I tell you the other fake videos that I hate. The ones where it starts....day 1 learning piano, then week 1,2,3 etc to a year later and they are playing a really complicated classical piece like some pro classical player. Such B.S. 😂
Or those where this guy is playing a public piano and suddenly another musician appears out of nowhere, casually carrying its own instrument, and they end up “improvising” together.
Most piano progress videos are legit even crazy ones. 1) some people are smart 2) people who record themselves from day ones are by default ultra organised 3) most of the time they record partial pieces, just 20-30s of hard pieces not 3min 4) a lot of them actually post weekly or monthly videos and are fully legit
These videos with numbers on the keys unfortunately also circulate frequently on RUclips shorts. It is a disservice to music and especially to pianists and keyboardists. Laziness and meanness have reached an unacceptable level and, worst of all, disguised as “easy” tools. NEVER USE THIS RIDICULOUS AND WRONG METHOD OF NUMBERS.
OMG! Thanks for exposing this lie, I had watched that here on RUclips, never again! I've learned so much with you guys, I'll stick just with you, thanks a lot.
It's a shame. This is why it's such a breath of fresh air when artists step up and actually perform live. Tori Kelly, Teddy Swims, Jacob Collier. These artists have such talent and seemingly don't fake any of their performances. The performances are always slightly different.
Playing playback has long been common. I remember the hard rock group Europe (80s; known for e.g. "The final countdown"). One of their former guitarists, John Norum, quit the group when he got tired of always just playing playback at the live performance - he wanted to play real live but wasn't allowed. And who has forgotten the 80s group Milli Vanilli...
Because playing the piano is a skill that requires thousands of hours, years, decades, most people dont have the required dedication to master such a skill.
I will just say, I played the piano for my 83 year old mum and she cried. I was totally crap playing something that wouldn't even pass a grade 1 piano exam. Then I spent 4 months practising Happy Birthday every single day on 2 hands and she cried again. Then she started hitting me and I finally got the message. But the crying part was true. She said she never thought of me as musical. It was the hardest I ever worked to give her a birthday gift.
Lewis capaldi not really playing the piano is kinda sad actually, he can't play piano anymore because he has a tourette syndrome. It's so sad to watch because he used to be a great pianist, that's why he tell the audience that he is not playing the piano anymore. Such a humble man
2.3 million likes. Truly insulting 🤦♂️ The Piano teachers face.. that’s the worst acting I’ve ever seen. So much crap online and most Piano/keys tutorials are generally abysmal. The miming badly on stage isn’t anything new 😂
JVKE has admitted to using the transpose button because he is not at the skill level to play it in the key it sounds best sung. But yeah the TikTok promotion is definitely edited to add the detail he can't play in one take.
I can't enjoy the performances at big events, like the Thanksgiving parade, halftime shows, or the Olympics ceremonies anymore, because NONE of it is live.
pretty much any pop show with click/backing tracks has a good amount of this...singers miming, plenty of faking...the unfortunate thing is that's more and more common to have the tracks louder than the musicians playing live...
This happens all the time with musicians on British television. Artist come on and you can see that they are clearly miming as well as the instrumentalists. It is a behaviur that started with Top of the Pops back in the 1960s. It continues today.
@@SimplicityForGood "But why do we let this continue!?" Probably because there's not much we can do about it. Singers that sing and do hip hop on stage are most likely lip syncing to their own songs in order to insure the jumping does not come across in the performance as a result of a hard landing rather than a soft one.
@@SimplicityForGood "no one does this on the street here in New York.. what ya talkin about man?!" Wait, what? You've seen people sing while hip hopping on the street without playback equipment? Whoa?
@@scotttovey are you talking about actual dancers? Sorry but they do not sing to begin with, they dance! For singers and actors they do all sorts of performances ask of the time, including syncing as well sining a Capella while dancing, what is your problem really?
