Truth, War and Consequences (full documentary) | FRONTLINE
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 авг 2021
- Did America rush into a war in Iraq for which it was unprepared? In this 2003 documentary, FRONTLINE examines why the U.S. went to war in Iraq, what went wrong in the planning for the postwar occupation, and what was at stake for both the U.S. and for Iraqis.
This journalism is made possible by viewers like you. Support your local PBS station here: www.pbs.org/donate.
In "Truth, War and Consequences," FRONTLINE producer and correspondent Martin Smith probes the fierce internal debate between the Pentagon and the State Department over the intelligence justifying the war and over the shape of post-Saddam Iraq.
Love FRONTLINE? Find us on the PBS Video App where there are more than 300 FRONTLINE documentaries available for you to watch any time: to.pbs.org/FLVideoApp
#Documentary #TruthWarConsequences
Subscribe on RUclips: bit.ly/1BycsJW
Instagram: / frontlinepbs
Twitter: / frontlinepbs
Facebook: / frontline
Major funding for FRONTLINE is provided by the Ford Foundation. Additional funding is provided by the Abrams Foundation; the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation; Park Foundation; and the FRONTLINE Journalism Fund with major support from Jon and Jo Ann Hagler on behalf of the Jon L. Hagler Foundation, and additional support from Koo and Patricia Yuen.
To watch soldiers LAUGH while literally destroying the lives of people,one can see one of the reasons why folks dislike America so much.... Imagine an IRAQI adult watching this who was a child back then
Most disgusting President of US the Bush'es, . all the presidents Accept JFK and Trump all others are War criminals
Seeing soldiers gleefully cheer a tank rolling over a man's car for catching him looting some crap lumber was the perfect visual allegory to describe the whole war. I hope those soldiers have some remorse for their actions today. They should be ashamed, and embarrassed by their absent leadership who never clearly defined what their roles were in Baghdad.
@@BrokeredHeart
Meanwhile shop looting is legal now in America as long as is below $900 the irony ……
@@007supertime You're the problem with the USA.
@@BrokeredHeart I'm pretty sure their dead either in Iraq, or by committing suicide as most do .
Just a correction. It's not the "Iraq war", it's the "Invasion of Iraq".
Exactly! Let's call it what it really was.
You nailed it
In Vietnam they don’t call it the “Vietnam War.” Like in Iraq it was an American War.
@@dalemllns Amen.
The invasion of Iraq was from March 2003 to May 2003, while the Iraq War was from March 2003 to December 2011.
And not one of these war criminals will ever be indicted.
Maybe in this world but after they die their doom will start
It was so that pardue pharma could be transported literal tons of opium to fuel the creation of OxyContin. It is a FACT. Right before the FDA associate was taken to a hotel for a week and said no before and came out saying yes. He was tortured into saying it wasn’t addictive and needed opium to make the pill. Morphine is needed for surgeries, for battle medics, for ambulances. Morphine is made with opium. It’s a little know fact but is absolutely true. 70% of the worlds opium lies in Afghanistan and Iraq. So we went and loaded up on oil and opium. Once we left they stopped manufacturing oxys. There’s documentation and documentaries on it
@@poorindiansanddogsarenotal1276 yes gib tony and bush 72 virgins
Actually,they're doing quite fine
for now@@leoninocat5070
After watching Frontline’s 4 part docu-series on the ‘08 economic collapse last weekend as the collapse of the Afghan government was happening live (2021), I think I might need a week or two before I can bare to watch this one. I was in middle school and high school when all this was going on so I didn’t fully comprehend the gravity of what was happening. Looking at these major historical moments from 1998-2012 as a full grown adult has ultimately made me feel disgusted and saddened. I cannot express enough how grateful I am that we have this type of journalism available to us. I hope and pray that we never repeat these mistakes. I truly want better for my children.
Unfortunately looking at Ukraine and the Middle East the neo con foreign policy approach that caused the invasion of Iraq seems very much alive in Washington today - this time with the very real potential of igniting a major war , even a world war.
Watch 9/11 the road to tyranny by Alex Jones as well.
I know the perspective about Jones is bad but watch it with an open heart.
This comment is exactly how I feel, and to think in 2024 we find ourselves close to more war and unrest!
Sadly the way this broken world works, in order for your kids to have the same quality of life you've had, means the oppression and exploitation of lesser nations and their ppl.
Those atrocities were not mistakes,
Those was made
On purpose
As an American I’m so embarrassed of those army soldiers shooting and crushing that car of people just trying to survive. Shame on them!!!
@Ari W you’re right. Destroying their vehicle was absolutely unnecessary. There were much better ways to have handled that situation, like destroying the lumber that they stole, giving them a stern warning and letting them go on their way. It doesn't take a soldier being trained in policing to do this, just a little decency. Instead they chose to bully those people which potentially created future insurgents. Yeah.. good job tough guys.
THANKS TO PBS FILMING CRUE, THOSE PEOPLE IN THE CAR DID NOT GOT SHOT.
Your son needs to go to school, he says. Then destroys their only transportation. Not to mention, the chaos, death and destruction. I'm pretty sure parents, felt so safe, sending their kids to school.
US Marines = war criminals. Hey jarhead! You are not the judge or the enforcer of law. Only reason that you serve is to profit the defense giants.
Wherever USA goes War's an Terriosm follows it. first U.S invades these poor countries on false flags an when thy fight back thyr labeled as Terrorists by there west medias. U.S NATO is the biggest Terrorists Organisation killed millions in Afghanistan Iraq Libya Syria Middle East
I’d take a Frontline Documentary over a Hollywood Blockbuster anytime
same. does that mean we're getting old? 😀😀😀
It is good to be educated. Too many people in America are not informed
real life is way more entertaining, I agree
@@stephenmolohosky1198 your using an opinion piece to get informed I think that is the main problem with Americans today
Check out Fallen Angel trailer
Call sign: extortion 17
I would leave the link but they keep erasing my comments.
