hilarious. Also quite obviously wrong. Or has no sunni ever done something technically haram? Mind you, you're going to step on a very paradoxical forest if you're loyal enough to your brain and answer truthfully.
I think this piece is missing the absolute brutality of ISIS (Sunni) that was perpetrated on the Shia. Shia mosques were attacked at prayer, Shia markets bombed, Shia murdered left and right. This became a blood feud. Lots of innocent people were swept up on both sides. This is why strong rule of law and professional law enforcement is vital to any society.
Yes but, two evils do not make a good.
Isis does not represent Islam nor Shia or Sunni.
Absolutely. Shia were seriously maimed the insurgency against Shia-US regime after fall of Sunni Saddam regime. It was quite heinous period for them, they had to rise up against!
@@henryjackson370ISIS was Islamic fundamentalist insurgent organization that held extremist version of Sunni Islam.
Isis killed more sunnis than anyone else.
I’m originally from Almuqdadia , everything in this documentary 100% True and there’s a lot of worse things but she can’t cover it .thank you very for your efforts to prove some of the truth .
Religions are basically just large scale violent scams.
Please provide English voiceover like most channels do now, to improve accessibility for visually impaired ❤
Yes, that is a wonderful point. As I age, my eyesight is failing. As an artist, this is absolutely devastating me. And I cannot afford treatment. So, things such as voice - overs would be incredibly helpful to the millions like us.
@@Albert-Arthur-Wison225
Try closed captions on TV?
@@paddyholly2184 You still need to see closed captions, are you dumb?
I prefer it because often I prefer to listen but not watch, so I can perform tasks at the same time.
@@ptgsdr589 she’s talking about accessibility for blind people, not for people too lazy to read subtitles. Get off your horse.
Here are few points to audiance only:
A. Whonis funding PBS ?
B. Why now this video is coming out?
C. Shia and sunni in iran and iraq specifically, were living together for thousands, how come we see this ?
D. Why PBS doesnt delve into all those who have been captive by shia milities ? Can they confirm they all were normal civilians ?
E. Least but not last, instead of seeding bad deed into two brother society, why dont you make a report on who created this chaos and who are your donners ?
These comments. Sigh. Argue the content. By all means. Go point by point. I’ll wait. Actually - I want to hear it.
100%. but don't worry, there will be a flood of "EARNEST VOICE" in this comment section to make sure all the herd gets to the correct conclusions.
@henryjackson370 I was thinking the same way you're thinking. Channels like these are very suspicious. Why didn't they investigate the crimes of ISIS which are far worse vis-a-vis the Shia community by bombing multiple times their mosques, markets etc? It is really a lie when she said that the Shia militias were committing these atrocities when the west was busy fighting ISIS. In actual fact we have the Shia militias to thank for defeating ISIS who looked set to expand their mindless terror to other parts of the world including to Europe. Don't forget that they started an armed rebellion in Marawi in the Philippines which lasted for about 3 weeks about 10 years ago. All the while, the US army showed their meaningless "fights" against ISIS by showing some meaningless bombings of ISIS "hideous" etc that would not secure a victory against ISIS when actually it was these Shia militias that were fighting ISIS on the ground and sacrificing thousands of fighters in the process (and the Hezbollah was taking on ISIS and defeated them in Syria at the same time).
ISIS also had always worked for the US, UK and Israeli interest, and hence the rebellion against President Bashar Al Asad (an Israeli foe), many bombings in Iran (a US and Israeli foe) and the recent massacre they perpetrated at Crocus hall in Russia (a stretegic foe of the US) while at the same time never firing a single bullet at the US, UK or Israel.
Lastly, that look of concern (for the supposedly oppressed Sunnis) on the face of the presenter of the documentary looks so fake and actually there are no enmity between Sunnis and Shias except when there's a portion of them who got influenced by the propaganda of imperial powers such as the US to divide them, make them fight each other and try to rule over them to steal more of their nations' wealth.
