The Jones Act is Drowning Puerto Rico
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 май 2023
- The Jones Act is a maritime law, passed in 1920, that has increased the cost of living, worsened poverty, and prolonged the recovery of Puerto Ricans from the devastating impact of Hurricanes Maria and Fiona.
The Jones Act, otherwise known as Section 27 of The Merchant Marine Act of 1920, requires all U.S. cargo transported by ship between U.S. ports to be carried on U.S.-flagged vessels built, owned, and operated by U.S. citizens.
Contact your elected officials: www.usa.gov/elected-officials
SEC. 27 of the Merchant Marine Act: “That no merchandise shall be transported by water, or by land and water, on penalty of forfeiture thereof, between points in the United States, including Districts, Territories, and possessions thereof embraced within the coastwise laws, either directly or via a foreign port, or for any part of the transportation, in any other vessel than a vessel built in and documented under the laws of the United States and owned by persons who are citizens of the United States, or vessels to which the privilege of engaging in the coastwise trade is extended by sections 18 or 22 of this Act: Provided, That this section shall not apply to merchandise transported between points within the continental United States, excluding Alaska, over through routes heretofore or hereafter recognized by the Interstate Commerce Commission for which routes rate tariffs have been or shall hereafter be filed with said commission when such routes are in part over Canadian rail lines and their own or other connecting water facilities: Provided further, That this section shall not become effective upon the Yukon river until the Alaska Railroad shall be completed and the Shipping Board shall find that proper facilities will be furnished for transportation by persons citizens of the United States for properly handling the traffic.”
@CasualNavigation @americanmaritimepartnershi6404 @TimBatSea @wgowshipping @CamoteXPrez13rcp @marineinsight @usnavalwarcollege @nytimes @TheNewYorkFed @forbes @politico @markets @thehill @harvardlawschool @cnbctelevision @theatlantic @washingtonpost @unctad @undp
#separatebutequal #justice #notaxationwithoutrepresentation #Statehood #Independence
Poverty can be reduced by letting the markets work, at least in this case. Repeal the Jones Act!
💯
Yes, but then the u.s.a. won't get paid, and your lord forbid we can't let that happen ¡
While some people may view Puerto Rico primarily as a resource, it is crucial to remember that the people of Puerto Rico are individuals with their own rights, identities, and aspirations. It is important to approach any discussion or evaluation of Puerto Rico's role in the United States with sensitivity and respect for the people who call the island home.
💯 thank you for the heartfelt and important comment!
Wow! That speech did so much for the lil island on a ball and chain.. But thanx.
Puerto Rico es Nuestra Patria. It is our homeland.
It's along the lines that Thomas Sowell discovered when he did a study about minimum wage in PR
Thank you for educating
Thank you for watching! More videos on Puerto Rico to come this year, please subscribe 🌟
UNFORTUNATLEY, THE GOVERNMENT OF PUERTO RICO HAS BEEN COMPLACENT ABOUT THIS AND HAS NOT DEALT WITH IT. WE NEED MORE PEOPLE WHO WILLING TO STAND FOR JUSTICE. THE PROBLEM WITH THIS STATEMENT IS THAT "MONEY ALWAYS PREVAIL"
Why has the Puerto Rican government been complacent?
The government and just about all the politicians in Puerto Rico are in Kahoot. They are making money by selling just about everything on the island. A majority of them are corrupt and do not care what happens to Puerto Rico! Wake up and start doing something about it like not selling your land! Look at Hawaii! It's coming to Peurto Rico! The natives will become poorer! It's by design!
@@thenearhorizonbecause last time anyone tried anything like Pedro Campos and other tries before that, we simply got shut down by AMERIKKKAN GOOBERMENT! Meaning, too many scared sheep! THEY DONT LOVE THE LAND ENOUGH TO SACRIFICE THEIR LIVES! 😢
Jones act is drowning Puerto Rico there’s more to it than that look at the politics and the way they run the island I was born and raised there lived there for 19 years. Takes one all almost all day to get a drivers license I figured by now they would’ve fixed it fast forward, watch some of these programs on RUclips. It still hasn’t changed.
Hawaii and Puerto Rico should stand together on this subject! It’s the root cause of many issues. We can start here and unite to abolish this Jim-crow (Jones) Act.
