Mixed reaction to Hlophe's nomination to JSC
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 июл 2024
- There's been mixed reaction to the nomination of MK Party Chief Whip John Hlophe, to sit on the Judicial Service Commission.
The impeached former Western Cape Judge president is accused of trying to influence Constitutional Court justices, in a matter pertaining to former president Jacob Zuma.
Judges Matter researcher Mbekezeli Benjamin and African Legal Practitioners Association chairperson S'the Mbhele discuss this further.
Tune into Newzroom Afrika DStv channel 405 for more.
If Dr Hlope qualify to be member of parliament then nothing stop him to serve at any cometees.
Leave Dr Hlophe alone
@@donaldchikudo1521 why chikudo?
Imagine a judge impeached by grade 12
Can u imagine 😢
Leave alone Dr Hlophe.
Hlophe is impeached as a judge, not as a politician. His role in parly and JSC is of a politician. Please mahn
@@GNK245 MAHN!!! HOWS LIFE IN JAMAICA MAHN? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Yhey kwedini phuma ku Dr Hlophe 😮
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Kwedini ndini 😂
What if Dayton MacKenzie was nominated to the JSE? Would we hear all this noise about his past criminal?
No.but Dr Hlophe is a threat to the system that's why there's a noise
Puppets young man of stellenboch
Thanks say it again i see a sell put young man dooming other young one
When he is talking out of his nose, mamina a tswe Kae. Spineless young man.
Your insults reveal that you fear black people who think.
HLOPE OUTCLASS ALL CANDIDATES IN ALL LEVELS.
He does, he is brilliant but also disgraced and found to have been dishonest.
Absolutely! Dr Hlophe is an intellectual on par. No one can match him there.
Dr Hlophe the well educated man 🎉🎉
This Benjamin tried his luck at becoming the Public Protector nd failed dismally, he was the weakest candidate
😂😂 weakest
Mr Mbhele is 100 percent correct , Mr Hlope is a member of parliament is got a right to be there he is not jugde
Hlophe is not sitting in JSC as a judge, he is sitting there as an Mp from MK party,. You took away his title, now can you let him fuction as a politician
Hi Duduzile , how u doing today ? Hlophe was found guilty of asking other judges to rule in zumas favor.. enough said..
Fusegi wena slima@@dilochetty9332
Ramaphosa is our loving President. Matras dollars.
He is called Dr John Hlophe not just John Hlophe. Let this sink
impeached
Hlope is good enough
Dr John Hlophe ❤😂
What was John hlophe called before now? Judge John hlophe. Let that sink in
He is a normal human being like U and I. And he is not my Dr, so he is hlophe the Impeached😂😂😂
Ramaphosa's ethical standing is in question as well "Section 89 Independent panel" but he's the President and no questions are asked.... this selective intellectualism.
This man he hates the Mk that's soo much to say Dr Hlophe does not qualify
These selective ethical nonsense annoys me,
The system doesn't want Dr John Hlophe. But they're ok with Ramadollar and Groenevald
Coconuts are annoying
He told his elder to read the constitution where do they make coconut like that
Black people must just stop supporting rubbish; how can John Hlophe be fit to recommend the appointment of judges when he himself is not fit to be a judge?
What law he broke? bcs he was removed for political reasons @@MzamoAdoons372
@MzamoAdoons372 He is very fit to be a judge, we do not care about what Zille boys decided in that parliament
100 %fit
AAAAH.......Benjamin is this what you were going to illustrate at Public Protectors Office if at all you were successful to occupy the office ...remember you were one of the most dismal failures during the interview ...so please give Judge Hlophe space we want the nation to benefit from such intellectuals blessed with such wisdom....unless he is a threat to you please disengage
Hlophe was impeached for political reasons 😂Benjamin is confused by soros Oppenheimers silver
Benjamin is a beneficiary of the white system... He works for UCT, what do you expect!??😅😂
😂
@@thabisonsibande7946 so does your president
Is phalaphala ethical and suitable to be the president of SA . Benjamin is paving his way to the highest office under dollarman. Unfortunately, dollarman's power is coming to an end.He is quoting the constitution that is biased
Let that sink in. Dr MJ Hlophe is in at the JSC. These clowns are late.
Who's morals and who's ethics?
This country is sold
This young man called Benjamin is an embarrassment to black professionals.
This Benjamin hate blacks he knows nothing but just hate .n my question is what dd he say abwt zondos failure
N this Benjamin he forgets that hlophe been suspended for just to defend ramaphosa on phala phala
Ithengiwe lantwana Benjamin
@@bonganemathewntuli7967 He is on the pay role of wrong people. Now they are using him to destroy black professionals
Huge disappointment
Bathong, 😊Dr Hĺophe is not a judge because he was impeached but he is a member of parliament and with PHD in Law
That's why people commit suicide, they do it as a result of what follows after one has persecuted someone else through character assassination, name tarnishing and other horrors, which can bring suicide to the side of the victims or victim family members as well!
