I replaced my $10,000 iMac Pro with a base model 24" M1 iMac for video editing!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 31 июл 2024
- Thanks to TotalAV for sponsoring today's video! Check out www.totalav.com/lukemiani to save 80% and get their antivirus suite for $19 per year!
The new M1 iMac is certainly a head turner, but Apple isn't really targeting professional users such as video editors. In today's video I decided to really push the 24 inch iMac to its limits with a real world benchmark, extended video editing on the M1 iMac. Can it actually replace my 10 thousand dollar iMac Pro? Let's find out!
Thunderbolt dock I mentioned in the video:
amzn.to/3oKxX8G
(Anker did not sponsor this video or provide the dock to me)
Follow me on Twitter: / lukemiani
Follow me on Twitch: / lukemiani
Join my Subreddit! / lukemianiyoutube
Gear:
iFixit Pro Toolkit: amzn.to/3bYIzdM
Panasonic Lumix GH5: amzn.to/3b3oMtj
Leica 12-60MM Lens: amzn.to/3hQ5URf
Sennheiser MKH 416: amzn.to/31zGwt2
Zoom H6: amzn.to/2ECYSk6
Sennheiser MKE 440: amzn.to/2JRwIRU
Edelkrone SliderOne V2: amzn.to/33mTZmt
Amazon Links are affiliate codes and generate small commission to support the channel 
Наука
Do you think an M1 iMac could replace your current Mac? Why or why not? Also, check out TotalAV at www.totalav.com/lukemiani to get their antivirus suite for $19 per year!
No I have quick heal😆🤣
Yes, we replaced our Late 2015 21.5” 4K iMac with the new 2021 4 port M1 iMac.
Hi
Man if your planing to give that away then send that to me please and congratulation on 300k subs
I have 2013 MacBook Pro sooooo Yeees
The fact that it is even comfortable to edit 4k with this thing is impressive
I dont think it's that impressive for a 1300$ computer to be able to edit 4k video easily
@@amirla5797 on god bro lol
@@amirla5797 but i mean for a base line mac its pretty good (Mac users just don't know windows uses can buy a 32GB pc for a little less but oh well)
FinalCut is pretty good with 4K. Drop resolution and I can do a 4k edit on an 8gb dual core i5 MacBook pro. But as soon as you do multicam it falls apart. The new ones just sail though it! (And yes, Windows can do it for "cheaper", but $70/mth for Adobe crashing all the time makes Apple actually cheaper for me in terms of time and subscription fees)
@@SeanRosairo yeah but Davinci resolve is a one time payment and has more tools then final cut
Love how you actually show your FCPX timeline/editing workflow and the specific cuts to where you encounter issues. This video gives out a relatable kind of feeling.
It would be interesting to see how the M1 iMac would compare if you had opted for the 16 Gig model.
Hey Luke! Super stoked how your channel has been growing over the last 2 years! Keep up the awesome work!
Just shows how well the Hardware and Software works together! The next 27" iMac (or it's replacement) is going to be epic! M1X or whatever it will be called!
This just shows how bad the price/performance of the iMac Pro was.
Thx for pointing out the inside difference between the base and higher tier iMac, saved me from making a huge mistake
Eel he helped save you, but you also saved yourself since a lot of people don’t bother doing any research before buying something that they will own potentially for years
@@thatwasprettyneat yeah mate
More RAM, an additional graphics core and an additional fan mean a WHOLE lot less on the M1 than it does on intel.
The main thing you're getting for buying a more expensive iMac is the wider choice of colors.
@@lorensims4846 The base and mid-tier iMacs have the same 8GB of RAM, hell even the $1699 iMac has 8GB of RAM. You have to add RAM in the customize section.
@@lorensims4846 Well, there's also the two additional USB-C ports...
Congrats on 300k Luke ur the best channel to watch for information
I’m still so proud of Jonah for moving on from the tv show Superstore & getting a job in Tech. He’s come a long way.
I came across that show for the first time the other week and my immediate thought was the same. . . "whoah, it's that dude from the interwebz."
😂😂😂
Hilarious. I knew he reminded me of someone but I couldn't quite put my finger on it! Now I keep waiting for him to tell us about an article he read, or something he heard on NPR! Lol
Great Video, Luke. Exactly the content most of us want!