In early 2000, Hawai'i, Alaska and Puerto Rico reunited to ask USA congress for the abolitionof Jones Act. Guess what... things got worse for all three.
@laborincana4490 in what ways?
@@thenearhorizon There was a study of a federal military agency. This " agency" concluyen that it would be " pernicious" for USA and the mercantil marine to abolición this JA, would recomend its continuation. The taxes weren't increased, the internacional merchan
@@thenearhorizon sorry couldn't complete my answer. El mercado internacional fue cerrado para Puerto Rico. We can no longer sell anything nor buy anything.. Internacional stuff is bought by USA merchants and they resell to us. Its difficult for me to explain this, I'm no economist. But I've seen our most prestigios business languish and dissapear after our attempt to eliminate JA. Prices are so high here, even higer than in the mainland. That military agency is the one behind la marina mercante and JA. Somos nosotros quienes mantenemos el negocio de la MM , JA y esa agencia. No lo digo yo. Lo dijeron ellos.
😢 ay ay ay
Puerto Rico needs to reunify with Spain. In 1898 Puerto Rico was richer than the Canary Islands and debt-free, had 16 congressmen and 2 senators from the Island in the Spanish Parliament., Puerto Rico was Spain's first autonomous province and had its own currency.
Lmaoooo
España no nos quiere. Pasa la página. El resto de las americas son independientes y tú aquí viviendo en los 1850s
@@LeftOfBori Las independencias no arrancan y son monigotes de los norteamericanos, siguen en la pobreza y la miseria, mira nuestros vecinos Cuba y Rep Dominicana. Tu vives en la fantasía de que las independencias son lo mejor cuando ha sido un fracaso estrepitoso donde unas elites conectadas a Estados Unidos se roban el pais y dejan al pueblo en la miseria o terminan en el infierno del Comunismo. Ni Islas Canarias ni Islas Baleares desean la suerte de Cuba o Rep Dominicana.
I would prefer that over statehood with the US, if those were the only two options, we would have more autonomy and we could keep our culture, we are more like Spain than the US, the US is a multicultural union, adding Puerto Rico will just cause more Non-Puerto Ricans with more buying power to buy up all the land and turn the island into Hawaii 2.0. But still I prefer Independence, the Spain reunification movement is very very small, they don't even have their own political party, its just people meeting in small zoom meetings and Facebook group chats. And there hasn't been any big push in Spain to take back Puerto Rico. Plus Spain has been going through some economic problems and with how they treat Independence supporters like in Catalonia, it will be 1948 gag laws all over again but with Spain in control.
@@jlm3744 I think the political party will eventually come, Spain is now allowing Puerto Ricans to recover their Spanish citizenship under a new law (look for the video ''Así he conseguido la nacionalidad española y europea - Puerto Rico'' ).
Puerto Rico is such an amazing place. I'm glad it's part of the US but I am saddened by how it, and its people, are treated as not fully part of the US. The disparities in hurricane relief, particularly after Maria, is appalling. I support repealing the Jones Act.
Thank you for sharing your positive comment. We hope you subscribe! We’ve got a lot more Puerto Rican content coming soon 🌟
Puerto Rico need to become an independent island to be able and move forward.
Why ?
@@thenearhorizon What part of Independent you don't understand? 🤔
@@JJ-nq3ll I understand independence, I'm just wondering why you think its the best option
@@thenearhorizon let’s start up by the Royal Decree 1815 from Spain towards P. Rico & Cuba. What has P. Rico gained under the dominion from 🇺🇸? Citizenship at what cost? Been drafted since WW1 to be killed over 🇺🇸 interest! Jones Act, in no way benefits the people on the island. P. Rico has the capacity to be an independent and prosperous island but only if they wanted.
Should US citizens (that can vote) literally call for abolition of the Jones Act & Statehood for PR? Whats the request when contacting representatives?
Yes 🙌🏻 just that. Please request from your senator that the US abolish or AMMEND the jones act due to the unequal impacts to places like Alaska, Puerto Rico, and Hawaii.
As for statehood…Puerto Rico is divided about that issue. But we believe they should have the right to determine their future, whether that is statehood, independence, or to stay a commonwealth. But as of today, the power lies with congress to decide…unfortunately.