Frontline is now better than Vice at its peak keep this kind of content coming props to the journalists and crew on the ground.
It's more zionist controlled, true!!
vice is a joke
Great documentary that reveals a lot about the unseen truth
Thanks
Lol you don't know sh*****it
14:53 One on the torture victims said ( I swear of God these people came to eradicate us not to liberate us) . The subtitle mistranslated on exchanging (eradicate with insult) . والله ذوله جايين يمسحونا ما جايين يحررونا.
A great report and a very brave reporter.
after Saddam Iraq is just became hell
I am a Sunni Iraqi from the city of Anbar and I was one of the detainees in the city in the period of ISIS control there, and then we were liberated by the Iraqi army and the popular crowd or as they are called Shiite militias. ISIS elements were trying to get out with families and many of them managed to escape because of the lack of families, but there are other elements who were arrested after confession and the security forces investigated them with them and I assure you that everyone who was arrested is an ISIS operative or a supporter of them.
كذاب يالتقيه هذي حركاتكم🤣😂🤣🤣🤣
@@dh6623thanks for exposing him.
We know how US appointed 💯 % shias in military, government jobs, politicians. No place for the sunnies.
Saddam has atleast maintained some balance with all sects, all religions.
You are in the side of militias but you write this comment to mislead what we hear and see for along time
City of Anbar?
There's no city called Anbar.
There is however a province named Anbar, which got it's name from a town that was deserted centuries ago.
I was born in Romadi, in the Anbar province.
@@dh6623جهاد النكاح، عرضك منباع للدواعش
Please do a Shia-Sunni history documentary. Their origins, differences, and the cause of their conflict.
another great agenda from PBS news .....where were they before ...why rit now when the whole world is seeing the atrocities of Israel against palestinians....
bothe sunni nd shia are in peace with each other
@@mohammadyasir7182 noo dont lie
Shia is a « sect » that came later and is closer ideologically to Christianity than Islam (worship of saints, belief in the trinity). Officially 90% of Muslims are Sunnis.
Shias were never really relevant in Islamic history, sadly they’re known for this bloodshed against Sunnis, and disrespecting the prophet Muhammad wives and friends
If you ever wondered why people in Iran are not religious at all it’s because they follow this cult. Shiites means in arabic « those who deviated (from the group) »
😂😂😂
What’s that mother’s fault to witness her 5 son’s heads blown off…. After seeing this I feel stupid about complaining about things in my life sometimes😔…. Thank you to the reporter who’s got the bravery of a 100 men 🙏
I commend this journalist for her professionalism and bravery. When people are going to learn that violence always begets violence, death and destruction!
Really,Sad,We,Pray, For, Peace
This woman has a lot of courage
What courage؟
Behind the front is different than to be in the front.
Because she has bodyguards on her everywhere.
Not as much as the men actually fighting but yeah
She's paid.
As a Sunni Muslim from Malaysia, I will try my hardest to prevent Shia from spreading in Malaysia. We'll have laws to prevent the spreading of other sects other than Sunni, in shaa Allah.
May Allah avoid us from Shia
they shouldn't even be considered as a sect but a separate religion
sunni = 1S1S. You guys have slaughtered us Shia Muslims for centuries
Exactly @@meezolaraveldev4611
So much hatred among yourselves !!! No wonder Islam is called the inventor of Hatred.
Are you with ISIS
Brave woman; Excellent reporting !!! It's a tragic truth -" Men with murder in their hearts will always find a way to justify their bloodlust. Clearly" When the mind is offended; the heart is revealed " no matter where you go on the Earth...!!! May peace come to this people !!!!
Saddam hussein should still be in power if this is what has become of Iraq, at least it was a country and not torn apart.I 🤔🤔
@@gw6496
Open your eyes 👀
@@gw6496Under Saddam all of this was done by the state.