Mr Benjamin tell us your credentials and qualifications that gives you the authority of objecting Judge Hlophe to serve on JSC? Justice Hlophe is a suitable candidate to serve on JSC.
Can U tell me the reason for hlophes impeachment please
At least we have another lawyer no more ubuxoki balomfana waseStellenbosch
Self hate
Bring Judge Hlophe to speak for himself don't gossip him...
With level of experience he will crush this boy of Rupert together with captured minds of JSC
@@lulamakumkati2702 😂😂😂😂😂
Says Superman
Bangabona ama simba chips emini ka Bha !!! 😂😂😂😂😂😂
he is not coming as a judge, he is a member of the parliamnet
Member of parliament, what a joke , all there to steal our monies again and again. No difference , no change. Please remember they r human beings like us and r not GODS
It's Dr Hlope please...
Wonder where, The Impeached Man, got his doctorate from . Hope not from Shoprite
Parliament is led by your darling Rama the most ethical person on earth
Rama is not leading the parliament but is led by Thoko Didiza who is the Speaker
@@mafolokgaogelostimela3080 who leads Didiza politically?
Which ethics are you referring to Benjamin? Deontological/ ontological/virtue ethics---
Didiza asked ethics questions being the ordinary member, hlophe is there to ask legal questions. Mbekezeli is not honest with himself.
Thank you Mr Mbele for the clarification
This one is captured
They dont want Hlophe to lead MK
He is party parliamentary leader and not Chief whip.
This was politically motivated.
Imagine the whole judge impeached by grade 12
😢😢😢😢
😂
and approve by alawyer😀😀😀😀
A former Judge President with an axe to grind what could possibly go wrong.
Judges matter proxies 😂are not an authority on any matter
I don't, I want to ask this., the decision to impeach Dr Hlophe, was it a legal one or political one? Was it a decision of a court or a hybrid(political/legal) process
It was a political decision
Benjamin Dr Hlophe never done anything wrong don't be confused by minority you are an African man but you serving the white skin in our land please don't do that you should be proud of your country we need Dr Hlophe for his huge knowledge someone who will deal with those who looted our Land and its people
Politic is unethical.
Go JUDGES MATTER! You will succeed!
😂DR hlophe, so it won't work his not going there to be a judge he is like malema so what is the cry for
We want him there
For those eager to engage in moral grandstanding, give us a break. How's this for morals: Wouter Basson has been employed as a cardiologist at not one, but at least two Mediclinic facilities in the Western Cape. For those unfamiliar with him, do yourself a favor and check out documentaries on 'Project Coast.'
How many of us black people have boasted about the class status we feel after being treated at a Mediclinic facility? With an establishment that hires such individuals, Basson never lost income. He's their hero. So, why should Hlophe lose his income for morals? What morals, exactly?
Mr Mbhele i salute you baba
How can someone found guilty of gross misconduct be suitable for this role.
Mr MbeleI concur 💯 the integrity and the impeachment passed makes him questionable for the quality role expected in the JSC,no subjectivity but objectivity as a preferable for the new dawn for all SAcans wlho yearn for better era in this neo GNU,pls,God help Mzanzi.
Benjamin is absolutely correct 👌
The same people who want Hlophe are happy to support Zuma. That says it all.😢
Do you want us to support who
@victordihangoane9664 maybe not openly corrupt people? 🤔
The Constitution in Section 178 is silent(moot)in this regard.The impeachment of Dr Hlophe was political and unfortunately and unfortunately the MKParty used a legal loophole in the Constitution to push a political matter.
His impeachment made him not a judge anymore and section 47(1)of the Constitution provides that every citizen who is qualified to vote for the National Assembly is eligible to be a member of the National Assembly and if his party feels that he is the person to serve their interests in the JSC,why not?
It is a matter of morality and unfortunately in Law,there's that thin line,as values,morality and religion are not necessarily embraces by Law.
You have ZiZi Kodwa MP who is facing corruption charges in the same National Assembly!!!
Well explained
We don't have judges
Who is earthcal in that parliament?
😂😂😂😂 This cult called media
Crooks always know the rules, but cannot tell the difference between right and wrong.
Whatever he did while he was judge is now irrelevant ..fact is he is NOT a judge anymore ...he is allowed by law to do whatever he wants.