Since you don't understand what the Jones Act is meant to do, it would be better to make an exemption for PR.
After seeing how few people were willing to do the leg work after the hurricane, independence would mean another Haiti.
Well I think 🧐 it’s pass time that Puerto Rico 🇵🇷 do a March on Washington, and their local government. It’s time for a change.
Have Puerto Ricans organized on that scale before?
@@thenearhorizon the Fuerzas Armadas de Liberación Nacional Puertorriqueña (FALN) carried out more than 130 bombings in the United States between 1974 and 1983. does that count? puerto rican nationalists in 1949 began preparing an armed revolt. in october 1950, uprisings were staged in the towns of Ponce, Mayagüez, Naranjito, Arecibo, Utuado , San Juan, and Jayuya. "The response was swift. The colonial government immediately declared martial law, and sent US National Guard troops, stationed on the island, to root out the barricaded rebels. In Jayuya, where the insurrection was strongest, Air National Guard P-47 fighter/bombers were sent on air strikes against nationalist-held neighborhoods, destroying over half the buildings in town. Canales and the Jayuya rebels held out for three days before surrendering." this prompted puerto rican nationalist sympathizers in the u.s to attempt the assassination of then president harry truman
A march? We literally shot up Congress. We won’t get results by asking pretty please
you don't need blood shed! what you need is strong political opposition in congress towards making puerto rico free! I believe that this is the time to make puerto rico free! because the iron of politic is starting again to get red hot! I believe if trump wins you have a great chance to set puerto rico free! and given the statue of joining the free market! plus her coast line is a gate way to the shipping lane industry from south north east and west, puerto rican are a very smart people, but there only true down fall is there pride! must not think separate but think in unity as one person!
Why do you believe Trump would set Puerto Rico free?
I'm sorry but without the jones act, those of us who work in the maritime industry will be taking a paycheck cut or worse
So we kill the colony in hawii Puerto Rico because people need the job. Removing the Jones act would help out economy as a whole including the mainland
@@Jumbo37279 no, I'm a American marine engineer for example. Why do you think marine engineers in the us get paid more on average than other countries? Its because of the jones act. Same thing applies to us deck officers.
@@xmzru Right, the cost your services are artificially inflated because of the Jones Act. The country as a whole would be better off without the Jones Act. Countless peer-reviewed studies and publications agree. But your companies and unions keep paying the politicians to keep things expensive for us.
@@lilmanluu and it’s not just about our wages, you also have to look at it through a national security standpoint. Ships going from US port to US port having to be built in the US and be US flagged and US crewed is a great idea, especially with today’s geopolitics. I mean, China already owns a scary amount of us ports. Imagine if now we chinese ships running around our waters instead of us ships. Not to mention, in times of crisis, mariners play a key role in transporting military personnel and equipment overseas.
Another perspective I would like to point out. The Jones Act secures the critical movement of goods within the US. Without this law, foreign-owned companies could influence the flow of domestic goods and resources, threatening thousands of American jobs throughout our shipbuilding and maritime workforces, and foreign governments could gain even more undue leverage over our economy (especially with countries like china or russia). Also since we’re talking about the economy here, do you realize how much of a impact taking away the jones act would do the maritime industry and the us economy?? The us maritime industry employs over 650,000 thousand Americans and contributes $150 billion to our economy.
@@xmzru first it's about your job ,then it's about your salary ,then it isn't about your job , it's about *national security* ,as if the USA was the only country on earth that cared about national security .
Jones act has nothing to do with foreign countries owning ports or not,you lied.
the ships you build are piles of garbage ,you have ruined all of the USA for your little salaries
If the USA abolished the jones act ,it would gain FAR MORE than 150 billion dollars and 650000 jobs ,considering how expensive shipping got because of your selfishness
You realize Porto Rico is an Island that is outside normal shipping channels. And just what we want low quality ships with Low paid sailors with low safety standards.
Huh?
@@thenearhorizon What I am say is,the US companies are on a set schedule with a well-paid crew, on a ship with good living and safety standards. the island is also a small market and may not be worth a foreign flagged vessel to make regular stops. I am willing to bet Crowly has a fair number of islanders employed too.
This is sad.
agreed!