@@untubus And now the police force hijacked, the government too weak, the militia is the most powerful, and the innocent still suffer. I think it seems worse. This, like the man in the video mentioned, will eventually spill over into the entire globe.
@@JessJoanne The polarisation definitely spills over. Instead of standing up against bad ideas, people stand up for hating other people 😢
May Allah have mercy on our fellow Sunni brothers and sisters....stay strong 💪 your on the right path..ure sunni brother from kenya 🇰🇪
Muhammad caused all this, He raised blood thirsty mongers, that fought each other and even non Muslims all in the name of following Muhammed
From Muhammed his wife Aisha to Ali, to Ummar all blood thirsty people
All involved in rape, lying, stealing nothing that has to do with the true God.
اللہ تعالٰی آپ کو حضرت محمد صل اللہ علیہ والہ اصحاب وسلم کے صدقے اعلی مقام عطا فرمائے۔آمین
Sunni kufar why are u talking????
you just kicked in the ass like you do it before with Shia, Christians, Yezidis and a lot more people who faced a horrible time under your beloved IS terror brothers and Sadam Hussain. For the whole people who are really innocent and never drives a wedge to the ethnicities and other religions I pray.
This lady is a proper and brave reporter
What time to put this video
These killings has to stop!!!!!! Shia and Sunni should come together as one to go after enemies.
It will never happen because one sect loves to kill and discriminate everyone such as Shias, Christians, Hindus etc.
Which enemies?
@@AMightyFortress Jews
This is absolutely fearless journalism by fearless journalist I salute 🫡
@Eli_Muwahhidsir idol worship is great sir please worship idols of hindu gods and goddesses
Some reality, and some prapoganda.. infact shia military save Iraq from ISIS..Etc
You are Big lair the civilian are afraid of Militia not than ISIS
Stop lying
The Shia group has helped the Sunnis They have not killed Sunnis.
The Shia group has eliminated ISIS
It is now our turn This is the sick world we are living in, And it never stops, No forgiveness
Chaos , violence , family shattered , so sad to see the world goes like this .
هذا جزء قليل من الجرائم هناك اشياء كثيرة لم يصل إليها الاعلام
😂😂😂
"The Fragrance of Compassion
I stand on the street, my heart sorrowful
The great disaster is looming overhead at the end times
Where are people heading in the hustle and bustle
The life-saving Dafa [Great Law has opened Heaven’s gate wide
I pass out this flyer of truth
Helping people at the command of the Creator
Most people are Gods incarnate, becoming humans
Doctrines of atheism and evolution are a deluding potion
Modern notions and conduct bring harm to oneself
This truth can save people, keeping them safe and healthy
He is compassion and fragrance emanating amid chaos
September 27, 2020"
Master Li Hongzhi (Hong Yin VI, from Falun Dafa teachings)
Great documentary!
I don't know what to make of this since Sunnis and Wahhabi Muslims have been fighting and killing Shiite Muslims ever since there's been that separation and in Iraq, the Sunni minority under Saddam Hussein was brutal to the Shiite population.
I mean really it's Sunni and Wahhabi that historically have done the most killing, and are the people who create and carry out global terrorism.
Shiites have tended to stay away from global terrorism but certainly have militant groups IN that region, not around the world.
So, same same? The Sunni leader before the US invaded Iraq and deposed of him used chemical weapons to kill thousands of people, both Shiite Iranians and Kurds in northern Iraq.
There's no love there in Iraq between these groups and if Turkey weren't so hateful towards Kurds it would probably be better to break up Iraq into 3 countries. It's not like there' a historical contest for that country. It was artificial lines made by the UK.
Ugh, you are simplifying the story a lot.
The biggest problem is the violent foreign policy of the USA, overthrowing governments, which although dictatorships they brought regional stability, peace and a basis for future development.