It reminds me of some other videos that show cartoon characters playing piano and then video shows what it actually would sound like based on the keys the cartoon character played. Technically not a tutorial but funny. I am taking actual lessons but would never fake play at a recital. I just practice piece for 6 months prior!
all the things that made the younger generations idiots; the hoe, the mule, the plow, the camera, the radio, the television. the internet, motion pictures, talkies!, pool, automobiles, rock and roll....etc etc etc. The slippery slope of technology brought to you by SATAN er...SEITAN!
OMG, there are SO MANY scammers on youtube. RUclips knows I occasionally watch car videos so it will occasionally spit out one of these "garage find" cars. You know, cars that were supposedly stored in a garage for decades and forgotten about. So these videos will have a title like "This decades old barn find... WILL IT START?" And they all have like 3.5 million views. I GUARANTEE you every one of those videos in a scam. They take some old car, put it in an old garage and cover it will dust, and then film the video. These grifters need to be banned.
Good subject guys! I kinda wondered in the back of my mind... But, when you see a whatever instrument player going viral, especially with a clickbait kinda title something just seems off about the performance.. . I play piano and the pipe organ, and it is painful to know people are giving faux lessons.
About the Jvke thing.. I think he was playing and singing in a different key for real.. then he put the studio track in the video during the editing. Atleast that's what it feels like
At least here in Portugal, in the morning and afternoon shows, when they don't say "live performance", we all know it's recorded, i mean the instruments are always the same, and they're not even plugged in😂😂😂
I wouldn't be that hard for Golden Hour: it's clearly dubbed and he's playing a simpler version but the intervals are the right ones so he may have been playing it live for the shooting but in C instead of E. For the tear, there is an editing glitch so it may have happened but clearly not at this exact moment ;)
The sad part is not that they are faking it but that so many people pay hundreds of hard earned dollars or euros to go and watch them and they go home after the concert with the immense satisfaction of having finally watched their favorite band play "live"...
And you all probably thought Milli Vanilli were the true pioneers of music miming. If you ever watch American Bandstand videos from the 60s and 70s, just about every one of those features artists visually performing along with the TV versions (that’s what they’re called) of their latest hit record.
I've seen lots of these videos where they have the numbers on the notes but they don't make sense but they all at least are playing the correct notes. That video just looks like someone took someone playing piano and then changed the music for the video. Haven't seen anything like that on there thankfully. I don't agree with the numbers method or the fingers used on most of those videos but all the ones I've seen at least are the correct notes being played for the music we're hearing 😀
Oh my god I have been playing keyboard for close to 2 decades now and I DID NOT notice the "Playing for Teacher" one was fake. Major Impostor syndrome 😢
So many artist can not sing so they lip sync....so why so surprised about fake playing your instrument.....its such an insult to us musicians that actually spend hours and hours a day consistently perfecting our craft
It just goes to show you that posers are an empowered lot now. And in this technological landscape people are more concerned with appearance than substance. But being a musician is so much more than just playing to a crowd. The joy of being able to correctly play a piece of music, the creativity that flows in a jam session, the feelings and meaning that music can convey, that cannot be faked. These fake videos cater to a certain audience. But real ability beats BS every day.
As a pianist, I totally get your frustration and expressions.. Like I lost hope after seeing millions of ''likes'' on those
I tell you the other fake videos that I hate. The ones where it starts....day 1 learning piano, then week 1,2,3 etc to a year later and they are playing a really complicated classical piece like some pro classical player. Such B.S. 😂
Or those where this guy is playing a public piano and suddenly another musician appears out of nowhere, casually carrying its own instrument, and they end up “improvising” together.
Most piano progress videos are legit even crazy ones.
1) some people are smart
2) people who record themselves from day ones are by default ultra organised
3) most of the time they record partial pieces, just 20-30s of hard pieces not 3min
4) a lot of them actually post weekly or monthly videos and are fully legit
Hah! Got a good laugh out of this. Kevin and Lisa have great synergy and love seeing them in videos together!
Such a deceitful world 😢
Lisa with the 'I'm not mad, just disappointed' vibes 😅
LOL. Thank you for being genuine! I'm thankful to actually be learning piano from Pianote 😆
This is what happen when you're playing to many guitar heroes thinking that that 4 buttons can play multiple notes.😂
I thinking learning a real guitar is easier then guitar hero 😂
These videos with numbers on the keys unfortunately also circulate frequently on RUclips shorts. It is a disservice to music and especially to pianists and keyboardists. Laziness and meanness have reached an unacceptable level and, worst of all, disguised as “easy” tools. NEVER USE THIS RIDICULOUS AND WRONG METHOD OF NUMBERS.