This sounds a lot like the people who wanted Roosevelt Roads shut down then complained about the loss of jobs and the giant debt in the economy.
How so
@@thenearhorizon in the short term this would be a small boon. That would be until trade changes and less ships would visit(it does often). While the jones act is not perfect it does guarantee trade. Pushing to amend rather than remove might be a better tactic. Removing it would be shooting oneself in the foot much like the removal of rosey roads.
Thanks for sharing JC! We actually agree that the Jones Act should be amended. Our call to action at the end of the video is this:
"If you live in the US, you have the power to alleviate poverty in Puerto Rico by calling on your congressional representatives to reform the Jones Act. Look in the description of this video to find a link to contact your congressional representatives. Please share this video with your friends and family so they can do the same. By creating a more fair and flexible framework that balances national security and economic growth, Puerto Ricans have a real chance at upward economic mobility."
@@JC-tf2jb
3:48 escribiste “dollars” mal
Thank you for catching!! I must have watched and reviewed this 1000 times and didn't catch it 😅
True story
🇵🇷🇵🇷🇵🇷🇵🇷🇵🇷
❤
Abolish the Jones act
💯
Míra hija todos tiene trabajar o estudier eses la ley de la vida
Tiene que joderte nada
Es gratis ok.
Can I just say if your going to flee your homeland I would make damned sure the one I was running too was better .. IT AIN'T...
Better in terms of economy?
The Jones Act was never about God's love of thy neighbor. The mistreatment undeservedly of any people of every nation in every and any way will always lack God's perfect love.
So what’s the insight here
Odd choice of background music
Which song? 1st, 2nd, 3rd?
@@thenearhorizon the one towards the end.
@@joeyyears Oh, the star spangled banner! We chose this song because It represents the US's struggle for independence. The US is imposing law on Puerto Rico similar to how the British had to the US.
@@thenearhorizon ah okay thanks for the context 👍
@@joeyyears you got it. I appreciate the feedback. Always trying to improve our videos :)
ya no se sabe lo que pasara con puerto rico 🇺🇲🇵🇷🇪🇦
Que pasara con el Mundo
The Jones Act could have been a factor immediately after WW2 when there were thousands of cheap cargo ships floating around. But the cost of operating a vessel nowadays is quite similar to US Flag vessels and Foreign Flag vessels. More than 13 foreign vessels visit San Juan Port every week bringing all sorts of products from all over the World. Difference in prices between products sold in the mainland US and the same products sold in Puertro Rico is not significant. The key to more economical shipping rates is big volume and not adding more ships, US or Foreign to the equation. A container ship capable of carrying 1,000 containers between Jacksonville and San Juan is cheaper to operate than 10 ships carrying 100 containers each under a foreign flag.
Do you have any stats to back your claims? We've provided stats and sources
I am a living stadistic. I worked for many years in the shipping industry, I belonged to the PR Manufacturer's Assoc. , the Chamber of Commerce and the US Coast Guard Comitee. Plus I have tons of years as a consumer both in San Juan and in Miami.
With all due respect....your argument is we should trust your opinion because you have experience in the industry? That is, by definition, an illogical fallacy: "Appeal to authority fallacy occurs when we accept a claim merely because someone tells us that an authority figure supports that claim."
Please provide any evidence to support the claim: "Difference in prices between products sold in the mainland US and the same products sold in Puerto Rico is not significant."
My comment is not a proposal to give you a course on cargo maritime shipping. But I can direct you to the sources of information. Lets use a 15.5 oz can of Goya Small Red Beans as an example and lets assume it comes from Goya Distribution Center in Miami. That can, together with thousands of other cans in carton boxes is loaded into a container and transported by truck or train to the port of Fort Lauderdale. There is loaded into a container ship with more than a thousand other containers and moved by water to San Juan on an American flag ship. All that is done under a freight tariff that is filed with the FMC. The tariff includes the truck movement, port fees, stevedoring fees, insurance and other charges even before the container is loaded into the ship. If this were a foreign chinese ship, up to now the charges are the same. Then the ship loads fuel , maintenence parts, buys insurance and hires a crew of about 21 sailors. Up to now, the fuel, maintenance, insurance and depreciation of the vessel are exactly the same for both the chinese and the american ship. The american 21 member crew earns about twice the chinese crew but that cost is diluted quite well between the 1,000 plus containers and thousands of Goya cans. Then all those charges are repeated in San Juan under the same costs all the way to the supermarket. Now, if you add three or four more shipping companies to the equation now the anmerican vessel does not carry the 1,000 plus containers and costs increase proportional to the decrease in cargo volume. Since there is already an aproved tariff for the shipping of Goya beans between Fort Lauderdale and San Juan, the chinese shipping company will use that same tariff. Of course the can of Goya beans price in San Juan will reflect a few cents increase to account for the freight but it is not a lot considering how many beans were transported in a particular vessel.