In Europe, Spain and Portugal had dictatorships similar to those of Saddam Hussein (Franco en Salazar), but they were not overthrown violently and traumatically by foreign powers, in this way they were able to slowly but decisively transition to a future of peace, prosperity and freedom for their citizens. Countries need time and space to develop...
Now Europe, which has the Middle East as its backyard, is suffering the consequences of this disaster, receiving thousands of Iraqi, Syrian and Afghan refugees (soon also Palestinians and maybe even Iranians and Yemenis due to the usa and it's wars in the región).....
Most of the killings of Sunnis have been done by Shia and forcefully converted them to shia practices.the killings by abbasids and eliminating majority Sunnis from iran by force are clear examples. Even today in iran Sunnis are on the paraphries of the country, where they escaped for safety against persecution of shia. Go to the north, south, east or west of the country you will find Sunnis, while they are haunted, persecuted and not allowed to pray and freely preach, othewise the Iranian will know the facts of their beliefs. Shias do not stay away from terrorism rather follow terrorism agaist Sunnis with the support of America and the Christian world otherwise they will not allow shia iran for one day on the world map. It is because shia dont belive in freedom fighting or resistance to crusaders and therefore stay away from supporting freedom fighting of muslims in Palestine , kashmir, Afghanistan or iraq. For shia mullahs Sunnis are non muslims and they even preach against the marriage with Sunnis unless converted to their faith. Shia mullah also doesn't allow their followers any teachings from Sunnis to keep them ignorant of the true teachings of the holy prophet pbuh. the ordinary shia is however a sincere follower of the faith but misguided by their mullah. The mullah called waez use occasions like Aushora to keep his followers in the same line and pollute the innocent minds with his ideology. He portrays sunnis as useruppers of khilafat and responsible for the Karbala tragedy to keep them to their beliefs . Before the US invasion of Iraq, on false pretext, Iraq was not ruled by sunni alone rather majority government was shias and also contained Christians. It was a secular stat under Baas Socialist Party, whose founder was a Christian, named Michael Aflack. The same was and is in Syria. These were to contain any Muslim uprising against the colonials and many more such leaderships were installed to crush any possible uprising. Others were controlled using the tool of religion.
For your information wahabism did not exist historically till the dismemberment of the Ottoman empire when they were introduced officially to devide Muslims. They are equated by enemies to Sunnis as a propaganda tool because the latter participated in Afghan freedom fighting against former USSR.
@@polunga7989 LOL, why are you always trying to draw parallels with the west. Muslims have dictators because if they don't have dictators they would elect the Muslim brotherhood, the reason overthrowing sadaam was so bad was because if you acted crazy and support isis he would kill your entire family. Same with Assad, we saw how as soon assad started to lose territory all the chiristans and the yezidis were killed.
This does not justify the horrific acts of violence by criminal militias.
Heart breaking 😮😢
Grt work, hats off to ur courage not an easy thing to document before these brutal so called liberators
As an Iraqi 🇮🇶 I can tell this is old stuff and there is a lot of wrong information
I’m from Iraq Baghdad thanks a lot frontline ❤
Ideologies define a nation...you shall know them by their fruits.
Go and fast your knowledges
Really… By their fruits you shall know them. (Mathew 7:16-20).
Will Iraq be the same again. Very heart breaking documentary indeed 😢😢😢
Many of those people standed with isis and supported them there is videos where the celebrated isis comin what do you expect them to do؟
Are you sure that the men in the video are only civilians.
Fo years we have been killed by sunni regime but when they needed help we helped them and we standed with them.
The war ended and we live peacefully we do not hate each other.
These videos are only to seperate us to make people fight against each other.
Leave us please go and mind your bussiness(i forgot your business is standing on the middle east you cant let them be in peace there should be conflict there should be fighting).