@@DavidOakesMusic How I did not understand
Sheet music for chord organs in the 1950s and 60s was numbered, as were the organs.
OMG! Thanks for exposing this lie, I had watched that here on RUclips, never again! I've learned so much with you guys, I'll stick just with you, thanks a lot.
Thank you Pianote! Really. Thank you for showing it to me and the world!
It's a shame. This is why it's such a breath of fresh air when artists step up and actually perform live. Tori Kelly, Teddy Swims, Jacob Collier. These artists have such talent and seemingly don't fake any of their performances. The performances are always slightly different.
Thank you for this, I absolutely despise the number videos. Lol
How about those endless ads you get that promise to teach you, a complete novice, how to play the piano to grade 8 standard in just a month...
Not grade 8 standard but Simply Piano works pretty well to learn basics. Not sure what ads you mean
such an ad doesn't exist
I agree, I've been playing the piano for 6 years and finelly I'm taking a grade eight exam at Abrsm.
Thank goodness you highlighted this! 😆 It was so frustrating.
Playing playback has long been common. I remember the hard rock group Europe (80s; known for e.g. "The final countdown"). One of their former guitarists, John Norum, quit the group when he got tired of always just playing playback at the live performance - he wanted to play real live but wasn't allowed. And who has forgotten the 80s group Milli Vanilli...
This is why I don't use TikTok, it's a cancer
Because playing the piano is a skill that requires thousands of hours, years, decades, most people dont have the required dedication to master such a skill.
any skill
I will just say, I played the piano for my 83 year old mum and she cried. I was totally crap playing something that wouldn't even pass a grade 1 piano exam. Then I spent 4 months practising Happy Birthday every single day on 2 hands and she cried again. Then she started hitting me and I finally got the message.
But the crying part was true. She said she never thought of me as musical. It was the hardest I ever worked to give her a birthday gift.
Good job.
Lewis capaldi not really playing the piano is kinda sad actually, he can't play piano anymore because he has a tourette syndrome. It's so sad to watch because he used to be a great pianist, that's why he tell the audience that he is not playing the piano anymore. Such a humble man
2.3 million likes. Truly insulting 🤦♂️ The Piano teachers face.. that’s the worst acting I’ve ever seen. So much crap online and most Piano/keys tutorials are generally abysmal. The miming badly on stage isn’t anything new 😂
Stephen Ridley ads must be stopped.
JVKE has admitted to using the transpose button because he is not at the skill level to play it in the key it sounds best sung. But yeah the TikTok promotion is definitely edited to add the detail he can't play in one take.
I can't enjoy the performances at big events, like the Thanksgiving parade, halftime shows, or the Olympics ceremonies anymore, because NONE of it is live.
You mean like a Taylor Swift concert?
Man, this is sad! Thanks for sharing
It's like a movie clip, bands don't play the instruments, because it's a recorded previously song! haha
pretty much any pop show with click/backing tracks has a good amount of this...singers miming, plenty of faking...the unfortunate thing is that's more and more common to have the tracks louder than the musicians playing live...
This happens all the time with musicians on British television. Artist come on and you can see that they are clearly miming as well as the instrumentalists. It is a behaviur that started with Top of the Pops back in the 1960s. It continues today.
But why do we let this continue!?
@@SimplicityForGood
"But why do we let this continue!?"
Probably because there's not much we can do about it.
Singers that sing and do hip hop on stage are most likely lip syncing to their own songs in order to insure the jumping does not come across in the performance as a result of a hard landing rather than a soft one.
@@scotttovey no one does this on the street here in New York.. what ya talkin about man?!
@@SimplicityForGood
"no one does this on the street here in New York.. what ya talkin about man?!"
Wait, what?
You've seen people sing while hip hopping on the street without playback equipment?
