🚨 Rupert Bell EXPLAINS Why Charlotte Dujardin Is RULED OUT Of The Paris 2024 Olympics! 🐎
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024
- Jamie O'Hara and Kevin Nolan are joined by Rupert Bell to discuss the controversy surrounding Charlotte Dujardin's horrific treatment of Dressage Horse.
Subscribe: / talksport
Enjoyed this RUclips video? 😍
🖥️ talkSPORT's Website: talksport.com/
📲 talkSPORT's Twitter: / talksport
📷 talkSPORT's Instagram: www.instagram....
👤 talkSPORT's Facebook: / talksport
📱 talkSPORT's Tik Tok: / talksport
🔴 Download the talkSPORT app HERE! - talksport.com/...
🔎 Want to see if you feature on our RUclips channel? Check out our Best talkSPORT callers playlist: • The BEST talkSPORT Cal...
#talkSPORT
#Olympics
#equestrian
What has gone on here is not inappropriate it is animal abuse . It ain't an error of judgement it is engrained behaviour. Why it came out now is incidental....are we bothered someone like this misses the Olympics? Although the issue should have been raised at the time to possibly spare more horses from this woman over the last 4 years.
She went to the other Olympics so I don't feel that sorry for her and she's got a medals from that and she's made her money from those medals and she's been giving copious amounts of cash from the lottery funding which will now stop however she will not be living in a caravan on a trailer park so I shed no tears
totally agree, & now she's whining abbout "victim blaming." She wasn't the victim---her horse was. I hope she sold it & it's having an excellent life---both of these women should be banned from owning any animal permanently.
The fact other people were there watching means she wasnt fussed about hiding it. Suggests it is common practice and I doubt she's the only one, the only one to be caught though
Exactly right, she was clearly familiar and comfortable with that whip in her hand.
There have been a number of whistleblowers recently, though. The Helgstrande footage was appalling. Dressage has become a farce and a disgrace. It used to be about partnership, harmony and relaxation.
I hope the British intolerance of animal abuse means this particular leak will force change. It’s sorely needed.
@@spellywelly It seems to happen in all equestrian sports. Look at horse racing and the rodeos in the US as well. We seem to have a different perspective with horses, as if they're tools rather than animals. And I'm no vegan
This must happen all the time, it was just filmed once
Why would you take a whip like that into a training area if you had no intention of using it? Does anyone seriously believe that this doesn’t happen in other dressage stables?
Actually that part isn’t true and whips are supposed to be GENTLE tools of communication . So pointing or a tap ( as in if I tapped you on the shoulder).
A horse can feel a fly land on it , so that’s how soft it should be.
And lunging a horse, that is generally non contact, so you use a long whip to block a horse’s forward movement or to indicate to trot canter ( and that generally doesn’t even touch a horse at all)
There is zero need to put force via a whip into training a horse unless a person is taking their temper and frustration out on it and then that’s abuse imo
Whips can be used as just an extention of your hand, or leg. The amount and quality of whipping is obviously something she is quite used to do. It is beyond unacceptable to do that to that horse. The horse is obviously unable to do the actions demanded. Any dressage movement must be ASKED of the horse, never demanded.
I am a keeper of equines - I have four donkeys - and I have a profound respect for their sensitivity and intelligence. If I treated them as appallingly as this "professional" horsewoman, I would expect to be prosecuted and have my animals removed. She should not be allowed to keep equines again until she has undergone some sort of RSPCA education course about animal suffering. After watching this video - which is utterly sickening - I wouldn't trust this woman to keep a hamster.
@@JohnPretty1 wow you are really smart John & Pretty good with your answers
She should just be banned for life from interacting with horses. if someone behaved this way to another human being it would be called sadism.
@@equusasinus Her hamster actually packed a suitcase and left after watching the video!
She should be charged with animal abuse digusting woman
Yet people on here ok with the slaughter and consumption of meat. Tens of thousands of animals slaughtered every year! That's ok?
I hope you don't pay for animals to be abused and then eat them. Horrific abuse, would make you very hypocritical if you do.