Imagine they're fighting against isis but they are more crucial than isis 😢
yes, they are the cause that made mad group like sis appears,,
Pretty sure crucial isnt what you mean
lol@@dont5363
@@johanliebert3943 ISIS was an American creation and a form of radical Sunni Islam. ISIS was a result of mainly the soviet invasion of Afghanistan and has nothing to do with Shia groups. Secterianism was widely spread in Iraq because of Saddam not because of the Shias
Great work. Great Documentary 👍
I have a brother he has down syndrome and autism he doesn't speak he needs help eating and cleaning him self basically he dont understand anything . I love him he is my baby brother he is almost 30 now. We have to know they are gifts from Allah and we know they will be in Jannah with no questions. And makes me feel good by loving him taking care of him that I will go to Jannah with him because of him and being the brothers we will always be InshaAllah.
Thank you madam for bringing this reality to us.
Heartbreaking to watch 💔
Tell that to Saddam Hussein and his sunni army who used chemical weapons on shia muslims in iraq and iran
@@tibodeclercq2131 Shia not muslim..
@@Zane17198 they say the shahada every day, so they are muslim.
@@tibodeclercq2131 Shia not muslim and they do not say the word shahada lol
@@Zane17198 I meant "I bear witness there is no god but Allah and that Mohammed is his prophet". They believe this statement.
Don't antagonize people.
Keep up the propaganda. We all know who wants the Sunnis and Shias to remain divided. It's pretty obvious by now.
They've been divided long before the 'West' was even involved.
Sister, you are Blessed with Divine courage✨I'm in awe... Salvation to all of these in Yeshua's Name!!!
Shias are persecuted by Sunnis in other places - Pakistan, Afghanistan....
As an American, my heart goes out to the innocent people and victims in Iraq. God bless you all, I go in peace. Peace and blessings to you my friends, God willing, the suffering ends. 🙏
@@art6358It wasn't the sole mistake of US. Sadam Hussain shouldn't have invaded other nations. He made a grave mistake!
@@commencaterwhat other nations? Saddam made Iraq and you Americans destroyed it. You did that in Libya and now you think Putin is a fool.
In Iraq? How about the entire world where religion becomes fanatical.
@@johndoh5182bro every of your comments is targeted against Muslims and Sunnis 😂 you’re the fanatical one and guys with your ideology have caused so many deaths
You do realize it was Sunni civilians who helped massacre the Yazidis, dont you?
What about the other side, why do nit call some shia victims, and ask them also!?
What about the 7000 college students who got killed by the help of Sunni people in this area, when people stand watching them dieing and no one care ,also no one helped them to escape
@@sarahtaher9188 Yes you are wright.
Why was this uploaded three days ago when it’s three years old or more? Thank you for the documentary though. I agree with the commenter below. Still grateful for it
Because these Shia'a militias will look for those innocent sunnis and revenge from them for sharing the truth. Telling you this as an Iraqi man living in Iraq.
It’s from 2017 ! They reposted again because the armed forces who defeated Isis are standing against the Zionist in Palestine so they want the Zionist to Benefit from Sunni-Shia divide ..
its obvious propaganda. What better timing than after the Israel Palestine conflict, in order to make Iran and their proxy militias look bad. This whole documentary is one-sided. Americans dont give a shit about Sunnis or anyone in the middle east for that matter.
Because, silly.
All eyes are on the Middle East.
Israel is loosing it's war against Suni group Hamas and Hamas only supporter is Iran and Hezbollah and they are Shia Muslims ..
Frontline trying to propagandize the unity of Shia Suni
🎉😊As an American I say, 🗣️”America & journalists Stay out of Iraq 🇮🇶 & Mind Own Business!!!”
If you really were American and not some abdool pretending to be one, you'd know "Mind Own Business!!!" is grammatically incorrect.
I didn't egree with you......other way we wouldn't know what is going on around the world
The American GOV who created or helped to create alqaeda and isis later now talk about fighters who defeats terrorists in Iraq
Shia (militia )paramilitary
Helped all civilians to return back home
Yo. Momma.