Love the video LukeM! Keep up the awesome work!!
Excellent down to earth real life (no waffling) honest video of the iMac 24 Vs iMac 27 pro. I'm sold, in fact I have ordered one with extra ports and 16gb ram.
Congrats on 300K subs! Been a fan of your channel since a few years ago! :)
That audio issue in FCP happens to me on my 2015 27” 5k iMac all the time lately. I think it’s an issue with the latest FCP version. Anyway, sweet video as always, Luke! Superior content lately
Congrats on 300k man love your video’s 👍🏻
Good job Luke. Personally I really enjoy your vids and analysis. Fantastic comparison, thanks again
Been editing with the M1 since the mini came out. It's just minor stuff for me but it still works very well.
Same here! I can finally edit 4k60 on the timeline without a proxy if I want I can edit a 4K timeline on 4K! It’s amazing
@@DeRock401 8 gpu or 7 gpu?? Basic model with 8gb ram ????
Congrats on 300k!
The review I’ve been looking for! Subscribed.
*300K!* Congratulations!
I saw this but today i forgot the thumbnail so i laughed out loud and then said Ight i gotta watch now
Proud to be in a family of 300k . Keep on the great work.
Well done. This was very helpful. I’m currently using a Late 2015 27” iMac and really looking forward to upgrading it especially for editing videos. What you showed here is very encouraging and would definitely be a step up from what I have now but I’m holding out for the larger screen and hoping for the M1X or whatever they decide to call the upgraded computers won’t be available until the end of 2021.
This is so useful I’m new to iMacs and deliberating between older models and the latest at entry level I guess there is absolutely no argument.
Congrats on 300K! been here since
same, miani proper apple guy
Can’t imagine how the new iMac Pro powered by a Apple Silicone would behave !!!!
I bet the imac pro will be exactly the same but a few more USB ports and space gray color. (And a PRO price)
@@mm-hl7gh 🤦♂️ how much do you bet?
@@mm-hl7gh What do you mean by "exactly the same"? You think Apple is going to replace its previous Pro with an M1 Pro with 8GB of Ram, the same GPU as this M1 iMac? Highly doubtful. No one who buys a Pro would ever buy that.
@@brandonb.5304 apple would never use the same chip in their macbook air in a "pro" mac. they'd just murder their own sales because everyone would go with the cheap model. i feel like the pro's main goal should be to be powerful enough to not only fly in m1-optimized programs, but be faster than intel in x86 programs.
@@cunty i mean, the current macbook pro m1 and air m1 are barely different
Awesome video! Love your channel, and the videos you make!
I am very shocked by how well that new iMac performed! Amazing!
I find it pretty impressive that te new iMacs can do almost anything the expensive pro models can.
This tech is a game changer
no
I agree. If we knew half of what it takes to get apps to perform on intel macs, it’s a cobweb kept running by very smart people. Apple has been “covering” for intel for years, M1 eliminates the middle man. As time goes on the apps we use will become more streamlined, because of M1.
Now you can plug the speakers into that dock vs the iMac itself.
I got a M1, 16 RAM, 2 TB MacMini on a Ultrafine 5K. I also use the same Anker hub you have in your video. I absolutely love it for video editing and I think I'm set for years to come with this setup.
I've had the sound issue also. Here's the scoop:
-Running an M1 macbook Pro, 8-core GPU, 16GB, 1TB
-I live in Logic Pro X; 8-10 hours per week
-issue occurred twice since November '20; mid action, sound drops, no explanation
-solution was to restart Macbook (issue occured across apps and sound was dropped while streaming vids in Safari)
Luke, you're a boss! Love your work, man!
Great video. I guess over a decade of optimizing Apple Silicon to function under all the constraints of being inside an iPhone shows up in the performance of the user interface. The other main differentiator is the way improved hardware implemented CODECS for more recent 4K (and 8K) video formats. If you had the Big MacPro tower or a Windows box, you could update the graphics card every year and those 18 Xeon cores would do everything you need for the next 15 years. Obviously what Apple’s done with an iPhone SOC in their entry level computers is impressive. By the end of 2022 when they’ve migrated their pro line to more workstation like CPU cores, it might be time to replace your Xeon iMacPro.