0:05: 🔍 Investigation into the truth, war, and consequences of the Iraq war.
10:55: 📝 Ahmad Chalabi's role in the fall of Saddam Hussein and the influence of the special intelligence office in the lead-up to the Iraq War.
19:27: 🔍 The Future of Iraq Project aimed to plan for the post-Saddam era, but many Iraqis were unaware of the challenges ahead. Ahmad Chalabi and other INC Iraqis were skeptical of the project and wanted to focus on who would rule Iraq after the war. Kanan Makiya initially declined to participate, believing that Iraqis would know better how to handle post-war issues. Chalabi and the INC received support from the US government, but their relationship deteriorated in the mid-90s. Chalabi later lobbied for the passage of the Iraqi Liberation Act to make regime change official US policy.
27:05: 😔 The U.S. government's claims of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq were not supported by reliable evidence, and there were discrepancies between the intelligence and the administration's statements.
34:32: 📝 The INC proposed a detailed blueprint for a democratic state in Iraq, including the removal of Saddam's bureaucracy, but faced opposition from the State Department who wanted to prevent rushing into a power vacuum before other Iraqis had a chance to organize.
42:48: 😳 The Pentagon's plan for post-war Iraq did not include the work done on the Future of Iraq Project, and there was a lack of consensus on why this material was not used.
49:32: 🔍 Secretary Powell presents evidence of Iraq's weapons programs, while Chalabi's attempt to lead an uprising fails.
57:51: 🔒 The lack of authority and instructions from the US military led to looting and chaos in Iraq after the fall of Saddam Hussein's regime.
1:06:29: 😔 The aftermath of the Iraq war proves to be more complicated and costly than anticipated, with a policy of complete de-baathification leading to alienation and increased sabotage, and a delicate balance between military operations and civilian casualties.
1:16:54: 🇮🇶 Chalabi discusses the need for security and plans for Iraq after the US occupation.
Recap by Tammy AI
@ambition.... I'm very dumbstruck by the pure brutality of the european!... that's first!.... second is, I feel so unclean knowing that I was born in these pilgrims sin!.... I do not support the vicious sadistic ways of a country/system, that reared me, and, converted me to be their slave. My question to you, and, all other commenters, on this topic is: when are you going to admit how brutal, and, sick, these aliens/pilgrims are!!!.. Amy Goodman, John pilger, and, so many other european voices, that report, and, witness the evils of their people, who rape, murder, pillage, lie, destroy life! and, you never stop spewing the wars, and, horrors these pilgrims constantly commit across earth. I am breaking away from these phones, TV's, looking at their images, and, movies!... its horrific what they did to marshall islands!!! unreal!... a mass murderer!!!... you sell death, and, implement fear!!!.. I would have never allowed you to steal my land!... yet, I am your subject! ambition? these pilgrims are eeeevvillll!!!... I appreciate your comment, even though I cringe seeing the blatant brutal beastly acts committed by these nazis!!!... read em and weep! O.G. Cypher the Don
The connection we had from Iraq is so full of shit and very very very bad at lying lol Reporter” so the document exsist? I’m not getting the feeling that it is real.” Iraqi an politician “It is in American hands “ reporter “ they say it’s in your hands” “reporter” they say you have it “ Iraqian “ yes we have it “ reporter “ can I see it?” Irsquisn “ no we do not know where it is”
Dude gave the information to try to take saddams place after they took him out. He has an evil look in his eye too. He just wanted to be the new head of state in Iraq by bring war into his own country and have his own people killed by war. One of the shadyest pieces of shit iv ever come across or heard of. It’s like listening to Hitler
I saw a film with the words war and truth in the same sentance. How could this bideo possibly be made hy mainstream professional lyers such as pbs
As a American I always wondered how many other Americans actually brought into this BS. I'm not the sharpest tool in the shed but I knew they were lying from day one. I'm so sorry for what happened to the Iraqi people.
It helped that papers like NYT went along with it. Millions marched in Europe & across the world. We saw through it. And were ignored.
USA spent 8 to 10 trillion dollars in Iraq and Afghanistan war while their friend Britain earned 6 trillion dollars from Iraq. USA needs a liberation movement!
I think we should have leveled the country lol
@@cruise-zf9gt
This is what Americans did in Iraq. The whole plot against Iraq was British/ English. Bush and co used fake English reports to make Americans accept being stupid as usual. USA spent 7 trillion dollars in Iraq whithout earning a dime, yet the English who spent nothing earned 6 trillion dollars and on going. They took over oil of Iraq and the Sheia clerics. Not a single oil American company working in Iraq. You need to call for liberation of your country America from the English moth. Trump tried to say a polite no to the occupants of USA and see what is happening to him. LIBRATE YOUR COUNTRY FIRST BEFORE PROPOSING WHAT SHOULD IT DO TO OTHER COUNTRIES!
@@cruise-zf9gt Lol. I hope you're joking..
US soldiers terrorizing locals and laughing about it. What a disgrace.
It was not a good move to destroy somones car.
I first went over there in 2008-09, I was a tank loader at the time. A gunner in my platoon had deployed in 06-07 and told me a story about when his unit had deployed back then they were shown that clip in Kuwait before they rolled up north into Iraq. It was meant to show what not to do when interacting with the Iraqi civilians but the whole unit(of tankers) watching the clip cheered and laughed. I thought it was funny at the time. Looking back on it now it was not funny at all. We invaded that country and terrorized them for years. Just a bunch of kids with big guns. I don't personally know anyone that was KIA in Iraq but I damn sure know many that have killed themselves. We were lied to and used and I hope my generation learns from this and Afghanistan.
War is a Racket.
A REASON THEY LOST...AND AFGANISTAN TOO
Yeah it doesn't take much intelligence to do such horrible things to desperate people trying to survive.
What a bunch of stupid low IQ assholes.
Don't think for a minute they wouldn't do it to us in the US if they had a chance.