Yeah arming the Kurds/SDF and conquering ISIS capital Raqqa while proving air support for those shiite militias was really pro ISIS policy 🙄
You spelled Saudi Arabia wrong.
@@cindypomerleau950
Yes these are only obey the great Satan
So evil’s these Governments filled the world with bloods and tears and terrors and sadness
Am sure something will change will never be the same for evils
How did America creat Al Qaeda?
Let's be reasonable. These militias are focused on saving civilians from ISIS. That's heroic. In the meantime they try to pick out the ISIS fighters from these big groups. They don't murder indiscriminately. They try to find the fighters and bring them to court. That's extremely careful and civil, considering they have seen gruesome actions from ISIS. Maybe there have been made mistakes, but that's not their goal. They are extremely civil considering the harm that ISIS did.
Very wrong and misleading statement. They do murder/torture/imprison/rape sunnis indiscriminately, just for being sunnies. That includes sunnnis men, women and children. This is a FACT since 2003.
my friend i live in Baghdad, on October 2019 there was a peaceful protest in many cities in Iraq against corruption in the government and those same militias have killed almost 500 and injured more than 21000 of the protesters.
look for it if you want
@@bakr.b.h5276 please give me a source so I can look it up
@@givemelibertyorgivemedeath001 He is lying. There is no evidence that the militias killed them and all accusations are directed at the government
To the main commenter
You don't know what's going on
Do you know that syria was majority sunni, rule by alawite which basically pegan worship group (bashar assad) which allied with iran
That allow him to genocide his own people and ethnic cleansing
1.5 million syrian die and 19 million made refugees cross the world
To spread untruth against shia millitia
Shia and Sunni always got along in Iraq till America came along
Religion of peace ☺
Like Christians crusader and liberal muh democracy.
😉
Any religion that includes humans is fallible. A murderer is a murderer is a murderer. It’s only the justification that changes.
@Ahmedahmed-tu8zn the crusaders were dealing with barbarians like what we're seeing they saved humanity. That happened over 1000 years ago, now just check peaceful community and their chaos today, it is a death cult.
wow what a serious thinker you are. you are genius. they should give you a big raise at Wendys.
Translation: Muslims gonna Muslim.
I been searching on Islam from last 6 years what I found out until now it's fake religion and spreading cancer to world
You said translation but it's already in English genius
thanks to the problems brought in by the west. none of these problems under saddam
Cave people would feel like they were way more advanced if they came back now.
Especially in the Middle East.
But in the US, as well. 😢
May Allah swt aid these people and free them from this oppression
Why are you re-airing on it now in here, hoping to cause enmity between Shia and Sunni in this war of Isreal.
As a Pakistan I totally condemned this brutalilty which going on with sunnis brother yes of course shias never want to progress sunnis we Pakistan will with you our beloved sunnis
😂😂 Don't let them put differences between us , Actually here in Iraq we live together Sunni and Shiaa but the west want to ruin Muslims countries by this way
@@Eli_Muwahhid proud to be shia rather than nasbi sunni 🎉
@@sarahtaher9188تنكري قتل ميليشاتكم للسنه في العراق😏😏😏😏
نتكلم عن مجرميكم مو الشيعه المدنيين
@@dh6623
تقدر تنكر قتل داعش وأخواتها للشيعة 😉
@@ali_haidar_313 تأكد مابيوصلوا لإجرام الميليشيات 🤷🤷🤷يعني إجرام داعش نقطه في بحر مقابل إجرام الميلشيات
The timing of reuploading this is suspicious
Superb presentation
My heart broken....couldn't control my tears
....I am from india
Where this world wants to go?
To Armageddon of course. Why ?
This is terrible. I praise the innocent civilians for their resilience and hope they live to see a day when this war is over and they are again safe and sound.
Also, this reporter and her team are incredibly brave.