This attitude is what has made politicians do as they have over the past 30 years. Carry on supporting these idiots and we will get nowhere. Doctor, what a joke😂😂😂😂
@SanjayKaidiots unyokondhai-pp3hg
Some are devoid of morals and just cannot understand ethics and integrity.
Separation of powers other arm of the state cannot interefere with another finish and klaar
This clueless young Oppenheimer puppets.
Is that the best you have😂😂😂
This boy Benjamin is captured why he never said anything and abwt what found of ramaphosa
Why hate Dr
Good people, the crab has failed to teach her crab babies to straight forward.
He is Dr John Hlophe. Not just John Hlophe show some respect guys please
Thank you it is only a momination.....
President is not ethical phalaphala
MK party wants him there , people who voted , Did you vote for them benji ?
Benjamin is 100% correct. Pending case or not is immaterial
Dr John Hlophe ,I don't know why journalist like always forget his title.
Ethical principles remain so elusive to most of these self-proclaimed 'Pan Africanists', the question of morality and ethics is the reason we flounder despite our colourful qualifications and capacity to carry out our respective roles in our spheres of influence.
It's so sad that Benjamin can be so biased let alone against Jugde John Hlophe. Mbekezeli should work hard to be promoted by University of Cape town
ANC ivukile emaqandeni manje
Us as the people we want Judge Hlophe to be a member of the JSC. What is unethical is our judiciary system that is captured by stellies thungs.
Little Man what did hlophe do. We all know he's impeachment was political
He try to defend hlope this clear these laws in South Africa if kusekho abantu abafana
This one it's talk a truth
We dont care what media says now because we know which side they are on so why bother believing anything. Even if they were correct now that they are compromised we dont take anuthing they say seriously in SA. Those that do are those who benefit out of this noisy media
This co-opted boy is forever on Hlophe's case🤔
No legal impediment...facts facts facts...they are just pushing a narrative of their bosses who are not there in parliament!! Ethics are subjective...
Sickening of these parties Everyday is a new eposide.Its a disgrace and disguisting
.The citizens have voted for them and instead of serving the population their are fighting among themselves .and this is happening everydayThat shows the circus never stopped .We the citizens are paying them for nothing .We not getting our service from them .Every day is the same. old storey .Digraceful!!!!!!?????.
Consider this: would we allow a police officer under investigation for corruption to lead an anti-corruption task force? Or a surgeon facing malpractice suits to head a medical board? The principle is the same. The appeal process does not erase the serious findings of misconduct that have already been established. Until and unless the Constitutional Court overturns these findings, the judge's involvement in judicial appointments remains highly inappropriate and undermines public trust in our judicial system. The Judicial Service Commission must prioritize maintaining the highest ethical standards and protecting the integrity of the judiciary above all else.
DA allowed & is protecting ramaphosa from his crimes.🤷♀️ there is no fairness in this country
But we did allow a president with a Phalaphala question mark to lead our country 😂
@nonkonzonyikiza597 obviously a wrong does not make a right.
@@fhelorosesmedia5954 you are correct
Unethical is ramaphosa who suspend those investigating him
Xoli's hatred of pro-black people makes him fail to recognise Dr Hlophe as Dr.
I don't agree with the gentleman from judges matters.
The fact that she is a member of parliament, he qualifies to sit in any committees.
Judges matter senior researcher? researching what
This young man is wild
anything that have Zuma print is shaking the white establishment, Xoli Dr Hlophe is a leader of mk in parliament no chief wip
He was elected to JSC
Ignore the TROLLS here!
This country has a serious problem. It produces lots of certificated people than educated people. When are people going to receive education that equips them to read or listern to content with analytical skills?
@Azaniabrands educated or not, people choose to be subjective when engaging on issues. I've seen it with highly educated people too.
This man it's a loyal
I think Benjamin is Xhosa
is the jsc superior than parliament or much important the parliament enact laws so Dr Hlophe should not participate
Zuma out for revenge and the people still suffer 😢😢😢😢😢
😂😂😂 Chest pain in stelenbosh and its puppets like xoli
Is Judge Hlophe qualified to be a member of Parliament? If Yes, why should his rights to participate in JSC as a member of Parliament be limited.
He sounds like Thuli Mandonsela 😅
In his speech before the legal society John Hlophe said Pan Africanism should be a vehicle to restore the monarchy, that's an aspiration 👏🏾👏🏾 👌🏾 BUT THIS IS A SUBJUGATIVE STANCE, WILL IT ACHIEVE ITS OBJECTIVE ???? 🤔🤔🤔 l THINK l'll NEED TO REVIEW THIS VERSION OF PAN-AFRICANISM ; Ingathi in the next 100 years isazocim' i results board !!!