Soldier's have absolutely no business policing
“Stealing is wrong, but you can’t understand me, so I’m going to destroy your car.” They may not understand you, but they’re going to understand how to hate now
Exactly. Most of the american videos in Irak should be titled: "How to make an insurgent"
I thought it was awesome lol
Completely the wrong thing to doing when fighting an insurgency
@@youngdeezy6969 No that was American arrogance.
@@youngdeezy6969 more insurgency. awesome.
When this war started, I immediately had a sick feeling in my stomach. At the time I was already a veteran, enlisted as a cavalry scout. I knew then that when modern war happens innocent people die. My unit the 3/7 Cav was the tip of the spear, the first unit into Bagdad. The second I heard about the US going into Iraq, I knew many of my friends would die, and hundreds of thousands of innocent people would die as well, children included. I took the same stance when we invaded Afghanistan (another crime, btw). You don't invade a country just because they are harboring a terrorist. Why not just use special forces? Even if you have to violate a country's national sovereignty, like we ended up doing in Pakistan when we got Bin Laden. War has to always be the last resort.
If only as a last resort...
Glad you made it back 😗👍
I believe the war had several motivations. I think one was to shake up the status quo and see a Shia Arab country emerge, which would also strengthen Iran. The Sunny Arab powerhouses are a lot more open now. Also creating a battlefield to engage the Jihadist in theory mean that we don’t fight them here.
Its the wishes of the zionists and the weapons industry. A bankers war
And the cries of that poor child is heartbreaking 😢😢🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿
The title should be Liars, Thieves and War.
They destroy the country and then expect the people to bow down to them.smh
Traitors and Warcriminals!
RUclips guidelines, cant speak poorly of our communist regime.
YUP
The expression on Bush's face when he want to go to the war makes me spook.
There's something just as barbaric crushing that guys taxi with a 20 ton tank as the human carnage we typically picture. All over 80 bucks worth of wood, just to get by. That scene to me is really emblematic of our time in the middle east: punishing the inhabitants with an oil-fueled, raging overkill, with no regard for human dignity
super cringe. morons
American cowboy-ism at its finest. :'(
pissed me right off.
just goes to show that even the lowest of the low in our military is spoiled senseless compared to the average iraqi
@WILLIAMS F1 RACING. their stupid, clueless reasoning/punishment makes them appear naive, childish, judgmental, and entitled (spoiled) next to the Iraqi taxi driver
Kept me glued for an hour and a half. Kudos to the team👌🙏
It was so that pardue pharma could be transported literal tons of opium to fuel the creation of OxyContin. It is a FACT. Right before the FDA associate was taken to a hotel for a week and said no before and came out saying yes. He was tortured into saying it wasn’t addictive and needed opium to make the pill. Morphine is needed for surgeries, for battle medics, for ambulances. Morphine is made with opium. It’s a little know fact but is absolutely true. 70% of the worlds opium lies in Afghanistan and Iraq. So we went and loaded up on oil and opium. Once we left they stopped manufacturing oxys. There’s documentation and documentaries on it
This was told to me by a guy that I believe was on the up and up. 1983 Rumsfeld met with Sadaam and tried to get access to the southern Iraqi oil fields. Sadaam said no, that oil had been set aside for future generations of Iraqis. In the spring of 1990 oil production began in earnest of the Iraqi southern oil fields. Horizontally drilled out of Kuwait. Kuwait knew nothing about it and Saudi Arabia was cut in on the deal if they would “launder” the crude oil obtained. Sadaam found out about and rolled tanks down to the Kuwaiti border. Coalition forces drove the Iraqis back to Baghdad starting in August of 1990. Kuwait wanted to know what was going on and instead of shutting down the pilfered oil operation they wanted to be cut in on the deal. Operations resumed and this time Kuwait City was getting the bling. Sadaam again returned to the border with tanks, this time they rolled into Kuwait City and looted and plundered the ill gotten gains. A letter was sent to the King of Saudi Arabia by his son Osama bin Laden in 1995. He outlined many grievances but one big one was Saudi Arabia relying on the West for defense and the rampant corruption in the House of Saud. Things continued to escalate and in 1998 the House of Saud sent a letter to the United States that said we needed to start fulfilling our defense agreement as outlined in the Carter Doctrine. We needed to have boots on the ground in defense of Saudi Arabia’s northern border or the United States could say goodbye to the sweet oil prices we had been paying. 9/11 sure was convenient in helping fulfill Saudi Arabia’s defense treaty demands and it kinda explains why we went into Iraq first, why we didn’t find any WMD’s or chemical weapons and why the 9/11 hijackers were Saudi’s.
John Brennan. CIA Station Chief for Saudi Arabia at the time (later Director of CIA) personally intervened to fast track approve the visa applications for the 9/11 hijackers after their applications had originally been turned down. Brennan later would be a key force behind the CIA coup of the democratically elected Ukraine government in 2014 that helped spark the Ukraine War as well as the being a primary creator of the Big Lie of RussiaGate against Trump.
Should have never invaded Iraq in the first place
👍👍
How would they have recived democracy and all the great things which come with it they are free now. 😥😥😢
@@freemanzak8995 so much democracy that they had to leave their homes for Western countries 😁
Not to be a dick but DUH!
@@freemanzak8995 What democracy? They were robbed (of their oil), killed and their country destroyed. The american elite are war criminals and deserve to pay in the afterlife for what they did. All of them: Bush Sr and Jr, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Rice, all the senators and representatives that voted and supported this invasion and genocide. And all the countries, UK first, who backed them.
That man scooping up the blood of a dead Iraqi screaming with so much ire and so much pain to the point that he ripped his shirt off, shocked me so much. I can’t imagine the pain and frustration that he felt. No wonder why suicide bombers came about; the US destroyed everything they had and killed their fellow brothers and sisters with impunity.