Whoa?
@@scotttovey are you talking about actual dancers? Sorry but they do not sing to begin with, they dance! For singers and actors they do all sorts of performances ask of the time, including syncing as well sining a Capella while dancing, what is your problem really?
Great video.
So many fake players ... so little time to see them all !!! 😢😢😢
It reminds me of some other videos that show cartoon characters playing piano and then video shows what it actually would sound like based on the keys the cartoon character played. Technically not a tutorial but funny. I am taking actual lessons but would never fake play at a recital. I just practice piece for 6 months prior!
Add these fake pianists to the legion of fake guitarists. 🙄
Kevin is so true to himself and honest! Cute! And, well, just cute too.
Maybe she's crying because she was a participant in a horrible scam .
This is why we can't have nice things
Tik tok is not a nice thing bro
@@Jan-lj6ej nothing nice about tiktok
@@niiii_niiii I never said there was?
@@Jan-lj6ej okay so
Thankyou for pointing the scammers out. I fell for two of those identified.
@1:25 when he was fingering "faded" and the sound was descending while his finger ascended from the d key to e key got me laughing like a hyena.
My God. This is unbelievable.
Same crap happens with many "show off" guitarists.
been a while, i think this is motivation to get back to the keyboard again😂😂😂😂😂😂
I’ve been thinking that too-
Tic tok is making the younger generations idiots.
I mean, all generations already seem to be idiots at this point, some exceptions aside lol
@@richardsummers2161 It's true! I've never used this terrible social network and I don't intend to.
Very well said
you mean more than they already are lol!
all the things that made the younger generations idiots; the hoe, the mule, the plow, the camera, the radio, the television. the internet, motion pictures, talkies!, pool, automobiles, rock and roll....etc etc etc. The slippery slope of technology brought to you by SATAN er...SEITAN!
OMG, there are SO MANY scammers on youtube. RUclips knows I occasionally watch car videos so it will occasionally spit out one of these "garage find" cars. You know, cars that were supposedly stored in a garage for decades and forgotten about.
So these videos will have a title like "This decades old barn find... WILL IT START?"
And they all have like 3.5 million views.
I GUARANTEE you every one of those videos in a scam. They take some old car, put it in an old garage and cover it will dust, and then film the video. These grifters need to be banned.
Damn! I've been blaming my kids for somehow moving the piano keys around.
I'm 67, and I saw this happening when I was a teenager. Today it seem the young just believe everything they are told and hear is true.
In the Golden Hour clip, he's playing maybe one layer of the music or at a different key maybe.
I am laughing throughout this video, because Lisa looks so confused 😂😂😂😂😂
OMG, Lisa’s reactions are the best! 😂😂
Brilliant! I always laugh when I see those tutorial videos.
Thank you for sharing your talent.😊
Good subject guys! I kinda wondered in the back of my mind... But, when you see a whatever instrument player going viral, especially with a clickbait kinda title something just seems off about the performance..
. I play piano and the pipe organ, and it is painful to know people are giving faux lessons.
I am so appalled by what I just saw!! Integrity is everything ppl!! It's what art is all about!! 🎹🎼🎶🎵
Thank you so much!
About the Jvke thing.. I think he was playing and singing in a different key for real.. then he put the studio track in the video during the editing. Atleast that's what it feels like
Nah buddy replicate what he played it's dogshit
I play and sing live, and yet I struggle to eke out a meager income doing music. Signed musicians make hundreds of thousands of dollars and fake it.
The irony is that as I am watching this video, RUclips has suggested me some of these fake videos and stories to watch next.
Lisas reactions exellent 😂
0:37 what! That is super fake!😂
At least here in Portugal, in the morning and afternoon shows, when they don't say "live performance", we all know it's recorded, i mean the instruments are always the same, and they're not even plugged in😂😂😂
Imagine I have been following those guys everyday, it’s easy to be fooled especially when you’re a beginner like me😢😢
I wouldn't be that hard for Golden Hour: it's clearly dubbed and he's playing a simpler version but the intervals are the right ones so he may have been playing it live for the shooting but in C instead of E. For the tear, there is an editing glitch so it may have happened but clearly not at this exact moment ;)
I deleted TikTok because I always felt it insulted my intelligence and I'm pretty stupid.
for sure they didn't take the pianote course.