The war ended in 2017 and the families returned to their homes and are now safe
Lol,you watch tv ?this is old as fukc
@@07iq7IT IS JANUARY 2024 THE IS NOT OVER.
American funded channel
Shias have bore a lot more than this in Saddam regime. But they will not show bcz it all is US and west policy to create the chasm deep and even deeper amongst shia and sunnis to control middle east
My heart pains for the children n widows. God protect you
This wasaired in 2017. It was true then.... and i am relatively sure it still holds true today.
Thanks
Thanks for your bravery sister
I am a fighter in the Iraqi army, and I tell you, unfortunately, this report is a lie. The names of the militias mentioned in the report are Iraqi civilians who took up arms and fought ISIS alongside their brothers in the Iraqi army and made great sacrifices in order to defend Iraq and its land. Did you know that what they call militias include thousands of fighters from various components, not just Shiites, and Christians, Yazidis, and Sunnis took up arms with the Shiites and fought ISIS and its organizations, and the detainees in Saqlawiya and the rest of the regions were working with ISIS. It is unfortunate that the Western media has become accustomed to distorting the image of my country, Iraq. Please tell the truth..
@@sajjad__alking6884It doesn’t surprise me that the news medias lie to western countries. Look at what’s happening in the Middle East now. There’s so many lies being told to the people. Most people don’t have a clue what is truly going on. I’m very sorry that politicians destroyed your country. The powers that be do whatever they want and then they try to Justify It!
@@sajjad__alking6884 Iraqi army is founded by USA and full of shias how is your comment even relevant 😂
I'm from Iraq, and these Iranian backed militias also killed the Shia people who protested Iranian interference in Iraq. So it's not Sunnis vs. Shias, it's actually Iraqis vs. Iran puppets.
And its Muslims vs Christians, and do not forget about what you did to the Yazidis.
هل انت شيعي؟
@@kholowedalmold3394 ملحد
@@Stewie-Griffin hahaha 😂😂
You are Mulhid that's why you hate both Shia's and Sunni's especially Shia because Iran is backing up them ...
@@pervaiziqbal9828 I literally defended secular Muslims who defend Iraq against isis in my response to @bunjijumper5345 .As an Iraqi I want to see peace between Sunnis and Shias but the problem you keep slaughtering each other like sheep 😔 so sad.
I dont see any difference Between shua and sunni. They are and will be my brothers and sisters. And same goes to other humans in this world. My faith and belief is for me alone.
Can't help but notice how big and Beautiful this journalist eyes are!!
I didn't see that. I don't understand how her eyes are beautiful (no offense). I might be gay to not understand that.
@@-rate6326
Lmao 🤣
@@-rate6326 yes, you're gay.
Beautiful and courageous documentary.
This woman will be remembered theoughout history as great tool of information for the world
America made shia army of Iraq and gave Iraq to shia government... It's what America and 40 NATO countries did
Iraqis sunni are leaving in a far more worse situation than that of Palestinians under occupation.
😳
You’re delusional
you are true shameless comparing gene....by State with non state actors
No we’re not!
u r a merkava
Now they trying to instigate between Sunni and Shias. This divide and conquer stuff is getting old😂
No need to instigate, Sunni and Shia kill each other all the time.
who they?
@@lennyshalmer7309 they is who they are.
The militia are working with the government too. And the government isn’t only Shia. So if some one is suspected being from ISIS chances they are
Sis is US creation
Anchor is so good
When was it filmed
2017
This is a tragedy.
Propaganda Broadcasts 😂
It nice how you call it propaganda! While innocent people starve and die daily. Y’all need serious mental evaluation 🤦🏽♀️
Nice timing when sunni and shia are closer since decades against Isreal and US we get this. Probably accident for channel that never made any materials about the suffering of Palestinians under the occupation
nicely pointed out...Their wicked face has been unveiled now ....
Why this lady isnot in Gaza.....
This is war of popaganda....