😢😢😢😢
Fredom is for the dogs lol
one way or another the Islamic War of Religious Extremism was going to be fought somewhere and it wasn't going to be Shanian
Afghanistan..... It's too bad for Iraq and they were innocent in everything aside from being ruled by a dictator, who would be hanging out with Putin till this day..... Hundreds of thousands of foreign fighters died in Iraq, it killed their cause, protected America and Europe and today.... Iraq seems to be a very good country, and is certainly better than what it would have been had Qusay Hussein become dictator til the year 2059
Their was an man behind that, that gave money to the suicide bombers and promised to make their families rich. They pretty much brainwashed kids into doing so. Just watch videos on the horrific shit isis did to its own people. The man behind the suicide bombings, was just as ruthless. Isis and the man behind the suicide bombings, come from the same breed, just 2 very different men
PoonI
Tks PBS FRONTLINE ! What did We learn from this ?
I clearly remember on a fall day in class discussing about the potential war with Iraq and we we're weighting in the consequences. I was absolutely against the war made my case based on everything here on this video! I was so right! One of my fellow classmates strongly believed saddam had weapon of mass WMD! The whole class agreed with him. I was saddened that day realizing how limited American student knowledge of geopolitic was and how easy they were manipulaed.
The connection we had from Iraq is so full of shit and very very very bad at lying lol Reporter” so the document exsist? I’m not getting the feeling that it is real.” Iraqi an politician “It is in American hands “ reporter “ they say it’s in your hands” “reporter” they say you have it “ Iraqian “ yes we have it “ reporter “ can I see it?” Irsquisn “ no we do not know where it is”
Dude gave the information to try to take saddams place after they took him out. He has an evil look in his eye too. He just wanted to be the new head of state in Iraq by bring war into his own country and have his own people killed by war. One of the shadyest pieces of shit iv ever come across or heard of. It’s like listening to Hitler
It was so that pardue pharma could be transported literal tons of opium to fuel the creation of OxyContin. It is a FACT. Right before the FDA associate was taken to a hotel for a week and said no before and came out saying yes. He was tortured into saying it wasn’t addictive and needed opium to make the pill. Morphine is needed for surgeries, for battle medics, for ambulances. Morphine is made with opium. It’s a little know fact but is absolutely true. 70% of the worlds opium lies in Afghanistan and Iraq. So we went and loaded up on oil and opium. Once we left they stopped manufacturing oxys. There’s documentation and documentaries on it
Watching those soldiers destroying that man's car for taking a pile of wood, truly destroyed my heart and filled it with rage at the moment. That is exactly the reason why you just do not have a military police a civil population, they are just not up to the task, their training is diferent, they are trained to use brutal force, deadly force to resolve a situation rather than de-escalate it. The level of irresponsability and the lack of strategy from our goverment to go "liberate" the iraqi people is unbearable.
Yes, I was thinking to myself, too, just how many hearts and minds they would win over with measures like this.
Timestamp please ?
@@loguchennai did u find it
@@presidential3228 7:41
It is actually crime. According to the international war law, you cannot do that. It is a crime.
Difficult to watch this video without feeling sorry for the ordinary people of Iraq who suffer the consequences of US policy on regime change.
Israel possesses nuclear, chemical, biological and all other kinds of weapons of mass destruction.What is clear is that Israel has not signed the1972 Biological and Toxin Weapons Convention
1😊
I stopped watching 10 minutes in....too ashamed to keep going.
I totally agree I'm a retired navy seal I did 20years 1 month from February 97 too March 2017 I'm retired now MEDICAL retired I served with some of the best men too live task UNIT bruiser Michael moonsor gave his life for this war and did it proudly that's beautiful but these politicians are should be ashamed in jail they lied I did a podcast jocko andy STUMP and laid into them bush chaney etc wmd's get real...I'm proud of my brothers and my service but its tainted by these scumbags political figures liars...I went too the top blue team 666..I just want you to know that I hate this our country is destroyed look at Afghanistan why...
Dick Cheney is evil.
A good example of How to Win Friends and Influence People...
Don't worry. They're totally telling the truth about Ukraine war.
Why smash the mans car.. that's stupid.. we had no plan for those ppl.
Exactly. And we wonder why the hate us Americans.
stupid grunts do stupid grunt shit
@@judjudersawn2596 they’re 18 year old kids with guns doing 18 year old kid stuff. Most of them are intelligent but brainwashed.
@@ginariffe5525 Why they so brave against unarmed poor local villagers !! It's not brainwashed, it's cowards only can do that.They went there to defend local people and find no existing chemical weapons, what a scam
Find the owner of the car and make it right please
Frontline does great documentaries.
We never should have been in Afghanistan in the first place.
I'm sure we left with something other than bodies
We had one job in Afghanistan. To kill Bin Laden and his followers as well as the Taliban. After that we should have left.
Yes we should have. It’s really dumb to be attacked on 9/11 and not expect an reaction. The taliban harbored alqueda. We got rid of em. And we pushed taliban back. Nation building may have not been in the details but what’s happening now is because a nation is not built.
@@ericacannon5832 , if you think 9/11 was committed by the Taliban, I got several bridges to sell you.
@@DavidCarmonaUX , and you know this. I believe Afghanistan or maybe Iraq had massive amounts of opium. I’m sure we left with plenty over the last few decades.
I found it mind blowing that a foreign country decides of the future of another sovereign country without consulting the people of the said country..and they still wondering what went wrong.
When US soldiers arrived in Iraq, they were told to protect the Iraqi 's oil fields were their first priority, NOT WMD.
Legend says bush is still trying to find Weapons of mass destruction
👍👍 ain't it the truth 😂
😂😂😂
And still trying to "Put food on his family" ! 😁
George Bush is a weapon of "Mass Deception."
@@IanPatrickOfficial "Mass Deception." for his Oil company in Kuwait and Texas.
If that’s what soldiers did in front of a camera, imagine what they did away from them
The narrators voice is one I’ll remember hearing on the tv quite a bit as a kid
But yet Bush says, he has no regrets as President. Hundreds of thousands Dead and Injured in Iraq and Afghanistan.
That says it all...jail 4 thier crimes against humanity
He said it, and I believe him! You should too!
