Remake Recon: The Ladykillers - Original vs. Remake Review
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
- haphazardstuff...
I take a look at the 1955 British black comedy The Ladykillers starring Alec Guinness and the 2004 remake starring Tom Hanks directed by the Coen Brothers.
This is a Remake Recon I did quite awhile ago. The original video was removed, I did some tweaks on it and thought I'd upload it again just because.
#remake #review
Suggestions for future Remake Recons:
"The Time Machine" (1960 & 2002)
"Around The World in 80 Days" (1956 & 2004)
"The Italian Job" (1969 & 2003)
"The Producers" (1968 & 2005)
"Murder on The Orient Express" (1974 & 2017)
“Wayans was annoying.” I really feel like that’s the only characters that Marlon plays. I hear that phrase A LOT in judging the characters Marlon Wayans plays.
Marlon always overdoes it and has to be one of the most overrated actors, especially when he has less famous and more talented brothers (Shawn & Damon) who don't get the same opportunities Marlon does. I can't believe Marlon has gotten to work with all these directors and actors, yet Shawn and Damon haven't.
The Ladykillers 1955 (100% on Rotten Tomatoes). The Ladykillers 2004 (54%). Moral of the story? Don't try and improve on perfection.
Excuse me but Tom Hanks, the fat lady and Pickles and the Gospel music with the excelent location makes an excelent and hilarius film.
One of my favourites of all my
life.
Irma Hall is the Lady’s name🖤
Great movie. Just finished the 2004 version about 5 mins ago. One of my fav movies of all time. Love everything about it.
Had no idea this was a remake. Going to watch that asap!
Tom Hanks was fantastic and I think each character was played perfectly by each actor.
Polarising movie that remake and one that will land up being recognised as an underrated gem. It has its Coenesque charm like the subtle stuff going on in the background and repetition gags.
I love the original, also nice to see Peter Sellers and Herbert Lom together before they had success with the Pink Panther series which is also great.
I quite agree with your assessment
The original is a classic and the Alec Guinness part was originally written for Alistair Sim, who could not do the film. Guinness's performance is a homage to Sim
May I recommend the films Green for Danger and Scrooge (1951) as a prime examples of Alistair Sim's absolute genius 👌
Absolutely right... the remake is abysmal. The script writing and acting in the original is tight and consistent... not so in the later version.
A case of, If it aint broke, don't try to fix it.
I felt the same way after watching the James Cameron movie "Titanic"...
The 1958 movie "A Night to Remember" is far more interesting and accurate in it's telling of this historic event.
I don't get it. What is wrong with some scene changes and some added slapstick? The deep southern yet timeless setting in the '04 one was just mesmerizing. The fat cops, the church sermon , the Gospel singers, the difference between Mrs.Munson's deeply religious life and the life of the ne'er-do-wells just scraping by , the gang of assorted characters, Professor Dorr's love for romantic poetry , are all so quintessentially American. I guess it boils down to which movie you watched first.
I haven't watched the original so can't comment on it. I found the remake to be exceptionally good comedy. It was also worth watching just for the gospel music.
The remake was hilarious.
I could have told you in advance that the remake would reflect the coarseness of our own period. The English elegance of the original is entirely absent. The remake is set in the American South with the token black character. Of course, the remake's gotta crap out with
with the scatological humor just like all movies these days. If you loved the original, then I've done you a great favor. I watched the remake, so you won't have to suffer thru it.
The ‘american version’ is crap. F off america
@@mickeyray3793 There were a lot of black players in the movie. They were all great.
I totally agree. British humor vs American . I think Coen underestimated his ordinance. The original is a forever classic. Unlike this version
One of my favorite movies of all time. The only opinion the reviewer and I agree on is that opinions are subjective.
To think Irma P Hall who plays Mrs Munson won a Jury Prize at the 2004 is Cannes Film Festival for her role. Clearly taste and judgment had evaporated that day
What's a Jury Prize? And are you upset she won or upset that she should have won more?
Saw this movie years ago and still love it. This and Oscar with Sylvester Stallone are my two favorites of all time......right below Lion King.
I like the fact that they didn't stick to the original. Imagine a wily old lady being more of a force to be reckoned with than 5 hardened criminals.
Looool....she had Jesus. She ain't scared o the likes of them.
I saw the remake before I saw the original and I like the original a lot more
Can't believe you didn't find Irma Hall's scenes in this movie hilarious.
Mrs Munson scares me too. Now I am afraid to go to sleep.
I gather that the actors doing the remake made a conscious choice not to see the original first
I guess this is an example of subjective opinion. My friend also tells me this is one of his favorites. I love the Cohen brothers movies; except this one. I hate this film. The way this film turned out it could've just been a Mr Magoo film. "The South"...? Compare O Brother... with this. It is way more authentic with hilarious archetypical characters. Not sloppy....stereotype caricatures? It was poorly done colonel sanders and sista Odell? Zero authenticity. The supporting cast is just not funny the jokes are awkward and would've fit better in a magoo film. If they had treated it with more seriousness the comedy would've come off better and the world felt more authentic.
Why do Americans think its a good idea to remake a classic European film? Its never going to be as good!
The original a classic.The remake was a disgrace in my opinion.
can u review 1958 no time to die aka tank force
You're just repeating whatever you read on the stupid review websites, cause you wanna be "part of the group".
The remake was much much funnier and better made than the original. 99% of people who watched both would agree.
*The remake is much better and more funnier than the original* are you British?
The original was infinitely better. Much darker.
Most remakes are garbage.
Man, I remember this movie from when I was a little one. My gramps had it on tape I think. He had Hella VHS tapes. I vividly remember them CREEPY ass statues, the trash boat, and the music that plays while the older woman walks home from church. Honestly finna give it a re watch