😊😊😂
It's so true, Tim tok is fake fake fake!
TikTok and Fake? Tautology!
this is why i have perfect pitch but you should never trust tiktok fake tutorials ever again in my opinion!
Whew! I wondered why I couldn’t get it to sound the same. 😊
I was always tricked by these fake tutorials!😂
How about all the fake 'spontaneous' singing videos in kitchens or parkinggarages, which are clearly pre-recorded and pitch corrected?
And now I’ll show you how to make an entire Thanksgiving dinner in 12 minutes, using only 2 ingredients.
My mom and grandmother read this and laughed so hard. 😂😂😂😂😂
Blows my mind!
Just highlights a new phenomenon among people: "Fake it till you make it" regardless of whom you may be deceiving. In very poor taste
These is how to fake piano 🎹 skills. You are right gonna hands be playing this keep repeating this.
The sad part is not that they are faking it but that so many people pay hundreds of hard earned dollars or euros to go and watch them and they go home after the concert with the immense satisfaction of having finally watched their favorite band play "live"...
How does one get on this show I WANT TO BE A PART OF THIS
I feel like I was just told Santa isn’t real
Please make a tutorial on Dr no James bond theme
Whell that was emotionally damaging🎹🎶
Lisa and Kevin experienced severe emotional damage during the filming of this video.
could you pls do a tutorial on another of ludovico einaudi's songs, like waterways or fly etc.?
Hi pianote what do I need to do to play any songs on the piano❤
Jvke is the most surprising, watched it from youtube short but at least it made me wanted to learn to play keyboard 😅
1:36 my high school teacher always use whiteboard pen to write on it😂
4.07 she's crying off thinking how bad a teacher she was
As a pianist I can see instantly that these are really terrible notes. How awful! Thankfully the people I follow are legit.
And you all probably thought Milli Vanilli were the true pioneers of music miming. If you ever watch American Bandstand videos from the 60s and 70s, just about every one of those features artists visually performing along with the TV versions (that’s what they’re called) of their latest hit record.
The thumb nail piano thing, I have seen it on Pinterest!
Hilarious. Can feel your pain, K and L... :D
I've seen lots of these videos where they have the numbers on the notes but they don't make sense but they all at least are playing the correct notes. That video just looks like someone took someone playing piano and then changed the music for the video. Haven't seen anything like that on there thankfully. I don't agree with the numbers method or the fingers used on most of those videos but all the ones I've seen at least are the correct notes being played for the music we're hearing 😀
Av always tried to follow these fake videos and got it wrong despite that ama a beginner but I went far away wrong...
Wow. Now i am also gonna wonder if a keyboardist is playing or not.
Oh my god I have been playing keyboard for close to 2 decades now and I DID NOT notice the "Playing for Teacher" one was fake. Major Impostor syndrome 😢
So many artist can not sing so they lip sync....so why so surprised about fake playing your instrument.....its such an insult to us musicians that actually spend hours and hours a day consistently perfecting our craft
You say tik tok is all a lie… wait that’s new…😂
Please make a tutorial of Bryant Barnes’ I’d rather pretend
this hurt to watch
Shame that people even bother with TikTok. I will never see the appeal.
I guess I don't need to watch Pianote anymore even though I did learn Music Box Dancer from Lisa. 🙂
These are just scammers, not artists! Thanks!
My ears are bleeding listening to this 😂I’m crying g to 😂
anyone who even pulls up the TikTok app is just adding to the problem....
Man I didnt expect at all that the Golden hour vid was fake! fk
It just goes to show you that posers are an empowered lot now. And in this technological landscape people are more concerned with appearance than substance. But being a musician is so much more than just playing to a crowd. The joy of being able to correctly play a piece of music, the creativity that flows in a jam session, the feelings and meaning that music can convey, that cannot be faked. These fake videos cater to a certain audience. But real ability beats BS every day.
Lisa innocence is ruined