War criminals be warcriminalin
@Donnell Okafor sadly we weren't as smart as the Russians. they left in 10 years.
Not his kids, so… 🤷🏽♀️ But surely, you can see all the women we “liberated.” 🙄
When you have no idea as who the enemy is, you can't win.
More importantly, the enemy within, as shown in this documentary (US Government.)
Its been 21 years, i was a kid back then and the pain will be there for the next tens of years to come
Thank you for the information.
Taxi driver picks up customer with pieces of wood as baggage. Soldiers think it's justice to crush and destroy the taxi cab. The poor taxi driver lost his only form of income. That is just wrong. This a war crime and they should be held accountable. Courts Marshall for every soldier that participated.
I mean it didn’t look like too expensive of a car, he could probably go buy another one. That’s what I’d do. 🤷♂️
@@TheBrianFlanagan it's not expensive in America, but it is in a war torn country.☮️🕊️✌️
Us protect their thieves soldiers
@@TodaTruth you are right.😊👍
@@TheBrianFlanagan the soldiers should buy it for him.😊🚙
"All Governments Lie" I.F. Stone - This is why a Free Press is so important to The People.
Free. But editors are paid. Anytime there is someone doing a job, the reason he is doing the job is usually money.
An unbias free press is essential. But then again maybe not! Because, there isn't a unbiased free press and there are people everywhere.
Guess it's time for that open mind every keeps talking about.
Izzy!👍👍
Lol. The naivety in your statement is a telltale sign that you are just another sheep led by western propaganda
The problem is when the press is a propaganda mouthpiece for agenda rather than reporting in a manner that enlighten and let intelligent people to make determinations or form opinions of their own. What is known is most consumers of information are not well educated or informed so they are more susceptible to accept what they hear as truth based on preconceptions and opinions they already formed from a more limited set of information from some early formative learnings or indoctrinations. Very few people take in all the information with discernment and then form cohesive thoughts objectively. This is very difficult. I would say frontline generally has less agendas and allow for this process more than other “news”.
@@MonroeYohey I agree. “This is very difficult” indeed. Free market corrupts free press corrupts free market and on. The fairness doctrine worked.
I was 9 when the 9/11 attacks happened. I’ll never forget where I was. I was in school and they brought in the television for us all to witness the tragedy. This documentary was so gripping and really a testament to the tenacity of America.
@@Ivan-tm9pd I went to a private school in Richmond Virginia lol. It was definitely in normal practice for them to show the whole school those types of things so we could pray for those who were affected lol. Public schools probably were a little different depending on where you’re from.
The tenacity of America? HAHAHAHA what a bunch of war criminals and psychopaths
the real tragedy was just like you americans were lied to about weapons of mass destruction you were lied to about what happened on 9/11 and who was behind it...and the greater tragedy that you americans still believe what you were told and continue to be told by the greatest source of misinformation in the world: the US government and the US Mainstream Media.
I was a sophomore in college when 9/11 happen I was on my way to science 🧪 lab
@@Ivan-tm9pd I was in high school in Ohio and they rolled the TVs out for us, too. It was a normal public school.
Ahmad Chalabi must be burning in hell. This guy started a huge long war where death, misery and poverty came to thousands of people. I feel sorry for the people and Iraq and the American Soldiers that die for no reason.
So, basically, one Iraqi ambitious man used US to get rid of his political opponent.
It’s bigger than that because Israel was behind this more than anything.
Shows how wack people are and annoying that region was/is
اكتب بل عربي افضل وانت يا عزيزي المشاهد ترجم ذالك : لا يوجد مثل صدام حسين كان يحب بلده وكان يدافع عنه بكل قوة وكان رجل يحب الخير الجميع الدول العالم لكن كان قاسي القلب الشخص الخائن يقوم بعدامه كان هناك امان ومال وكان هناك سعاده بين الناس في زمن صدام حسين لكن جاءت امريكا وبعض الدول تحت مسمى يوجد السلاح الدمار الشامل لدي صدام حسين وكانت الصدمه الكبرى من قبل العرب الاقرب اليه قام البعض منهم بل اشتراك في الحرب مع امريكا ضد حكومه الرئيس صدام حسين صدام حسين لا يوجد مثله في الكواكب الافضل كان ولكن قاسي جدا لكن لقد رحل الى الله في مكان بعيد عن الارض فل يرقد في سلام❤حقا حببت صدام حسين
“The wealth that is extracted from imperialism goes into the pockets of a selected few whereas the costs of empire are paid out of the common treasure of the people"
- Michael Parenti
Anyone who has the power 2 make u believe absurdities has the power 2 make u commit injustices. -Voltaire. Greetings from Kenya 🇰🇪. Let's pray for peace ✌️
Hapo umenena!
Please be safe, because things such as war$ and pandemics never really produce happy happy afterlives in the sky.
Theres now winner In War.
@@Arun71150 kweli kaka. Usiku sacco.
Ni pesa na kiburi....
This documentary leads me to believe that the problems today in the Middle East is still tied to what happened in the early 2000's and allot by what America did in Iraq!
it goes back farther than that, the USA created the coop that overthrew the democratically elected president in Iran and installed the shaw as leader for the oil companies! The USA has caused many problems in the middle east over oil
@@buddyflood6758 You are right about that statement.
You're exactly right America is reaping the consequences of its tyranny against other countries.
Absolutely!
@@buddyflood6758 true, Volker Pispers has a pretty accurate monologue (German audio, English subtitles) about the hole history
I very much remember at the time having a feeling that this was a mistake.
It was so that pardue pharma could be transported literal tons of opium to fuel the creation of OxyContin. It is a FACT. Right before the FDA associate was taken to a hotel for a week and said no before and came out saying yes. He was tortured into saying it wasn’t addictive and needed opium to make the pill. Morphine is needed for surgeries, for battle medics, for ambulances. Morphine is made with opium. It’s a little know fact but is absolutely true. 70% of the worlds opium lies in Afghanistan and Iraq. So we went and loaded up on oil and opium. Once we left they stopped manufacturing oxys. There’s documentation and documentaries on it
Generals tell their men to win the hearts and minds of the people.Soldiers,naw let’s run over this guy’s car for grabbing a little bit of wood.