'An error of judgment'. Please tell me that an Olympian of this quality would actually say this. It was simply a unacceptable act on a horse.
Totally agree. Any rider of that caliber should never, ever resort to this kind of training method. To me, it makes her look like she doesn't know what she's doing. And there's no way that this incident was a "one off". You're a world class rider, and all of a sudden you thought beating the horse was your best option? Unbelievable!
She should never ever compete again!
You are the same people who never dare say a word against the Gcide of a whole population... but very quick to denounce animal abuse. How about you fight against the slaughter of more than 200 000 children for more than 10 months now?
Not an error of judgement, a display of extreme cruelty.
Exactly...she's a disgrace.
That video didn’t look like ‘an error of judgement’ it looked like something she does constantly…that video is sickening and as for the woman laughing (who’s recording the video) whilst she videos is appalling….that didn’t look like her first rodeo doing that 🤷♀️
So if this commentator heard that an abusive parent had the habit of viciously beating their children he would call it an "error of judgment".
I agree with you, & is Rupert type of man who would deny a girl's claim 4 yrs ago she was beaten & assaulted by male Rupert knew?
Should have a lifetime’s ban from keeping horses. Pure evil.
From keeping any animals. I wouldn’t trust her around any defenceless animal. She should be prosecuted and have all her medals removed. There’s no excuse for animal abuse.
Definitely didn't look like her first rodeo. She's definitely accustomed to abusing animals
From people who know nothing about dressage. This a common practice since centuries ago and it was filmed just accidently by a jealous ugly rival and propagted by envious people who have not the money to ride a horse and the woke BBC. Greetings from Paris by a French rider 😂😂
@@MsJustice4ever I hope you don't pay for animal abuse and then eat them.
This woman is famous and caught on film. She isn’t a one off. You aren’t hearing about all of the other horses in her sport who undergo the same kind of treatment during training. The entire sport needs to end.
Should be banned for life, What a cruel person she is!
Rupert said they whip the horses as part of the training but not to the extent of Charlotte... *apparently* as nobody knows. They all do it as much behind closed doors, be in no doubt. So realistically, following your logic, the whole sport should be banned
Garbage.
She should be banned from keeping horses ever
What about the migrant that stabbed a soldier 70 times. Community service.
@@paulpaisley5291 your anger is directed at immigrants. What have they to do with this issue.
What type of blindness must someone be affected with to watch ten seconds of a dressage competition and not understand immediately that horse behaviour is the result of torture? It blindingly obvious...
That and the fact that the judges in the arena can see this torture, (Rollkur, double bits in their mouths and spurring) and yet they turn a blind eye to it goes to show how ingrained this s**t is.
Why didn't the horse owner report this to the FEI four years ago? They are just as implicit in the cruelty towards their own horse as the trainer is.
Sorry, but you're questioning the *timing*??? Looking at this horrible video, I'm questioning the cruelty. Is the cruelty diminished because of the timing? Ridiculous question!
@equusasinus You're missing the point. If we agree that the act was cruel then why wait years to report it giving her the chance to carry on behaving like this for years? Of course the timing should be questioned.
Because she was only 15@@justlookin28
Have you never heard the phrase "revenge is a dish best served cold"? Had this come out at the time of the offense then Charlotte could have potentially cleared her image in time for these Olympics, but by bringing it to PUBLIC knowledge now is the most damaging thing to Charlotte. No the owners are not to blame in the slightest.
Because it's normal for them to do it regardless of what they say.
Dressage shouldn't even be a sport in the first place, it's animal abuse akin to bear dancing and lion taming.
Charlotte's whipping abuse of horse in video shared & viewed has brought into discussions to ban horse sports in Olympics.
I used to write for the dressage judges at put local shows, I gave up because u couldn't bear to watch the way some riders treated their horses.
It was 2 and 1/2 years ago not 4. Don’t believe the word of an animal abuser.
Evil person who should be in jail. Ask any horse expert. You never use fear and violence. 😢
Get her arrested and charged.