Nice review, it confirms my belief, that for my purpose (general PC use) the middle iMac configuration will be fine, although I am thinking of going for 16gb for a bit of future-proofing. Now those desk mats, what is the brand of the matching green one you place under the green iMac?
Bought mine. Will be here tomorrow 🥰🥰 can’t wait 😝
Whoa! Thanks for the information!
My boy out here looking like a dad with that shirt
I am not surprised about the performance. Over the weekend, I was editing a virtual choir video that has 109 videos. 80% of them are 1080P and the rest 720P.. 95% of these videos have color correction and other effects. At the end of the editing process I have ALL 109 videos on screen at the same time, there are 4 compound clips, that are inside of a 4 quadrant effect (that has an animation). I was originally editing this on my 2019 iMac 3.6 i9 with 40GB of ram. Can you imagine how much fun it was to edit this video in that situation. Well after hours of waiting around to do anything I decided to pack this up, move the project to my M1 MBP (8GB ram) and see if I could finish the edit there, and guess what? I was able to finish this monster of a project in about 30 minutes. For me this just proves the power of Apple Silicone, and I will be first in line to get a new next-gen top of the line iMac, or Mac Pro. If you want to see what 109 layers of video look like, let me know.
Wow!
i want to see it!
I just bought the 2020 iMac 3.6ghz i9 with 32gb of ram, did I shoot myself in the foot by not buying an M1 iMac?
@@thelouisbisson would like to know that too
I want to see, can you please send a screenshot to my email?
Congrats
300K !,!!
Congratulations to a new iMac 2021, dear Luke!
I’m so excited to get my mid tier iMac. God, it has been long awaited for something like this to come out from Apple. I was never a fan of the Intel memory as it seemed buggy and slow at best… I hadn’t upgraded for 7 years. I am so giddy with excitement to get back to editing videos and making art videos without losing quality (using just my iPad)
(I think) you said blender was worsened by Rosetta. Please try your Blender bench again with the beta Universal or straight Apple silicon Blender version. I think you'll see some improvement (assuming it works, they were still missing some features a couple of weeks ago with I gave it a whirl). Thanks for this episode!
It's amazing to see this level of performance
Waiting for a 2022 iMac purchase. Thank you for your reviews!
I am waiting for the next Pro line too.
You know you’re early when not even luke miani has 500 views 😂 congrats on 300k btw
I wanna see the long term review for this model and the mid tier to see how they hold up and if 16gb of RAM would be necessary
My 2009 iMac has 16GB RAM. It is hilarious that new iMacs have less! WTF!
@@777jones new iMacs don't need that much.
@@unknownaura "Need" is a relative term and increased RAM would make the M1 efficient. You might not need more RAM, but I sure do.
Congo 300k big fan since your 17 subs
Congratulations on 300,000 subscribers
I recently did some color work on a video in Davinci Resolve with my base M1 MBP. It took about 2 hours 30 minutes to render. Curious to see how it would compare, I rendered the same job with my high performance "gaming" PC that has an overclocked water-cooled Core i7, RTX 2080 Super, 32 GB RAM, and a 1TB 970 Evo Plus NVMe SSD. I figured the PC would finish _slightly_ faster and that would be a testament to how amazing it was that my little MBP could keep up with this huge, custom built, water cooled behemoth. I couldn't have been more wrong. DaVinci estimated that it was going to take _over 11 hours_ for the PC to render the exact same job!! I couldn't believe it! the next generation of Apple silicone is going to be insane!
What this tells me is that tests like cinebench only gives you part of the result. There’s no substitute for real use tests.
Congrats for 300k Subs!
Loved this video!
I'm curious to see how the mid level iMac with 16GB of RAM would do against your current beast. I'm definitely upgrading to the new iMac because my mid 2011 iMac is finally getting so slow it hurts!
@15:00, I agree completely. It cannot be understated what Apple has designs on what's to come. The base 8gb ram is ok for now, but consumers will ultimately force Apple to boost the base model to minimum 16gb ram.