Totally agree , how much they paid for this woman to spread their propaganda
Its a iranian woman as well she want to destroy the picture of iraq
The suffering of Palestinians, the barbarism of ISIS , All of that can not justify the inhuman satanic crimes of Chi3A Militias ..
وَلَا تَحْسَبَنَّ اللَّهَ غَافِلًا عَمَّا يَعْمَلُ الظَّالِمُونَ ۚ إِنَّمَا يُؤَخِّرُهُمْ لِيَوْمٍ تَشْخَصُ فِيهِ الْأَبْصَارُ
This id what Iraq looks like after saddam , free , secure, safe and prosperous?
😂😂😂
Saddam hide his own atrocities
People especially in the USA make snape judgements about the media, but they are way too cowardly to see the truth like what is covered in news watches like this one. Thank you for your love for truth. It's not a task for anyone faint at heart. May creator keep you safe.
I am a fighter in the Iraqi army, and I tell you, unfortunately, this report is a lie. The names of the militias mentioned in the report are Iraqi civilians who took up arms and fought ISIS alongside their brothers in the Iraqi army and made great sacrifices in order to defend Iraq and its land. Did you know that what they call militias include thousands of fighters from various components, not just Shiites, and Christians, Yazidis, and Sunnis took up arms with the Shiites and fought ISIS and its organizations, and the detainees in Saqlawiya and the rest of the regions were working with ISIS. It is unfortunate that the Western media has become accustomed to distorting the image of my country, Iraq. Please tell the truth..
@@sajjad__alking6884So you think the evidence given by these families is what, a lie? The mother who filmed her 5 sons dead w/ bullets in their heads? She found their bodies. It’s not a bad thing to say there’s both brave men & monsters in these militias. This is the problem with being investigator, judge and executioner. No one should be killed without an actual trial & evidence of guilt.
@@sajjad__alking6884 What is gained by this story?
@@t.l.1610Hahahahaha, you speak as if you are Iraqi and know Iraq.. I am Iraqi and I know my people. These people you are talking about were fighting with ISIS against the Iraqi army, and it is the duty of army men and volunteers. Arresting them and investigating them until the innocent of the guilty emerges... You are talking about human rights. You must hold America and its coalition accountable, which destroyed Iraq and took lives. More than 500 thousand Iraqi children. America and 34 European countries fought Iraq, destroyed it, and returned it to the Stone Age after it had been the greatest country in the Middle East.
@@andrearenee7845I swear the Western media is laughing at you
I’m Sunni and I’m telling you both Shia and Sunni are brothers and sisters, your plan will never work out
Brothers and sister that killed each other, even killed the descendant of Muhammed.
Can yall please remember this was filmed like years ago? It’s actually not as close as to what it is today
How about the abuse of Shias in Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, Indonesia, Malaysia, Syria, Pakistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Nigeria and more?🤔
I also find it funny how ISIS are in Sunni controlled cities in Iraq. In this documentary alone there were 3 cities ISIS positioned in who were all Sunni dominated cities.
I wonder why ISIS members are able to make themselves at home in those cities 🤔 almost as if Sunni Muslims perhaps welcome them to stay…
singapore ? it's not even a muslim country 😂😂😂 and no there is no abuse to shias saudi arabia and other muslim countries
@@AhmedAAbas-xv3um you’re straight up lying. Shias in Saudi reported that they are getting treated like second class citizens.
what is your prove ?@@forgetm8961
@@AhmedAAbas-xv3um Lies! Shias in Sunni majority countries have always been oppressed. In Pakistan, Shias have been victims of target killings and terrorist attacks since the beginning. In Afghanistan and Nigeria both Shias have been killed in large numbers. It has got better in Afghanistan now but before it used to be horrible
The shia defeated isis
It wasn't just them who fought. Without global coalition airforce i don't think they would have been so successful
In the name of religion? Oh my God have mercy.
When was this film made
2017
Beautiful journalist, good work.