What a lot of BS from this guy. He clearly would have known about the abuse and is trying to create sympathy for that abuser. She should have her career in tatters for the brutal cruelty she has inflicted on so many animals (and there are many photos of her in shows with her horse's tongues turning blue and foaming at the mouth so claiming he's surprised by her abuse is ridiculous).
There are no photos of her with a horse with a blur tongue. Horses are supposed to salivate when accepting the bit. It means a soft mouth. You have no proof she has practiced brutal cruelty on her horses.
Done 4 years ago. How many times since? What's nearly as disturbing is the person laughing in the background during the filming.
It will be interesting to see if and how many more people come out and admit she beat their horses during training sessions too.
Love the way he's trying his best to portray her as a victim. Error of judgement my armpit.
And only worries about winning a medal ffs.
The person filming it can be heard laughing.
If this person didn't release it with such perfect timing it would have been in the news 2 days and then- forgotten.
This video will NEVER be forgotten
Who is the person in the background laughing 😢?
I cannot watch this. Very disturbing,to say the least.
The timing of the release of the video is 🤢..they allowed the potential abuse of 🐴 go on for 4 years
It's disappointing that whoever took the video has waited four years to come forward and release it. I mean, if that's how Charlotte treats and trains horses on a regular basis, then that's potentially a lot of unnecessary suffering that these poor animals have had to go through, that could of been prevented many years ago.
No way was that her first time . And the person laughing in the background 😡
I can't even watch her abusing the horse. One very sick person.
i can't watch it either, it would stay with me and haunt me
I don't believe for one second this is the first time she's done this. RSPCA investigate and remove all animals while investigating individuals based on just allegations, there's actual footage and a confession here, if they don't remove ALL her animals and prosecute I'm never donating to them again
“Dressage Should Be Banned From The Olympics”. Ultimately it is animal cruelty. There is no excuse for such behavior.
I don't need horses that jump around unnaturally. Leave the horses in peace.
That the disgusting treatment of an animal was done so nonchalantly (as if it was normal) is very disturbing. Any previous medals must surely be questioned.
Any sports using animals should be banned anyway its disgusting
totally agree with you. Animals are not sports
She should be heavily fined for animal cruelty
Let's face it whether people wanna accept it or not.. Whip training is cruel, even a little bit. I don't see a difference between training a horse for dressage and training a dancing bear... But if you do the latter you go to prison...
Using a whip is not supposed to give pain. I ride with a whip all the time and I tap with it to gently remind my horse to move sideways or forward. The action is similar to someone tapping your arm.
The force that Charlotte is using is not acceptable and I’ve never seen anyone using a whip in this fashion
So these upper class folk that recorded that floggin was made 4 years ago and they wait to and wait and wait instead of report it inmediately to cause maximun damage and uproar. Man...that is cruelty or the right thing to do? I am confused.
Should be banned by the RSPCA from working with or keeping horses.
2min 6secs . . .It certainly was a surprise to me when I saw that (opps) At the start he said he had not seen the video. That stinks! Deliberate and repeated CRUELTY is NOT AN ERROR OF JUDGEMENT.
Let a court decide.
The Horse was frightened ! You cannot beat a horse into submission they will be scared of people for ever. You want a horse to love you as you love them and have the desire to please you.
banned for life
This must happen all the time and as with Sir Mark Todd over 2-years ago, its been filmed and released the week of the Olympics for a bigger impact. Cruelty has cost her another Gold medal and the certain knighted which she would've received. Career finished in disgrace and does it happen in other stables?
Ban her for life. She should be charged with animal abuse!!! Disgusting!!!
The timing of the video is good for the bigger issue, right before the Olympics where it will get the most noise and hopefully all of them are lookee into as this is not an isolated incident in the joke hobby that is dressage.
Great to see Nolan and O'Hara get to the heart of the matter, two great dressage experts. As for Rupert, well the equestrian community once again circle the wagons, oh this is out of character, this isn't normal, shes a lovely girl, I've never known this before! She is done, so is the "sport", and I hope the RSPCA get involved.