They were probably over-compensating for the American army failing to control looting at all during the first days and weeks after the invasion. And who knows what kind of off-the-wall orders they'd been given.
in the process destroying all the timber they might have stolen. all for nothing...
They just created more hatred towards Americans.
Probably turned that guy into an instant terrorist!!
Not surprising at all.
Anyone who has worked in an management position knows many low level worker don't give a shit. Cutting corners, instant personal gratification are their priorities. Grand long term goals are never in their sights.
This is maddening. I am still stuck on we were duped into this. And our own government needed to convince us this was the right thing. They needed the American people to feel this was just. I remember it happening. And I was sold. I was fooled. It changed my view of our government forever. I was 20 years old. Thank you Frontline for even going further. So well done.
Well said, Erick. Thank you.👍
That’s why they demolished the twin towers, and building 7, as an excuse.
At least you didn't join the army and occupy these people's country. I was truly dooped. Anytime anyone says "thank you for your service " it makes me want to grab them by their head and scream in their face. You should never thank a veteran for OIF OAF. We did nothing for you. We were tricked and I will never forgive myself for being so stupid.
Please write to your American Government took bring george bush the ex-president to trial for war crimes its never to late blood in his hands a national disgrace send him to the hague
Duped AGAIN BY THE SAME LOT. TILL TO SAY THERE'S NO EVIDENCE TO PROVE THAT SADAM HAD ANYTHING TO SO WITH THE 09/11/ BOMBING OF THE TWIN TOWERS. Sheer corruption on the part of the Americas and AGENTS.
Almost died here in 2005 driving Halliburton Executives around. I got out shortly after.
I joined a Patriotic young man in 1999. By 2005 I was disgusted with our corrupt evil politicians and the multinational billionaires / criminals that control them.
I lost friends there. I lost myself there. For what? So somebody could have a percentage?
It was so that pardue pharma could be transported literal tons of opium to fuel the creation of OxyContin. It is a FACT. Right before the FDA associate was taken to a hotel for a week and said no before and came out saying yes. He was tortured into saying it wasn’t addictive and needed opium to make the pill. Morphine is needed for surgeries, for battle medics, for ambulances. Morphine is made with opium. It’s a little know fact but is absolutely true. 70% of the worlds opium lies in Afghanistan and Iraq. So we went and loaded up on oil and opium. Once we left they stopped manufacturing oxys. There’s documentation and documentaries on it
It's infuriating to see these pathological liars act like they didn't needlessly destroy millions of lives.
american neo con foreign policy is still very much alive in Washington today still creating wars like that in Ukraine and has the very real potential of starting a world war soon
Destabilizing a region is never a good idea.
No, it's not.. Nation Building is never a good idea either..
But for those that want make money off of War, well, it is a good idea..
We must learn from all of this and never forget..
@@whyputaname it would be nice unfortunately those in charge of the government refuse to learn from the lessons that history has taught us throughout the years
@@reaperking7748 👍👍
@@whyputaname the only reason I say this is because not all the politicians in charge but a good majority of them believe that they are entitled to everything under the sun. Which makes the rest of us Americans look like a joke to the rest of the world
If "stability" means totalitarian dictators that rain roughshod over their people (and committing a few genocides here and there), sometimes you do need some destabilization. What should the West have then done about Hitler, continue to appease him? You need to smash some eggs sometimes to make an omelette.
As an American citizen, I can honestly say that I don't know what to believe anymore concerning the various wars that America has engaged in. What is the truth, why did America get involved in these various wars, what was America trying to gain from these wars. There seems to be so many lies and false flags surrounding these wars.
Since the end of WW2 the USA has invaded more countries than any other country. Always claimed to be in the name of Democracy & Freedom yet in nearly all those invasions no democracy was ever created, in fact. usually quite the opposite. I can think of many examples of the CIA overthrowing a democratically elected government and replacing it with a authoritarian regime/dictatorship but am at a loss to list one example of the CIA overthrowing a dictatorship and replacing it with democracy.
I was once a small boy when this war began. Eventually I grew into an adult, shocked and appalled by our aggressions and failure to do just about anything... for what? What did we achieve? We killed civilians with blankets of bombs and "precious" missles. Our young come back scarred and changed, yet there is no "victory".
The U.S. were there to liberate the Oil not the people ⛽💰
Frontline reports, are in my judgement, First Rate, thans John
The LOVE of money is the root of all evil.
Everyone involved in these wars from Vietnam, Korea, Iraq, Libya, Afganistan, and to wherever it was... they all have this in common... GREED.
The war was rooted in racism. The majority of the american public after 9/11 wanted, and racism was an effective medium. The Cheney/powell facists probably used this racist sentiment within the american public to try to achieve their goals wrt money or whatever.
once again the old rule of thumb - FOLLOW THE MONEY - will tell you why the invasion of Iraq happened and who benefitted.
Let's gooo Frontline. Can't wait for it to start.
@LTrain45 45 where? Now I’m curious
@LTrain45 45 11qq111
@LTrain45 45 Are you talking about "lets roll"?
@LTrain45 45 no and I don't care. Frontline is the best
Most disgusting President of US the Bush'es, . all the presidents Accept JFK and Trump all others are War criminals
The US government has one of the most negative effects on other countries and people in this world.
It was so that pardue pharma could be transported literal tons of opium to fuel the creation of OxyContin. It is a FACT. Right before the FDA associate was taken to a hotel for a week and said no before and came out saying yes. He was tortured into saying it wasn’t addictive and needed opium to make the pill. Morphine is needed for surgeries, for battle medics, for ambulances. Morphine is made with opium. It’s a little know fact but is absolutely true. 70% of the worlds opium lies in Afghanistan and Iraq. So we went and loaded up on oil and opium. Once we left they stopped manufacturing oxys. There’s documentation and documentaries on it
"Feels no discomfort" 😢
Wars are *ALWAYS* about money. Those that have the gold make the rules. Follow the money. End of documentary.