Yo me fui a Russia no a USA aqui no hay racismo pura union hoy tengo negocio propio estoy casado con 4 hijas se los recomiendo pero no vengan a bagiar aqui si se trabaja
I love that song!
Which one??
@@thenearhorizon sea chanty medley. Wellerman
@pinkyrose6307 ahhh yes, I love it too 😄 what wouldja do with a drunken sailllorrr haha
@@thenearhorizon 😂
REALLY?! 🤦🏽😡
So secede from being in the U.S.
lol
Eso quisieran ustedes😂
Just when you thought you were not on a prison island...who's your daddy josae?
🤔
The Lord may never give justice to those who have been used and abused because of indifference. But those who have been given undeservedly unjust favor will suffer want in remembrance of those who suffered want and were never shown mercy.
larceney pays the unjust.@@javier-dr3om
Puerto Rico is money pit that island is curse. Puerto Rico is the worst USA colony.
Why do you say that?
🖕🇵🇷
Bugo:Porque dices eso?Porque no queremos someterlo a ustedes ni sus intereses que solos benefician 100%a USA?Eso prueba lo racista y codiciosos que son tipos como tú Ivan.Bugo.
Tiene suerte USA TE Da 4 mil miñones de
Dolares en cupones.
What do you mean?
Tenemos suerte que pagamos 72 billion 💲por año a los u.s.a.
why I believe trump would set puerto rico free? first trump can not set puerto rico! it's is a act of congress! but like I said you need political power to do this! and common sense! puerto rico has to come before congress with a good and fair proposition to why should congress vote to set puerto rico free? there are very good examples to nations that were under the rule by other nations! for example one india under britain's rule! puerto rico must set in motion a plan that would make puerto rico self sufficient from the US! she must prove to congress that she deserves her freedom to make wise choice to further her independence as sovereign nation willing to take care of her people's needs! and the welfare of the nation's needs! and to establish a republic! and a fair democracy where the land is governed by fair laws that does not favor one over the other! and adopting of a Constitution that would protect the rights of the people! if puerto rico really wants her freedom from the US, she has to be one voice! if she is not one and all? she will remain in that state! of always being but never coming to a conclusion! thus always being just a territory nothing more! and if the people can not come to a solution, US can make her a state, and never have the chance of being free like many other nations that have become free! I believe puerto rico should be free! she has payed in full her services with the blood of men in battle for the USA! she has earn her freedom! God is watching!
Independence they Will lost all federal government help will be poverty country in the Caribbean 150 miles from Florida state we all ready make it state 51 in 2030 Les make it state 51 one this time please USA territory
How do you think Puerto Rico will benefit?
One investor could make hundreds of millions of dollars in crypto, a million investors could pull in 10s to 100s of billions of dollars in crypto, with no capital gains taxes, yall have such a competituve advantage...I just dont get it...
Puerto Rico should go Independent. Once Puerto Rico is its own nation we can do whatever we want with trade in the world. If we become a state, the Jones Act will be on Puerto Rico forever. It is very unlikely this will be taken down, the US doesn't want to lose billions. And if Puerto Rico somehow got an exception to be taken off the Jones Act, Hawaiians and Alaskans would be pissed.
In researching this video, we listened to talks with Maritime/law professionals who say that The Jones Act needs to be updated to address these disproportionate effects on Hawaii, Alaska, and PR. So hopefully, whatever law comes next will try to resolve all the issues and not just for puerto rico
The issue is that the US isn't letting us go independent, we've been fucked over WAY too hard plus the blatant corruption from our government.