The lawyer is now saying the video was taken 2 and 1/2 years ago. Four years ago was Dujardin's say. His explanation for the delay is better than this speculation about "why now"...
to show people what an evil person she is and that this is clearly how she behaves
Also in horse racing the whip should be banned!
Horse racing itself should be outlawed!!! Not just the whips!
Listen it looked really bad right? But see the person that's finally put this footage forward after 4YRS because she's concerned for the animals well why didn't she report this in the immediate aftermath? There's more to this than meets the eye with regards the timing of this!!
Getting good at turning those comments on and off Talksport. Hope the guys getting paid for the extra work
She deserves banning
I wonder how many medals had been won with that whip technique.
I fail to see the connection between training and outright sadism!
There is more to this story than meets the eye. The female who recorded the video is another equestrian rider. She was giggling while recording because she intended to use the video to blackmail Dujardin. She contacted Dujardin within the past few days, threatening to go public with the video if Dujardin did not pay her a ridiculously large amount of money. When Dujardin refused, the blackmailer purposely went public with the video just a few days before the Olympics began. She knew the authorities would respond by removing Dujardin from competing, which would increase the blackmailer's chances of winning a medal and all the publicity and money that would follow.
"increase the blackmailer's chances of winning a medal" ??? How???
It is as normal as an athlete juicing up😂. This is not a sport its something for rich people to do in their spare time. Absolutely no access to it if you are not from the upper-class
A question i wanted to ask, a lot of these equestrians dont actually own the horse they ride and train, they are usually owned by other people, i would like to know what the owners of these horses think, or do they overlook this kind of treatment as long as they are making money
More than just trainers whipping! Rolkur, bits, over extension ! FEI should be ashamed of themselves all round! Sadly everyone is looking up to this standard of "dressage". As well as jumping horses at unreasonable heights pulling them up by the bit to get over the next jump when they are exhausted! Bits whips spurs all deemed fine by calling it "aids". The equestrian world is warped towards tradition and ego it's mostly negative. Sports involving animals at such high stakes should not be supported because the animal always looses, always.
She wasn’t lunging it
I will never watch or follow dressage again!
If it had been reported at the time it happened , it could have saved other horses from being abused. The owner of the horse cared more about revenge on Charlotte than the other horses that Charlotte would train.
It's not a sport , it shouldn't be included in the Olympics. If anything the horse should get the medal.
ALOT OF PEOPLE AROUND THOSE HORSES KNOW/KNEW ABOUT ALL THE ABUSE.
THEY ONLY CARE ABOUT WINNING AND MONEY.
It’s shocking to watch, l wanted to get sick after l watched the video. She didn’t abuse horses only that once, it’s something she’s been doing for a long time, she just got caught this time. It’s the best time to expose her now, punish her for the Olympics
Probably she Dejardin has whipped her own horse 🐴 poor horses. Can not she feel some sympathy for the horses 🐴 ? Can she feel awful, hurting such noble animals.indeed she has A heart so cruel ! An error , Dejardin said ? She whipped the horse 24 times in less than a minute. A video did not emerge ! A lawyer has presented the video to protect the future of horses. Horses have to be protected from Dejardin.
The timing for releasing this video is superb. Good job for maximal impact.
It's the sound of the whip that is being used... not the actual lash.
If that was you and not the horse out there... you would've come away without a single mark on you.
And you're a lot softer and weaker, than a full grown horse.
Every 'working' horse throughout history... was 'broken' ...they were all broken-in.
Just remember... two hundred million farm animals were slaughtered today... for meat, for you to eat.
absolutely disgusting.
She is an aristocrat bourgeois. She'll be well
not that well when animal rights find her!
Not really. She has a posh name but speaks with a typical Essex / East End accent.