Thank you for not trashing the M1 iMac for being slower like other channels have. Like you say, $10,000 machine vs. $1300 machine. Some other reviewers have been comparing it like it's the same price! For my uses, all I want is a computer than can keep up with my spreadsheets, word documents, music, web browsing etc. Nothing more. I am not patient, so I need something fast and responsive. My needs changed, and I sold my Mac Book Air M1 as soon as this came out, and I got my hands on one. This is my first ever iMac - having owned 3 MacBook Airs over the last 10 years. Must say, I am happily throwing away my old PC speaker system, and selling the second screen I used to have. The 23.5" display is more than enough space for me not to need two screens, and like you I am super happy with the design of it. I did go for the £1,649 model, purely because I wanted 512 storage, but that's more for longevity for me. Also, I wanted the extra ports, and now understand it has an extra fan also. Perhaps the base model would have been fine, but this year my business has done well, and I have the funds to pay - of course it's offset against my tax :)
Guess this new iMac fits for more casual users with that design and colour options and as an added advantage the power of M1!!! Love your videos !!
Seeing this I want to wait a little bit for the M1X Mac but this makes me so excited for it
Yeah exactly.
Have you purchased a newer iMac?
Don’t wait, you’ll be disappointed
@@sarahamaniampong1405 Nobody can tell, but you might be right in the sense that models based on the next Apple ARM chip (M1X or whatever), will not replace M1's, but the top-end Intel-based ones. In other words, they will not have prices comparable to m1's, but constitute a more expensive tier in the range.
It’s literally like two week wait just wait
@@semahj Isn't it sooner now? (:
I’ll actually look into this as it cost less than my new iPad Pro 🥺
Amazing! 300k subs good job!
Very good lighting in the video :)
Luke, I wasn’t surprised at all. That iMac Pro is a beast of a PC. I think you’ll switch back eventually to the iMac Pro eventually.
See you soon iMac Pro. 😉
No he Don’t do that
Bye
@@JuniorTechnoArtist I barely had a chance to say hello. 😂
Anyone else watching on a new iMac? Great video Luke!
Meee. Which color did you got. I got a green one
@@NoOne-im3cs I am poor🥲
Watching this on my 11 year old iMac 😀👍🏻
Watching on iPhone 11
Going to a Mxxx mini for my desktop. Already have monitors, a keyboard, and a mouse I love.
I’m using the m1 Mac mini. My videos are far less complexed than yours, but I am loving it. Being able to actually edit 4k60 and not have to lower the resolution of the timeline is amazing.
I’m still using Davinci resolve because it is what I know and works so good but I do have 3 months of Final Cut Pro installed but I’m not sure I want to try it cuz if I do end up liking it then that’s 300$ I gotta spend lol.
Great review. It seems the on die RAM is more like a fast L2 cache that's keeping thing moving, if they can make that system work with some proper off die RAM then we'll be in business.
Nice review that I really appreciated. I would like to see the M1 chip perform some 2D and 3D CAD work.
I use my m1 for CAD work in school and it performs great. Big upgrade over my aging 2013 macbook air it replaced
If it wasn’t for the smaller 24” screen, I would already have sold my iMac Pro
@@Kierant2010 that's why he hasn't sold it yet.
Have had the same audio issue with my 16 GB RAM/ 1 TB M1 Mac Mini and FCP. It drops, I relaunch FCP and it works fine. Thought I was doing something wrong, glad to hear I'm not the only one!
Great lighting my dude. :)
Seeing the old and new designs side by side really just reminds me how good the old design looks. Sure, the new one is thin as hell, but the old one still just looks better.
PERIODDDDDDD the new one is ugly 😂😂😂😂 (the pro does look a lot better in general tho, like a beast, coz it is!)
No way the old one looks ugly and basic
@@DaffyTaffy93 the new ones looks like it’s made kids
@@StaceChristopher that’s couse it kinda is. It’s not a pro model. It’s supposed to look appealing not industrial like iPad Air vs iPad Pro.
I’m getting that audio issue on my MacBook Air. Happens every couple of days. It fixes itself when I leave if for a minute or two - but it’s quicker to close and relaunch
Here as well with a cMP 2010… FCPX issue not related with the Mac model for sure
@@AlvaroGutierrezRomero interesting. I don't get it on either of my other machines, weird!
Hello, have the same problems. I try on several Mac m1, and it the same results....there is no sound when I move or work on rushes. it coms back when I quit and restart fop, or after several minutes....did you solve this problem?
You have a marvellous on screen presence. You really should consider television or acting. Well done.