It's simpler than that, just follow the US army.
money = power, power = money. It's reciprocal af.
you spelled Poppy wrong!
@Incomeking Power allows you to keep your money, which bought the power to begin with, Sir.
@Incomeking Power allows them to control matters in the way they see fit, and they wield that power to make more money. So, how did they get that power to begin with, dude? Money. Period. Plain and simple, and everyone knows this as well.
There is so much to be learned from this on so many levels.
That's very true.
Yes. Don't trust the US Government when it comes to the actual truth.
Yeah..like staying out of ukraine is a good start..did france and china send millions to "stand with iraq"
That is true. But I'm afraid our governments will never learn. The people on both sides hurt the most. Governments can never be trusted. Just pure lies and propaganda of the highest level. No weapons of mass destruction. Iraq had been under sanctions for so long. If Saddam farted the USA would have known. Maybe
tell the Obama/Biden neo cons that
WOW! Talk about dragging suppressed rage to the forefront. I'm going to have to take this one a pinch at a time.
It's an absolute disgrace that those who died in 9 11, all of those deaths were used in this way.
One of the lessons that could be learned from war is not to trust the ego fear’s perceptions. This would save America billions which are needed to help seniors and bridges at home in US
👍👍👍
First lesson: stop following the neo-con colonial agenda.
Second lesson: stop invading other countries.
Third lessong: stop invading orher countries which are on the agenda of neo-con zionists.
@@absolutdevil9705 .. 👍👍
Colin Powell knew better, but his job and being within the nucleus of the American power structure was more important to him than the lives of 10s of thousands of innocent people.
As a Jamaican, I’m so ashamed of him.
I feel you on that. The whole WORLD knew that this war was a super wrongheaded decision, and Powell was the world's last bastion of hope. He had that much gravitas at the time, but he chose to go against his own doctrine, the "Powell Doctrine" that he came up with having first hand knowledge of the treachery of war. Sadly, he STILL embraced the darkness. It was a heart breaking performance he put on. But I must forgive him. God bless.
I agree he knew the war was wrong, but I guess he didn't want to be bashed for going against the power structure.
Just shared on Truth Social App
Good Morning Steve Laboy...Thanks NYPD
I am an American and to everyone who were effected by what the US did, I apologize for all the atrocities that my government did and is still doing to this day
it's not on you, it was them. Justice will arrive in one day, I believe in it. And I pray for all the people like you.
Sooner or later,America will pay for all of her war crimes.Blood debt does not settled by using apologies. It will happen when nations stopped using Dollar for reserve currency (some nations already doing it and many more to come) and PetroDollar is destroyed. When that time comes,retribution will brings terrors to the USA Mainland. Pray for all the safety of good American like you.🙏
one of course does not have to but might ask if the plotline of truth, looting, and consequences is very different from that of die hard inclusive of essays devoted to the funneling of assets offsite (nakatomi plaza, iraq), verlierst nicht daẞ du bist eine einstein, love, لا اله الا الله محمد رسول الله
Why are you apologizing for something you had no say so or responsibility for?
The worst thing is they sent poor and middle class americans kill innocent people to fill their elite pockets.
i love how in these comments you can tell who just watched the first 10 minutes and who actually watched the whole thing
"You can help yourself by being truthful."
It was so that pardue pharma could be transported literal tons of opium to fuel the creation of OxyContin. It is a FACT. Right before the FDA associate was taken to a hotel for a week and said no before and came out saying yes. He was tortured into saying it wasn’t addictive and needed opium to make the pill. Morphine is needed for surgeries, for battle medics, for ambulances. Morphine is made with opium. It’s a little know fact but is absolutely true. 70% of the worlds opium lies in Afghanistan and Iraq. So we went and loaded up on oil and opium. Once we left they stopped manufacturing oxys. There’s documentation and documentaries on it
Something that I find extremely troubling... many of the same players involved in getting us into Iraq have been in charge of Ukraine policy/politics.. from the 2014 "Revolution" to the current proxy war.
This is the best show out there.
Ladies and Gentlemen, creating a state of chaos is not a blunder but a strategy!! It is not incompetence, but rather a very deviant strategy!
War has to STOP.
I We thank you All
I've seen this one before. Worth watching again. All Frontline documentaries are.
I think this is an updated version..
@@whyputaname sweet even better
@@HeatherBoo916 👍👍
Got my popcorn ready! Love you FRONTLINE!
What's worse than doing nothing? Watching corruption onfold and doing nothing about it. Enjoy the popcorn.
@@laturista1000 same thing I said you going to get popcorn instead of standing up for the basic rights of others in their own country where so many innocent people were killed hmmm that’s a Shame at least we both saw this
Very good documentary ❤
Man of excellence from the Bronx, Powell.
Watching this in 2004 after the chaotic state of Iraq then was sobering. Watch this in 2021 is just nuts. How could the policy makers been so naive and out of touch is just crazy.
Us humans have not yet learned how to learn from our past mistakes.
Brought to you by Republicans. We can always rely on them to do the wrong thing.
It was all about money..
@@str8ballinSA .. Yes, they can mess up a wet dream . 👍👍
@@str8ballinSA Really? So I'm just imagining the events of the past week? Like the mess that Biden, a Democratic president, has left in Afghanistan?
The American GI crushing the taxi with his tank is the perfect analogy for the thoughtlessness of US foreign policy. No wonder it's all a mess.
THEY DID NOT GOT SHOT BECOUSE OF THE FILMING CRUE.
حتى مشكلتي انتم من تتحلووها باصحاب الفخر والاعزاز
We have beheld him, FULL OF GRACE AND TRUTH. "The truth is not in him." He's completely full of truth, according to the 1953 Calhoun Georgia (J. Fred Muggs) definition.