If the story had come out before, it would not have made headline news. In 2022 former equestrian and racehorse trainer, Sir mark Todd was suspended from training after a video showing him hitting a horse ten times went viral. At the time of the incident he was a patron of the charity World Horse Welfare.
what is it with these horrible evil people
And that guy got off Scott FREE basically!!! It's the corrupt authorities. Nobody advocating for the animal sake. That's why anything involving animals and money, should be automatically outlawed. Animals are life and they have rights to that life. They are callous & evil, treat the majestic creatures as if they're a punching bag. The problem too is they are around them too much and fame, it all goes to their head where there is no accountability and no self control. They are crazed and psychopathic.
What's more shocking is the Patronising title of this video!!!😡👎
Don’t they have vets at the Olympics that look over horses that compete and disqualify those that look like they have suffered any kind of abuse?
No part of cruelty is never part of training a horse for dressage. The timing of bringing this to public discussion was vindictive as it could be. It should have come to light at the time and the perpetrator given the chance to rehabilitate their control on their stress levels.
She’s definitely finished her career is no more that’s a given it’s too shocking and no one will want her in dressage events. My main thought here is she knows you only tickle the horse as an aide so it understands to pick its legs higher which gives the dancing aide. The ? here is why did they tell on her 4 years on something is definitely amiss here. Brutal!
She's disgusting. Sure, we all believe it was just ONE "error in judgement" - NOT.
Jockeys in races repeatedly whip horses in order to win. What is the difference ? Answer none!!!
So do something about it
Racing and all animals from "sport" & "entertainment" must be outlawed and is LONG overdue!!!
Please remove this unfair sport out of Olympics. Olympics is about human not horse competition.
You are completely wrong relativating. She did this only 1 time to a horse she's not owning? I saw this as daily praxis on low level dressage trainers. Why now? The question should be why not earlier!
4 years is a long time....the timing is totally wrong... the woman who filmed the action is trying to be an Attention Seeker. ... Bang goes a Gold Medal
If there's any justice in the universe, she'll be a dressage horse with a sadistic owner in her next life (come to think of it, all dressage owners/practitioners are sadistic so they all have a lot of bad comeuppance coming to them).
No other duo that can get to the bottom of these Dressage stories like Ohara and Nolan 👊
How can you speak of an INAPPROPRIATE technique? This is cruel treatment of the horse, it is outrageous, and she deserves it if her career is in tatters. Are we supposed to pity the lady???
everyone continues saying 'error in judgement' when in fact she has been abusing horses for years (e.g. bloody mouths). She is not a good human. Period. Quit trying to downplay what she's done and that she isn't the only rider, professional or otherwise, who abuse horses in the name of the sport. Dressage itself is terribly problematic so that should be another discussion.
The poor horse must have been thoroughly terrified. As, probably, are all the horses Dujardin “trains” (read “tortures”) much of the time. What an utterly despicable, heartless creature she must be. The sooner a lot more is found out about this horrendous practice the better.
She abused the horse, this obviously is NOT the first time she has done this. She deserved getting kicked out END OF STORY... 🤨
Why she gritting her teath while smiling. 😂❤
She should be banned from going near horses for 5 years, if this was any other case involving animal abuse a ban would be in place.
Please God "Take pity on any horses in Charlotte's care"
They tried to cover it up but someone knew the inner workings of British trainers 🧐🤔
Also show jumping, the fences these days are huge
😬 How many horses were beaten for her to have all this fame?
🙈 Simply disgusting how she treats animals.
People without empathy...there is no cure
I dont think horses should be whipped, using scare tactics. Surely it is better to use kinder methods of training?!
Imperialist mentality 💂🏻♀️👸🏻🤪🤔
Disgraceful
She just booked her one way ticket to hell
4 years??? She should be banned for life. She followed the horse around the arena!!! What about the rider? Was she trying to kill them, too?
This was not an error of judgement, this looks a usual training method for her. This entire billion dollar industry has to be brought to an end. Let's see whether anything sustainable comes out of this, if the FEI really acts accordingly. I suspect Charlotte Dujardin is not the only top-level rider with such practises.
Whipping horses is normal, unfortunately. Why is this news now? Should it really be a sport?