Congratulations on 300k! Also how is your day/night/noon going? :D
What if instead of a base model you got one of the more higher end M1 iMacs? Would that have given you better ram and render times?
and ports
I totally expected to say that you won't switch to the new iMac despite it being so good at 14:09, but woah. It's incredible that an entry level iMac can replace your Pro desktop that costs 9x more.
Good video, Luke. I have just recently begun running Resolve on my Minimac M1. Yes, audio problem here like you have experienced. I had to restart to get audio back.
Need the single core metrics between the Xeon and M1, I'm guessing it'll be a reverse blood bath.
The single core Geekbench benchmarks for the Intel Xeon W-2191B (released in late 2017) is 1067, while on the Apple M1 it is 1710 (approximately 60% faster). Passmark's CPU Benchmarks (with a Xeon W-2195) show similar single core benchmarks (2413 vs 3758; approximately 55% faster). The multi-core Geekbench benchmarks for the Intel Xeon W-2191B is 13356, while on the Apple M1 it is 7412 (approximately 45% slower). Passmark's CPU Benchmarks show similar multi-core benchmarks (27325 vs 15131; approximately 45% slower). Unless, my percentage estimations are mistaken....
Same intro 3 times in a row, video could have been Half this length. Still the M1 is a beast...
Congrats on 300k my boy
Always enjoy your videos Luke, so much info and just like you I love my Apple stuff. Wish I could afford buying more Apple stuff.
A M1X space grey iMac Pro would be a perfect desktop for me! M1X will probably be able to render 10 videos at a time or something 😂
I also really hope apple introduce a Mac Pro, especially in slightly more subtle colours! 😂
I’m gonna put an emoji for no reason 😂
@@YimYum911 😂🤣
The high end configs of it will be able to play back 4 8K30fps videos in Final Cut. And that won’t even be Apple’s highest end SoC, that’ll be the M1Z with 32 high performance and 4-8 high efficiency cores, and 128 GPU cores. And maybe an even higher end SoC in the future, if the rumors Luke reported on are correct (128 CPU cores, 256 GPU cores).
@@utubekullanicisi I wonder how big the actual silicon will be given how big (or small) their current M1 package is. It would have to be 16 times bigger for 128 cores alone I think, maybe less if it's at 2 or 3nm. But still, 128 cores is no joke. Just look at how big AMD Threadripper 3990X is with just 64 cores.
Question: if you only have 8gb of Ram in a M1 machine, is that comparable to 8gb in a Intel Mac? Or does your 8gbs go further with M1?
Love the 24” design. My only qualm is I have a 27” Thunderbolt 2.5K Display so if a baseline larger iMac with 16 Gb is available b4 end of year for say $600 to $700 more than a similar memory/ ssd capacity then I would be all in! My 2012 15” hi-res MacBook Pro is still going strong. But using the Thunderbolt Display with a similarly sized larger iMac would be stunning! Great channel🙏🏻
I'm glad to see that the reviews of the M1 are finally pointing out some of the problems.
What problems ?
@@Lexusgx550, in this case, the ones mentioned in the video.
Have had my M1 Mac Mini for 6 months and edit in FCP every week. Have never had the audio issue.
I have issues with Airplay 2 audio to my ethernet wired speaker from an m1 mac mini; very annoying but the machine is glorious!
@Zain Uddin audio isn't rendered through a gpu
Many people thought I was crazy to sell my maxed out MBP 16" for a M1 MBA… Best decision ever 👏
Apple silicon is incredibly impressive
I did the same!
I mean the maxxed out model is more powerful then M1 with 16GB, but I guess it wont die from over heating
8gb m1? or 16gb?
8gpu cores, 16gb with 1tb SSD
@@catherinedesrochers you can max out to 8TB and 64Gb but thats will a good configuration I get why you would get a M1
Subscription earned today. Great video.
I get the Audio problem on fcp on a MacBook M1 pretty much every time I edit a video - very annoying I have to restart like you did
I ordered purple, 512 GB, 8 Core GPU, 16 GB RAM. I think it will be my main computer for four or five years. :)
purple looks really good imo
5 years with 512gb?
@@florider_hd My current PC has 512 GB as well with about 160 GB free after exactly three years. So 256 GB wasn't an option for me. If 512 GB will not be enough, I'd buy an external SSD though, the "official" upgrades are way too expensive in my opinion.