I’m Iraqi-Assyrian and man all this hits home. I hope my country will come to know peace but tbh it’s been a battlefield for thousands of years it just sucks that there’s no end in sight.
How's democracy and freedom working out for yo after sadam.
Great outlook hhhhuuuhhhj!!!
Atmna lka aslama Wa Alaman, sahlan.
I hope Assyrians get their own country in their own land some day. Or a North Mesopotamian country of combined Assyrians-Armenians-Kurds-Sabians-Yezidis-Chadleans-Turkomens.
Ragna Kokomo
I hope you saw the part where them fellow Iraqis on Exile was lieying to American people ?
Because they both wanted to be president of Iraq 🇮🇶
@@eromalandersson5716 please stop it right there
Itaq was ok before the US decided Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. It was the sanctions imposed on a lie that destroyed Iraq, not the Bath Party.
This is what our Nightly News should be. REAL JOURNALISM!
🙏🙏🙏🌎✝️ Thank God I have overcome the world with the truth. The scandal behind politics
These government officials need to be charged
I met a lot of Iraqis who fled to Thailand when I was living there and all of them said that life under Saddam Hussein was pretty good. Women had rights, they could go to college and dress normally and he told me that a lot of American business owners we're broken hearted that they had to leave Baghdad when The war started.
you should ask America how many WMD did they found on Iraq...and why George Bush Jr thought he needed death and war to be reelected
Yep. He was cleaning up terrorists. They only invaded because they refused the central banks. Never made sense either cause if Afghanistan really did blow up those buildings, why wait 3 years and go to Iraq first. Cause it was a false flag set up to invade 7 countries. Osama was CIA
the invasion and obliteration, not 'the war'..
The USA lied about Saddam. just like the USA lies about Putin, just like the USA media lies about Trump
That was disgusting to watch, shame on us.
7:30, a civilian car in Iraq was destroyed by American soldiers by tank because they apprehended individuals who were using it to steal wood from a building that had been struck by US missiles. This raises the question of who truly bears the responsibility for exploiting Iraq's resources. How much longer will this situation remain unresolved and unforgiven?
It was so that pardue pharma could be transported literal tons of opium to fuel the creation of OxyContin. It is a FACT. Right before the FDA associate was taken to a hotel for a week and said no before and came out saying yes. He was tortured into saying it wasn’t addictive and needed opium to make the pill. Morphine is needed for surgeries, for battle medics, for ambulances. Morphine is made with opium. It’s a little know fact but is absolutely true. 70% of the worlds opium lies in Afghanistan and Iraq. So we went and loaded up on oil and opium. Once we left they stopped manufacturing oxys. There’s documentation and documentaries on it
Donald Rumsfeld would try to talk his way out of a sunburn.
None of the documentaries of this type is 100% perfect, but Frontline comes closest to perfection. Martin Smith is my top favorite warzone correspondent and interviewer; he goes where danger lurks. I believe, all in all, Frontline is the best documentary series of all of them. Thumbs up. Subscribed. Notifications enabled. Even so, it sometimes, rarely, promulgates false information. So... Everyone watching should be careful. Everyone listening should check for the facts.
I shall be fact checking vigilantly !🤭👍👏
ur totally right, they do a pretty good job in disguising where they lean politically, where you can tell the most is trump vs obama
Yes still alot if holes. I was in Bagdad a year prior. Hands Afgan. Watching the. Poppy trade.
DW engages both sides as well.
@@judiesuh6858 kn onjnnoon p nnpnjjn 😊 npno pn j. Ok job pjopjjn I 😊jkijob it 👨💻 in n😊k on ibooj open o n okno o
Holy kitty cats, seeing this 17 years later is...wow, I don't have the words...sobering? Heartbreaking? Shocking? Certainly saddening.....
Reminiscent of those times when criticism of Iraq adventure was called unpatriotic...
@@str8ballinSA 👍👍
Most disgusting President of US the Bush'es, . all the presidents Accept JFK and Trump all others are War criminals
@@str8ballinSA To be fair, while not everyone who opposed the war was against America necessarily, there was a lot of anti-Americanism coming from the anti-war camp.
@@007supertime Trump lauched more missiles than Obama and killed more innocent civilians. Reevaluate your beliefs before you pretend to be anti-war.
PBS always give facts and figures
The Iraqi people were the last consideration in their equations. Political and military careers were worth thousands of lives a piece.
It was so that pardue pharma could be transported literal tons of opium to fuel the creation of OxyContin. It is a FACT. Right before the FDA associate was taken to a hotel for a week and said no before and came out saying yes. He was tortured into saying it wasn’t addictive and needed opium to make the pill. Morphine is needed for surgeries, for battle medics, for ambulances. Morphine is made with opium. It’s a little know fact but is absolutely true. 70% of the worlds opium lies in Afghanistan and Iraq. So we went and loaded up on oil and opium. Once we left they stopped manufacturing oxys. There’s documentation and documentaries on it
The lesson here is stay out of other. Countries business
Let the people solve their own problems their own way
Democracy is not for everyone
KOREA ?
True to some degree, but not all situations are the same.
That's assuming we were there to bring democracy, which everyone by now should know we weren't.
Yes l agree
The only way US ideology will survive is to expand as much as possible to as many ppl as possible. I agree with you in that democracy is not for everyone but that’s not the point. US freedom and ideological survival depends on assimilating other ideas and cultures into itself .
Martin Smith is such a fantastic journalist. 👏
Without a doubt. I've thought that for a long time
And yet idiots at fox, cnn and msnbc call themselves "journalists"
I had to respond to FRONTLINE's error,...but I am a regular fan of your reporting...I look forward to any new investigation/s...BUT had to state the fact?
That sadistic soldier who said “that’s what you get for looting” how sick do you have to be? What about looting Iraqi’s oil?
At the end of the day it comes down to control over another, power, greed an resources.
That incident with that Taxi driver and the tank squad answered quite a few of my questions. I was feeling so much sorry for him. Even though I'm not from US and never felt that hardship they must have been feeling.