You have the solution or at least try to solve the problem. Go to the island and vote PIP or any of the leftist parties, so, there is not connection with the USA and no American citizenship, according to the. congress. Let's see how the island is going to defend itself from the hawks out there ad from the drug trafficking along the island. Freeloader aliens will welcome you or your people to join them on their odyssey by sea or the jungle.
Puerto Rico and their politics take a look at them. Watch some of these RUclipsrs originally from there and how they talk how it takes forever to get things done and how much it cost I was born and raised there and lived there for 19 years and to get a drivers license. It took forever fast-forward now, and I watch the RUclipsrs and they described How it took them almost all day it hasn’t changed and if they go independent what are you gonna do be like Cuba
Forget the Jones act, we WILL COMPLETELY LOSE THE ISLAND!
Foreign ships should not be transporting goods between the US and Puerto Rico. What do you want, China to take over?
Why not?
Statehood gives us power in the US Congress for many things, not just the Jones Act situation. All independent countries of the world are one way, or another ran by America or one of the other 4 world powers like China, Russia, EU, or Britain... They lobby the crap out of any political party or politician no matter what part of the the world they're in. Two days ago I was speaking the married Dominican couple who own and operate a restaurant in NYC... I told them, I hear there's a lot of gold and other natural resources in DR, and they told me ... "Yes there is, and all of it owned by the US, and Canada!"
So much for independence!! 🤷
Thank you for sharing your insight and experience with the Dominican couple!
“So let’s just throw our hands in the air and fight for nothing” this is a very shallow understanding of geopolitics and the hand we’d be able to have in determining our own fate. So many countries play both sides for their own benefit. Reality is much more complicated than merely everything being divided up between major powers. Yes they have undue influence, but as an independent country we’re not just completely at the whims of one like we are now.
@@LeftOfBori
That's just it, I'm not implying that we just throw our hands up in the air, on the contrary, we should be fighting for the right of finally becoming a part of the biggest independent country and protector of Democracy in the world... USA 🇺🇸 .. our ancestors left their blood on the battlefields for this privilege. We're way overdue.
And I haven't mentioned it , but there's a difference between other independent countries, and PR, and that is that PR has and is part of the US, Cuba was in some type of relationship with the US and what happened to them when Castro decided to intervene with such??
The US screwed him over ,and his ppl are still suffering the consequences today. Big difference when you're in a relationship and invest in a girlfriend, and when once in a while , you buy some random girl a shake , burger and fries .
Time for marriage and tie this knot that our warriors have bravely fought for. I used to be a Pro-common wealth supporter, but things have changed very fast , and we can't waste any more time being a girlfriend. Independence will piss the US off and they'll make the island pay, just like they did to Cuba and Venezuela. Ain't no one country going to help them once the US puts the mark on them. US rarely listens to the UN, so forget about them trying to throw PR a life saver lol
Like I always say in these debates; do you think if the Dominican Republic, or any impoverished country in the world had a chance of becoming a part of the US, that they'd be dumb/naive as our ppl??
Best believe not!! There is a reason millions and millions of people risk everything to come to America the beautiful, with most of them just making it to our southern border and getting turned away, but PRs are so freaking spoiled, that they can't see but 2ft in front of them. Millions have crossed the dangerous water of "La Mona" trying to get from our neighboring Dominican Republic to PR with other ppl from other islands in cheap made wooden boats.
Our ppl are to freaking blind, thank God it's just a small percentage that are blind.
@@xavierrivera9597 “protector of Democracy” my dude the US has put up more fascist regimes than I have fingers and toes.
I’m not reading the most pro statehood, US propaganda comment in the internet
@@xavierrivera9597 you’re believing an image of the US that doesn’t exist. Native Hawaiians have lost major historical areas due to the imperialism they suffered before and after statehood. You’re fooling yourself if you believe we’ll be better as a state
I dont understand tho, if you have no capital gains taxes, why arent all of you investing in crypto and at least making enough to thrive?
Many people are barely making enough to survive, so people don’t have much if any to invest.
@@thenearhorizon its a vicious cycle for sure, guess puerto rican families dont send money to their family on the island like they do in mexico....the corruption certainly doesnt help I imagine
If you want to reach most Americans, i suggest that you have a narrator who does not trill every "r".
Thanks for sharing. Was her accent hard for you to understand?
Looking forward to your reply
Independent is the only Way