Now that those Mac’s also run iOS apps it would be fun edit an video in LumaFusion on the iMac.
Why lol?
Congrats with 300k. Earned another sub. Love the new iMac.
First off, I appreciate your non-biased point of view when you make videos like this, Luke. Second, I have a similarly spec'd custom PC (the build is almost 2 years old at this point) to your iMac Pro I use that's connected to my 49" 4k LG SmartTV (webOS and all that) for when I wanna play certain game consoles I have (to stream/consume content on a large screen etc) and it's fast... It's got a Ryzen 9 3900X with 32 GB of RAM and I dual boot with Windows 10 and Void Linux (Void Linux being my main/preferred OS most of the time. I have Win10 there for emergencies/testing/convenience). I also recently got an M1 Mac mini (mid tier I guess?) with 16 GB of RAM and 512 GB of SSD storage onboard. I have an 8TB drive connected over USB (non-C) for storage for projects I'm doing. I use BlackMagic Design DaVinci Resolve as my NLVE (NonLinearVideoEditor) of choice because I grew up using the various versions of Adobe Premiere basically since version 1 and Resolve has a similar layout at least in my eyes. I've also not bothered to learn FCP properly, but maybe some day I will. It's M1 optimized and it works great. With all that said, this Ryzen 9 is NO SLOUCH WHATSOEVER..
If I have to or need to edit/render some video on here (using the open-source and up and coming NLVE called Olive, since Resolve hates certain Linux distros) with my slightly older AMD Radeon RX 480 4GB (this machine is hilariously all AMD) I have a great time doing it. Now granted, I've not done any strict benchmarking between my two powerhouse machines, but when it comes to my M1 mini I was able to export my unboxing video of it (13 min of footage 1080p footage, but still footage) in like 5-6 min or something like that. My Ryzen 9 here with its 12 cores and 24 threads would probably do it faster, but the M1 platform is no slouch either. I'm happy with both systems, but if I had to choose one and only one I'd totally go with my M1 Mac mini partially because I like macOS given I grew up watching it evolve into what it's become today, and because it's not Windows.... lol joking aside thank you for making this video. It was very interesting to watch. Keep em coming! Congrats on breaching 300k subs! You deserve it! I'll keep watching! I ain't goin' nowhere. lol :)
What about the screen size? Does it feel like it's too small to work on once you are used to 27"?
24" is definitely big enough but the 27" is much better IMO.
I think if you need a bigger display a Mac Mini + whatever you want is more cost-effective (you loose something, but you gain more ports an choice, and 8 gpu cores on the base model)
Someone once called the new iMac an 'ipad on a stick' and I can't stop thinking about it
I'm now torn between an iMac or a Mac Mini as my new work machine when I do upgrade, pretty rediculous performance for a base level iMac
I love my intel Mac mini, once one comes out with a bit better IO and multi-monitor support, I will snag one.
yes. before we used to see differences on Mac computers and iMac used to be "the beast" now, iMac is just a fluffy-colored computer and all models (air, pro, mini...) deliver more or less the same result, bad for consumers to select one...
@@jimkika I actually kind of agree with you here. Like it is almost all entirely about form factor now.
@@ryanb55 I'm thinking the same. There's rumours/leaks about a redesigned mac mini which seems to be smaller and have better IO. Whats making me want an iMac is that I'm currently using a 2004 cinema display and there's no fucking way I'm going to bother doing a load of adapters to make it work with a 2021 machine...
Congratulations 👏👏 for reaching 300k subscribe . We wish you to reach 500k subscribe in the end of the year
Luke, you did a great job with your channel and your presentation of the M1 Macs have intrigued me. If I wanted to try Mac OS, would you recommend to buy the Mac Mini now or wait for the possible upgrade?
My mother walked by, saw you and said you could be the third property brother but for tech. Not sure what to say.
I’ve never noticed that but wow it’s true lol
My thoughts? Well, we don't have the luxury of getting a new iMac every time a new one comes out. The waiting game can't always be played by us.
Woah 300k congrats
Congrats on 300k
meanwhile today my 2014 base Mac mini struggled with 5 tabs open in safari. that's with an SSD swap.
Get a ram swap and check activity monitor for other programs